What a sly man. Oh, he grew up poor, so sided with the weak in society, and so "naturally" become a Chinese Communist Mao follower? Why? He grew up in Hong Kong, there are lots of ways for him to help the poor without falling for such an evil ideology. The truth was that very few Hong Kongers fell for that ideology because a lot of them escaped from China in the first place. Lien never said whether his family were among the refugees; if so, why would he buy into something his parents escaped from? You could see how Hong Kong people overwhelming supported the Colonial Government during the 1967 riots. People like Lien were very rare. The reality was Lien thought with his Hong Kong University degree, he would be admired and used by the Communists and had a shot cut to wealth and success. Oh, it took him until the late 80s to "realize something was wrong." So, the slaughter of "landlords" and "rich business people," the anti-rightist, "correct the wind" campaigns, the Great Leap Forward where 45 million died of starvation, the Cultural Revolution were all OK dokey by this highly-educated young man. I knew about the famine as a child because every single month I had to go the post office with my grandmother to send food parcels and old clothes to mainland China. And Lien did not know anything about it? He said he did not know how violent and destructive the ten year long Cultural Revolution was. Did he not see the corpses flowing down the Pearl River Delta as I did? Did he not know about the two little brother and sister bombed to death at North Point; the assassination of Lam Bun; the hundreds killed and ; the bombs all over our streets right here in Hong Kong? So he joined the SAR Government because he "was hoping to give constructive advice," but was sacked because his words fell on deaf ears. We don't know how true it was. But my bet is he was again hoping for a fat salary and a steady Government job. His firing probably was due to the whims of the Communists than any real challenge he put up to the authority. No, the truth is that knowing he would never be trusted by the notoriously partisan and paranoid Communists, and seeing that Communism no longer had a market in the world, he morphed into this Communist "critic" and sought his bread and bacon in the opposite camp. Lien presented himself as somebody who does not care much about reward, only his ideals. But if you look at his pitiful and slippery life, he is an opportunists par excellence, somebody without any moral or ethical compass.
真香港人朋友們：在僅有狹小的範圍裡，我們不能作什麼，但係可以拒絕作什麼。不能有所貢獻，卻能有所持守，不要同流合污😌
感覺練教授講嘢好真，誰沒有真心愛過自己的國家，但看到那麼多年壞事做盡，出爾反爾，唯一選擇只有遠離和仇恨
我以前的心態就是像練博士一樣 心存希望中國會好 善待人民 但一次一次的失望😮💨真的如夢初醒🤔天佑香港🙏🙏
很喜歡練總的自我剖白，有理有節，有情亦重義，慶幸香港有這樣一位公共知識份子
可惜大部分时間都判斷錯誤，可幸臨老知返。。。小弟是練生的長期读者，年前的改土歸流論亦佳作
練博士的心路歷程、經歷和醒覺，都與好多人有着共同點，早十年八年之前，好多人會同情理解中國或中共的處境，對中共有期望，我都是其中之一！現在披羊皮的狼露真身露真性情，是一件好事來。
HK仆街，多谢有您和練博士。。。
@archie un 4543
@archie un 4543
如果時光能倒流50年，中国回復過往吃草的日子，是值得他爱護的，但中国今時唔同往曰，已目中無人，不吃這一套，就係抵死！👻👻🤪😂
@archie un 中共這農夫確曾動用国家力量不断恊救港人，如自由行……。（可是英美養下的蛇已成窩）🤪🤪
謝謝練教授的坦誠，
謝謝沈教授能邀請到練教授接受訪問。
練先生，講到香港人心聲，講得好好
訪問精彩，真摯深刻👏🏻👏🏻👍🏻👍🏻
Thank you 練乙錚博士
好喜歡練先生嘅分享
練老師，你說的真是我們相信的，
更多謝沈老師的訪問議題，
都是我們想問練老師的。
希望我們這一代(50後)有機會見到中國會像樣。
共產黨人應該反醒。
清「醒」
反「省」
首先，我同意練先生所講，至於覺醒則更早，毛左思想始於文革之初，即66~67年，直至約20歲某日，感覺共產主義理想乃人類史上最無恥卻最美麗之謊言，從那時開始已知道中共並非偉丶光丶正，但一段相當時間依然屬大中華膠一族，即所謂愛國，擁護民族主義，2019年6月開始令我徹底改變，我極其量是血統上的中國人，此外，中國二字已跟我扯不上任何關係。
我同你完全一樣，我好多朋友都係咁！2019年改變咗自己
證明所謂共產主義只是包裝，見光死！
我比你早，我係2014傘運。
同意鍊sir所言👍
林鄭唔係墮落, 係折墮。 以為上帝留左個位比佢, 一步步踏上天堂之路, 點知天堂門前, 雙眼一張, 已是煉獄熊熊火光。
琳病喺墮落、 變折墮、 有排折墮、無恥無知、無人性無道德、唔衰唔做、黑變白、 等著作繭自斃！!！
好多人都未睇到共產黨的魔爪 測試武漢肺炎封食市
限 聚令
帶口罩威逼利誘打針
Thank you very much for sharing! Much appreciated!
練先生可以出回憶錄
失败者回憶錄。。。
練先生，共產主義並非中華文化！
中華文化…不如就看看現今台湾人的生態吧！
沈先生，練先生之前對海外民運發展的不同意見，就是自由開明的學術討論，和而不同，各舒己見。
謝謝
好精彩的
風骨👍👍👍
練乙錚先生！未睇先like!
多謝先生嘅分享，今晚聽君一席話，勝讀十年書。已經無得再喺蘋果日報見到你成頁嘅評論，今晚竟然有機會邀請到你，而更重要係今日嘅題目！
我即時分享俾我媽咪，等佢一個由大陸偷渡嚟香港嘅人，好好聽聽你嘅分享，點解你會由左變成今日咁，太好了。可能同輩嘅人，佢會聽得入耳。多謝先生。
咁你可以問你阿媽點解當年佢又會冒著生命危險，千辛萬苦都要偷渡嚟香港呢？
先生有理
60後香港長大的我，沒辦法理解中共立國後，當時共產政權的行為為何仍然得到像練先生這類受高等教育人士支持，可以崇拜共產主義幾十年之久！
八十年代前都有教授的錯看錯判!一有時間就馬上背著背包遊歷大江南北壯麗河山絲綢之路,但可惜一埸六四那份感覺江山如此多紛變得粉碎!!這埸血流成河的六四他們還未反省過來!!其實好應該為此事及時向好方向著想作出道歉!!並不是把事實埋藏在深深處!!
習大大唔係打左燈右轉，亦唔係打左燈左轉，而係打左右燈卻調頭倒後轉，結果就係死火拋錨！😫
打左燈非轉左轉右，係直奔向下跳懸崖，笨豬跳但冇绑繩
@@fuhualee4061 懸崖在背後，所以先要掉頭衝！😂
看來仍有下文，期待
聽練先生的分享，再次肯定資訊不流通，或獨裁者監控資訊是愚民產生的最大原因。
thanks
請問有機會可以打上中文字幕嗎？這些親身經歷的口述非常重要！也可能成為歷史資料，更能幫助全世界的華人了解中共. 感激不盡！
Support CLASS
可惜大部分时间判斷錯誤，可幸臨老知返。。。小弟是練博士的超長期读者，近年的改土歸流論亦佳作
看他回顧他年輕時代到中年可看到他的刻骨的痛苦.
你是指在視頻上他的面部表情？
He is just saying the right things. Don't believe a word these "former Communist followers" say. Just a highly educated actor.
@@ellene.8558 一位博士回首前塵數十年，發現大部分重大的判斷都是錯的，可以不痛吗。。。
@@jacksonyuen4421
和他有這樣經歷的人，良善之心錯付，都不知有幾多人；可恨的是歷史不斷重複，「有人辭官歸故里，有人漏夜趕科場」。
@@ellene.8558 可幸練博士臨老知返。。。
同意閣下談及人墮落急速的論述，難以相信
Support.
🙏🙏
練先生，提議你探討一下偉大的文化有何種特徵和內涵？
希望你能從地球上歷代文化興衰去比較，中華文化是否稱得上偉大？
👍👍🙏🙏
通常藍營都有個格類，似被人害過敵視外國
👍👍👍
👍💪💪
👍💪
Support
💪👍
没有邪惡，只有更邪惡！😂😂😂😂😂
沒有最邪恶，衹有更邪恶。
個人意見，奇實曾任權同黃仁龍試過保護，可惜失敗
練先生反証左高牆vs雞蛋，要企喺原則果邊，因為雞蛋都可以有一日變成高牆。而且道德成份不能太多
👍💥🌏🏆📚🥇💓🕊️🙏
好似西方一樣，後來先至了解中共嘅邪惡，已经係太遲啦。
權力令人沉淪。大中華膠+老共迷惑+掌控權力，就更容易急速沉淪，令人不懂再分辯大是大非，只懂"國家(中共權貴家族)"就是一切正義和真理
這三個要素，真是百發百中的迷魂藥。
接受現實吧:
香港不可能被光復 （保住台灣最重要）
東烏克蘭、克里米亞會併入俄羅斯（保住西烏克蘭最重要）
敘利亞、伊拉克、也門也會受伊朗控制（保住以色列、沙特阿拉伯最重要）
中、俄、伊朗都是歐亞/亞太陸權，三者相加再加友好有30%世界話語，而西方陣營（美國為首，北約/歐盟、日/韓/以色列、五眼、沙特海合會、東盟除老緬柬、哥倫比亞/利比里亞/摩洛哥/肯雅/南蘇丹支持）佔世界70%話語權。
美國就算有Trump連任，要完全打敗中俄伊朗是不可能 ~ 中国有龐大人力，包括愚民、憤青、愛國主義者，俄羅斯軍事科技遠落後於美國但仍能威嚇歐盟，伊朗輸出的激進伊斯蘭主義就連塔利班、伊斯蘭國、沙特阿拉伯也要忌憚；還未計算大外宣（海外親共華人、小粉紅）及爛頭卒（真主党、敘利亞、北韓）。 也别忘記歐美左膠興起，美國現在自顧不下，别奢望她現在領導盟友抗軸心國（中俄伊朗）。
南亞（印度、巴基斯坦）的取態就變得重要，印親俄反中、巴親中反俄，巴國民間反美但軍方親美，印度會為西方反中卻不會為西方反俄，這種微妙關係不是歐美vs中俄伊朗的二元關係咁簡單。
自由世界可以做的，只能孤立中共、俄羅斯、伊朗。(亞洲大陸早已被『反美三雄』中共、俄羅斯、伊朗瓜分。)
俄羅斯仍控制中亞，對印度也具影響力。
中共牢固控制新疆、西藏、香港，也對北韓、巴基斯坦、緬甸、柬埔寨、老撾有影響力。
伊朗對敘利亞、伊拉克、真主黨有影響力。
塔利班也要對『反美三雄』腑首稱臣。
只要三地人民不醒覺，『反美三雄』是絕不可能被推翻! 你奢望自由世界派軍隊去掃低三雄? 恐怕開戰未夠一個月，歐美三十幾國民選政府都要下台。
自由世界首要保住南美、非洲、海合會、東盟其他7國和日韓台，免落入『反美三雄』手中。
所以有機會就離開香港吧，不要將後代培養成粉紅生力軍！
Swisse : 10 minutes
☺
Kaplan : 12 minutes
自鸣清高, 林老闆的信報为啥賣给李嘉诚？
此
林老闆的一生，乃完美动作，充滿智慧，判斷正確。。。如果你有幸读完林的作品，你就會明白
衰過建華
自投羅網。上了不歸路。
777是自甘墮落。👹
🤓
CLS
自甘墮落
讀壞書，又系失败者回憶錄之一，可幸臨老知返。。。
你呢?
@@bobyheung5930 小弟既冇呢个本事，亦未到回忆錄的时候。。。🤭
@@jacksonyuen4421 ,既然你咁水皮,咁仲亂咁批評人哋?
@@bobyheung5930 你呢🤭
有乜关系??
@@bobyheung5930 現代社會，总统都可以被批评，虽然我們正步向奴隸社會的途中。。。
練乙錚嘅文章好，但原來口才算差😅
口窒窒詞不達意，聽得好悶啊！
@@chau11chu as
中國俾人蝦？咁大清時代義和團殘殺外國教士教徒連中國教徒都不問三七廿一都殺。咁邊個鶢蛋邊個高牆？
當年歷史教育係教外國人蝦清朝的
練生指的中國人俾人蝦，應該是指韓戰之後被全世界禁運（包括歐美蘇聯），抗生素藥物糧食全部短缺，要求香港人走私的文革年代
@@hkchan1339 咁即係話香港人咁多年受嘅歷史教育都係錯嘅。你俾人打就係俾人蝦，你打人殺人就係自衛。個龍門搬到呢。。。其實咪同依家中國政府搬龍門，即係雙重標準一模一樣。醒下啦！仲話乜乜教授。中國共產黨開頭係正義。仲未醒㗎。如果中國共產黨又出個類似鄧小平嘅，又什麼.撥亂反正，呢位仁兄又受坤。
共產黨最善長製造假像，美國都俾中共呃左咁耐
你们这个节目不能够给听得懂广东话的人听啊，你要跟更多的那些在中国大陆可以觉醒的人听啊，这样让更多的人觉醒后推翻共产党。please put Chinese subtitles at the bottom of screen
他們二人本身並不一定能講流利普通話，而且對像一向都是香港人。你想聽明白敬請自行學習，不能去別人地方叫人依你的
中國人聽明白是冇用的，華人天生懦弱，不到死到臨頭是不會反抗的
@@hkchan1339 ok, no problem.
What a sly man. Oh, he grew up poor, so sided with the weak in society, and so "naturally" become a Chinese Communist Mao follower? Why? He grew up in Hong Kong, there are lots of ways for him to help the poor without falling for such an evil ideology. The truth was that very few Hong Kongers fell for that ideology because a lot of them escaped from China in the first place. Lien never said whether his family were among the refugees; if so, why would he buy into something his parents escaped from? You could see how Hong Kong people overwhelming supported the Colonial Government during the 1967 riots. People like Lien were very rare. The reality was Lien thought with his Hong Kong University degree, he would be admired and used by the Communists and had a shot cut to wealth and success. Oh, it took him until the late 80s to "realize something was wrong." So, the slaughter of "landlords" and "rich business people," the anti-rightist, "correct the wind" campaigns, the Great Leap Forward where 45 million died of starvation, the Cultural Revolution were all OK dokey by this highly-educated young man. I knew about the famine as a child because every single month I had to go the post office with my grandmother to send food parcels and old clothes to mainland China. And Lien did not know anything about it? He said he did not know how violent and destructive the ten year long Cultural Revolution was. Did he not see the corpses flowing down the Pearl River Delta as I did? Did he not know about the two little brother and sister bombed to death at North Point; the assassination of Lam Bun; the hundreds killed and ; the bombs all over our streets right here in Hong Kong? So he joined the SAR Government because he "was hoping to give constructive advice," but was sacked because his words fell on deaf ears. We don't know how true it was. But my bet is he was again hoping for a fat salary and a steady Government job. His firing probably was due to the whims of the Communists than any real challenge he put up to the authority. No, the truth is that knowing he would never be trusted by the notoriously partisan and paranoid Communists, and seeing that Communism no longer had a market in the world, he morphed into this Communist "critic" and sought his bread and bacon in the opposite camp. Lien presented himself as somebody who does not care much about reward, only his ideals. But if you look at his pitiful and slippery life, he is an opportunists par excellence, somebody without any moral or ethical compass.
👍👍👏