Bacteria Dosing Deep Dive: MB7 vs. Clean, Rappin' With ReefBum Sound Bite

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 21 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 47

  • @bigadventure3797
    @bigadventure3797 2 роки тому +1

    WOW that was great talk. Wish I would have seen this 3 years ago when I started my tank.

  • @sprayo1e
    @sprayo1e Рік тому +1

    Marketing at its finest. I would never trust a company that talks trash on another to get ahead of the game.

  • @capone-qk2pj
    @capone-qk2pj 3 роки тому +4

    What happened to the rest of the video

  • @karennation3580
    @karennation3580 3 місяці тому

    I have heard mb7 and dr tims refresh together works on cyano. What product is the same or replaces dr tims refresh? Would that be clean. I read to dose mb7 daily then dr tims once weekly! I think a brs video!

  • @karennation3580
    @karennation3580 3 місяці тому

    Great videoi am having a problem with some kind of alage or film that is growing on acrylic frag racks them smothers out my zoas! Its only on the and the new ones and no where else intank but glss right in front of them. . In one tank coraline took over and its gone but my other tank wont grow coraline for some reason and I cant get rid of it even with chemi clean! What could this be and how to treat. I dose mb 7 weekly! i also dose clean weekly. after mb7 didint work or chemi clean. I think I could have introduced it to my new frag tank too! Also peroxide gets rid of it temporaryly and comes back on zoas. I have a rubble bottom frag tank. I waited 3 months after cycling to turn lights on and its allover the rocks/rubble. How can I know if its cyano or just diatoms? It it to young to add chemiclen too a new frag tank? I just strated a 2 week regime of dosing clean daily! Hopefuly that works. I was dosing 1 x per week! I might have screwed up because he said not to add both in a less then 6 month old tank and i have added mb7 a few times too!

  • @CherryHaze86
    @CherryHaze86 3 роки тому +1

    I like the snippets, thanks.
    In a different note:
    I am surprised the idea that bubble algae will "release the spores" and spread if you pop it is so present in the hobby. Is there any research that can actually confirm or deny this idea?

    • @ReefBum
      @ReefBum  2 роки тому

      Apparently some research was done on this topic.

    • @Vdeez
      @Vdeez 2 роки тому +5

      The research that was done in this shows that it isn’t true.

    • @insanity4224
      @insanity4224 2 роки тому +1

      It doesn’t make any sense otherwise emerald crabs or any herbivores that eat it would spread the algae when they chew it. Sounds like an old tale from those who couldn’t keep it away.

  • @apdroidgeek1737
    @apdroidgeek1737 Рік тому

    i feel like a better comparison would be clean vs razor cuz both claims to loosen debris and clean also works with algae and cyano

  • @WB25Penn
    @WB25Penn 2 роки тому

    Hey Keith!! Great interview, question you mentioned you used the MB clean, how long did you use it for? Also, what was the schedule and dosage you used? and did you feel like it made a big difference? TIA

    • @ReefBum
      @ReefBum  2 роки тому +2

      I followed the dosage recommendations on the bottles. And this should answer some of your other questions: ua-cam.com/video/bNi-lB2et8o/v-deo.html

    • @WB25Penn
      @WB25Penn 2 роки тому

      @@ReefBum thank you!!

    • @WB25Penn
      @WB25Penn 2 роки тому

      @@ReefBum Hey Keith! Hope all is well, question, when you were using microbacter clean did you notice your nitrate drop and Po4 stay okay? I’m at .07no3 and .06 Po4. I have dosed mb clean for about 6 weeks now.

    • @ReefBum
      @ReefBum  2 роки тому

      @@WB25Penn I did take my chaeto offline when I started dosing both CLEAN and MB7 so I believe both nitrates and phosphates dipped after using these products.

  • @Stevedola11
    @Stevedola11 2 роки тому +2

    I am starting a new tank and was wondering on which product to dose? Im guessing MB7 would help with my bacteria population from the start and allow for a healthy tank start. What are your choices for starting a tank off correctly? I have a few pieces of LR but mostly dead marco rock which is why I want to seed it properly for good tank health.

    • @onlyericdunn
      @onlyericdunn 2 роки тому

      I used Micro Bacter XLM heavy handed. Then started dosing MB Clean after every weekly WC

  • @johnkelley4404
    @johnkelley4404 2 роки тому

    Yeah what about the white slime. Set-up a Red Sea max nano with 1 year old Carib sea rock from another tank. White slime 2 months later. Should I use mb7 or mb clean?

  • @lawrenceskegz781
    @lawrenceskegz781 2 роки тому

    Hi thanks for the really informative talk! People need more of these types of content videos as people drop out due to these issues!
    My question though to the both of you is thus:
    Nitrate @ 25 on salifert test kit
    Phosphate @ 0.09
    Alkalinity @ 8.3
    PH @ 8.1
    Calcium 430
    Magnesium @ 1430
    Salinity @ 1.025
    But ive got an issue with some golden brown algae thats on my glass ?? Just started dosing MB7 4 days ago and still no change??? Any help at all please.
    Thanks bum your vids are helping me loads!

    • @ReefBum
      @ReefBum  2 роки тому +1

      I would monitor it for a couple of weeks and adjust as needed. But your best bet is to reach out to Brightwell since it is their product.

  • @ronniekregar3482
    @ronniekregar3482 2 роки тому

    So what about this white slime I keep getting?

  • @sam89645
    @sam89645 2 роки тому

    Which is better for hair algea?

    • @FloodXL
      @FloodXL 2 роки тому

      It's sounding like Clean, based on the video.

  • @jahsreef8386
    @jahsreef8386 3 роки тому +1

    I always dose mb7 after a chemiclean treatment

    • @bigadventure3797
      @bigadventure3797 2 роки тому +1

      Learned that with this video. Wish I would have known a long time ago because I always have issues after a Chemiclean treatment.

    • @karennation3580
      @karennation3580 3 місяці тому

      @@bigadventure3797 My cyano or whatever it is I have just gets worse after chemi clean!

  • @mdwaller0416
    @mdwaller0416 2 роки тому

    Should filter socks/polishing pads be removed while dosing MB7?

    • @TonysCorals
      @TonysCorals 2 роки тому

      No the bottle does not say that, it does say to turn off UV and protein skimmer

    • @hurricaneaquatics
      @hurricaneaquatics 2 роки тому

      Yes, you should remove filter socks. You can keep a general pad that catches excess, food, etc. but a filter sock has the potential to affect the bacteria.

    • @TonysCorals
      @TonysCorals 2 роки тому

      @@hurricaneaquatics I would think the amount the filter sock catches is negligible, bacteria is just to small. And by the time it got to the socks it already got on your rock, sand, tank walls, and pipes. he says in the interview that it immediately sticks to surfaces it comes in contact with. I would assume that's why the bottle does not talk about socks. Unlike Dr Tim's that does mention the sock. Dr Tim knows his stuff so do w/e lol

    • @TonysCorals
      @TonysCorals 2 роки тому

      @@hurricaneaquatics Oh also I think the reason Dr Tims talks about sock and MB7 does not is because Dr tims is used all at once and MB7 ask to be dosed over like 2 weeks.

  • @sam89645
    @sam89645 2 роки тому

    Can you use bacter 7 and clean together as I restarted my tank with cycled rock after out of control hair algea. I flushed the whole system and now started with clean to boost the bacteria in the tank and thought to also start the bacter 7 is that good or not?

    • @ReefBum
      @ReefBum  2 роки тому +1

      Brightwell only recommends using both CLEAN and MB7 on established tanks at least a year old.

    • @sam89645
      @sam89645 2 роки тому

      @@ReefBum thank you for your information but wondering the tank was around 1 years old before I flushed the whole system and replaced the rocks with cycled ones due to out of control hair algea so I thought to increase the population of bacteria in the tank to avoid any issues so what you think? Only use clean?

    • @ReefBum
      @ReefBum  2 роки тому +1

      @@sam89645 You can reach out to Brightwell to get their recommendation. I would say to start with MB7 but they are the experts since they manufacture the products.

    • @sam89645
      @sam89645 2 роки тому

      @@ReefBum sure thanks I have already started with clean and leaving the 7 for later on that's why but you think 7. Both will be aggressive on the tank but I can see some of the ugly stage showing.

  • @rayrclark
    @rayrclark 3 роки тому

    Jesus another regurgitated old video. I love your content but I can't understand the repost.

    • @FloodXL
      @FloodXL 2 роки тому +5

      Likely because this a consolidated clip to emphasize some key points about both products. I certainly found it helpful for that reason. Keith's full length videos of these interviews can be over an hour.

  • @y_gagaring
    @y_gagaring 2 роки тому +5

    Wtf, way to slip your dig on a country by stating, "countries that viruses come from sometimes" sure you're not racist?! And before people start getting up in my response think about this, why bring up that point? Is it relevant to this discussion? If that really bothers you then maybe you should throw away 90 percent of the things you own like your iPhone, iPad, almost all electronics and most things you own. Because that country is the world's manufacturing hub.

    • @jerryzhao3026
      @jerryzhao3026 Рік тому

      Not going to spend a single cent on BW products anymore, bruh.

    • @marcopalazzo9349
      @marcopalazzo9349 8 місяців тому +1

      Because covid came from China and this was during or not long after covid. This isn't rascism stop playing the victim card.

    • @y_gagaring
      @y_gagaring 8 місяців тому

      @@marcopalazzo9349 you're missing the whole point as I stated, "why bring up that point" especially in that way. Why not just say manufactured in another country, you don't have to single out a specific country even though he didn't say it by name we know which country he is referring to. That my friend is the meaning of racism.
      Let's say he's trying to make a business deal with another company that is Chinese owned, do you think he would say to them our products aren't manufactured in a country that viruses are made. No, he would say we make our products in house.

    • @marcopalazzo9349
      @marcopalazzo9349 8 місяців тому

      @@y_gagaring because all cheap knock offs come from the country China, fucking grow up and put your victim card in the bin.