It really depends whose voice would fit in the song the best and which part you get like minnies lion lines she got the least amount of lines but her part is one of the more memorable
Low key disappointed you didn't give Miyeon any of Sana's lines: their voice styles are so similar! But either way I still respect your opinion on this 'what if' :D
And most idle songs don't really have ad libs or high notes, and probably they would give Minnie the ad libs based on 2019 management (which I think was pretty unfair to Miyeon)
Ugh finally a song where our MAIN VOCALIST MIYEON gets the MOST LINES thank you so so much how can a main vocalist usually get the least lines in a song?! At least Fancy did her justice!
well technically main vocalist isn't about getting the most lines. If you're a main vocalist it just means you have stronger vocals and can probably hit a higher range. It doesn't mean you'll get the most lines because your voice can't always fit every part of the song. Especially in a group with such different vocal color, there's gonna be parts where other members' voices fit better than even the main vocalist. But it's still a little sad seeing a main vocalist get last
This is my opinion in their deserving line MiyeonJihyo/Jeongyeon Minnie-Nayeon/Mina Yuqi-Chaeyoung/Tzuyu Soojin-Sana Soyeon-Dahyun Shuhua-Momo This is only my opinion and you can comment yours...
Realistically Soyeon would get the entire rap part as she doesn't usually share except in Hann where Yuqi gets a low singing part in between. And Soojin getting the rap, plus verse 2, plus prechorus 2 is too much.. Besides that good job and overall fair! :)
Luna_K Lion showed smth else,and her korean is actually really good my friend who is korean american told me that his mom says that Shuhua is actually great at speaking korean
I stan Loona i didn’t say that she’s not good at Korean, I just said that she is (or WAS) not that comfortable with many lines. And yes I loooved Lion era
I think Mina and momo’s part in the beginning would be Soojin as Mina more then soojin as Momo (based on their usual distribution) and Shuhua might only have Momo’s part for the whole song.... but I think making such a fair distribution is damn good. Good job
nope nope nope nope NOPE. Sorry if I come off as rude but I'm Miyeon biased and I'm so SICK of Cube not treating Miyeon like the main vocal she is. She was the original main vocal (Minnie got promoted in due course of their success) and even they know she's the best vocalist in the group. YET SHE NEVER GETS A HIGH NOTE. SHE'S ALWAYS IN THE *BOTTOM 2* OF ALL OF THEIR DISTRIBUTIONS I MEAN ARE YOU KIDDING ME? Sorry for my rant I'll go now have a nice day!
@@hiraimomosslave9251 Shuhua has a cute voice when she speak because she rise her voice and scream a lot lol but when she sings she has a low voice. Soojin has the cutest and softest voice between Gidle members.
Well, i think it doesn't suit their voices and vocal ranges, but it's an okay line distribution. Tho Soyeon would've gotten more lines, probably the whole rap line.
@Fake Jisooo I agree with you, people always like to complain but they didnt try to appreciate, Also i can say that your words that you used "Worst"? Really? I think you're the one who is being salty here. You really need to make your own if you know what is the "BEST" line distribution of this.
Fake Jisooo Ohh so I have to add "You can give some parts to the other members" to make it as a critics comment? It doesn't have always to be like that you know. Well that's my comment is about, having only 2 member to sing for that long and that much part is ridiculous. Who's offended? Me? Lol i literally calm asf.
Fact: *when 'how would' line distribution videos are more fair then the actual line distribution*
It really depends whose voice would fit in the song the best and which part you get like minnies lion lines she got the least amount of lines but her part is one of the more memorable
Actually it was miyeon sorry
Innit
bc there are a lot of english line for Shuhua so it's fair
If not i cant imagine how unfair it is
PERIOD
Who else noticed that the results are in the order of age
Soyeon is older than Soojin though
@@GoinSolo nope Soyeon is younger than Soojin
@@Nick-ue1kg oh wait nvm
Me...
I cant imagine Soyeon singing as Sana
I mean look at their Fake Love cover
@@rajupersaud6298 okay now I see
I can
@@someignorem3146 no one asked you
@@detergenthwachae You don't need to be rude
Low key disappointed you didn't give Miyeon any of Sana's lines: their voice styles are so similar! But either way I still respect your opinion on this 'what if' :D
Yass
They are best friends too 😉
This was frustrating to watch Miyeon not get any lines except in the chorus and Adlibs but that’s how she gets treated in their own title tracks :((
And most idle songs don't really have ad libs or high notes, and probably they would give Minnie the ad libs based on 2019 management (which I think was pretty unfair to Miyeon)
Yeah she’s one of my biases and usually she just gets the chorus or prechorus
Ugh finally a song where our MAIN VOCALIST MIYEON gets the MOST LINES thank you so so much how can a main vocalist usually get the least lines in a song?! At least Fancy did her justice!
So true
just-another gg-trash Minnie is also main vocalist and don’t tell me I’m wrong because I’m right
@@rawtoast9026 she didn't say Minnie isn't a main vocalist though.
well technically main vocalist isn't about getting the most lines. If you're a main vocalist it just means you have stronger vocals and can probably hit a higher range. It doesn't mean you'll get the most lines because your voice can't always fit every part of the song. Especially in a group with such different vocal color, there's gonna be parts where other members' voices fit better than even the main vocalist. But it's still a little sad seeing a main vocalist get last
@@Yes-bl7mp agreed.
I'm happy that someone is actually giving shuhua lines in this how would videos
@Alo 12345 at least it's not a woo oh oh oh twice in a song...
It wouldve been cool if you did shuhua and tzuyu since they are both Taiwanese but anyway love the video💕💕
their voice r different lol-
This is my opinion in their deserving line
MiyeonJihyo/Jeongyeon
Minnie-Nayeon/Mina
Yuqi-Chaeyoung/Tzuyu
Soojin-Sana
Soyeon-Dahyun
Shuhua-Momo
This is only my opinion and you can comment yours...
Why is soyeon dahyun instead of cheayoung? Just a question.
Good line Distribution but yuqi should've gotten a rap part
Not really she is not a an official rapper
Mina is not a oficial rapper too but she rap sometimes so
@@imwass but here we talk about "how would" which means they will distribute the lines based on the members' positions and roles
This dislikes is from G-idle?
omg 😂
No
I really love your layout 💕💕💕
Thank youuu :>
Soojin got lines! :D
:P멜라니 she always got lines lol
@@vulpes2063 true true
You wanna mean Shuhua?
When doesn't she even get lines?! 🙄
You probably wanted to say "Miyeon got lines" or ''Shuhua"! 😏
@@sabbirshuvo4201 Miyeon gets lines
Who said for you: Soojin is the lead rapper? YUQI IS LEAD RAPPER OF G IDLE
are you serious or joking rn? i'm actually curious no harm intended
@@sleepytofuu you're talking with me?
@@cristianemelomadeira2703 uhh yeah, you know soojin is the official lead rapper right?
@@sleepytofuu yes but , que don't make rapp, and Yuqi cam
Shuhua getting repetitive lines? Well, we are used to it! 😏
- Soyeon: jigeum
haneul gureum saegeun tropical yeah jeo
taeyang ppalganbit ne du bol gatae
- Soojin: oh tell me I’m the only one
babe i fancy you, i fancy you, fancy you
- Minnie: it’s dangerous ttakkeum
hae neon jangmi gata gwaenchana
jogeumdo nan geomnaji ana
- Yuqi: deo sege kkok jaba take
my hand jom wiheomhal geoya deo
wiheomhal geoya baby
- Shuhua: dalkomhan
chokollit aiseukeurim cheoreom
nogabeorineun jigeum nae gibun
so lovely kkamkkamhan uju
sok gajang banjjagineun jeo
byeol jeo byeol geu yeope keun
ne byeol
- Miyeon: geogi neo i fancy you amuna
weonhaji ana hey i love you geurae neo
i fancy you kkumcheoreom haengbokaedo
dwae ’cause i need you (Sj: what)
- Soyeon: fancy/ Minnie: you~ ooh~
- Yuqi: nuga meonjeo joahamyeon eottae
- Soyeon: fancy/ Miyeon: you~ ooh~
- Yuqi: jigeum neoegero gallae (Sy: fancy ooh)
- Soojin: maeilmaeil nan jeongmal
amugeotto motane oh my mayday
ireoda keunil nael geot gateunde
- Soyeon: bang bang meoriga hollin
deut reseti dwae eojjeomyeon joa ige
manneungeonji molla s.o.s
- Minnie: swim swim neoran badae
jamsuhami dwae maeiri birthday
dalkomhae neowa naye fantasy
- Yuqi: dream dream machi kkumgata bol
kkojibeobwa yojeum naye sangtae mesejin
lallalla baby
- Shuhua: dalkomhan
chokollit aiseukeurim cheoreom
nogabeorineun jigeum nae gibun
so lovely kkamkkamhan uju
sok gajang banjjagineun jeo
byeol jeo byeol geu yeope keun
ne byeol
- Miyeon: geogi neo i fancy you amuna
weonhaji ana hey i love you geurae neo
i fancy you kkumcheoreom haengbokaedo
dwae ’cause i need you (Sj: what)
- Soyeon: fancy/ Minnie: you~ ooh~
- Yuqi: nuga meonjeo joahamyeon eottae
- Soyeon: fancy/ Miyeon: you~ ooh~
- Yuqi: jigeum neoegero gallae (Sy: fancy ooh)
- Soojin: yeongicheoreom
huk sarajilkka neul gadeuki
dama neol du nune dama
- Miyeon: saenggang
maneuro pogeunhaejeo
- Minnie: mollae dwieseo
ana neol nochi aneullae~
(Mn: fancy~ oh woah)
- Miyeon: geogi neo i fancy you amuna
weonhaji ana hey i love you geurae neo
i fancy you kkumcheoreom haengbokaedo
dwae ’cause i need you (Sj: what)
- Soyeon: fancy/ Minnie: you~ ooh~
- Yuqi: nuga meonjeo joahamyeon eottae
- Soyeon: fancy/ Miyeon: you~ ooh~
- Yuqi: jigeum neoegero gallae (Sy: fancy ooh)
Ooh i like how you distributed this. Good job! I agree with you
Perfect line distribution!
Mi Opinión es
Miyeon/Jihyo, Jeongyeon
Minnie/Nayeon
Soojin/ Momo, Dahyun
Soyeon/Chaeyoung, Sana
YuQi/I don't know :c
Shuhua/Tzuyu, Mina
Imagine soojin rapping to dahyun 's linesss
I think Soyeon’s bar is to close to the color of the Backround. I would recommend making more different. I love this line distribution tho
You distribute this very equally like the lines are shared perfectly
Miyeon 1 lugar 33.5
Minnie 2 lugar 32.8
Soojin 3 lugar 32.5
Soyeon 4 lugar 31.9
Yuqi 5 lugar 29.9
Shuhua 6 lugar 29.8
I mean this is good and all but not very realistic. Soyeon wouldve gotten the entire rap, and shuhua wouldnt have that many lines.
Ya me estaba muriendo, Miyeon sin líneas al comienzo xd
Beutiful
Realistically Soyeon would get the entire rap part as she doesn't usually share except in Hann where Yuqi gets a low singing part in between. And Soojin getting the rap, plus verse 2, plus prechorus 2 is too much.. Besides that good job and overall fair! :)
shuhua singing the fancy you is really inaccurate in my opinion
How (G)I-DLE would sing Fancy
Give Shuhua 2 lines
Give Everyone decent lines
And give the main rapper,vocal parts.
I stan Loona facts only
Luna_K
I’m 706% sure that if they perform Fancy live Shuhua will only do the *~fancy youu~*
I stan Loona probably but I mean.. if she’s not comfortable with many lines
Luna_K
Lion showed smth else,and her korean is actually really good my friend who is korean american told me that his mom says that Shuhua is actually great at speaking korean
I stan Loona i didn’t say that she’s not good at Korean, I just said that she is (or WAS) not that comfortable with many lines. And yes I loooved Lion era
Fancy you feel especial
Lovw
The rap part would just be Soyeon
I think Mina and momo’s part in the beginning would be Soojin as Mina more then soojin as Momo (based on their usual distribution) and Shuhua might only have Momo’s part for the whole song.... but I think making such a fair distribution is damn good. Good job
I think you should have given the high note of jihyo to minnie
nope nope nope nope NOPE. Sorry if I come off as rude but I'm Miyeon biased and I'm so SICK of Cube not treating Miyeon like the main vocal she is. She was the original main vocal (Minnie got promoted in due course of their success) and even they know she's the best vocalist in the group. YET SHE NEVER GETS A HIGH NOTE. SHE'S ALWAYS IN THE *BOTTOM 2* OF ALL OF THEIR DISTRIBUTIONS I MEAN ARE YOU KIDDING ME? Sorry for my rant I'll go now have a nice day!
just-another gg-trash she/he said “i think”
yuqi had to sing the part of mina or dahyun
What you use to make your line distribution, and What app you use?
Sorry If I am boring and sorry for bad English
I’m using Kinemaster on my Laptop :)
@@BUNN1X_Official Thanks 💕
@@BUNN1X_Official How?
Momo should've been Shuhua and sana should've been soojin nonetheless pretty okay
Shuhua no is rap
I would give 1 of jeongyeon’s/Mina’s rap to yuqi since they both have deep voices like her and yuqi can rap
Soojin and momo😍
This line distribution is more fairer than twice g idle and blackpink lol
Why does every channel have to make shu Hwa cry less? I don't understand, what are you doing?
minnie - nayeon
miyeon - jihyo
yuqi - jeongyeon
shuhua - tzuyu sana
soyeon - chea dahyun
soojin - momo mina
How do you make this line distribution ?
*finally shuhua got justice*
Which program do you use?
Soyeon as Sana seems... off
Probably because Soojin has the cutest/softest voice in Gidle
@@SicaRun noo Soojin has a sassy voice, Shuhua has the cutest voice
Remember when Soyeon *sing*, she have a voice a little similar like sana
@@hiraimomosslave9251 Shuhua has a cute voice when she speak because she rise her voice and scream a lot lol but when she sings she has a low voice. Soojin has the cutest and softest voice between Gidle members.
G-ifle
Miyeon wouldn't have alot of lines.
Well, i think it doesn't suit their voices and vocal ranges, but it's an okay line distribution. Tho Soyeon would've gotten more lines, probably the whole rap line.
Perfect but I think soojin wouldn't get that much lines:(
Îs good but minnie's voice suits more with jihyo
but minnie voice suit nayeon voice and nayeon voice don't really suit with miyeon
1:36 - 2:11 Only Soyeon and Soojin? This is the worst line distribution i've ever seen.
Fake Jisooo Well even though I know it doesn't mean i should 😌 Why so salty about it? 😶
@Fake Jisooo I agree with you, people always like to complain but they didnt try to appreciate, Also i can say that your words that you used "Worst"? Really? I think you're the one who is being salty here. You really need to make your own if you know what is the "BEST" line distribution of this.
Fake Jisooo Nope it's not a complaining. And like i said, i know but it doesn't mean I should just saying.
Please tell me why you hate lisa Read my first reply! Ok thanks bye.
Fake Jisooo Ohh so I have to add "You can give some parts to the other members" to make it as a critics comment? It doesn't have always to be like that you know. Well that's my comment is about, having only 2 member to sing for that long and that much part is ridiculous. Who's offended? Me? Lol i literally calm asf.
good but not accurate
Cái qq j z??