Rafisahab wo fankar the jo aise halke fulke happyer gaane ko sadness ki un bulandiyon par pahuncha sakte the No comparison for that legendary voice master in our musical world..
Mohd. Rafi Sahab To Mohd. Rafi Hai, Tha aur Rahenge. And As A "DIE HARD" Mohd. Rafi Sahab Fan, I Can Say That Kishore Did It Very Well 😉👌🏽 Ies Geet Ko Kishore Kumar Ne Bahut Khubie Se Nibhaye Hai 😉🙏🏽
All 3 sang extremely well. One cannot choose. Each was sang in different circumstances and with different feelings and sentiments. The makers of the film and SJ would never have released the songs if they were not sang to their satisfaction. Having said this, in my opinion, Ashaji and Kishoreda would not have sang the song any different if it was projected on different actors. But Rafi Saab would have sang the same song differently if it was on Dev Anand, Dharmendra and any other actors at that time. This was the greatness of Rafi Saab.
Please listen the song with details. Rafi sir has sung one mukhda and one antara too. It is exactly a song. But there is no question of comparison. All legends were great. I am agree with it
Rafi sahab said in one interview that, "Kishore bahut hi accha gaate he aur me unke geet bahut shauk se sunta hu, me unki kamyabi se bahut khush hota hu"💗 For me both are anmol ratan of our music industry.
don't compare Kishore da and rafi ji compare karne ka matlab Dilip Kumar ji se amitab bachchan ji ko compare kiya jaisa hair both are legendary apne apne daur me
@@dr.pankulgoel945 Jii bilkul Dr sahab .......sabki apni apni feelings hoti hai.... kucch log ranu mandal ko lata ji se compare krte hai lekin music sabki field nhi jo isko harr koi judgement kr ske ..... Rafi Sahab aur Lata ji music ke maa baap hai 🙏
@@harindersinghsandhu4972 Her insan ko apni pasand Rakhne ka Haq hai Lekin Mohammed Rafi Sahab ne Kishore Kumar ji per picturies 11 songs mein play back diya hai
Rafi Sahab ka version sirf film me hi rakkha gaya.... Agar LP me HMV wale rakh dete to ye version bhi kaamyabi ke bulandiyon ko choota.... A conspiracy certainly.....
@@harindersinghsandhu4972 kishor agar rafi sahab ko 30% bhi gaa le to bohot h.....rafi sahab ki range lata didi nhi pakad payi to or singer ke bare me to kya kahu
@@harindersinghsandhu4972 Kahan se aa gaye bhai kishor kumar ko beech mein lekar jab log comment mein bol rahe hai RAFI SAHAB ko God toh aap beech mein kishor kumar ko le aa rahe ho
गाना का वोल ऐसा हे की ए गाना Happy Mood में ही आच्छा लगता है। इस गीत के लिए हसरत जयपुरी (Lyricist) साहब को दुसरे वार यानी आख़री वार Filmfare award for best Lyricist का Award मिला। Rafi Sahab world's Best Singer🤩🥰😍😘😘😘😘
रफी साहब बहुत अच्छे गायक हैं इसमें कोई शक नहीं लेकिन किशोर दा किसी से कम नहीं है किशोर दा हर फन में माहिर हैं किसी गीत के चाहे जितने भी वर्जन बने हो उसमे सर्वाधिक किशोर दा का ही गाना सुपर हिट हुआ है
Janab Mohammed rafi saheb khud ek unmoal heera hai. Vo duniya ka KOHINOOR hai. Bharat ratan milte hai sabko. Heera karodo mai sirf ek hai vo hai rafi saheb hai. .
Whether people accept it or not nobody can compared rafi sahab voice to any body in the film industries Rafi sahab voice is sun before every playback singers in the film industries Rafi sahab the greatest singer ever born in the world and always will be till Qayamat man with golden heart bharat ki shaan
sir ye kahani mere leye nai h..kyu ki mene ye picture nahi dekhi .or na hi mujhe ye malum h ..itna popular geet..jo wakai kishor da ne bohut hi khubsurat gaya h ♥ lajawab h.wohi geet Rafi sahab ne bhi gaya...bohut..shukrya..is jankari ke leye 😊 .
Kishore Kumar's version was popular because of Rajesh Khanna's popularity and yudling. At the same time Rafi's version was picturised on Shammi Kapoor, whose popularity was declining in the leading roles.
@@ninadchoudhury3362 Rafi's popularity never declined at any point of time, even after 40 years of his death. Thanks to SD & HD reproduction of audio, we are able to clearly distinguish and enjoy his high quality singing up to date.
@@ninadchoudhury3362 Shemaroo video company recorded 21 million views of Rafi's solo in 1974 film Thokar. The music was by little known Music Directors Shyam ji Ghanshyam ji.
@@farruqameen3560 Rajesh Khanna tajessh Khanna kishor Kumar ki vajah se bne us samay Kishore da jiske liye gate the vo film hot or hero star ban jate h
During 1950' s once the great SD Burman ji rejected Kishore Kumar's play back singing , remember both of them are from Bengal , during that era the songs were composed on classical touch & the saptha swar of music was reflected during that periods song , 1950 to 1970 the hero's were not graded no 1 ,2 etc , but Rajesh Khanna was popularised because of some storys of the films , then onwards the hero's opinion was taken into consideration for to whom to sing his song , Amithabh also followed the same , but after 1976 once again rafi was popular in hindi film history , example Film Sargams songs etc
SIR JI,,,MOHAMMED RAFI,,,KISHOR DA,,,ASHA BHOSALE,,,,,3 NO SINGER'S,,,,EK HI MAALA KE MOTI,,,,,SHANKAR JAYKISHAN SAHAB JI GREAT GREAT GREAT GREAT GREAT MUSIC DIRECTOR,,,,,,AND GREAT GREAT VERY VERY NICE INFORMATION 👌
Due respect to Rafi saab n Ashaji but Kishorda had edge over rest of the singers - this song is still popular but only in kishorda’s voice. Nothing wrong in giving credit to Kishorda that doesn’t make rafisaab inferior singer - he was also great.
Mohammad Rafi is the best and greatest playback singer ! ...incomparable ! His songs make such a vast repertoire , huge range and myriad of genre and numerous moods. Just consider any field e.g. romantic songs , qawwalis , bhajans , patriotic songs et. el ....in all the fields Rafi sahab is outstanding. Other singers have limitations : some have thick and hoarse voice which goes well in a limited range , but they can't fit in higher octave ; some singers are highly trained in classical music with a high range , but their voice lacks the intoxication of romance which Rafi Sahab's voice is inherited with. Just watch what the great maestros viz. Yesudas ji , Manna Dey ji , S P Balasubramaniyam ji , Jayachandran ji , IliyaRaja ji , O P Nayyar ji , Ravi ji and many others have said about Rafi sahab - you then know that Rafi Sahab's voice was a special gift by God to the mankind !
Comparison between these legends is not good, I am diehard fan of Rafi sahab but still feels they all given their best to Indian music industry, they all are like a gems in crown of Indian music industry.
Kya Mohd Rafi Saheb se kisi ko compare karna sahi hai ??? Mohd Rafi sahab ne kaise kaise gaane gaya hai . Nobody can touch the range of Rafi sahab . No male or female singer , can reach Rafi sahab .
@@dr.priyanka__6 Madam Mr Kishore himself said in his interview Rd used to make tunes lighter for him , so that he could sing. Now if you claim to know more about kishore than himself , then Madam you think does that make any sense?
For this song, everyone has forgotten Rafi and Asha version, we remember only the clarion call of zindadilli with Rajesh Khanna racing on mobike and Kishore's voice.
Kishore is right Kishore. None is near him, none is beyond him. His voice sweet, heavy, masculine. Crying and shouting are not found in his singing. A half-feminine crying tone is never comparable with that of Kishore.
Litu das, Do you know what is called 'এড়ে গলা'? 'এড়ে গলা' means hoarse voice which is possessed by Kishore kumar you may say it 'masculine' but he is populr all over the world.Men accepted him.In the same way huge number of people accepted Rafi's crying and shouting.I think you are envious of Rafi's soothing voice. I like kishore da's 'এড়ে গলা'.😀😀😀
@@farooqhussain9301 Try to understand the difference between singing and crying. Crying can never be dignified as song. If musculine and heavy voice can't be sweet, is the voice of Mehdi Haasan very sour?
Rafi saab Kishore da manna Dey mukesh ji sab lajwaab hai Sabke apne apne mood apne apne andaaz hai. Is liye tulna karna vayarth hai. Sir geet sune or anand le.
This song turned out to be the last song that Jaikishan (Shankar Jaikishan) recorded before his death. This song was in the TOP 1 in Binaca Geetmala(ALL INDIA RADIO)in 1971.
Kyuki bahut se log comment karte hai Kishore da was a street singer agar street singer Ho te to unhe 8 filmfare Award nahi milata aur 28 gaane filmfare ke liye nominate nahi hote
Very goood yaaaar. Ye bat ki apne. Sanjana g. Ye kute ki tarah bhokte hai sanjana. Inko kon samjhaye. Ye bas compare karte rahenge. Aur kuch nahi. Kyuki ye khud kuch nahi kar sakte na isliye. Love u kishor da an rafi sahab. Sacha bhagat fan wohi hai jo barabar. Inko respect de. Nahi toh kute bohat bhokne ke liye
Nahi bhai mera koi bhi aisa maqsad nahi hota. Dono hi kalakar utne hi mahan kalakar the aur rahenge. Main without script video banata hun to ek flow mein jo bol diya wohi on air upload ho jata hai. Aap ke suggestion ke liye dhanyavad bhai
If it had been sung fully, it would have been a bigger hit than Kishore Da. The portion of Rafi sb is even not Audible, the recording quality is also very poor. It's a fact that many people in the industry were jealous of him because of his popularity. Due to politics of other singers/director/producers, Rafi sb lost many tracks, which went to Kishore Da, or sang by others. All music lovers know in their heart 💓, who was/is/will be the best, till the dooms day.
Mai bhi Kishor Kumar ka fan Hu unke gana bahut sunta Hun , lekin Jo baat rafi sahab ki aawaz me thi o ksi or me nahi 🇮🇳💞 i love kishor Da and rafi sahab
Md Rafiji was great and he is real "son of India"...but this song borned for only Kishore Kumar...it was created high sentation allover India....it was one of the "only Kishore Kumar's song"
Chahe kuch bhi kaho. Jab bhi koi. Is gane ki bat karega. Ya puchega. Sabse pehle kishor da hi yaad ayenge. Kyunki. U ka version jyada hit hua. Aur kya khooob khaya dada ne.
uss waqt filmi duniya mai sabhi kis actor per kis playback singer ki awaaz mach hoti hai ye sabse pehle sochte thhe.. isliye Rajesh Khanna ji per Kishore da ki Awaaz di gayi or Shammi ji per Rafi saahab ki.. Ye baat alag hai ki Rajesh Khanna ji per filmaye Kishore da ke geet ki wajah se Andaaz film ko jitni kamyabi milni thhi usse zyada mili.. Jai Rafi saahab 🙏 Jai Kishore da 🙏 We love Rafi saahab ❤️ We love Kishore da ❤️
Rafi sahib iss choti ke gayak thhe ki wo har acter ke sath apni awaj match kar kar lete thhe. ye baat galat ha Rajesh ji sath unki awaj match nahi thhi. Do raste ke Geet suno. Sacha Jhootha ka Geet yunhi tum mujhse baat karti ho suno. Sirf Aradhna ke Geet jis movie ne Rajesh ji ko star banaya u aue RD ko hit kiya usi wajah se Kisore lime light main aa gaye. Warna 1980 main Kishore ji ne Jitender ji ke liye jo geet gaye thhe unhone Music ka level gira diya thha.
Rafisahab wo fankar the jo aise halke fulke happyer gaane ko sadness ki un bulandiyon par pahuncha sakte the
No comparison for that legendary voice master in our musical world..
Absolutely right brother
Mohd. Rafi Sahab To Mohd. Rafi Hai, Tha aur Rahenge.
And As A "DIE HARD" Mohd. Rafi Sahab Fan, I Can Say That Kishore Did It Very Well 😉👌🏽
Ies Geet Ko Kishore Kumar Ne Bahut Khubie Se Nibhaye Hai 😉🙏🏽
Kishor da ne bohat khoob gaya. Kishor da toh kishor da hai. Unka Gaya hua kabhi galat ho hi nahi sakta. Baki rafi sahab g ne acha gaya.
Mohd Rafi Saheb the best singer of all time and the most humble human being. No one comes close to him and never will.
You lousy fellow Kishore is the greatest singer ever
Once Mannadey Sir said taht we all can not do Rafi Sahab can easily do
Mannadey ji ka ye interview main ne bhi dekha hai.
once rafiji said that kishorda is better than him ....so the legend himself accepted that kishorda is the greatest ever...
@@rockstar25559 kab aur konse interview me kaha hai. Ulta ye baat kishore da ne rafi sahab ke liye kaha tha
@@rockstar25559 कुछभी कहेनेके पहले ज़रा सोच लिया करो...अपने मनमे कुछभी कहानी बनाकर बोल देतेहो...तुमको शर्म आनी चाहिए 🤪🤪🤪
@@sulemansheikh1998 bilcool shi kaha aapne....ye kishore fans kabhi nhi sudhrenge 🤣🤣🤣
Kishor song was most famous !👍
Yes
Waaha-rafi-saahab
Waaha-kishor-dada
Waaha-asha-ji
BAHUT-KHOOB
LAAJAWAAB
THANKS-DAVE-BHAI
Shukriya sir ji
Mohammed Rafi Sahab the Greatest Singer of All Time 🙏🙏🙏
Lousy fellow Kishore is the greatest singer ever
Mohd Rafi Sahab is greatest singar personality in the World..
Lata ji his says
You lousy muslim Kishore is the greatest singer ever
प्रत्येक गायक बहुमुखी है और उसकी एक दूसरे से तुलना नहीं की जा सकती है। गायक का चयन गीत और कलाकार के साथ-साथ स्थिति पर निर्भर करता है।
Jitesh Dave ji aap ka bolne ka andaz bahut hi khubsurat hai salam hai aap ko The Greatest singer in world only one MOHD RAFI SAHAB
Shukriya bhai
All 3 sang extremely well. One cannot choose. Each was sang in different circumstances and with different feelings and sentiments. The makers of the film and SJ would never have released the songs if they were not sang to their satisfaction. Having said this, in my opinion, Ashaji and Kishoreda would not have sang the song any different if it was projected on different actors. But Rafi Saab would have sang the same song differently if it was on Dev Anand, Dharmendra and any other actors at that time. This was the greatness of Rafi Saab.
Thanks for your valuable feedback
Rafisab has sung only one line. It is not a complete song. Moreover, it's a different mood and different situation. Thus, comparison is out of place.
Please listen the song with details. Rafi sir has sung one mukhda and one antara too. It is exactly a song. But there is no question of comparison. All legends were great. I am agree with it
Yes👌
You lousy fellow Kishore is the greatest singer ever
Kishore da 👌👌👌
Kishor da and Aasha taee great but md.Rafi different,,,the voice of GOD🙏🙏🙏
Thanks for your feedback
Aapne sahi kaha 🙏🌹
You lousy muslim Kishore is the greatest singer ever
Rafi sahab said in one interview that, "Kishore bahut hi accha gaate he aur me unke geet bahut shauk se sunta hu, me unki kamyabi se bahut khush hota hu"💗
For me both are anmol ratan of our music industry.
Wrong they said I listen manna dey song
Well said.
Rafi sb used to hear Manna dey
Kk and Asha B song in a happy mood. Rafi sang in a sad mood.
There is a difference IN PLAYBACK SINGING THE MOOD DEPENDS ON THE SITUATION IN THE MOVIE.
I ama fan of kishor kumar still donot want to hear any thing worse on md.rafi
ये गाना जब भी याद आता है तब किशोर कुमार जी के ही स्वर के साथ ही याद आता है.
लेकीन तुम बीन जाऊ कहा यह गीत रफीजी के स्वर के साथ ही याद आता है.
Yeh gana hi kishor Kumar ji ka bna hai Rafi sahib sirf ek line gaya hai
Sara gana hi kishor da ka yad to uni ke nam se hoga rafi ji ne ek line ghungunaai sirf
I wish Rafi sang full song , his master class touch is something else
You wish
You lousy muslim Kishore is the greatest singer ever
तिनो अपने आप में अववल है।हम कौन है उनको कम या ज्यादह आकनेवाले? हरेक ने अपना आवाज तपाया था।उपासना थी वो आवाज की!महान शहकार थे तींनो!!!!!
Yes agree. Thanks for your valuable feedback
The great MD Rafi sahab aap ka compair kisi v singrs se nh kr skte Rafi sahab is the best playback singer in the world
Always sir Kishore Kumar ji number one singer and all rounder in the world 🌎🌍
एक किशोर आवाज अनेक जैसा अभिनेता वैसी आवाज वो हे किशोर नटखट 🤔🤔
Kishor Kumar best voice
don't compare Kishore da and rafi ji compare karne ka matlab Dilip Kumar ji se amitab bachchan ji ko compare kiya jaisa hair both are legendary apne apne daur me
As a diehard rafi fan I must admit I loved the kishore version more
Happy version gana Kathin Nahi lekin sad version gana Kathin rahata hai isse rafisahab ki mahatta aur badati hai
@@manojkamble4506 ye to sahi hai lekin kuch log yaha par hindu muslim karenge
Both were genius. But here I feel kk was more good
@@dr.pankulgoel945
Jii bilkul Dr sahab .......sabki apni apni feelings hoti hai.... kucch log ranu mandal ko lata ji se compare krte hai lekin music sabki field nhi jo isko harr koi judgement kr ske ..... Rafi Sahab aur Lata ji music ke maa baap hai 🙏
@@manojkamble4506 that’s a good point
SWAR SAMRAT KO SHAT SHAT NAMAN DUNIYA KI SABSE KHOOBSURAT AWAZ SURO KE SHENSHAH AWAZ KE JADUGAR VOICE OF GOD JAI JAI MOHAMMED RAFI SAHAB
Yes agree. Thanks
Satya vachan🙏🙏🌹🌹
भगवान की आवाज़ रफी साहब
No Kishore is greatest in Indian history
@@harindersinghsandhu4972 Her insan ko apni pasand Rakhne ka Haq hai Lekin Mohammed Rafi Sahab ne Kishore Kumar ji per picturies 11 songs mein play back diya hai
Rafi Sahab ka version sirf film me hi rakkha gaya.... Agar LP me HMV wale rakh dete to ye version bhi kaamyabi ke bulandiyon ko choota.... A conspiracy certainly.....
Yes. Thanks for your valuable feedback
Exactly, this might have happened.
Male or female rafi sahab was the best singer for ever
I disagee with you.
@@sumitmajumder1223 rafi sahab god of singing
Kishore is best ever singer Indian history
@@harindersinghsandhu4972 kishor agar rafi sahab ko 30% bhi gaa le to bohot h.....rafi sahab ki range lata didi nhi pakad payi to or singer ke bare me to kya kahu
@@harindersinghsandhu4972 Kahan se aa gaye bhai kishor kumar ko beech mein lekar jab log comment mein bol rahe hai RAFI SAHAB ko God toh aap beech mein kishor kumar ko le aa rahe ho
गाना का वोल ऐसा हे की ए गाना Happy Mood में ही आच्छा लगता है। इस गीत के लिए हसरत जयपुरी (Lyricist) साहब को दुसरे वार यानी आख़री वार Filmfare award for best Lyricist का Award मिला।
Rafi Sahab world's Best Singer🤩🥰😍😘😘😘😘
No one can take place of Rafi sahab..
You lousy fellow Kishore is the greatest singer ever
रफी साहब बहुत अच्छे गायक हैं इसमें कोई शक नहीं लेकिन किशोर दा किसी से कम नहीं है किशोर दा हर फन में माहिर हैं किसी गीत के चाहे जितने भी वर्जन बने हो उसमे सर्वाधिक किशोर दा का ही गाना सुपर हिट हुआ है
Rafi Sahab ki aawaz me gaana bahut bahut pasand hai ji Salam Aadab Namashkar ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
@@lallitasingh616 yes agree
Mohd Rafi all time greatest singer this man deserve Bharat ratan Award
Yes agree
Janab Mohammed rafi saheb khud ek unmoal heera hai. Vo duniya ka KOHINOOR hai. Bharat ratan milte hai sabko. Heera karodo mai sirf ek hai vo hai rafi saheb hai.
.
Whether people accept it or not nobody can compared rafi sahab voice to any body in the film industries
Rafi sahab voice is sun before every playback singers in the film industries
Rafi sahab the greatest singer ever born in the world and always will be till Qayamat man with golden heart bharat ki shaan
Yes agree. Thanks
You lousy fellow Kishore is the greatest singer ever
Voice of god institute of singing frishta on this earth real bharat ratan of india in caroro hearts of people till to date. RAFISB RAFISB RAFISB.
Rafi was ghanta .😂
@@AjaySharma-ve6in 😂😂🤣
@@satyendrasinghbhadauriya594 yeah jo baate kishore da ke liye bolna chahiye tha wo rafi ke liye kh rhe hai
@@AjaySharma-ve6in absolutely correct 👍👌🤝💓
@@satyendrasinghbhadauriya594 🙏🙏
जनाब मोहम्मद रफी सहाब का गाया हूवा छोटा हीस्सा आज पहेली बार सूनाने के लीए जीतेश दवे भाई शूक्रीया
No doubt Kishore's version is number one.
Kaya andaz masti thi kishore da... ki lekin dekhiye kaisey kishoreda ke liye negetive naratting ki gai...lekin KISHORE da ...u r great
Kishor Kumar is better always
sir ye kahani mere leye nai h..kyu ki mene ye picture nahi dekhi
.or na hi mujhe ye malum h ..itna popular geet..jo wakai kishor da ne bohut hi khubsurat gaya h ♥
lajawab h.wohi geet Rafi sahab ne bhi gaya...bohut..shukrya..is jankari ke leye
😊
.
Shukriya bhai
my fav is kishore kumar..
Rafi sab and Kishore da both are incomperable.Both of them are great.
Yes totally agree
Kishore Kumar's version was popular because of Rajesh Khanna's popularity and yudling. At the same time Rafi's version was picturised on Shammi Kapoor, whose popularity was declining in the leading roles.
Rafi's popularity was declining drastically as well
@@ninadchoudhury3362 Rafi's popularity never declined at any point of time, even after 40 years of his death. Thanks to SD & HD reproduction of audio, we are able to clearly distinguish and enjoy his high quality singing up to date.
@@farruqameen3560 The number speaks for itsellf.
@@ninadchoudhury3362 Shemaroo video company recorded 21 million views of Rafi's solo in 1974 film Thokar. The music was by little known Music Directors Shyam ji Ghanshyam ji.
@@farruqameen3560 Rajesh Khanna tajessh Khanna kishor Kumar ki vajah se bne us samay Kishore da jiske liye gate the vo film hot or hero star ban jate h
Unbeatable Kishore kumar 👌👌👌🌷🌷🙏🙏🙏
It's the emotion and the expression that Rafi sahab puts in any song that he sings,he just puts life into it.
Kishore is the greatest singer ever
Mohd rafi is greatest of all and everyone a devine pesonality with the voice of god himself
During 1950' s once the great SD Burman ji rejected Kishore Kumar's play back singing , remember both of them are from Bengal , during that era the songs were composed on classical touch & the saptha swar of music was reflected during that periods song , 1950 to 1970 the hero's were not graded no 1 ,2 etc , but Rajesh Khanna was popularised because of some storys of the films , then onwards the hero's opinion was taken into consideration for to whom to sing his song , Amithabh also followed the same , but after 1976 once again rafi was popular in hindi film history , example Film Sargams songs etc
@@devikadevika2360 very true
Kishore is greatest in Indian history
गुलाब, हिना और जन्नतूल फ़िरदौस इत्रों का आपसी मुकाबला कैसे सम्भव है ??
Jo kishore kumar ji ne gaya tha..wo geet amar ho gaya.
Always.. Kishore Kumar ji.... superb..
Mohammad rafi ka jawab nahin.... Par ye gana Kishore kumar ne jaise gaya hai vaise koi nhain ga sakta
kishore kumar ji best singer.
SIR JI,,,MOHAMMED RAFI,,,KISHOR DA,,,ASHA BHOSALE,,,,,3 NO SINGER'S,,,,EK HI MAALA KE MOTI,,,,,SHANKAR JAYKISHAN SAHAB JI GREAT GREAT GREAT GREAT GREAT MUSIC DIRECTOR,,,,,,AND GREAT GREAT VERY VERY NICE INFORMATION 👌
1 rafi sahab
2 kishor da
3 Mukeshji
4 udit narayan
5 Kumar sanu
Due respect to Rafi saab n Ashaji but Kishorda had edge over rest of the singers - this song is still popular but only in kishorda’s voice. Nothing wrong in giving credit to Kishorda that doesn’t make rafisaab inferior singer - he was also great.
Mohammad Rafi is the best and greatest playback singer ! ...incomparable ! His songs make such a vast repertoire , huge range and myriad of genre and numerous moods. Just consider any field e.g. romantic songs , qawwalis , bhajans , patriotic songs et. el ....in all the fields Rafi sahab is outstanding. Other singers have limitations : some have thick and hoarse voice which goes well in a limited range , but they can't fit in higher octave ; some singers are highly trained in classical music with a high range , but their voice lacks the intoxication of romance which Rafi Sahab's voice is inherited with. Just watch what the great maestros viz. Yesudas ji , Manna Dey ji , S P Balasubramaniyam ji , Jayachandran ji , IliyaRaja ji , O P Nayyar ji , Ravi ji and many others have said about Rafi sahab - you then know that Rafi Sahab's voice was a special gift by God to the mankind !
RAFI-SAHAB-ALL-TIME-GREAT
YOU ARE RIGHT
HATS-OF-YOU
Ye gana bhi agar pura rafi sahab ko kishore sahab ke andaz me gate to ye bhi hit ho jata
Bahut sahi
Rafi Saab k bhajno me sakchhat ishwar ki anubhuti hoti he. Kohinoor of India rafisab, kishore, latadi. 🙏
Kishor Kumar is the God of singing no one can compare with him. He is all-rounder
NO ONE CAN NEVER BEAT RAFI SAHEB.
HE IS UNBEATABLE FOR EVER.
You lousy Kishore is the greatest ever
Rafi Sahab 🙏🙏🙏🙏
Comparison between these legends is not good, I am diehard fan of Rafi sahab but still feels they all given their best to Indian music industry, they all are like a gems in crown of Indian music industry.
Thanks for your feedback. There is nothing like comparison bhai
Kya Mohd Rafi Saheb se kisi ko compare karna sahi hai ??? Mohd Rafi sahab ne kaise kaise gaane gaya hai . Nobody can touch the range of Rafi sahab . No male or female singer , can reach Rafi sahab .
Kishore Kumar jesa koi nhi mere bhai
@@rajmandal5823 Give reason
@@russelindia listen rup tera mastana song kishor ji jo gaya vo koi Nhi ga pya
@@dr.priyanka__6 Madam Mr Kishore himself said in his interview Rd used to make tunes lighter for him , so that he could sing.
Now if you claim to know more about kishore than himself , then Madam you think does that make any sense?
Rafi sahab is d greatest singer ever
For this song, everyone has forgotten Rafi and Asha version, we remember only the clarion call of zindadilli with Rajesh Khanna racing on mobike and Kishore's voice.
Kishore da ne jo gane ko gaya woh dusro ki awaz me nhi sun sakte. Kishore da ki awaz bahut powerful hai
Yes agree
Only rafi sahab
You lousy Kishore is the greatest singer ever
Kishore is right Kishore. None is near him, none is beyond him. His voice sweet, heavy, masculine. Crying and shouting are not found in his singing. A half-feminine crying tone is never comparable with that of Kishore.
Udlay udlay udlay,Uhh uuu meaning at the end of life crying and helpless shouting only remain.😀😀
@@farooqhussain9301 It is very absurd and shameful that a Man has womanish voice.
Litu das, Do you know what is called 'এড়ে গলা'? 'এড়ে গলা' means hoarse voice which is possessed by Kishore kumar you may say it 'masculine' but he is populr all over the world.Men accepted him.In the same way huge number of people accepted Rafi's crying and shouting.I think you are envious of Rafi's soothing voice. I like kishore da's 'এড়ে গলা'.😀😀😀
@@litudas793keep in mind masculine and heavy voice can not be sweet,so sad song did not give kishore da the perfection he might be expected.
@@farooqhussain9301 Try to understand the difference between singing and crying. Crying can never be dignified as song. If musculine and heavy voice can't be sweet, is the voice of Mehdi Haasan very sour?
Rafi version was not available on record during that time
Because it was not that popular in comparison with Kishoreda's version.
Kishorda sung the whole song. Rafi sahab sung only one line.
Kishore ji ke voice ke samne Rafi ,manna, Hemant koi bhi aaye sabka voice fika par jata hai Joy Ho kishore da ka ❤️❤️❤️
Thanks for your valuable feedback
@@DILSEDILTAKJD welcome sir 🙏
Rafi sahab is a versatile singer
Rafi saab Kishore da manna Dey mukesh ji sab lajwaab hai
Sabke apne apne mood apne apne andaaz hai.
Is liye tulna karna vayarth hai.
Sir geet sune or anand le.
This song turned out to be the last song that Jaikishan (Shankar Jaikishan) recorded before his death.
This song was in the TOP 1 in Binaca Geetmala(ALL INDIA RADIO)in 1971.
Thanks for your valuable updates
Kyuki bahut se log comment karte hai Kishore da was a street singer agar street singer Ho te to unhe 8 filmfare Award nahi milata aur 28 gaane filmfare ke liye nominate nahi hote
Thanks for your valuable feedback
Very goood yaaaar. Ye bat ki apne. Sanjana g. Ye kute ki tarah bhokte hai sanjana. Inko kon samjhaye. Ye bas compare karte rahenge. Aur kuch nahi. Kyuki ye khud kuch nahi kar sakte na isliye. Love u kishor da an rafi sahab. Sacha bhagat fan wohi hai jo barabar. Inko respect de. Nahi toh kute bohat bhokne ke liye
You need to make proper analysis , till 1970 Kishore did not get any nomination .
Also Kishore won 3 awards during lifetime of Rafi .
आप मोहम्मद रफी को जनाब मोहम्मद रफी कह रहे हैं। परंतु किशोर कुमार को किशोर कुमार कह रहे हैं। आश्चर्य होता है।
Nahi bhai mera koi bhi aisa maqsad nahi hota. Dono hi kalakar utne hi mahan kalakar the aur rahenge. Main without script video banata hun to ek flow mein jo bol diya wohi on air upload ho jata hai. Aap ke suggestion ke liye dhanyavad bhai
Mohd rafi is better than anyother singer in the world.
Rafi sb best
Kishore Kumar..
सच कहे ताे रफीसाहब ने गाया गीत सबसे सुमधुर है
Yes agree
Very nice
If it had been sung fully, it would have been a bigger hit than Kishore Da.
The portion of Rafi sb is even not Audible, the recording quality is also very poor.
It's a fact that many people in the industry were jealous of him because of his popularity.
Due to politics of other singers/director/producers, Rafi sb lost many tracks, which went to Kishore Da, or sang by others.
All music lovers know in their heart 💓, who was/is/will be the best, till the dooms day.
Best out of best is Rafi Sahab no doubt best video
Rafi sahab is the best best best classical songs sad songs every types of songs
Very nice information thanku sir
Kishore Kumar ka koi jawab nhi waah gajab ki awaz h,aisa singer koi nhi ho sakta the great Kishore da
Mai bhi Kishor Kumar ka fan Hu unke gana bahut sunta Hun , lekin Jo baat rafi sahab ki aawaz me thi o ksi or me nahi 🇮🇳💞 i love kishor Da and rafi sahab
Mohammad Rafi is a legend ✨
Awesome Rafisab love forever 👌❤
सिचुएशन अलग अलग है दोनो गानों की, किशोरदा का गाना हैप्पी मूड में है और रफी साहब का गाना अलग सिचुएशन पर है...no comparison both are great
Ek dam sahi bole hai
👍
Yes totally agree with you
No body can come near to Rafi the great Top singer of the world
You lousy muslim Kishore is the greatest singer ever
Sach bolane se Dara mat karo Kishor Kumar sahab ka gana sabse super tha aur Aaj bhi hai ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️🙏🙏🙏🙏
ये गीत किशोर दा की आवाज मे ही अच्छा लगता है,
Rafi sahab sub she bestsong gaay hai
Sandar.💜
Md Rafiji was great and he is real "son of India"...but this song borned for only Kishore Kumar...it was created high sentation allover India....it was one of the "only Kishore Kumar's song"
Chahe kuch bhi kaho. Jab bhi koi. Is gane ki bat karega. Ya puchega. Sabse pehle kishor da hi yaad ayenge. Kyunki. U ka version jyada hit hua. Aur kya khooob khaya dada ne.
Thank,s a lot I miss u rafi sahab
Thanks for your feedback
i Love You Md Rafi
uss waqt filmi duniya mai sabhi kis actor per kis playback singer ki awaaz mach hoti hai ye sabse pehle sochte thhe..
isliye Rajesh Khanna ji per Kishore da ki Awaaz di gayi or Shammi ji per Rafi saahab ki..
Ye baat alag hai ki Rajesh Khanna ji per filmaye Kishore da ke geet ki wajah se Andaaz film ko jitni kamyabi milni thhi usse zyada mili..
Jai Rafi saahab 🙏
Jai Kishore da 🙏
We love Rafi saahab ❤️
We love Kishore da ❤️
Yes agree
@@DILSEDILTAKJD 🙏🙏❤️
Rafi sahib iss choti ke gayak thhe ki wo har acter ke sath apni awaj match kar kar lete thhe. ye baat galat ha Rajesh ji sath unki awaj match nahi thhi. Do raste ke Geet suno. Sacha Jhootha ka Geet yunhi tum mujhse baat karti ho suno. Sirf Aradhna ke Geet jis movie ne Rajesh ji ko star banaya u aue RD ko hit kiya usi wajah se Kisore lime light main aa gaye. Warna 1980 main Kishore ji ne Jitender ji ke liye jo geet gaye thhe unhone Music ka level gira diya thha.
Great Mohamma Rafi Sahab Ki Jai Ho Rip
100 SINGER EK TARAF ___KISHORE DA EK TARAF 🙏🙏🙏💐💐💐 (VOICE OF GOD)🙏🙏🙏💐💐💐
Md. Rafi. No comparison.
Kishore Kumar 👌👌
RAFI SAAB
Aapne janab Mohammed Rafi kaha sir dil khus hogaya jio yaar dil se Salam he
Thanks bhai
Kishore da Bhagwan hai
Yes agree
Kishoreda ka koi zabab nahi...isko gaya tha kishore da ne per lobbying ke karan KISHORE da... ko vote ni mila...jai kishore da..