@@Real-talk10167 you are partly correct, it should not be playing In girl sports,,. As far as it being a man, my 10 year old brother is more of a man then whatever that is
Keep it up girls. Fight for your rights. He is a he. Enough is . Why would you have to see it girl. Come on common sense. We should not even to be having this conversation.
I am having difficulty with understanding why a controversy even exists. Women's sports, Men's sports, so create transgender sports and make everyone happy. It should be equal in order to be a FAIR competition. Otherwise, the competition becomes a controversy, and the athletes are the one's who suffer.
Not a transgender, birth certificate is male with a male first name Brandon. Played boys volleyball in high school. Banned from a South Carolina college from playing on a women’s volleyball team. Took SJSU female roommates that exposed it was a man. Associated head coach was suspended for speaking out for her women’s players safety.
It doesn't matter if they suppress testosterone, it's still much higher than a female (same for intersex). By the way, suppressing testosterone does not negate other advantages of the male body like bone length, bone density/ strength, height, etc.
But that's if they actually supress it at all, they might do it out of season or if they think they're going to get tested. But in a world where everyone does what they can to win I think the thought that they would intentionally give up a competitive advantage is a logical fallacy.
The old coach and current coach have delusional ideas and expect the world to play along with it. Crazy. You are right -- they don’t believe it. But they love pushing their propaganda
Money. The transgender industry is predatory. It makes billions sterilizing and mutilating the most vulnerable among us by turning them into lifelong pharmaceutical patients. Look up gender industrial complex.
So testosterone is what makes me a man? My DNA has nothing to do with it? XY chromosones are there just for flash. The only reason I am a man is because I have higher levels of testosterone... Interesting way to redefine biology. If I was to take an estrogen shot tomorrow, would I then be a woman?
In women's volleyball, fairness and safety are essential. Biological differences can impact athletic performance, making competition uneven. Women should compete with those who share similar physical characteristics to ensure a level playing field. We should focus on protecting women’s opportunities, sports integrity, and safety in every game and competition. If they want to include transgender athletes in college sports, they can create their own league. This would ensure fair competition while respecting everyone’s participation rights, allowing athletes to compete on an equal playing field without impacting existing categories in collegiate sports.
Hate crime. Cause allowing a cheater to play. Is absolutely absurd. Name the coach, and every single person on that team. See how they feel about standing up for cheating when they get their faces blasted n branded as cheaters.
Thank you KPIX for showing reasonable views against this unfairness. This is unlike most other local TV news, The former Mills AD is a disgrace....testostronone is not the issue, it is chromosones.
A Bay Area news network showing the reality. This delusion maybe more publicized in coming months now that common sense people have broken the taboo of speaking out.
Good point i think there must be chatter that the team in the finals is gonna forfeit so in order to play the girls on the team are turning on cousin it.
Lowering testosterone DOES NOT create a level playing field. You can't undo what happens at male puberty. Muscle mass, bone density, aerobic output, tendon forces, femur length, etc etc etc remain basically the same. That lady that said otherwise doesn't understand the science
All sports leagues can be divided into two types, restricted and unrestricted. Examples of unrestricted leagues are the NFL, NBA, MLB and NHL. These leagues are open to all players without restriction. Then there are competition restricted leagues open only to persons who meet specific criteria. Examples of restricted leagues include paraplegic leagues, blind leagues, deaf leagues, age restricted leagues (little league and/or senior leagues), and female only leagues. Restricted leagues exist specifically to allow competitors with similar capabilities to compete against each other without being crushed by persons that have an unassailable advantage over the persons meeting the leagues defined restrictions. Sport leagues restrictions are defined by the competitors’ actual physical characteristics not by what a competitor ‘feels’ like there characteristics are. As such a persons perceived gender should not be taken into account when deciding if they are eligible to compete in a restricted league, only their actual physical attributes as they pertain to the league’s restrictions.
Where are the parents on this ridiculous issue? Your daughter comes to her mom or dad and said, “There is a boy changing in the girls only locker room” or “we must compete against a team with a boy on the other team”.
I don’t like this balanced reporting. I came here for an echo chamber. Does CBS think they are a news agency now or something. I want one side of argument that way I don’t have to think but be affirmed in my beliefs.
@@kearonagnes SJSU women should of boycotted the conference championship match and not played. That would of been a historical moment for Women’s Rights…
So the co-captain doesn't want the man to play in the championship, but didn't protest the man playing in all the games that GOT THEM TO the championship?
Does he use the same locker room and showers as his teammates or do they have to take extra precautions and be discriminated against to keep away from him?
How can “she” not have ‘come out publicly’ when he’s been known as a boy in public for his first 10-14 years of life? Do people just wonder where that young man disappeared to a few years back?
Do you recall about 10-12 years ago they shouted “your sexuality is determined at birth”? Now they are saying it’s fluid and can change at anytime. Delusional.
The focus on gender is distracting us from the core issue which is fairness in sports. Some sports have different weight classes to ensure they are matching like athletes. There's no reason why we can't do the same. If one were to look at physical ability, except for the long tails, there is significant overlap between the genders. There's no reason athletes in the overlapping region cannot compete in non-contact sports because they have the same physical abilities. Instead of arguing endlessly over gender we should have sporting experts define how athletes should be sorted into different leagues/divisions so there's fairness regardless of gender.
Focus on gender? There's no need to "focus," it's perfectly clear to most that, biologically, you are either male or female. If you decide to transition then start your own transgender league, don't try to compete in womens sports with the biological advantage of being a man.
who cares if they haven't come out as trans, all the players are adults. The dude's name is Blaire fleming. You are so quick to point out the co-captain as brooke slusser but, oh no, can't talk about the person cheating in college sports? please...
I think they shouldve just played...Its a team sport. San Joes state has losses, which show they are beatable even with a transgender male on the team.
I totally don't understand why there is a discussion about this. When I was 7, I learned there was no santa. There is also no such thing as a trans woman. I was born a girl, my baby brother a boy and that s that. By the way for those that don't know, the reason I'm here today is because my PA is a real man and MA a real woman, not imaginary. By the way my German shepherd had a real ma and pa too
@gatvestreet9248 Seriously, I can't even believe we are talking about this, I'm lucky, I live in very rural Alabama, we don't have those kinds here. All the kids in my school are normal. Have a good night
Where's Mom and Dad? Whoever lets this happen to their kids is just as guilty and should be publically shamed. "Oh... We didnt know..." Lies. Your daughters should out you and never speak to you again.
Its an interesting topic. Since there are about 500,000 female College athletes and only 50 "Trans" athletes involved in those female sports....thats 0.01% and 1/100th of 1% makes this a "non-topic" really and most assuredly not worthy of the air time it has received in the recent political season. I wish they would have interviewed more. players, fans rather than just those few. I also wish the folks naming "safety" as an issue had some stats to back up their claims. For example, i would love to see the stats about the higher vertical leap of "males" or the amount of concussions associated with that as well. Can i add that i love to read all the commenss below from the amateur Biologists and Sociologists here....fascinating.
It would be nice to know if this player in question was the real reason why the SJ team was winning? Were they the only one primarily scoring? This is a rather poor report. It’s a team sport, a little harder to gauge vs a 1 person sport like track, boxing, etc. it’s crap journalism like this is why the cult of Maga has won over so many people. It’s just hard to be well informed these days. If this person really is the factor then maybe there maybe grounds for taking another look at this. We hear a lot of transgender men, how about transgender women? Should they be allowed to compete w women and not men?
Four teams have forfeited against San Jose, refusing the play while there is a transgender human on the San Jose team. Worried you might win? The lengths some people will go to to prove their ignorance.
This is a tough one! What a stressful and distracting situation for a team. It would seem like the teammates would want any advantage that the trans person bring to their team.
Possibly the most ignorant comment or thought ever. Can you imagine all the “wrongs” with such an idea? It’s not a tough one at all. It’s quite simple. Boys are boys and girls are girls. And those that believe otherwise can do so --- BUT do not force it in kids or endanger others.
Players #3 Blair Fleming, birth name is Brandon Fleming with a doctor certified birth certificate male. He was ban from a South Carolina college from playing.
When you watch an NFL game, what is the genitalia of every player out there? This is women’s volleyball. His genitalia should be obvious based on the sport he is participating in but not the case.
This nonsensical gibberish ends on a day one of Team Trump 🇺🇸 The New Avengers....DOJ going after the criminals, Kommissar Governor Newscum, and his Sacramento Politburo..... resistance is futile
That's hilarious and the moon is made of cheese. You think the ability to get pregnant is what defines a woman? Do you have any idea how insulting that is to women?
You can support their choice but you can't ignore science. We have women's sports for a reason. This is just ridiculous.
That is a man get him off the court.
Trans stays on court. Protected by LGBTQ.
@@Real-talk10167 you are partly correct, it should not be playing In girl sports,,. As far as it being a man, my 10 year old brother is more of a man then whatever that is
Biology not feelings.
I’m gay too 🏳️🌈
I’m fat too🍗
Stop the madness
@@chuckxu5910lol
@@chuckxu5910that’s your choice. Always has been. A choice ☕️
Keep it up girls. Fight for your rights. He is a he. Enough is . Why would you have to see it girl. Come on common sense. We should not even to be having this conversation.
You tell 'em Brenda!
I am having difficulty with understanding why a controversy even exists. Women's sports, Men's sports, so create transgender sports and make everyone happy. It should be equal in order to be a FAIR competition. Otherwise, the competition becomes a controversy, and the athletes are the one's who suffer.
Just like women sports nobody will watch transgender sports then they/them will complain about not getting paid the same as both women or men
Not a transgender, birth certificate is male with a male first name Brandon. Played boys volleyball in high school. Banned from a South Carolina college from playing on a women’s volleyball team. Took SJSU female roommates that exposed it was a man. Associated head coach was suspended for speaking out for her women’s players safety.
It doesn't matter if they suppress testosterone, it's still much higher than a female (same for intersex).
By the way, suppressing testosterone does not negate other advantages of the male body like bone length, bone density/ strength, height, etc.
Strength and speed is the biggest factor here.
Parading and masquerading as something one is not is no way to go through life
@@chinatownboy7482Biology over feelings
Suppressing testosterone should be illegal anyway. You don’t help a confused person by messing up their chemistry.
But that's if they actually supress it at all, they might do it out of season or if they think they're going to get tested. But in a world where everyone does what they can to win I think the thought that they would intentionally give up a competitive advantage is a logical fallacy.
What happened to trusting the science?!? I guess science doesn’t matter when it doesn’t support your narrative!
Not "narrative" Kevin. Be specific, call it genuine term. Political propaganda.
The old coach and current coach have delusional ideas and expect the world to play along with it. Crazy. You are right -- they don’t believe it. But they love pushing their propaganda
Let's bring back common sense again!
That’s what the Trump vote was all about. The Dems still don’t understand
Bring back common sense laws
Then why was Life with Jazz on the TLC Channel?
Money. The transgender industry is predatory. It makes billions sterilizing and mutilating the most vulnerable among us by turning them into lifelong pharmaceutical patients. Look up gender industrial complex.
Did not name the trans player. Did not need to. Easily identified.
I think his name is Adams Apple! He's the son of Harry Knuckles! HA!
Who? I couldn't ID them.
I'm not a doctor...but I know what the difference from a dog and a cat!
😂
Are you sure???? Done is same tone as Marisa Tomei being questioned in My Cousin Vinny
It's in the tail right? Lol
Dogs and cats are different species on different parts of the evolutionary tree of life. Hope that helps
Support from pittsburgh
Hope the girls go further with the lawsuit
So testosterone is what makes me a man? My DNA has nothing to do with it? XY chromosones are there just for flash. The only reason I am a man is because I have higher levels of testosterone... Interesting way to redefine biology. If I was to take an estrogen shot tomorrow, would I then be a woman?
In women's volleyball, fairness and safety are essential. Biological differences can impact athletic performance, making competition uneven. Women should compete with those who share similar physical characteristics to ensure a level playing field. We should focus on protecting women’s opportunities, sports integrity, and safety in every game and competition. If they want to include transgender athletes in college sports, they can create their own league. This would ensure fair competition while respecting everyone’s participation rights, allowing athletes to compete on an equal playing field without impacting existing categories in collegiate sports.
Hate crime. Cause allowing a cheater to play. Is absolutely absurd. Name the coach, and every single person on that team. See how they feel about standing up for cheating when they get their faces blasted n branded as cheaters.
oh , so hard mate... slag off
The Left cheats like breathing
Thank you KPIX for showing reasonable views against this unfairness. This is unlike most other local TV news, The former Mills AD is a disgrace....testostronone is not the issue, it is chromosones.
💯
A Bay Area news network showing the reality. This delusion maybe more publicized in coming months now that common sense people have broken the taboo of speaking out.
When was this report filed? 5 teams have since forfeited than play a the SJSU team.
Good point i think there must be chatter that the team in the finals is gonna forfeit so in order to play the girls on the team are turning on cousin it.
Lowering testosterone DOES NOT create a level playing field. You can't undo what happens at male puberty. Muscle mass, bone density, aerobic output, tendon forces, femur length, etc etc etc remain basically the same. That lady that said otherwise doesn't understand the science
Thank goodness for Riley Gains. She has pushed back on this and helping more girls/women stand up to this nonsense.
maybe make a trans team and then they can have 3 teams ... males,females and trans
California is so broken
I don't have to go watch to know it's not fair
Hope these ladies stand tall and see this through! Why should everybody else pay a price for that guys feelings! Dang people!!
Excellent reporting. This case is one reason Trump won.
I agree that this was one of the reasons he won.
They should never have brought the T into the mix. What’s next……… a “P”. Pedophilia is normalized?
I'd love to see what all these supporters would say if the SJSU Third Baseman decided to go play on the Women's Softball team.
All sports leagues can be divided into two types, restricted and unrestricted. Examples of unrestricted leagues are the NFL, NBA, MLB and NHL. These leagues are open to all players without restriction.
Then there are competition restricted leagues open only to persons who meet specific criteria. Examples of restricted leagues include paraplegic leagues, blind leagues, deaf leagues, age restricted leagues (little league and/or senior leagues), and female only leagues.
Restricted leagues exist specifically to allow competitors with similar capabilities to compete against each other without being crushed by persons that have an unassailable advantage over the persons meeting the leagues defined restrictions. Sport leagues restrictions are defined by the competitors’ actual physical characteristics not by what a competitor ‘feels’ like there characteristics are. As such a persons perceived gender should not be taken into account when deciding if they are eligible to compete in a restricted league, only their actual physical attributes as they pertain to the league’s restrictions.
Have "HER" play in the men's leagues. Isn't it equally as fair and inclusive if the new woman plays in the male games?.
Where are the parents on this ridiculous issue? Your daughter comes to her mom or dad and said, “There is a boy changing in the girls only locker room” or “we must compete against a team with a boy on the other team”.
So there's an undercover brother out there?
add a man on the opposing team to equalize things!
That doesnt make it "right" it just makes "2 wrongs" muppet
They should show up with a whole team of men to play. Watch them holler about it.
And that would reduce another girl from playing, scholarship, and create mixed sports teams AND endanger more women on the court.
I don’t like this balanced reporting. I came here for an echo chamber. Does CBS think they are a news agency now or something. I want one side of argument that way I don’t have to think but be affirmed in my beliefs.
Good for women athletes sticking up for themselves!
@@kearonagnes SJSU women should of boycotted the conference championship match and not played. That would of been a historical moment for Women’s Rights…
This is ridiculous! Take him off the team! He can make his own intramural team if he wants to play so bad.
Of course it’s unfair!
Who said life is fair?
There is only one side to the issue. You either believe in sanity or not
Very well said.
Natural doping
Isn't it crazy they include HIS records as the best female records of all time?
So the co-captain doesn't want the man to play in the championship, but didn't protest the man playing in all the games that GOT THEM TO the championship?
The Trump effect, women can now speak out about this discrimination of women in sports !😊
Ridiculous, the Penn swimmer Lea Thomas and this issue was a national discussion before Trump. You should not rewrite history 🙄
They do know that the player has been named in the media multiple times over the past however many months now, right?
ITS MAM!
Manthing
#3 if anyone was curious... not in that way.
Save Women’s Sports!!
Spectators need to also boycott.
Amazing how now women think men and women are different. They use to say men and women are the same
Don’t give up!!!!
He calls himself "Blair Fleming."
Thanks for the name.
His birth name is Brandon Fleming and doctor certified male.
I love it when the pronouns just fit
😂 Manthing
Does he use the same locker room and showers as his teammates or do they have to take extra precautions and be discriminated against to keep away from him?
How can “she” not have ‘come out publicly’ when he’s been known as a boy in public for his first 10-14 years of life?
Do people just wonder where that young man disappeared to a few years back?
Do you recall about 10-12 years ago they shouted “your sexuality is determined at birth”? Now they are saying it’s fluid and can change at anytime. Delusional.
it's not about inclusion, but about exclusion of women. why do we have gender separated sports in the first place?
The focus on gender is distracting us from the core issue which is fairness in sports. Some sports have different weight classes to ensure they are matching like athletes. There's no reason why we can't do the same. If one were to look at physical ability, except for the long tails, there is significant overlap between the genders. There's no reason athletes in the overlapping region cannot compete in non-contact sports because they have the same physical abilities. Instead of arguing endlessly over gender we should have sporting experts define how athletes should be sorted into different leagues/divisions so there's fairness regardless of gender.
They already have done that. That's why we have women and men's sports separated.
We do do that in the beginning of a child's sports adventure. Then about JR High, that attitude takes a dramatic turn for winning at all cost.
@chlrsnj326 what's wrong with winning? And define all costs please?
Focus on gender? There's no need to "focus," it's perfectly clear to most that, biologically, you are either male or female. If you decide to transition then start your own transgender league, don't try to compete in womens sports with the biological advantage of being a man.
So the top athletes of one gender overlap with the bottom athletes athletes of the other.
All those years fighting for Title IX destroyed by one administration.
It's a shame Boise forfeited after coming back to make it to the playoffs. SJ state should have a man on the team in the first place.
that MAN has caused so much chaos
who cares if they haven't come out as trans, all the players are adults. The dude's name is Blaire fleming. You are so quick to point out the co-captain as brooke slusser but, oh no, can't talk about the person cheating in college sports? please...
I can't wait for the conservative US Supreme Court to weigh in and have the final say on this issue... And then we all can go back to reality
Good for them for being objective and seeing it for themselves to make up their own mind. Get the man of the court.
2:13 wtf is she talking about thats exactly whats happening! 🤦🏽
Blaire Fleming is the transgender player on the team, please don't censor that.
I am sure all of the 16 spectators have opinions that nobody cares about. All 16 of them.
Be who you wanna be but Born a male then yeah not fair to the women period
Let the best man win!
I think they shouldve just played...Its a team sport. San Joes state has losses, which show they are beatable even with a transgender male on the team.
So lame, to predator on ladies this way is the lowest of despicable.
I totally don't understand why there is a discussion about this. When I was 7, I learned there was no santa. There is also no such thing as a trans woman. I was born a girl, my baby brother a boy and that s that. By the way for those that don't know, the reason I'm here today is because my PA is a real man and MA a real woman, not imaginary. By the way my German shepherd had a real ma and pa too
That was a great addition about the German shepherd. I think even a large % of the gay community thinks the T addition was a huge mistake.
@gatvestreet9248 Seriously, I can't even believe we are talking about this, I'm lucky, I live in very rural Alabama, we don't have those kinds here. All the kids in my school are normal. Have a good night
Where's Mom and Dad?
Whoever lets this happen to their kids is just as guilty and should be publically shamed.
"Oh... We didnt know..."
Lies.
Your daughters should out you and never speak to you again.
#2 because a man in the team.
Go #10!
They won't name the player due to safety and privacy concerns? It's public knowledge. Blaire Fleming is his name and can be found on the SJSU roster.
Its an interesting topic. Since there are about 500,000 female College athletes and only 50 "Trans" athletes involved in those female sports....thats 0.01% and 1/100th of 1% makes this a "non-topic" really and most assuredly not worthy of the air time it has received in the recent political season. I wish they would have interviewed more. players, fans rather than just those few. I also wish the folks naming "safety" as an issue had some stats to back up their claims. For example, i would love to see the stats about the higher vertical leap of "males" or the amount of concussions associated with that as well. Can i add that i love to read all the commenss below from the amateur Biologists and Sociologists here....fascinating.
Its fn wrong!
It would be nice to know if this player in question was the real reason why the SJ team was winning? Were they the only one primarily scoring? This is a rather poor report. It’s a team sport, a little harder to gauge vs a 1 person sport like track, boxing, etc. it’s crap journalism like this is why the cult of Maga has won over so many people. It’s just hard to be well informed these days.
If this person really is the factor then maybe there maybe grounds for taking another look at this. We hear a lot of transgender men, how about transgender women? Should they be allowed to compete w women and not men?
Four teams have forfeited against San Jose, refusing the play while there is a transgender human on the San Jose team. Worried you might win? The lengths some people will go to to prove their ignorance.
... ignorance is being convinced that your something your not.
Remember when a Trans Am meant a really cool American car, a Pontiac Firebird?
@@Vicente666Fernandezand parading and masquerading as something one is obviously not is no way to go through life
Their delusion is of their own making and others should not play pretend with them. It only enables more delusion.
DEI TRANS GENDER VOLLEY BALL TEAM. wow just make across sports
!
This is a tough one! What a stressful and distracting situation for a team. It would seem like the teammates would want any advantage that the trans person bring to their team.
Absolutely NOTHING tough about this. Men do NOT belong on a women’s team. PERIOD.
That's not the point. It's a biological man playing with women.
So the trans should take the spot of an actual woman then? Because that's what happens.
Possibly the most ignorant comment or thought ever. Can you imagine all the “wrongs” with such an idea? It’s not a tough one at all. It’s quite simple. Boys are boys and girls are girls. And those that believe otherwise can do so --- BUT do not force it in kids or endanger others.
This seems incredibly invasive of the student's privacy. I don't need to know the details of a student's genitalia.
You seem incredibly stupid if you think it's about their genitalia.
Players #3 Blair Fleming, birth name is Brandon Fleming with a doctor certified birth certificate male. He was ban from a South Carolina college from playing.
When you watch an NFL game, what is the genitalia of every player out there? This is women’s volleyball. His genitalia should be obvious based on the sport he is participating in but not the case.
@@Divetech2 But if you change your name doesn't that make you a woman?
This nonsensical gibberish ends on a day one of Team Trump 🇺🇸 The New Avengers....DOJ going after the criminals, Kommissar Governor Newscum, and his Sacramento Politburo..... resistance is futile
Please show some tolerance and understanding in these comments and just accept that nowadays with all technological advances men can get pregnant.
That's hilarious and the moon is made of cheese. You think the ability to get pregnant is what defines a woman? Do you have any idea how insulting that is to women?
Unfortunately, a lot of people believe that nonsense.
Biology over feelings.... parading and masquerading as something one is not is no way to go through life
No.
That daughter is just jealous 🤣🤣
Jealous of a man pretending to be a woman?
Check yourself into a facility, you need help
It only takes being open minded. Sleep with her.
Jealous of what? Unfairness in womens' sports?
She stating facts not feelings.
Safety and fairness and common sense
It’s not too much to expect in sports
It’s not!