Just gorgeous. Ive had so many unfair feelings towards Frank, but you've made done him justice, he did love her... So much so that he destroyed his own life. He did the best he could for her and Brianna.
Thank you so much! It's such an interesting dynamic to explore. I'm really not fond of Frank in the novels, but I think Tobias' characterisation of him was very strong and sympathetic. I'm really happy that you enjoyed my video.
this just broke my heart, i'm actually crying. i don't know if i really shipped them, maybe in a way, multishipping is a thing after all... but this just overwhelmed me showing how sad their story is. they loved each other so much, and then she tried to get back to him, he kept hoping, he kept waiting, and at some point, it almost feels like she forgot him. and then she comes back, and it's all broken. but they still try, and she can't do it, and it's so fucking unfair on him, and so fucking heartbreaking. and this just me made feel it all so intensely!! so amazing briony!!
wow, i'm really moved that this video made you cry! i don't think i shipp(ed) them myself, but i do find the tragedy of their relationship/marriage very compelling to work with, and i really like how this song, imo, really captured many elements of the dynamic from claire's POV. i'm really happy that you enjoyed this video so much - thank you!
This video broke my heart in so many ways. The music, the editing, the relationship between Claire and Frank and how it ended. Even though I'm a diehard Jamie fan, I feel really sorry for Frank and their relationship. Good job on the vid!
this is stunning!!! I love claire/frank. don't get me wrong, jamie and claire are True Love (TM) and I respect that, but claire and frank were in most ways more interesting and I was really rooting for them.
i love this video so much. it's one of my favorites of your outlander vids and i find myself returning to it a lot. one day i will leave a proper comment on it, but for now, i want you to know this!
Ok im here again properly ready for death. So when you showed me this preview (and made me listen to this song) I knew I was in for pain but wow you outdid yourself truly. Ok the lyrics at the start matching up with all those shots of the photos wow and the "every little boy is so naive" with Frank looking at that wanted poster of Jamie wow that repetition of the 'chance and circumstance romance' is just so fitting to the whole theme of this video how do you always find and then vid songs that seem like they were specifically made for you to edit your ideas to (because you're a GD artist) All those hands/rings shots at like 0:47 with the lyrcis wow the cut at 0:53 is actual art, the flow there is just wow The part at like 1:17 with the lyrics "every little girl is so naive" and claire looking at the window of vases and thinking thats what she needs in her life to be happy wow i see what you did there And then following it with the 'falling in love with the first man you see" but quickly tearing it down and showing how much has changed between them now GOD 1:33 omg that shot of Brianna's baby head full of red hair I SEE YOU VILLAIN And then all those shots of Frank, showing how he did love claire and how he tries to get that love back but just can't. the 1:51 reversed shot: i love you (and just again showing how she's tied to two men, due to what the lyrics keep repeating) And then when you slow it down and have those shots at the stones, god that is actual art, the way you tell a story just the way you cut those scenes is a talent I'm so jealous of wow That underlying simmering resentment and rage after is so palpable even though there's no actual violence noted and just the almost claustrophobic atmosphere they now live in (that shot at 2:52 yaass queen) And then showing that through it all, even though they're not in love anymore, they did love each other at one point and Frank's death does of course cause her pain (and then going back to showing the good memories they had, the actual love they shared at the start) The shot at 3:41 with her going off frame and then cutting to that shot of Jamie putting the ring on her finger, DID I ASK? Ok I feel I've just rambled but honestly, I just love how you're able to weave a story so perfectly and the way you cut things together, paralleling the good things and the bad things so perfectly and just showing all the emotions they did fell, love, and pain and anger and resentment and how under all of that love was still the emotion underlying it all, though the love changed an may have focused more on their common love for Brianna later on. This was just as brilliant as I expected it to be when I first knew you were going to do this video and of course you killed it. Thank you for this honestly
Yeeeeees! I'm so happy you decided to make this video! You know in season 1 I didn't mind Frank, I actually felt sorry for him then, but seeing the way his attitude changes towards Claire after she comes back... Episode 303 was so infuriating for me to watch and I'm glad his character is gone! Anyways, I love how you show the good and bad of their relationship (this song fits them so well!!) and keep showing the stones and the rings throughout. I just really love that you've made a video exploring their journey.
Thanks bb. Frank was definitely much more of a sympathetic character in the first season, so it was really interesting to see how warped and unhealthy and toxic his relationship with Claire became when she returned to the twentieth century. I think Tobias and Caitriona did a wonderful job playing off one another in the first few episodes of this season, but I'm definitely glad to an end to that storyline. I'm really glad you enjoyed my video, it was a really interesting experience exploring a relationship that I don't ship. I'm very glad I did it! :)
Just gorgeous. Ive had so many unfair feelings towards Frank, but you've made done him justice, he did love her... So much so that he destroyed his own life. He did the best he could for her and Brianna.
Thank you so much! It's such an interesting dynamic to explore. I'm really not fond of Frank in the novels, but I think Tobias' characterisation of him was very strong and sympathetic. I'm really happy that you enjoyed my video.
this just broke my heart, i'm actually crying. i don't know if i really shipped them, maybe in a way, multishipping is a thing after all... but this just overwhelmed me showing how sad their story is. they loved each other so much, and then she tried to get back to him, he kept hoping, he kept waiting, and at some point, it almost feels like she forgot him. and then she comes back, and it's all broken. but they still try, and she can't do it, and it's so fucking unfair on him, and so fucking heartbreaking. and this just me made feel it all so intensely!! so amazing briony!!
wow, i'm really moved that this video made you cry! i don't think i shipp(ed) them myself, but i do find the tragedy of their relationship/marriage very compelling to work with, and i really like how this song, imo, really captured many elements of the dynamic from claire's POV. i'm really happy that you enjoyed this video so much - thank you!
This video broke my heart in so many ways. The music, the editing, the relationship between Claire and Frank and how it ended. Even though I'm a diehard Jamie fan, I feel really sorry for Frank and their relationship. Good job on the vid!
Thank you very much! This means a lot! And I am a diehard Jamie fan too, so it felt a bit odd working on a video that doesn't feature him.
I can imagine. But you nailed that shit
Great job!
And I loved the music!
this is stunning!!! I love claire/frank. don't get me wrong, jamie and claire are True Love (TM) and I respect that, but claire and frank were in most ways more interesting and I was really rooting for them.
Frank é um sonho! Culpa do Tobias que é incrível 😍
Okay just break my heart then
i love this video so much. it's one of my favorites of your outlander vids and i find myself returning to it a lot.
one day i will leave a proper comment on it, but for now, i want you to know this!
Ok im here again properly ready for death.
So when you showed me this preview (and made me listen to this song) I knew I was in for pain but wow you outdid yourself truly.
Ok the lyrics at the start matching up with all those shots of the photos wow and the "every little boy is so naive" with Frank looking at that wanted poster of Jamie wow
that repetition of the 'chance and circumstance romance' is just so fitting to the whole theme of this video how do you always find and then vid songs that seem like they were specifically made for you to edit your ideas to (because you're a GD artist)
All those hands/rings shots at like 0:47 with the lyrcis wow
the cut at 0:53 is actual art, the flow there is just wow
The part at like 1:17 with the lyrics "every little girl is so naive" and claire looking at the window of vases and thinking thats what she needs in her life to be happy wow i see what you did there
And then following it with the 'falling in love with the first man you see" but quickly tearing it down and showing how much has changed between them now GOD
1:33 omg that shot of Brianna's baby head full of red hair I SEE YOU VILLAIN
And then all those shots of Frank, showing how he did love claire and how he tries to get that love back but just can't.
the 1:51 reversed shot: i love you (and just again showing how she's tied to two men, due to what the lyrics keep repeating)
And then when you slow it down and have those shots at the stones, god that is actual art, the way you tell a story just the way you cut those scenes is a talent I'm so jealous of wow
That underlying simmering resentment and rage after is so palpable even though there's no actual violence noted and just the almost claustrophobic atmosphere they now live in (that shot at 2:52 yaass queen)
And then showing that through it all, even though they're not in love anymore, they did love each other at one point and Frank's death does of course cause her pain (and then going back to showing the good memories they had, the actual love they shared at the start)
The shot at 3:41 with her going off frame and then cutting to that shot of Jamie putting the ring on her finger, DID I ASK?
Ok I feel I've just rambled but honestly, I just love how you're able to weave a story so perfectly and the way you cut things together, paralleling the good things and the bad things so perfectly and just showing all the emotions they did fell, love, and pain and anger and resentment and how under all of that love was still the emotion underlying it all, though the love changed an may have focused more on their common love for Brianna later on.
This was just as brilliant as I expected it to be when I first knew you were going to do this video and of course you killed it. Thank you for this honestly
Video and song absolutely brilliant. I don't need to say more, everyone else said all the other good stuff. BRAVO!!!
Who sang the song?
Yeeeeees! I'm so happy you decided to make this video! You know in season 1 I didn't mind Frank, I actually felt sorry for him then, but seeing the way his attitude changes towards Claire after she comes back... Episode 303 was so infuriating for me to watch and I'm glad his character is gone! Anyways, I love how you show the good and bad of their relationship (this song fits them so well!!) and keep showing the stones and the rings throughout. I just really love that you've made a video exploring their journey.
Thanks bb. Frank was definitely much more of a sympathetic character in the first season, so it was really interesting to see how warped and unhealthy and toxic his relationship with Claire became when she returned to the twentieth century. I think Tobias and Caitriona did a wonderful job playing off one another in the first few episodes of this season, but I'm definitely glad to an end to that storyline. I'm really glad you enjoyed my video, it was a really interesting experience exploring a relationship that I don't ship. I'm very glad I did it! :)
acmmproductions what would be ur reaction if u were in place of frank.. He loved her n tried every possible way to get their love back like old times
i am attacked i have so much to say about this but that shot at 3:43 and the cut after it who asked you. A full comment is coming.
Okay... since Folklore is now a thing you have to edit them to Exile. It must be done.
Frank was too much for her; he truly deserved some one who really loved him.
Please edit them to coney island of Taylor's new album. Please please please.