Micoh Pangan yeah.. atleast half of yeonjungs line could've been destributed between soobin dawon seola and dayoung.. not shitting on yeonjung only one starship (but do you expect from starship..)
I hate to admit it but this is another Yeonjung and Friends.. I really love Yeonjung and she's my bias in WJSN as well as IOI, but tbh starship should give the spotlight to others especially Luda... ://
hoshi's carrot yeah.. not that I dont like Yeonjung having more lines.. i just find it kinda unfair... :/ and Yeonjung might get alot of antis because of this.. :/
She's the most stable one during live stages, so it's kinda expected that the company would give her more lines. Besides, this song is too high pitched for all of them, even yeonjung has hard time to sing during Live, not to mention other members. I'm not sure about Dawon, but Seola basically lip synced in almost all live performances during her parts, so... If you view from their live singing ability, this is actually quite fair considering the fact that those capable ones get more lines. But of course if you view from fan perspective, it would be unfair for others.
A M I know she is the main vocal, but I just hope that Starship won't kill her voice off. She's been promoting so much in a row so she barely rests her voice. I don't want her to strain it.
Ryan Lundgren I know! She was part of I.O.I (well technically still part of it but they're unfortunately disbanding soon) but I've been keeping up with Cosmic Girls since debut. Same here about the main vocals. I personally don't like Dawon's voice, but I hope she gets her time to shine as well as the others. I also hope some underrated members get some stuff too.
i think it's pretty fair considering the fact that yeonjung is the main vocal/most popular member and that exy got a great rap part that didn't take 1/3 of the song moreover everyone get to sing and even if my baby gets to sing the same sentence on repeat i'm glad that starship is trying to improve their distribution a little
btsvelvet it wouldn't be so bad if the parts attributed to dawon were actually sung by her. they just had her lipsync to yeonjung even tho she's another main vocal.
Well... 1) Soobin finally got back some of her lines (she normally has this amount, she is a LEAD VOCAL [and no, I never considered her a MAIN vocal, but she is MY BIAS and I love her enthusiasm anyways]). 2) Cheng Xiao finally got more lines! I guess our SJW'er efforts to Starship paid off. 3) Luda got more than 7 seconds makes me happy! 4) Of course Yeonjung will get the most lines because she has the best voice, and is way more popular than all of WJSN (and she actually SAVED WJSN's popularity, as they were "hated" for how they were going to be "the next EXO", but Yeonjung saved the group, you need to admit this). Overall, I'm SO happy with the line distribution.
OneProudBBC seriously?! i don't know if we can call that saving the group we shouldn't call that a group this is litterally Yeonjung and her backups the other members need to get see too! Plus having a girl group with 12 members where 3 of them get 50% of the song it's kinda sad even though they are better
Starship should give some of Yeonjung lines to SeolA and Dawon, but at least Luda and Cheng Xiao got more seconds this time even though Xiao's part is mostly "tell me why"
Justice for Dawon, why has Starship been wasting Dawon's talent so much? I don't get it... *rarity* Cheng Xiao got 4th place wtf... Also my bias got 2nd most lines 🌚🌚🌚
Touchy Taehyung well if you think about it, most of cheng xiao's "tell me why" were only in the background and dude she literally ghad three words hahahahhaha or maybe it was to make up for her not having a line in momomo and catch me 😂 i dont believe this is accurate tho coz yeonjung got 28% and dawon only has 5%
Sansa Stark Yeah the cheng xiao part true... But I think it is accurate I mean starship is TERRIBLE w/ line distibution like they had the second best vocal (if not as good as yj) in front of them and gave her the 6th least lines :( ... Though this is their best distribution as a whole but it doesn't do justice for all their individual talents let's hope for updated line distributions after their live shows ;/
okay, this I don't get, a lot of fans are actually complaining that she doesn't have enough lines during her stay in I.O.I then Starship is like giving her exposure (well Starship is kinda like that look at Hyorin for example) and chance to shine but she don't seem to please you or some other fans that think this way
jjcoriana lol. Im so glad she is getting exposure. And finally her time to shine. But! There are 13 girls. And it is very unfair for the other main vocals to have that quantity of lines. Again, yeunjung is my bias.
If you disregard the fact that Yeunjung sang 28% of the song, the line distribution is actually not that bad. Everyone got to sing equally. And Luda tho getting them lines bit by bit hahaha.
MaKaveli obviously this isn't sistar stop it okay is there four members? no there is 13 and besides yeonjung it's quite even. it also just so happens she's the most popular I don't think everyone who's saying this actually understand how much recognition this group gets just from her being on produce 101. oh and another thing they are all happy so everyone needs to stop being petty. they are happy because they did it they are idols and they are popular and it's not like yeonjung wants all the lines she was given all these lines
I FINALLY CREATED AN OFICIAL TWITTER ACCOUNT. LIKE 261 LATER AHAH Here is the link: twitter.com/watasy_wahyo (@watasy_wahyo) Make sure to follow me i'm taking requests via DM ;3
I can't believe how some fans still think that the line distribution is fair. Secret was a little more fair than this song and that's speaking wonders. Like what's the point of having a group of all these girls if most of the girls are only going to get a little bit of lines.
mulan4ever14 - You're telling me gaining 3.8 seconds in Secret is better than getting at least more than 5 seconds in I Wish? The voice concept doesn't suit Dawon. I mean, of course Yeonjung is pretty much Hyorin number 2, and also, you should be proud of Cheng Xiao who got more than a freaking Lead Vocalist, yet she gets almost nothing at Secret. Also Secret is EXY biased. Also, you need to love all the members equally to be A REAL FAN. Being a real fan is just supporting them no matter what. Not just loving and supporting you're Dawon here.
X1xXSwagGamer_21Xx1X Okay, so because we mention our bias that automatically means we hate the others? That’s what you seem to be saying. If we want to comment about Dawon we can. Go comment about Cheng Xiao if you want her to get attention (even though she *gets* attention but sure). You say being a fan is about loving all members equally but from your comment it honestly just seems that you enjoy bashing Dawon stans because god forbid we support our bias so I guess that means you aren’t a fan since clearly you don’t care about her in a good way. Leave us alone. This comment didn’t even say shit against other members, there was nothing wrong with it and yet you came in acting all high and mighty like us being upset over Dawon’s lack of lines was the end of the fucking world. And I’m curious. How is Secret Exy biased? She got one line. She did her rap and was done. That was it. Yeonjung was the focus of that song but it made sense, because that was her entrance into the group. Plus her voice made it fantastic anyway.
After what i Saw i think i have just two mistakes: 1:37 it's Seola 3:17 it's Yeoreum With that the final ranking would be: #1 YEUNJEUNG - 47,8s (23%) #2 SEOLA - 24,2s (11,6%) #3 DAYOUNG - 20,8s (10%) #4 SOOBIN - 20,2s (9,7%) #5 CHENG XIAO - 17,8s (8,6%) #6 YEOREUM - 12,2s (5,9%) #7 DAWON - 11,9s (5,7%) #8 EUNSEO - 10,4s (5,1%) #9 BONA - 9,4s (4,5%) #10 MEI QI - 8,7s (4,3%9 #11 XUAN YI - 8,4s (4,1%) #12 EXY - 7,9s (3,8%) #13 LUDA - 7,6s (3,7%) But still, is better to wait for the live performances :)
Finally Soobin is getting some justice! I'm a bit disappointed at the fact that ChengXiao has more lines ((even tho they are short and pretty much always the same)) than MeiQi, Seola and Dawon tho..
yeah, im kinda confused as to why she got autotuned same sentence lines and why she got more lines than some main and lead vocals. and also that luda still remains with the least lines :(
***** I know, but in terms of promotions, that makes a big difference. Even if it's only for 2 seconds each time, ChengXiao has more chances to appear on camera. I get that she is probably the most popular alongside Yeonjung, but this kind of stuff makes the public focus more on her instead of help them get familiar with the least popular members in Korea like Soobin, Yeoreum, MeiQi or Luda.
***** IKR :( poor baby...she got such shitty lines in both MoMoMo and Secret, specially in Secret..I hope the "underrated" line gets some time to shine next comeback. But for now on looks like starship wants to keep pushing Yeonjung, Dayoung and ChengXiao.
For a 13 member group this line distribution is just ridiculous, I was really hoping Starship wouldn't push Yeonjung with a boatload of lines like this. Seola, Dawon, and Soobin could definitely need more lines, I'm glad Dayoung got more lines though
This is why 9 is the max of members to have in a group. But even with 9 members or less, there would still be terrible line distribution. This was straight up Yeonjung and WJSN (not that I have anything against Yeonjung, she's my favourite member and I'm upset)
AzureSteel yeonjung is basically the main vocal yeah tbh (but considering a 13 membered group theres probably 2-3) but the only reason is basically yeonjung got EVERY SINGLE CHORUS
I see a lot of benefits of adding yeonjung, because they got a lot of attention from it, but i think only dawon, the previous MAIN vocal is disadvantaged, she even went on Girl Spirit and gained attention but now this line dsitribution... i feel bad for her, but still love Yeonjung, dilemma!!!
it usually gets balanced a lot more for side tracks... even for sistar when everyone is complaining over and over again, the side tracks have a lot more of the other girls than main.
Well take a lot at their catch me song, dawon has over 45sec, exy over 20 and than there are 4 girls that only got like 1 second each and poor cheng xiao that didnät even get to sing anything.... Clearly this line distribution is pretty fair except yeonjung. Is that dawon a main vocal or something?
Erika Edström dawon is main vocal with yeonjung.... in secret yeonjung get 40+ sec and this song she got almost 1 minute... so, its worse than dawon's 45sec...
Dawon is the main vocal too so give her more lines not only Yeonjung get all the lines like that. Why Chengxiao has more lines than Dawon serious ?? So much tone
I think we need to give it time. Remember, Yeunjung has a few things Starship needs to exploit: 1) The girl had a golden voice and is considered the next Hyorin and is their best main vocal. (Seriously, her high notes and ad-libs are RIDICULOUS). 2) IOI. Nuff said. 3) With a few IOI wins under her belt, it should boost her popularity. 4) New maknae and brings a livelier energy that helps attract more fans. I think after this comeback, the line distribution will hopefully get even better, because despite Yeunjung getting the choruses it really wasn't as bad. Cheng Xiao got more time (TELL ME WHY). It's because she is suuuuuper popular right now and has been landing all kinds of cool things left and right. This is how the group gets popular, which in turn brings more revenue, fans, and wins. Let's just support as best we can! :)
Well at first Exy had all the lines now its Yeonjung. But I don't mind right now the company is properly trying to use their popularity from the shows they did to gain fans. I bet once they succeed in that things will switch up.
chengxiao: first: just tell me why second: just tell me why third: just tell me why fourth:just tell me why me: just tell me why chengxiao repeat this lyric 😂
I'm glad Yeonjung is finally getting some appreciation after being hidden behind the more popular members in I.O.I. But it must be very frustrating for the other members.. it's hard getting recognition in such a big group to begin with. And then another member is being put in and suddenly gets all the attention.. so much pressure. I wouldn't want to be a part of WJSN!
Im upset for Dawon but happy for Yeunjung. Despite that... sad part is the fact that this is the fairest line distribution for WJSN so far... for a title track at least.
Back at it again with Yeunjung and her crew. Well Dawon's voice may not suit this kind of song, her voice is really rich and powerful. But Soobin's voice is similar to Yeunjung, she could have shared some line with Yeunjung.
Yeonjung is my favorite vocalist for sure (like beyond just high notes I really love the tone of her voice and everything) but I really really wish they'd split her main vocal pieces a bit more evenly. She could still have the most lines if they gave some of her chorus parts to Dawon, Soobin, and Dayoung, and the song would be just as strong and stable. Other than it just being unfair to the other girls I'm really worried they're going to exhaust Yeonjung or have her voice become damaged from overuse afternonstop promoting between IOI and Cosmic Girls...
The amount of disrespect for Dawon WHO WAS AND IS THE MAIN VOCALIST is OUTRAGEOUS. Why are they acting like Yeonjung's the only who can sing? Glad to see EXY gave up some of her lines but they really did Dawon dirty.
my own opinion is her voice doesn't fit with this song. her voice is unique so i think more line turn to subin and dayoung more than her. it's like Secret she got line more than them
I think the last line (after Soobin) is Yeoreum, cause if you see she walks to be in the middle of the dance almost before the song ends, plus the voice doesnt sound as high as Yeonjung's, its more a sweet tone like Yeoreum's (like her first part in secret)
Pretty sure 1:37 and 3:17 is Bona's voice When main vocal only gets 11.9 secs. As a fan since debut tbh, I'm seriously upset... Also Exy only getting 4 bars
i know that this is unfair, my bias is yeunjung, soobin, dawon, dayoung, luda, yeoreum, exy, seola, bona, eunseo, mei qi, xuan yi, cheng xiao... i think that starship is being unfair in their line distributions cause they wanted a voice that suits that kind of song. we must love them all, so please don't hate YEUNJUNG, like its all of her fault, other says that when she is added in the group, other members are not shining anymore. pls. just look in the positive side. i know dawon dont deserve this, cause she is a talented girl, i even love her more in girl spirit. pls dont hate, just love them. i cant speak in english so i cant really explain anything.
After watching Produce 101 I'm very confident that Yeunjung is a very positive and humble girl. Starship giving her all the lines will make her look bad and it makes me worry for her. I don't want people to misunderstand her, she's not greedy T.T They should have made her a soloist if they were going to just give her practically the whole song to sing.
Anyone else hear only Yeonjung during Dawon's parts? It seems like Yeonjung sang and they just had Dawon lipsync her parts for the MV. She'll probably sing them live but it's pretty messed up not to give her parts in the studio version :///
Touchy Taehyung i literally only hear her in the background doing the "aaaaah~" @ 3:17. it's so sad idk why they gave lines to yj that couldve so easily gone to her.
Well... Seola, Soobin, Dayoung and especially Dawon are very good as for rookies so I think that Yeonjung should sang less and Dawon and Seola more. And I understand that Yeonjung is main vocal so she should sing hooks and hit high notes but I don't understand why she sings parts that could be handled by weakest vocal in group. Soobin at 2:46 O.O It was so nice.
Where did I hated on Yeonjung? I just said what I'm thinking about this line distribution and why I don't like it, I'm allowed to do it even when you don't really liked it, okey? And If I even hated on Yeonjung I still can do it :)
Joao Jackson Sim, eu amo a Yeonjung, ela é minha bias, mas tinha tantas partes que poderiam ser cantadas pelas outras integrantes. Por mim ela poderia cantar só no refrão e nas high notes
Bona's line 😍😍 I seriously love her voice! also, Starship you suck. Dawon, Dayoung and Soobin could've sang any of Yeunjung's lines. I feel like the distribution for this group is only good for the sub vocalists. they have trouble giving enough lines to the good singers, if that's any testament to how talented the group is.
I actually think the line @ 1:38 is Soobin considering she's on the screen for it and it sounds her voice! but we'll wait for the live to figure it out!
at least no one gets 2 seconds parts, right 😂 and STARSHIP TELL ME WHY YOU DID DAWON DIRTY in this song :"( I love Yeunjung but if you gave all the parts, she'll get a lot of hate :"(
ATENCION HABLA HISPANA📣📣📣, soy un fan de Cosmic Girls💖 pero esto no se puede quedar asi. Luda es mi Amor Platonico😍 y tengo que esperar como 6 meses para que hagan comeback para escucharla cantar 7.6 segundos? y todo por la culpa de Yeonjung que solo se integro al grupo para opacar a las demas😠, a los fans de Yeonjung lo siento pero es la verdad y para variar siempre baila de las ultimas atras😭. Yeonjung, ella se llevo todas las lineas y la lider Exy💖 una de mis raperas favoritas canta 7.9 segundos. Starship por favor denle lineas a las otras. Todos los fans unidos💙. Tambin Starship hace lo mismo con SISTAR, en I Like That Bora solo canto como 8 segundos y la otra como 1 minuto, ALTO A LA INJUSTICIA Y DENLE LINEAS A LAS OTRAS. FANS DE COSMIC GIRLS Y SISTAR UNANSE A MI REVELION CONTRA STARSHIP PARA TRAER DE VUELTA LA LINE DISTRIBUTIONS PAREJAS Y EQUILIBRADAS.
Leandro Melgarejo Pero no crees que el problema esta en el número de integrantes, 13 es demasiado, especialmente cuando las que tienen buena voz cantan la mayoría de la canción. Para mi el perfecto numero es 6, nunca hay necesidad para tener mas de 10, calidad sobre cantidad. Pero estoy de acuerdo que tener mas de 50s para una persona es injusto especialmente para Dawon que era la vocalista principal.
Francisco Perez Estoy de acuerdo contigo pero si es un grupo de 13 miembros no crees que deberia ser MAS pareja y equilibrada la Line Distribution? pero estamos de acuerdo con la gran cantidad de segundos para una sola persona asi que unete a mi rebelion contra la injusticua de lineas en Starship 😉
Leandro Melgarejo Ste men:v Entiendo lo de Cosmic Girls, pero no tienes nada que hacer con Sistar. Esa "injusticia" se arregla con las canciones del álbum, donde, si realmente fueras fan, sabrías que las cosas se igualan.
Ale Ojeda Bueno reconosco lo de SISTAR pero me importa mas Cosmic Girls y que verdad que LUDA no cansa casi nada, en Secret solo canto 3 o 4 segundos 😉
"Tell my why" follows Cheng Xiao in her nightmares lol
Jungkookie Stan HAHAHAHAHAHAHAH At least she got 8.6% of the song.
Jungkookie Stan 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
OK. That's mean "tell me why" is 8.6% of the song XDD
lmao all cheng xiao sang was just "tell me why" but she got more times than like half of the member lmao
tell me why
Febri Hafa half the members: TELL ME WHY
hope this tell me why will be huge
Febri Hafa ChengXiao's "tell me why" is the new "whoop whoop" LOL
Limitless - 无限的我 😲🙊😂😂😂😂
Yeunjung ft. Cosmic Girls
Vanialla.wafer true
Vanialla.wafer because Yeunjung the savior of Cosmic Girls lol
Vanialla.wafer tell me why
Mickey Tan, They xan sing even without Yeonjung :)
Sassy Suarez I know. but Yeunjung help WJSN get more public recognition tho
in the rankking i putted ''KEI'' instead of ''YEOREUM'' i'm sorry!
Did you have Lovelyz on your mind when making this? lol
Watasy Wahyo lol Kei XD
Watasy Wahyo just wanted to comment the same thing, my mind suddenly blank with that name trying to figure out who is kei
Watasy Wahyo Summer is better than Kei XD bruv
Watasy Wahyo the amount of time is also off for her too, she didn't get anywhere close to 51.2 seconds, so that threw off all the percentages too
yeonjung = kihyun = hyorin
starshit lol.
Dawon does not deserve this disrespect
Micoh Pangan yeah.. atleast half of yeonjungs line could've been destributed between soobin dawon seola and dayoung.. not shitting on yeonjung only one starship (but do you expect from starship..)
Micoh Pangan doesn't dawon is main vocal as well?
Austria Mallak she is
Austria Mallak tell me why
Micoh Pangan maybe her voice didn't really suit this song oK NO JUST IGNORE ME DON'T READ MY OPINION FAM
Dawon: TELL ME WHY
Seola: TELL ME WHY
Exy: TELL ME WHY
Basically everyone: TELL ME WHY
Luda: ...I'll take what I can get tbh
no TELL ME WHY
IKR cri for my baby Luda
CHENG XIAO HAS LINES
I REPEAT
*CHENG XIAO HAS LINES*
Squishy Satansoo she had lines in the last song too though 😂
YAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAY!!!!!
Squishy Satansoo THE DAY HAS COME
I'M CRYING😭
She has more lines than Seola :p
I hate to admit it but this is another Yeonjung and Friends.. I really love Yeonjung and she's my bias in WJSN as well as IOI, but tbh starship should give the spotlight to others especially Luda... ://
Rio cvrg and Dawon and seola being the main vocals also should get more lines
hoshi's carrot yeah.. not that I dont like Yeonjung having more lines.. i just find it kinda unfair... :/ and Yeonjung might get alot of antis because of this.. :/
Rio cvrg luda getting 7,6 is double the amount of her line in secret so this obviously is better tbh.. dawon is the one I think deserve more line
She's the most stable one during live stages, so it's kinda expected that the company would give her more lines. Besides, this song is too high pitched for all of them, even yeonjung has hard time to sing during Live, not to mention other members. I'm not sure about Dawon, but Seola basically lip synced in almost all live performances during her parts, so... If you view from their live singing ability, this is actually quite fair considering the fact that those capable ones get more lines. But of course if you view from fan perspective, it would be unfair for others.
i come from the future.
now Luda is basically a center.
ChengXiao RISE!!
Dawon Down!!
Luda: im still here... why no one care about me??
Gachi Gallae? 같이 갈래? I care about you Luda :(
I care about baby luda 🥺💕
Cheng Xiao: Tell me why~ *sings*
DaWon,Eunseo,Bona,Yeoreum,Mei Qi,Xuan Yi,Exy: TELL MY WHY.
Luda: tell me the fck why.
queenOHMYGIRLslay OMG SO TRUE
HAHAHAHA
And I was hoping Yeonjung wouldn't get many lines. She needs to rest her voice :(
she is the main vocal
A M SeolA, Dawon and Soobin are still technically the main vocals...I think Starship is just trying to use YeonJung's talent to promote the girls :)
A M I know she is the main vocal, but I just hope that Starship won't kill her voice off. She's been promoting so much in a row so she barely rests her voice. I don't want her to strain it.
Kpop Rankings She's the maknae...she was added before Secret, and so I'm hoping the original main vocals don't keep getting pushed aside :3
Ryan Lundgren I know! She was part of I.O.I (well technically still part of it but they're unfortunately disbanding soon) but I've been keeping up with Cosmic Girls since debut. Same here about the main vocals. I personally don't like Dawon's voice, but I hope she gets her time to shine as well as the others. I also hope some underrated members get some stuff too.
I WISH that everyone would get equal amount of lines. It's not a SECRET that starship gives all the line to one person like sistar. Please starship.
i think it's pretty fair considering the fact that yeonjung is the main vocal/most popular member and that exy got a great rap part that didn't take 1/3 of the song
moreover everyone get to sing and even if my baby gets to sing the same sentence on repeat i'm glad that starship is trying to improve their distribution a little
btsvelvet tell me why
btsvelvet it wouldn't be so bad if the parts attributed to dawon were actually sung by her. they just had her lipsync to yeonjung even tho she's another main vocal.
abbee i know but we all know how starship sucks in terms of line distribution
j n i know but she is also the most popular member, she have to have the spotlight on her so the group is getting recognized
btsvelvet true but a main vocal singing only half of a line and an adlib in the recording of a title track is pretty absurd.
OK NOW IT'S FOR REAL:
1:37 it's Bona
3:17 it's Yeoreum
With that the final ranking is:
#1 YEUNJEUNG - 47,8s (23%)
#2 DAYOUNG - 20,8s (10%)
#3 SOOBIN - 20,2s (9,7%)
#4 CHENG XIAO - 17,8s (8,6%)
#5 BONA - 17,2s (8,3%)
#6 SEOLA - 16,2s (7,8%)
#7 YEOREUM - 12,2s (5,9%)
#8 DAWON - 11,9s (5,7%)
#9 EUNSEO - 10,4s (5,1%)
#10 MEI QI - 8,7s (4,3%9
#11 XUAN YI - 8,4s (4,1%)
#12 EXY - 7,9s (3,8%)
#13 LUDA - 7,6s (3,7%)
thankyou!!! if you dont mind can you upload the new version(when you have time :))
Watasy Wahyo If u don't mind, i want to see the new version. But that's okay i know this kind of vid is actually hard to do.
Watasy Wahyo and the high note at 2:47 is Yeunjung, not Soobin!
and thats why this is called Yeunjung - I Wish (ft. Cosmic Girls) she has way too much lines :/
aww even yeoreum get more lines than dawon
THIS WAS THE HARDEST LINE DISTRIBUTION I'VE EVER MADE XD
Oh and I'm not sure if this is 100% correct xD
Watasy Wahyo on the end of the video you write 'kei' but is the baby yeoreum
it looks pretty accurate, good job lol
Watasy Wahyo wait for their performance to drop
Watasy Wahyo Starship tsk
Pretty accurate. Anyway, I was wondering if you could make one for April April's Story that came out today too? Pretty please.
This is the best line distribution WJSN ever had
Nessi Nessa that's kinda sad ngl 💀💀
Nessi Nessa Sad but true
not really
ana Whats the best then?
just tell me why
Well...
1) Soobin finally got back some of her lines (she normally has this amount, she is a LEAD VOCAL [and no, I never considered her a MAIN vocal, but she is MY BIAS and I love her enthusiasm anyways]).
2) Cheng Xiao finally got more lines! I guess our SJW'er efforts to Starship paid off.
3) Luda got more than 7 seconds makes me happy!
4) Of course Yeonjung will get the most lines because she has the best voice, and is way more popular than all of WJSN (and she actually SAVED WJSN's popularity, as they were "hated" for how they were going to be "the next EXO", but Yeonjung saved the group, you need to admit this).
Overall, I'm SO happy with the line distribution.
OneProudBBC seriously?! i don't know if we can call that saving the group we shouldn't call that a group this is litterally Yeonjung and her backups the other members need to get see too! Plus having a girl group with 12 members where 3 of them get 50% of the song it's kinda sad even though they are better
OneProudBBC Lmao you have low standards tbh. It's terrible that Chang Xiao got more lines than people 10x better than her.
no Cheng Xiao's voice isn't even that bad, she actually can sing well. Her voice reminds me of F(x)'s Victoria.
OneProudBBC Didn't say she was bad if you bothered to read. I said she's not as good as Seola, Dawon, and Meiqi
Add Exy to that. Justice for Exy.
Starship should give some of Yeonjung lines to SeolA and Dawon, but at least Luda and Cheng Xiao got more seconds this time even though Xiao's part is mostly "tell me why"
Justice for Dawon, why has Starship been wasting Dawon's talent so much? I don't get it... *rarity* Cheng Xiao got 4th place wtf...
Also my bias got 2nd most lines 🌚🌚🌚
Touchy Taehyung well if you think about it, most of cheng xiao's "tell me why" were only in the background and dude she literally ghad three words hahahahhaha or maybe it was to make up for her not having a line in momomo and catch me 😂 i dont believe this is accurate tho coz yeonjung got 28% and dawon only has 5%
Sansa Stark Yeah the cheng xiao part true... But I think it is accurate I mean starship is TERRIBLE w/ line distibution like they had the second best vocal (if not as good as yj) in front of them and gave her the 6th least lines :( ... Though this is their best distribution as a whole but it doesn't do justice for all their individual talents let's hope for updated line distributions after their live shows ;/
Touchy Taehyung cheng xiao only say tell my why:")
Bona,Exy,Xuan Yi and Mei Qi only have 1 line. LMAO
she just says "just tell me why" and that's repeated more than 3 times 😁
Cheng Xiao got more lines than Dawon? What is this??😱😱
I dont know why but everytime you comment my videos the youtube marks it as SPAM xD
Yeonjung with 58 seg and Dawon with 11 :(
Watasy Wahyo I don't know what's going on lmao
Sotiria Lazaridou I'm more surprise because chengxiao line and only two different words
Cmon he said he wasn't 100% sure. Lets just wait for a live performance from them haha
Cheng Xiao making up for MoMoMo & Catch Me and HIT THAT NOTE SOOBIN
yeunjung its too much😂 she is my bias but STARSHIP is going to get her tired af.
Allison Dunning tell me why
okay, this I don't get, a lot of fans are actually complaining that she doesn't have enough lines during her stay in I.O.I then Starship is like giving her exposure (well Starship is kinda like that look at Hyorin for example) and chance to shine but she don't seem to please you or some other fans that think this way
jjcoriana lol. Im so glad she is getting exposure. And finally her time to shine. But! There are 13 girls. And it is very unfair for the other main vocals to have that quantity of lines.
Again, yeunjung is my bias.
jjcoriana Exactly! Omg
If you disregard the fact that Yeunjung sang 28% of the song, the line distribution is actually not that bad. Everyone got to sing equally. And Luda tho getting them lines bit by bit hahaha.
but is like sistar all over again
Scezipert Ranger tell me why
MaKaveli obviously this isn't sistar stop it okay is there four members? no there is 13 and besides yeonjung it's quite even. it also just so happens she's the most popular I don't think everyone who's saying this actually understand how much recognition this group gets just from her being on produce 101. oh and another thing they are all happy so everyone needs to stop being petty. they are happy because they did it they are idols and they are popular and it's not like yeonjung wants all the lines she was given all these lines
Scezipert Ranger you can't disgerad Yeunjung line because all the fuss is because HER LINE
I FINALLY CREATED AN OFICIAL TWITTER ACCOUNT. LIKE 261 LATER AHAH
Here is the link: twitter.com/watasy_wahyo (@watasy_wahyo)
Make sure to follow me i'm taking requests via DM ;3
so happy my girl cheng xiao got more lines in this come back, even if it was just
'tell me why" lol
josie denson they gotta respect chengxiao...she gave them alot of money ahbabajajnanana
josie denson i mean she worked so much appearing on shows and she appeared in almost every magazine in korea last year
I can't believe how some fans still think that the line distribution is fair. Secret was a little more fair than this song and that's speaking wonders. Like what's the point of having a group of all these girls if most of the girls are only going to get a little bit of lines.
Amen!
Mai Juah ikr. Justice for dawon
this line distribution is even worse than Secret. ugh
poor Dawon, is she even a MAIN VOCAL anymore?
Well, It's Starshit. No one knows.
that's what i was thinking :(
She still is. But Hyorin2 cough Yeunjung is THE main vocal, so the rest are more like lead vocalists lol.
mulan4ever14 - You're telling me gaining 3.8 seconds in Secret is better than getting at least more than 5 seconds in I Wish? The voice concept doesn't suit Dawon. I mean, of course Yeonjung is pretty much Hyorin number 2, and also, you should be proud of Cheng Xiao who got more than a freaking Lead Vocalist, yet she gets almost nothing at Secret. Also Secret is EXY biased. Also, you need to love all the members equally to be A REAL FAN. Being a real fan is just supporting them no matter what. Not just loving and supporting you're Dawon here.
X1xXSwagGamer_21Xx1X Okay, so because we mention our bias that automatically means we hate the others? That’s what you seem to be saying.
If we want to comment about Dawon we can. Go comment about Cheng Xiao if you want her to get attention (even though she *gets* attention but sure).
You say being a fan is about loving all members equally but from your comment it honestly just seems that you enjoy bashing Dawon stans because god forbid we support our bias so I guess that means you aren’t a fan since clearly you don’t care about her in a good way. Leave us alone. This comment didn’t even say shit against other members, there was nothing wrong with it and yet you came in acting all high and mighty like us being upset over Dawon’s lack of lines was the end of the fucking world.
And I’m curious. How is Secret Exy biased? She got one line. She did her rap and was done. That was it. Yeonjung was the focus of that song but it made sense, because that was her entrance into the group. Plus her voice made it fantastic anyway.
I feel like Kei got way too many lines in this song.
omg haha whos kei i tried to figure out one missing member at the end but too stupid to remember
Hyungwonho is life YEOREUM.
After what i Saw i think i have just two mistakes:
1:37 it's Seola
3:17 it's Yeoreum
With that the final ranking would be:
#1 YEUNJEUNG - 47,8s (23%)
#2 SEOLA - 24,2s (11,6%)
#3 DAYOUNG - 20,8s (10%)
#4 SOOBIN - 20,2s (9,7%)
#5 CHENG XIAO - 17,8s (8,6%)
#6 YEOREUM - 12,2s (5,9%)
#7 DAWON - 11,9s (5,7%)
#8 EUNSEO - 10,4s (5,1%)
#9 BONA - 9,4s (4,5%)
#10 MEI QI - 8,7s (4,3%9
#11 XUAN YI - 8,4s (4,1%)
#12 EXY - 7,9s (3,8%)
#13 LUDA - 7,6s (3,7%)
But still, is better to wait for the live performances :)
Watasy Wahyo omg xuan yi :'((
no, 1:37 is Soobin
Quenn KPOP you sure?
I agree too, I'm pretty sure it's Soobin's voice...there's a slight nasal(?) voice that Soobin has, but I guess we'll see for sure in the live. ^^
Yeah, im actually pretty sure, not only that it really sounds like her voice, but she got alot of screentime under that line
What the hell is this? Starship, tell me why you gave Yeonjung every chorus when it's not even a challenging line. ANY of the member could have sung.
ThomasSteff17 right..
True other member also could sing well they sould give other member more line.
but not all the members can be that stable while dancing and jumping, maybe that's why
Dayoung sang the last chorus
Finally Soobin is getting some justice! I'm a bit disappointed at the fact that ChengXiao has more lines ((even tho they are short and pretty much always the same)) than MeiQi, Seola and Dawon tho..
WJSN's #1 supporter it the same
yeah, im kinda confused as to why she got autotuned same sentence lines and why she got more lines than some main and lead vocals. and also that luda still remains with the least lines :(
***** I know, but in terms of promotions, that makes a big difference. Even if it's only for 2 seconds each time, ChengXiao has more chances to appear on camera. I get that she is probably the most popular alongside Yeonjung, but this kind of stuff makes the public focus more on her instead of help them get familiar with the least popular members in Korea like Soobin, Yeoreum, MeiQi or Luda.
***** IKR :( poor baby...she got such shitty lines in both MoMoMo and Secret, specially in Secret..I hope the "underrated" line gets some time to shine next comeback. But for now on looks like starship wants to keep pushing Yeonjung, Dayoung and ChengXiao.
i think for this comeback yeorum and soobin shined !!! they got some lines
For a 13 member group this line distribution is just ridiculous, I was really hoping Starship wouldn't push Yeonjung with a boatload of lines like this. Seola, Dawon, and Soobin could definitely need more lines, I'm glad Dayoung got more lines though
1:37 doesn't sound like yeonjung. 3:17 too
As much as i love yeonjung but dam starship should distribute the lines fairly between the main vocals =(
The top three people has 48% of the song. That means that 10 people share the last 52%. But sure, that's fair.
luda is prob now like "i give up on having lines, at least i still have fans"
MEI QI SLAYEDTTTT. YAAS HIT THOSE HIGH NOTES
This is why 9 is the max of members to have in a group. But even with 9 members or less, there would still be terrible line distribution. This was straight up Yeonjung and WJSN (not that I have anything against Yeonjung, she's my favourite member and I'm upset)
im laughing bc if yiou take away "tell me why" from cheng xiao she has no lines but i love her
I'm not entirely sure if this is correct, there is no way that Dawon only has 11.9s while Yeonjung has 58.2s
It may be possible I mean we all know how starshit works
AzureSteel yeonjung is basically the main vocal yeah tbh (but considering a 13 membered group theres probably 2-3) but the only reason is basically yeonjung got EVERY SINGLE CHORUS
I see a lot of benefits of adding yeonjung, because they got a lot of attention from it, but i think only dawon, the previous MAIN vocal is disadvantaged, she even went on Girl Spirit and gained attention but now this line dsitribution... i feel bad for her, but still love Yeonjung, dilemma!!!
it usually gets balanced a lot more for side tracks... even for sistar when everyone is complaining over and over again, the side tracks have a lot more of the other girls than main.
I see that with Seventeen a lot, especially in Special stages they get More lines
I don't know who 1:39 is, but I really don't think it's Yeonjung. It just doesn't sound like her voice.
Jenny Madison Sounds like Seola
Jenny Madison i think so
lmao it's Bona's part. You can check it at their performances in music shows.
its kinda rare that exy got the second least:/
Starship strike again with unfair line distirbution....
thought it was pretty fair except for yeonjung xD
Erika Edström unfair to dawon and exy.... and too much of yeonjung... they deserve at least 20sec
Well take a lot at their catch me song, dawon has over 45sec, exy over 20 and than there are 4 girls that only got like 1 second each and poor cheng xiao that didnät even get to sing anything.... Clearly this line distribution is pretty fair except yeonjung. Is that dawon a main vocal or something?
Erika Edström dawon is main vocal with yeonjung.... in secret yeonjung get 40+ sec and this song she got almost 1 minute... so, its worse than dawon's 45sec...
in that case I can agree with you that dawon should have gotten some of yeonjungs lines, but the rest of the girls have it fair.
Dawon is the main vocal too so give her more lines not only Yeonjung get all the lines like that. Why Chengxiao has more lines than Dawon serious ?? So much tone
Little Snow yeahhh
I think we need to give it time. Remember, Yeunjung has a few things Starship needs to exploit:
1) The girl had a golden voice and is considered the next Hyorin and is their best main vocal. (Seriously, her high notes and ad-libs are RIDICULOUS).
2) IOI. Nuff said.
3) With a few IOI wins under her belt, it should boost her popularity.
4) New maknae and brings a livelier energy that helps attract more fans.
I think after this comeback, the line distribution will hopefully get even better, because despite Yeunjung getting the choruses it really wasn't as bad.
Cheng Xiao got more time (TELL ME WHY). It's because she is suuuuuper popular right now and has been landing all kinds of cool things left and right.
This is how the group gets popular, which in turn brings more revenue, fans, and wins.
Let's just support as best we can! :)
oh no this is gonna turn out like dia where the company gives chaeyeon way too much attention for her popularity
Venus Angels true
喬 Kiu but wjsn has other great vocalists as well
Well at first Exy had all the lines now its Yeonjung. But I don't mind right now the company is properly trying to use their popularity from the shows they did to gain fans. I bet once they succeed in that things will switch up.
chengxiao:
first: just tell me why
second: just tell me why
third: just tell me why
fourth:just tell me why
me: just tell me why chengxiao repeat this lyric 😂
I'm glad Yeonjung is finally getting some appreciation after being hidden behind the more popular members in I.O.I. But it must be very frustrating for the other members.. it's hard getting recognition in such a big group to begin with. And then another member is being put in and suddenly gets all the attention.. so much pressure. I wouldn't want to be a part of WJSN!
Yeonjung feat WJSN lmao she's my bias but have a more even distribution!
Woahh. 2 lead and a sub vocal get more lines than than the other 2 main vocalist. But it's a good thing too, Soobin and Dayoung can shine more.
am i the only one who think this is actually pretty fair except for yeunjung lines?
I was waiting for This lol
all cheng xiao said was tell me why
THANK YOU FOR THIS!!!
Wait I can't find the Mv??
Starship didn't realease it in the youtube yet but they released it in Vapp
Watasy Wahyo ohhh okayy thanks
Ahhhh That's why !!!!!!
Blackpink Love whst
Blackpink Love tell me why
Im upset for Dawon but happy for Yeunjung. Despite that... sad part is the fact that this is the fairest line distribution for WJSN so far... for a title track at least.
I don't think Yeonjung sings the verse after the first chorus. That sounds more like Bona.
2:22 she is singing. also in 3:03
Lets just wait until the live performance to see this might not be completely correct like they said.
Last time I was this early I had a life.
Thanks!!! I was waiting to listen the song but they didn't realise the MV >:3 This song is realy stiky 💖
Do I wish Screen time please
as a meiqi stan, im not ready for that pain :---(
Dan M lol so what about luda? she just got a millisecond on her own part
I feel you! MeiQi is center and vocalist, and we only actually hear her harmonizing
Back at it again with Yeunjung and her crew. Well Dawon's voice may not suit this kind of song, her voice is really rich and powerful. But Soobin's voice is similar to Yeunjung, she could have shared some line with Yeunjung.
Yeonjung is my favorite vocalist for sure (like beyond just high notes I really love the tone of her voice and everything) but I really really wish they'd split her main vocal pieces a bit more evenly. She could still have the most lines if they gave some of her chorus parts to Dawon, Soobin, and Dayoung, and the song would be just as strong and stable. Other than it just being unfair to the other girls I'm really worried they're going to exhaust Yeonjung or have her voice become damaged from overuse afternonstop promoting between IOI and Cosmic Girls...
The amount of disrespect for Dawon WHO WAS AND IS THE MAIN VOCALIST is OUTRAGEOUS. Why are they acting like Yeonjung's the only who can sing? Glad to see EXY gave up some of her lines but they really did Dawon dirty.
But.. But.. What about Dawon? Isn't she a lead/main vocalist or something? D:
she's one of three wjsn's main vocalist :(
my own opinion is her voice doesn't fit with this song. her voice is unique so i think more line turn to subin and dayoung more than her. it's like Secret she got line more than them
yes, i think her voice tone is strong like yuju's. so this kind of song doesn't fit her voice. or her voice doesn't fit this kind of song. xD
I think the last line (after Soobin) is Yeoreum, cause if you see she walks to be in the middle of the dance almost before the song ends, plus the voice doesnt sound as high as Yeonjung's, its more a sweet tone like Yeoreum's (like her first part in secret)
My baby Yeunjung slay!! 😘😘😘 hopefully more screentime and more lines for you next time
Mickey Tan more lines for yeonjung??
more lines?? 😮 did you even think about other members lines compared to her?? nah the next song should be just her solo
RV BP SONE EXOL ARMY ONCE BUDDY MEU MIRACLE VIP maybe Yeonjung's solo's song and wjsn cameo in her mv ! meh :/
you've got to be kidding me....
Pretty sure 1:37 and 3:17 is Bona's voice
When main vocal only gets 11.9 secs. As a fan since debut tbh, I'm seriously upset...
Also Exy only getting 4 bars
Anyone know why they did not upload it to UA-cam?
KESHI they released it on V app it will be on UA-cam shortly
KESHI it's there now c:
yeah, thanks guys
SHIT FIRST COMMENT
*annyeong*
Why cant people just be fans of the group as oppose to fans of group members?
i know that this is unfair, my bias is yeunjung, soobin, dawon, dayoung, luda, yeoreum, exy, seola, bona, eunseo, mei qi, xuan yi, cheng xiao...
i think that starship is being unfair in their line distributions cause they wanted a voice that suits that kind of song.
we must love them all, so please don't hate YEUNJUNG, like its all of her fault, other says that when she is added in the group, other members are not shining anymore. pls. just look in the positive side.
i know dawon dont deserve this, cause she is a talented girl, i even love her more in girl spirit.
pls dont hate, just love them. i cant speak in english so i cant really explain anything.
Apparently a new member named Kei took Yeoreum's place with 51.2s not bad
You're better than HEXA6ON coz they never do all group that have comeback. They just do a famous group instead of the underrated one. Keep it up! ^^
The disadvantages of having a big girl group; less lines for the members
Sistar would like to have a word with you
1:37 and 3:17
it doesn't sound Yeunjung at all
Before anyone start complaining, this what you get when there are 13 members in a group, i wish it would be less, 6 or 8 would be better.
SISTAR have 4 members, but it's pretty much the same with them. Just Starship things
After watching Produce 101 I'm very confident that Yeunjung is a very positive and humble girl. Starship giving her all the lines will make her look bad and it makes me worry for her. I don't want people to misunderstand her, she's not greedy T.T They should have made her a soloist if they were going to just give her practically the whole song to sing.
Yasss Chengxiao got lines💛but Isnt Dawon one of the main vocalists?? Or am i mistaken?
Also Exy : O
This is quite unexpected
Tell Me Why? InTenSiFiEd
I miss C Line and im new Ujung
Cheng Xiao only have repeated lines,
#JusticeForChengXiao
Yeonjung and the others girls...
Anyone else hear only Yeonjung during Dawon's parts? It seems like Yeonjung sang and they just had Dawon lipsync her parts for the MV. She'll probably sing them live but it's pretty messed up not to give her parts in the studio version :///
abbee ME I THOUGHT THAT THE WHOLE TIME LIKE WTF THAT DOESN'T SOUND LIKE DAWON AT ALL :|
Touchy Taehyung i literally only hear her in the background doing the "aaaaah~" @ 3:17. it's so sad idk why they gave lines to yj that couldve so easily gone to her.
my babe yeonjung. ♥
Well... Seola, Soobin, Dayoung and especially Dawon are very good as for rookies so I think that Yeonjung should sang less and Dawon and Seola more. And I understand that Yeonjung is main vocal so she should sing hooks and hit high notes but I don't understand why she sings parts that could be handled by weakest vocal in group. Soobin at 2:46 O.O It was so nice.
Luxorris blame starship and don't hate Yeonjung please :(
Where did I hated on Yeonjung? I just said what I'm thinking about this line distribution and why I don't like it, I'm allowed to do it even when you don't really liked it, okey? And If I even hated on Yeonjung I still can do it :)
How can the main vocalist have 11.9 secs??????
I dont think 1:33 was yeonjung, but Im not sure enough. Lets wait until live stage
And I dont think the last part is yeonjung... Its not like her voice._.
Am i the only one hating how they shared the lines?
In the minute 1:36 part is Luda/SeolA and the last part 3:15 it's not YeonJung, sounds like Yeoreum/Dayung
O cenário do MV me lembrou Secret delas...
InShOt Kpop é basicamente a intenção, já que representa o "planeta" delas
InShOt Kpop sim, quando vi as fotos achei que se passaria em uma escola, algo do tipo, mas não
amei o mv achei muito lindo , só não achei lindo a yeonjung com 50 segundos
Joao Jackson Sim, eu amo a Yeonjung, ela é minha bias, mas tinha tantas partes que poderiam ser cantadas pelas outras integrantes. Por mim ela poderia cantar só no refrão e nas high notes
eu também amo muito ela , mais olha as outras vocais tipo a Dawon só com 11 segundos
thanks you so much ^^
Bona's line 😍😍 I seriously love her voice!
also, Starship you suck. Dawon, Dayoung and Soobin could've sang any of Yeunjung's lines. I feel like the distribution for this group is only good for the sub vocalists. they have trouble giving enough lines to the good singers, if that's any testament to how talented the group is.
I actually think the line @ 1:38 is Soobin considering she's on the screen for it and it sounds her voice! but we'll wait for the live to figure it out!
at least no one gets 2 seconds parts, right 😂
and STARSHIP TELL ME WHY YOU DID DAWON DIRTY in this song :"(
I love Yeunjung but if you gave all the parts, she'll get a lot of hate :"(
I know that yeonjung is the most popular member and all but seriously after sistar i like that, i thought i wont be disappointed anymore
justice for my girl luda!!!
How come there is still no official release of the MV? I already checked Starship Ent channel and I don't see it on 1theK neither,
ZK Extreme it was on V app they released it there first
ATENCION HABLA HISPANA📣📣📣, soy un fan de Cosmic Girls💖 pero esto no se puede quedar asi. Luda es mi Amor Platonico😍 y tengo que esperar como 6 meses para que hagan comeback para escucharla cantar 7.6 segundos? y todo por la culpa de Yeonjung que solo se integro al grupo para opacar a las demas😠, a los fans de Yeonjung lo siento pero es la verdad y para variar siempre baila de las ultimas atras😭. Yeonjung, ella se llevo todas las lineas y la lider Exy💖 una de mis raperas favoritas canta 7.9 segundos. Starship por favor denle lineas a las otras. Todos los fans unidos💙.
Tambin Starship hace lo mismo con SISTAR, en I Like That Bora solo canto como 8 segundos y la otra como 1 minuto, ALTO A LA INJUSTICIA Y DENLE LINEAS A LAS OTRAS.
FANS DE COSMIC GIRLS Y SISTAR UNANSE A MI REVELION CONTRA STARSHIP PARA TRAER DE VUELTA LA LINE DISTRIBUTIONS PAREJAS Y EQUILIBRADAS.
Leandro Melgarejo Pero no crees que el problema esta en el número de integrantes, 13 es demasiado, especialmente cuando las que tienen buena voz cantan la mayoría de la canción. Para mi el perfecto numero es 6, nunca hay necesidad para tener mas de 10, calidad sobre cantidad. Pero estoy de acuerdo que tener mas de 50s para una persona es injusto especialmente para Dawon que era la vocalista principal.
Francisco Perez Estoy de acuerdo contigo pero si es un grupo de 13 miembros no crees que deberia ser MAS pareja y equilibrada la Line Distribution? pero estamos de acuerdo con la gran cantidad de segundos para una sola persona asi que unete a mi rebelion contra la injusticua de lineas en Starship 😉
Leandro Melgarejo Ste men:v Entiendo lo de Cosmic Girls, pero no tienes nada que hacer con Sistar. Esa "injusticia" se arregla con las canciones del álbum, donde, si realmente fueras fan, sabrías que las cosas se igualan.
Ale Ojeda Bueno reconosco lo de SISTAR pero me importa mas Cosmic Girls y que verdad que LUDA no cansa casi nada, en Secret solo canto 3 o 4 segundos 😉