Question Time | 18th January 2024
Вставка
- Опубліковано 11 жов 2024
- Fiona Bruce presents live debate with politicians, commentators and the public, from Peterborough in Cambridgeshire. On the panel, from the government, Bim Afolami MP, who is a Treasury minister; Labour’s shadow attorney general, Emily Thornberry MP; the political editor and presenter at Times Radio, Kate McCann; and the barrister and author Hashi Mohamed. Also live on iPlayer at 8pm.
Copyright (C) BBC, BBC News, BBC One, BBC Worldwide, 2024. If you would like me to remove this video, please contact me, not UA-cam.
Hey! It would be greatly appreciated if you could buy me a coffee in lieu of all the videos I have uploaded. Everything here is free, worldwide. It really helps, Thank You.
www.buymeacoff...
I have been living in France now for 19 years . We live outside a very small Village that has Two doctors and a Dentist. The Doctor can always see the next day, and spends as much time with you as you need. My Dentist was able to see me in three days. All through the French Health Service.
damned french system .. not failing like the NHS -- how dare they !!!
Hashi Mohamed needs to run as an MP... the current crop (on both sides of the house) can't speak in anything but soundbites and we need some clear and articulate voices speaking the truth.
Question Time, the bridge between Have I Got News For You and 8 Out of 10 Cats.
Disturbing yet accurate
To say COVID is responsible for the lack of NHS Dentistry is a joke, Private Dentistry survived?
Thankyou Political TV for giving me good access to UK politics.
Hashi has done great.
Big problem in the NHS is the amount of money being funnelled to private organisations - done during the 90s and Labour years to "alleviate the back logs". We've got contractor agency staff and medical companies already doing vast amounts of work at higher cost... and it still can't cope. A big part of that cost is the extra red tape that PFI requires - a bit like leaving the EU, if you increase system barriers & complexity you increase cost and decrease quality. Mental health provision in this country is almost all private now. Anyone feel like there's an adequate provision? The money we spend 'on' the NHS that supposedly keeps increasing? That's the same pot of money that the the PFI partners get paid from. Why does no-one ask what proportion of the NHS budget that is? Let's really see how much of our failing NHS is currently private before we go charging off down the road of 'flexing out' using the private sector.
Given all that, why would trying to tackling the current backlog with "Private medicine vouchers" and bolting on more complexity do anything but accelerate the decline? Bad idea. Those medical staff still have to come from somewhere - meaning immigration until we've sorted out NHS working conditions and trained up a new generation of staff which in medicine takes years and years. Someone still has to manage the contracts - more cost. Private sector do what they do by cutting corners to maximise profits, and are protected from major failure by the arms length nature of PFI (see Fujitsu and the Post Office) so we don't get any accountability - and we get little enough accountability in this country as it is.
Get the private sector, other than medical/medicine suppliers, right off the NHS teat and bring all those services back in house - it WILL be cheaper. Remove the layer managing the interface between NHS and all those provider contracts.
The answer to the NHS is to take development of our own population's skills seriously, to do everything we can to make the working lives of NHS workers bearable (let's start with help with housing and parking costs, discounts on council tax, that sort of thing, as well as massively ramping up recruitment), and return control of (and budgets for) social care to them, which should never have been split off and given to local authorities (thanks labour!), because it increased complexity, increased the number of gaps people can fall through, and are not integrated with NHS needs so we get bed backlogs - it's taken 20 years and a pandemic to start getting them to really work together properly again and it's still full of barriers between organisations because they're all funded and therefore motivated differently.
It's been allowed to get into a state where it IS going to take 10 years and a ton of money to 'fix'. If we do anything private-related to help us get through then that all those contracts need a very short fixed term on them so that the companies are motivated to do a good, not cheap, job. If private sector is so amazing we should pay them to lead the way on quality and efficiency (not cost and efficiency) and help us develop our new processes, in order for our NHS to stand on it's own again.
It is going to take a lot of money and a lot of time - like everything else that's broken now. 14 years of bare minimum or less investment will do that to a nation.
DONT. VOTE. TORY. They just want to wreck the place and let big business feed on the remains and tell you to suck it up it's good for you. I thought people learned this in the 80s but apparently not.
DONT. VOTE. LABOUR. They do the exact same thing when it comes to institutions and our rights, but they tell you they love you whilst they're doing it. I thought people had learned this in the 90s/00s but apparently not.
There are other parties out there. There are other electoral systems to demand other than first past the post. Stop being fooled by 2 parties forcing a hand on you in perpetuity. They need to know we WILL turn away from them or they will never change our voting system, they'll never fix these problems because it's in their interests to have something to argue loudly but vaguely about every 5 years .
The problem is, much like here in the U.S., the parliamentary system aside, the two unprincipled major parties fail the country and people they're supposed to serve. It's devolved to a competition for power first and foremost, the public interests a distant second if at all and only to the point of avoiding revolution and violent overthrow.
Shows like this are Useless
All Talk while the country Rots 👎🇬🇧
Glad I got the fck out of Britain 30 years ago, feel so sad about the what has happened in the last 14 years, need to take a leaf out of the French !!!!
I’m glad I left too.
Plus 3
I think the greatest use the current state of Britain has is giving faith to those who have left that they’ve done the right thing.
@@kiriakoz can’t argue with that mate 👍
What, rioting and endless strikes and homeless people at all time high?
I am very afraid that Britain is finished!!!! The people still seem prepared to accept the tory gaslighting. Where will labour get the money from? Where did tories get the BILLIONS for their friend's giveaway contracts during covid etc, Rwanda plan etc, etc, etc The problem is that the tories have been and are still spending your money in a reckless way and the Brits are allowing it!!!! Britain/UK need a revolution NOW!!!
Yes always question Labour when it come to money sound economics never once have I heard Tories been answerable to the huge economic disaster they have implemented on the tax payer.,
Tories are not the party of sound economics plenty facts out there to proof that. Journalists do your job description take on the tories when it comes to prudence etc....
Fiona Bruce clearly is a Tory. She never grills them about economics as if the last 13 years are done resounding testimony saying they are perfect with money. @@lindacurrie8817
Best thing to do is get out! That's what I did- never been better.
Bim Afolami, like all the other incompetent MPs, keep using Covid as an excuse for their failures.
"What's your plan?" For the love of god, does that man not have ears? SQUASH THE GANGS, PROCESS THE APPLICATIONS is the plan from Labour. How many times do they have to say it before people like that hears it? This infuriates me.
Sure... but what's your plan? 😂😂😂
@@dub604 To eat cold meats, cheese and crackers after a hard day marking lol😂😂😂
A bit like when the media constantly ask Labour "how are you going to pay for it?".
Labour - "We want to bring back breakfast clubs and free school meals".
The media - "how you going to pay for it!?"
The Tories - "we want to send asylum seekers to Rwanda"
The same media - "yes".
Governments are mandated to sort out the country's challenges and problems.
Blame doctors, train drivers, and people of above average wages.
Do not blame politicians, please treat them with the respect they deserve.🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Bullshit mr
How useful to the NHS was the 210, mil that Baroness Mone took for PPI which was added to the sums invested in the NHS?
for the STory party she was worth each penny .... she crashed the NHS even more ... oven ready for sale .. as planned !!!
Must say QT is now low rate stuff...viewers leaving in droves...
Fiona should stick to antiques roadshow...
Needs a Brian Waldon type who can correct them..
American posting...never, ever, ever, ever give up your National Health. You will regret it, as will your kids, grandkids, great-grandkids and on and on. *Never* believe *any* conservative that tries to sell you on private insurance.
But they will not listen.
@@sanp6092: Sadly...tragically, you are probably correct.
american posting... i'd rather keep my private insurance. the waiting list is terrifying
@@tdub102 The waiting list with private insurance in the USA is terrifying...then the bill comes and you go bankrupt.
@@ChronicExcessiveManliness there is no waiting list. that's not something i've ever experienced.
You really do need to sell your soul to be a MP... an ability to convince people of the most improbable.
What laws could we not control when part of the EU lol.
Another remoaner who won't accept the referendum
Yep. we controlled them all. Not any more
Freedom of movement?
@@sandeepmann2642hello sandeepmann….I’m a Brit living in the Netherlands , I first arrived in 1979 on Freedom of Movement , I will tell you what happened when I arrived , I first went to the local cop shop and was given a three month stamp in me passport , which enabled me to find work , do the rest yourself boyo ,
So funny all these tories, all educated in the same school, look at this guys big hand gestures when talking. So cringey and fake like the PM. People dont communicate and talk like that in real life.
All learnt in Oxford Union debating and private schools. These are the most loathsome types of politicians, preaching prudence and economising to the masses while they fill their pockets and have booze ups that the taxpayer helps to fund.
Omg this. The "one" it's amazing that working class people can relate to them. Such pompous bastards.
And did that pointy thumb thing
Emily Thornberry's statement about when Labour left government (2010) that the NHS was "sorted" is true. The Labour governments from 1997-2010 invested the necessary money and kept waiting lists low. The NHS was not a burning issue amongst the UK public. It was regarded as the jewel in the crown, that everyone was very proud of.
Once the Tories took over, they began to deciminate it, and all public services.
Their ultimate goal is to ensure that it does completely crumble so that it will privatise it. as they have with so many other public services which they have ruined.
Once privatised, there will be CEOs, Boards of Directors, and shareholders enriching themselves and costs for medical treatment will soar.
The US is the worst example of private healthcare in the western world.
Why do people think that it’s a choice between the UK NHS and the US system? Singapore and Germany have systems that are better than Britain with no up front cost.
As for privatisation, if you had a large amount of money to invest, took at look at the NHS there’s no way on earth you’d want to buy it.
@@Jesus420.69It's already been mostly privatised from within. This started under John Major and continued with Tony Blair.
@@moomin7461 yes, there’s private sector tender. When I broke my arm two years ago, the X-ray camera was built by Samsung. It didn’t cost me a penny. There’s no reason to believe a state built camera would be superior.
@Jesus420.69
Why are private investors hovering like vultures around the NHS I what you say is true? Much is already 'outsourced'.
Trump wanted to 'invest' in the NHS. It has a captive audience waiting to be exploited, squeezed dry like Americans.
Liebour sold part of the NHS of and built hospitals WITH PF FINANCE WICH THE NHS CAN NOT FULL OPARAT ON FOR PAYING THE INTREST OF THATS LIEBOUR FOR YOU NO DIFRENT TO TORYS VOT REFORM PARTY GET RID OF THE HATE UK LOT OF HATERS LIEBOUER TORYS
Stop the boats, stop the boats.
Well stop some of the boats, reduce the stop. Help to stop the boats, give loads of money to stop the boats we will stop the boats. We will redefine stop the boats put the government on a boat, no, no, send the government to Roanda, we've done that, it didn't stop the boats.
Go back to primary school 🏫
The boats/Rwanda are a red herring. If they stopped them they would have to spend more time talking about how they have trebled annual legal immigration in this parliament.
👍
Not to mention the Tory twarts have increased the national debt by 1.2 trillion in 13 years, where the fck is the money honey???
Boat people is what they focus on in order to scare people. Also, love how they have another right wing journalist (times and TalkTv presenter). Disgraceful country.
750, 000 immigrants last year of which approx 30, 000 arrived by "illegal" small boat crossings. Sledgehammer to not even crack a nut???
30k on small boats? The point is no one knows how many are arriving as it's not recorded...it's impossible to do so
Dim Bim
THE TORIES ARE TOTALLY OUT OF TOUCH.
THERE POLE RATINGS ARE ON THE FLOOR.
AND THEY PUT ON A POSH SCHOOLBOY WHO HASN'T A CLUE.
Thanks for posting
I was in the UK two years ago and I checked out the cost of beef and if that is what it cost me to buy meat in Canada there is no way I could afford it.
Lets see the cost analysis of the Rwanda plan to prove it is value for money.
750k immigrants came to the UK of that 30k on via boats. What is happening to the other 720k. How many will be sent to Rwanda per year & at what cost.
🤡😂
Don’t use logic, not in the uk. The tabloids set the agenda and they’ve scared everyone silly.
None, it's deliberate, has been for decades under every government.
750,000 were invited by your beloved Tories. 10's of thousands they said they would get it down to when they lied when selling you the scam of brexit
Legal immigrants?
The UK has been living way beyond her means for decades and now the chickens are coming home to roost. I’m a retired NHS trained registered nurse and was damn proud of it but it took working overseas to make me realise that there are many other countries with infinitely better health systems. The problems are complex and many. Staffing, quality of staff, procurement, waiting lists, old computer systems, crumbling buildings, the list goes on.
What happens when more people want to go private? So many health care staff work across both sectors. Nobody seems to have thought about that one. And the whole world is short of health care staff. The way things seem to be going no one is going to want to work in the uk.
I’m lucky enough to now live in Australia. I have to say while not perfect it’s much fairer system.
Last year my now 89 year old mum who lives in the uk needed a hip replacement ..she had it done privately as the waiting list was so long. It was straightforward but cost £16000!
Just a few months later a friend (in Australia) , his father in law who had emigrated 2 years previously needed the same op. He also went private but it cost him $18000! That’s roughly £8500!!!Meaning UK cost was almost double that of Australia. Why should this be so? Our health care professionals earn considerably more than uk equivalent!! So the uk are making a killing pardon the pun. Such greed. It is well known that a lot of over servicing goes on within the private health care sector. A year before her op my mum had a stroke and I didn’t think she would be fit enough for the hip op. But on having her follow up the consultant told that while actual op had been a success her mobility was still limited because of the stroke!! I believe she was ripped off.
Yes, for how long have we heard that the British health service is the envy of the world? IT JUST ISN'T TRUE!!!
I have lived in France for more than 20 years and have experienced their FAR SUPERIOR health system at first hand!!!!! It Is truly wonderful and much better than English, Welsh or Scottish NHS!!!
This stuff DOESN'T get said..... this should not be a UA-cam comment ..... this is an important news reference.....we need to hear this stuff. Prima Facie evidence from the coal face.... professional high calibre credible and experienced input, combined with personal difficulties and a summary that would be considered gold-dust for any enquiry or investigation...... far too valuable for a simple UA-cam comment.
Thank you for this.
Thanks for the positivity , I appreciate it.
I guess I’m old school , but I’m so disappointed at what’s happened to the NHS. I try to visit the uk every couple of years and each time things seem to get worse than before.
I even heard recently that uk trained health care staff will be asked to undertake a bridging course to get a visa to work in places like the US, Canada, New Zealand and Australia. This is in order to meet the competency outcomes. Entry into the study is actually easier than it used to be under the traditional system and we are hearing stories of unis passing students when they are not yet competent as they are under pressure from government to get more qualified staff out there. No wonder people are leaving in droves . That’s an accident waiting to happen. You’ve always had to have half a brain to be a competent and proficient nurse. Academia is only part of it. Florence Nightingale will be turning in her grave!
Apologies for the rant but I’m really disappointed at what’s happened to the profession. It used to be against the RCN rules to go on strike and that’s a disappointment too.@@FEAR.LESS.
Never apologise for the truth. It stacks up and gains weight. My Mum is 76, retired, RCN and said it fell apart when sister's were abolished and replaced with managers and contractors replaced direct employees (from cleaning to catering, medical and clincal..... the railways went the same way..... privatisation, trusts, shareholders and replaced care, well..... that's what she always said. She still finds the demise shameful but totally predictable and to think that the people who knew how to run the whole delicate miracle of Clement Atlee were brushed aside and replaced with politician's cronies and wasteful bloated management.
Again, thank you. Don't apologise for having integrity.
Xx (bet you don't miss the weather)
Totally agree with your mum!
@@FEAR.LESS. Yes, it’s a beautiful 30 degrees today. X
I can't believe we woke people on the panel.
As a Hitchin MP I have contacted him with a Ukraine refugee child. I reminded him he did not reply. His answer was did i get your email and when. A hotel was used in our area and he did not even know about it. I will not vote for him Mr A. I let you listen to him and think your thoughts.
At the end, they started to talk about meat on the table and one of them said eating less meet would save the planet. No one needs to save the planet, Earth will be there long after humanity is gone. What he and others, debating this topic, should say is: "We need to do this (or that) to save humanity. Earth will not be destroyed, it will become uninhabitable to humans, but thats it.
With all due respect, that's a very pedantic argument. When we are talking about saving the planet, we are talking about saving the planet from a state in which it is no longer inhabitable. You're simply arguing over linguistics. It is a scientific fact that meat, particularly beef, causes significant environmental damage and is something we need to cut down on to reduce emissions.
Meat has been proven to cause cancer. I mean all meats. Cancer is now 1 in 2. This system is toxic we must create an alliance no more governments. No more bs. No more cabal master puppeteers.
Not one person will be sent to Rwanda. Will refugees who have risked their lives and spent their life savings getting to Dover be deterred by the very slim possibility of being sent to Rwanda - a less than 2% chance? No. Are any aircraft available for these two way deportation flights? No. Two way because taking into account the returns agreement, the net numbers will remain the same as we ferry Rwandans back to the UK. Even if aircraft are tracked down, there will be mass protests against these flights at Boscombe Down, or wherever they might depart from. So has the perimeter been secured to cope with protestors, and if so, how many more millions have been spent on security? Come on Mr Sunhat, what's the REAL motive behind this unworkable plan? Is it to enable you to shamelessly blame Labour for vowing to do what is morally and legally right in promising to bin this revoltingly dishonest and hugely expensive ruse? Or to blame the "unelected House of Lords" for injecting commonsense and pragmatism into an unworkable, illegal and spurious ploy? Yeah right, point accusing fingers at the Lords, where the CONservatives have a 100 seat majority! Or is this a delaying tactic to buy enough time to clinch a lucrative UK/India/Infosys trade deal before being forced out of office? Or to provoke a handful of refugees to the point of despair so they appeal against being sent to an unsafe autocracy? Whereupon the government will pounce at the excuse to overrule UK and International courts when they attempt to do their duty in upholding the rule of law and imparting humanitarian justice? Is it part of a surreptitious plan to further erode the Separation of Powers? Another step towards deregulation? For example, if the government weaken the independence of the Judiciary by overruling, bullying or bypassing the courts over matters of asylum law, they'll feel free to do exactly the same for employment law. Maternity leave, paid leave, working hours directives, minimum wages, health and safety obligations, human rights - all very costly and totally anathema to the concept of high profit "de-regulated" Free Ports and SEZs. We see the real motives behind this Rwanda debacle - not all of us have been brainwashed by the Daily Whatevers. The polls show that the clear 'will of the people' is not to clamour for specious Rwandan ruses. The undeniable 'will of the people' is actually for Mr Rich Sunhat to call the removals lorry and vacate No. 10.
Yes I would spend and risk everything to escape from France
Yes, exactly that!
Who's literally supplying the boats? The vendors / manufacturers should be regulated / fined and some kind of licence put in place to stop them being used for illegal crossings
Too much focus on stopping gangs and not enough on providing safe legal routes. If you provide safe affordable routes then the gangs will not have these desperate customers.
Why not open a few offices in france where people can put in their asylum applications? After doing that just make in clear that anyone arriving on boats will get deported. But you can't do that second part without doing the first first.
safe legal routes ? all the way back to your post code ?
Kier Sunack same shite different shelf 😂
Both puppets of the USA and corporations
We are the 51st state 😱
The £400 million that we have already given to Rwanda, for us to send a few hundreds or a thousand per year, is bloody reminds me of silly season.
Crowd laughing at 28 billion borrowing but that was clueless and didn't know where the money is borrow from.
3 options
1. Grow the economy
2. Raise taxes
3. Borrow money
Which do you choose 2 of 3 to fix the country (hint: if option 2 is one of your choices don’t tell anyone before the election)
Where's the option cur uneccesary costs - like all those of foreign extraction here that don't bring more benefits than costs?
@@GodsOwnPrototype drop in the bucket
Thanks P TV
Yey :) Great channel. Righto, got my coffee and my toast, let's go...
13.00 some people still don’t realise the sick disgusting slogans of Brexit, “take back control”, “oven ready”. I just hope one day people can realise they have been done, it was not about the small person, it was about tax loopholes and the super rich. It has been a disaster, and we need immigration.
We don't need the level of immigration we have right now its ridiculous
Exactly
You dont need ALL immigration. And what the hell is wrong with demanding it be by legal and sorted means?
With many EU countries looking at using a 3rd country to process immigration, with Denmark actually proposing a Rwanda solution 2 years before the UK, is the UK still wrong?
Absolutely!
Disappointing to see that people in Britain are as conceding if not spineless when it comes to Trump as in the Republican party.
I have no idea what you're talking about
@@GodsOwnPrototypeYes,can't understand the grammar or make sense of the comment.
You sound like Joe Biden!
@@paulsmith9418 : He is damn lucky to be aligned with President Biden. Better him than that the functionally illiterate convicted sex offender.
I'm going to Peterborough to talk to the people and I know nothing about Peterborough.🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
I had a dream the other day : there were no tories sitting in parliament and all the aristocracy guillautined for not helping their fellow human being during hard time.
I have a dream!
So the UK are meant to fix other countries problems. Send them all back on boats and look after our own.
please stop living in dreamland and come back to reality. what do you think Labour would do? Do you think Labour would solve this issue? They have no plan and never will. all Labour are interested in is increasing their vote share by getting these people into the country, following the socialist ideolgy of providing for them at the expense of the UK taxpayer. Labour have no intrest in solving this crisis. But then if you agree Labour could not solve this who else do you think would? I suggest you do some research on this topic because there are many factors to this mess. There are approximately 17000 individuals roaming around the country with absolutley no knowledge of their wareabouts. This is a risk to those individuals for various reasons (slave labour just one example) and a risk to society where potentially known criminals are at large. Would you feel the same if a member of your family was a victim of crime of one of these absconders? Ithink not. Oh please dont play the race card, because nothing I have said is racist, its just plain fact and common sense. The French Government could stop this ina heart beat, but why would they. They are happy to offload to the UK and there is evidence that the French government have been complicit in facilitating this.
@@richardbentham6760so you are quite happy for this shambles of a gov to continue for another term. Look at the stats. GDP 13 years ago, NHS waiting lists, pre Brexit balance of payments, utility companies service standards pre nationalisation, social mobility, wealth differential between different socio economic groups, living standards generally outside the millionaire bubble. Now country is being dictated to and irrevocably changed by small cabal of extremists whose only driving force is their own narrow self interests. No labour won't reverse these debilitating trends in one term. The seriousness of our situation may mean they won't be able to achieve it in two terms but to think more of the same politically and economically is madness and may well lead to social unrest even anarchy.
Sounds more like a, nightmare.
@@patricksril no monarchy, sell of palaces and contents to clear national debt, Shore up NHS and social care, means tested university education, abolish faith schools, unelected 2nd chamber, no 2nd jobs for MPs, no pressure groups in parliament, Abolish private schools, tax rich at 90p in £, tax threshold increased to £30k, raise inheritance and capital gains tax, rejoin EU, no second homes, stop supporting Netenyahu and zionist government, Abolish factory farming and introduce stringent and regular inspections to ensure high welfare standards, renationalise railways and utilities, means tested provision of insulation, heat pumps and solar panels for all homes, all homes should meet minimum green standards with strict penalties for non adherence, add further 5 council tax bands, adequately sized homeless shelters in every city to provide sleeping and bathing and medical facilities. Well at least that's a start anyway. I had a dream.
As a German (one of nearly 400,000 living in the Divided Kingdom), I am an entrepreneure and owner of a very successful business owner here in Norfolk. I employ many hundreds of people, however I have given up on this country. I am closing down all my British operations and relocating back to Germany, because Brexshit makes everything ridiculous; paperwork, additional costs, tariffs and also I no longer feel welcome! Bye bye English, and good luck!
Filed under things that never happened...
Bye
Why would you use nhs if you can go private lol. Love how everyone claims using the nhs like some sort of badge and points.
Because we pay taxes for it lol
If you have a cardiac arrest whilst in a private hospital you will betaken to the nearest NHS hospital!
Why Is It the responsibility of UK tax paying population to feed and house and pay to all of North African Illegal Immigrant MEN?!!
the migrants come from many places not only Afrca and bear in mind it is NOT ILLEGAL to migrate, so stop regurgitating tory shite will you cheers
@@tomfinney3416 So you're a backer of the demograph9lic policies that is set to make English children a minority in English schools within 12 years.
The English Nation to be rendered a minority in their homeland of England in mere decades; all Britons to be a minority in the Isles a few short years after that.?
@@GodsOwnPrototype im sorry i do not bother answering folk who believe such crap , sort your head out we chat then
Thornberry needs to make way for the next generation - people who are competent
Sack her
Trump (and Biden) should then make way for the next generation and the one after that.
how would people on benefits get private healthcare?
After centuries of immigration ( have a look how much of your genetic code is foreign !!! ) since Hastings , the people of the Uk who ,often can follow back their ancestors to people from Angle and Saxony ( isn't is ironic - from the Hunns as you call them !!) , have now discovered that they do not like asylum seekers or people from the EU to come to their country
ok - we stay home and good luck over there ..
Calling Trump a cancer of US politics? I hope he gets in as POTUS as he gets things done.
I work in the NHS. There is no investment in training nurses hence we spend 2x the wages on agency nurses. We recruit so many nurses from India now.
seems Brexshit works finally !!! good news ...
In Australia our government made a decision to stop illegal boat arrivals by turning back the boats. There was a lot of objections on moral grounds and saying that if was dangerous etc. but the boats stopped arriving. It just needs the UK to make the decision and then stick to it. If anyone should make it to the UK, remove them within 72 Hours no ifs no buts no legal challenges. Governments have to stand up and be firm
but the english invaded australia with boats.
Lowkey? what a useless comment If you can't contribute with a meaningful comment don't waste our time, you don't even use your name@@lowkeyconvert8971
Italy had 115.000 in 2023 arriving new , in Germany 1.3 million refugees in total , in Turkey live 3,8 Millionn , Sudan 1.3 million - Jordan took 670.000 ...
The Uk had 30.000 last year !!! your island really must be packed !!! we can see it from the numbers !!!
They are ALL TALKINg BOLLOX!!!
You're all playing with us, Fiona included.
400 million wasted to send just 500 people to Rwanda a year and also getting people from Rwanda in return ?
It really is time for the Government to go.
Question Time,
'Does the panel agree with my bigoted opinion that people oop north are more miserable than people down south '
Fiona Bruce, ' lets start with you Sir Kenneth......'
Ofc he blames the junior doctors lol typical politician behaviour- take no responsibility whatsoever.
stop the benefits then the boats will stop quite simple really
Yes good idea
This was the worst panel ever
Labour will get the national debt up to 5 trillion, they always over spent, then we will have 15 year of austerity measures again under another party.
nice belief
"...stop the boats from coming over...."
does anyone else see the irony?
Seems lots of folk cannot get an NHS dentist. Easy answer: just get a cheap flight to Budapest where dentists have the latest equipment, great facilities and are half or more than half cheaper than the UK.
Thornberry wasn't there to answer any questions or explain what is the Labour plan. All she done was a campaign for Keir Starmer. What a shambles. Fiona asked her directly, where the money come from and she wouldn't answer.
56:22 You can make your own decisions as long as it's not to hop on a small boat from Calais!
Or TO Calais???????,
The problem we have with the NHS is we have more people coming into the country then leaving & we have to many top managers that’s why there is no money the more we pump in the more they will take & that is fact
Some/many Americans seem to be rehearsing for another 1933.
'reduce significantly the number of boats!' The new Tory slogan.
Ohhh gosh absolute shambles 😅
It’s not funny but I couldn’t hold it when the labour lady said there are 5000 immigrants and they’ve lost 4250 🤦🏽♀️🤦🏽♀️🤦🏽♀️
I think the Conservative should be ashamed of themselves, for turning this once great country into a third world country.
If the Tories have managed to bring down the small boat crossings by a third already then they don’t need the illegal Rwanda scheme because the problem will fixing itself. Just create more Albanian style return schemes, process asylum seekers and let the successful applicants work and pay back into the system.
Kate McCann... The whole package!
Get victoria derbyshire on this programme it might then be worth watching
Nobody from Peterborough present in a BBC question time in Peterborough. As usual a London-centric panel if I was from Peterborough I would complain.
The ECHR has nothing to do with EU Laws. It's Human Rights Law that protects the people in Britain. The Hillsborough victims got justice via the ECHR when the UK Supreme court denied them justice! We're giving that up to send 500 people a year to Rwanda, and no cap on Rwandans arriving here. Lol. Isn't that ludicrous!
How correct you are. Citizens of UK must not let the Tories get their vile toxic hands on ECHR they will set a bone fire to all working rights and much more laws that protect the people in Britain will be scraped. Tories will rattle in a written piece of fag paper legislation and a half baked bill of rights and sell it to the UK citizens, sadly many will buy it. Do not buy it, Do not let that happen must not give Tories more power majority of citizens will not benefit from the loss of ECHR
Why do they never have Nigel Farage on?, this topic is right up his sleeve. Are we so scared of a leader that will do as he said.
He’s been on question time more than anyone since 2010.
@@chazzacw3947 You obviously like listening to lies, I would rather someone tell it as it is.
Didn’t make any political assertion at all.
Just counting my dude.
QT go to Kent or any city where boats are turning up on the shores and ask them people if they want the boats stopped. ffs
Moynihan’s Law: The Better Things Get, The Worse They Seem
The greater the number of complaints being aired, the better protected are human rights in that country." In other words: the better things get, the worse they seem.
Or it could be bull shit.
It's time to book your table at The Restaurant at the End of the Universe.
Emily Thornburry won't say NO to Israel
Can people have enough time to finish a sentence!
How does Fiona Bruce deal with so many BIG EGOS on the panel?
What do you mean state beneficiary
28 billion is half of what was spent on track and trace. Where is the track and trace money?
oh nice lets have a watch of question time then
We trusted the conservatives, god help the u.k.
The thing that is most upsetting is that political party after political party has chosen to close their eyes to the impact of their actions in Africa.
Children denied school, health care, food. And it goes on and on and on. But some of those Children will survive and will grow up to hate you and i hope one day the African countries put sanctions on European, England and America. Long over due in fact.
There isn’t enough housing or infrastructure to keep the people in this country now, society is breaking down the uk is broken
Fiona is shocked about dentists !! Shocked !!!
that guy who wants an agreement with France. we had it then voted out of it. its our own fault
yeah.we should do as France says, the reason illegal immigrants come here is because of do gooders like you
10:30 Dresden the German "town", population 54,000😕
END OF 500 BILLION SPENT ON A RAILWAY WE DONT NEED BY THE TORIES, THINK WHAT THAT COULD HAVE DONE TO HELP THE NHS, ANYONE WHO VOTES TORIE WANTS THERE HEAD TESTING ,
bim's not gonna fall for the banana in the tailpipe
One Uk politician will say no to Trump or any USA president ever.
Cruel Britannia...Thornbury
...fake anger pathetic!
NHS ...❤...still value for THE MONEY YOU PUT IN..want better ..stop private ...problem solved.
31:54 Neville Chamberlain would approve (cringe) It doesn't matter if you kiss Trump's butt, the UK is of no concern to him.
I've just watched this and have concluded I'm sick of the Tories, the media, the 'news', the labour lot, the nationalists, the liberals, the lawyers, the greens, donalodo trump, brexit, apples into dover etc etc. Most of aal I'm sick of the Tories though cos they've had the power and have telt the whoppers that did the most damage. Christ on a bike take me back to 82 when i was permanently pissed/on glue/smoking tabs ) More net, more propaganda - I'm on me way to the Coop to see if they still do white lightning/evo stick and bensons tabs. In 82 i didnt bother with dentists like