The History of the Turkic Languages

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 3 лип 2017
  • Developing some time after 1000 BCE, the theoretical 'Proto-Turkic' language gradually spread throughout much of Central Asia during the first few centuries of the Common Era. It divided and further divided into sub-families, which continued to spread west during the Middle Ages. Today, the descendants of these people can be found as far west as Turkey, and as far east as the fringes of Mongolia.
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Support me on Patreon: www.patreon.com/user?u=4740833
    Follow me on DeviantArt: olliebye.deviantart.com/
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Original Map:
    new.demis.nl/products/web-map-...
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Thanks to:
    TeeMee for helping speed up the animation process with "Number Animationer"
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Music:
    Magnus Ringblom - Turkish Journey 2

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1,8 тис.

  • @arghunpride5704
    @arghunpride5704 5 років тому +204

    Great video! Greetings from Kazakhstan to all turkic brothers around the world!

    • @kultigin1998
      @kultigin1998 5 років тому +15

      Sana da selam olsun kardeşim.

    • @drswag0076
      @drswag0076 3 роки тому

      your country is a dictatorship, change my mind.

    • @kenan8589
      @kenan8589 10 місяців тому

      Aleyküm selam kardeşim. 🇹🇷🇰🇿🇰🇬🇺🇿🇹🇲🇦🇿

  • @OllieBye
    @OllieBye  7 років тому +198

    As some of you may be able to tell, I haven't included all Turkic languages - information on some minor ones was scarce. If you have any information that would make this video more detailed, please make me aware.

    • @ceplio
      @ceplio 7 років тому +1

      first to reply

    • @BrySchec
      @BrySchec 7 років тому +4

      Well Tajik-speakers have their own country

    • @legeekduvendredi
      @legeekduvendredi 7 років тому +39

      Tajik isn't turkic, it's a persian dialect.

    • @politruk5712
      @politruk5712 7 років тому +14

      you forgot Idil Tatar (Kazan,Volga) and u can be specialize Altaic langs like Tuva Khakas .. And you could show Sakha Yakut dialect

    • @adidoki
      @adidoki 7 років тому +14

      you forgot to include the turkic people far east in siberia called the yakuts I think it was

  • @ada6220
    @ada6220 2 роки тому +35

    2:31 Pecheneg Turks went to the Balkans and became Christians. Later, they became mercenaries in the Byzantine army. In the war between the Seljuk Turks and Byzantium in 1071, the Pecheneg Turks switched sides and joined the Seljuks, as we spoke the same language.
    If there is a Turkish Republic today, we owe it to the Turkish language and Turkish brotherhood
    Yaşasın dilimiz!

    • @thecoomernomad8223
      @thecoomernomad8223 Рік тому +2

      keep in mind, Turkic mercenaries often waited to see who was winning and then either switched to the side of the winner or simply abandoned the field.

    • @user-jh8gz1lo4e
      @user-jh8gz1lo4e 2 місяці тому

      Only about 1000 mercenaries crossed over to the side of the Turkish army. Seeing this, Roman Diogenes made the other Turkish mercenaries swear on the Bible and still kept them under strict observation at night.

  • @braineurons
    @braineurons 2 роки тому +30

    Thanks for such great video. Bardık türk elderine salam 🇰🇬🇹🇷🇦🇿🇺🇿🇹🇲🇰🇿

  • @sdonasd327
    @sdonasd327 5 років тому +68

    From Turkey.
    İ understand Azerbaijan language %98 , Turkmen language %70 , Uzbek language %50

    • @mediterraneanmapping9657
      @mediterraneanmapping9657 3 роки тому +1

      What about Siberians

    • @khansarts4298
      @khansarts4298 3 роки тому +8

      @@mediterraneanmapping9657 %30

    • @farizkeren5730
      @farizkeren5730 3 роки тому +1

      Or Chuvash

    • @uzpower
      @uzpower 3 роки тому

      That’s good you learn Turkish my friend. We brought a good language to the Greek lands

    • @babekasadli
      @babekasadli 2 роки тому +5

      From Azerbaijan I understand 100%Turkish, 90%Uzbek, 60%Turkmen, 50%Kyrgyz and Kazakh

  • @user-bx7gd8uf8m
    @user-bx7gd8uf8m 4 роки тому +155

    Love all my Turks family. Salam Aleykum from 🇰🇬🇰🇬🇰🇬

    • @altaiturk3817
      @altaiturk3817 4 роки тому +13

      Män Kyrgzstanı köp seviräm Alga Kyrghz Turklär(I love Kyrgz Turks) Sanga dediklarımın neçäsını anladın? (% kach?)

    • @user-bx7gd8uf8m
      @user-bx7gd8uf8m 4 роки тому +11

      @@altaiturk3817 100% tuşundum, anladim.

    • @altaiturk3817
      @altaiturk3817 4 роки тому +13

      @@user-bx7gd8uf8m sän choq jashayasyn mänım Kyrgz Türik qardosym Altai Turikdarından sangä choq sälem!

    • @altaiturk3817
      @altaiturk3817 4 роки тому +7

      @@user-bx7gd8uf8m säni tanımağımä mämnun oldum Alga Kyrgzshstän! 🇰🇬

    • @user-bx7gd8uf8m
      @user-bx7gd8uf8m 4 роки тому +8

      @@altaiturk3817 men da Altai turk birtuganym

  • @Cosmicmonkeyman
    @Cosmicmonkeyman 7 років тому +457

    A group of languages that traveled so far yet retain high mutual intelligibility between each other. From Siberia to Thrace of Europe the Turks have left a forever lasting linguistic legacy.

    • @-SUM1-
      @-SUM1- 7 років тому +50

      It's not distance that determines mutual intelligibility - it's time.

    • @alsamiyasfh4416
      @alsamiyasfh4416 7 років тому +8

      Cosmicmonkeyman no they invaded Thrace, Thrace was Greek until 1453!

    • @ekn_38
      @ekn_38 7 років тому +33

      The Wise Crusader Now it's turkish...Deal with it,the only way making Thrace and Anatolia Indo-european again is through genocide...

    • @djprojectus
      @djprojectus 7 років тому +7

      Emirkaan Baş Well,its not like turks do not deserve a little genocide themselves.

    • @ishakyldz5519
      @ishakyldz5519 7 років тому +8

      Wow, you really don't know history do you?

  • @rizaasghari5567
    @rizaasghari5567 5 років тому +168

    Where is Turkic Regions of Iran? South Azerbaijan, Qashqai yurt, khurasan, Iraq and Suriya Turkman lands?!

    • @e7384tttt
      @e7384tttt 5 років тому +5

      Aynen gardaş. Ama onları saymamış bağımsız değil diye

    • @leovinci5335
      @leovinci5335 4 роки тому

      @@RokoKaran lmfaooo 😂😂😂

    • @Sahin4604
      @Sahin4604 4 роки тому +7

      Sout Azerbaijan in my heart, Sizi Sevirem❤🇦🇿

    • @yurdagulkaya4085
      @yurdagulkaya4085 4 роки тому +4

      Hangi birini saysın, heryerdeyiz 😄

    • @Burak-gr4ee
      @Burak-gr4ee 3 роки тому +2

      @@e7384tttt Çuvaş, tatar, Altay, Uygur da bağımsız değil

  • @qwertylello
    @qwertylello 7 років тому +54

    2:28: It's a bird, it's a plane...

  • @duduchannel6729
    @duduchannel6729 7 років тому +577

    Let's prepare for the Greco-Turkish war in the comments

    • @riotergr1
      @riotergr1 7 років тому +58

      I don't see any reason for that...

    • @Ozigs52
      @Ozigs52 7 років тому +2

      Dudu Channel reserving...

    • @ShaizeOn1
      @ShaizeOn1 7 років тому +38

      Hell no! I love Greek culture and not gonna comment anything offensive as long as i saw any Greek person insulting and if i see one i'm gonna go and eat some snack, thinking why they did that...

    • @dianathescornofthemoon7762
      @dianathescornofthemoon7762 6 років тому

      //res

    • @headlander7119
      @headlander7119 6 років тому

      Alternatehistorymapper 420 no it isnt you idiot

  • @dianacampbell6336
    @dianacampbell6336 3 роки тому +82

    I am Kazakh and I am proud to be Turkic.

    • @user-xg9yg8kg7i
      @user-xg9yg8kg7i Рік тому +3

      I like turkic languages, but they all sounds same, like: dırlır ız kır bitrınfırdır.

    • @amjan
      @amjan Рік тому +2

      @@user-xg9yg8kg7i That's why they are a family.

    • @amjan
      @amjan Рік тому +7

      I wish more Kazakh actually spoke their beautiful langauge, and not Russian.

    • @user-xg9yg8kg7i
      @user-xg9yg8kg7i Рік тому +6

      @@amjan And another thing I like in turks, that despite historical conflicts and different politics they all love each other. As russian, I hope that one day slavs will forget about their conflicts and just live together in peace.

    • @cola_stealer5719
      @cola_stealer5719 Рік тому +2

      i am turk and i am also proud to be turkic

  • @khodearad4288
    @khodearad4288 5 років тому +204

    We are 30 million Turk in Iran

    • @Rogerrramjet1
      @Rogerrramjet1 4 роки тому +8

      Iranians think Azarbeyjanis are Aryan,,,,lol

    • @birvatandas2559
      @birvatandas2559 4 роки тому +13

      @Amethyst boşver aga uğraşmaya değmez cahil çomar hepsi

    • @birvatandas2559
      @birvatandas2559 4 роки тому +6

      @Amethyst ya harbi hiçbi şey bilmeden konuşuyolar sürekli az önce de şeyciler gördüm güya biz kürtleri eziyomuşuz falan. Yanlız kürtler türkiyede türklerle aynı hakka sahip ve ben kürdüm diyen insanı kimse de dışlamaz gayet normal bişey kürt olmak. Kürdistan kurmaya çalışan teröristleri öldürüyoruz zaten kürtlerin neredeyse çoğu da sevmiyo onları (türk kürt kardeşliğini bozmaya çalışan pkk yanlıları hariç) diyorum. Sanki bunlar yaşıyo odda batı medyası ne yalan haber verse inanırlar zaten gel bi türkiyede yaşa öyle konuş.

    • @MrRamazanLale2
      @MrRamazanLale2 4 роки тому +13

      @ᠮᠥᠩᠬᠡᠪᠠᠲᠤ ᠪᠠᠭᠠᠲᠤᠷ Azeris are turkic you fucking moron

    • @emrebayram1778
      @emrebayram1778 4 роки тому +8

      @ᠮᠥᠩᠬᠡᠪᠠᠲᠤ ᠪᠠᠭᠠᠲᠤᠷ cry you ignorant moron. Are u Kurdish? Or Greek?

  • @hanliu6043
    @hanliu6043 7 років тому +58

    WHERE IS QASHGAI

    • @kamranhuseynov3424
      @kamranhuseynov3424 5 років тому +7

      Eko Kıranyan
      Lan aptal mısın? >_<
      Kaşkaylar bir Türk toplumudur, günümüz İran'ın güney kısmında, Şiraz civarlarında yaşayan göçebe tayfalardır.
      "Nissan Qashgai" modelinin adı da Kaşkaylar'dan geliyor zaten, kendin İnternet'te baka bilirsin.

    • @zombifilmleriturkcedublaji8815
      @zombifilmleriturkcedublaji8815 5 років тому +4

      Qaşqaylar oğuzdur

    • @danim5881
      @danim5881 5 років тому +5

      Qashqai are a group of Oghuz Turkic speaking people that live in Iran. They’re part of the oghuz family, not separate.

    • @love_x_love6619
      @love_x_love6619 4 роки тому +3

      @@danim5881 Yes, that's true. Greetings from Peru, South America.

    • @YamamuraMaria0
      @YamamuraMaria0 3 роки тому +1

      @@zombifilmleriturkcedublaji8815 türkiye kuzey kıbrıs türkmenistan azerbaycan da oğuz boyu

  • @NeroPiroman
    @NeroPiroman 7 років тому +219

    What about yakut?

    • @wandererj4437
      @wandererj4437 7 років тому +16

      Chinese looking russian

    • @muhammetocak5042
      @muhammetocak5042 7 років тому +46

      Nero Piroman but they are literally turkish

    • @-SUM1-
      @-SUM1- 7 років тому +94

      Muhammet OCAK *Turkic

    • @kaanataonder806
      @kaanataonder806 7 років тому +12

      lap ja Actually, old Turkic looking people who migrated to the Siberia and speaking Turkic with heavy Russian influences. Also they are Christians.

    • @batrider322
      @batrider322 7 років тому +5

      Kaan Ata Önder and with heavy old mongolian influence. But majority are shamanists mixed with orthodox christianity.

  • @momino9024
    @momino9024 7 років тому +106

    You forgot tatars in Tatatrstan. While in Crimea the are minority, in the Tatatrstan the are majority, so it would be more correct to put them here on the map of 2017.

    • @user-py5gc5dn7t
      @user-py5gc5dn7t 7 років тому +6

      Western Anime Guys
      In Tatarstan there are only Volga bulgarians which were renamed tatars by Stalin

    • @ebuuuu2833
      @ebuuuu2833 6 років тому +3

      But you are talking Kıpchak language Like Tatars.. Just chuvash peoples speaking bulgar language.

    • @mihailnikoloff2554
      @mihailnikoloff2554 6 років тому +3

      Tatars are not turkic, they are mongolic.

    • @gorurtartar7947
      @gorurtartar7947 6 років тому +3

      Боян Михов
      Volga Bulgars are Chuvashes!!!
      "Чуваши потомки волжских булгар.Чуваши на Средней Волги жили задолго до нападения татар.Дунайские хаган-болгары и Кубанские чёрные болгары связаны с ними".
      А.А.Куник.
      "Чувашский язык, который так сильно отличается от остальных тюрко-татарских языков, пренадлежит народу, который со всей уверенностью следует рассматривать в качестве наследников волжских булгар".М.Рясянен.
      "Чуваши, пережив сложные этнокультурные метаморфозы, сохранили в основе волжско-булгарский язык".Р.Г.Кузеев.
      "Чуваши- племена волжских булгар".П.И Шафарик.
      "Чувашский язык- единственный остаток языка древних гуннов, то есть группы гуннов, которая называла себя булгарами". Г.Рамстедт.
      "Чуваши по языковому признаку- суть потомки волжских болгар". А.Кондратов.
      "Чувашский язык- единственный сохранившийся язык булгарской ветви". М.И.Скворцов.
      "Промежуточным народом между древними гуннами и сегодняшними чувашами являются булгары". Н.И.Ашмарин.
      Kazan Tatars are real Tatars!!!
      МАТВЕЙ МЕХОВСКИЙ
      ТРАКТАТ О ДВУХ САРМАТИЯХ
      DE DUABUS SARMATIIS
      Глава третья. О татарах козанских и татарах ногайских.
      Третья орда - козанских татар - названа так по замку Козан, стоящему над рекой Волгой у границ Московии, где они живут.
      Они произошли от главной татарской орды, а именно от чагадайских или заволжских татар, как и все другие татары.
      Эта Козанская орда имеет около 12 тысяч бойцов, а при необходимости, когда они созывают и других татар, они могут выставить до 30 тысяч воинов.

    • @mihailnikoloff2554
      @mihailnikoloff2554 6 років тому +5

      I agree. The Chuvash people are the true descendants of the Volga Bulgars. W
      While the Tatars are descendants of the Mongols who came during Chingiz Khan and conquered the Volga Bulgars.

  • @mertomerbozlak6220
    @mertomerbozlak6220 7 років тому +105

    you should add Turkic music in to your Turkic history videos . 😐

  • @aybala4127
    @aybala4127 5 років тому +229

    Freedom for Uyghur Turks of East Turkestan and Tibet from chinese fachism and racism

    • @MagnusVenter369
      @MagnusVenter369 5 років тому +14

      Freedom for Kurdistan and all nation under turkish occupation in Anatolia land

    • @ugurbasar5180
      @ugurbasar5180 5 років тому +17

      @@MagnusVenter369 I would say freedome for kurdistan too, if the Turks would suppress the Kurds, but they do not!!

    • @MagnusVenter369
      @MagnusVenter369 5 років тому +3

      @@ugurbasar5180 Somewhere they suppress them, somewhere not. Let's look back at history

    • @ugurbasar5180
      @ugurbasar5180 5 років тому +4

      @@MagnusVenter369 In the past the turks suppressed the Kurds (as a turk, i cant understand why!), but fortunately not today.

    • @MagnusVenter369
      @MagnusVenter369 5 років тому

      @@ugurbasar5180 Maybe

  • @mergenhudayberenov7562
    @mergenhudayberenov7562 4 роки тому +49

    Türkmenistan'dan Salamlar tüm kardeş Türkülere

  • @turkishpatriot9318
    @turkishpatriot9318 6 років тому +102

    Sakha is siberian Turks

    • @emrebayram1778
      @emrebayram1778 4 роки тому

      @Accelerated cry you ignorant

    • @TeymurKhan571
      @TeymurKhan571 4 роки тому

      Real history is unpleasant!
      Damn saka=/=sakha
      aminoapps.com/p/1udhdk just read it before giving some random stupid source read the blog I made

    • @YummYakitori
      @YummYakitori 4 роки тому +6

      @Kirman Selçuklularının Haritasını Arayan Dost
      Sakha/Yakuts are the most purebred Turkic people. They are descended from the Kurykan Tiele tribe of the Xiongnu confederacy in northern Mongolia / southern Siberia near the Turkic homeland. They migrated north along the Lena River from Lake Baikal to modern day Yakutia. They have 90-95% Y-DNA Haplogroup N

    • @ShamanOGHUZ3
      @ShamanOGHUZ3 4 роки тому +4

      and Tuvan Turks of Altai ; -)

    • @ps-zp6mr
      @ps-zp6mr 3 роки тому +2

      @@YummYakitori saka were Iranic It was Yuezhi who were Turkic

  • @user-vn7mg3pd8o
    @user-vn7mg3pd8o 7 років тому +38

    what about full history of the turks

    • @zedernaga9174
      @zedernaga9174 7 років тому +7

      there is already a video on that, not from ollie bye but still really well done.

    • @hasanceylan1889
      @hasanceylan1889 5 років тому

      ua-cam.com/video/_KmfhURrAuY/v-deo.html

    • @alexankhazarjian5299
      @alexankhazarjian5299 5 років тому +1

      Bood and crimes worse than the Nazis!!!

    • @boraatilla
      @boraatilla 5 років тому +7

      @@alexankhazarjian5299 have you ever read Rome tyrants on poor people oh I know your answer they are ancestor of modern italy and italy in europe so they are generally Christian

  • @jangelbrich7056
    @jangelbrich7056 2 роки тому +5

    What a simple and great way to display the spread of languages!

  • @lilsultan9206
    @lilsultan9206 5 років тому +13

    Beautiful Video 👌👍 Thank you and greetings from 🇹🇷❤️

  • @zengii1198
    @zengii1198 5 років тому +176

    Türkiye Oğuzlarından Tüm Türklere selam ola

  • @user-jm4qh4jc3i
    @user-jm4qh4jc3i 2 роки тому +7

    Old Turkic was alliance with Korea ancient country Goguryeo

  • @hexkobold9814
    @hexkobold9814 4 роки тому +7

    Uzbek and Uyghur didn't really split until the 19th Century. Also, you missed Sakha, Tuva, and smaller languages like Salar, Yugur, and Fuyu Kyrgyz. Salar is an Oghuz language spoken in Gansu, China. Yugur is a language spoken in Gansu split off from "Old Uyghur" which isn't shown here, and Fuyu Kyrgyz split off from Yenesei Kyrgyz / Khakas in Heilongjiang, China.

  • @0reozsgaming995
    @0reozsgaming995 3 роки тому +8

    I think it is safe to now regard Germany as the western extent of this family of languages. One in six Berliners speaks Turkish. Oh, and by the by Ollie Bye, your work and dedication has given us such fantastic videos. Absolutely brilliant. Thank you very much.

  • @watirMapping
    @watirMapping 7 років тому

    You really need to make more of these types of videos, this was awesome!

  • @ShamanOGHUZ3
    @ShamanOGHUZ3 4 роки тому +1

    Thanks for your efforts sir, you have done a pretty good job there.

  • @papazataklaattiranimam
    @papazataklaattiranimam 3 роки тому +7

    Where is the Tuoba Turkic?

  • @OliveOilFan
    @OliveOilFan 7 років тому +26

    Turkish and Kazakh here
    And also I'm waiting to read these comments

    • @beknurerzhanov1175
      @beknurerzhanov1175 6 років тому

      Sexy Tomato oghuz is old karahanid usuns?

    • @ShamanOGHUZ3
      @ShamanOGHUZ3 4 роки тому +1

      there is no war, they are mainly Kipchak, and Krygyz, Nogai. Turkish are Oghuz Turks and directly related with Kazakh Turks, we are all Turks. Not sure what you were waiting for ? : )

  • @xy4057
    @xy4057 5 років тому +1

    objective and informative, thanks for the summary of a big story

  • @cihanturan7398
    @cihanturan7398 2 роки тому +8

    I am proud to be a part of the Turkic family. (From Turkey)

  • @Kiiii642
    @Kiiii642 4 роки тому +2

    Рахмет! Керемет видео!

  • @patrickmc3827
    @patrickmc3827 7 років тому +43

    If you're now doing videos on spread of languages, please do the spread of German languages from the Teutonic Knights to 1945 because the German language once stretched from Alsace to the Volga River in Russia.

    • @jwkerr007
      @jwkerr007 7 років тому

      Do you have a source for that. I'm interested in reading about it.

    • @patrickmc3827
      @patrickmc3827 7 років тому

      This source right here. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ostsiedlung

    • @jwkerr007
      @jwkerr007 7 років тому

      Thanks.

    • @adidoki
      @adidoki 7 років тому +5

      Patrick Cunningham Are you dumb no Russian,Czech,Slovak,Greek,Swede,Polish,Belgian speaks german and is thus not considered the spread of a language but the stretch of it's short lived influence and if ollie bye included the places the turkic people had conquered it would be much bigger

    • @patrickmc3827
      @patrickmc3827 7 років тому +12

      Of course German never made up a majority in those countries, but after the Baltic crusades, there were mass settlements of noble families descended from the Teutonic Knights that made up no more than 5-10% of the population, but still held disproportionate political power and influence. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baltic_Germans en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Danube_Swabians en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transylvanian_Saxons en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volga_Germans

  • @Rogerrramjet1
    @Rogerrramjet1 5 років тому +1

    Thank you Ollie Bye, For making a video about Turks, thumbs up and subbed.

  • @altaiaila7098
    @altaiaila7098 5 років тому

    It could be narrated so clear in such a short time , congratulations

  • @uxaines8910
    @uxaines8910 3 роки тому +13

    Proud to be Kyrgyz, we are ancient nation.
    Thanks our ancestors, unknown warriors, who gave their lives for our nation. Tengri bless them.

    • @xanshen9011
      @xanshen9011 3 роки тому +1

      Over 2,200 years of history! Where are the huns? Where are the bulgars? Gone. Extinct. Meanwhile we Kyrgyz are a resilient people that are a continuation, *NOT* descendent.
      Even though our country has a corrupt government im still proud to call myself a Kyrgyz 🇰🇬💪

    • @uxaines8910
      @uxaines8910 3 роки тому

      @@xanshen9011 agree bro

    • @xanshen9011
      @xanshen9011 2 роки тому

      @Sir Ergin Ataman Sen tsıgansıŋ.

    • @RestlessWandererOriginal
      @RestlessWandererOriginal 2 роки тому

      You are mongolic, not turkic

    • @uxaines8910
      @uxaines8910 2 роки тому

      @@RestlessWandererOriginal ancient turks looked east asian. And even then there was no thing like mongolian, Indo-European, everybody mixed on the Great steppe, turks and mongolians mixed during Huns, Gokturks. And even some mongolian have more european appearance. You are just a dumb ass, who keeps believing in stupid stereotypes. And by the way, Kyrgyz are ancient turkic nation according to Qima Qian, in his work Records of Grand Historian, Kyrgyz exited during Huns. Now kyrgyz in Kyrgyz Republic are united tribes from different nations, like kyrgyz, naiman, kiphaks, mongols, khitans etc. And Kyrgyz people are in Manchuria, Siberia, Crimea, Central Asia. Bashkorts, Altais, Hakas, Tuvans, Sakhas,Mongols, Kazakhs have tribes named Kyrgyz.

  • @TheDragonHistorian
    @TheDragonHistorian 7 років тому +171

    inb4 the "go back to Mongolia" comments

    • @EgemenSahin
      @EgemenSahin 7 років тому +91

      A flock of disrespectful people. Then leave Canada, America, Australia, New Zealand, South Africa .

    • @anltoranoglu346
      @anltoranoglu346 7 років тому +1

      Where have I heard before it ?

    • @kenu665
      @kenu665 7 років тому +1

      Make them? The difference is that they have the power to send you back if they wanted to (and kill you if you resisted) - you don't! If it ever comes to that, do you think it's a fucking game where they care about stupid responses like "you should leave too"? Who is gonna make them if they make you go back? You would be wiped out for such ideas in the past. That is, before the Europeans/white people castrated themselves, that's how they acted, and you submitted yourself to their power. A fact!
      Europeans can annul all these concepts if they are left with chaos and in the midst of that chaos a radical leader emerges and says "hey, what about those Turks that sent a lot of people we didn't want and have been a nuisance to Europe for centuries"?
      Don't forget, these concepts of universal human rights and social justice is modern western inventions. Even the idea of occupation is a western concept. In the past, everyone just called it "yours"; meaning that what you could conquer was yours (it amuses me to hear from anti-western IS, Al-Qaida and such that USA must leave "occupied lands"). Back then, the one with the most power was supreme. Reverting to that mode is still a possibility for the so called civilized world. If the only thing you got in response to that is a western borrowed ignorant idea of equal outcomes then you're doomed.

    • @Ulix100
      @Ulix100 6 років тому

      The Dragon Historian 😂

    • @user-zr9ui7ot9t
      @user-zr9ui7ot9t 6 років тому +2

      go back to Mongolia

  • @franco2359
    @franco2359 7 років тому +1

    Nice vídeo, make more videos like this too please, it is very interesting to see the spread of groups of languages, do on the Italic languages too, and the Japonic languages.

  • @dariomoreno9267
    @dariomoreno9267 4 роки тому

    Great video 👍

  • @Tonnidas
    @Tonnidas 6 років тому +3

    Thanks for the video! It really gave me a picture of how these languages evolved because I had no idea before.

  • @danastyla9937
    @danastyla9937 7 років тому +313

    TÜRK OLANLAR +1

  • @lovepeace3069
    @lovepeace3069 5 років тому

    great video ... thanks

  • @Richard_is_cool
    @Richard_is_cool 7 років тому

    Fell asleep during intro. Good job mate.

    • @OllieBye
      @OllieBye  7 років тому

      I'll make a shorter one when I have time, just wait.

  • @MyRocktail
    @MyRocktail 7 років тому +115

    Free east Turkestan!On July 5, 2009 Chinese force killed thousands of peaceful Uyghur protestors in Urumqi, the Capital of East Turkestan

    • @maskelihrsz7063
      @maskelihrsz7063 6 років тому +1

      Salam kandaşım

    • @rusplia1088
      @rusplia1088 6 років тому +3

      装你妈外国人弱智东西

    • @user-tw7kq5ti8y
      @user-tw7kq5ti8y 5 років тому

      Çamaşır Suyu Bro u trippin 😂.

    • @MrPatlijohn
      @MrPatlijohn 5 років тому +1

      麤鬻彠爨軉灪 not funny tho

    • @goodnesswins4906
      @goodnesswins4906 5 років тому

      İ wanna save you but i am alone wolf .a lot of humans are selfish.i will save you brother/sister be patient.Allah bis menen

  • @dakilla228
    @dakilla228 7 років тому +15

    Where tatar and bashkor languages

  • @xbox_cheeto5338
    @xbox_cheeto5338 6 років тому

    this was really great, even if only text. you should make some on other language groups after your done with your history of the world project.

  • @YrossGaming
    @YrossGaming 7 років тому

    Nice video as allways ^^
    Could you make a video about spread of religions in the world ? Would be nice ^^

  • @abloodorange5233
    @abloodorange5233 4 роки тому +2

    That was extremely interesting. I was watching how the kazachs, Uzbeks and Turkmen all shuffled around in the central Asian region, displacing each other from different areas

    • @skullsforerlikkhansthrone9306
      @skullsforerlikkhansthrone9306 3 роки тому

      They didnt displace each other. They just spread and languages evolved differently. That is how linguistic evolution works. The "displaced" ones tended to go to europe.

  • @123TeeMee
    @123TeeMee 7 років тому +86

    10/10 would divide into oghur and orkhon again

  • @trexyit6655
    @trexyit6655 7 років тому

    Great vid

  • @bsinita_wokeone
    @bsinita_wokeone 7 років тому

    excellent production and beautiful❤💙 music🎶🎼 Ollie😁 keep up the good work✌👍.

  • @tasbykekerey1203
    @tasbykekerey1203 5 років тому +8

    1. Cuman = Kipchak.
    2. Yenesei Kyrgyz location was wrong.
    3. Where are the Naiman, Khereit, Merkit, Hongirat, Wuakh, Zhalair?

    • @user-nq6mh4jc4w
      @user-nq6mh4jc4w 3 роки тому

      3. all listed then were Mongol tribe

    • @WooBackBaby
      @WooBackBaby 3 роки тому

      @@user-nq6mh4jc4w Not Mongol Tribe İt İs Tatar Turkish Tribe

    • @user-tl4zn3wr5h
      @user-tl4zn3wr5h 2 роки тому +1

      2 . Yenesei Kyrgyz isn't wrong!

  • @suleimanthemagnificent1494
    @suleimanthemagnificent1494 2 роки тому +3

    The predecessors of Huihe were Xiongnu. Because, customarily, they ride high-wheeled carts. They were also called Gaoche during the Yuan Wei times, or also called Chile, mistakenly rendered as Tiele.
    - Xin Tangshu, 232
    Weishu, vol. 103 txt: "高車,[...] 其語略與匈奴同而時有小異,或云其先匈奴之甥也", tr: "The Gaoju, [...] their language and the Xiongnu's are similar though differ a little; or to say it differently, they are the sororal nephews/sons-in-laws of the Xiongnu”
    According to the Book of Wei, the Yuebans' language and customs were the same as the Gaoche, who were Turkic speakers. Yuebans(Weak Xiongnu) cut their hair and trimmed their ghee-smeared, sun-dried, glossy eyebrows evenly, and washed before meals three times everyday.
    Weishu, Vol. 102 "其風俗言語與高車同,而其人清潔於胡。俗剪髮齊眉,以醍醐塗之,昱昱然光澤,日三澡漱,然後飲食。"
    Chinese sources link the Tiele people and Ashina to the Xiongnu, According to the Book of Zhou and the History of the Northern Dynasties, the Ashina clan was a component of the Xiongnu confederation.
    Linghu Defen et al., Book of Zhou, Vol. 50. (in Chinese)
    Li Yanshou (李延寿), History of the Northern Dynasties, Vol. 99. (in Chinese)
    Uyghur Khagans claimed descent from the Xiongnu (according to Chinese history Weishu, the founder of the Uyghur Khaganate was descended from a Xiongnu ruler).
    The Gaoche are probably remnants of the ancient Red Di. Initially they had been called Dili. Northerners take them as Chile. Chinese take them as Gaoche Dingling. Their language, in brief, and Xiongnu [language] are the same yet occasionally there are small differences. Or one may say that they [Gaoche] are the junior relatives[18] of the Xiongnu in former times.
    The Gaoche migrate in search of grass and water. They dress in skins and eat meat. Their cattle and sheep are just like those of the Rouran, but the wheel of their carts are high and have very many spokes.
    - Weishu, 103
    The forebears of the Tiele belonged to those Xiongnu descendants, having the largest divisions of tribes. They occupied the valleys, and were scattered across the vast region west of the Western Sea [Black Sea]
    At the area north of the Duluo River, are the Bugu (僕骨), Tongluo (同羅), Weihe (韋紇),[17] Bayegu (拔也古), Fuluo (覆羅), which were all called Sijin (Irkin). Other tribes such as Mengchen (蒙陳), Turuhe (吐如紇), Sijie (斯結),[a] Hun (渾), Hu (斛), Xue (薛) (or Huxue) and so forth, also dwelled in this area. They had a 20,000 strong invincible army.
    [...]
    The names of these tribes differ, but all of them can be classified as Tiele. The Tiele do not have a master, but are subjected to the both Eastern and Western Tujue (Göktürks) respectively. They don't have a permanent residence, and move with the changes of grass and water. - Suishu, 84

  • @user-tx1uk6qc3o
    @user-tx1uk6qc3o 7 років тому +1

    You got it wrong at the Ta(r)tars.
    Tatar- tribe you were looking for
    Tartar- name for all mongol tribes used in west Europe

  • @MultiSciGeek
    @MultiSciGeek 7 років тому

    Great video. I am so happy this channel isn't as biased as most channels like this are, full of pseduohistory.

  • @uzpower
    @uzpower 5 років тому +31

    Uzbeks kind of Turks
    Amir Timur
    Bow down to Babur

  • @alishakury7321
    @alishakury7321 6 років тому +14

    you forgot to even mention Turks of iran. specially northwest- South Azerbaycan/central iran and south-west ( Kayı(Qashqayi/KashKayı) , Nefers , Biçaqçı ) and northeast-Khurasan. their population overall constitutes 40% of all irans population. please make a video including Turks of iran

    • @maryb6074
      @maryb6074 5 років тому

      There is no Turk in Iran. Some can speak the language as myself but don't consider ourselves as Turk. We are Iranian.

    • @kuykasamjoktar6191
      @kuykasamjoktar6191 5 років тому

      Mary B You are a turkish citizen of Iran. There are afghans,kurds,leks, tats,talyshs and other nations in Iran , they are proud of their ancestors. Everyone can live here and be iranian citizen.Don't deny your roots or ethnicity, dude.

    • @tahak.9275
      @tahak.9275 5 років тому +2

      @@maryb6074
      Iranian is nationality not ethnicity. You fucking idiot.
      More than %24 of iranians are Turks

    • @youtubeisabitch5758
      @youtubeisabitch5758 2 роки тому

      Only 16% are turks in iran

  • @ar910
    @ar910 7 років тому

    Nice bro !

  • @alejndraalmirowitsch4897
    @alejndraalmirowitsch4897 7 років тому +1

    i want this texture on the next history of the world

  • @hydrocarbonartichoke
    @hydrocarbonartichoke 7 років тому +65

    where is the anti-turkish sentiment in the comments?

  • @empirehistory4055
    @empirehistory4055 3 роки тому +5

    ‘’The History’’ was written by the Largest Empires such as British, Mongol, Great Selcuq, Ottoman, Russia, Spanish, Ummayad, GokTurk Khaganate, Khazar Khaganate, Roman, Timurid etc. They had built the world map, while others were living under their rules. Possible ways of measuring their size include area, population, economy, and power. They had consistent power and strategy to spread across the Continents and huge areas and build a system to manage countries and its people. There are many nationalities, unfortunately, who had been disappeared as a result of the war. They are those, who resisted without having compatible capability and resources. BCE (Before the Common Era) etc that people share today, are Purely Myth and subjective views of some individuals. Last 1000 years still may have more relevant and accurate information, which still being interpreted by people. However, sounds like only Turkish Empires/ Dynasty has left huge Turkish countries who is in current world map. They are Turkey, Kazakhstan, Kirgizstan, Turkmenistan, Azerbaijan, Uzbekistan

  • @mihribangencturk8141
    @mihribangencturk8141 5 років тому

    Nice video

  • @papazataklaattiranimam
    @papazataklaattiranimam 3 роки тому +4

    The predecessors of Huihe were Xiongnu. Because, customarily, they ride high-wheeled carts. They were also called Gaoche during the Yuan Wei times, or also called Chile, mistakenly rendered as Tiele.
    - Xin Tangshu, 232
    only the Turkic Gaoju origin of the Hephthalites should be retained as indicative of their primary ethnicity.[82]
    Weishu, vol. 103 txt: "高車,[...] 其語略與匈奴同而時有小異,或云其先匈奴之甥也", tr: "The Gaoju, [...] their language and the Xiongnu's are similar though differ a little; or to say it differently, they are the sororal nephews/sons-in-laws of the Xiongnu
    "
    According to the Book of Wei, the Yuebans' language and customs were the same as the Gaoche, who were Turkic speakers. Yuebans(Weak Xiongnu) cut their hair and trimmed their ghee-smeared, sun-dried, glossy eyebrows evenly, and washed before meals three times everyday.[18][19]
    Chinese sources link the Tiele people and Ashina to the Xiongnu, According to the Book of Zhou and the History of the Northern Dynasties, the Ashina clan was a component of the Xiongnu confederation.[84][85]
    Uyghur Khagans claimed descent from the Xiongnu (according to Chinese history Weishu, the founder of the Uyghur Khaganate was descended from a Xiongnu ruler).[86]
    Both the 7th-century Chinese History of the Northern Dynasties[87] and the Book of Zhou,[88] an inscription in the Sogdian language, report the Göktürks to be a subgroup of the Xiongnu.[89][90]
    Tiele are originally Xiongnu's splinter stocks. As Tujue are strong and prosperous, all Tiele districts (郡) are divided and scattered, the masses gradually dwindled and weakened. Until the beginning of Wude [era], there have been Xueyantuo, Qibi, Huihe, Dubo, Guligan, Duolange, Pugu, Bayegu, Tongluo, Hun, Sijie, Huxue, Xijie, Adie, Baixi, etc. scattered in the northern wastelands.
    - Jiu Tangshu, 199, lower

    • @editlys
      @editlys 2 роки тому

      Be mübarek 4 ayrı videoda srni görüyorum.

  • @muhtesemsiyanur
    @muhtesemsiyanur 5 років тому +9

    1:17 *_gotta go fast_*

  • @Roel93
    @Roel93 7 років тому +5

    I wish you had done it with usual colors even if they wouldn't be accurate.

  • @drfmkaya
    @drfmkaya 4 роки тому

    Though there are minor mistakes, the video is mostly accurate. Thanks.

  • @boryanlazarov1475
    @boryanlazarov1475 5 років тому +1

    Hey, Ollie Bye, it looks very confused from Bulgarian point of view. First, it's strange the way Bulgar and Khazar appear from Onogur at the same as though they lived together in so far. We were much earlier there together with the Huns and Avars!!! Then Khazars came and probably their language mixed to be found similar some time later on.
    Second, we moved to the Balkans in the 5th, 6th century, where is that?
    Then there is a wrong representation of the Bulgarians moving very early to Volga, at the time we were still near the Caspian and the Azov. After that at least three different branches are missing, two in Balkans, one in Panonia etc. It's really weird to show us in the far north in the mid 7th century when our capital was on the Azov sea!?
    Balkan Cumans totally missing!? : ): )
    Please correct that if possible. I personally like the way you added the Chuvashian, but it may be just a guess : )

  • @Anskurshaikh
    @Anskurshaikh 7 років тому +13

    Please Do History of Indian languages as well. Theres so many languages!

    • @mongolchiuud8931
      @mongolchiuud8931 5 років тому

      Abu Dabegave varaseed daradata garajuki dookie nam poon poon curry spoon Punjabi crabbe Patty!

  • @asimansaidzadeh6012
    @asimansaidzadeh6012 5 років тому +2

    Besides about 10 mln native speakers in Azerbaijan, Azerbaijani is spoken by around 20-30 mln people in the north of Iran. These people are also Azerbaijani Turks.

  • @emreardic1670
    @emreardic1670 7 років тому

    That video obtains some good information but you could have expressed these info better if there would be some classifications between these dialects. For instance, you could do it with different colours.

  • @TheHistoricalScenarios
    @TheHistoricalScenarios 7 років тому +1

    Thanks Man ! I'm Turk and I'm glad to see that :)

  • @danieljones9463
    @danieljones9463 6 років тому +4

    Thank you for this beautiful presentation, Ollie Bye. The map is beautiful and the movements upon it well illustrate the Evolution of languages...in this case the Turkic languages and dialects.
    Could you build a presentation like this that illustrates the Evolution of the Persian languages? I ask because of the controversy that is ongoing about these two language systems.
    I believe they both have common roots, way back in time, in the Altai Region...and before that in the Mesopotamia of the Nodites (referred to in the "Urantia Book") the Gardens Of Eden and the Origin Homelands of all Humanity near India.
    I understand that the further back you go in tracking these languages, the harder it is to be accurate about them. But it might be at least entertaining, to build one of your composite masterpieces incorporating the "Big Picture" that goes back, say, sixty thousand years? Of course, you would have to include the Neanderthal (Andonite) tongues too. This might be a fun project for you.

  • @oyonggofomocci2078
    @oyonggofomocci2078 6 років тому +13

    wheres yakut and dolgan... i want some yakut yakut

  • @orkunyucel3095
    @orkunyucel3095 4 роки тому

    Great video. But I dont understand what is the Khaka?? Did you mean Sakha(Yakut) Language or Khakas(not plural) Language. İf you purposed to say Khakas, you didn't mention about Sakha(Yakut) Language that is one of the oldest Turkic Languages. Sakhas(Yakuts) who live in northeast of Siberia are the most northeast part of Turkic Languages. Thanks for this video, I love it.

  • @iKrivetko
    @iKrivetko 7 років тому +1

    Some important ones are missing. Tatar has well over 5 million speakers, for example.

    • @CrapeCraft
      @CrapeCraft 7 років тому

      I think for some reason it's called Tartar and it is included in Russia/Ukraine.

    • @iKrivetko
      @iKrivetko 7 років тому

      The language spoken in Crimea (that's what the "Tartar" in the video probably refers to) is called Crimean Tatar and it's very different from Tatar spoken in Tatarstan. I'm pretty sure they aren't even mutually intelligible.

  • @nunciosidereo4070
    @nunciosidereo4070 7 років тому +8

    your intro is not too long.

  • @joshfish2
    @joshfish2 2 роки тому +3

    To think, they went even further historically, in terms of conquest and expansion! Central and Eastern Europe, to North Africa, parts of East Africa, India, parts of China...

  • @Hrolfgard
    @Hrolfgard 7 років тому +1

    I spent the first full minute of this video wondering where Lake Baikal was

  • @SaydamNomad
    @SaydamNomad 4 роки тому

    The idea is good, but the execution leaves much to be desired. Starting with the description in the beginning: "as far east as the fringers of Mongolia" - you meant Eastern Siberia, right? Mongolia is not a Turkic region.
    Lots of languages are omitted. By 2019 it should have been presented also by Tatars and Chuvash (almost right next to Chuvash), Azerbaijans, Kymyks, Karachays, Balkars in the Caucasus, you've also forgotten to put Tuvans near Altay. And Khaka should have been evolved into Sakha.

  • @Rogerrramjet1
    @Rogerrramjet1 5 років тому +10

    From a broad historical perspective, the History of Central Eurasia has been described as the " conflict between steppe and sown " referring to the tensions between the nomads of the steppe and the agriculturalist living on the land sown with seeds. When the sedentary kingdoms were powerful, and trade was profitable, the nomads would frequently become willing trading partners. On the other hand, if the sedentary states(Indo Europeans) were weak, a charismatic khaghan arose in the steppes, or natural or political disasters forced the nomads to the verge of starvation, the nomads would often attack, and occasionally overwhelm sedentary civilizations. The history of Central Eurasia is in part the story of repeated waves of nomads attacking- with varying degrees of success, the sedentary states of China, India, the Near East, and Europe.

  • @p00bix
    @p00bix 7 років тому +6

    20 seconds is far too long an intro for a 4 minute video.

  • @ArktourosUltorMaximus7600
    @ArktourosUltorMaximus7600 2 роки тому +4

    0:51 Yes I agree that the Huns were Turkic peoples, however it is not known whether they were Oghur Turks.

  • @KarausTheReTeller
    @KarausTheReTeller 6 років тому +4

    Tartar language was spoken in *from Eastern Europe to Caspian sea, not only in Crimea.* Kıpçak langauge was spoken in *from Crimea to Caucasus and to Chuvash area, Kıpçak language still living with Bashkir and Kazan Tatar language.* Actually Tartar language is a Kipchak language too, here: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kipchak_languages#Classification

  • @turkiyeyoruk9284
    @turkiyeyoruk9284 5 років тому +7

    Proud to be an Oghuz Nomad Turkmen !

    • @ugurtekeoglu6007
      @ugurtekeoglu6007 5 років тому

      Türkmenistan göcmeni Me to ;)

    • @alexankhazarjian5299
      @alexankhazarjian5299 5 років тому

      A homeless bloodthirsty psychopathic beast !

    • @boraatilla
      @boraatilla 5 років тому +1

      @@alexankhazarjian5299 scared right?

    • @naberkanka2489
      @naberkanka2489 Рік тому

      @@alexankhazarjian5299 Homelesses are armenoids after 1915

  • @Atlas-xz3us
    @Atlas-xz3us 7 років тому

    What did you use to animate all of this?

  • @David_Sirovsky
    @David_Sirovsky Місяць тому

    What language did the population of Central Asia speak before 700 BC?

  • @orbbirb
    @orbbirb 2 роки тому +3

    Love all! From Azerbaijan/Turkey/Iran!🇦🇿🇹🇷🇮🇷!

  • @kidtsunami3993
    @kidtsunami3993 7 років тому +16

    Kipchak became a language of Golden horde, and the descendant khannates (Crimean and Kazan tatars, Nogai horde, Kazakh khannate, etc) languages.. appeared from Kipchak, and turkic languages like Kazakh, Tatar, Nogai includes in Kipchak group of turkic languages. so and video isn't 100 percent accurate, in video Kazakh appeared instead of qarluq, which is wrong. because kazakh divided from Kipchak. Qarluq was a basis for so called "Shagatai" language, which in its turn became ancestor language for modern Uzbek and Uighur. I think dividing so called Cuman from Kipchak, is not necessary, because Cuman it's just a European name for Kipchaks. anyway.. thanks for great job!

    • @doskhanzhakeshov3462
      @doskhanzhakeshov3462 7 років тому +10

      Yereshev Dauletiyar durys Biz Kazaktar Kipshaktan taradik!Bul videoda Qarluk deidi))Qarluk ol:Uzbek,Uyghur

    • @StefanDruga16
      @StefanDruga16 5 років тому +1

      Didn't Kazakh come from Kyrgyz?

  • @enginylmaz3068
    @enginylmaz3068 5 років тому

    Thanks Ollie Bye

  • @lucioagelvis2134
    @lucioagelvis2134 3 роки тому +1

    In the Seljuk period plates persons depicted though probably mixed, look predominantly Mongoloid (east Asian)

  • @arizaliit
    @arizaliit 6 років тому +5

    Wrong. Seljuk were already in eastern Anatolia around 1050. By 1200s Turks were drinking Tea in symrna. According to your map they were still in Iran around 1250 lol. Even ottoman was founded in 1299 couple hundred jams far from Istanbul. Get your facts right before posting

    • @mongolchiuud8931
      @mongolchiuud8931 5 років тому

      Seljuks we're mongoloid that's how I know ottomans are not real Turks.

  • @turkoglu1122
    @turkoglu1122 6 років тому +87

    Benim Türk dillerini anlamamaq faizim şu
    Azerbaycanca 0% ( Ana dilim )
    Gagauzca 3%
    Gaşgayça 1%
    Türkçe 2%
    Türkmence 4%
    Özbekçe 6%
    Uyğurca 9%
    Kazakça 10%
    Kırgızca 11%
    Tatar , Başqır 9%
    Kumuk , Nogay , Balkar 10%
    Altayca 25%
    Tıvaca 35%
    Şor , Xakas 30%
    Saxa , Dolgan 55 %
    Çuvaş 50%

    • @naturalselector8938
      @naturalselector8938 5 років тому +6

      @joseph eagle Actually Uighur is one of the closest to Turkish.

    • @lorejderi9388
      @lorejderi9388 5 років тому +2

      @@kultigin1998 kardeşim bu konuştuğu şekil azerice senin beynin türkçeyi sadece bu şekilde (türkiye türkcesi ile) gördüğünden komik buluyorsun

    • @kultigin1998
      @kultigin1998 5 років тому

      @@lorejderi9388 Komik demeyelim yanlış anlaşılabilir. Sempatik buldum yalnızca.

    • @kultigin1998
      @kultigin1998 5 років тому +2

      @@lorejderi9388 Bu arada Azerice değil hocam Azerbaycan Türkçesi.

    • @lorejderi9388
      @lorejderi9388 5 років тому

      @@kultigin1998 aslında daha doğru olarak "Azerce"

  • @blooome_
    @blooome_ 7 років тому

    Do a history of Colorado. Include the native tribes, countries and present day.

  • @AtillaTheGreat
    @AtillaTheGreat 7 років тому

    I love your work! 😄

  • @alihandemir2872
    @alihandemir2872 6 років тому +24

    GREAT NATİON ! 🏹🏇🏻🏹🏇🏻

  • @christopherellis2663
    @christopherellis2663 7 років тому +3

    would've enjoyed it more if the proper Turkish orthography were used. ğıçəqx etc.

  • @HuckleberryHim
    @HuckleberryHim 7 років тому

    Ollie, isn't Yenisei related to Na-Dene, not Turkic?

  • @keeseman
    @keeseman 7 років тому

    So why did the language spread stop in 1600?