'You Wouldn't Let Your Neighbor Weigh In On Your Family Budget': Avi McCullah Rips Noncitizen Voting
Вставка
- Опубліковано 15 вер 2024
- At an Americans for Citizen Voting press briefing, ACV President Avi McCullah slammed noncitizen voting.
Fuel your success with Forbes. Gain unlimited access to premium journalism, including breaking news, groundbreaking in-depth reported stories, daily digests and more. Plus, members get a front-row seat at members-only events with leading thinkers and doers, access to premium video that can help you get ahead, an ad-light experience, early access to select products including NFT drops and more:
account.forbes...
Stay Connected
Forbes on Facebook: forbes
Forbes Video on Twitter: / forbes
Forbes Video on Instagram: / forbes
More From Forbes: forbes.com
No reading from a cue, script or notes, that was a TRUE and GENUINE message.
So meaningful and well spoken. Voting in America is a right for it’s legal citizens
weird then that the Constitution doesn't grant us any such right.
@@lordmeandor2328 Weird that the Constitution doesn't grant ANY rights. The Constitution PROTECTS rights.
@@randallsimmons391 That's an interesting way to dance around it. In real terms, it absolutely does grant rights.
But by your logic, it doesn't really protect the right to vote for all citizens either. It just says that the states can't discriminate against people for certain reasons. It doesn't require that the states allow us to vote at all.
@@lordmeandor2328 Show me a right that the Constitution grants. There is not one. The presumption when drafting the Constitution was that these rights already exist and certain ones need protection from an ever present, authoritarian government.
You are right in that the Constitution does not protect the right to vote per se, but it does protect aspects of the existing right to vote. But these are for citizens, as the founding fathers envisioned. It does, however, dictate that each State mandates how voting is to be conducted.
@@randallsimmons391 you're operating from a basis of text, and not how things operate in reality. While you may like to pretend that the Constitution doesn't grant rights, in real terms it absolutely does.
The Constitution is what makes these rights enforceable and REAL. Without the framework it creates, no such rights would actually exist.
I came to the U.S. legally, pursued my education, earned a PhD, and followed the process to apply for a green card and eventually citizenship. Now, as a proud U.S. citizen, I cannot support policies that aim to undermine our country by keeping the Southern border open. Illegal immigration has become an issue, and yet some Democrats want to eliminate voter ID requirements, potentially allowing non-citizens to vote in our elections. It took me 10 years to become a citizen by following the proper legal steps, and I believe in respecting the law.
The issue is that the law on the border is being followed. So not sure what your issue is. Dems and some repubs attempted to change the law, but Trump blocked it so he could campaign on the issue. And some people believe in one of our founding principles of no taxation without representation. So non citizens sous be able to vote in state and local elections
Followed the process? What process? Marriage green card? That’s not a process. That’s cheating.
She’s eloquent and right on point. As Dinesh De Souza pointed out, it takes a foreigner to show Americans born in this country what we stand to lose by not recognizing the greatness of the freedoms we take for granted.
Well Said.... Thank You,, Hopefully This Statement Will Open Some Eyes And Minds.....
You are free unless you want to come here. Then you are not free. Contradiction?
God Bless you young lady, you did it the right way..🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
Thank you for your kind words!
@@yourfriendaviAvi. Illegal immigrants pay property and sales taxes in every state. They should be able to vote. Not that they are even interested in voting. My Brazilian mother has no interest in voting. But if they are getting money taken from them by the system, then they should have a say in what that money is used for.
That was incredible and completely from the heart . ❤️ 🇺🇸 GOD BLESS THE USA 🇺🇸
I am moved by your story and compassion for our country. You are so articulate and well-spoken. I see a future US Congresswoman in the making.
That is very kind. While there are issues I am passionate about, I know that can make a difference as an average person. I truly have no interest in being involved in politics beyond exercising my right to vote as an American Citizen!
@@yourfriendaviPlease reconsider. We desperately need politicians who actually love this country, have a moral backbone and possess the courage to do the right thing. I don't care what party you join, just run for office!
Thank you for sharing your journey to citizenship and all that it means to have chosen the United States to call home!
Wow, she makes you really Realize what we have here. I mean I'm ALWAYS America First--Love it or Leave it----But when someone new talks about just HOW SPECIAL it is and how they RESPECT this Country, It still gives me chills and a feeling of pride. Thank you Avi and your mom for Respecting this country enough TO Come in the Right and Legal Way!! Welcome to Our Family!! Yes, ONLY CITIZENS VOTE!!!
You got that right, Stop the great American swindle
Thank you for trying to do it right from the beginning.
Im a legal permanent resident and believe only citizens should vote. I would never approve of my wife and neighbor determining how my house is run while i just sit there...
Thing is permanent residents don't just "sit there". They pay taxes and contribute to society. Why shouldn't they get a say in how their taxes are spent? Our country was founded on the very issue of taxation without representation, so I don't really understand why so many are against them voting. They are the modern example of that very issue (along with American citizens who live in American territories, who somehow have less federal rights than Americans living abroad in other countries).
@lordmeandor2328 I agree, I pay my taxes and do everything by the books. I however can decide tomorrow to go back to my country and leave. If I decide to vote for people who don't have the USAs best interests then leave, it will be the citizens who have to deal with the repercussions. I believe in citizens only vote as they have a greater vested interest in the country and it's success and prosperity.
@@Truetoself3838 that situation is no different than an American citizen who chooses to go elsewhere after voting. Your scenario is a distinction without a difference.
People who choose to set up residency here are MORE law abiding than native born citizens. I'd wager they have more vested interest than native born citizens by virtue of the fact that they consciously chose to come here and had to jump through many hoops. It means more to them, so your hypothetical scenario really carries very little weight.
And if your neighbor was paying a portion of your mortgage? Would they get a say then?
@@michaeltillotson3711No
Since when do employees tell the employer who pays for their lifestyles that criminals are coming to the next board meeting to vote on policies?
Since Biden took office
🎯 100%.
What a wonderful life story.
Thank you. I feel truly blessed 🥹
@@yourfriendavi when you choked up. I also had that feeling and still do when I enlisted in the Air Force. Serving was the greatest experience.
About 40 years ago a coworker of mine commented on the dumbing down of America, that the more education you acquired here the dumber you got. Here we are, 40 years later, and I am constantly reminded of his prophetic words, especially when I listen to college students' beliefs/opinions. We are becoming a nation of morons! How can any native born American not thank the Creator for being born in this country of opportunity?
AMEN!
Amen
probably because they don't see it as a country of opportunity. And there is more and more evidence of this. The United States scores lowest among advanced economies when it comes to social and economic mobility - so this isn't really the country of opportunity it used to be. And to be frank, even when it was, it still wasn't that way for all.
We need more people like her.
The Democratic Party nominee for President cannot speak half as well as this lady can.
Amen and Thank You!!
So proud to have her as one of our citizens!
As 1st Gen American I truly understand what she is saying. Both of my parents immigrated here and both became American Citizens. Voting in American Elections is a Right afforded ONLY to American Citizens.
I learned what you learned to become an American citizen in public school civics class and government class. I learned how great America is. The schools do not teach this anymore. This is why we have so much hate and discontent now.
or, maybe people felt it wasn't the school's job to propagandize young minds into mindless adoration of the country. That flag doesn't represent the same thing to everyone, and there are very real terrible things that have been condoned by the government to its own people. They don't teach how 'great America is' because it was a fairy tale that was never real.
As a natural born American let me say, We the people, love you Avi and your parents, and are so very glad you are now our American sister. We will always be proud of you, your accomplishments, and your very American spirit! Welcome home Avi McCullah!
Thank you! I’m actually married now and working on the process to change my name to Fortenberry 😁
Great speech and she makes so many points that need to ring clear to Americans…
Beautiful words from a beautiful lady!
‘We came legally’. There it is. Simple. The end. ❤
They no longer teach what it means to be a citizen. Basic civics classes are overrun with ideology instead of how the government works. Citizen responsibility is an unknown factor. So sad.
Welcome To America 🇺🇸 And For Doing It The Right Way.. And Thank You For Your Deep Understanding That True Americans Feel As You Do....
How can this only have 200 likes out of 4000 views! Seriously 😳
I’m sure all the other “likes” are on the original full length video 😉
I have been liking footage for Trump for hours today and have noticed it doesn’t change nor the amount of views on a lot as well. Most likely some control from people voting for Kamala.
Because someone not understanding the constitution who is part of a group that some Republicans are calling for losing their right to vote isn't worth liking?
This woman is an angel. 😇 brilliant and beautiful. Whoever the guy is to call her his home is one lucky fella. She understands and values our country better than the ungrateful ppl who were born here and profess their hatred for 🇺🇸 ( I swear Latina women are the most beautiful women on the planet)
You are so kind, thank you! I recently married my soulmate, and we were also long distance for several years just like my parents! 😁
She is spot on! Thanks for your strength and courage!
***Love this lady, thank you Avi****
Non citizen voting! I wonder which Political Party supports such a thing?
Democrats
Thing is permanent residents pay taxes and contribute to society. Why shouldn't they get a say in how their taxes are spent? Our country was founded on the very issue of taxation without representation, so I don't really understand why so many are against them voting. They are the modern example of that very issue (along with American citizens who live in American territories, who somehow have less federal rights than Americans living abroad in other countries).
Open border for votes. 💨💩
@@lordmeandor2328 You must be a U.S. citizen in order to vote. If you are in the country illegally, you should be deported-period. There is nowhere on earth where noncitizens are allowed to vote. Would you give a neighbor's child or a foster child the same rights as your own children? The answer is no, because they are not part of your family. Only if you adopt them would they be granted the same rights. Let’s be honest: Would you distribute your wealth equally between your children and your neighbor's children just because they mow your lawn or clean your sidewalk? Again, the answer is no. Why? Because they are not part of your family-period.
@@michaelscience2481 nobody is talking about illegals, mike. I clearly said permanent residents. Reading comprehension much?
"There is nowhere on earth where noncitizens are allowed to vote."
Of course, this is not true. It is not common, but there absolutely are countries where non-citizen residents can vote - New Zealand, Chile, and Uruguay are just a few examples.
"Would you give a neighbor's child or a foster child the same rights as your own children? The answer is no, because they are not part of your family."
Poor analogy. But yes, I would. If they were living in my home and behaving, why the hell wouldn't I? Don't ask a question you don't know the answer to mike, you might just prove yourself wrong with the premise of the question. Not everyone thinks the same way you do.
"Let’s be honest: Would you distribute your wealth equally between your children and your neighbor's children just because they mow your lawn or clean your sidewalk? Again, the answer is no."
Again, you are well versed in the art of poor analogies. Someone working on my lawn is paying taxes and earning their living, and deserving of all that entails. A family is not a society - you seem to think it's a pertinent analogy. It isn't.
She transcended from becoming a U.S. citizen… to becoming a ‘True American’. 🇺🇸👍🏻
Becoming a citizen in any country is difficult. It's designed to keep evil people out. I love this woman's attitude.
Let's vote for HER for president! She's articulate and doesn't need a script. And the best part is she doesn't CACKLE.
Promote legal citizen status in voting. Not illegal aliens. Respect the legal people of USA
I'm an American living in Brazil, and I did it the right way, I don't vote in their elections, do it the right way.
Being a citizen to vote should not be controversial.
Pow! Her explanation.. its that simple. Much respect for her journey.
Only citizens vote!
Outstanding speech, Avi.
Best thing I’ve heard in a long time.
Eloquent and accurate.
Eloquent and accurate for a Brazilian
God bless you Avi. You are exactly what it means to be an American. You, or any of us could move to Italy and never become an Italian. You can move here and become an American citizen and forever you are. We need you to teach natural born citizens what this means.
That is the American.
CNN will never show this ever
Welcome, Avi
American educational culture must change!
Make this go viral! Awesome story!
THANK YOU!
As a naturalized American citizen I feel the same way. I feel that native born American citizens take it for granted and most don't truly understand that it means to be an American citizen.
Phenomenal voice of reason!
What a powerful, thoughful message.
Amen, sister!!
My God. Let this lady run for president
My wife is from the Philippines. She has been here 8 years now and still not a citizen. Green card and working but not able to vote. It is a very long, complicated and very expensive process to be a Legal citizen here.
It is a slap in the face and a disgrace to see illegals being handed everything on a silver platter while we struggle to get her legal through the proper channels.
And those questions for citizenship - I am learning more from studying with my wife than I ever did in school. Those questions are complicated and tough for me and I went through the US schools and college.
I do believe that the citizenship process should be less expensive and time consuming. Not everyone has the ability to drive 10 hours or spend hundreds of dollars to attain citizenship, and that is certainly an issue that should be addressed as well.
@@yourfriendavi Quite the contrary is happening, it only gets harder for legal immigration. Some people wait years to get a fiance or marriage visa.
Well said and welcome to our great country! Thank you for telling your story!
It currently is citizen only voting in the US.
Every immigrant I’ve ever met supports LEGAL immigration not a criminal 💩 show at the border.
So well-said!
Common sense is sadly in short supply these days.
Good for you and your mother, and congratulations on your citizenship.
she is an american!
Amazing yes! Absolute insanity that we don’t already have this as an amendment. Maddening.
As a foreigner from a distant land I cannot comprehend how any country can contemplate voting rights for non-citizens! Crazy....
Thank you for informing my right ear.
So EXCELLENTLY presented! >> Wellness, Blessings, Much thanks.
What a magnificent patriot. God bless you.
Fabulous. She is calm, intellectual and pretty. This will resonate with other young women
You are fabulous. I am so happy you shared this valuable information.
She is so on point!
Well said. She is the American 🇺🇸 dream.
No one could ever say this better, I wish I could like this video twice
What an amazing woman and she speaks the truth!
well...that kinda made me well up...to hear a naturalized citizen speak like this doesn't surprise me at all. I take nothing for granted. I've been to other countries in the world. I know how lucky I am...
We natural born citizens should be taught in school the same "course" that immigrants are. Imagine a nation of grateful patriots.
We need voter ID! I would happily take the day off and wait in line to vote for Donald Trump! I’m an immigrant from South America who came to this country legally, how it should be.
It makes sense that any kind of apportionment counts ONLY Citizens.
Latinos voting for president Trump 2024
I bet lulac doesn't express your values.
I am a child of first generation Americans and I 100% agree!!
How is this even a question? Unbelievable that we even have to bring up the subject. Citizen only!!!
Thing is permanent residents pay taxes and contribute to society. Why shouldn't they get a say in how their taxes are spent? Our country was founded on the very issue of taxation without representation, so I don't really understand why so many are against them voting. They are the modern example of that very issue (along with American citizens who live in American territories, who somehow have less federal rights than Americans living abroad in other countries).
EXCELLENT!!! we'll said
Citizen only Voting.... I cannot believe that we have to make this argument. omggggg
My left ear really loved this story.
Wonderful speech.
A Beautifull, well spoken women...
Boy is she spot on! Civics is so important, yet most Americans have no idea who represents them in government. They are so un-educated.They have no idea what government is supposed to do (protect and serve up personal security). However when government oversteps their charter the citizens have no concept of protesting and putting government policies back in the jack-in-the-box they horribly sprang from. Worse yet they give up their freedom for the perception of false benefits. FIGHT! Let’s change Election Day to the same day taxes are due April 15. You want to know what a government program costs you; look to your taxes due.
God bless this wonderful Lady❤ and our beautiful country
Great video. My story is similar. I was born in West Germany in 1953. My father never married my mother. In 1958, my mother married an officer stationed in an American base in my birth city. He was from Puerto Rico, but still and American citizen. My mother and I received green cards. When I turned 18, I requested citizenship and it was awarded. My mother stayed with her green card until her death. Thirty years later, after my divorce from my first US citizen wife, I met a Colombian lady who had come to the US legally on a work visa. We married some time later and then went trough a grueling three year process with INS in both Philadelphia and Baltimore. The grilling and the amount of evidence and information needed was overwhelming. Finally my wife’s citizenship was approved, but she still had to study and pass an exam. Today we ask ourselves, why did we have to go through this if the US government lets anyone in with no questions asked. Why did my wife spend a year trying to get a visa to enter legally and why the three years of processing her citizenship request. Now we are also talking about giving voting rights to Illegal aliens. Yes ILLEGAL ALIENS. My wife was not an illegal alien. Is this how democrats value citizenship? This obviously shows that it no longer is about the country or any patriotic feelings. It is about a globalist agenda that restricts free speech, censures those who dissent, illegal in migration, budget deficits, endless debt, military spending, wars, out of control crime, persecution of Christian’s, killing millions of babies through abortion, using law fare to prosecute political opponents, supporting terrorists etc. Need any more reasons to throw out the democrats? I left the US nine years ago, when Obama was beginning the destruction of the country. Sorry for those that still have to live with this. The US is no longer the freest country in the world, it is no longer safe, crime in the cities is rampant (I cannot see myself to return to any of the cities where I lived before, New York, Philadelphia, Baltimore, Northern Virginia, Richmond, VA and Miami).The US everyday looks more like authoritarian regimes around the world. By the way, Canada, the UK, Ireland, Western Europe, Australia and New Zealand are not any better. I support Trump, but I do not believe that he can change the imbedded deep state globalists.
Hi Avi! I remember you as the sweet spirited watch girl! You are a warrior now! God bless you p
Thank you! God bless you, and God bless America! 🇺🇸
Right on
She used the same analogy I've been using, I'm sure I can't take credit for but it makes the most sense, America is our home, we are invested in it, as far as all these people that have recently flooded our country, I'm sure when they were back home they never would let or agree with any of us U.S. citizen to weigh in on any decision making in their country, it's really just common sense. "You wouldn't let your neighbor weigh in on your family budget, but you might invite them over for dinner" 👍🙏
It SHOULD be hard to become a citizen of the greatest country on Earth. And Voting here should only be for citizens
I am also a naturalized citizen, and I agree 100%. Only citizens should have the right to vote.
She is beautiful..
USA is lucky to have her.
She speaks 100% truth respectfully our ancestors fallwed the rule of becoming citizens it's they way it's has been well over a 150 years.
Now this Woman knows more than Kamala! I'd vote for her before I'd vote for Kamala! She's actually saying what Kamala should be saying. Too bad that the people that really should see this won't!
I'm proud to call her a fellow American. Please vote for the only president who wants to protect the border and is willing to stand in the way and take a bullet for us. The other kept it wide open.
Lack of citizenship means lack of “skin” in the national “game”.