What an amazing podcast, thank you Dr Rangan for your sharing Hannah’s wisdom with all of us. Love your guests today, full of love and humanity, very grateful!
We must never forget what can happen. An important story to be told again and again so this never happens again. Right now the world is going through change that could should signal to us all, be aware of what conflict can lead too and let’s make sure this doesn’t happen again.
I didn’t want to watch because this topic is just so sad, but I was transfixed. So much hope and positivity from all three of you, despite trudging through such a sad story. Really enlightening thanks
How would have I survived if I would have gone through what these amazing people endured? I have visited Auschwitz and Birkenau concentration camps and I think everyone should visit! Looking at the faces of the victims displayed on the walls it’s heartbreaking and it’s a wake-up call for us to be the best person we can be, be thankful for what we have and treat everyone with respect. This podcast, by sharing this incredible life story, is bringing consciousness of all these matters we should reflect on and act upon!
Thank you for sharing this story!! We all need to be more aware of the horrible things that happened in the past - and to be kind to one another - making sure they are not repeated.
Thank you doctor for this very emotional podcast story of Hannah and Gaby. Heart was torn thinking of the sufferings they had to endure througn the words of Ruth and Dina. Loved the message on love compassiin and to do good to other people. Thank you
You Country killed more than 12 million civilians worry about that! Holocaust happened 80 yrs ago. Your Country killed Africans 50 yrs ago and no one wants to talk about it or interview them. Your are Pessimistic if you keep listening to this. This man have to make money through interviewing people.
0:23: 📚 Hannah, a Jewish girl born in Berlin in 1928, becomes a refugee in Amsterdam during World War II and forms a close friendship with Anne Frank. 7:43: 😢 Hannah, a young Jewish girl living in Amsterdam during World War II, experiences the fear and uncertainty of the Nazi invasion and helps her father hide incriminating evidence. 15:54: 😢 The book 'My Friend Anna Frank' tells the story of Hannah's friendship with Anna Frank and her experience during the Holocaust. 23:55: 😢 Hannah's family and friends are being deported, but some manage to escape. 31:39: 😢 Hannah and her family were in Bergen Belson concentration camp, and Hannah believed her friend Anne Frank had escaped to Switzerland. 38:16: 💔 Hannah risks her safety to find her friend Anna in the concentration camp, despite the danger and lack of food. 45:01: ❤ Kindness and humanity in the midst of unimaginable suffering and dehumanization. 53:22: 🔑 Hannah's story highlights the guilt and shame felt by Holocaust survivors and their complicated feelings about survival and rebellion. 1:00:41: 😢 The power of hope and purpose in surviving difficult situations. 1:13:03: 😢 The interview discusses the impact of the Holocaust on people's relationship with food and cleanliness. 1:16:57: 👩👧👦 Hannah and Gabby had a close bond, with Gabby taking care of her sister even before the concentration camps, and they remained close throughout their lives. 1:24:48: ❤ Hannah's story is a life-affirming and heartbreaking human story that teaches us the importance of kindness, compassion, and treating everyone with respect. 1:32:54: ✨ The importance of doing good to others and speaking out against mistreatment. Recap by Tammy AI
I've been a holocaust enthusiast for many years and I will tell you the level of questioning that is in this interview is very very good a lot of questions I really wanted to know he addressed and im glad
I got the hardback version rather than the electronic or audio book. I think it was worth the extra for the photos. What can you say, but what the real Nazis (as opposed to those today unsure about pronouns) did was unspeakably cruel. We are fortunate that people like Hannah and her sister were able to survive and thrive. It is wonderfully written, but I found the extracts from Anne's diary the most moving. I will be re-reading it.
First they came for the Communists And I did not speak out Because I was not a Communist Then they came for the Socialists And I did not speak out Because I was not a Socialist Then they came for the trade unionists And I did not speak out Because I was not a trade unionist Then they came for the Jews And I did not speak out Because I was not a Jew Then they came for me And there was no one left To speak out for me Martin Niemöller
@alxdava2004 And the earth is flat I suppose? Seriously, what is wrong with that wonderful poem is that it seems to hold the notion that the Nazis could have been defeated by people "speaking out". Apart from the fact the Nazi party itself was full of politically motivated people "speaking out," people did speak out against the Nazis and often soon regretted it. If poetry could solve the world's problems ...
I too wonder how a people who have endured the worst atrocities that you can imagine can then be silent or assent to the inhumanity inflicted on Palestinian people. Are they so traumatized that they cannot see the suffering of others.
@@Afflictamine irs amazing how many people don't know anything about anything. No one thinks it's strange that the Israeli Mossad was trained by Skorzeny, an SS Commando who later retired to a farm in Ireland. Also the SS had a commemorative medal commemorating the Havara agreement. The World Zionist council was working with National Socialists until the Allies bombed all the infrastructure. There were 150,000 Jewish soldiers in the NSDAP forces as well. Wait until you read the new published diary of Winston Churchill!
Great talk, very interesting. The young woman needs to pace herself and speak with less hesitancy and rushing. When she hits her stride she is ok but the speaking style is unfortunate mostly. Too.scattered.
It's a great story, but Dina sounds like she did a few lines before this interview. The way she's talking is so rushed and manic, she talks over Ruthie constantly and interrupts her talking about her own mother. The way she talks is as if she knows more about Hanna than her own daughter does, which is very off-putting. I wish the interview was just Ruthie and Dr Rangan one on one, it would have been so much more impactful.
⚠️⚠️⚠️ *48:48** '...WHEN GOOD PEOPLE STAY QUIET,* *TERRIBLE THINGS CAN HAPPEN...'* ⚠️⚠️⚠️ I'm afraid you, Dr. Chatterjee, are sadly in this silent majority camp... I've been following you for many years & have recommended you to many many people, but i am very very disappointed with your silence on what is unfolding around the world in lockstep at the hands of 'The Powers That Should Not Be'... Time is of an essence... Imagine 2 / 5 / 10 years down the line, living in a dystopia: ' *DAD, WHY DIDN'T YOU SPEAK UP, WHEN YOU HAD THE CHANCE* ⁉️ '
*DR. CHATTERJEE,* When are you going to start talking about the following: - WHO Pandemic Treaty - Injuries Of A Certain Experimental Medical Procedure Which Are NOT Rare - The Society Wide Propagation Of Gender Dysphoria - Transhumanism - Programmable Central Bank Digital Currencies - Social Credit System - 15 Minute Cities - Etc, Etc, Etc ⁉️
Sorry not a fan of this one. My perspective is living with a child of WWII, it's my parents story, not their grandchildren. Furthermore, I would think as a doctor and the other valuable lessons about healing from trauma would resonate more. I would love to hear more recent stories of those that survived atrocities such as the Rwanda massacre, Bosnia etc.
Holocaust was 80 yrs ago. For 80 yrs every yr America reminds about Holocaust. Elementary kids have to watch horror videos and pictures about this sad event what happened. That put fear in kids mind. In war millions of civilians dying and its more then 12 million which no one’s talks about it. If they do then government will be forced to avoid wars and talk one on one. Right after this event Germany started paying the survivors families every month. Each family members gets more than $3 thousand dollars. These checks goes all over the world where they live. These checks are for the life time. I never heard anyone talks about how Germany every month giving millions of dollars to the survivors each family members. I don’t understand this didn’t happened in U.S. and we hVe our own problems so why are we being reminded all the time in America ? Even in Israel they don’t remind this every yr.
I guess I’m confused by this comment. I’m not sure how your parents having been in World War II (?) has to do with your children or this video, which isn’t just about World War II? Healing from trauma would resonate more than what? I thought they were talking about trauma here-how can you care about healing from trauma if you don’t know what causes it? But you do care about Rwanda and Bosnia because they’re more recent-and it’s ok to hear their stories? But only of healing? Are you saying the past is the past, in which case why bring up other past atrocities that are still historical? I assume you also didn’t like them mentioning slavery because that’s too far back - but you didn’t mention that for some reason. If there explained other specific issues you had with this, it might be understandable. As it is, it seems as though you are suggesting that you do have compassion for people around the world who were victims of atrocities but are not only uncompassionate towards but “not a fan of” other victims of atrocities. I thought the point of this was that compassionate towards one group of oppressed people should extend towards others. But you’re saying the opposite, that you actively dislike this idea and want to hear about … other atrocities only? Because they’re more “recent”? And “positive”?! (Aka about healing.) I don’t know how that works. (If I’m missing something in the video that explains this comment, feel free to point that out and call me a fool lol.)
@@dodgeroliver8469 People do talk about the many who died, and the number of civilians offed during WWII wasn’t 12 million, it was more than that. It’s good for people to be afraid of some things because fear helps us survive. Learning about this also helps us develop compassion and understanding of our current world which is essential for children. But many people don’t learn about it anyway, even in the United States, and obviously people didn’t learn about it for “80 years” because people barely knew about or acknowledged it for some time. People have also been complaining about the Holocaust “getting too much attention” since before the word was coined, so that also prevented and still prevents people from learning about it. Survivors did not get paid “right after the event” and it is not a uniform $3,000 a month. It took years and many people didn’t “qualify” for anything, no matter how much they should have. Obviously people in America have our own problems, all humans have their problems. Saying the Holocaust is just a “problem” that everyone in America has experienced the equivalent of shows you actually don’t know anything about it in spite of apparently being forced to learn about it as a kid. You are very misinformed.
Half way through the video, I felt very grateful for what I have now , I was being very negative with my life before listening to this. Thank you 🙏
What an amazing podcast, thank you Dr Rangan for your sharing Hannah’s wisdom with all of us. Love your guests today, full of love and humanity, very grateful!
A very good talk and a good healthy reminder of how kind as well as cruel humans, all of us, can be. TY Rangan, Dina, and daughter of Hannah.
RIP Hannah Goslar Pick
1928-2022
We must never forget what can happen. An important story to be told again and again so this never happens again. Right now the world is going through change that could should signal to us all, be aware of what conflict can lead too and let’s make sure this doesn’t happen again.
Such a powerful powerful message for today. G-d bless this woman, and everyone affected by the holocaust
Minute 48:45:
"When good people stay quiet,
terrible things can happen."
Reminder for eternity .
Sometimes when people speak out and get pro-active, terrible things happen.
There are no simple solutions.
Thank you for this time stamp. It's a damn shame Dr. Chatterjee is remaining silent on the tyrannies unfolding right under everyone's noses...
@@psychologicalprojectionist
True, .....sad reality
BUT !!!
I didn’t want to watch because this topic is just so sad, but I was transfixed. So much hope and positivity from all three of you, despite trudging through such a sad story. Really enlightening thanks
How would have I survived if I would have gone through what these amazing people endured? I have visited Auschwitz and Birkenau concentration camps and I think everyone should visit! Looking at the faces of the victims displayed on the walls it’s heartbreaking and it’s a wake-up call for us to be the best person we can be, be thankful for what we have and treat everyone with respect. This podcast, by sharing this incredible life story, is bringing consciousness of all these matters we should reflect on and act upon!
Thank you for sharing this story!! We all need to be more aware of the horrible things that happened in the past - and to be kind to one another - making sure they are not repeated.
Thank you doctor for this very emotional podcast story of Hannah and Gaby. Heart was torn thinking of the sufferings they had to endure througn the words of Ruth and Dina. Loved the message on love compassiin and to do good to other people. Thank you
You Country killed more than 12 million civilians worry about that! Holocaust happened 80 yrs ago. Your Country killed Africans 50 yrs ago and no one wants to talk about it or interview them. Your are Pessimistic if you keep listening to this. This man have to make money through interviewing people.
Every Holocaust survivor has an inspirational story. Looking forward to listening and learning.
Yeah I wonder why? $$$
These stories must be kept alive to remind us what hatred does and, most of all, how kindness makes us strive ❤❤
Read The myth of German villainy first. Search the data and come here again to tell us what you think
This was SO PROFOUND to listen to this story.
I'm in tears listening to the Hanna and Anna meet exchanging what happened with them
0:23: 📚 Hannah, a Jewish girl born in Berlin in 1928, becomes a refugee in Amsterdam during World War II and forms a close friendship with Anne Frank.
7:43: 😢 Hannah, a young Jewish girl living in Amsterdam during World War II, experiences the fear and uncertainty of the Nazi invasion and helps her father hide incriminating evidence.
15:54: 😢 The book 'My Friend Anna Frank' tells the story of Hannah's friendship with Anna Frank and her experience during the Holocaust.
23:55: 😢 Hannah's family and friends are being deported, but some manage to escape.
31:39: 😢 Hannah and her family were in Bergen Belson concentration camp, and Hannah believed her friend Anne Frank had escaped to Switzerland.
38:16: 💔 Hannah risks her safety to find her friend Anna in the concentration camp, despite the danger and lack of food.
45:01: ❤ Kindness and humanity in the midst of unimaginable suffering and dehumanization.
53:22: 🔑 Hannah's story highlights the guilt and shame felt by Holocaust survivors and their complicated feelings about survival and rebellion.
1:00:41: 😢 The power of hope and purpose in surviving difficult situations.
1:13:03: 😢 The interview discusses the impact of the Holocaust on people's relationship with food and cleanliness.
1:16:57: 👩👧👦 Hannah and Gabby had a close bond, with Gabby taking care of her sister even before the concentration camps, and they remained close throughout their lives.
1:24:48: ❤ Hannah's story is a life-affirming and heartbreaking human story that teaches us the importance of kindness, compassion, and treating everyone with respect.
1:32:54: ✨ The importance of doing good to others and speaking out against mistreatment.
Recap by Tammy AI
I've been a holocaust enthusiast for many years and I will tell you the level of questioning that is in this interview is very very good a lot of questions I really wanted to know he addressed and im glad
A Holocaust enthusiast?!? Perhaps rephrase lol (I hope)
I love Anne Franks Diary and the story of her life as well Hannahs. A-lot of whats going on today is a repeat of the holocaust
thanks for that we al need know about that suffer😢
31:47 - same
Any friend of Anna!
I got the hardback version rather than the electronic or audio book. I think it was worth the extra for the photos.
What can you say, but what the real Nazis (as opposed to those today unsure about pronouns) did was unspeakably cruel. We are fortunate that people like Hannah and her sister were able to survive and thrive.
It is wonderfully written, but I found the extracts from Anne's diary the most moving. I will be re-reading it.
So very harrowing and Hannah sounds remarkable, would be truly interested to know what she thinks of what is happening to Palestinians 🤔
Breaks my heart humanity hasn't learned.
I beg for a ceasefire.
Save Gaza
Did we learn nothing?
So interesting!
First they came for the Communists
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a Communist
Then they came for the Socialists
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a Socialist
Then they came for the trade unionists
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a trade unionist
Then they came for the Jews
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a Jew
Then they came for me
And there was no one left
To speak out for me
Martin Niemöller
And now they are coming for a BBC newsreader?
BLA BLA BLA
Read The myth of German villainy and tell us afterwards what's what
@alxdava2004 And the earth is flat I suppose?
Seriously, what is wrong with that wonderful poem is that it seems to hold the notion that the Nazis could have been defeated by people "speaking out". Apart from the fact the Nazi party itself was full of politically motivated people "speaking out," people did speak out against the Nazis and often soon regretted it.
If poetry could solve the world's problems ...
@@psychologicalprojectionist yes, is flat as your brain
@alxdava2004 Thank you for making this flat earth just that little bit better with those lovely sentiments.
I too wonder how a people who have endured the worst atrocities that you can imagine can then be silent or assent to the inhumanity inflicted on Palestinian people. Are they so traumatized that they cannot see the suffering of others.
Here we go. 😂
Would love to know how she sees Germany currently in the political scenario
Or the book burning in the US.
its Happening as we speak, with ukraine., yes we need these stories.
google the Ha 'avara Agreement. Also google Otto Skorzeny an SS officer who taught the Israeli Mossad.
spot on, it is amazing that so many people don't know about the Haavara Agreement
@@Afflictamine irs amazing how many people don't know anything about anything. No one thinks it's strange that the Israeli Mossad was trained by Skorzeny, an SS Commando who later retired to a farm in Ireland. Also the SS had a commemorative medal commemorating the Havara agreement. The World Zionist council was working with National Socialists until the Allies bombed all the infrastructure.
There were 150,000 Jewish soldiers in the NSDAP forces as well.
Wait until you read the new published diary of Winston Churchill!
Yap. Read The myth of german villainy. All there, and many many many more
Great talk, very interesting. The young woman needs to pace herself and speak with less hesitancy and rushing. When she hits her stride she is ok but the speaking style is unfortunate mostly. Too.scattered.
Dina talks too quickly… it’s stressful to listen to her
It's a thing with Jewish culture. You just gotta lean into it from a perspective of "we're here to just chatting and having coffee or tea etc."
Dan Carlin just released a really interesting podcast on the holocausts. Warning it is very graphic
It's a great story, but Dina sounds like she did a few lines before this interview. The way she's talking is so rushed and manic, she talks over Ruthie constantly and interrupts her talking about her own mother. The way she talks is as if she knows more about Hanna than her own daughter does, which is very off-putting. I wish the interview was just Ruthie and Dr Rangan one on one, it would have been so much more impactful.
Why is anti-semitism only talked about from "the far right"?
⚠️⚠️⚠️ *48:48** '...WHEN GOOD PEOPLE STAY QUIET,*
*TERRIBLE THINGS CAN HAPPEN...'* ⚠️⚠️⚠️
I'm afraid you, Dr. Chatterjee, are sadly in this silent majority camp... I've been following you for many years & have recommended you to many many people, but i am very very disappointed with your silence on what is unfolding around the world in lockstep at the hands of 'The Powers That Should Not Be'...
Time is of an essence... Imagine 2 / 5 / 10 years down the line, living in a dystopia:
' *DAD, WHY DIDN'T YOU SPEAK UP, WHEN YOU HAD THE CHANCE* ⁉️ '
*DR. CHATTERJEE,*
When are you going to start talking about the following:
- WHO Pandemic Treaty
- Injuries Of A Certain Experimental Medical Procedure Which Are NOT Rare
- The Society Wide Propagation Of Gender Dysphoria
- Transhumanism
- Programmable Central Bank Digital Currencies
- Social Credit System
- 15 Minute Cities
- Etc, Etc, Etc
⁉️
Ridiculous!
What is ridiculous? ThT 6 million Jews died..
OK Tim, go back to your fridge
@@danc8458Ya. And you to school again. Read The myth of german villainy, about the Haavara agreement. You're so brainwashed that you're pitiful
Sorry not a fan of this one. My perspective is living with a child of WWII, it's my parents story, not their grandchildren. Furthermore, I would think as a doctor and the other valuable lessons about healing from trauma would resonate more. I would love to hear more recent stories of those that survived atrocities such as the Rwanda massacre, Bosnia etc.
Holocaust was 80 yrs ago. For 80 yrs every yr America reminds about Holocaust. Elementary kids have to watch horror videos and pictures about this sad event what happened. That put fear in kids mind. In war millions of civilians dying and its more then 12 million which no one’s talks about it. If they do then government will be forced to avoid wars and talk one on one. Right after this event Germany started paying the survivors families every month. Each family members gets more than $3 thousand dollars. These checks goes all over the world where they live. These checks are for the life time. I never heard anyone talks about how Germany every month giving millions of dollars to the survivors each family members. I don’t understand this didn’t happened in U.S. and we hVe our own problems so why are we being reminded all the time in America ? Even in Israel they don’t remind this every yr.
@@dodgeroliver8469obviously the world hasn’t changed as we have seen since Oct 7.
I don’t need to wonder where you stand on this.
I guess I’m confused by this comment. I’m not sure how your parents having been in World War II (?) has to do with your children or this video, which isn’t just about World War II? Healing from trauma would resonate more than what? I thought they were talking about trauma here-how can you care about healing from trauma if you don’t know what causes it?
But you do care about Rwanda and Bosnia because they’re more recent-and it’s ok to hear their stories? But only of healing? Are you saying the past is the past, in which case why bring up other past atrocities that are still historical? I assume you also didn’t like them mentioning slavery because that’s too far back - but you didn’t mention that for some reason.
If there explained other specific issues you had with this, it might be understandable. As it is, it seems as though you are suggesting that you do have compassion for people around the world who were victims of atrocities but are not only uncompassionate towards but “not a fan of” other victims of atrocities.
I thought the point of this was that compassionate towards one group of oppressed people should extend towards others. But you’re saying the opposite, that you actively dislike this idea and want to hear about … other atrocities only? Because they’re more “recent”? And “positive”?! (Aka about healing.) I don’t know how that works.
(If I’m missing something in the video that explains this comment, feel free to point that out and call me a fool lol.)
@@dodgeroliver8469 People do talk about the many who died, and the number of civilians offed during WWII wasn’t 12 million, it was more than that. It’s good for people to be afraid of some things because fear helps us survive. Learning about this also helps us develop compassion and understanding of our current world which is essential for children.
But many people don’t learn about it anyway, even in the United States, and obviously people didn’t learn about it for “80 years” because people barely knew about or acknowledged it for some time. People have also been complaining about the Holocaust “getting too much attention” since before the word was coined, so that also prevented and still prevents people from learning about it.
Survivors did not get paid “right after the event” and it is not a uniform $3,000 a month. It took years and many people didn’t “qualify” for anything, no matter how much they should have. Obviously people in America have our own problems, all humans have their problems. Saying the Holocaust is just a “problem” that everyone in America has experienced the equivalent of shows you actually don’t know anything about it in spite of apparently being forced to learn about it as a kid. You are very misinformed.
@@NoelleMar unless you lived it, you don’t get to call it your story
Such a creative & imaginative narrative. 🥨