They both work for me, both having their individual use. I use both in various recipes like potato salad and tuna macaroni salad to get that little tang from Miracle Whip to enhance the flavor, even a hint of mustard. I use mayo when I want the full flavor of an item to shine thru like ham/egg salad or lunchmeat and other foods. They are definitely different but I like the qualities and flavors of both.
I prefer miracle whip. But if you made tuna fish and blindfolded me. I honestly don't think I could taste a difference. Quite actually I'm just happy that somebody else made it instead of me. Plus that's what momma served. And as we ALL KNOW! No one cooks better than momma. Lol.
If I'm at your house and ask "Got any mayo?" and you say "Yeah, it's in the fridge.'. If I open that fridge and find only Miracle Whip I'm going to take that as a personal attack. For one how dare you tell me you have mayo when you know damn well Miracle Whip is not mayo. Laaty.. if you tell me "You can't even tell the difference." we're fighting.
As someone who spent some time in the Midwest, I was surprised upon first taste. A much sweeter and tangier flavor. After that first taste I got used to it and also knew which sandwiches it would work with.
My every day choice is Miracle Whip LIGHT. On special occasions, I might go for regular mayo. Like lots of other 75-year olds, I'm trying to take better care of my heart. And Miracle Whip LIGHT fits the bill.
This is funny to me because my wife grew up in Florida (hates miracle whip) I grew up in Indiana (hates Mayonnaise) we have both in the fridge at any time.
@Mashed: Miracle whip in canada does not have high fructose corn syrup and neither the regular corn syrup, just the normal sugar instead and neither have citric acid but it does have vinegar to replace the citric acid, and the add dry garlic, it does have the other ingredient that you listed egg, and mustard and soybean oil.
Recipe on UA-cam for mayonnaise: milk and oil 50/50, blend. Long shelf life. Choose your milk and oil. Can't go wrong. Thank you to the people/person who made the video for real mayonnaise. Kudos!
In NJ, the map explains why Miracle Whip is only available in small jars now in NJ. 20 years ago there were dozens of large Miracle Whip jars on the shelves. Now, only a handful of small jars.
New Jersey is more disgusting than Miracle Whip, & I loathe Miracle Whip! Also, I do live in the deep south, & nobody here eats Miracle Whip! This is Duke's Country! That map is a joke! We put Mayo on Everything!
Who said you had to pick one? Different condements for different uses - mayo for lighter sandwiches/etc. where its lighter flavor won't get overpowered, whip for sandwiches/etc. with stronger flavors. Also depends on the flavors too, since mayo and whip have noticeably different flavor profiles. All about matching the right flavors with the right flavors.
In the UK, the choice is between Mayo and Salad Cream (which isn't like Miracle Whip). Salad cream is fairly dense (but less stiff than good jar Mayo), quite yellow, sweet/sour/mustardy I think Miracle whip will only be available in a few specialist shops/online (imported from US and pricey)
As a European I'm shocked that America has a substitute for mayonnaise. Your Miracle Whip would never sell here, especially in Belgium where fries are enjoyed with real mayonnaise.
As a very small child, before I ever started school, I refused to eat anything with mayonnaise - I hated the flavor. I wanted ‘the other one’. The ‘Whip’. I have tried every mayo on the market ( in-laws preferred it), and yet, at 68 years, although, for courtesy sake, I am able to eat mayo-containing recipes when I dine out, my fridge has only Miracle Whip.
I grew up mostly in Indiana, and lived my entire adult life in Florida. Of course I love Miracle Whip. Mayo, vomit. Deviled eggs with Miracle Whip...delicious. My favorite food featuring Miracle Whip is the bacon sandwich...toasted bread, iceberg lettuce, lots of bacon, double serving of Miracle Whip.
Miracle Whip for me. Grew up with it. Only time I ever have mayo is when I eat out. . . Pretty sure no fast food joint or restaurant uses Miracle Whip. So no hate here. But where Miracle Whip really shines is in salads- its primary intended purpose. Macaroni and potato salads are elevated when made with it.
People gotta stop looking at ingredients as "good or bad" and start just accepting different ingredients for different uses. Mayo and Miracle Whip are certainly similar, but they definitely aren't the same, anyone who's had both should certainly understand that. Mayo has a lighter flavor the compliments other similarly light flavors, while Whip has a more pronounced flavor that won't get overpowered by other strong flavors. For example, mayo all day for something like a chicken or turkey deli sandwich(especially one where you may not want Whip's sweetness) - and Whip all day for a BLT or a fried bologna sandwich. The mayo won't overpower something as light as turkey while still complimenting its flavor(and adding some moisture if it's dry as hell LOL), and Whip won't get overpowered by the shear density of flavor from bacon/fried bologna while the sweetness it has balances out the bitter char on the outside of the bacon/bologna as well as just the savoriness. I don't have a preference, I just have different use cases. There are no bad ingredients - only bad cooks!🔫🔫🔫
Considering that Best Foods is only sold west of the Rockies and Hellmann's is sold only east of the Rockies, and both are basically the same product, the distribution of preferences on the US map is not a significant finding.
Growing up i thought i hated mayo, turns out my absolute dunce of a father had me and somehow himself convinced that miracle whip was mayo, he still thinks so and it drives me crazy. When i grew up and found out that miracle whip is not mayo my mind was blown, i actually really like mayo. To this day i bring my own mayo to cook outs at his house.
miracle whip for potato salad/egg salad/deviled eggs (mustard added for a little sour kick) I also like it with chicken salad or a spam sandwich. mayo has its uses as well tho.
STOP... You just made me lose my appetite. I can't believe anyone still uses that nasty shit. You must have REALLY nasty smelling bowel movements... I would never eat anything you cook. Miracle Whip is sweetened sperm juice in a jar with sugar.
I hardly ever ate any mayonnaise growing up and plan to eat very little of it in the remainder of my life as well. But just want to throw in a 3rd option, Asian mayo. You're welcome --> old Chinese American from Taiwan.
I buy miracle whip because it makes egg salad and chicken salad taste so much better because of the sugar and the added spices. Mayo I use for things that I need the flavor to shine threw.
Miracle Whip is NOT mayonnaise. Stop confusing the two. One tastes good and the other one is nasty. Mayo is better. Miracle Whip is just as much a waste of money as Cheez Whiz. Yuck. Grody...
Miracle Whip and mayo each work better with different sandwiches. For me, Miracle Whip is best with a BLT or simple homemade deli meat sandwich. Mayo is better with a chicken sandwich or burger.
I've NEVER been a fan of Miracle whip! It's always tasted to sweet for my likes. I've ALWAYS been a Mayo person. That being said...neither one is a healthy choice though!👍
Fun video guys！I like mayo very much, but some jars are not easy to open, I have a stainless steel jar opener named GTAGGEE, which can be easily opened
This. I for a while thought Kraft mayo was the best as it had a zestiness to it. But then I tried blue plate. Now I that I'm out of blue plate I gotta finish the kraft...
i can do a blind taste test and tell you which is Hellman's, Kraft, Duke's and Blue Plate, but my favorite is Chick-fil-a, but you cant buy it in a store. I buy the Aldi brand because it's actually Hellman's but for half the price. Miracle Whip belongs in only one place.....the land fill.
The main problem with HFCS is, IMO, the fact that it doesn't trigger a 'full' sensation the way regular sugar does so you keep eating/drinking products sweetened with it.
Mayo is a base to use in cooking (make with) like in a Potatoe Salad etc.... Miracle Whip is for things like Sandwiches and Thus, is a Mans Favorite for Sandwiches other than Mustard, Italian Sauces/Dressings. Have a sandwich made with Mayo and one with Miracle Whip = Miracle Whip will always win. Miracle Whip is seasoned, Mayo is not. Mayo is a general product to use. Miracle Whip is not, it is much more. Mayo would be like to Water and Miracle Whip would be like to anything else!!!!!! QUESTION THEN BECOMES: Do you want to Drink Water (General product aka Mayo General Product) and only water or would you like something else with more flavor? Mmmmm...............Miracle Whip.
I've unsubscribed, but I wouldn't trust anything you say. It's your narrative, but it doesn't mean you can back your narrative. Can't have the cake and eat it too. I trust the cake won't be eating me because it gets mixed up in stuff too much.
Miracle Whip sucks.💩 Hellman's is the bomb.😋 Just sucks they put MW on Whoppers at Burger King for the last 3 years.👎 This throws off the taste BIG-TIME!🤬
Do you prefer mayonnaise or Miracle Whip?
Miracle Whip all the way.
Team Miracle Whip in fact we don’t even have mayonnaise in our household.
Dukes Mayonnaise for the last 10 years
Miracle Whip is for people that rode the short bus. Hellmann's all the way. Dukes is for the driver of the short bus.
@@brentworls8509 clearly you don’t know good food when you taste it. You probably like 🍍 🍕 too.
They both work for me, both having their individual use. I use both in various recipes like potato salad and tuna macaroni salad to get that little tang from Miracle Whip to enhance the flavor, even a hint of mustard. I use mayo when I want the full flavor of an item to shine thru like ham/egg salad or lunchmeat and other foods. They are definitely different but I like the qualities and flavors of both.
I agree. I always have both in the pantry.
I aslo agree. Both have their place in many dishes.
I don't know how anyone could mistake Miracle whip for mayonnaise.
Said absolutely no one. Who gets them confused I Wana know..
I prefer miracle whip. But if you made tuna fish and blindfolded me. I honestly don't think I could taste a difference. Quite actually I'm just happy that somebody else made it instead of me.
Plus that's what momma served.
And as we ALL KNOW!
No one cooks better than momma. Lol.
i did. i had no idea what miracle whip was until now
I did when I first moved on my own I thought it was mayo and it was disgusting 🤢🤢
Lol they literally look the same
People overlook the name of miracle whip, it’s truly a miracle. Nothing can ever touch that flavour.
If I'm at your house and ask "Got any mayo?" and you say "Yeah, it's in the fridge.'. If I open that fridge and find only Miracle Whip I'm going to take that as a personal attack. For one how dare you tell me you have mayo when you know damn well Miracle Whip is not mayo. Laaty.. if you tell me "You can't even tell the difference." we're fighting.
I support this a million percent 😅
I only use Hellman's mayo. Thank you for sharing have a blessed day stay safe and healthy. 🙏❤🙏❤🙏
As someone who spent some time in the Midwest, I was surprised upon first taste. A much sweeter and tangier flavor. After that first taste I got used to it and also knew which sandwiches it would work with.
My every day choice is Miracle Whip LIGHT. On special occasions, I might go for regular mayo. Like lots of other 75-year olds, I'm trying to take better care of my heart. And Miracle Whip LIGHT fits the bill.
This is funny to me because my wife grew up in Florida (hates miracle whip) I grew up in Indiana (hates Mayonnaise) we have both in the fridge at any time.
My Grandma used to make her chicken salad with Miracle Whip, so does my whole family now. Only for Pommes Frites (French Fries) we use Mayo.
@Mashed: Miracle whip in canada does not have high fructose corn syrup and neither the regular corn syrup, just the normal sugar instead and neither have citric acid but it does have vinegar to replace the citric acid, and the add dry garlic, it does have the other ingredient that you listed egg, and mustard and soybean oil.
Is hfcs banned in Canada?
Recipe on UA-cam for mayonnaise: milk and oil 50/50, blend. Long shelf life. Choose your milk and oil. Can't go wrong. Thank you to the people/person who made the video for real mayonnaise. Kudos!
In NJ, the map explains why Miracle Whip is only available in small jars now in NJ. 20 years ago there were dozens of large Miracle Whip jars on the shelves. Now, only a handful of small jars.
New Jersey is more disgusting than Miracle Whip, & I loathe Miracle Whip!
Also, I do live in the deep south, & nobody here eats Miracle Whip! This is Duke's Country!
That map is a joke!
We put Mayo on Everything!
kelly you don’t have to be so mean lol …. we aren’t all crazy! i’m from jersey . also it’s Hellmanns mayo all the way up here lmao
Duke's 'til the end, but I mess with Miracle Whip. It's good on a cold cut sandwich that you put way too much ish on and stuff your face.
I had no idea that I was playing into a regional stereotype by liking miracle whip.
Me too 😂
I grew up loving miracle whip but 10 years ago I was introduced to Dukes mayonnaise and I will not go back to miracle whip.
Who said you had to pick one? Different condements for different uses - mayo for lighter sandwiches/etc. where its lighter flavor won't get overpowered, whip for sandwiches/etc. with stronger flavors. Also depends on the flavors too, since mayo and whip have noticeably different flavor profiles. All about matching the right flavors with the right flavors.
In the UK, the choice is between Mayo and Salad Cream (which isn't like Miracle Whip). Salad cream is fairly dense (but less stiff than good jar Mayo), quite yellow, sweet/sour/mustardy
I think Miracle whip will only be available in a few specialist shops/online (imported from US and pricey)
I love Miracle Whip or Sandwich Spread on my sandwich.
I worked at Duke's in Greenville for 8 years..
I literally made both..
Now I can't eat either 🤣
As a European I'm shocked that America has a substitute for mayonnaise. Your Miracle Whip would never sell here, especially in Belgium where fries are enjoyed with real mayonnaise.
no one cares mate
@@poluticon Europe cares.
@@PatGeo95 as I said...
@@poluticon 👍😁
Try Ranch dressing on yer fries.... & say bye bye to Mayo!!!!
As a very small child, before I ever started school, I refused to eat anything with mayonnaise - I hated the flavor. I wanted ‘the other one’. The ‘Whip’. I have tried every mayo on the market ( in-laws preferred it), and yet, at 68 years, although, for courtesy sake, I am able to eat mayo-containing recipes when I dine out, my fridge has only Miracle Whip.
I like the miracle taste of the Miracle Whip and that's all that matters
Are both keto friendly?
I grew up mostly in Indiana, and lived my entire adult life in Florida. Of course I love Miracle Whip. Mayo, vomit.
Deviled eggs with Miracle Whip...delicious. My favorite food featuring Miracle Whip is the bacon sandwich...toasted bread, iceberg lettuce, lots of bacon, double serving of Miracle Whip.
It’s called a blt brotha. Just without tomato just how I like it
I hate Miracle Whip. It’s Hellmanns all the way jack.
@@josephk7530 To each his own, chief! 🤣
Miracle Whip for me. Grew up with it. Only time I ever have mayo is when I eat out. . . Pretty sure no fast food joint or restaurant uses Miracle Whip. So no hate here. But where Miracle Whip really shines is in salads- its primary intended purpose. Macaroni and potato salads are elevated when made with it.
Eloteros in Cali use something similar to Miracle Whip
My mother always preferred MW over Mayo.I love Mw
I kraft mayo made with avocado oil. No soybean oils. Top of the line spread!
People gotta stop looking at ingredients as "good or bad" and start just accepting different ingredients for different uses. Mayo and Miracle Whip are certainly similar, but they definitely aren't the same, anyone who's had both should certainly understand that. Mayo has a lighter flavor the compliments other similarly light flavors, while Whip has a more pronounced flavor that won't get overpowered by other strong flavors. For example, mayo all day for something like a chicken or turkey deli sandwich(especially one where you may not want Whip's sweetness) - and Whip all day for a BLT or a fried bologna sandwich. The mayo won't overpower something as light as turkey while still complimenting its flavor(and adding some moisture if it's dry as hell LOL), and Whip won't get overpowered by the shear density of flavor from bacon/fried bologna while the sweetness it has balances out the bitter char on the outside of the bacon/bologna as well as just the savoriness.
I don't have a preference, I just have different use cases. There are no bad ingredients - only bad cooks!🔫🔫🔫
ONLY Hellmann’s mayonnaise or Kraft Mayo for me, I switch back & forth ....no Miracle Whip. To each her/his own flavor.
Miracle Whip is revolting. Ive tried so many times, to add it in certain recipies, etc. But I just cannot stand it. I'm a Duke's girl 200%
3:11 Imagine downgrading Mayonnaise to Miracle Whip, and spending EFORT to do it!?!?
Better Call Saul
I'm here from the newest episode of Better Call Saul
Considering that Best Foods is only sold west of the Rockies and Hellmann's is sold only east of the Rockies, and both are basically the same product, the distribution of preferences on the US map is not a significant finding.
Miracle Whip makes great pimento cheese spread
I knew I’d find a vid on this. UA-cam has anything
I’m an east coaster who likes miracle whip more than mayo and I feel like some people hate me for it here lol, what can I say I think it’s good 😂
I love miracle whip
Growing up i thought i hated mayo, turns out my absolute dunce of a father had me and somehow himself convinced that miracle whip was mayo, he still thinks so and it drives me crazy. When i grew up and found out that miracle whip is not mayo my mind was blown, i actually really like mayo. To this day i bring my own mayo to cook outs at his house.
I don't know either. They are totally different. Altogether different taste.😊
I've always used Best Foods mayonnaise!
miracle whip for potato salad/egg salad/deviled eggs (mustard added for a little sour kick)
I also like it with chicken salad or a spam sandwich.
mayo has its uses as well tho.
STOP... You just made me lose my appetite. I can't believe anyone still uses that nasty shit. You must have REALLY nasty smelling bowel movements... I would never eat anything you cook. Miracle Whip is sweetened sperm juice in a jar with sugar.
Anyone here after Better call saul Penuntlimate episode?
Miracle whip is the "boneless wing" of the sandwich spreads. I feel like, in general, boneless wing people intersect with miracle whip people.
One is better than the other,depends on what your making,and when you figure it out..its 😋🤗🤗
I grew up on Miracle Whip, but after trying mayo on my own, especially hellmans, Im for mayo
Nothing beats the old Miracle WIPE! 😋😋
I hardly ever ate any mayonnaise growing up and plan to eat very little of it in the remainder of my life as well. But just want to throw in a 3rd option, Asian mayo. You're welcome --> old Chinese American from Taiwan.
Hellman’s all day but I have to try dukes.
Dukes is better!
I was Hellmans all my life till I tried dukes.
Like, if you are here for better call saul
Miracle Whip. My great grandmother switched soon as she tried it. 😊😊😊
I buy miracle whip because it makes egg salad and chicken salad taste so much better because of the sugar and the added spices. Mayo I use for things that I need the flavor to shine threw.
its the mustard... there isnt that much sugar at all in MW
One is extremely sweet one isn't one is smooth.
I’m a blue plate fan
The absolute best especially for salads...(tuna, potato, etc.)
Why does this video say that Miracle Whip has lemon juice?
0:03 MOAR MAYOOO I can almost see the bun
Miracle Whip is NOT mayonnaise. Stop confusing the two. One tastes good and the other one is nasty. Mayo is better. Miracle Whip is just as much a waste of money as Cheez Whiz. Yuck. Grody...
I love Cain's, its what I grew up on, Hellman's would be my other go to if I cannot find Cain's. MW has never been my favorite
This is stupid they taste totally different and I love Duke's!!! I wouldn't put miracle whip on my dogs food
I've never seen Duke's, always MW, Cain's and Hellman's, and of course store brand, Duke's must not be where I am
Love Kraft💙❤️🇯🇲
Thanks Paula I thought I was tripping. Miracle whip 🤮🤮
Miracle Whip and mayo each work better with different sandwiches. For me, Miracle Whip is best with a BLT or simple homemade deli meat sandwich. Mayo is better with a chicken sandwich or burger.
Miracle Whip is for Tuna and Craboroni. Mayo is for Everything else.
Miracle Whip for sandwiches and Mayo for salads
Vice versa for me
I’ve never like mayo and always liked MW it’s a night and day difference in this spread
I thought that thing was some kind of cream, whip, like whipped cream
I've NEVER been a fan of Miracle whip! It's always tasted to sweet for my likes. I've ALWAYS been a Mayo person. That being said...neither one is a healthy choice though!👍
Thumbs up Always!💕The person who is reading this comment, I wish you great success, health, love and happiness 🌹
Fun video guys！I like mayo very much, but some jars are not easy to open, I have a stainless steel jar opener named GTAGGEE, which can be easily opened
Miracle Whip is the only way to go!
Blue Plate mayo is the best mayo... It's head and shoulders above the rest
This. I for a while thought Kraft mayo was the best as it had a zestiness to it. But then I tried blue plate. Now I that I'm out of blue plate I gotta finish the kraft...
Best Foods ta Ras!
i can do a blind taste test and tell you which is Hellman's, Kraft, Duke's and Blue Plate, but my favorite is Chick-fil-a, but you cant buy it in a store. I buy the Aldi brand because it's actually Hellman's but for half the price. Miracle Whip belongs in only one place.....the land fill.
Only Hellman's (Best) for me.
I have never heard of miracle whip but I thought it was just mayonnaise with a different name
MAYONNAISE ON AN ESCALATOR
Sometimes it's hard to choose which one to use.
The main problem with HFCS is, IMO, the fact that it doesn't trigger a 'full' sensation the way regular sugar does so you keep eating/drinking products sweetened with it.
Yep yep yep
The difference is......Mayo is bland and oily. Miracle whip is yummy!
I accidentally tried it thinking it was mayo and almost threw up it’s disgusting 🤮
@@lemonhead1442 It's your choice to eat oily bland goo. I prefer something with TASTE.
@@bettysmith3921 you’re probably just fat and like sweeter things
@@lemonhead1442 I guess if weighing 130 lbs is fat to you, you've got problems.
0:42 Rolling corn in miracle whip is truly gag inducing.
Sorry.
Both
Your just figuring this out.
Miracle Whip is the best. Mayo is nowhere near.
Salad dressing is not mayo ppl.
Duke's is the 🐐
It is not hard to tell the difference. Here's the difference:
Mayonnaise - Delicious!
Miracle Whip - Disgusting!
Miracle Whip is the worst of the worst. I've tried Dukes Mayonnaise and it's the absolute best. And who would put Greek yogurt on a sandwich?
Miracle Whip is amazing. Mayonnaise is extremely bland.
I agree, miracle whip is flavorless.
Agree about the yogurt but enjoy miracle whip on a lunchmeat sandwich.
HELLMANN'S ORIGINAL 4 LIFE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Mayo tastes better and has a better texture.Miracle Whip tastes gross.
Kraft is an insult. Their food is disgusting. All of it. I am not a Kraft user, no thank you.
Mayo is a base to use in cooking (make with) like in a Potatoe Salad etc....
Miracle Whip is for things like Sandwiches and Thus, is a Mans Favorite for Sandwiches other than Mustard, Italian Sauces/Dressings.
Have a sandwich made with Mayo and one with Miracle Whip = Miracle Whip will always win.
Miracle Whip is seasoned, Mayo is not.
Mayo is a general product to use. Miracle Whip is not, it is much more.
Mayo would be like to Water and Miracle Whip would be like to anything else!!!!!!
QUESTION THEN BECOMES: Do you want to Drink Water (General product aka Mayo General Product) and only water or would you like something else with more flavor?
Mmmmm...............Miracle Whip.
I only like Miracle Whip. I detest that no taste mayonnaise. Miracle Whip is the best.
Miracle Whip = Miracle Ick.
Hellmann's always
Miracle Whip has more carbs.
DUKE's all day
The soybean oil is over used. Mayo has eggs?????? More soybean oil to replace eggs.
Raw egg at that.
I've unsubscribed, but I wouldn't trust anything you say. It's your narrative, but it doesn't mean you can back your narrative. Can't have the cake and eat it too. I trust the cake won't be eating me because it gets mixed up in stuff too much.
I hate Miracle Whip its sweet
Miracle Whip sucks.💩 Hellman's is the bomb.😋 Just sucks they put MW on Whoppers at Burger King for the last 3 years.👎 This throws off the taste BIG-TIME!🤬
@RockinRob69 Thx for that news... no wonder they taste different!