How To Make Authentic Victorian Scottish Shortbread | Royal Upstairs Downstairs | Absolute History

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 30 тра 2024
  • At the time of this visit to Scone in Scotland, Victoria had been married to Albert for two years and had given birth to her first two children Princess Victoria and Prince Albert Edward.
    Amazingly their host, the Earl of Mansfield, who had been planning the trip for two years, had problems with cowboy builders along the way, and ended up with just 12 hours to impress the queen.
    This visit was part of a charm offensive the queen made to improve the monarchy's standing in Scotland. Scone was chosen partly for its symbolic place in Scottish history and also because for centuries Scottish kings were crowned here on the Stone of Scone. Tim reveals a mystery surrounding the precise whereabouts of the original stone. It was supposedly moved to Westminster Abbey for the kings and queens of England (including Victoria) to be crowned upon - but was it?
    It's like Netflix for history... Sign up to History Hit, the world's best history documentary service and get 50% off using the code 'AbsoluteHistory' bit.ly/3vn5cSH
    This channel is part of the History Hit Network. Any queries please contact: owned-enquiries@littledotstudios.com

КОМЕНТАРІ • 296

  • @saspurillie
    @saspurillie 3 роки тому +122

    when she breathed all over that decoration I was like ah yes the pre-times!

  • @gollywog6695
    @gollywog6695 3 роки тому +125

    2oz self raising flour
    19oz plain flour
    2oz rice flour
    8oz sugar
    7oz of unsalted softened butter sufficient to bring it together
    1 egg
    Put all flours in a bowl with half the sugar. Rub the butter in little by little until it's crumbly in appearance but can hold itself together. Add in the rest of the sugar and the egg. Combine.
    Roll out, cut and dock
    Bake at 180C for 20 minutes

    • @OldDunollieman
      @OldDunollieman 3 роки тому +9

      Double the self raising flour and skip the rice flour. Much better.

    • @ItsJustLisa
      @ItsJustLisa 3 роки тому +4

      Thank you! I want to make this one myself since shortbread is one of my favorite cookies.

    • @lostcontrol1981
      @lostcontrol1981 3 роки тому +10

      @@OldDunollieman I thought the rice flour was to make the cookies lighter and more delicate tasting (as rice has no gluten). When I make shortbread I usually use 1/2 flour + 1/2 cornstarch, and sugar as the dry ingredients, and butter as the liquid ingredient.

    • @princessrose17
      @princessrose17 3 роки тому +6

      i prefer my Great grandmothers shortbread recipe. born 1903 in Scotland.

    • @lostcontrol1981
      @lostcontrol1981 3 роки тому +1

      @@princessrose17 - does your great grandmother’s recipe have egg? I’m so confused by the recipe given in this video

  • @msdemeanor3797
    @msdemeanor3797 3 роки тому +113

    The metric version:
    56 grams self raising flour
    538 grams plain flour
    56 grams rice flour
    227 grams sugar
    198 grams of unsalted softened butter sufficient to bring it together
    1 egg
    Put all flours in a bowl with half the sugar. Rub the butter in little by little until it's crumbly in appearance but can hold itself together. Add in the rest of the sugar and the egg. Combine.
    Roll out, cut and dock
    Bake at 180C for 20 minutes

    • @pjleary7063
      @pjleary7063 2 роки тому +3

      Does the Victorian recipe in video use both self rising and regular flours? Any chance oat flour was used in that time?

    • @AnthonyLeighDunstan
      @AnthonyLeighDunstan 2 роки тому +2

      Great! Thank you! I did the same but didn’t hear him say the weight of the butter nor the oven stats. How did you decipher that?

    • @emiliamartucci8291
      @emiliamartucci8291 Рік тому +4

      @@AnthonyLeighDunstan The above proportions may - may be off. Isn’t the standard ratio 2 parts (2oz sugar) 4 parts (4 oz butter) 6 parts (6 oz flour)? Just asking. Hope an expert replies. Thanks if you do.

    • @margaretteoh1428
      @margaretteoh1428 Рік тому +2

      The usual recipe call for,2 flour: plain flour -& rice flour. butter, sugar

    • @kasie680
      @kasie680 Рік тому +1

      What’s the point of the sr flour 🤷🏼‍♀️ they dock it to prevent rising lol

  • @utej.k.bemsel4777
    @utej.k.bemsel4777 2 роки тому +18

    In Southern Germany we have some similar moulds for our "Springerle".

  • @lostcontrol1981
    @lostcontrol1981 3 роки тому +143

    Amazing all the money that was spent for a 12 hour visit. At my house it would have been “there’s the spare bedroom. We’ll order pizza at 6:00pm”. I guess that’s why the Queen has never popped by for a visit 🤣🤣🤣

    • @breeinatree4811
      @breeinatree4811 3 роки тому +3

      😂😂😂

    • @carmeno9635
      @carmeno9635 3 роки тому +23

      I don't even have an extra bedroom. The queen would just have to sleep on the couch with the TV on lol

    • @breeinatree4811
      @breeinatree4811 3 роки тому +4

      @@carmeno9635 😂🤣😂🤣

    • @vampcaff
      @vampcaff 3 роки тому +4

      Won't even cook for the queen. Lol

    • @rockwilder0
      @rockwilder0 3 роки тому +8

      You never know. There was a couple who invited the Queen to their wedding and she actually showed up.

  • @grimnirnacht
    @grimnirnacht 3 роки тому +28

    The recipe for anyone who wants to try making it too
    2oz self raising flour
    19oz plain flour
    2oz rice flour
    8oz sugar
    Softened butter sufficient to bring it together (they didn't give a quantity)
    1 egg
    Put all flours in a bowl with half the sugar. Rub the butter in little by little until it's crumbly in appearance but can hold itself together. Add in the rest of the sugar and the egg. Combine.
    Roll out, cut and dock
    Bake at 180C until done (time not specified - assume lightly golden)

    • @gollywog6695
      @gollywog6695 3 роки тому +2

      Elizabeth Black it did state the time. She said 180C for 20 minutes

    • @OstblockLatina
      @OstblockLatina 3 роки тому +2

      I'd additionally recommend a hearty chop with a freshly honed guillotine as a palate cleanser to crown the meal

    • @kristic4472
      @kristic4472 3 роки тому +1

      Thank you! I was wondering!

    • @serendipity9944
      @serendipity9944 3 роки тому +5

      Actually, my Nanna made the most delicious shortbreads, she got it from her mother. Family secret 🤫 but it’s not like this recipe

    • @grimnirnacht
      @grimnirnacht 3 роки тому +1

      @@gollywog6695 my bad, I missed that. Thanks :)

  • @tinktaylor444
    @tinktaylor444 8 місяців тому +4

    Interesting they used self rising flour and it had not been invented yet! I also never heard of an egg in a shortbread, but I must try this! 💙

  • @carmeno9635
    @carmeno9635 3 роки тому +33

    I really love history. I wish my friends loved history too

    • @lostcontrol1981
      @lostcontrol1981 3 роки тому +6

      You need to get better friends! We travel every year to places like Scotland, England, Wales, Iceland and Australia. We have a great time seeing castles, museums, archives, etc….

    • @sweetlikehoney5216
      @sweetlikehoney5216 3 роки тому +5

      Find friends that enjoy what you enjoy, you will be happy you did . Sorry old Frauds I mean friends no offenses lol

    • @carmeno9635
      @carmeno9635 3 роки тому +2

      @@lostcontrol1981 My friends are bored of history and don't find it interesting haha

    • @ramkuse7810
      @ramkuse7810 3 роки тому +1

      @@carmeno9635 it is not either ... Or.
      Enjoy the time with your hitherto existing friends and find new ones, that are interested in history, e.g. in local history societies

    • @robinbirdj743
      @robinbirdj743 Рік тому

      We do! ❤️

  • @thepartyfairyllc7678
    @thepartyfairyllc7678 3 роки тому +20

    We really need a second season of this show!!!!!

  • @kamanama3671
    @kamanama3671 3 роки тому +4

    Scotch shortbread when made correctly is Divine

  • @Dorky9394
    @Dorky9394 3 роки тому +31

    These two always brighten my day :)

    • @OldDunollieman
      @OldDunollieman 3 роки тому

      You don't have much of a life, do you?

    • @TheDilovely
      @TheDilovely 3 роки тому +1

      Same...I really enjoy their interaction.

    • @crow-t-robot
      @crow-t-robot 3 роки тому +8

      @@OldDunollieman Says the wet sock writing rude comments on youtube. Yikes bro.

    • @lennybuttz2162
      @lennybuttz2162 Рік тому

      They made me want to puke. I thought I was seeing a recipe video not a couple of old toads who enjoy the sound of their own voices way too much.

  • @pharossymphony
    @pharossymphony 3 роки тому +24

    lol. For some reason when at 13:51 she seems annoyed at him because when she makes the next cookie she goes at her own pace. Meanwhile he is trying to mansplain it to her even though she herself is a chef.

    • @sandraweiss4412
      @sandraweiss4412 3 роки тому +5

      I was thinking the exact same thing! He took things out of her hands too. My goodness, I'm sure she knows how to transfer cut out cookies to the baking tray. 🙄

    • @pjleary7063
      @pjleary7063 2 роки тому +1

      His kitchen, his rules. Chef’s prerogative.

    • @shadeson6910
      @shadeson6910 2 роки тому +1

      They have worked together many times before

    • @FigaroHey
      @FigaroHey Рік тому

      The information and instructions are for the audience, obviously. They are acting.

  • @kristialexander7677
    @kristialexander7677 Рік тому +3

    Wonderful! I have taught 18C American hearth cooking for over 35 years - hooray for all of Mr. Day's research. Time to bring him back, for more lessons!!!! Let him cook in his kitchen, historic recipes. Please!!!!

  • @serendipity9944
    @serendipity9944 3 роки тому +23

    My Nanna made the most delicious shortbreads ever. She got the recipe from her mother. It’s a family secret but now that my Nan has passed on I have taken the roll of making them. But it’s not like this recipe!!

    • @Zippythewondersquirrel
      @Zippythewondersquirrel 3 роки тому +5

      Try this,
      1 cup butter (softened)
      1/2 cup confectioners sugar
      1/4 cup cornstarch
      1 1/2 cup flour
      Mix, roll, cut, bake at 375 degrees Fahrenheit.

    • @sharynhay9993
      @sharynhay9993 3 роки тому +15

      My ex's great grandfather was given the warrant as shortbread maker to King George. Each monarch chose a preferred tradesman to receive the warrant for each item made for the place during his/her reign. The recipe is slightly different from this one for it's simplicity.
      Ingredients are weighed, not measured and all mixing is done by hand on the table, not a bowl. The result is a stiffer dough that is patted out into 3/4 inch cakes and imprinted with the family seal. The cakes are about 4" by 8" but each family adds it's own touch. In our generation each family chose their own seals and they will pass them down.
      This recipe yields a dry shortbread that can be wrapped and stored on a shelf for a year. Chunks are broken off and eaten with tea.
      The recipe shown here results in a thinner, flaky, tender shortbread used more for cookies. It is scored before baking. This is my favorite but doesn't store as long.
      In the family the tradition was for the oldest son to make it every year and he had possession of the iron imprinters. Enough was made for each family to get some and some was given as gifts. The recipe was kept in the family because the great grandfather who had the warrant said that if the family became impoverished they could make and sell it.

    • @freedomfreedom9523
      @freedomfreedom9523 Рік тому +4

      Thats real scottish shortbread if you use fruit powered sugar instead then sprinkle it on top and when it comes out I brush butter over top

    • @kathycarlson7947
      @kathycarlson7947 Рік тому +2

      @@sharynhay9993 thank you for sharing that history. I am amazed.

    • @lennybuttz2162
      @lennybuttz2162 Рік тому +1

      That is a lovely memory but I find it very annoying when people have "secret" recipes. It's quite selfish and often comes from an inflated ego and sense of self pride as if other people aren't worthy. They also tend to be very stingy with the secret items. I'm not saying your nanna was any of these things but it usually goes with the "secret" recipe or ingredient.

  • @jaxstorey6734
    @jaxstorey6734 Рік тому +10

    I've only just come across the two of you. Thank you so much for your wonderfully entertaining and informative tour of this "fine-looking house of reddish stone". All that preparation and money for a 12-hour visit!!!
    I'll bet that beautiful and fancy shortbread was delicious.

  • @marrishart4727
    @marrishart4727 3 роки тому +32

    There is risk in everything,so be prepared for ups and downs.

    • @mathewlawrence7140
      @mathewlawrence7140 3 роки тому

      By being modest in your spending, you can ensure you will get enough in your retirement and can give back to the community as well.

    • @jeremylerebvre-financialed5008
      @jeremylerebvre-financialed5008 3 роки тому

      diversification is relevant, and once you have confidence in your investment, you can adjust your profit and make bigger bets.

    • @jennyperkins7352
      @jennyperkins7352 3 роки тому

      Just do the necessary research, study and analyze before making any investment.

    • @justinsmith4958
      @justinsmith4958 3 роки тому

      From the research I have done so far as old as the pandemic the word is out, Bitcoin May reach $100k by next year, and is going to change a lot of people's life.

    • @kimkate9233
      @kimkate9233 3 роки тому

      Many people are struggling from grass to grass, the concept of Bitcoin after it became a household name.

  • @denkendannhandeln
    @denkendannhandeln Рік тому +40

    The quality and taste of shortbread depends entirely on the quality of the butter you use. It must be fresh, best made of untreated milk with a high fat content, produced by free ranging happy cows, who eat only grass and no artificial food. If you have the choice use only the best butter you can get, it is worth the extra price.

    • @stellagrau8871
      @stellagrau8871 Рік тому +4

      Here in my country butter is always fresh.Blesssed Uruguayan cows.0

    • @faodail3913
      @faodail3913 Рік тому

      @@stellagrau8871 Same here in New Zealand.

    • @trevorstolz8580
      @trevorstolz8580 Рік тому +1

      Thank you! I am going to try that. I have miniature jersey cows (google them). They are super cute. I have them so I can always have raw milk whether the government likes it or not! My cows are pampered and always on green grass when available.

    • @lennybuttz2162
      @lennybuttz2162 Рік тому +1

      Happy cows? You've been watching too many commercials. LOL Untreated milk? Do you mean raw milk straight from the farm?

    • @jegsthewegs
      @jegsthewegs Рік тому +1

      Make your own with organic cream. Cheaper too-and we all know the Scots like c h e a p 🤣

  • @psarah6777
    @psarah6777 3 роки тому +15

    They look amazing shortbread in Victoria period.I would love to make them.

  • @DrBrunoRecipes
    @DrBrunoRecipes 2 роки тому +5

    Amazing :) Greetings from Scotland. Have a wonderful day everyone!

  • @WaiferThyme
    @WaiferThyme 2 роки тому +7

    This shortbread is quite common here in Nova Scotia . I've made it myself.

    • @janisthompson9801
      @janisthompson9801 Рік тому +3

      And in BC! It’s the only recipe❤️🇨🇦❤️

  • @somewhat7
    @somewhat7 2 роки тому +3

    24:22 sitting at my computer in 2022 wondering where it all went wrong...

  • @JTRocks4Ever
    @JTRocks4Ever Рік тому +3

    I love Shortbread!

  • @Holidaygal
    @Holidaygal Рік тому +3

    Here's the recipe from the Queens baker
    Ingredients:
    250 mL (1 cup) unsalted butter at room temperature. The more fat in the butter the better.
    125 mL (1/2 cup) superfine or fruit sugar
    125 mL (1/2 cup) rice flour
    375 mL - 425 mL (1 1/2 to 1 3/4 cup) all purpose flour
    Method:
    In a bowl cream the butter.
    Gradually add sugar and beat until fluffy.
    Gradually add rice flour and all purpose flour until the mixture is too difficult to mix with a spoon.
    Turn onto a floured board and knead lightly, drawing in flour until the dough begins to crack.
    Form into a ball, cover in plastic wrap and refrigerate for at least 30 minutes.
    Preheat oven to 150ºC (300ºF).
    Cut ball into half.
    Place one segment on one side of an un-greased baking sheet.
    Pat the dough into a circular shape roughly 1/4 inch thick.
    Take a fork and prick a lovely pattern onto the top of the dough.
    Do the same for the second segment of dough.
    Bake for 45 minutes to 1 hour.
    When the dough is slightly golden remove from the oven and let sit for 5 minutes.
    Cut into wedges and remove from baking sheet to cooling rack.
    OR
    Roll out the dough to 1/4 inch thick and cut into cookie shapes.
    Place on an un-greased baking sheet and bake for 15 to 18 minutes in an oven set at 300ºF.
    When slightly golden remove from oven and let stand for 5 minutes.
    Remove from baking sheet onto cooling rack.

  • @EukalyptusBonBon
    @EukalyptusBonBon 3 роки тому +3

    Salute the Piper playing in the background

  • @patpeters6331
    @patpeters6331 3 роки тому +10

    Shortbread cookies....sooo good. 😋

    • @eunicestone838
      @eunicestone838 2 роки тому

      Pecan shortbread cookies are my favorite.

  • @winterquilting7318
    @winterquilting7318 Рік тому +6

    I e never heard of an egg in shortbread.

    • @kathycarlson7947
      @kathycarlson7947 Рік тому +1

      Nor have I. I lived in Scotland for 3 years and learned to make shortbread. No eggs ever. Interesting

    • @Luna.3.3.3
      @Luna.3.3.3 Рік тому +2

      I'm Canadian and don't believe there's egg in proper shortbread.

  • @barryandjackypowell8239
    @barryandjackypowell8239 Рік тому +6

    I have a book of genuine Scottish recipes, by author Patricia Blacklock in collaboration with the National Trust of Scotland and her Shortbread recipe comes from Culzean Castle but merely gives 12oz flour, to 4oz sugar and 8oz butter. I will try the recipe given here. I do have a Scottish shortbread mould but never knew about the docker! Will get my son to make me one.

    • @Ann-my1dg
      @Ann-my1dg Рік тому +5

      The one you have is the correct method - 3 ingredients is the traditional one. (plus a pinch of salt) In the case of shortbread less is best :)

    • @bakokat6982
      @bakokat6982 Рік тому +2

      @@Ann-my1dg
      Yes! Three ingredients, that’s how my English mum taught me how to make Scottish Shortbread.

    • @mmb_MeAndMyBees
      @mmb_MeAndMyBees Рік тому

      Your correct !
      Shortbread is :
      x3 Ingredients only :
      Butter, Sugar and White Flour (not Bread Flour !)
      From the Inventors of Shortbread, Scotland 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿
      And it's NOT a Cookie !!!
      It's Short - Bread, meaning Short (Buttery Crumbling in Texture !)
      Baked flat (not like Cakes, these needed the later invention of Baking (Rising) Agents.
      Shortbread is a sweet Teatime Treat, Baked, originally on a Griddle, which also cooked Oatcakes, as well as unlevened Bread, (to that made and baked in Ovens.)
      Every Scottish Home had a Cast Iron Griddle, an open Hearth (Fire) and a Porridge Pot.
      Simple. 😎

  • @angelasieg5099
    @angelasieg5099 3 роки тому +1

    I'm going to have to try this shortbread recipe these two are delightful

  • @sandymilton7633
    @sandymilton7633 3 роки тому +4

    Great video! I also get as excited about shortbread!!!

  • @tinyGrim1
    @tinyGrim1 3 роки тому +4

    Thank you

  • @noeraldinkabam
    @noeraldinkabam Рік тому

    0:38 that chair!

  • @violetdreams1799
    @violetdreams1799 2 роки тому +3

    *love* these shows! history with a recipe! 😊

  • @eternal8364
    @eternal8364 3 роки тому +3

    I’m obsessed with that shortbread 😍😍

  • @aurorajuarez9930
    @aurorajuarez9930 Рік тому

    Thanks so much for the story 👏🏻.

  • @deannastevens1217
    @deannastevens1217 3 роки тому +1

    Wonderful!!

  • @63artemisia63
    @63artemisia63 2 роки тому +1

    How sweet, they use the same shade of hair color to cover their gray 💕❤️💕

  • @grumpyoldwizard
    @grumpyoldwizard 3 роки тому +86

    You know your too rich when you refer to this palace as a “house”.

  • @feralbluee
    @feralbluee 2 роки тому +3

    OMG - look at ALL that gorgeous copper cooking wear!! imagine polishing all that! it would be never ending - once you’ve finished, you’d have to start all over again!!
    myself, i have one little bowl and a ladle brass-handled. :) 🍯

  • @thepitt80
    @thepitt80 3 роки тому +6

    And Victoria was only here for 12 hours! 😂😂😂😂😂

  • @Blessings.429
    @Blessings.429 3 роки тому +5

    I have a Wax Seal ring of Queen Victoria, Seal for someone in India doing her work. Silver & Gold.

  • @christinamiller4660
    @christinamiller4660 Рік тому

    it appears that the 'household' was run on a tight budget.....however, with the queen coming, methinks it might have been an occasion to 'pad the budget' a bit and use the 'overage' to sustain the 'household' for quite a bit AFTER the visit. As a scotsman myself (genetically speaking)....I know the thriftiness of the scotts...... this wouldn't have surprised me at all. delightful recount of an iconic event. thank you for posting.

    • @Trixtah
      @Trixtah Рік тому

      I doubt very much Her Maj would have paid anything towards the cost of the visit. It's not like a hotel with owners submitting a bill. Queen Elizabeth I was notorious for her long "progressions" staying in stately homes all around the country, practically (and actually) bankrupting many of her courtiers.
      I think I read somewhere it may have been a deliberate ploy - if an aristocrat seemed a bit too prosperous, Her Majesty would pay a *very* extended visit, and expect only the very, very best, including purpose-built furniture, rooms, or even entire buildings.

  • @jhb61249
    @jhb61249 Рік тому

    Ivan should do more performance work. Very nice to watch.

  • @dannydawn
    @dannydawn 3 роки тому +6

    Yo I love your videos... but could you make some about the first half of 20th century aside of the wars?
    I mean like the nightlife, music, style, crime and crime investigation, society, shopping and so on...

    • @emilydavies9012
      @emilydavies9012 2 роки тому

      Check out turn back time on absolute history, great stuff on the family and high street :)

  • @sam-ekunene6410
    @sam-ekunene6410 3 роки тому +2

    "Nudge, nudge, say no more", 😂😂😂😂😂.

  • @jojo-ir9um
    @jojo-ir9um 2 роки тому

    Very nice

  • @smallbeginning2
    @smallbeginning2 3 роки тому +12

    Geez the castle cook is a bossy one. Want to remind him that she's a chef too damn.

    • @OstblockLatina
      @OstblockLatina 3 роки тому +8

      He's being THE chef (he's also a culinary historian specializing in that era) in that kitchen and teaching HER (and the audience) about Victorian recipes and cooking techniques and fulfilling the role of the host in relation to her being a guest. Had he been doing a show where he would be knocking to her door to share some cooking ideas with him that she specializes in, SHE would've been in her right to be bossing him around. So no, you don't need to remind him of anything, he's doing nothing wrong.

    • @gollywog6695
      @gollywog6695 3 роки тому +2

      Not all chefs can bake and vise versa

    • @smallbeginning2
      @smallbeginning2 3 роки тому

      @@OstblockLatina well, I didn't like his attitude. According to me he was rude. End of.

  • @mazhansen8804
    @mazhansen8804 Рік тому +1

    I love shortbread

  • @Laffingrl
    @Laffingrl 3 роки тому

    She really did 'take the biscuit!'

  • @lisamcdivitt3606
    @lisamcdivitt3606 3 роки тому +4

    Lovely music in the background. I wonder what the name of that Strathspey tune was?

  • @iblessyou.forextrablessing7597
    @iblessyou.forextrablessing7597 2 роки тому +1

    Piped into buttery scone

  • @emilydavies9012
    @emilydavies9012 2 роки тому +3

    If I was Scottish id still hate the English (me ) for Culloden.

  • @catblack4091
    @catblack4091 2 роки тому +3

    All that for a 12 hour visit. Bizarre!

  • @wurlitzer895
    @wurlitzer895 8 місяців тому

    1842 - the year in which Arthur Sullivan (of the 'Gilbert and Sullivan' partnership) was born in Lambeth, SE London on 13th May.

  • @libertyann439
    @libertyann439 5 місяців тому

    Breathing on the shortbread. Perfect for covid!😂

  • @dotcassilles1488
    @dotcassilles1488 Рік тому +1

    I found a recipe that had brown sugar, butter and plain flour as the only ingredients. It is very crumbly... I will have to dig the recipe out of my file, I give shortbread as presents at Christmas. This year I am going to try to make it with a gluten free flour as last year I was diagnosed as being coeliac (very allergic to gluten containing foods like wheat) and was very sad to give up my favourite sweet biscuit . I hope to get my extended family to compare the two types (I will stick to the gluten free stuff). I have to be very careful about using the flour with gluten so as not to mix them up by mistake and gluten myself.
    Thankyou to all who offer recipes in the comments, they are wonderful inspiration to adapt my recipe into a gluten free version. Blessings from South Eastern Australia, Dot

    • @wartgin
      @wartgin Рік тому

      I had a recipe with vanilla extract and I think you could use different extracts for the gluten vs gluten free versions. Vanilla in one vs almond or orange extract in the other.

    • @Trixtah
      @Trixtah Рік тому

      Gluten free works really well for shortbread. I wouldn't use brown sugar myself - raw caster sugar would hold together better. As for not getting them mixed up, I'd suggest making them in different shapes - rounds vs fingers, maybe. Obviously choose your preferred shape for your ones!

  • @eunicestone838
    @eunicestone838 2 роки тому +2

    Are cowboy builders what we call "fly by night". They work til they get some money and fly away by night so they don't have to finish the job!

  • @christinewilson1538
    @christinewilson1538 2 роки тому +2

    Why doesn't he say how much butter?

  • @EnlightenedCate
    @EnlightenedCate 6 місяців тому

    I tried this recipe the other day and I couldn't get it to come together. I ended up throwing the whole lot out and using a different recipe where you cream the butter and sugar first. Much better.

  • @octaviorangel1726
    @octaviorangel1726 3 роки тому +4

    Shes keeping a grudge for not being able to use the docker

    • @jackiepayne7843
      @jackiepayne7843 3 роки тому +2

      I don’t blame her! Selfish son of a bachelor!

  • @lennybuttz2162
    @lennybuttz2162 Рік тому +1

    There's probably more than 1,000 recipe for shortbread but they're all basically the same.

  • @davidmeyer6908
    @davidmeyer6908 3 роки тому +12

    Alright, any other Mrs Crocombe fans here?

  • @ellencarbone9346
    @ellencarbone9346 3 роки тому +1

    I wish they told the full recipe for the shortbread. I didn't heard them say how much butter and that is very important as too much and you get a puddle when you bake it.
    2 oz self rising flour
    19 oz plain flour
    2 oz rice flour
    8 oz sugar (1/2 at a time)
    Butter (3/4 or 1 lb it looked ??)
    1 egg
    Bake 20 min at 180°c
    Has anyone made it that could confirm how much butter to use?

    • @gollywog6695
      @gollywog6695 3 роки тому +1

      7oz of unsalted butter

    • @ellencarbone9346
      @ellencarbone9346 3 роки тому

      @@gollywog6695 thanks. I might try to make some, when it cools down, now that I have the portions.

    • @sandrajames7961
      @sandrajames7961 3 роки тому

      14 tablesoons

    • @sandrajames7961
      @sandrajames7961 3 роки тому

      14 tablespoons

    • @herbrand47
      @herbrand47 2 роки тому

      7oz or 198G unsalted soft butter.

  • @robertkinkaid4732
    @robertkinkaid4732 3 роки тому +9

    Egg in shortbread???

    • @breeinatree4811
      @breeinatree4811 3 роки тому +6

      That's what I thought. My Scottish grandmothers recipe never called for it.

    • @boyinblue.
      @boyinblue. 3 роки тому +1

      He did say that we wouldn't normally add an egg in modern times, maybe it’s something that was dropped from the recipe over the years?

    • @breeinatree4811
      @breeinatree4811 3 роки тому

      @@boyinblue. could be but the recipe I have is from my great grandmother. So its been in the family from Victorian times. Might be a regional thing, or an English thing.

    • @boyinblue.
      @boyinblue. 3 роки тому +4

      @@breeinatree4811 it’s probably an English thing, they have an obsession with adding things that don’t belong both in history and apparently shortbread.

    • @Himbros
      @Himbros 3 роки тому +6

      The historian spoke of an Italian confectioner, and Italian shortcrust has a bit less butter and some eggs in it

  • @dionanderson8185
    @dionanderson8185 2 роки тому +1

    When she breathes all over the shortbread my mind 🤯😂

    • @Trixtah
      @Trixtah Рік тому

      All I could think was "ugh". It also wasn't very effective. I think it needed a light dab of water a few minutes before to "tack up" the gum arabic again, then apply the gold foil.

  • @glendafulton
    @glendafulton 2 роки тому +4

    I would think you should wear gloves to handle such old rare books or am I wrong ???

  • @Willow893
    @Willow893 3 роки тому

    Food and the monarch. What else do you want?

  • @naomipagecoachingreddragon5991
    @naomipagecoachingreddragon5991 2 роки тому +1

    I absolutely love the Scottish accent 😜😊💜🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺

  • @chavak3497
    @chavak3497 Рік тому

    If "clerks" are CLOCKs in England, what are Clocks? Clerks?

  • @janicewolk6492
    @janicewolk6492 Рік тому

    At Queen Elizabeth's funeral, the stone either went back to England or back to Scotland.

  • @harrietfishlow685
    @harrietfishlow685 2 роки тому +4

    I opened this for the recipe for shortbread, not a jolly description of Victoria’s trip to Scotland by a really irritating couple.

    • @63artemisia63
      @63artemisia63 2 роки тому

      Me, too neither. Decided to look up the recipe.

  • @johnpluta1768
    @johnpluta1768 3 роки тому +1

    Downton Abbey anyone?

  • @soniatriana9091
    @soniatriana9091 3 роки тому +12

    In the kitchen, Ivan is too much of a Control Freak!!!

  • @Amaqse
    @Amaqse 2 роки тому +1

    oh my god its sugar butter egg and flour and yet this supposed to be food specialist is almost in spasm because of its beauty..

  • @annettefournier9655
    @annettefournier9655 3 роки тому

    I always stress over to add egg or not to egg.

    • @catrionamacfarlane4949
      @catrionamacfarlane4949 2 роки тому +1

      no egg in my recipe

    • @pjleary7063
      @pjleary7063 2 роки тому

      The video recipe has far less butter than traditional recipes to allow for the egg.
      Adding the egg reduces the fat.

    • @emiliamartucci8291
      @emiliamartucci8291 Рік тому

      @@pjleary7063 i did not hear how much butter was used. Could you please tell us how much butter he used? Thanks much.

  • @jvallas
    @jvallas Рік тому

    Am I the only one who thinks the male baker was a bit of a control freak?😊

  • @tiner3315
    @tiner3315 3 роки тому +20

    Her breathing on the food like that just doesn’t feel right after 2020 😬
    At least they didn’t actually eat it ...

    • @lostcontrol1981
      @lostcontrol1981 3 роки тому +5

      I was thinking the same thing! After wearing a mask for the last year, breathing on dessert until it’s moist seems so wrong.

    • @OstblockLatina
      @OstblockLatina 3 роки тому +5

      Her (or anyone for the matter) breathing on food feels bad enough, but the fact something that costed so much money and time to make would just be chucked away without being eaten doesn't make it any better to me.

    • @lannguyen-pu1db
      @lannguyen-pu1db 3 роки тому +2

      Not nearly as bad as birthday cakes... For EVERYBODY TO ACTUALLY EAT🤢🤧🤒💀

    • @bethroundell8424
      @bethroundell8424 2 роки тому

      Would holding the confection over a slightly steaming cup of water imitate the cooks warm moist breath? That would be my alternative to breathing on the art. Fitting my closed family circle nickname is Breathless!

  • @user-grannyb
    @user-grannyb Рік тому

    Can anyone confirm if in this context is “Plain Flour” what we would call cake flour, or all purpose flour? It makes a difference.😊

    • @hsh8729
      @hsh8729 Рік тому

      Right?!

    • @dotcassilles1488
      @dotcassilles1488 Рік тому

      Plain Flour is the flour that doesn't have any raising agent like baking powder added to it before being packaged. Cake flour usually has baking powder in it to make the cake rise when it is cooked. I think all purpose flour may be the same as what we Aussies call self raising flour, it has baking powder mixed into it. To turn plain flour into flour for a cake you add the baking powder or another raising agent such as yeast, fizzy mineral water or carbonated water, beer or soft drink into the mixture.
      Hope this helps you out.
      Blessings from South Eastern Australia, Dot

    • @dotcassilles1488
      @dotcassilles1488 Рік тому

      Forgot to say if you make a cake using plain flour and forget to put in the baking powder/raising agent then the cake will not rise, is likely to collapse in on itselfand take longer to cook as the baking powder helps to trap the air in bubbles within the cake making it light and fluffy. You don't need to ask me how I know... One time I was making a birthday cake for someone and got the wrong flour in the mixture. Only found out after baking the mixture and being disappointed with the resulting mess. I tasted it but didn't like the texture, very heavy and not properly cooked in the middle. The chooks on our farm loved it tho, lol.

    • @heatherreid2567
      @heatherreid2567 Рік тому

      All purpose flour

    • @Trixtah
      @Trixtah Рік тому

      I agree with all purpose - not high gluten like bread flour, nor extra low like cake flour. That's what they added the rice flour for - to ensure there was less protein, giving a cake flour-like effect. If you have cake flour, I'd certainly use it for shortbread, even if it wouldn't be exactly like this recipe. It'd enhance that melt-in-the-mouth texture. And I'd omit the "self-raising" flour. What a waste of time.

  • @Orpilorp
    @Orpilorp Рік тому

    Are you sure they would have used self rising flour and rice flour in Victoria's days?

  • @anastasia10017
    @anastasia10017 6 місяців тому

    How much butter for the recipe ??????? if he used 8 oz sugar, that means 16 oz butter ? = 24 oz of flour ?

  • @delishme2
    @delishme2 2 роки тому +5

    Rosemary did so well not to react to all that mansplaining. The chef spoke to her as though she was completely unfamiliar with flour sugar and eggs. Ffs what was that ?? 😆

    • @FigaroHey
      @FigaroHey Рік тому +2

      He's explaining to the AUDIENCE, obviously. Imagine how annoyed everyone would be if they just got in with it and didn't say step by step what to do.

  • @nikolaaston5239
    @nikolaaston5239 3 роки тому +49

    The presenters are unbearable, and that’s exactly why I’m watching it.

  • @timg3504
    @timg3504 2 роки тому +3

    I guess I’m not the only one who noticed that Ivan was annoying.

  • @GenaF
    @GenaF 3 роки тому +1

    16:52 I am very surprised those looking at the Book of Expenditure didn't wear white gloves.

    • @thehutch7728
      @thehutch7728 2 роки тому +2

      They don’t do that so much anymore because it’s been found that wearing gloves tears up the delicate pages. Typically everyone washes their hands very well to remove as much oil as possible, and then they feel it is safe to look through old volumes.

  • @ella_cinder4361
    @ella_cinder4361 3 роки тому +2

    I realize you're going for authenticity when laying the gold leaf, but perhaps for hygienic reasons; a little water would have done the trick

  • @KittyHerder
    @KittyHerder Рік тому

    It blows my mind that they coat dessert with gold just so the queen can poop it out three days later.

  • @paulasmith4251
    @paulasmith4251 Рік тому

    Hi rosemary do you miss your side kick Jennifer xxx

  • @Jade_1872
    @Jade_1872 3 роки тому +2

    Now I want shortbread, darn you stomach

  • @theeutecticpoint
    @theeutecticpoint 3 роки тому

    Oooh, very interesting "skim milk" not "skimmed milk"

    • @gollywog6695
      @gollywog6695 3 роки тому +1

      We call it Skimmed milk in the UK. Well us in Scotland do.

    • @theeutecticpoint
      @theeutecticpoint 3 роки тому

      @@gollywog6695 that's the interesting part, the ledger said "skim" not "skimmed"

    • @CelestialCookies
      @CelestialCookies 3 роки тому +1

      @@theeutecticpoint Maybe they just wrote it that way to save time? It's just my silly assumption

  • @eunicestone838
    @eunicestone838 2 роки тому

    They should take the stone back to Scotland. Only bring it down when needed.

    • @Holidaygal
      @Holidaygal Рік тому +1

      It was returned in 1996. In December 2020, the Scottish Government announced the stone would be relocated to Perth City Hall. In September 2022 following the death of Queen Elizabeth II, it was announced that the stone would be temporarily returned to Westminster Abbey for the coronation of Charles III.

  • @sherriepectol9324
    @sherriepectol9324 Рік тому

    He said they nicked our scoon. First of all regardless of King James becoming the King of England and Scotland ect. The throne and the scoone would have belonged to the Scottish People and Scotland. Leave it to the British to claim that everything belongs to them. It blows my mind that the British/German monarchs did everything in their power to rule the world on their tiny island. It does say alot that they have ruled over so many Countries.

  • @notit340
    @notit340 3 роки тому +4

    It must be hard working with a food historian 😆

  • @axelsmith4722
    @axelsmith4722 3 роки тому +3

    Now that's a travesty! It isn't 'Victorian bread' if there's no plaster in the dough.

  • @melissasaint3283
    @melissasaint3283 2 роки тому +4

    The term "cowboy builder" is, I have to say, offensive.
    If they're your own British scam artists, please don't name them after a totally unrelated career in another country which, based on online discussion, the British don't know anything about. They're confusing "cowboy" (a specific job, and later subculture) with an Old West "outlaw" or lawless gunslinger.
    This is like if we called Americans who pluck things from unlocked cars "Yorkshire gardeners" 😂

    • @dotcassilles1488
      @dotcassilles1488 Рік тому

      As far as I understand "cowboy builder" means someone who listens to what his client wants then does it his way anyway... Not necessarily a scam artist but rather someone who stubbornly sticks to what they believe is right, doing their job in the way and time that suits them.
      The stereotypical cowboy is someone who knows how to get the job done, that will do it in his own good time... Ask them nicely and then get out of the way. They won't be told how to do a job.
      I'm sorry if you find this offensive, I don't believe the guy in this video meant to offend, and neither do I. Blessings, Dot

    • @FigaroHey
      @FigaroHey Рік тому

      @@dotcassilles1488 Cowboy builders are here today and gone tomorrow. It's definitely a derogatory term. They are builders who take your money, do nothing or half a job or a quick and incomplete job and then disappear. You lose money and get a half-finished job or flimsy work.

    • @FigaroHey
      @FigaroHey Рік тому

      You don't know the history of the term. From Wikipedia: "In the Tombstone, Arizona, area during the 1880s, the term "cowboy" or "cow-boy" was used pejoratively to describe men who had been implicated in various crimes. One loosely organized band was dubbed "The Cowboys", and profited from smuggling cattle, alcohol, and tobacco across the U.S.-Mexico border. The San Francisco Examiner wrote in an editorial, "Cowboys [are] the most reckless class of outlaws in that wild country ... infinitely worse than the ordinary robber." It became an insult in the area to call someone a "cowboy", as it suggested he was a horse thief, robber, or outlaw." This is the sense behind "cowboy builder," a builder who is little more than a thief.

    • @melissasaint3283
      @melissasaint3283 Рік тому

      @@FigaroHey lol, I love how far you had to scan to find that. In an extensive wikipedia Article for the term "Cowboy" that covers hundreds of years and multiple countries, with uses in America that are primarily about legitimate careers working with livestock, you had to scan many paragraphs until you found a small subsection that springs up during the Civil War, and does back down soon after..
      That definition is not "the history of the term"...and definitely not it's origin, which begins outside of English.
      It was a brief aberration, only regionally used during a time of immense internal strife.

  • @sallyevans5734
    @sallyevans5734 2 роки тому

    Get to the recipe

    • @63artemisia63
      @63artemisia63 2 роки тому +1

      Realized right away that I was just going to look up the recipe.

  • @jimmydemetriou7847
    @jimmydemetriou7847 7 місяців тому +1

    What is it with these people and their secrets.? They gave the ingredients, but deliberately didn't say the weight of the butter. Not that it matters because it is not too difficult to work out the ratios, and they know people will want to know...but still, it is petty mindedness!

  • @OstblockLatina
    @OstblockLatina 3 роки тому +4

    Rosemary (or anyone for the matter) breathing on sb's food feels bad enough, but the fact something that costed so much money and time to make would've just been chucked away without being eaten doesn't make it any better to me.
    All this waste and squandering of funds listed in yet another episode of this show makes the absence of anti-monarchic revolution in England even more incomprehensible to me.

  • @gaylebynumcardosa7034
    @gaylebynumcardosa7034 2 роки тому

    Is it me or is this host very camp? He is very funny. It seems he used to host some antiques show that I watched from time to time and I didn't like him at all on that show. I like him here.

  • @proudgrandma138
    @proudgrandma138 Рік тому

    Unappetizing. No fingers in my dough

  • @mindyours2771
    @mindyours2771 3 роки тому +2

    Please bring back the Turn Back Time series. Not going to lie, these presenters are a little boring

  • @katarinastene9069
    @katarinastene9069 2 роки тому

    Emmm..... I would not eat some shortbread wich was breathed on of another person.... Brrrrrr..