The Untamed || Book VS Adaptation

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 4 лют 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 11

  • @Paula-133
    @Paula-133 9 місяців тому +14

    The Untamed is a treasure and masterpiece. They did an excellent job of working around the censors in China. It was more satisfying to me because their relationship seemed real and mature. It just seems real and deep. It is a wonder it ever got made and shown at all let alone being so realistic emotionally. Everyone is so gorgeous and talented. OST is incredibly beautiful. The is the OST, BGM, and a character OST in which All the characters have their own songs. I love the cultural differences. I loved it! It is now my favorite fantasy. Thank You reviewing it.

    • @oceansbooksandstuff
      @oceansbooksandstuff  9 місяців тому +1

      Love your points on their relationship. They did do a great job with it!

  • @SammyExperiencingTheWorld
    @SammyExperiencingTheWorld 10 місяців тому +6

    i love all the adaptation of the mdzs and thank you for the review. The head band thing was not because wwx did not wanted to part with him but because those strings would attack anyone who was not from the lan clan. wangji was not attacked because he was wearing the headband. wangji had to tie the headband to stop the attacks from the strings. Also because i watched The Untamed first i did not catch up with the golden core thing. I did not connect the dots and the reveal had me gutted at that time.

    • @oceansbooksandstuff
      @oceansbooksandstuff  10 місяців тому +2

      Yeah, you're right about the headband thing. I just think if they hadn't had that scene at all, they wouldn't have had to break the sacredness of the headband! But I'm glad you still had a good reaction for the golden core when you read it!

  • @nabilahalshari7880
    @nabilahalshari7880 10 місяців тому +3

    So agree with you on the headband thing. The Untamed, at least when it comes to Wangxian's relationship, has a bit of an instant gratification problem. I understand that most fans are not bothered by it as they see it as the creators getting around censorship, and that's fine. But the donghua also has the censorship problem and they were able to follow the vibe of the novel better.

    • @oceansbooksandstuff
      @oceansbooksandstuff  10 місяців тому

      Yes. I think that's why I like the last half of the show so much better than the first half.

  • @PriyadarshiniChowdhury
    @PriyadarshiniChowdhury 3 місяці тому +4

    I think the best part about the untamed is how they managed to preserve the love. I know the difference between a good bromance and actual love, the untamed definitely endorsed the latter theme. it seemed mature, and realistic. but well, I guess there's only so much censorship will allow us.

  • @akshitasingh-wc6gw
    @akshitasingh-wc6gw 10 місяців тому +4

    I watched untamed and read the novel too..& I think I did good that I watched untamed before reading the novels becoz during reading i have a good imagination of the character with their faces , that gives me a good feeling , infact about the intimate scenes which I didn't see in the drama I get a good imagination of that too😅😅 ...
    Long story short it was good to watch the drama before reading the novel , ..., it gives a satisfactory feeling you know ...

    • @akshitasingh-wc6gw
      @akshitasingh-wc6gw 10 місяців тому

      By the way could you plz recommend me something similar novels which has adapted drama tooo...

    • @oceansbooksandstuff
      @oceansbooksandstuff  10 місяців тому +1

      @@akshitasingh-wc6gw I think Heaven's Official Blessings has something, but I haven't watched or seen any of them yet!