❣️ CAN'T STOP SINGING || OLD VS NEW || OFFICIAL COMPARISON ❣️
Вставка
- Опубліковано 2 кві 2023
- NEW: • ❣️ CAN'T STOP SINGING ...
OLD: • (Remake In Desc!)【❣ CA...
I'm part 13 in the map and got permission to upload it from SaturnSkyez, we wanted to make this video to thank for the support of both maps! So this is the official comparison :DDD - Фільми й анімація
Since apparently this has to be said: if you write comments about how "the original is better" or just dunking on parts, you comment //will// be deleted! Animators came together to redo their parts for YOU and for YOUR enjoyment. We did not have to do this. By saying the original is better, you are actively saying that the artist's old work is better than their new work; which isn't a good thing to hear.
This idea was the first of it's kind: having a reanimated project with the original animators. Given some of the abhorrent comments we've received on both videos, I find it highly unlikely others would attempt the same thing.
Seen the old one before the new one released i compared them and the newer version looks better for some reason but both were good sorry to confuse you (edit:im just saying the new design looks good but both are wonderful do come for and correct me if I'm wrong i did see a few mistakes from my point of view in the older version) and 1:09 when sandstorm throws firestar/heart away from her i laughed so hard
I think the new one seems better in my opinion.
Both of them are super good like super super super super sup………(1000supers)sooooooooooooooooooooo goooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooood both of them are awesome
how are y'all reading a comment literally asking you to not compare them and are still doing that 💀
@@meevins we want to i just wanted to see how they improved over the past two years they still look the same but the remake looks better from my pov
Tysm for uploading this! To clarify for commenters, I gave permission for this to go up on their channel!
Ok good I was about to say something also love your work keep it up
@@davenolan5 ty for looking out haha, I'll do my best!
Cherrypics’s art style is strangely nostalgic
Thank you for clarifying
Your vids re awesome, thanks for the great content!
its genuinely so insane how the growth throughout the years, even the people who didn't remake their parts
Oh that’s why some of ‘em looked exactly the same
I agree
1:50 Omg the new animation is stunning with this one!
Both ones of them are amazing but the new one is just AAA so much improvement
I absolutely love this map, both versions! My favorite piece was CherryPics, just because the animation was so smooth and I love their improvement! Great work, SaturnSkyez, and all the people who took time out of their days to work on this beautiful MAP!
Yeah that was AMAZING!
Also it’s at 1:50 to save time
My eyes: ⬅️➡️⬅️➡️⬅️➡️⬅️➡️⬅️➡️⬅️➡️
Yes, my also😅😂😂
Both have their own fun moments! It's really cool to see how much animators in this MAP improved!
DUDE it really is insane how much people can improve in a short amount of time (I'm absolutely at you Shan)
EHEHEHE I LOVE YOU
Everyone improved so much!!
It’s incredible to see!!
Thank you to all the artists for doing this again!!
Yay!! Love seeing them side-by-side.
Biggest plot twist of the year is learning that the cats at 2:12 were _not_ Graystripe and Dustpelt.
I always thought MouseFur and BlueStar instead of CinderPelt 😂😂
I know right 😂
NO I WAS SO SHOCKED
It was surprising, but 1, Dustpelt wanted to be Sandstorm's mate, so it wouldn't make sense for him to be supporting her decision, and 2, Cinderpelt was to one to tell Firestar that Sandstorm liked him.
I love this. So interesting to see the difference and how much each artist has come on in their chosen style( that's not meant to be negative) . I think more people should try this. THIS IS EPIC!!❤❤🎉🎉
Can we all agree that 1:53 had the best improvement?
The old part was AMAZING, I loved it. But when side to side you could see just how much they had improved
Yea
Yup
Oh for sure! Cherry has improved so much! I’m greatly inspired by her stuff…
1:50?
Or 1:53 bc I’m confused
Its amazing to see how much the animators have improved!! Good job to everyone!
This is the definition of if you practice you can become even better than you already are!
It is genuinely so amazing how much this song has improved over the past few years! I mean there both amazing, and have good parts in their own ways- but it just insane how different they are!
-Moonsong medicine cat of ThunderClan
OMG I REMEMBER THIS MAP!
i would watch it all the time because i loved it and i was going through a hard time.
Im going through another hard time, and i found this, and im so happy im crying
I love both versions, i cant choose a favorite😢
Thank you, saturnskyez, and all these animators, for bringing this into my life❤😊
You r welcome!
2:16 The way Cinderpelt gets ran over by tiger star in the backround of the NEW frame XV
Is it just me or did anyone else notice cinderheart get runiver by a motorbike
(2:16)
it is so amazing and inspiring to see the improvements made over the years. One of the biggest things I noticed was the framing/camera movements. The experience the artists have gained have seriously improved the quality of the MAP
This is so beautiful to see both the improvements of style and animation as these artists made a remake of this. You all made such great improvements!👏👏👏
This Map includes several of my favorite animators and a few friends. I love this map to bits. I’m so glad it was remade XD. It also helped me meet several of my friends and made me who I am today. Love it
Seeing the side by sides of the improvements people made is so beautiful!
i love seeing the growth
I think there are a few parts from the old one that were done so incredibly well, but it really is cool to see the improvement over the people who came back to redo their parts.
the growth of these artists is amazing!
This is a very nostalgic map for me. And I love both versions! And all the artists have improved but I do love both of the versions!
EVERYONE’S COME SO FAR AAA SO PROUD OF YALL!!!!
You definitely can see the difference on how the animators have changed! They have grown and gotten better and their work has a more advanced look to it! Not gonna lie, 2021's version is very good as well, just pointed how much the animators have gone in only a few years.
I love this! It's so much fun to watch how much people have improved over time, or even their new animations
it’s AMAZING seeing the improvement in just 2 years! wow!
These are such great improvements! I love all of the art styles ❤
I love how the artists improved! I love seeing people improve! Because both the old and new are good! Keep up the good work!❤👍
2:11 is my favorite improvement
It's so awesome to see the growth of the animators' skills over the past few years! Great work to everybody in the MAPs, all of the parts look great in the old and the new, and you should all be proud of how far you've come since the original!
The both animations are AMAZING!! Now pls don’t delete this, but I’m a sucker for the 2008-2012 style and the old one is a representation of it imo, so i personally like the style of the old one and the skill and improvement of the newer one. They both are good in their own ways.
You guys have improved so much better I love the new version
holy shit the new version is way more lively and also comical (lmao that part at 1:47) and more fluid it's insane to see how did the artists improve
(cherrypics you're a god how even did you improve that way in 2 FUCKIN YEARS)
The improvement is such a good thing to see! Very very nice!
This is incredible, the artists improved ALOT.
wow! I love both, but the new one is so improved it’s insane. the creators are so talented!!
All the people improved so well!their art was amazing to begin with,but wowee they improved!
1:46 is so goofy in the new one
I love how you can tell who didn’t redo their parts, wether they decided not to because they’re onto new styles or things in general or even if they just disappeared for whatever reasons
Mostly, I love the growth the animators had along the way!
Wow, this was one of the first maps I watched. It’s incredible how much it improved and the artists did so good!!
Thanks for uploading!
I love all the improvements in animation and art style! The original was fantastic but this is a whole new level!
aaamagawd :00 i remember watching the original two years ago >w< the improvement is amazing :00
I love seeing everyone improve
Both are so amazing! 👍
I love how the animators made whole new parts while being able the maintain their style from the og. That’s talent
I'm stunned at the difference! Good job to everyone who made this!
I love this !! Super cute
It’s sad to see some people quit and couldn’t make a new part for it but overall amazing!
CINDERPELT AND MOUSEFUR DUDE I LOVE IT
I thought this was sandstorm????
@@ghoulsdean8590 it is- i mean the background voices and stuff
@@KallMeToby oh
No- i love how they r singing in the back ik abt this
I love all of them, but urs and Cherrypics are the exceptional in my opinion!
The art improvement is 🤌🏽✨ chefs kiss
Dude! I LOVETHIS! ITS AWESOME ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Hey... how did these people get so much better at art in such a short time?
What is this sorcery of beautiful improvement that has been bestowed upon me?
so much improvement 🥰
AHHH I LOVE THIS SM
THE EYE CLOSE TRANSITION WAS SO EPIC WHAT
The hunter behind the bush has to be confused ahh 💀
2:16 I love that in the new one, CInderpelt and Mousefur r just sitting there, and then a car comes along......
I love this video so much I think both of them are pretty good❤❤
Lots of improvement, and some /really/ impressive improvement for some. All people did a really good job, and improved a lot in 2 years!
THE IMPROVEMENT IS AMAZING
I was just watching this over and over 2 weeks ago! I can't believe u got them all together to remake it 2 weeks later 😶
oh my goodness there is so much in thereand i can see how they have put ever piece of sweat and time into this!❤❤❤
Woah, this is amazing! Comparing it to the old one, I can definitely see how much the artists skills have improved! The only part of the old one I miss is: 0:47 - 0:57. But besides from that, this is amazing!
loved how the artists have developed with their art
This is so cute! I remember watching the original when it came out. Everyone did a great job
Omg, fr the best 2 and a half minutes of my life.
Hello, I'm here to do something a little... Different? I'll mark each part of the map and I'll give my opinion on it, if I think the new version is better than the old version, let's get started.
(my opinion)
Old better for me:💚
New better for me:💙
Both are perfect (indecision?):❤️
No changes:🖤
( *ALERT: BIG TEXT!!!* )
*Intro /* 0:00 (💚)I really like the old intro better, I like the way FireHeart and SandStorm move, but the new version is also great especially the expressions.
*Part 1* / 0:06 (💙)In the old version, the characters moved a little slowly and it made everything a little strange, In the new version all the composition of movements has improved and everything seems to flow better.
*Part 2* / 0:15 (❤️) I love how fast the characters move in the old version, even if the movements are kind of exaggerated. In the new version, the art style has changed a lot, the hairs and lines make everything beautiful and the movement is excellent.
*Part 3* / 0:25 (💙) The best thing about the old version is the movement when speaking, but otherwise everything is quite simple, in the new version both the stroke, the movement and the light have improved a lot.
*Part 4* / 0:35 (❤️) The improvement in the stroke and movement of the animation is very good, the new version is almost the same as the first one, but prettier, in my opinion.
*Part 5* / 0:47 (💚) The new version is more fluid than the first one and that gives it a really nice charm, but I prefer the old version, especially the "make It stop, am i real or just a prop?" part, because of the drawing xp
*Part 6* / 0:57 (🖤) (No changes) But I love the half-square ArtStyle and the colors used, it's really pretty, and also the movement.
*Part 7* / 1:07 (🖤) (No changes).I really like the movement and the extremely high number of frames per second, it must have taken a long time to do and the result was really good.
*Part 8* / 1:17 (💚) In the old version the drawing style was very disproportionate, the muzzle of SandStorm and FireHeart was very strange, Already in the new version everything is more proportional, I prefer the movement of the first version, but I have to say that the second one is more... Visually pleasing.
*Part 9* / 1:27 (💙) The most notable evolution from the old version to the new one is the ArtStyle, how much the creator has improved in 2 years is surprising, the second version is undoubtedly prettier than the first.
*Part 10* / 1:36 (💚) I like the ambiance of the old version, how the green tones of the forest meet the colors of the cats and it makes everything more, Wow, And the style of the cute Chibi characters is beautiful,And in the new version the movement is more fluid.
*Part 11* / 1:42 (💙) The old version is beautiful, the movement and camera switching is very good and the expression on the faces of both characters was very well drawn and expressed. Buuuuuuuuut,The new version's scenery has more light and depth, and the movement and expression of FireHeart and SandStorm is better than before, and quite funny too.
*Part 12* / 1:50 (❤️) I for some reason would like to say that the old version was better, but I would be lying.The movement in the new version is much better and everything feels faster and more fluid.
*Part 13* / 2:00 (💙) The biggest problem with the first version is the movement, it's good but it's a bit, stuck, locked, broken?( Sorry, I'm from another country, I don't know if the translation of this word is right. DX ). The slightest amount of movement made everything more still and at the same time more pleasant.
*Part 14* / 2:09 (💚) I know the new version is better crafted, with memes in the background, plaques naming cats I didn't even know existed lol, and lots of details but... I can't think of the new version is better, for me the simplicity of it all makes the old version more beautiful.
*Part 15* / 2:18 (🖤) (No chenges) Look at the expression of the characters, how beautiful, it is a genuine expression of love very well drawn, and the whole body of the cats is very beautiful and proportionate, Not to mention the background that puts the final touch on this art show.
I hope you enjoyed it, if you disagree with anything I said, just let me know, I'd love to hear your opinion.
All the new parts are excellent, great job to the animators, it's really nice to see your evolution, I hope I didn't upset anyone with that comment, and if I did, I'm só sorry, that wasn't my intention.
(Sorry for the giant texts)
Bye Bye💖
This shows us how much an art style can change in 2 years.
Bro this is the true birthday gift posted on my birthday great job everyone
I like seeing the improvement of the animation and/or style this isnt meant to be rude but its cool how some got a different style or better animation
The fact that cinderpelt and mousefur are backup singers is funny. The fact that cinderpelt gets run over is gold
it looks amazing!!!!
I'M IN LOVE WITH THIS
i LOVED 1:50 new and old, i see so much improvement since 2021 :o although this ENTIRE thing is really good!! all these artist are great!
I love how mousefur and cinderpelt are doing background vocals in the new one lol
2:16 I LOVE THE PART YOU ADDED LMAO
omg i love CherryPicse’s art style and they animated this part so well! 1:50
LOVE this
2:12 I think the arrows to specify which cats cinderpelt and mouse fur are is so funny lmao.
this song brings back so much memories
My eyes trying to see these both: 👀⬅➡⬅➡⬅⬅⬅⬅⬅⬅➡
I love them both there so good!!😊😊
OMG IT'S DEAD LARUS I LOVE THE PART YOU MADE❤❤❤❤
i remember watching the old one! I loved it so much, lol.
Love it!!!
1:53 this part is my fav ngl
1:19 SANDSTORM IS SO CHUBBY 😭😭😭😭😭😭
IM LOOPING THIS LMFAO I LOVE IT
Firestar just playing that trumpet while sandstorm is having a breakdown
2:13 i literally died when i saw fireheart playing the trumpet in the background
I’m dead.. THAT MOMENT WITH CINDERPELT AND (BIKE?) KILLED ME HAHAHAH
I like a few parts of the OG more, mainly the little flower scene. I think that’s adorable. But it’s amazing to see how much talent these artists have. They’ve clearly grown so well and both versions are awesome. I don’t know why some people are hating on the new version. It’s different because they’ve grown and learned. Art styles change, new techniques are learned, and while it is always good to look at your past work with pride because it’s your best work of the time, it’s also super important to appreciate how far you’ve come.
I’m a digital artist and while I love the artwork I made a few years ago and I do sell it on my website with pride, I still love seeing how much I’ve improved. It makes me proud and feel accomplished. Like my hard work was worth it. Like learning all of those techniques and shortcuts and skills was worth it. I’m proud of the steadier hand I’ve gotten, and seeing that I successfully learned how to make colors more appealing together, and doing better with shading to show light angles, and remaking my old art to fix the things I missed back then, and putting my new art style into those older works to make something new. I love seeing it all.
And it would really hurt to see or hear people saying that my old work is better. Because that takes away some of the pride you have in your current work and how far you’ve come. It’s like “oh…I guess it’s not as good as I thought…I was so sure I did better. I put in so much time and work to do better. How does it sound like I went backwards?“ That’s really sucky to think.
Both versions are amazing. They *are* different. But the reason they’re different is because artists change over time as they learn and experiment and go through trial and error with every art project they do. And we should celebrate that because releasing this is them saying “look at this. I’m so proud of the work we made together. I’m so proud that we were able to take something we’ve already done amazingly and make it newer and different and add more detail, movement, and depth. Isn’t this so cool?” The answer is yes! It is extremely cool to see! That’s what we should be telling them!
🩵 From one artist to several others: I’m so sorry to those of you who were told anything negative. You all did amazing in both versions of the video. Don’t let the haters get you down. It’s clear that you’ve grown, changed your art styles a bit, learned from the past couple years, and are proud of where you’re at now. As you should be. Keep up the amazing work and I can’t wait to see what you all create next 🩵
Omg Cinderpelt at 2:16 in the new one is hilarious, I'm dead 💀