Okay fine but there's a big difference between being critical and/or giving a negative critique of someone's food and just going out of your way to be an asshole to someone.
This man, rarely, RARELY offers good criticism towards ANY cook whatsoever. I understand that there is always a script. Yet becoming a mood killer over 15 episodes is way too much
@@jade7631ill be open minded, he does critique but he is out of pocket throwing food away without tasting it and judging food based on looks usually always and not on taste
@@jade7631you do understand they taste it before it was even served to them right.? They even explain this before final tasting and picking top 3.. plus Joe does help and gives really good cooking tips that actually help the contestants.. it's just overshadowed with how people like you only pick up on what he does during the final judgement.. if he's a bad judge then Ramsay won't invite him to judge over and over again.. I'm a massive MasterChef fan and Joe's tips and helpfulness rarely gets shown on the show but those rare instances you can see how he wants the amateur cooks to learn.. of course he's gonna be pissed if someone's not listening to advices and thinks what they're doing is correct and will wow the judges just to prove them right and the cooking is terrible.. I mean let me ask you this.. have you ever taught someone in the field of your expertise and they shrugged you off to the sides saying they know what they're doing just for them to prove you are right and they are stupid.? Irritating isn't it..? Well that's Joe for you.. Ramsay is also like that but he is much more constrained.. yet we see Ramsay can also be overboard like in Hells Kitchen where he teaches professional chefs what to do only for them to think they know better and fuck up..
@@A.jmmmm04I think on masterchef, other than taste, they also have to judge the food based on looks because they're trying to find the best homecooks from all of the US. So SOMETIMES simple isn't the answer. When you become the winner of masterchef you will open your own restaurant and so you have to be professional.
Theres a difference between attacking and giving criticism. gosh why people these days using words misleadingly, im scared of future era communications
@@basedneutral1173lmao it's not that deep and he's right. Joe is just attacking people. Not even the food. One time he "critize" the plating not by mentioning it looks mismatched, or lack of contrast, or y'know any other technical term. He said "are you proud of this plating? I'm not impressed, it looks cartoony" like, how do you improve from that comment. What even is cartoony?
im ok if the pride based on something real like what Gordon did, absolutely respect Gordon, but this fking Joe guy is just Stupidly Arrogance based on his ego and bully pride.
Worst part is compared to Graham, Gordon, Aaron etc Hes not even a chef, half the time he has no idea what hes even talking about when it comes to all the important cooking stuff.
It’s a character. He won’t say that outside Masterchef ON CAMERA because of nda’s and the potential of him returning. All the chefs on that were judged critically and heavily like that by him all said he’s a nice guy, so.
Yeah, after he said that, I kind of just lost respect for him because Christine was an amazing chef, and the fact that Joe called her a liability, even though she had so much talent just pissed me off so much.
He is totally correct. a blind person being a chef. how the hell does she know what the ingredients are. how does she not burn herself on the stove? How does she know the correct measurements for the ingredients. How does she know The correct temperature for the oven. It is totally ludicrous. 🤪. Off camera I am almost totally positive that there is someone helping her. she only won because they felt sorry for her and it was good for the show and it was politically correct
Except Cutter was indeed the most obnoxious and baffling contestant during that season. He reached the Top 5 yet he was consistently bad, only having a few good dishes. Not defending Joe, he's just as pretentious. Just saying that some of the cringe-inducing contestants at least get deserving nasty reviews.
Right. Because only the most knowledgable should ever be allowed an opinion. Also Joe is extremely knowledgable. He owns a bunch of restaurants, his mom made millions off of cookbooks. Deal with it.
@@AlexDuWaldtin the nicest way possible: knowledge of cooking should absolutely not be measured by how many restaurants you own and that is a crazy criterion to suggest. Any Michelin-starred chef on Earth knows more about food than Salt Bae.
Remember the time when he said "do you miss your husband, well.. you might see him tonight" to a contestant who was not safe in the competition. Why tf would you attack someone's personal information in a competition.
@@frenchfriedbagel7035 Gordon Ramsay is on the same line as Marco Pierre White. Severe, strict, but willing to give advice in order for people to improve (if they have the right behavior and don't act all cocky and shit)
@@astrovisionbroadcastingunion Gordon does like to talk shit, but he usually and almost always does it in a jokey poking fun kind of way and doesn't really 100% meant what he said.
@VIDEOHOMESYSTEM and he has no right to open his counterfeit mouth on the topic of food if it wasn’t for his mom and being able to coast by on her accolades. Joe embodies the essence of not earning your station and his criticisms strongly reflect how little he knows.
What your saying is people who can’t sing or dance can’t be judges on America’s for talents. Or only athletes can judge on Olympics or only criminal can be judges. You don’t need to be a chef to judge food. You just need to know food. Joe is a winemaker and restauranteur.
A good non-chef judge that I've noticed is Matt Preston from MasterChef Australia. He's a food critic/journalist, and is known globally in the culinary world. The basic difference between Joe and Matt is that Matt is unironically more knowledgeable and open-minded about food. He's familiar with cooking techniques and skills, despite not being in a professional kitchen himself. He also travels the world because it's his literal job, and that he's not eurocentric unlike Mr. Baldy. When he gives criticism it's constructive and actually insightful, he talks about the presentation and considers the techniques applied just by looking at a dish. He doesn't feel like a snob. The show and himself also acknowledge greatly the fact that he's not a chef. When he's shown cooking in the show, he would always just do simple, cheaty recipes that are easy to make that literally any person with a kitchen and oven can do.
He never gives feedback though, he just says disappointing, whenever contestants try to get creative he shuts them down, he thinks of food way too conservatively
@@basedneutral1173 Nothing I said is to the contrary, my point is that Joe doesn’t care about any of those factors. He’ll demean the contestant simply for the sake of it.
@@billqiu4692 Not really. He doesn't care more into creativity sh1t most of the times. If someone put so much detail over my food too, i wouldn't even enjoy eating it. Food is meant to be consumed and tasted, not for creativity or art. A normal steak is already beautiful naturally, don't need to ruin the fk of it.
@@basedneutral1173agreed. These judges clearly und that presentation is merely the surface level, though it does show what kind of chef they're dealing with.
So does that mean only criminals should judge other criminals in court? Only video game developers should review video games? Only top athletes at the Olympics should judge the other athletes? I can keep going but the point is you don’t have to have certain talents to judge the results of those talents. Most food critics aren’t even chefs.
@@nolanhewitt2563 Joe co owns 30 restaurants in four different countries. What exactly makes him unqualified to judge food? Again, most food critics are not chefs.
So he does not feel bad. Should of asked him about the time he was mean to Christine ha. Cause she is blind she is a liability in the kitchen. He is not a judge he is a jerk how he was not fired is still crazy to me
A judge I respect is someone like chef Michael from Masterchef Canada. He gives you the good points and other things that can improve the dish. His decisions are final, but he still wants the best out of those home cooks. If it's blatantly bad, he'll also tell you why instead of slamming it into the trash right away.
People defend joe and say hes just "doing his job" no he isnt. he the amount of times he targets the food that he is supposed to "judge" is extremely lacking, and his ability to provide advice and give feedback, which is what judging entails, is similarly lacking, especially when comparing him to other judges on the show. Instead, he attacks the chefs themselves, being downright rude to many of them. You can be harsh as a judge, sure, but to be rude, discrimatory, and outright a bad person is simply unacceptable and, in his words, is "digusting".
"Those are three big mistakes. Finally, Bastianich explains he is not a chef, but that doesn't mean he can't throw down in the kitchen. In fact, he's confident he would beat both of his fellow judges, Gordon and Aarón, in a competition. “I could easily predict that I would win, even though I'm not a chef,” he reveals." Yeah he's beyond arrogant, he's downright delusional.
OK that was a bad example of Cutter. He was actually asking an appropriate question and none of the judges actually gave him a non passive aggressive answer😂
Yall are some weaklings. Tough love. Thats his way of showing someone that they need to imporve their dish. Honestly, without Joe, Master Chef would be soft and no real criticism. Except for Gordon of course.
I think the moment that cemented the fact that he doesnt know what he is talking about was the garlic bread incident where the other judges are just flabbergasted when he said garlic bread cheapens a traditional italian cuisine
He was a little bit sweeter and shared some guidance with only one contestant ever and that was Luca. Joe is actually very snobbish and does judge people by their personality than their food. I don't hate him though.
I refuse to believe that’s actually how he’s like and that he’s not just playing his character right here. Until I meet a person in real life, I won’t make any real judgements on them as a person. I’ll judge his made up character, just not him.
@@user-sf9gs2pg1b Thank you sooooo much for your comment. No one in this Forum had met the REAL HIM, I suppose. These Reality Shows are not 100% real, afterall. The people involved were doing what they were told, most of the time.
Tearing down Tali was more than necessary and only Joe had the balls to call him out. Dude's delusional, proclaims himself a genius, takes no notes, no feedback and cooks subpar stuff.
@@YonkoBlackbeard lol no. The 1st restaurant he opened was not inherited from his parents. You probably just heard his parents were famous so you assume he just inherited everything 🤣🤣
So far Gordon Ramsay & Alvin Leung is my fav judges yes Alvin Leung throwing the food, but i really appreciate that he still taste the contestants dishes❤
Nah you know what, I get it. I honestly understand the satisfaction of cutting down someone’s major hubris. He was only insufferable to the people who acted insufferable. And if anyone has genuinely watched master chef from top to bottom, they really did have a lot of insufferable, over confident cooks who thought their food was gods gift to this earth.
He's also on a SHOW. He has to spice things up to the absolute maximum. If he just said, "food's bad," then it wouldn't be half as entertaining. Personally for me, Joe's overreactions make the show even more enjoyable because of how over the top he gets.
There's NOTHING WRONG about his comments. He makes his reviews for YOU, for all the Contestants who have a chance to meet him. Anyone who doesn't like these, just go back home. Perhaps they don't know WHAT they really want. 😅
What you mean Tali? He is one of the most arrogant contestants to ever join masterchef. He thinks he is better than Gordon Ramsay even though he's no good at all. Cutter is a better cook than he is.
If you watch Masterchef Italy he's completely different. Harsh sometimes, especially in the first seasons, but overall definitely not as mean as americans perceived.
Ironic that he made the claim about the guy being presumptuous and responding with “I’m a judge,” yet other times REFUSING to try a dish. Hypocrisy, no?
i like Joe a lot, to me he is honest, some of them need to be put in their places, so many have big egos and he's good at taking them down a notch, well done!
Out of all the chefs I love Joe tbh yes he’s critical but one it’s a show, two he’s judging idiots who serve him raw pork, made him a disgusting pizza, like if I was given shit food and have to be dealing with 6 shit plates and 2 good I’d be irritated asf myself and not give a shit about hurting someone’s feelings after they insulted food
Oh my goodness he’s even being critical of the question he’s being asked😅😅😅
😂😂😂😂
Nah that asian or Chinese guy is way more annoying the one with glasses
@@deathkiller2213From canada? Nah he only like that in the first couple seasons
@@deathkiller2213 u prolly only seen one episode. he's only like that in season 1 lmaoo
Okay fine but there's a big difference between being critical and/or giving a negative critique of someone's food and just going out of your way to be an asshole to someone.
EXACTLY.
He can’t give criticism because he’s not an actual chef so he’d look like a dumbass if he gave actual critiques
@VIDEOHOMESYSTEM Pretty cool burn, guy who just time travelled here from 1991.
@VIDEOHOMESYSTEMclearly not captain obvious if tons of people dont get it 😂
@VIDEOHOMESYSTEM are you him?
"I'm a judge I have to be critical"
You're not being critical, your a bully.
Completely different things
nope
He is and cutter and tali aren't?
You're
@@roarer700as if this video is about them 😑
I bet yall wouldnt say this if it was gordon or anyone else
This man, rarely, RARELY offers good criticism towards ANY cook whatsoever.
I understand that there is always a script. Yet becoming a mood killer over 15 episodes is way too much
He does give criticism. I think what your talking about is FEEDBACK
@@jade7631ill be open minded, he does critique but he is out of pocket throwing food away without tasting it and judging food based on looks usually always and not on taste
@@A.jmmmm04 what he did is out of line. But the reasoning for them is fine. He could be nicer with it though.
@@jade7631you do understand they taste it before it was even served to them right.? They even explain this before final tasting and picking top 3.. plus Joe does help and gives really good cooking tips that actually help the contestants.. it's just overshadowed with how people like you only pick up on what he does during the final judgement.. if he's a bad judge then Ramsay won't invite him to judge over and over again.. I'm a massive MasterChef fan and Joe's tips and helpfulness rarely gets shown on the show but those rare instances you can see how he wants the amateur cooks to learn.. of course he's gonna be pissed if someone's not listening to advices and thinks what they're doing is correct and will wow the judges just to prove them right and the cooking is terrible.. I mean let me ask you this.. have you ever taught someone in the field of your expertise and they shrugged you off to the sides saying they know what they're doing just for them to prove you are right and they are stupid.? Irritating isn't it..? Well that's Joe for you.. Ramsay is also like that but he is much more constrained.. yet we see Ramsay can also be overboard like in Hells Kitchen where he teaches professional chefs what to do only for them to think they know better and fuck up..
@@A.jmmmm04I think on masterchef, other than taste, they also have to judge the food based on looks because they're trying to find the best homecooks from all of the US. So SOMETIMES simple isn't the answer. When you become the winner of masterchef you will open your own restaurant and so you have to be professional.
He's not even criticizing the food, he's just attacking the person
Theres a difference between attacking and giving criticism.
gosh why people these days using words misleadingly, im scared of future era communications
@@basedneutral1173it's not that deep lol, plus what they said makes sense and not misleading
@@basedneutral1173lmao it's not that deep and he's right. Joe is just attacking people. Not even the food. One time he "critize" the plating not by mentioning it looks mismatched, or lack of contrast, or y'know any other technical term. He said "are you proud of this plating? I'm not impressed, it looks cartoony" like, how do you improve from that comment. What even is cartoony?
@@devaraft Thats literally not attacking, i never seen him physically beat the sh1 t of a person for making bad food. Yall really need therapy ffs 💀
@@basedneutral1173 Other person is right tho Joe doesn’t criticize every dish for some of them he just outright insults the dish or even the person
If Arrogance was a person
im ok if the pride based on something real like what Gordon did, absolutely respect Gordon, but this fking Joe guy is just Stupidly Arrogance based on his ego and bully pride.
If narcissistic was a person lol
YES 1k
Worst part is compared to Graham, Gordon, Aaron etc Hes not even a chef, half the time he has no idea what hes even talking about when it comes to all the important cooking stuff.
He's relatable
Man he's unbearable even outside Masterchef
It’s a character. He won’t say that outside Masterchef ON CAMERA because of nda’s and the potential of him returning. All the chefs on that were judged critically and heavily like that by him all said he’s a nice guy, so.
Naw
Baldie was the worst judge on Masterchef
I disagree. He's an honest man who tells it like it is and keeps the standards high.
Sounds like you're just a sensitive snowflake.
@@NotoriousMcGregor
It’s not a character he plays. He is that awful.
He was born rich and he is a snob. This is who he is.
He said The blind chef shouldn't be in a kitchen that she is a liability then she proves him wrong and wins the whole season
Yeah, after he said that, I kind of just lost respect for him because Christine was an amazing chef, and the fact that Joe called her a liability, even though she had so much talent just pissed me off so much.
Not defending him but after her team won the challenge, he literally admitted he was wrong.
And now SHE is a judge herself. One of the very few moments where he gets owned and it’s so satisfying
He is totally correct. a blind person being a chef. how the hell does she know what the ingredients are. how does she not burn herself on the stove? How does she know the correct measurements for the ingredients. How does she know The correct temperature for the oven. It is totally ludicrous. 🤪. Off camera I am almost totally positive that there is someone helping her. she only won because they felt sorry for her and it was good for the show and it was politically correct
@@rainysunday6186you definitely takin it guts deep gang 😭🙏
The dude who said "you dont have to eat it" wasnt even pretentious, he was just not confident
Except Cutter was indeed the most obnoxious and baffling contestant during that season. He reached the Top 5 yet he was consistently bad, only having a few good dishes.
Not defending Joe, he's just as pretentious. Just saying that some of the cringe-inducing contestants at least get deserving nasty reviews.
What!? 😂😂😂 did you watch that season??? Cutter was ridiculous! So was Tally- just delusional!
@@Jay3ll388 This guy will make even Tali the Picasso of cooking just so he can say Joe is wrong in everything.
Cutter is a toddler in a grown man’s body
Absolutely incorrect Cutter was the biggest dbag on the show that season.
Words of SIR MARCO PIERRE WHITE ;
"I am being judged by someone with less knowledge on the art than me"
The audacity of this shit
Look at Cutter’s cake lol, that’ll change your view on his level of knowledge
Right. Because only the most knowledgable should ever be allowed an opinion.
Also Joe is extremely knowledgable. He owns a bunch of restaurants, his mom made millions off of cookbooks. Deal with it.
@AlexDuWaldt, if you can't cook, then you're not knowledgeable at all
@@AlexDuWaldtin the nicest way possible: knowledge of cooking should absolutely not be measured by how many restaurants you own and that is a crazy criterion to suggest.
Any Michelin-starred chef on Earth knows more about food than Salt Bae.
@@silver_rocket_25didn't know you know him personally and know exactly how skilled he is
Remember the time when he said "do you miss your husband, well.. you might see him tonight" to a contestant who was not safe in the competition. Why tf would you attack someone's personal information in a competition.
@@tarzencheda7928 I agree.
Marco Pierre White compared to him is a whole different person
Yeah, Marco is intimidating by default, but gives solid thoughtful criticism to a dish. Joe feels the need to act angry 24/7.
@@frenchfriedbagel7035 Gordon Ramsay is on the same line as Marco Pierre White. Severe, strict, but willing to give advice in order for people to improve (if they have the right behavior and don't act all cocky and shit)
@@astrovisionbroadcastingunion Gordon does like to talk shit, but he usually and almost always does it in a jokey poking fun kind of way and doesn't really 100% meant what he said.
Marco is a legend joe is a wannabe
@@woottipat06 Correct me if I'm wrong, but Gordon's yelling is just to sell the show, right?
He’s not even a chef 😭😭😭
@VIDEOHOMESYSTEMpreety wild to be hating on people about their culinary skills when u urself(joe btw) dont know jack shit about food💀
@VIDEOHOMESYSTEM and he has no right to open his counterfeit mouth on the topic of food if it wasn’t for his mom and being able to coast by on her accolades.
Joe embodies the essence of not earning your station and his criticisms strongly reflect how little he knows.
What your saying is people who can’t sing or dance can’t be judges on America’s for talents. Or only athletes can judge on Olympics or only criminal can be judges. You don’t need to be a chef to judge food. You just need to know food. Joe is a winemaker and restauranteur.
@@billqiu4692fake news buddy
A good non-chef judge that I've noticed is Matt Preston from MasterChef Australia. He's a food critic/journalist, and is known globally in the culinary world.
The basic difference between Joe and Matt is that Matt is unironically more knowledgeable and open-minded about food. He's familiar with cooking techniques and skills, despite not being in a professional kitchen himself. He also travels the world because it's his literal job, and that he's not eurocentric unlike Mr. Baldy. When he gives criticism it's constructive and actually insightful, he talks about the presentation and considers the techniques applied just by looking at a dish. He doesn't feel like a snob.
The show and himself also acknowledge greatly the fact that he's not a chef. When he's shown cooking in the show, he would always just do simple, cheaty recipes that are easy to make that literally any person with a kitchen and oven can do.
ah yes i love constructive criticism like “it sucks” very helpful
I don’t he knows the difference between constructive criticism and insulting someone’s lineage
Or someone’s physical disability
He never gives feedback though, he just says disappointing, whenever contestants try to get creative he shuts them down, he thinks of food way too conservatively
He’ll shut them down for being creative and then later in the episode talk shit for not taking risks and being simple.
@@billqiu4692Best food isnt something to be creative for most important, it focuses more on taste
@@basedneutral1173 Nothing I said is to the contrary, my point is that Joe doesn’t care about any of those factors. He’ll demean the contestant simply for the sake of it.
@@billqiu4692 Not really. He doesn't care more into creativity sh1t most of the times. If someone put so much detail over my food too, i wouldn't even enjoy eating it. Food is meant to be consumed and tasted, not for creativity or art. A normal steak is already beautiful naturally, don't need to ruin the fk of it.
@@basedneutral1173agreed. These judges clearly und that presentation is merely the surface level, though it does show what kind of chef they're dealing with.
"i review the food not the contestants"
>proceeds to judge the contestants before even getting near the food
Because it looks unappetizing and disgusting
It's hard to judge a chef when you're not a chef
So does that mean only criminals should judge other criminals in court? Only video game developers should review video games? Only top athletes at the Olympics should judge the other athletes? I can keep going but the point is you don’t have to have certain talents to judge the results of those talents. Most food critics aren’t even chefs.
@@Churrowhisperer all im saying is people like joe should not judge something they know nothing well enough to give an unbiased statement
@@nolanhewitt2563 Joe co owns 30 restaurants in four different countries. What exactly makes him unqualified to judge food? Again, most food critics are not chefs.
His face got "punch me" writen all over it
Don't understand how the guy didn't talk back when he said it's garbage
Joe: We don't review...
Also Joe 10 seconds later: If I can give a nasty review...
He isn't even a trained Chef, but talks like he is the best chef in the world.
are you some sort of trained Keyboard Warrior?
I still can’t believe Cutter made it as far as he did.
So he does not feel bad. Should of asked him about the time he was mean to Christine ha. Cause she is blind she is a liability in the kitchen. He is not a judge he is a jerk how he was not fired is still crazy to me
Agree with you there
then he admitted he was wrong bout her
@@sruchan3072 Does not matter NoExcuse for it
@@sruchan3072but it was inexcusable.
@@sruchan3072he still owes an apology
Id love to see him host one season of Kitchen Nightmares or Hotel Hell, even the most tolerable, least stuck up owners would wanna fight this man
What he doesn't understand is that he needs to give out "constructive criticism" not just plain criticism, because that would be plain bullying.
Now ask him if he feels bad over throwing food away while people starve
Do you feel guilty for that too? Unfortunately we all do it
I actually love Joe on masterchef. Him and gordon have the best masterchef seasons.
Yes love them too 🇬🇧❤🇮🇹
I love Joe as well. Why else would Ramsey have him.
Facts
"...I give constructive criticism."
*proceeds to slam plate into a trashcan*
Dude thats absolutely not judging someone's food, thats humiliating people
A judge I respect is someone like chef Michael from Masterchef Canada. He gives you the good points and other things that can improve the dish. His decisions are final, but he still wants the best out of those home cooks. If it's blatantly bad, he'll also tell you why instead of slamming it into the trash right away.
People defend joe and say hes just "doing his job" no he isnt. he the amount of times he targets the food that he is supposed to "judge" is extremely lacking, and his ability to provide advice and give feedback, which is what judging entails, is similarly lacking, especially when comparing him to other judges on the show. Instead, he attacks the chefs themselves, being downright rude to many of them. You can be harsh as a judge, sure, but to be rude, discrimatory, and outright a bad person is simply unacceptable and, in his words, is "digusting".
He doesn't criticize food. He criticizes people.
Yeah, it says to judge people. Not to be a literal POS.
Makes me laugh how people find him arrogant, unbearable, and even not qualified to critique... you obviously never understood the context of the show
"Those are three big mistakes. Finally, Bastianich explains he is not a chef, but that doesn't mean he can't throw down in the kitchen. In fact, he's confident he would beat both of his fellow judges, Gordon and Aarón, in a competition. “I could easily predict that I would win, even though I'm not a chef,” he reveals." Yeah he's beyond arrogant, he's downright delusional.
OK that was a bad example of Cutter. He was actually asking an appropriate question and none of the judges actually gave him a non passive aggressive answer😂
Yall are some weaklings. Tough love. Thats his way of showing someone that they need to imporve their dish. Honestly, without Joe, Master Chef would be soft and no real criticism. Except for Gordon of course.
It’s almost like he’s projecting at this point. Hope he finds peace in himself.
This guy hasn't stepped foot in a kitchen in over 30 years.
God, he tore one guy apart i hated it. I think Malcom from season 4. He made the guy cry, he was so mean to him.
This dude isn't even a chef, he has 0 right to judge ANOYONES cooking ability.
Dude, what makes this more mean is he would never do this on MasterChef Junior
I like him, he’s a favorite among all the judges
Team Joe Bastianich ❤🇮🇹✊🏻He make Gerron a Winner 🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆
Yall stupid bruh he’s the worst judge
What you said right there is inappropriate and ultimately disgusting
I ironically like him for how I can never take him seriously even during this interview
Criticizing the food is one thing but criticizing the person is something els xD
Be a judge, not an asshole.
I think the moment that cemented the fact that he doesnt know what he is talking about was the garlic bread incident where the other judges are just flabbergasted when he said garlic bread cheapens a traditional italian cuisine
Zero respect for Joe and his accolades for saying Christine who's blind belongs in a coat room rather than the kitchen....
Bro doesnt know the difference between constructive criticism and telling someone that they're worthless
He was a little bit sweeter and shared some guidance with only one contestant ever and that was Luca. Joe is actually very snobbish and does judge people by their personality than their food. I don't hate him though.
I refuse to believe that’s actually how he’s like and that he’s not just playing his character right here. Until I meet a person in real life, I won’t make any real judgements on them as a person. I’ll judge his made up character, just not him.
@@user-sf9gs2pg1b Thank you sooooo much for your comment. No one in this Forum had met the REAL HIM, I suppose. These Reality Shows are not 100% real, afterall. The people involved were doing what they were told, most of the time.
Impressing Joe is like winning a trophy.
He's like Andrew Tate's older brother. He even looks like him lmao
The nerve of him to call anyone else "obnoxious" holy shit
Tearing down Tali was more than necessary and only Joe had the balls to call him out. Dude's delusional, proclaims himself a genius, takes no notes, no feedback and cooks subpar stuff.
He should be asked what he would consider bullying and not criticising food.
Well he had the idea, just terrible execution. He knows to judge the food, but somehow he manages to fuck that up
Lemme get this straight…
The guy is a judge, on a show called master chef, and he’s not even a chef?
He is a restaurateur who employs the best chefs (in his opinion) in his successful restaurants.
@@paulievespucci6867restaurant’s he inherited from his mom and dad
@@YonkoBlackbeard lol no.
The 1st restaurant he opened was not inherited from his parents.
You probably just heard his parents were famous so you assume he just inherited everything 🤣🤣
mommy and daddy gave him money to open a restaurant @@paulievespucci6867
So far Gordon Ramsay & Alvin Leung is my fav judges yes Alvin Leung throwing the food, but i really appreciate that he still taste the contestants dishes❤
First be a real judge yourself and then judge others
No no... Joe was absolutely right about Tali's risotto. Who puts berries in a risotto???
Man sometimes i am suprised how easy it is to hate a person
He was a lil too harsh omg lmfao
Joe has been nice in the recent MasterChef seasons though. Like in this season, he gave contestants some advice when they're cooking too
i dont know why people dislike him personally he is my fav judge from masterchef and i really like him
Imagine being married to this guy
I actually really enjoyed when Joe was on the show
What you did on that dish is inappropriate, and ultimately kinda disgusting
I feel like he could still be a tad nicer but I’m not complaining I like it, Gordon is my favorite but I have no issues with the others.
Nah you know what, I get it. I honestly understand the satisfaction of cutting down someone’s major hubris. He was only insufferable to the people who acted insufferable. And if anyone has genuinely watched master chef from top to bottom, they really did have a lot of insufferable, over confident cooks who thought their food was gods gift to this earth.
He must have been a really obnoxious contestant. 😮
He was…
Joe: "That's the most fucked up Risotto I've ever seen!"
Contestant: "It's Nasi Goreng..."
Dude wanted to be Gordon so bad hahaha
@@guywithahelmet9597 No I don't agree with you.
Judges from masterchef criticize too but they do it with class.
@@chimmy9222 I myself found Joe very classy. His comments were harsh but classy.
@@meganchan5432 but mkat of the time he's not. He straight up throws a tantrum. But to each their own i guess.
i dont understand why people hate this man, i mean... i like this guy, yes sometimes hes out of the line but its all for the show, he is quite likable
He's also on a SHOW. He has to spice things up to the absolute maximum. If he just said, "food's bad," then it wouldn't be half as entertaining. Personally for me, Joe's overreactions make the show even more enjoyable because of how over the top he gets.
hes been alot nicer in the latest season of masterchef and united tastes of america. he seems like a happier guy now
“Im a judge, we don’t review”
0.737 seconds later
“ye so when I give a review”
- Gordon Ramsays rent boy 2023
There's being critical on a poorly made dish while being firm and polite, then there's Joe.
Nah I like Joe and his intensity. High standards.
There's NOTHING WRONG about his comments. He makes his reviews for YOU, for all the Contestants who have a chance to meet him. Anyone who doesn't like these, just go back home. Perhaps they don't know WHAT they really want. 😅
For Cutter's attitude I get why Joe's like that but for the first guy you dont have to make him feel like he molested someone
What you mean Tali? He is one of the most arrogant contestants to ever join masterchef. He thinks he is better than Gordon Ramsay even though he's no good at all. Cutter is a better cook than he is.
If you watch Masterchef Italy he's completely different. Harsh sometimes, especially in the first seasons, but overall definitely not as mean as americans perceived.
Has he ever given CONSTRUCTIVE criticism to someone. He just roasts a person and not their cooking
But Joe’s not a chef he just some dude who owns restaurants!
Man he is always in his character😅
Ironic that he made the claim about the guy being presumptuous and responding with “I’m a judge,” yet other times REFUSING to try a dish. Hypocrisy, no?
i like Joe a lot, to me he is honest, some of them need to be put in their places, so many have big egos and he's good at taking them down a notch, well done!
Agree 100%!
He should learn how to criticize from Master Chef Australia
"if a person's being obnoxious"
*shows video of someone literally embarrassing themself saying you don't have to eat their food getting rinsed by Joe*
I get that this is his profession but there is a fine line between giving criticism and being a douche.
What he does is not criticising or judging, but just toxic narcissistic bullying. Straight
Biggest narcist on the planet.
who tf thought that getting this guy onto a show would be a great idea
Honestly he kinda fit the role of the hard judge that will pinpoint all the details without caring for the gestures and politeness
“it is easy to do that” ?!!!
He say like he is pround of it to bully someone 🤷🤦♂️
He definitely wanted to be an actor (wanted to play villian) but somehow become a chef
He has quite a strong new York accent
Welll he was born in New York :v
The most irrelevant, useless comment i’ve read all day @ryanwani216 😂
I was wondering what if he existed and said the same thing in North Korea😂
Shouldn’t actual cooks/chefs be the judges
JOE DIDNT EVEN GO TO CULINARY SCHOOL!!
Out of all the chefs I love Joe tbh yes he’s critical but one it’s a show, two he’s judging idiots who serve him raw pork, made him a disgusting pizza, like if I was given shit food and have to be dealing with 6 shit plates and 2 good I’d be irritated asf myself and not give a shit about hurting someone’s feelings after they insulted food