Chapters: Have I Told You Lately: 0:00 Upstream: 3:27 Canon in D: 7:09 Three Generations: 13:20 She’s Always A Woman: 16:21 Windless (Ice Cream Truck Song): 19:42 How Deep Is Your Love: 23:21 Will You Come Back My Love: 27:27 Ever Changing Times: 29:36 Till There Was You: 33:38 Make It With You: 35:52 After The Love Has Gone: 40:06 The World I Know: 43:43 You Don’t Know Me: 47:29 Say What’s In My Heart: 51:10 If We Fall In Love Tonight: 54:04 Ill Never Fall In Love Again: 56:43 Ill Remember: 59:26 When Sunny Gets Blue: 1:03:29 Just Once: 1:08:26 Every Breath You Take: 1:12:48 Until You Come Back To Me: 1:16:20 Bad Sneakers: 1:19:20 Sarah Smile: 1:22:35 Never Can Say Goodbye: 1:25:50 Carey: 1:28:38 Don’t Let The Sun Catch You Crying: 1:31:39 Whenever You’re On My Mind: 1:34:29 Desafinado: 1:37:07 Julia: 1:42:00 Funny How Time Slips Away: 1:44:36 Black Cow: 1:48:29 Goin Out of My Head: 1:53:06
This is surprising given that I only know the taliercio footage recording music on the Plaza on the fateful day. Maybe they relied on witnesses and contacts at muzak to find most of the music.
@@marcofreyssonnet9673 there's an FBI sound recording from the marriott hotel cafe when the first plane hit. when they exit through the plaza, you can hear the plaza music. the song was "How Can You Mend a Broken Heart".
Have i told you lately, Three generations, Shes always a woman, Windless and How deep is your love were all played on 9/11 after the second plane and "Till there was you" was playing seconds before the south tower collapsed. After the love has gone was playing before the first plane hit, the song playing when the first plane is unknown.
Yep. There is footage from the Greenhouse Cafe in the plaza right after the first plane hit, and that song was playing. It was totally quite because everyone had just fled. So the song is really the only thing hauntingly playing. Song still creeps me out because of that. There is footage of that in the NatGeo "One Day in America" documentary.
@@DragScopeDevinsong that was playing when the first tower was hit was probably “I’ll never fall in love again” than after it’s confirmed that it’s how can you mend a broken heart from the mcardle tape
imagine if the Towers still stood, and they added to these masterpieces with more modern songs from the 90s and 2000s, it would've been beautiful I'm sure!!
Bad Sneakers was always a household classic in our home .. and having so many great moments to that song and black cow ..now knowing ,im sure some people faintly could hear these jazzy songs before their end , there is just no words for it
I think for me I love this music because you don't really hear it anymore. Once stores found out that getting the customer hype tended to make them buy more, they did away with it (probably at the cost of our sanity). Maybe we conditions ourselves especially now for the opposite to be true now
I'm obsessed with Dancing Queen and Every Breath You Take. I think Dancing Queen isn't confirmed to have played at the plaza, but it definitely gives me carefree vacation vibes and it just fits so well. And Every Breath You Take is just bittersweet to me. It sounds hopeful, nostalgic, yet melancholic, just like the original.
How Deep is your Love lyrics: Cause we're living in a World of fools, breaking us down, when they should all just let us be, We belong to you and me. I believe in you, know the door to my very soul. You're the light in my deepest, darkest hour. You're my savior when I fall.
@@WorldTradeCenterMuzakCommunity Was that verified by just the Taliercio footage and the McArdle Audio, or are there other sources as well? I believe you though
I cannot hear that cover of "Never Can Say Goodbye." This version is way more sadder than the Original song. Side note, Michael Jackson was actually due to be at the World Trade Center. But missed the meeting because he overslept after talking to his family. Imagine how eerie that song would of been if he was there.
I wonder which song was playing when the first plane hit. Actually now that I think about it: if we were able to find out the track list/order of songs it was playing on 9/11 we could deduce which song was playing then since we know what time “She’s Always A Woman” was heard from the Jack Tallerico footage.
I don’t think so as after 20 odd years of continuous service I think that the order might have changed as new songs are added and some old ones removed formats change and so on. Then agen a company that is running there systems the same way for over 20 years would also probably not touched the medium of play for probably longer. I believe that the music is played at random using a combination of a computer and multiple burned cds
It doesn't work like that, the songs were chosen at random so other than the play log from that day, or footage revealing the song, there is no way to prove it, there are rumors of what it is, such as I'll Never Fall in Love Again, but right now nothing is confirmed
They found Audio from a FBI Agent who had a wire on the day. You can hear him in the Mall before the attack happened. I listened to it today. It was very surreal.
Kinda scary that 27:27 would be the last recorded song on 9/11 just before the south tower callapsed and (correct me if im wrong) the entire speaker system cutting out from the callapse
You know, some of these song i remember being in the eastside jumper plaza video. While some of thr skbgs i dont remember at all being included in the available footage, ive seen.
So I walk up on high And I step to the edge To see my world below The chorus lyrics to "The World I know". And, if you've seen the video for it, it's even more poignant. And to think, it likely played during the event that morning. Heartbreaking.
@@mevoycontumamaxdTo w sumie jedyna piosenka, którą znam z tej listy. Temat Muzak to dla mnie był pewien rabbit hole i nie spodziewałem się utworu z mojej playlisty wśród nich.
Charles Michael Brotman made Three Generations but we have now confirmed that was not the song heard on 9/11, it is instead How Can You Mend A Broken Heart by Lenny Moore. We discovered the mistake on November 3rd, 2023
From what I know, only a few of them, like from the airport muzak, though it includes the new songs unincluded in this video since this was uploaded months prior to it being found.
I think it's because when people were trying to identify it from the JT 9/11 plaza footage, a segment, the twinkling part in the middle was recorded and a bunch of people said it sounded like an ice cream truck so they nicknamed it the ice cream truck song
@@alvenhchanne we don’t have the original copy unfortunately, only the one recorded off the satellite since She’s Always a Woman was removed around 2010.
The last recorded song was (Will You) Come Back My Love, but that was about 15 minutes before the collapse, so anywhere from 4-7 songs played after that
our group is working on such a project for people to see the original tapes the songs are from in one spot, most can be found on the channel "Pre 9/11" there are also many clips there that we have not confirmed yet
Chapters:
Have I Told You Lately: 0:00
Upstream: 3:27
Canon in D: 7:09
Three Generations: 13:20
She’s Always A Woman: 16:21
Windless (Ice Cream Truck Song): 19:42
How Deep Is Your Love: 23:21
Will You Come Back My Love: 27:27
Ever Changing Times: 29:36
Till There Was You: 33:38
Make It With You: 35:52
After The Love Has Gone: 40:06
The World I Know: 43:43
You Don’t Know Me: 47:29
Say What’s In My Heart: 51:10
If We Fall In Love Tonight: 54:04
Ill Never Fall In Love Again: 56:43
Ill Remember: 59:26
When Sunny Gets Blue: 1:03:29
Just Once: 1:08:26
Every Breath You Take: 1:12:48
Until You Come Back To Me: 1:16:20
Bad Sneakers: 1:19:20
Sarah Smile: 1:22:35
Never Can Say Goodbye: 1:25:50
Carey: 1:28:38
Don’t Let The Sun Catch You Crying: 1:31:39
Whenever You’re On My Mind: 1:34:29
Desafinado: 1:37:07
Julia: 1:42:00
Funny How Time Slips Away: 1:44:36
Black Cow: 1:48:29
Goin Out of My Head: 1:53:06
Thanks! Listening to this not to gloat but to remember. This should have never happened! RIP. They were gone, too soon
We got Soul Food To Go now!
@@polotiks-wx mmmm I probably should make another successor video, compiling everything.
Can these songs be found anywhere outside of UA-cam on any other streaming platforms?
@@justowil7165 Mood Harmony
Almost the 1 year anniversary of this masterpiece
Now it is the 1 year anniversary,THROW YOUR PARTY HATS ON!!! 🎉🎉🎉
It’s actually fucking crazy how many songs have been found from what little available footage there is
True!
This is surprising given that I only know the taliercio footage recording music on the Plaza on the fateful day. Maybe they relied on witnesses and contacts at muzak to find most of the music.
Not all these songs are from 9/11, most actually are from 2000 and 1999
So fffgg true man. I d like my kids to share this. But .. ........ .
@@marcofreyssonnet9673 there's an FBI sound recording from the marriott hotel cafe when the first plane hit. when they exit through the plaza, you can hear the plaza music. the song was "How Can You Mend a Broken Heart".
Bro she’s always a woman makes me cry sometimes because of how calm it is
Same for me with how deep is your love
theres one video of it playing after the planes hit and its really haunting its such a peaceful song happening in the middle of all that
have you got a link?
ua-cam.com/video/ECgPnpGo_Lo/v-deo.html&ab_channel=VitorMathews@@fuwapanzer
@@fuwapanzerit’s in this video bro
Have i told you lately, Three generations, Shes always a woman, Windless and How deep is your love were all played on 9/11 after the second plane and "Till there was you" was playing seconds before the south tower collapsed. After the love has gone was playing before the first plane hit, the song playing when the first plane is unknown.
😢makes me think of all those people thay died that day. They just were working like everyone else around the world. They never deserved to die. So sad
I just wish, someone at PA HR would get a petition approved to play all of these songs at Liberty Park and the New World Trade Center Plaza.
I heard HDIYL playing in a different version then the original plaza music in the Oculus Hub when i went a month before september 2023
"She's always a woman" song is like the credits title song of the whole WTC. That's how their movie ended...
Yep. There is footage from the Greenhouse Cafe in the plaza right after the first plane hit, and that song was playing. It was totally quite because everyone had just fled. So the song is really the only thing hauntingly playing. Song still creeps me out because of that.
There is footage of that in the NatGeo "One Day in America" documentary.
@@DragScopeDevin - Yeah... That's really sad and at the same time thrilling.
@@DragScopeDevinsong that was playing when the first tower was hit was probably “I’ll never fall in love again” than after it’s confirmed that it’s how can you mend a broken heart from the mcardle tape
So, that was not only me who had that weird feeling that the WTC is saying "goodbye" to us by playing this song on Plaza?..
Playing this through my integrated tube amp right now.
The unknown muzak hero
the Canon in D is like the calm before the storm
imagine if the Towers still stood, and they added to these masterpieces with more modern songs from the 90s and 2000s, it would've been beautiful I'm sure!!
''Will You Comeback my Love'' was the final song played on the plaza before the South Tower fell.
That's so haunting. 😢
Source?
That’s only the last recorded song. We don’t know for sure what was the very final song that was played since there is no record of that.
Bad Sneakers was always a household classic in our home .. and having so many great moments to that song and black cow ..now knowing ,im sure some people faintly could hear these jazzy songs before their end , there is just no words for it
I think for me I love this music because you don't really hear it anymore. Once stores found out that getting the customer hype tended to make them buy more, they did away with it (probably at the cost of our sanity). Maybe we conditions ourselves especially now for the opposite to be true now
I'm obsessed with Dancing Queen and Every Breath You Take. I think Dancing Queen isn't confirmed to have played at the plaza, but it definitely gives me carefree vacation vibes and it just fits so well. And Every Breath You Take is just bittersweet to me. It sounds hopeful, nostalgic, yet melancholic, just like the original.
Loving the song “til there was you”. It hits nostalgia in a very warm way.
AND HE STRIKES AGAIN, WTC MUSIC!
I’m a she, actually
@@TopTradeMuzak so I've been lied to my whole life 💀
@@TopTradeMuzak sorry SHE!
@@yhfhdcf Well, she's always a woman
@@yhfhdcf1 year later lol but same
Amazing collection! Love from China
I can’t believe there aren’t more people mentioning how “The World I Know” is eerily SO perfect for that day..
와.... 진짜 사람들이 불에 타고 땅바닥으로 떨어져서 처참한 모습으로 변해가는 과정에 이런 느낌있는 재즈 음악이... 너무 충격적이다
How Deep is your Love lyrics: Cause we're living in a World of fools, breaking us down, when they should all just let us be, We belong to you and me.
I believe in you, know the door to my very soul. You're the light in my deepest, darkest hour. You're my savior when I fall.
Nice touch doing SAAW, Windless, HDIYL back to back to back like on that day.
Thanks! It was @w4sp408’s idea.
@@TopTradeMuzak Do you happen to have the clip that Canon in D was heard in if it exists?
Every song from 1 to 8 was played on 9/11, they are all in the order of which they were played.
@@WorldTradeCenterMuzakCommunity Was that verified by just the Taliercio footage and the McArdle Audio, or are there other sources as well? I believe you though
@@TheAbele992 they were heard on both the McArdle tape and Jack Taliercio’s footage.
Thank you so much for having the full list 🙏. Never forget and never forgive.
Chrześcijanie zawsze powinni przebaczać
I would take this over the pop garbage playing at any modern day commercial establishment any day.
Not possible anymore, the heyday of capitalism is in the past at least in the U.S. and this music belongs there
I cannot hear that cover of "Never Can Say Goodbye." This version is way more sadder than the Original song.
Side note, Michael Jackson was actually due to be at the World Trade Center. But missed the meeting because he overslept after talking to his family. Imagine how eerie that song would of been if he was there.
Can we please get the playlist that was used at the plaza during christmas time?
Sure!
thank you for this
Perfect Studying Music
@@TheAbele992 definitely.
I wonder which song was playing when the first plane hit. Actually now that I think about it: if we were able to find out the track list/order of songs it was playing on 9/11 we could deduce which song was playing then since we know what time “She’s Always A Woman” was heard from the Jack Tallerico footage.
I don’t think so as after 20 odd years of continuous service I think that the order might have changed as new songs are added and some old ones removed formats change and so on. Then agen a company that is running there systems the same way for over 20 years would also probably not touched the medium of play for probably longer. I believe that the music is played at random using a combination of a computer and multiple burned cds
@@qmacaulay69 I see
From what I've heard people say it was "How Deep is Your Love" which was the last song to be played
It doesn't work like that, the songs were chosen at random so other than the play log from that day, or footage revealing the song, there is no way to prove it, there are rumors of what it is, such as I'll Never Fall in Love Again, but right now nothing is confirmed
They found Audio from a FBI Agent who had a wire on the day. You can hear him in the Mall before the attack happened. I listened to it today. It was very surreal.
I listened to every song on this list, very cool.
Kinda scary that 27:27 would be the last recorded song on 9/11 just before the south tower callapsed and (correct me if im wrong) the entire speaker system cutting out from the callapse
La última grabada si es pero no la última en reproducirse porque faltaban unos 20 minutos para el colapso de la torre sur
If that was the final song, the guy filming the plaza just escaped death. He was still there filming while the previous song was playing.
You know, some of these song i remember being in the eastside jumper plaza video.
While some of thr skbgs i dont remember at all being included in the available footage, ive seen.
Oh wow
In another video , you can hear jumpers splattering while “ She’s always a woman to me “ plays calmly in the background.
56:43 The AA Flight 11 song 😱😱😱!!!
number 28 one of my favorites
33:39 BEATLES MENTIONED‼️‼️‼️
1:42:00 too
I saw in one video they were playing a soundtrack from Titanic that day
So I walk up on high
And I step to the edge
To see my world below
The chorus lyrics to "The World I know". And, if you've seen the video for it, it's even more poignant. And to think, it likely played during the event that morning. Heartbreaking.
What footage was 54:04 heard in ?
#16 apparently
@@eridanimo2311yeah I found out it was heard on 11/12/00
1:12:55 the best
La 5 la 6 la 7 y la 8 son especiales también porque fueron grabadas y por ellas conseguimos todas estas canciones
@@mevoycontumamaxdTo w sumie jedyna piosenka, którą znam z tej listy. Temat Muzak to dla mnie był pewien rabbit hole i nie spodziewałem się utworu z mojej playlisty wśród nich.
Does anyone know who wrote Three Generations 13:20 and if i can find a vynil or cassette or cd of the song/album?
Charles Michael Brotman made Three Generations but we have now confirmed that was not the song heard on 9/11, it is instead How Can You Mend A Broken Heart by Lenny Moore. We discovered the mistake on November 3rd, 2023
@@dylansandas920 ok thank you
Is there a CD/cassette/vinyl with this wonderful music?
From what I know, only a few of them, like from the airport muzak, though it includes the new songs unincluded in this video since this was uploaded months prior to it being found.
just once 좋네
They should play those songs at the freedom tower
O'Connell View
Why is Windless called "The Ice Cream Truck Song?"
I think it's because when people were trying to identify it from the JT 9/11 plaza footage, a segment, the twinkling part in the middle was recorded and a bunch of people said it sounded like an ice cream truck so they nicknamed it the ice cream truck song
From 8 to 33 is awesome
just to know, is always a woman 3:24 minutes long or 3:26 minutes long?
Are you looking for the "most original" copy to rip and save?
@@alvenhchanne we don’t have the original copy unfortunately, only the one recorded off the satellite since She’s Always a Woman was removed around 2010.
@@alvenhchanne yes, im still waiting for that somehow.
@@WorldTradeCenterMuzakCommunity Jim Devlin made it right?
@@yhfhdcf yeah I contacted him but he didn't have it
Imagine hearing that ice cream song and getting a scoop from the truck for 50 cents and looking up at the twin towers, not having a care in the world!
Upton Cliff
does anyone know what was the last song played before WTC2 collapsed?
It might be "will you come back my love". Not 100% sure though. Hope this helps.
how deep is your love?
The last recorded song was (Will You) Come Back My Love, but that was about 15 minutes before the collapse, so anywhere from 4-7 songs played after that
last recorded song, not the last official song@@sran438
Im sure the last ever song, said by many people was Queen Of My Soul, which started to play around 9:56
In what video does Canon in D could be heard?
In that FBI informant recording. It was playing inside the Greenhouse Cafe in the Marriott
oh never heard that audio, is lengthy, thanks@@dynasty0019
Were these songs known to be played on 9/11?
Yes.
@@TopTradeMuzak thank you for the response! Great work! :)
I only know the name of 1 and that was "How deep is your love" during that time.
@@TopTradeMuzakI’m sure the wtc families n fireman would never want to hear those songs again cause it would bring them bad memories
Not all the songs here are from 9/11
How do we know this?
Footage, check out PRE-911 for footage of the plaza with the Muzak playing
I’m positive I heard Hootie in one of the videos out there. Only wanna be with you.
Wehner Expressway
Tyrique Village
Ashleigh Crest
Me waiting for the beat drop from 7:09-13:19:
Excluding the songs played on 9/11, I’d like a video source of the other songs
our group is working on such a project for people to see the original tapes the songs are from in one spot, most can be found on the channel "Pre 9/11" there are also many clips there that we have not confirmed yet
Brad Forge
Russel Roads
Marisol Drive
Two (2) Steely Dan songs.
based
Trace Meadows
Crona Village
Shields Circle
Koch Haven
43:16
44:18
44:54
Cremin Stravenue
Bessie Crescent
Champlin Hill
Zane Radial
Josiane Isle
Legros Ports
Sonia Union
Aaliyah Prairie
Rath Land
Stehr Views