It doesn't look like he's getting mad he's just saying all the mistakes the Animator has messed up on. your Probably mad because this youtuber is just saying the mess ups that the animator has messed up on.
Cant hold 2 at once, and even if you could, thats still way less than the 7.5 seconds it would take at double speed Edit: I timed it and it took me 12 seconds to break obisian, so 6 seconds at double speed. But it only took him about 4 seconds
Animation Sins Logic "They cannot be killed with one hit of a sword/arrow." "He got shot in the face. How is he still not dead?" And he's been using MineCraft to defend his sins.
actually, when the original video was made that was true but now you can so slightly more damage by head rather than body. it's like only half a heart more though
Honestly compared to the other animations that he sinned, and their duration. This is the best throughout all of them, it just shows how “consistent” the animation is.
“Why are zombies hiding in random files” maybe because they came out of a certain file that has a zombie spawner that the red guy might’ve spawned in and zombies roam around.
The water didn’t cause the TNT to disappear.... when TNT is in water it does not damage it’s surroundings.....he put water on the TNT as they were exploding which prevented an explosion. Sinner Sin counter: There’s a lot of them but now there’s one more.
6:55 you're complaining about things not being like minecraft, but then something that can happen in mc and not irl adds as a sin? I like this vid but that irritates me
@@SumGuyyTM depends on difficulty, they do anywhere from 1 to 5 damage (1/2 to 2 1/2 hearts) and on hard mode, they do 5 damage, I went to the wiki and checked armor, 5 damage scaled to the 20 points of armor equal 1.5 damage (1 or 2 damage based on whether you round up or down)
Yes they must be damaged 1 heart or half heart also 33 sins only because that's how minecraft do also also *laughing* make thousand sins for making those arrows not falling in the ground why try it on minecraft😂😂😂😂
1. Who cares, it’s a question either way. And 2. Nob off you sack of ungrateful shite, I was trying to help the guy answer his question, rhetorical or not.
5:54 People in Minecraft can get shot like what 3 times maybe without dying.Plus he has diamond armor on so it would take even longer to kill him with a arrow
@WONG XIAN YIK Moe the hell is wrong with ya? peeps saw this animation and came to like it, so they defend it, in the comments etcetera, wth is wrong with that??
7:42 note you could plant a tree even if there are blocks above it in an earlier version of minecraft. it was also one of the only ways to destroy bedrock without creative mode or cheats.
@@ryanm4166 bro that old alan becker animation was made in earlier minecraft versions and this guy just did a reaction when new minecraft version appeared so yes it is older but alan made it in past somewhere in older version
Everything Wrong With "Everything Wrong With Animation Vs Minecraft" 0:11 Sinning League of Legends. 3:20 Nobody said he mined the entire thing. 4:11 It's a very unimportant part of the animation, the normal viewer wouldn't have noticed. Also, that's how items are dropped on minecraft, specially with 2D item textures. 4:52 Following what you've been doing for like, half of the video, Minecraft logic, zombies did not have an attack animation by the release of this video and they still knock you back, 1.9 released a few months after. 5:51 Going by Minecraft logic, headshots don't do more damage. 5:58 You do realize that they have full diamond armor, don't you? 6:23 You didn't take off a sin for every single arrow that had to be animated. I'm sinning you for that. 7:17 He had two, on a dual wielding mod (vanilla minecraft does not allow using left click items on the second hand) that would be perfectly possible.
“The orange dude got shot straight in the face. How is he not dead?” In the actual game all arrows do the same amount of damage no matter where you get hit. Because Minecraft logic. “Also, skeleton arrows do more damage than only 2 health points.” Also, they’re wearing diamond armor.
Exactly! They probably haven’t even seen Alan Becker’s other AvA related animations, and went ahead with only watching this one. They’re soooo centered on Minecraft. I demand a refund!
ok. first u complain about "u can't kill a zombie with ONE arrow!" then u complain about "he just got shot in the face with ONE arrow. how is he not dead?!". if u can't kill a zombie with one arrow then why would u be able to kill a player with only one? chew a little on that!
Super Gamers I know that’s true, but he said he said that he made this video for fun and not to harass people. Yet you are harassing animationsins, grow up dude.
@@rookieonraceway That doesn't mean you can't criticize a video. Becker made this animation for fun, but guess what? Animation Sins still decided to give criticism. It's still fair to criticize Animation Sins.
For the “skeleton arrows do more than only two health points” that’s invalid. Everyone is wearing full diamond armor, which reduces damage taken by 80%, so as a matter of fact they should have done way LESS damage.
"That pickaxe is laying sideways on the crafting table." That's because the Orange Guy is crafting it. You expect it to be vertical on the crafting table? "How is he hanging onto the wall? His legs aren't even touching the wall, and his sword isn't hanging onto anything. Is he some sort of wizard?" He's actually hanging onto the scroll bar. Even though the bar itself is down at the bottom, he's hanging onto the part of the path where the bar can scroll up. "The orange dude just got shot straight in the face. How is he not dead?" Because in Minecraft, an arrow fired from an unenchanted bow to the head can't kill you, even if you're not wearing armor. And these guys are all wearing armor - DIAMOND armor, at that - so it makes sense how they'd still be alive. "Also, skeleton arrows do more damage than 2 health points." Again, they're all wearing *DIAMOND ARMOR*. "Even charged creepers don't have an explosion radius this big." It doesn't matter the explosion radius here; the arrows are flying through the air purely by momentum, not explosion radius. "What is this abomination." It's Herobrine. The Red Guy is clearly possessed by Herobrine. That's why he's acting so evil in the animation. That's all the little errors of some of your sins that I noticed. The other sins, though, are completely logical, and I must praise you on your great attention to detail on this animation! But even for all its faults, the animation is still a treat to watch. :)
Terrifyger I’m honestly impressed of how much thought you put into trying to diss this guy... but on the other hand, you’re probably not able to understand satire or sarcasm so forget I said anything
Also at 7:12 the sin should have been "you can't mine with two pickaxes at once" rather than the time it took, as the time actually made sense if you were able to use 2 picks at once.
@@wetube6513he's canon technically since he was mentioned so many times by mojang and notch and he's not an oc since creepypasta in Minecraft wasn't a thing back then really
Note: SC used two pickaxes to break the obsidian, halving the 9-10 seconds it takes to break obsidian with a singular pickaxe in the base game. It does take SC roughly half that time to break the obsidian, maybe a second or so off.
Why do you talk about how so many things don't happen in Minecraft that happens in the animation, yet add sin for not dying when the guy was shot in the head, even though in Minecraft you don't die when shot in the head?
0:25 How did he build in mid-air? +1 Sin 1:35 Command blocks don’t have to be seen in order to say they’re commands. 2:17 If you’ve been watching the OG Animator vs Animation series (which you probably haven’t, since you’re all about Minecraft animations), you’d obviously attribute the stickfigures to ninjas. -1 Sin. 5:35 He’s hanging on to a scroll bar element. -1 Sin. *AnimationSins Sins* You probably haven’t watched Alan’s past animations, especially the legendary Animator vs Animation series which has been a thing since 2005, more or less. +5 Sins. You’re only doing this just because Minecraft, and until now I’ve yet to see you do his other animations. +5 Sins. 0:57 At this point, Alan has only showed 3D depth, not 3D rotation. You could’ve compared it to the armor the stickfigures wore in a later scene, but damn no they didn’t. +2 Sins. Okay, now I understand why this has 11K dislikes.
@@melodywuvs_chu5565 Certainly did not, but the uploader did. My point still stands, AnimationSins is only doing this just because there’s Minecraft, and never did he bring Alan’s other works up.
What? Just by adding a diamond block it would be considered hard to animate? Ok I get it, it takes a very long time, and it does show,but that’s not a reason to say, “ Oh he shouldn’t get a sin because it took him long.” Well, he still should. A sin is a sin. Every animation has one. But I’m still a massive fan of Alan Becker. Heck, I’m even subscribed. So yeah, he works hard to make videos just for us, but that doesn’t mean that it’s all perfect. Nothing is.
@Banana Shake in later episodes SC kiIIs Green after a build disagreement. Green later respawns back into the black and white fight house, or the “Stickfight Animation” tab Alan made
3:07 Fun fact: the armour was so hard to animate that Alan had to hire people to help animate the armour and The foot clipped through the floor because the stickman's layer is above the layer that contains the blocks
Okay, I get none of you may be big builders in Minecraft, but I am, and when it comes to building in these videos, that's what I like. Cobwebs are the closest thing to smoke in Minecraft that *actually* look like smoke and you can actually control the size and shape of. There are very little blocks you can use for smoke and have it look nice and in a 2D format like this animation, Cobwebs were the only option.
You missed the fact that he mined 1 piece of wood and somehow had enough planks to make a pickaxe, when he would have 2 planks left after making sticks.
7:10 he's touching the TNT with water as it explodes, negating the block damage that the explosions would have caused. 7:44 This is actually false, you can plant large trees through blocks, although rare. They also do have the ability to replace blocks with logs, but not leaves. Also, not gonna bother finding the time stamps, but armor does visually go through blocks below the players feet, and he was hanging onto the scroll bar's column.
Well Alan has Captions in his video as a secret for true fans, so you can’t expect him to automatically know to turn captions on, so that’s still a sin.
@@ballsmcgee2599 Yes. And that doesnt change my point. With animation smoother and phyics considered, it would be much better. Imagine instead of breaking the log into planks and sticks, a thing for new crafting recipie pops up. Imagination.
@@operationdeadmemes3498 my guy zam is just bashing on stuff that'll make a video better. People mining faster is just to not bore the viewer. The log turning into planks, and that turning into sticks is just for the video to have a good entrance point.
Well that the point of the video. His whole channel is basically a joke and should not be taken seriously. And what you said to that: nah fuck that! (yes it did not say to take it seriously but use commonsense)
You should do You Belong Here! :)
Ekrcoaster your own vid?!
Ultra The Omega Hero yup. ;)
Ekrcoaster *Gasp* Woah! Unheard of! (Dis is a joke btw) Also how do you make those?
Ultra The Omega Hero Make what? :)
Ekrcoaster Well what do you make that hundreds of people enjoy? (I do too)
first animation sin: *_league of legends_*
last animation sin: *oh no*
lol
Lol
lol
Lol
Lol
This guy: Gets mad when physics don't match the game
Also this guy: Gets mad because The Second Coming wasn't one shot by an arrow to the face.
Hes not mad. But ok
Bruh don’t players in Minecraft get shot in the head and don’t die dumb dumb
It doesn't look like he's getting mad he's just saying all the mistakes the Animator has messed up on. your Probably mad because this youtuber is just saying the mess ups that the animator has messed up on.
Dude this guy is the pissed off one here
@@ramiroarroyo4549 he literally just explained how his "complaint" made no sense
“Even with a diamond pickaxe you cant mine obsidian that fast” Me: HE HAS TWO FOR A REASON
Cant hold 2 at once, and even if you could, thats still way less than the 7.5 seconds it would take at double speed
Edit: I timed it and it took me 12 seconds to break obisian, so 6 seconds at double speed. But it only took him about 4 seconds
Hold --> use
@@tthsgun thats true ;-;
@Owen and Anna is right you can't mine an obsidian with 2 diamond picks.
Look, he is a stick man
maybe he is more OP than normal players
so chill
The first sin: *League of legends*
The last sin: *League of legends*
Hmmm
Wtf are you saying to league!!!!!!!!
Lol = league of legends
Your honor,
League of Legends
*Death*
This animation was made before zombies could move their arms, wood could be turned around etc so some of these sins weren't really mistakes.
Again, this was prior to wood being able to be placed that.
Holy shit they answered
I see you on like every UA-cam channel lol
And umm when u said the arrow hit his face he didn't die because they are in Minecraft
Year
5:51 - Complaining how that didn't kill the stick figure
5:27 - "You can't kill a zombie with one arrow either."
@ROBOT TNT DESTROYER zimbie
Thanks, now i can't get that outta my head.
ROBOT TNT DESTROYER zombies and players both have 20 hp
ROBOT TNT DESTROYER that happened
cause armor
@ROBOT TNT DESTROYER it's still not deleted, also,
r/oopsdidntmeanto
8:36 , where the fun starts
T/W Creature tru
Tru
9:02 where the fun ends :c
Yes
Yeah
person: * makes an innocent animation *
Animation sins: everything about you is terrible
please stop arguing im sick of it
CONSTRUCTIVE CRITICISM
Ik
Animation: exists
AS: My disappointment is immeasurable and my entire day is ruined
While I agree that the animation was great there is nothing wrong with bringing up some mistakes as long as you do it respectfully
DO YOU MEAN ALAN BECKER!!
Animation Sins Logic
"They cannot be killed with one hit of a sword/arrow."
"He got shot in the face. How is he still not dead?"
And he's been using MineCraft to defend his sins.
@@n646n right but In minecraft, shoot Something in the head and they wont die unless it's a chicken
@@dictator_plague_doctorspid553 and not there "head" there hitbox.
@@davidkinkade3884 I know and dont care smart ass
Enchantments
@@spacex6997 it's not shining
5:54 Theres no extra damage when hitting someone in the head in minecraft
actually, when the original video was made that was true but now you can so slightly more damage by head rather than body. it's like only half a heart more though
Norville rogers Oh ok
@@cybershadoww9224 still not drastic enough for that comment to be invalid
I know right?
Because this is not Infinity War
That isn't a 3D house, it's like a background thing, like how in Terraria you can place walls
But background walls dont exist in minecraft
Yeah this is minecraft not terraria
But how would he be able to make it 3D in a 2D animation.
@@shellm80 it's called suspension of disbelief, boi
@@Cognitive_player but they exist in windows
This dude turns Alan's unique ideas into mistakes.
Ik
Ikr
I hate this channel
reverse positive mindset
@sinisterVR rush profile
‘’ The orange dude just got shot in the face. How is he not dead?”
Me: Cuz it’s Minecraft.
Yeah and critical hits does only 1 more damage
Not real life
Its minecraft
1 sin to this video
Me: Cuz hes wearing helmet...
Me: *Drinks Water*
(Saws Herobrine while he pause)
Me: *Laughs with water spilled everywhere*
*saws*
Uhhhh did you mean see/see's/seen?
Gacha JP 6:44
Thats one sin for bad grammer
SpiderGuy Another bad sin for not spelling grammar correctly.
Honestly compared to the other animations that he sinned, and their duration. This is the best throughout all of them, it just shows how “consistent” the animation is.
Animation: walks around a home
Animation Sins: Clearly all videos are 2d so you cant do that
5:37 Yes, yes he is. In fact he’s Harry Potter.
You're a wizard Harry!
Eric Zhang so true
Lol I like how he points out this is a sin when the orange is CLEARLY sitting on the file
he's also holding on to the bar, just it's very hard to see
2:55 i used to be an animator but making it a little longer will cost hour
Then random youtuber review it for get ads
Sir Ocong that English do
yeah
not really a hour like 15 minutes though
banana hero gaming especially if you watched the behind the scenes video where he took a long time to make that
“Why are zombies hiding in random files” maybe because they came out of a certain file that has a zombie spawner that the red guy might’ve spawned in and zombies roam around.
that is so right
The water didn’t cause the TNT to disappear.... when TNT is in water it does not damage it’s surroundings.....he put water on the TNT as they were exploding which prevented an explosion. Sinner Sin counter: There’s a lot of them but now there’s one more.
5:50 because Minecraft
Exactly what i thought
Omg i had that picture for my background some years ago
William Frederick iversen because minecraft logic
Its minecraft
William Frederick iversen **blame mojang**
Animation sins:
7 year olds: imma bout to end this mans whole career
Coryxkenshin reference
Kylie Healy true
I mean they're kids so they really can't do shit
@@cxarhomell5867 Language !!! Kids read the comments too
@@coderz4life You think I give a fuck about language on youtube? Exactly, I don't.
6:55 you're complaining about things not being like minecraft, but then something that can happen in mc and not irl adds as a sin? I like this vid but that irritates me
Agree
Totally
I really agree to that
Ikr
Skeleton arrows do more than two harts of damage
Me: ARE YOU STUPID they have full diamond armor
and they do 2 hearts without any armour
@@SumGuyyTM depends on difficulty, they do anywhere from 1 to 5 damage (1/2 to 2 1/2 hearts) and on hard mode, they do 5 damage, I went to the wiki and checked armor, 5 damage scaled to the 20 points of armor equal 1.5 damage (1 or 2 damage based on whether you round up or down)
@@DisKorruptd we're still write
@@SumGuyyTM right*
Yes they must be damaged 1 heart or half heart also 33 sins only because that's how minecraft do also also *laughing* make thousand sins for making those arrows not falling in the ground why try it on minecraft😂😂😂😂
6:43 "what is this abomination?"
I'll tell you thats called *FRICKIN HEROBRINE*
it sounded funny though
A human abomination
hunchbackbrine
Oh shut up
6:45 To answer your question, that is Herobrine, an old Minecraft creepypasta character.
1. Who cares, it’s a question either way.
And 2. Nob off you sack of ungrateful shite, I was trying to help the guy answer his question, rhetorical or not.
lol
Voch 123 ikr!
He was being...sar...castic...
Im done....
Lord Exetior i think that he more meant the posture, just look how he stands.....that is an abomination
5:54
People in Minecraft can get shot like what 3 times maybe without dying.Plus he has diamond armor on so it would take even longer to kill him with a arrow
dying.Plus
Exactly yo.
you accidentally made a link lol
Animation sins: Makes video on a popular animation
People who grew up watching the series:
*so you have chosen death*
Nah they just make dumb arguments
@WONG XIAN YIK Moe damn bro go get some bitches
@WONG XIAN YIK Moe no I think your talking about yourself
@WONG XIAN YIK Moe Dude calm down. It's just an opinion being expressed. It is a popular animation so people react differently. Don't be so mean.
@WONG XIAN YIK Moe the hell is wrong with ya? peeps saw this animation and came to like it, so they defend it, in the comments etcetera, wth is wrong with that??
Where are the zombies coming from??????
*sees spawner* uh... the spawner is wrong.
He never asked that. Also they came from the files.
Operation: Dead Memes Yeah, but the spawned was inside the file
Debunked.
@@cyxhe The Zombies came out of multiple files. The spawner was in one file
Operation: Dead Memes Who knows? Maybe there were more spawners in the other files.
5:53 you can get shot in the face in minecraft and not die, *health points exist*
Scrolled way too far for this. One sin says you can't kill a zombie in 1 hit. And then another says Orange should've died from a singular arrow...
_-Shadow-_ maybe read his comment a little more thoroughly. He just agreed with you and said that the creators logic made no sense
LegOWhite - Official I read it wrong, the “Scrolled way too far for this” part threw me off
He got hit in the face with a arrow multiple times
@@laura4678 and also had diamond armor on
**Animation Sins does a sin on fav video**
Me: *CARES?!?!*
Over here boy'ssssssssss
Oof
I left deviantart guy for good when he started attacking a fandom that did nothing to them or him
Ya
I know
6:58
Neither can you control cobble or change blocks without command blocks
Would it kill you to suspend your disbelief a little? The implication is that red has complete control over the blocks.
@@axis4813 lol like if anyone had a problem with that. You are taking this overly serious
@@axis4813 I agree with u
7:42 note you could plant a tree even if there are blocks above it in an earlier version of minecraft. it was also one of the only ways to destroy bedrock without creative mode or cheats.
“In an earlier version” well clearly this is older
@@ryanm4166 bro that old alan becker animation was made in earlier minecraft versions and this guy just did a reaction when new minecraft version appeared so yes it is older but alan made it in past somewhere in older version
@@VanoEditz937 oh ok thanks for clarifying
Everything Wrong With "Everything Wrong With Animation Vs Minecraft"
0:11 Sinning League of Legends.
3:20 Nobody said he mined the entire thing.
4:11 It's a very unimportant part of the animation, the normal viewer wouldn't have noticed. Also, that's how items are dropped on minecraft, specially with 2D item textures.
4:52 Following what you've been doing for like, half of the video, Minecraft logic, zombies did not have an attack animation by the release of this video and they still knock you back, 1.9 released a few months after.
5:51 Going by Minecraft logic, headshots don't do more damage.
5:58 You do realize that they have full diamond armor, don't you?
6:23 You didn't take off a sin for every single arrow that had to be animated. I'm sinning you for that.
7:17 He had two, on a dual wielding mod (vanilla minecraft does not allow using left click items on the second hand) that would be perfectly possible.
Hey Zam, do you need some ice for this burn?
Nice one dude
MrMysticHD05 lel
1+ sin for you sinning what he was sinning,also that profile pic 80+sins
good one
“The orange dude got shot straight in the face. How is he not dead?”
In the actual game all arrows do the same amount of damage no matter where you get hit. Because Minecraft logic.
“Also, skeleton arrows do more damage than only 2 health points.”
Also, they’re wearing diamond armor.
Like 4 u.
“You can’t activate pistons without a Redstone source”
He says when red/Herobrine is controlling a moving cobblestone stickman
Bfb_Pencil fucking fanboying, he fucking wasn’t using redstone while controlling it
WILLIAM WEST and? just because he is?
WILLIAM WEST its literally a joke made by the devs
【M u n G a l a x i e s】 by the way this comment thread is months old
2:27 It's not Stone, it's CobbleStone.
Still the same thing
No it's not
stone breaks slower than cobblestone
SOMEONE normal it’s the same they have the same breaking stone
**ding**
+1 sin
When you get shot in the head in minecraft with an arrow you do not die so remove one sin
KSIPGAMER ur a dumb ass this aint mindcraft its poeple with ninecraft armour
Says the guy who cant even spell Minecraft or Armor correctly -_-
Armour is spelt like that in the UK.
Yunco Heart Yet he sinned it for *not* following Minecraft's physics, then he sins it *for* doing it.
"aweee.."
one second later "oh no." 😂😂😂😂😂
Did anybody else's UA-cam stoped working when Herobrine died?
o
what do you mean Marco Ramirez
“These are 4 blocks tall”
“He would need a climb vertically”
Duh, they are animations. It’s ANIMATION vs Minecraft not MINECRAFT vs Minecraft
Calm down dude
@xdmarco65 I mean, the channel is called "animation sins" so what do you expect (sorry for my bad english)
ikrr
Exactly! They probably haven’t even seen Alan Becker’s other AvA related animations, and went ahead with only watching this one.
They’re soooo centered on Minecraft.
I demand a refund!
You are absolutely write
Animation sin sins:
"Subtitles say "this game" when voice actor says "Minecraft"
Lol
ok. first u complain about "u can't kill a zombie with ONE arrow!" then u complain about "he just got shot in the face with ONE arrow. how is he not dead?!". if u can't kill a zombie with one arrow then why would u be able to kill a player with only one? chew a little on that!
Ditlev Is stop being so butt hurt over this.
Shut it he makes mistakes so do you
Super Gamers I know that’s true, but he said he said that he made this video for fun and not to harass people. Yet you are harassing animationsins, grow up dude.
Rookie on Raceway sorry but I was talking to them
@@rookieonraceway That doesn't mean you can't criticize a video. Becker made this animation for fun, but guess what? Animation Sins still decided to give criticism. It's still fair to criticize Animation Sins.
7:17 but he's mining it with two pickaxes
Seth Gaming QUICK BREAK!!!
THAT'S WHAT I SAID ABOUT THE TWO PICKAXES XD
He was still hitting 5 times a sec (how many times a pickaxe hits a block in a second)
Christopher Nystrom have you not read my comment? Read it again so you can understand.
Ikr
For the “skeleton arrows do more than only two health points” that’s invalid. Everyone is wearing full diamond armor, which reduces damage taken by 80%, so as a matter of fact they should have done way LESS damage.
How do you know so much about Minecraft but Dont know about Herobrine Sin:1
Edits it's a joke
mmarco3256 Smh why do so much people think he doesn’t know hero brine, HE DOES,. He’s just saying how bad it looks. And I know it’s. A joke.
you got a point
R/whooooosh
Ferret45 r/facepalm
People mostly get woooshes from different platforms
Ferret45 lolololol
I get that this whole video is probably for comedy purposes but you think you'd catch on its not supposed to COMPLETELY follow the laws of minecraft.
Shadow Space yes, my exact thoughts
"That pickaxe is laying sideways on the crafting table."
That's because the Orange Guy is crafting it. You expect it to be vertical on the crafting table?
"How is he hanging onto the wall? His legs aren't even touching the wall, and his sword isn't hanging onto anything. Is he some sort of wizard?"
He's actually hanging onto the scroll bar. Even though the bar itself is down at the bottom, he's hanging onto the part of the path where the bar can scroll up.
"The orange dude just got shot straight in the face. How is he not dead?"
Because in Minecraft, an arrow fired from an unenchanted bow to the head can't kill you, even if you're not wearing armor. And these guys are all wearing armor - DIAMOND armor, at that - so it makes sense how they'd still be alive.
"Also, skeleton arrows do more damage than 2 health points."
Again, they're all wearing *DIAMOND ARMOR*.
"Even charged creepers don't have an explosion radius this big."
It doesn't matter the explosion radius here; the arrows are flying through the air purely by momentum, not explosion radius.
"What is this abomination."
It's Herobrine. The Red Guy is clearly possessed by Herobrine. That's why he's acting so evil in the animation.
That's all the little errors of some of your sins that I noticed. The other sins, though, are completely logical, and I must praise you on your great attention to detail on this animation! But even for all its faults, the animation is still a treat to watch. :)
Terrifyger I’m honestly impressed of how much thought you put into trying to diss this guy... but on the other hand, you’re probably not able to understand satire or sarcasm so forget I said anything
YEAH!
Also at 7:12 the sin should have been "you can't mine with two pickaxes at once" rather than the time it took, as the time actually made sense if you were able to use 2 picks at once.
Dragma Plays so true. Maybe we should do a Wrong Sins channel where we explain some of the wrong stuff about some of the sins.
Good idea XD.
With the Piston arm scene, extended pistons and regular unextended pistons are separate blocks, Red-Brine can change them.
"This bow made a firing sound even though there was no arrow." I always thought the "firing" sound was the twang of the string
He can do all that stuff
I’m talking about the red guy
He’s possessed by herobrine
Herobrine isn't even a real character in minecraft. Just an OC.
@@wetube6513he's canon technically since he was mentioned so many times by mojang and notch and he's not an oc since creepypasta in Minecraft wasn't a thing back then really
Congratulations you have won a one way trip to hate town!
is it a good place
I don’t know tbh ;-; it is if you want to be hated
oh i dont think he will go there
RazerPlayz you’re a hater to haters
8.2 to 8.2....
You: How is he hanging onto the wall? Me: Sigh, that’s because he is sitting on the file.
You can't even shift lol
@@flareblitz2528 don’t be rude
@@jakethompson3083you still mad he was "rude"
4:14
Fishing rod: *spins/rotates through air*
"Could've at least given them some rotation"
BOI IF YOU DONT-
If you don’t What finish your Sentence i wanna know
At least it doesnt have as many sins as other animations, Alan sure does check for mistakes.
8:29
Sentence: recycle bin
Monika(DDLC): *TRIGGERED*
Sayori: *sees Monika in the recycle bin*
Monika: Ohhh...... Heyyyy... Sayori
*Monika gets beaten*
Note: SC used two pickaxes to break the obsidian, halving the 9-10 seconds it takes to break obsidian with a singular pickaxe in the base game. It does take SC roughly half that time to break the obsidian, maybe a second or so off.
so 33.
*reads comment section*
Me: *laughing at funny comments*
Also me: *Jesus, this comment section is saltier than the dead sea*
XD Nice
Yeah, just made 17 roasts.
*- Danniematiøn -* i thought it was the red sea that was salty
ua-cam.com/channels/sM5qDa0edjsLahCqbSO34Q.html
Lmao why did you link me to my own channel
Why do you talk about how so many things don't happen in Minecraft that happens in the animation, yet add sin for not dying when the guy was shot in the head, even though in Minecraft you don't die when shot in the head?
Nightmare . io True
Yeah, it's not supposed to be fucking accurate, yet it seems he treats the animation poorly.
This guy doesn't even know anything about Minecraft
@@unaliver he does
There is no sins here
This channel is a HUGEEEEEEEE SIN!!!!
Actually there is 34 sins so... EXPLAIN THAT
Way to be fun, retro gamer.
Yea there’s one Minecraft in general
Are*
“ you can’t plant a tee if there are blocks above it” he’s says as they fight a giant obsidian mech with grappling rushing rods Minecarts and a tree
Logic:
sins vid for killing one headshot zombie
Then
Sins vid for NOT killing the chosen one one headshot
Because it makes no sense and deserves a sin.
Stop being a big baby.
@@wetube6513 minecraft logic, he is not being a baby, you are just being dumb
i think it's just a really cool animation.
0:25 How did he build in mid-air?
+1 Sin
1:35
Command blocks don’t have to be seen in order to say they’re commands.
2:17
If you’ve been watching the OG Animator vs Animation series (which you probably haven’t, since you’re all about Minecraft animations), you’d obviously attribute the stickfigures to ninjas.
-1 Sin.
5:35
He’s hanging on to a scroll bar element.
-1 Sin.
*AnimationSins Sins*
You probably haven’t watched Alan’s past animations, especially the legendary Animator vs Animation series which has been a thing since 2005, more or less.
+5 Sins.
You’re only doing this just because Minecraft, and until now I’ve yet to see you do his other animations.
+5 Sins.
0:57
At this point, Alan has only showed 3D depth, not 3D rotation. You could’ve compared it to the armor the stickfigures wore in a later scene, but damn no they didn’t.
+2 Sins.
Okay, now I understand why this has 11K dislikes.
actually, who knows, he might just be sitting on that Flash/Animate file.
Did u ppl forgot that they *stickfigures* not actual minecraft playEr
@@melodywuvs_chu5565
Certainly did not, but the uploader did. My point still stands, AnimationSins is only doing this just because there’s Minecraft, and never did he bring Alan’s other works up.
This video should ha e been called "Correcting Animation vs Minecrafts physics to actual minecraft"
Even diamond pickaxe can’t mine obsidian that fast me: he using double edit: this comment is to talk about entertainment
Derrick Yang even though the whole animation is non Modded minecraft, you can’t duel wield without mods
MemeKinglol11 Or plug-ins.
Derrick Yang even with two you can’t mine it that fast
Btw animations sometimes don’t need to make sense
Derrick Yang “sometimes”
Actually, you can plant a tree if there are blocks above it,
Although it’s only with certain trees, and idk if jungle is one of those.
This is a bug that's patched if I recall
At 2:47, the sin counter does not update.
4:27
Specialty crafted! After all, Orange made the armor, so he could have thrown in an extra diamond to make it a bit bigger. It's not impossible!
Very true
They know the recipies as they sometimes help Alan or watch him do stuff and alan does mc
Lemon SP that makes sense actually
yeah agreed
5:51-The same way minecraft players don't die after just one arrow in the face.
7:48
do you know chain reactions?
@Martin Doyle yep Shannon Mcpeak thats not da minecraft thing
2:56 It's really hard to animate you know
Correct
What?
Just by adding a diamond block it would be considered hard to animate?
Ok I get it, it takes a very long time, and it does show,but that’s not a reason to say, “ Oh he shouldn’t get a sin because it took him long.”
Well, he still should. A sin is a sin. Every animation has one. But I’m still a massive fan of Alan Becker. Heck, I’m even subscribed.
So yeah, he works hard to make videos just for us, but that doesn’t mean that it’s all perfect. Nothing is.
@@angelesgomez8495 dude he is complaining about *Length of the video*
@@angelesgomez8495 shut up
MyNameIsShurikenGD Shut up, thats his opinion
5:57 that is because wearing armour makes you take less damage.
@ROBOT TNT DESTROYER there not playing on any difficulty,its a animation.
@Banana Shake in later episodes SC kiIIs Green after a build disagreement. Green later respawns back into the black and white fight house, or the “Stickfight Animation” tab Alan made
*Sins tally: 34*
*Sentence: Recycle bin*
*Nice sentence there buddy. No period?*
Sin counter: 1
PurpleAks3l noice
There wasn't enough sins
no ones uses periods now for sentences on the internet bud
It’s not a sentence at all.
SIN COUNT: 2.
Does he even know how hard he worked for this animation? He took a year to make it. 100 Sins. *Sin counter 102*
Video sin
2:42 you add 1 to 8 but it is still 8
Total Sin Tally: 35
one sin to Animation Sins. calls Alan Becker "the animator"
i mean he's literally the Animator
[ding!]
He doesn't want to say the animators name
Yeah. Animation sins is literally INSULTING my favorite youtuber
Luckily it's only got 34 sins, but not over 100. It has almost gotten more dislikes than the likes anyway.
YOU
*you have offended my RELIGION*
(Also by the way, the League of Legends thing was on purpose)
Ik
Bug fixer: judging on a video
Animator: Puts him in jail
⬇
Alan aint an idiot, even it it's a meme, he'll accept it. He gets complains from fans and fixes so we can enjoy his animations even more.
@@radical9619 You're right.
3:07
Fun fact: the armour was so hard to animate that Alan had to hire people to help animate the armour and The foot clipped through the floor because the stickman's layer is above the layer that contains the blocks
Congrats.
Ur being hated now.
Dude.
Not by me.
I like the video.
He just do sameing-the-like-and-dislike challange #ripenglish
Ocong Kimak! 5.176likes
And 5.173dislikes .w.
Because TSC (The Second Coming) was drawn by Alan in AvA 4. The other four stick figures were from another flash animation.
6:43 that is what you call Herobrine that is tall
the problem was that he was so tall
you see
The thing you must not understand is, IT'S TO ENTERTAIN YOU NOT TO BE PERFECT AND LOGICAL
Chris Ceb Same with this video
Chris Ceb calm down
Fak u
Chris Ceb No u
4:38 this one is not an error, its the red dude that put spawns of mobs
Ikr also he said it takes 3 hits BRO HE PROBABLY JUST SWANG REALLY HARD
*When the like button has 8.k likes*
*And the dislike button has 8.4k*
Perfectly balanced as all things should be.
I have no strong feelings one way or the other
7.9 now
Now it has 8K likes and 8K dislikes....
8.1 for both now...
Now its dislikes 8.2k and likes 8.2k
you have to be a MASSIVE nerd in order to notice all these flaws. I love it.
THEREDCAP: World's Crappiest UA-camr that’s why he sounds like NerdCubed isn’t it?
You both just called him smart
No not really, you just have to be logic to see if everything in the video is logic too
CringyMinecraftGamer69 lol you just wasted all that time saying minecraft is crap when it is really the second best game in the world.
Yeah virgin alert
Cobwebs were meant to be smoke lel.
Outertale Napstablook but it was still cobweb
*But they're the closest thing to smoke in Minecraft that looks like smoke and is a block*
Outertale Napstablook they were meant to be smoke but they aren’t...
Outertale Napstablook but they're STILL cobwebs
Okay, I get none of you may be big builders in Minecraft, but I am, and when it comes to building in these videos, that's what I like. Cobwebs are the closest thing to smoke in Minecraft that *actually* look like smoke and you can actually control the size and shape of. There are very little blocks you can use for smoke and have it look nice and in a 2D format like this animation, Cobwebs were the only option.
You missed the fact that he mined 1 piece of wood and somehow had enough planks to make a pickaxe, when he would have 2 planks left after making sticks.
7:10 he's touching the TNT with water as it explodes, negating the block damage that the explosions would have caused.
7:44 This is actually false, you can plant large trees through blocks, although rare. They also do have the ability to replace blocks with logs, but not leaves.
Also, not gonna bother finding the time stamps, but armor does visually go through blocks below the players feet, and he was hanging onto the scroll bar's column.
imlegos first of all ok tnt cannot break obsidian or bedrocks second you can only plant trees on dirt and grass
ryan ranga First of all ok this is an animation, not real minecraft.
imlegos true!
imlegos also it doesn’t make the tnt go away as you said it just stops the damage
imlegos that was lapis bruh....also this dude needs to stop hating
6:10 Animation Sins, turn on captions then you’ll understand that part
Salt the Dog oh the video.
Yellow: Uh... Guys?
Kyle Lac yeah that part
Well it isn’t clear unless you put it in the actual video so that’s a sin
Well Alan has Captions in his video as a secret for true fans, so you can’t expect him to automatically know to turn captions on, so that’s still a sin.
YOU CANT DESTROY MY FAVORITE VIDEO ON UA-cam LIKE THAT!!!!! But the memes at the end where pretty decent but still
Hey, I love AVM too. But he has good points. If Alan Becker watches this, he can use it to improve if he ever wanted to reanimate the video.
Operation: Dead Memes you do realize some of the sins were just about Minecraft physics and how league of legends existed, right?
@@ballsmcgee2599 Yes. And that doesnt change my point. With animation smoother and phyics considered, it would be much better. Imagine instead of breaking the log into planks and sticks, a thing for new crafting recipie pops up. Imagination.
@@operationdeadmemes3498 my guy zam is just bashing on stuff that'll make a video better. People mining faster is just to not bore the viewer. The log turning into planks, and that turning into sticks is just for the video to have a good entrance point.
Animation sins: Everything wrong with animation vs Minecraft
Everybody:So you have chosen death
xD
I see more people complaining ABOUT people complaining than people actually complaining...
Popo the Genie ALL HAIL LORD POPO ALL HAIL LORD POPO ALL HAIL LORD POPO ALL HAIL LORD POPO ALL HAIL LORD POPO ALL HAIL LORD POPO
Popo the Genie Then you really need to go to the newest comments section.
Your complaining right now.
There stickmans not Minecrafters!
send me nakde pick snow you bich
It's Just an Animation.....
By Alan Becker....
Pls don't judge him...
Deovic Sison the fuck is a minecrafter
I know that is no minecraft rules but it is ANIMATION !!!
I'm with you
Yea
Yeah simo is right
It truth person making vidieo you are fool
I agree! 😊
Alan's new Parkour animation is a huge plot twist....
Without a REDstone source? Look st the head of the cobble structure!
I’ll see myself out
the door is that way
You miss a sin!! 2:50!When you break the "down layer" of the beacon,the beacon don't turn off because it still have a layer
Your timing is shit
Not true. If you look, you see it gets cut into like it's a cliff, ergo the block turns off after running out of power.
ItsNikolasGR Correct
Also the counter in 2:50 still didnt change
No not true if you break one layer the beacon turn off
Dude its Animation. Its up to the creator of the Animation. No Need to be same to the real game
I agrre
i do agree to an extent, he did take the video a bit too literally.
Well that the point of the video. His whole channel is basically a joke and should not be taken seriously. And what you said to that: nah fuck that! (yes it did not say to take it seriously but use commonsense)
@@Shibbie_In_U Plus criticism