Debunking the Pseudoscience of Nassim Haramein
Вставка
- Опубліковано 1 лип 2024
- - Patreon: / meromorphic
- TeeSpring: www.meromorphic.store
- Instagram: / meromorphicyt
- Discord: / discord
#FakePhysics #Pseudoscience #WeStanGeraldine
----
-- ALL STATEMENTS MADE WITHIN THE VIDEO ARE STRICTLY THE OPINIONS OF MEROMORPHIC (Don't sue me) --
------
**I go through some of Haramein's flawed math in the video, though it goes fairly quickly and I don't talk about it in extreme
detail, so I have linked all the relevant math in the following link. You can either just pause the video, or look at it here at your leisure.**
Math: drive.google.com/file/d/1TvTt...
--------
Sources: drive.google.com/file/d/1T3dy...
Music:
Easy by Ron Gelinas Chillout Lounge | open.spotify.com/artist/03JYf...
Music promoted by www.free-stock-music.com
Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)
creativecommons.org/licenses/...
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Intro: (0:00)
1. Background: (3:44)
2. Publications: (10:27)
3. The Schwarzschild Proton: (15:23)
4. Quantum Gravity and the Holographic Mass: (25:53)
5. More Publications: (35:45)
6. Why you should care: (40:17)
7. Conclusion: (48:36) - Розваги
Hi, I'm Geraldine and I approve this video 😜😜
Say Hi to 🦄 for me
@@Meromorphic Vatch my last video if my comments are not appearing or are deleted ;) :*
Vatch my last video and stop vith all the frauds such as nassim and GAIA idiots ;)
Liar, we know your name is Josie! What did you do to Geraldine??
You are who?
I like to see you doing different content in addition to lore! Your style fits in with this as well as it does for Destiny lore. I LOVE the destiny lore you do -- I stopped playing the game year one of D2, but your lore vids got me back into the story. Having said all that, I really like that you're continuing to branch out.
Thanks man! Much appreciated. I just want to make stuff that I enjoy making. I think it results in better content. Have no fear though, as soon as Witch Queen lore books drop, I'll be making more of those vids.
Why isn‘t there some kind of a head to head discussion. Nassim Haramein vs. somebody with „old school physics“ background. Someone reflecting the opinion of this video. Both perfectly prepared to proof everything they say. Well, this would bring some real clarity in my eyes.
If you want true physics look up to Edward Witten, if you want true spirituality look up to ancient Books, like Rig Veda or Kybalion
the Kybalion isn't ancient?
@@60circuits60 it is indeed !
@@fernandocabrera4599 come on, the Kybalion was first pubblished in 1908...
Yogi publication society!
It’s a good little book but it’s not ancient.
It’s a decent primer for basic introduction to more advanced hermetica.
I've read Haramein's Schwarzschild paper many years ago, and as a physicist from this field (quantum gravity) I was really surprised by how sloppy and weird it was. Apparently that didn't stop him from producing more pseudoscience. So I really liked your video. One small remark (if already noted by others, forget about it): you pronounce Schwarzschild as "Schwarz-child", but it's actually pronounced as Schwarz-shield" ;) All the best!
Grateful for your willingness to decipher this obscure culprit! I looked for the origin of his name; not clear either. Another one off the list... Well done!
I can't believe I was duped by this grifter. You're doing a great service. Thanks for sharing.
I would love an in-depth look at his most recent paper "the origin of mass and the nature of gravity" because the way him and his team describe it, it sounds extremely plausible to a layperson like myself who has also spent a lot of time learning about physics but certainly not a professional or an expert.
I'm curious about his claim that quantum vacuum fluctuations in the electromagnetic field result in gravity, the strong force, and the color confinement force... I can't seem to find ANY real physicists out there going through the paper (either to confirm OR to deny) seems like his work is just being ignored but I would like to know if his latest work is actually more rigorous or just more clever in his attempts to manipulate people. There are apparently multiple PHD physicists working with him on it so I would really like to see a technical breakdown of the paper in depth, as I'm not sure where to even start in analyzing it directly myself.
Who are these multiple PHD physicists ?
You can assume that this is a lie and his new paper is as bad as the other ones. He is a fraud and will never change
its one of two things:
1. he was somehow infected with sophons from trisolaris to deliberately spread misinformation.
2. ......Savathûn
But really the response to that comment reminds me way too much of the sales tactics I was taught when I worked in cold calling. Good on you for laying all the facts out and combating his bullshit.
Imagine being wrong by 38 orders of magnitude.
Why don’t you invite Nassim on your program and have a discussion?
Because that would be embarrassing for Nassim
How do you handle a swindler? Nassim has managed to cash in quite handsomely peddling his line of woo. He lives in Hawaii sith mo other means of support than the suckers buying his pseudoscience and phony spiritual nonsense
You don‘t debate fraudsters. This is an example of „false balance“, where you have two opposing views and claim that the truth is in the middle. Here its like putting a flea and and elephant on a balance and claiming the have the same weight.
By debating him you give him credibility which he doesn‘t have. He wants to earn money by selling overpriced paperweights and cooking classes
Used this to help a friend. Thank you
I would like to see a clash of you and your adversary. Actually I was waiting for someone to stand opposed his theories. That would be something!
Real Physicists won’t give this guy the time of day. It takes us no time to dismiss him as a fake.
@@williamdavis2505 look at you including yourself in the group of "real physicists", so cute.
@@JohnDoe_69 real high school graduates (which Nassim is not) could find some of the errors made in Nassim’s papers. With several graduate degrees, and decades of job experience as a researcher at a national physics lab, I am plenty real enough to dismiss him as a fake.
@@williamdavis2505 how so?
The very first recommended video for me under this one is a Nassim talk with almost 1 million views
Finally someone with a platform address Haramein's bullshit. I used to argue endlessly against his followers in Facebook until they banned from his page.
It's too bad ... I glance thru the comments and still see people snickering and shouting, "Man can't fly! If GOD intended man to fly he would have given him wings! Those pseudo-scientists from Dayton, OH, think that a heavier than air machine can "fly" people around. They obviously don't know a thing about physics nor GRAVITY!" ... AND, folks didn't believe in Tesla's alternating current... until they did. I could go on and on. One day, the people in comments section will say, "I recognized Haramein's theory years ago. It's self-evident!"
That's because it's tiresome trying to educate someone who lacks the intellectual capacity to understand what their being taught.... Lmfao...
Thanks for your work.
Awesome vid man. Great topic. Keep them coming!
PAULO?! How u doing man? How'd you find my channel? Lol. (Thanks btw👍)
Appreciate the background meme.
Hi, I like your scientific view on Nassim and his early "scientific" papers. Have you gotten his new paper (origin of mass and the nature of gravity )? Any feedback to this new unifying theory paper?
Very interesting video I’m glad I finally had time to listen to the full thing, keep up the good work my man. you somehow always manage to make physics sound way more fun!
Thanks bro! Always good to see a comment from you
I really appreciated and enjoyed the video.
A friend of mine mentioned him today, in a very positive light, so I wanted to look him up and gather some information. You put forward a very convincing case that he’s a fraud.
Thank you.
But at the end you mention Covid denialism? What do you mean by that?
He is inviting physicists in september to poke holes in his new soon to be released paper, isnt that a great setting for a followup video?
Have you seen the lecture where Herrimein
Talks about a spaceship flying into sunspots?
I'm really tired of these hacks fueling the anti science trend.
What's frustrating is that his followers will defend him violently.
I don't know where you find the patience.
Great video!
I did see that. Matter of fact.. I've been looking for it. In 2001 an asteroid the size of Jupiter came around the sun- heading towards us...and yes... I saw some type of object fly into the sun causing a huge CME to fly out the othger side and disrupt the trajectory of the asteroid thus causing it to miss Earth. I've also seen many other videos of some type of craft or objects flying into sunspots- but I've seen hundreds of those at SOHO and many other sources.....
I"m curious if you're implying that these are fake videos or something? It's impossible for live SOHO feeds to be faked... or is it?
I know old ego's in physics don't want to give up hardened concepts they feel identified with. Have Nassim on your show and let the world decide who is right?
Nassim would never agree to such a thing because he knows he'd get rekt. He very carefully controls the narrative.
it felt kinda eerie that you were looking above the camera. But regardless, how does such a high quality video only have 250 views, is this a repost or something?
Haha. I'll pretend that was an aesthetic choice. And, I guess because I'm a smaller channel that usually does other stuff, but no it's 100% my video. I'd definitely like more people to see it though.
Because it's pious bullshit
what does these mean when coincidentally connecting back to the main [Flower Game] verses I wonder?
Imagine making money by being a detriment to society. I wonder how that could possibly happen when we put so much effort into leaving companies and people unchecked in the hopes they'll run the country for us.
Well _that_ got political fast.
You dont find it at all compelling that the measured strong force is the same as if you modeled protons as black holes? Like, exactly the same. That seems too coincidental. That doesnt mean protons are black holes per say, but that merit further consideration, *of just this one point.*
Honestly it's been a while since I read the paper, so I don't remember whether that was something stated in there. Regardless, if we assume that is the case, he still had to make his hypothetical black hole proton have more mass than a mountain which we know from decades of experiments is simply not the case. The standard model is probably the single most successful theory in Physics. To disprove it, you would need a SHITLOAD of evidence on your side - not just some frankly sloppy calculations that get a fundamental fact of nature wrong.
I'll be happy to revisit this if he does one day come up with actual proof. Not gonna hold my breath, though.
This video is amazing. Keep it up!
Hey Google algorithms look at me engaging with this video.
Brother, i must say that i´m a very great fan of Nassim Haramein work, and was waiting for the day to come to buy, not one, but 64 of his ark krystals, at a cost of $76.800,00 thousand dollars, or some R$400.000,00 Reals, since i´m from Brazil. That´s enough to buy a house, a BIG ONE here in Brazil.
Because i believe in Intelectual Honesty, everything that you have said is intelectually honesty, even a child with rudimentary notions of mathmatics could undestand what you are saying, i´m not capable of buying the Krystals anymore. If they are based in the science in the papers, and they are wrong, than, by logical necessity, the krystals are wrong also, because they are the product of an intelectual mistake.
I know haramein for more than 10 years, theres a lot of things that he said that made strong sense to me, but i lacked the intelectual rigor to really examine the degree of truth contained in them. You contributed to set myself free, as it is written:
"You shall know the truth, and the truth shall set you free"
Thank you so much for such a great work done in the name of mental and spiritual freedom.
What Haramein says seems intellectually positive and deep
I listened to many of his videos
and I loved them although I dont quite get all the physics involved
but when I saw those Ark Crystals I started to question these claims
Normal Crystals can be bought cheap in any New Age shops or other places
he sells those little ones for
a thousand dollars
My brain started to question this person
He is a Guru
Guru sells things to make money
an honest physicist will not do that
won t be interested making money out of his knowlelge
The friends of Haramein
like Gregg Braden
Robert Edward Grant
and may be
Matias de Stephano
are not people I trust
@@patrickhamon2632 When theres money involved, we need to be really rigorous with what is being said.
People sell their honor cheap.
@@GeorgesSegundo
yes
totally agree
The algo threw me the Moral Orel videos after a cursed media binge on my part (a show I'd not heard much of since I live in the UK), so I wasn't expecting to find a detailed debunking of a quantum brained charlatan on your channel but I am here for it! I love me a good science based debunking!
Also don't let all the "just debate him & let the world decide!!" commenters convince you it's possible to reason a grifter out of their grift. It's how Alex Jones & his like keep worming their way back into public discourse, despite being wrong about mostly everything. Engaging further would just be trying to wrestle a pig in mud - you get muddy and the pig enjoys it. The only winning move is not to play 😉
But this is an important video to hopefully divert people falling down the pseudoscience pipeline and I applaud you for making it!
My moms a huge fan Nassim and i’m sending her this. Lets see how it goes…
Definitely give us an update!
@@Meromorphic So turns out she listened with an open mind and although your snarky jokes threw her off a little she seems to be skeptical now to the point to where after he releases his official whateverthefuck this month, if it doesn’t get any traction in the scientific community she will no longer be apart of his weird cult following. You did an excellent job sir and I applaud you for you hard work you put into this video. Its really changing minds for the better so thank you. I couldn’t have said enough to convince her but your credentials and detailed analysis did just perfect I think. Again I truly appreciate it.
Wow. This is really, really cool. I knew going into it that I wouldn't be able to convince the majority of his fans, but even reaching a few would be great. I'm really glad to hear it! Give her a big hug for being so open minded!
@@irpersonality2673 Your comment is precious, and reminds us that it's never lost to fight against crackpottery and cults.
I'm glad to know Meromorphic's work prevented someone from falling deeper into the cranckery, and glad your mother has sense and an open mind.
I'm not much of a believer but bless her soul and yours, may you and your family live long and happy lives :)
@Meromorphic That's why you should never listen to the people who say such videos are useless because addressed to people who already agree with you (I don't know if you've encountered that argument yet, but if not you will, sooner or later).
It might not change anything for most people who're already too deep into it, but there are some who are undecided or still have enough sense left to understand your points and what's wrong with such pseudoscience.
Just for that, and for every person freed from gurus and bullshit (especially when you know the damages new age bullshit can do when taken too far), it's worth it.
Thank you again sir.
@@Meromorphic Yes its amazing! To give some background on her she grew up with a hippy mom (although her mom was crazy) she started out with an open mind. But she has dabbled with mushrooms recently bc I suggested them to her and that opened her mind even more, so yeah i do not have the typical mother and i’m beyond grateful for that. Thats how shes even able TO change her mind at all. But yes i’m gonna give her the biggest hug the next time I see her! Thanks again, much love from a new subscriber ❤️❤️
thank you so much!
I must humbly admit I'd got lured into watching his stuff, because he was talking about geometry, which I find fascinating. However, I'm well aware of the concept of 'baffle them with bullshℹ️t', so I definitely do recall, when he was talking about overlapping something or other, planck length, blah blah, thinking to myself, for all my ability to see the overriding philosophical concept of some scientific finding, I had feck all idea what he was talking about, and it didn't sound scientific, it sounded like convenient wordplay. Whilst, I do maintain their are 'some' people that are on the fringes of science, that DO have good intentions, and are genuinely trying to push the boundaries of understanding, whilst using accepted physics and methodolgy, you have proved to me adequately that he is simply a white lab coated snake oil salesman. So thankyou for taking the time to research his material. 👍🏻
"Tell the W.H.O.!" Plays music by the Who...
😎
Would like to see you address some of William Browns research with ark crystals
They wouldn't understand what William saying... 😂
Mr Brown has a Masters in biology, and is an employee of Mr Haramein. Nobody is impressed - scientific progress doesn't work that way. Tell me that physics professors from France, China and Brazil have read this research, carried out the same experiments and got the same results - then I'll be impressed. Also: most physics geniuses don't sell merchandise on the side.
@@dalgetty you don't have the intellectual capacity to understand the science your judging! Stick to watching x factor it's within potential for understanding
Just thought I should comment here as a precautionary measure, just incase a 3rd John is needed to flush anymore Ark Crystal BS down the comode.
Omg video games, TV shows and movies and debunking? Can you do some cooking videos so I never have to go anywhere else for content?
Lmao. Trust me. You do not want to be near anything I cook.
@@Meromorphic haha fair enough. I guess nobody's perfect. Lol
I've listened to some of his theories and it sounded really plausible but I am not a Physicist and though I think there may still be some truth to his theories the one thing that made me shift my "Oh, he's just too progressive for the community" view was the fact that it is hard to search for differing opinions on his theories. I think if you truly stood for what you say, discussion and feedback should be welcomed because that is how you GROW. By seeing faults that either you find solutions too or realise it's time to move in a different direction or find a different perspective. That kind of behaviour speaks volumes about how he views his own credentials. I do enjoy alternate theories and I am definitely that "spiritual" bish, but I am not stupid and i like to cross check my facts. Thank you for this video!
Yeah, obviously the crystal thing makes him seem much less sincere considering he should know better with his background. However, I'm interested why it would be incorrect to add variables that cancel out. It seems like he is proposing that there are hidden variables, and maybe there are other evidence of them outside of those formulas, but I don't know enough about physics to know if that is a possibility (regardless of whether he presents compelling evidence). Also, I'm surprised you didn't look into his "Best Paper" award at the University of Liège, Belgium in 2009 for The Schwarzschild Proton paper. That's where he got his start I think and seems to offer more credibility than the publication you had trouble finding and the allegedly pay-for-play ones. He (and/or original uploader) mentioned it in his 4hr lecture that is now on UA-cam under the title "Nassim Haramein At Rogue Valley Metaphysical Library" (I saw it so long ago it was on Google Video when that was a thing).
Hidden variables rings a bell. Speaking of bell, I think hidden variables are proven with Bell theorems.
It's a well known fact that if you claim to be a physicist or god forbid you get a PhD in physics later in life you can simply claim whatever you want. Never forget Pauling and Benveniste totally flip-flopped after making very important discoveries. A doctoral degree does not make one immune to irrationality. It's particularly bizarre in this case because his algebra while circular is at least self-consistent if you look at individual bits. He's clearly not devoid of basic numeracy. Every here and then he even seems to be able to use jargon correctly in a way that suggests he isn't *purely* a markov chain of smart sounding words. Then again perhaps he's just copied someone else. It's quite sad that he's devoted his life to both scamming people and undermining actual scientists.
Definitely one of your weirder Destiny lore videos.. JK keep up the solid content. I respect the dedication to finding the truth
Lmao. Thanks brah
I think your explanation of unified theory is incorrect, it refers to unifying the forces not a map from classical to quantum physics and visa versa (which already exists for many areas) (see quantization).
I could have been a bit more clear. I was specifically talking about gravity there, because that is what Haramein is most concerned with -- and I believe that is also contained within the idea of UF. But yeah you are correct, the other forces have a clear map between regimes
Gravity is still a classical theory while weak and strong forces and electromagnetism have all been quantized. Unifying the forces would therefore provide a “map between”classical and quantum physics, a theory of quantum gravity.
The problem with physicists and scientists in general is that if they're wrong they've all wasted at least 10 years of their lives learning BS...so they're bound to have issues with free thinkers
excellent video... after watching Nassim's TEDTALK, I was a bit suspicious, so I did some research
and POW!... your video pops up. thanks for exposing a huckster.
There will be every opinion on every topic. Right and wrong are subjective not fact
@@AllGoodLongchenRabjam108 you obviously don’t know math, or even logic for that matter. In these fields there are an infinitude of statements that are indisputably true or false.
Hi there. I stumbled on this today because the Sonic Bloom festival is about to happen in Colorado. I stopped attending after 2012 because I realized the producer was one of Haramein's shills. One of the unspoken goals of the festival is to recruit for this bullshit. It's way bigger than those Ark crystals, Haramein has a compound in Hawaii and has been recruiting (I guess it's networking?) from festivals for decades. He has people out there earning for him at all of them. It's like a transcendental pyramid scheme. Your sister possibly found one of his shills at one of these festival talks. This weekend, during this festival, this festival producer is going to try to get people to give him an hour and a half to listen to him talk about this unified theory shit - and he knows a lot of them will be inebriated and malleable. The festival is so built around it, they call the space The Unified Field during the festival and the producer lists being a Resonance faculty member as his primary occupation. He calls himself a physicist, but he's really a dulcimer player and a festival producer. I think he was in the string cheese incident or something.
THANK YOU for putting out content about this guy's grift.
I honestly read that as "Sonic Boom" Festival, like the video game. I was very confused. But I'm glad you enjoyed it! I had not heard of the things you're mentioning, but that is really interesting 🤔.
so peer review trumps actual science
No. Peer review is *part* of actual science.
Had the same with a friend of mine. She said that I will like Nassim because he's a physics. I told her in a second not to buy his garbage. And stop watching his stuff. Very dangerous man. Good job on the video
whats wrong with him?
Thank you!
He is from Quebec. French Quebec citizens use the word ark but it usually means: disgusting.
One of his "ark crystal" pendants came through lost and found. I want to make sure it's safe to store, ship, and potentially give to donation because I know a lot of "health science" has dangerous chemicals and even radioactive materials.
I've not purchased one because the price tag is frankly ridiculous, but from all the information on their site, it appears to just be an inert hunk of quartz with titanium.
The website that you show at 14:59 is not from the AIP but a predetory conference provider. That's why a conference on such a niche topic is offered 4 times a year
I had no previous knowledge of this man or his graft but I appreciate how well done is this video and I was educated on the subject and furthermore entertained. Should def be viewed more widely.
I must point out that I was very impressed with the in-depth research you did following your sister's curiosity to go down the rabbit hole.
Although I think that in the process itself you missed a few important things that you did not seem to fully understand their weight (literally). I will focus on one key: It’s true that the ratio
n/R*ml you saw actually comes to the same Schwarzschild solution. But, it using the holographic concept, which is something that was not exist at 1920’s. And that should be noted. As you can see, he divides the “shell” space n (imaginary of course, because we live in 3D) by the volume R contained in it (and get a constant number) all by thinking that the shell boundaries dictate the relative amount of information (energy) expressed in Planck units, emerges from the trapped volume and multiplied by its Planck’s mass to produce mass in general. And that's my dear friend, an amazing and a NEW thing in itself. Because it means that the above solution can be reached from only simple geometric reasons and maybe also getting us to the real source of gravity (Occam's razor) without using long calculations of General Relativity that uses complex tensors and metrics.. and that my dear friend, you missed.
Another thing that you could raise in your review as one that actually does accept the concept of the proton as a black hole is to innocently ask how then the proton did not fade and disappear following Hawking radiation. I raise this because I myself have asked myself this question. And I came to the conclusion that it does support this idea without Hawking's radiation limit. Well, The short answer is that time slows down from the proton's point of view so the decay process is extremely slow on a much larger scale than the age of the universe.
Why didn't the owner of this YT channel put a little cutesy heart on your comment. You make more sense.
@@carlalakins
The explanation is quite simple. For his part, he spread the gospel and moved on. Any criticism of his words that makes use of logical means will lead him to a confrontation that he has no interest in dealing with.
@@carlalakins Idan's reasoning might feel like it makes sense, but it's incorrect. This is how pseudoscience operates: provide a story that feels right, then sell it to people who don't have the time or the experience or the inclination to test it carefully. Unfortunately, Brandolini's law is true here: it takes ten times more effort to explain why someone's story is nonsense than it does for them to come up with it. Very few people have the time for that. Mero has done a brilliant job.
Thanks for your input Einstein.. Its all solved
Sorry, I don’t see that the place for your responses provides the proper answer contrary to what I have written. It's ridiculous and it's unprofessional. If I'm wrong, point out where I'm wrong and don’t tell baseless stories about me and my work in physics. I explained how the individual case can be arrived at in the Schwarzschild solution using pure geometry. This is simple math, want to argue about it? Please, I'm all ear..
Oh If you have no knowledge to respond, please do not respond. it’s simple as that.
I`m not a degree physics, i being interested on the subject for more than 10 years. The same than you, my sister toll me about this pseucientific. Of course I didn`t beleve him and look for more and better information. Thanks very much for your analysis
Quidaté José. Ellos son falsos y mentirosos. No crees el decepción.
thanks for that video I do understand his gibbrish on the level of insight but it's very informative to have the perspective of an expert in the filed
I think shielding one's theory from scientific criticism is unacceptable
lately he's collaborating with real physicists to re write his theory in a more scientific manner we shall see how it goes
Our society is dissolving. Too much complexity to handle for normal human brain. Science is too "big", and science does not give purpose, sense.
Resonance and vibrations are not special. They’re just fancy shaking
Based Haramein getting down on the jiggle physics.
What will your T-shirts do for me?
Most complete video I've seen about this crank.
You went over pretty much everything, thank you for your hard work, sir !
(I'll add this : Did you see that he pretends on his RSF website that the Paul Scherrer Institute made a measurement of the charge radius of the proton which allegedly came after his own and confirmed it, when his paper has been "published" in april 2013, and the PSI measurement has been published in january 2013 ?)
Glad you liked it! And yes, I did see that. It was pretty hilarious.
I'll be honest, it was supposed to be in the script, but I must have forgotten to add it at some point
@@Meromorphic It's all fine, your video is definitely complete without that, it's just one more drop in the middle of an ocean of bullsh*t, which you already successfully exposed for what it is :)
Sad story about Bob shutting down his blog about Haramein, big thanks to him too (and WayBackMachine).
I would like to hear your opinion on the hemisync document which is posted on the official cia website. Just google it, UA-cam removed my previous comment.
It's sad that this video doesn't do well.
You should join forces with Coffezilla
just curious what your background is
I honestly dont understand how some people can knowingly lie for their living. I lie on occassion, but it always sits in my head as a liability, no matter how much of a white lie it is. So brazenly lying like this is just unthinkable to me, it's like these charlatans lack certain components in their minds that would make a person fully human.
It's all about money.
Narcissistic Personality Disorder?!
To their defense; they also bend their perception of reality according to their grandiosity. So to them lying all the time is just a bunch of white lies since the ultimate truth is their own empty shell of an identity.
As long as narcissistic supply keeps coming their way and enough dumb people affirm them they don't care and enjoy their destructive personality since they can externalise the destruction. The are very risk taking. Lots of them in esoteric scene/self development coach scene etc. !!
BRUH! 🤣 would love to hear your opinion about, NASA physicist, Thomas Campbell (My big TOE theory) 🙏🙏
Had to look him up. He seems maybe less dangerous than Haramein, but he is just as full of shit. Any time anyone makes claims that involve quantum mechanics and consciousness, it's basically guaranteed hogwash. Quantum mechanics has no more to do with consciousness than it does toe cheese, or a rock - in other words, quantum mechanics is the science of the things literally everything is made of. There is no deeper connection there, and anyone trying to tell you otherwise is either delusional or trying to sell you something.
@@Meromorphic Im curious who has a proof that "Quantum mechanics has nothing no more to do with consciousness than it does toe cheese, or a rock " ?
"Not even wrong." - Wolfgang Pauli
What about Dan Winter?
dan winter is a real G
Just asinine. First you jump to some of the implications in terms of products based on his scientific theories which are all valid and consistent (as far as they go) with known facts of physics. Why is it always the people with the least accomplishments to their name who are always trying to criticise those who actually look at the assumptions that are implied and often flawed in modern day physics and coherently challenge them? Maybe because they lack talent themselves? Let's look at several truths that modern physics still doesn't want to deal with:
1. Distinguishing between experimental and observational data on the one hand and the interpretation of those data on the other. Data are often open to more than one interpretation. Any interpretation is based on certain assumptions, which may be unverified or even unverifiable. - The author criticises Haramein's assumptions not because he can prove that his assumptions are flawed but just because they don't align with what he believes.
2. A model of reality is not reality itself. A model or theory is always a simplification, an approximation; it may have a degree of validity and/or utility without being literally true. Even if the equations associated with a particular theory or model allow accurate calculations of real events, this is no guarantee that any particular physical interpretation of those equations corresponds to mechanisms in the real world. - So Haramein's model can enable more accurate calculations of real events but the products based on those theories may or may not be of value to the world.
3. Mathematical abstractions such as zero-dimensional particles, one-dimensional strings, two-dimensional spacetime ribbon-tape, and curved spacetime are not concrete realities! These concepts can be useful in certain contexts, but they have no concrete existence outside the human imagination. The thing that most scientist including the author of this video has failed to grasp is that they cannot directly influence the real world and explain nothing! This is the fatal flaw of most university scientists who either make up or follow absurd theories, or ‘mazes of unrealities’, that are passed off as ‘science’.
4. Another deep flaw of many so called scientists is that there are no ultimate explanations of natural phenomena. If we are to find the direct causes of events, one needs to look to real substances, energies, forces, and entities, whether physical or superphysical. Things that apply at the micro level should generally also apply at the macro level. There is little to no attempt to reconcile the profound disconnect between all of their strange theories. Consider that the standard model predicts the Higgs boson, which shows up sometimes, among the total number of 61 elementary fermions and bosons! And the Higgs boson is said to be a component of the hypothetical Higgs field made up of elementary particles that supposedly acquire mass by interacting with this field - including the Higgs particle of which the Higgs field consists! This is said to occur through spontaneous symmetry-breaking of the SU(2) gauge symmetry - mind you, an abstract mathematical symmetries theorists have dreamt up to classify and ‘understand’ fundamental particles, which is said to have no spin, electric charge, or colour charge, and to be so unstable that it decays into other particles almost immediately! There are or were extensions of the standard model that predicted the existence of more than one kind of Higgs boson. But now the CMS and the ATLAS experimental teams at the Large Hadron Collider have said that they have found the Higgs Boson because each detected a spike in their data which they interpreted to be a very heavy particle with a mass of 125.3 and 126.5 GeV respectively that is supposedly ‘consistent with’ the Higgs boson, despite there being numerous discrepancies with predictions. Amazing what one can learn by doing the equivalent of smashing things apart at higher and higher speeds!?! And let us not forget those leptons and quarks which are said to be structureless, zero-dimensional, infinitely small particles (you know, infinitesimal points also known as abstractions, that don't have any concrete realities with measurable properties). And riddle me this? Scientist claim that if the electron are infinitely small, the electromagnetic force surrounding it would have an infinitely high energy, since electrical force increases as distance decreases; the electron should therefore have an infinite mass!?! So an electron with a mass of 9.1 x 10-28 grams, or 511 keV (thousand electron-volts). How does scientist like the author get around this silliness? They use a a mathematical trick: they simply divide each positive infinity by a negative infinity and then substitute the experimentally known values. (i.e. ‘renormalization’ - pioneered by Richard Feynman).
And let's dig into some of conventional physics other silly properties:
What is 'Colour charge’? - A purely abstract ‘property’.
What is quantum ‘spin’? - it does not refer to the classical concept of spin; spin-½ electrons, for example, supposedly have to be rotated through 360° twice in order to return to their original position.
What is ‘isospin’? - it is claimed that if a nucleon (a particle composing an atomic nucleus) is ‘spun’ one way it becomes a proton, and if ‘spun’ the other way it becomes a neutron!?! But such ‘spinning’ takes place not in the space we move in, but in an imaginary mathematical realm!?!
Let's look at the "six types" of quarks - No single quarks has ever been directly observed, and their existence is inferred from the correspondence of their expected properties with the light, heat and path generated by a violent collision in a particle accelerator. This is despite the fact that accelerator experiments produces more data than could ever be interpreted, so supercomputers sift through this information looking for the patterns that theorists have "decided" are important. Scientists say in some particle collisions, concentrated jets of particles are emitted in certain directions, and this was "interpreted" to mean that unobserved quarks are being hit which then emit observable particles in the direction in which they are moving. But up until now quark theory has made few if any predictions that were subsequently verified and is continuously modified to accommodate new "observations". Remember Murray Gell-Mann first proposed the theory in 1964, at that time there were only three quarks and three antiquarks. Now the number is 36, plus 8 gluons, and not a single one of these supposedly physical particles has ever been directly observed. Each quark is theorized to carry an electric charge measuring either one-third or two-thirds of an electron charge, but no such charges have ever been detected!?!
I could go on. As is evident that are serious problems with a theory in which ‘virtual’ particles are continually appearing from nowhere and then disappearing so fast as to be unobservable. Not only do such events violates the law of the conservation of energy, but physicists like the author turn a blind eye to this as it lasts only for a fraction of second, which is allegedly allowed by the Heisenberg ‘uncertainty principle’. But consider that at any given moment there are unlimited numbers of such particles, so no matter how briefly each one exists, this amounts to a permanent loan of infinite energy. If one thinks about the general relativity theory, all this energy should curve the universe into a little ball - which obviously doesn’t happen! Experiments confirm that detectable electron-positron pairs surround every charged particle. The author's vaunted quantum theory does not explain where they come from or go to; the equations simply contain a ‘creation operator’ and an ‘annihilation operator’. Consider that nothing comes from nothing, so there must be a subquantum energy realm not included in standard physics, out of which physical particles crystallize and back into which they can dissolve. (Hmmm. This sounds like Nassim Haramein and the idea of black holes?). And yet even, Richard Feynman invented the notion that a positron (anti-electron) was really an electron travelling backwards in time. Are we all starting to see how the author's notion of physics has serious problems with it? Because you know, the universe is not connected!
Bravo for this guided tour yet those apparently chaotic tentatives at interpreting reality as intelligent o rdely system point out to connectiveness ...we are the infinite stupidity ...togetherness
Thank you for this very knowledgeable answer which, of course, author of the video did not address.
this is probably really interesting if I could understand it lol. So are you saying nassim is full of s**t or does he have some interesting points?
Very well said. I have a friend who has a Masters degree in astrophysics and he said to me that he thinks that everything they think they know about physics might actually be wrong and that was the perspective that he thought was actually correct. I asked him about Harramein’s work and he said he would have to sit down and go through it properly as it required a lot of concentration. I feel because Harramein is not classically trained he doesn’t speak fully in their language or fully explain things in ways they understand. However, he has physicists with PHD’s working and writing papers with him. I’ll be interested to see how his latest paper The Origin Of Mass and the Nature of Gravity is received.
Lol taking a page out of Nassim's playbook. Nice, almost coherent reply. Will probably fool some dummies out there.
I went to school with this guy. Nice video David.- Omar. Really good stuff.
Thanks man! Been a long time
Let’s hangout once I get my life sorted lol
Have you actually read his white paper?
I thought he was someone who was first a pseudoscience and that then studied to become a real scientist with te difference that he was still saying things that were not well funded LOL.
This guy doesn't even know about the research in book "Fourth Phase of Water"...
Getting a paper peer reviewed doesn't mean as much anymore. I will not mention names but 2 academics, submitted 8 papers know by them to be false. Four of them were accepted as true science because it fit the narrative. I personally have had good results with scalar wave therapy. So this looks like a video for the narrative.
you should do a video on dan winter
Him and Greg Braden have just put a video out on UA-cam called symbols we haven't seen before but the artifact they discussed looks fake, it has pictures of flying saucers and hieroglyphs but it looks fake to me and I'm not an expert but my gut feeling is he is also fake
I heard Haramein talk about archaeology. Having studied for a master's degree in history and actually worked on a few archaeological digs, it's pure cringe to hear him spew false statement after false statement and see how clueless he is.
Don't forget to mention that in "A Scaling Law For Organized Matter", on page 4, Haramein wrote:
"10^w + 10^R = 10^8 so that 10^(w+R) = 10^8", which means that he's unable to add two large numbers properly.
Oh shit. Hahaha. I didn't analyze that one. Great catch! I'll have to read it now. How central was that to the paper's main thrust?
@@Meromorphic I have no idea what the impact is, but the mere fact that it is there is embarrassing enough.
Yes this glaring and rudimentary error is in the paper, near the bottom of page 4. Yes it is central, in the discussion of figure 1, which depicts the “scaling law” for which the paper is titled. The discussion on p 4 is borderline incoherent and full of errors.
What do you expect from a high school dropout? This where we learn properties of exponents. Yes there are errors in this paper that high school students could catch.
Worse, I just discovered Nassim’s self references (5) & (6), purporting to being published in the Bulletin of the APS, are fake. The BAPS is freely and easily internet searchable and there are no such publications.
Read the Entropy Law and the Economic Process by Nicholas Georgescu-Roegen
Why isn’t people like Nassim are put in jail? He is definitely is work hard to mislead people !!!
All these Nassim sycophants showing up in these comments, and not one of them can justify $1000 USD for a piece of quartz covered in some titanium.
Outstanding! You are magnificent. Thank you for sharing your expertise. You are helping the world. His Tetrragammatron video is interesting and you are correct he could be better if he further edified himself because he is smart. A lazy or desperate smart person is quick to grift. Again thank you for the presentation sharing knowledge. Go physics
“The only true wisdom is in knowing you know nothing.” - Socrates
Great video. I don’t have the physics background to parse his works myself, but I do have a science background and can understand when a bad methodology is pointed out.
Unfortunately, even at the highest levels of science education, my personal experience was that people’s laziness or apathy led even students at a prestigious university to fudge numbers, cut corners, dismiss unexpected data points, and generally arrive at the right results the wrong way - when the training wheels were on. I shuddered to think about how these people would repeat those behaviors when pursuing their own research, and it led me to take the cowardly path of abandoning my studies in biology.
I am glad that there are people out there who care about rigorous scientific discipline and who will defend the rest of us against the fudgers.
The whole reason we do peer review in science is specifically to counteract all those lazy biases and shortcuts people might be taking.
If I can do the thing in the same way that you said you did it and get the same result that it's probably at least partially valid especially if 27 other people can do it.
‘Peer review’ hm …. Doesn’t that just mean ‘a bunch of ego maniacs trying to secure their funding gravy train by knocking off their competitors?’ 🤔
@@QuitWithNick Preach!
no? you think the entire world community of academia is ran like a company or a mob lol?
Someone grab this video before it gets removed by false claims from Nassim.
Thanks
Thanks so much!
8:28
This would be some good advice for a fellow named Kent Hovind…. hey look him up you might be surprised at the video you might be able to make just from him alone😏
Maybe Terrance Howard and Nassim Haramein can get together and solve the unified theory of everything and save all of humanity...😂😭💀
Dont discard everything they say my man,sure they re both scammers,but they will give you bits and pieces you can use,like when Howard talked about space between bubbles,he presents it as solid space,but what if that space is another bubble bein suppressed by larger bubbles around it? Think in term of soap bubbles in a bathtub...people can manipulate but to do so they have to use truth in order to sell lies,learn how to process information correctly and you ll use that truth while ignoring lies..
I had the misfortune of attending one of Mr. Haramein's tapings back in 2009 (when I was working towards my BS in Physics). I naively thought that he was going to present actual research on a Grand Unified Field Theory (which typically refers to the unification of the strong and electroweak forces). I could only sit there with a slack-jawed expression as he proceeded to vomit absolute nonsense about "sacred geometry", aliens and pyramids, and other New Age bullshit. Not once did I see a single equation displayed in his presentation, let alone any actual analytic or numerical results with accompanying explanations. It was all incoherent world salad. Dollars to donuts, I guarantee his "paper" is nowhere to be found in those 2008 AIP Conference Proceedings on GUTs. It's simultaneously frustrating and sad to see so much delusion and Dunning-Kruger going on...
This video deserves many more views and certainly a significantly higher like-dislike ratio. I can only imagine that the source of downvotes is exclusively from other practitioners of woo and pseudoscience in general; otherwise, my faith in humanity will continue to sharply decline.
Glad to see you got your BS degree.
Thank you very much!!
Thank you man. I used to think that this guy is a hidden genius or something.
A conman who fools the gullible whites
"The arc crystal does not influence you. Nor does our phiazeerMürderWhaks nor EMweps." Lalu ja Tyson are in the same team. Also is meromorphic who´s taske is to make you to belive that *at least on is not a crook*. THEY ARE ALL CROOKS.
meromorphic - once you meet telepaths (natural or technological, it does not matter), or popout of the body, you can become "spiritual" (it may not mean much more than one understands, that usual accepeted senses are just once small band to excperience the world). The problem with Haramein is that he is part of the NWOcult. Through these ill intent spiri-ppl (99%) they mark and tag them othe spiri ppl. Maybe for removing them later, maybe for using as tools. Maybe getting their dna. etc. Once you get a close look how vile this world is, you may have to step back praising scientists. You know taht top "marketing scientists" are all occult? Very spiri. Very horny. I have a lot of information what do i see what is going on. Very sad info. Even you, are probably be in big mason club.
As even psysichist say time-space is doomed. (this is the next level where time looses its meaning.) Idk how it happens, does some next level spiri warn me or do just some horrible events ripple "back in time". In that way i can prevent them happening. Ususally at the last second.
If you´d know all the things i know, Id think youd say this place is a energy harvesting simulation ("3D") that uses souls as energy generators. Once someones soul wakes up (for reason or another) they are presented the next lie (that this place is a school, you yourself chose it). But prison it is. Some elite puppets get very mad if I tell about things. It´s their problem they tried to abuse me. Two k1llattempts for talking but they are weak. As you see i´m still talking.
Nassim has re-emerged and is grifting again. A friend forwarded me this.
“Those who follow my work have patiently awaited the release of my Unified Field Theory of Everything Paper with building anticipation. I've been absent from calls and interviews over the last year and for good reason.
Thank you for your patience.
Many of you have reached out curious about my whereabouts, perhaps wondering why I've gone silent. Believe me, I have missed you and I have much to share. We are creating an engineering roadmap for technologies that precisely describe how to extract energy from the zero-point energy (ZPE) field.
It's been difficult to be away from you, and I've had to entrench myself in the quantum; drawing from it the mathematical equations for the fundamental mechanics of nature at the Planck scale.
In a podcast with Lewis Howes, I was asked, "How do you manifest in the quantum field? Our listeners want to know!"
My reply was, "In order to know how to manifest, you have to understand the mechanics of how the Universe works. How did it manifest itself?
My team of scientists and I have solved the mathematical equations that unify all forces, all scales, and all constants, taking the guesswork out of Einstein's field equations and bridging incomplete theories with precise analytical mathematical equations. To unravel the esoteric paradoxes of modern-day physics, we've had to rework and connect seemingly disconnected theories to find an analytical path to Maxwell, Einstein's, and Max Planck's theories, unlocking a puzzled framework that has plagued Quantum Physics and the Theory of Relativity for the last century.
Most physicists are baffled by the nature of the quantum field and do not understand that zero-point energy is fundamental to the mechanics of quantum physics. This nature of reality was discovered by Max Planck, the father of Quantum theory, yet modern physicists do not believe that we can pull energy from the vacuum.
Solving the Unified Field Theory of Everything is no small feat. What's even more challenging than solving mathematical equations is reverse engineering the perplexities of the standard model built on discontinuous theories and unexplained constants and free parameters.
It has not been easy to stay away from you all, but it has been necessary. As if unraveling the greatest mysteries of the Universe hasn't kept us occupied, we have orchestrated commensurate changes to our organizations in order to take these technological discoveries to the next level. Now is the time. I need your help and participation more than ever. It is time to change the world together and build a community that will launch humanity into the new world.
Come and talk with me
I will host a call with my leadership team to share how we will bring these technologies into the world.
Hear our plans for building a new future for humanity.
60-minute conversation plus,
30 min Q&A
French Speaking (LIVE)
Thursday, August 3
8pm CEST
English Speaking (LIVE)
Saturday, August 5
11am EST”
Wild and impossibly unbelievable claims but I am sure he will find some dupes. No paper yet.
The paper on The Origin of Mass and the Nature of Gravity is out. A follow-up is in the works.
The only people being "grifted" are those who have decided his theory is wrong and can never be proved. Short-sighted people in my view.
Try reading Cosmometry. It might help you to understand Haramein's work. Better yet, work out his math and try to find something wrong with it. No one has been able to so far.
@@jcinaz you seem to be missing the point of this video. The arguments are mathematical. I independently arrived at the same conclusion as Mero using equivalent mathematical arguments. My two cents are attached in the description of this video if you can read math. Honestly it is not much more than high school algebra so it should not be too difficult.
@@jcinaz I read Cosmometry btw. More pseudoscience imo. It is slick and glossy though.
@@jcinaz I also read the new paper. As expected it delivers on none of Nassim’s wild promises for a “unified theory of everything.” It is, however, dressed up nicely by two PhD coauthors.
I only read the first part in depth. I stopped where it said ZPE is not a consequence of Heisenberg uncertainty, which I know is not true.
Just a question. What do you make of cymatics?
Cool
My first time here..... Great question.
I think it's safe to say that this young fellow is a "scientist" (who considers cymatics to be pseudo-science). I'm betting that he also believes that living creatures do not have "souls" AKA measurable "electro-magnetic whatevers" and actual measurable electrical (charges controlled and created by the brain/mind)
Waveforms in liquid are a real thing, even when caused by sound vibration. So not really a Pseudoscience
I don’t feel this was actually a debunking. You noted some interesting points though chose to criticise his early papers rather than his recent work.
Also can intuition not play a factor when assumptions are made? Often with intuitives they receive information they know to be true even if they can’t fully explain it. To people who’re more left-brained this would appear to be making assumptions rather than receiving intuitive information by connecting with a deeper level of awarenes.
Harramein states himself that he didn’t choose conventional education, because he felt it would restrain him. I myself also chose not to go down that path as I felt mainstream education is very limited and lacks balance.
I’ve been following him for years and had not heard about his crystal products. They aren’t marketed on his FB page so if he was a conman, as you suggest, he’s not doing a particular good job at marketing his products.
I remember his debates with Bobathon and I think the main argument was that Bobathon was misunderstanding and failing to grasp what was being said.
I’ve seen some interesting debates on Reddit feeds with physicists and a physicist member of his team who was able to answer all criticism.
If he is a conman then I’d love to see you debunk his latest paper The Origin of Mass and The Nature of Gravity. If you’re indeed correct then it should be a fairly easy task for you.
Thanks for this. I saw a meme about him in a Facebook group and immediately saw red flags. I will be sharing this with the group. 👍🏼🙂
How'd they respond?
If you say that you are the best, it means that your own merits don't agree.
He is as much a con with his "education and teaching", as Donald Trump was with Trump University. OOPS that cost him 25 Million to settle!
Quantum University only has degreed programs in holistic medicine. Several prominent scientists and doctors are on the staff. If you want to say that Nassim is a scammer because of his association with this university, then please include Dr. Rupert Sheldrake, Dr. Bruce Lipton, Dr. Joe Dispenza, Dr. Amit Goswami, and all the other contributors and faculty members at the university. Holistic medicine is an alternative to medical practice. Anyone who doesn’t believe in holistic medicine will obviously lump it with anything that they think is pseudo science or even a scam. That’s your prerogative, but it doesn’t nullify it outright as a useful health practice, nor does it mean that the staff and instructors are any part of a scam. Hence, a scam is could be anything that you pay for and get nothing material in return to show for your money, like being a Patron to this or any UA-cam channel.
WHO FDA is your God send . I like your moustache mate !!
Sorry I lost it when your friend was reading the comments and you could hear him smiling 💀
My manager at work told me about this guy. Really hyped him up and sent me one of his videos. I haven’t watched it yet because I wanted to research this guy a bit more. Really glad I found this video
Because you would not want to make up your own mind?
Lmao dude,can you be more lost in life...
I considered looking up that TED talk video just to downvote is, but then remembered that downvotes are now hidden…
Seriously, guys like Nassim are why the world needs dislike buttons.
Unfortunately companies like Google, Meta, etc, care more about their profits and social media users are too sensitive about their dopamine drip being interrupted by a downvote so dislikes are probably going to disappear at some point. 😣 Which is great news for Nassim because that makes it more effective for him to spread his bullcrap. [/rant]
Anyway, excellent video, per usual! Keep up the good work. 😄
Thanks brother! Much appreciated as always. 😉
Great video! Who we taking down next?! Haha
Savathûn, obviously! 😆