He is a sensible, educated and mature individual, a true Bengali bhadralok. Sensible not to be part of this circus and mela which is in anyway in it's dying stages and will soon be shown the door, by the electorate !!!!!!
I too like Budhadeb very much for his simplicity and principled governance. But ,can't appreciate not accepting the award which ,probably is prompted to show the party's eagerness to grab some headlines. Even when Jyotibasu was willing accept PM ship, party declined. They ,bith Jyotida, Harikishan and Budhadeb were true communists who followed the communist principles and lived a very simple and austere life. unlike today's comrades who live 5 star life and are preciding over the extinction of communism in India. Not allowing Jyotida to become PM is a historic blunder because that single act led to deterioration of values in politics with unbridled corruption and near extinction of parties line Congress as well as Communists . Shubh chintak At the same time,
@Kafir X not necessarily my friend, its just against the ideology. Let me try to explain. In a class room, the 1st rank holder is honoured and will be teachers favorite. The backbencher for what ever the reason feels demotivated. Communist ideology is that everyone grows together and everyone is equal. I am not a communist, because i feel communist regieme will not work in the mordern world. Thankfully we are democratic country. And when democratic ruling works along side left leaning ideology the common people will be benefitted. But i do agree that corruption and other self interests have grown within the party. But the amount of true party members (who actually work for the people) will be more compared to other parties.
@Kafir X where does it say it supports china ? When an idelogical difference even came through the communist party had split into two groups. Same like the case of far right and extreme far right.
@@sandrosadhukhan King of Bhutan was given Padma Award in 1954. Guess who was ruling India in 1954. Plus, it is given to those people who have helped the nation. So those US citizen have helped the country in some way or the other, otherwise they wouldn't have received it
Ghulam Nabi Azad is willing to join the BJP. PM Modi shed tears for him. Before that Azad must damage the Congress. Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee escaped the net wisely.
why didn't cong appreciate G.N.Azad by giving him the award for his public service. the answer is the award is reserved only for the family and its cronies.
And nationalists? Go for a stroll during national anthem... Use the national flag as a tissue during yoga day... Thereby proclaiming to the world, our sense of pseudo patriotism.
It is very very unfortunate that this government did not give atleast Padmasree award to Sonu Sood! What a pity! What direction BJP government wants to advocate to the people of India?What morale lessons this govt wants to propagate to the people? Where are we leading as a country morally???
Sooooper BEtee. Here you remind me of the Doordarshan Period's Newscasters and their outstanding presentations in every aspect. Greetings and Best Wishes. Regardless of the party at the Centre, Civiliam Awards have been incurring the wrath of criticism and favoritisms are getting ascribed. Probably, the Janata Government's way could be adopted.
@@evalia123 , he was good at some aspects while Mamta Banerjee is also good in some other aspects. Mamta Banerjee developed health sector and travelling sector (road) well.
@@Adivasilover10 is cpim now active in Bengal I know that they does not have any seats ....... in our states bjp has 0 seats but there party is active...... like that is cpim active now in WB
@@evalia123 , there is a big problem. CPIm is active in Bengal and its leaders are also valuable to my knowledge but somehow BJP dragged all CPIM voteshare in the last 2 or 3 elections. It is the fault of CPIM leaders as well. The reason is CPIM leaders has been very vocal against Mamta Banerjee but soft on BJP in Bengal. I talked every CPIM supporters, they says to defeat Mamta banerjee, they are even ready to vote BJP. Their explanation, since CPIM can not win election election, so they will vote bjp to defeat Mamta banerjee and CPIM supporters has no problem with bjp's hatred ideology. This is the reason CPIM has lost voteshare. But i think CPIM has future if it strongly attack on BJP like Kerala CPIM does
Good Decision... There were many Bengali before refused Padma Award... Hemanta Mukherjee (Hemant Kumar in Hindi), Sandhya Mukherjee and many more..... Due to Communism ideology Everyone is equal and will grow / develop together. So, Communists will not accept any special award or will not accept any special benefit. He stayed in a very old 2 room flat with his wife. Don't accept any government sponsored car/ benefit. Proud of you Buddha Babu, a true gentleman. BTW what's the credibility of Padma Award now?? When it is given to Kangana and many undeserving people.
Hello Arati, We like your talk show .. They are to the point, quite analytical and objective. You don't push any hidden agenda of supporting fakes like Brother Nair. Keep up your objective and incisive shows
Aarti looking elegant in sari. Please correct you intro picture as the person on the left is achuthanandan former CM and not ems. Insidestory shows him correctly
Maybe Pakistan or Bangladesh give Padma Pushan he may except. Who cares Buddhadev declined or except? Buddhadev disrespectful to Government of India. He do not deserved to be called Leader.
संविधान काहे लिखा गया काहे कि आम गरीब परीवार सुकून से एक संवैधानिक रेशनल नॉर्मल व्यवस्था का आनंद ले सके काहे कि एक साधारण इंडिवीजूअल फैमिली पर्सन धर्म धार्मिक कर्मकांड से अंजान रहता है और थोड़ा बहुत आशा के वशीभूत पूजा इबादत करता है लेकिन साधू अघोरी तांत्रिक मौलवी धार्मिक प्रवचनकर्ता लंडचंड आदि 24*7 इसमें इंवाल्व होते हैं और ऐसे लोग अदृश्य आत्माओं का मिडीयम होते हैं इसलिए धर्म को संविधान की किताब में जगह ना दिया गया इसलिए प्राचीन राजा धर्म प्रवचन के लिए जंगल में चले जाते थे ताकि आम प्रजा को निगेटिव प्रभाव ना भुगतना परे संविधान लिखने वाले पहले इंसान को ना पता था इसलिए भारतीय संविधान लेखक कॉपी ना कर पाएं ,,,,,सोचा बता दूं।...that's it. ☠VJ...☠
Why should not Gulam Azad take the honor bestowed on him, and still be s congress man? If there is feelers in the congress party, that he has put himself for auction, then the people who voted for him till now, will judge him, when he stands for the next election.
He is a sensible, educated and mature individual, a true Bengali bhadralok. Sensible not to be part of this circus and mela which is in anyway in it's dying stages and will soon be shown the door, by the electorate !!!!!!
I too like Budhadeb very much for his simplicity and principled governance.
But ,can't appreciate not accepting the award which ,probably is prompted to show the party's eagerness to grab some headlines.
Even when Jyotibasu was willing accept PM ship, party declined.
They ,bith Jyotida, Harikishan and Budhadeb were true communists who followed the communist principles and lived a very simple and austere life.
unlike today's comrades who live 5 star life and are preciding over the extinction of communism in India.
Not allowing Jyotida to become PM is a historic blunder because that single act led to deterioration of values in politics with unbridled corruption and near extinction of parties line Congress as well as Communists .
Shubh chintak
At the same time,
The man of an impeccable integrity, Long Live Buddhadeb Bhattacharya!! Proud of you
Cant blame them. When awards are given to people like kangana, what is the credibility.
saif ali khan
@Kafir X not necessarily my friend, its just against the ideology. Let me try to explain. In a class room, the 1st rank holder is honoured and will be teachers favorite. The backbencher for what ever the reason feels demotivated. Communist ideology is that everyone grows together and everyone is equal. I am not a communist, because i feel communist regieme will not work in the mordern world. Thankfully we are democratic country. And when democratic ruling works along side left leaning ideology the common people will be benefitted. But i do agree that corruption and other self interests have grown within the party. But the amount of true party members (who actually work for the people) will be more compared to other parties.
@Kafir X why ? Do you have allergy towards facts and understanding ? You just keep repeating the same thing.
@Kafir X and whats the source ? Whatsup university ?
@Kafir X where does it say it supports china ? When an idelogical difference even came through the communist party had split into two groups. Same like the case of far right and extreme far right.
Mr.Bhattacharjee is a True Leader.
He has done the Right thing.
This is the right decision by Budhadev Bhattacharjee because he believes in Ajadi not Gulami.
Yes he believed in Ajadi from communist ideology that's why he lost in 2011.
Dude... These pseudo nationalist cowards have made a ridicule of our padma awards by using it as a bribe.
@@navinasimoes
They would have heartfully accepted if it was from china
Tumi ekta boro Baal.
@@npd9758 Abey chutiya Tera bap mudi sey bjp rss sey cpim accha hai
Communists work for the people, not for awards... Lal Salam
lo. joke of the century
@@Punitasingh-y3q You are a joke
@@Mark___933 here truth always joke only my frd
@@Punitasingh-y3q where is the joke 🤔
@@Mark___933 but the award has been rejected only by communist so joke is one you
What's the point of awarding Microsoft and Google ceos? They are American citizens and got where they are due to USA.
In your logic, there is no point in awarding Bharat Ratna to Nelson Mandela as well
@@npd9758 your argument is devoid of logic, we are talking of Padma awards given to Indian civilians, think before you try to sound smart.
@@sandrosadhukhan
King of Bhutan was given Padma Award in 1954. Guess who was ruling India in 1954.
Plus, it is given to those people who have helped the nation. So those US citizen have helped the country in some way or the other, otherwise they wouldn't have received it
@@sandrosadhukhan
Bharat Ratna is the highest position of Padma awards.
Padma awards or rajya sabha seats.... Open offer....
BJP tries to play politics at each and every events whether big or small
The left person in the cover picture is VS Achuthanandan and not EMS Nambuthiripad
Right person bhuddadev
He was right he cant take from gomuthra party
Arthi, Today we see as part of our family. Let Journalism embrace you
Ghulam Nabi Azad is willing to join the BJP. PM Modi shed tears for him. Before that Azad must damage the Congress. Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee escaped the net wisely.
why didn't cong appreciate G.N.Azad by giving him the award for his public service. the answer is the award is reserved only for the family and its cronies.
@@vm3306 there's only 3 people running the country :- Modi and his crony capitalist
To refuse an award is a fundamental right.
Great!Really his reason for declining is great
They are working for the suppressed, not for awards❤️❤️❤️
Good Decision
He is Refusing to be a Part of
Fascist Narrative. 🤨👍🏽
🤣🤣🤣
Commies are torchbearers of intolerance and fascism
And nationalists? Go for a stroll during national anthem... Use the national flag as a tissue during yoga day... Thereby proclaiming to the world, our sense of pseudo patriotism.
@@npd9758 I think you're forgetting Modi's name when remembering fascism 😗😉
@@abhishekdutta1859
If that was the case you wouldn't have commented this in the first place
It is very very unfortunate that this government did not give atleast Padmasree award to Sonu Sood! What a pity! What direction BJP government wants to advocate to the people of India?What morale lessons this govt wants to propagate to the people? Where are we leading as a country morally???
It is a pity that more than Sonu Sood, the govt could not give Bharat Ratna to Former Prime Minister P V Narasimha Rao
Communism 🔥🔥💥
Rejecting Bharat Ratna needs strong will power and commitment to the communist ideology
Because most of the cpim candidate are educated and very understanding. 🙂🙂😌
Good analysis
Very nice attire Aarti Ji, thanx for the updates
Sandhya Mulkhopaddhay and Aninda Chatterjee also refused to take award.
Sooooper BEtee. Here you remind me of the Doordarshan Period's Newscasters and their outstanding presentations in every aspect.
Greetings and Best Wishes.
Regardless of the party at the Centre, Civiliam Awards have been incurring the wrath of criticism and favoritisms are getting ascribed.
Probably, the Janata Government's way could be adopted.
Topic is explosive and the attire as well. Keep up the good journalism and unbiased 👍👍 analysis
I am Bengali
Was battarachya a better ruler than mamata? What do you think as a a bengali ......I am from kerala
@@evalia123 , he was good at some aspects while Mamta Banerjee is also good in some other aspects. Mamta Banerjee developed health sector and travelling sector (road) well.
@@Adivasilover10 is cpim now active in Bengal I know that they does not have any seats ....... in our states bjp has 0 seats but there party is active...... like that is cpim active now in WB
@@evalia123 , there is a big problem. CPIm is active in Bengal and its leaders are also valuable to my knowledge but somehow BJP dragged all CPIM voteshare in the last 2 or 3 elections. It is the fault of CPIM leaders as well. The reason is CPIM leaders has been very vocal against Mamta Banerjee but soft on BJP in Bengal. I talked every CPIM supporters, they says to defeat Mamta banerjee, they are even ready to vote BJP. Their explanation, since CPIM can not win election election, so they will vote bjp to defeat Mamta banerjee and CPIM supporters has no problem with bjp's hatred ideology. This is the reason CPIM has lost voteshare. But i think CPIM has future if it strongly attack on BJP like Kerala CPIM does
Wrongly portrayed picture of VS or Velikkakathu Sankaran Achuthanandan as EMS.
Communist ideology need to be understood to understand the refusal. Lal Salam
Photo of EMS is not shown. It is the photo of VS you are showing
It’s EMS photo
@@nandyalasundararamudu8638 In the thumbnail photo of VS is shown. In the core matter, they rightly put EMS picture.
Dictatorship of PB have to be abolished or suffer rejection by the common people.
Please reduce the price of your subscription as it is not very affordable
Good Decision... There were many Bengali before refused Padma Award... Hemanta Mukherjee (Hemant Kumar in Hindi), Sandhya Mukherjee and many more..... Due to Communism ideology Everyone is equal and will grow / develop together. So, Communists will not accept any special award or will not accept any special benefit. He stayed in a very old 2 room flat with his wife. Don't accept any government sponsored car/ benefit. Proud of you Buddha Babu, a true gentleman.
BTW what's the credibility of Padma Award now?? When it is given to Kangana and many undeserving people.
You look good… Analysis is like always very critical and a view from Bombay…
Maam you are looking gorgeous today. God bless you😇
Why is VS Achuthanandan's pic on the thumbnail?
Hello Arati,
We like your talk show ..
They are to the point, quite analytical and objective.
You don't push any hidden agenda of supporting fakes like Brother Nair.
Keep up your objective and incisive shows
Oh... I dont think you daw the video where Mr Nair was supporting demo.... He lays facts and his views....
It's not a talk show bro!! It's a news broadcast.
@@bhaskaranvinod
Thankful if you can share the link for the show where Brother Nair talks about demo.
Red salute comrade
Happy republic day 🇮🇳
I rarely missed any of your episode 😇😇
Your traditional look is so glamorous🥰
👍.... Homely is wat i can say...
Mam, looking Beautiful in Saree ❤️
Good research, it would have been better to throw some more light on these awards and the communist perspective!!
Aarti looking elegant in sari. Please correct you intro picture as the person on the left is achuthanandan former CM and not ems. Insidestory shows him correctly
For the name Cyrus Poonawala you are wrongly displaying the photo of his son Adar Poonawala.
The photograph you have shown is of V S Achuthanandan and not of EMS Namboodiripad.
Why did you put Vs Achuthanandan's picture instead of and Ems Namboodiripad in your thumbnail....🙄🤔
👌👌
Arti has been calling Buddadeb Bhattacharya but the footage was showing Bhattacharjee.
Cyrus punawala why
You look more graceful in a saree.
Honoring Buddhadeb is to tease TMC
Happy republic day aarti
35 ruling party has nothing who takes responsibility
Maybe Pakistan or Bangladesh give Padma Pushan he may except. Who cares Buddhadev declined or except? Buddhadev disrespectful to Government of India. He do not deserved to be called Leader.
The news reader and anchor Ms Ghargi, though an excellent personality, in this video has spoken a line twice, starting 'in the last few years.........
संविधान काहे लिखा गया काहे कि आम गरीब परीवार सुकून से एक संवैधानिक रेशनल नॉर्मल व्यवस्था का आनंद ले सके काहे कि एक साधारण इंडिवीजूअल फैमिली पर्सन धर्म धार्मिक कर्मकांड से अंजान रहता है और थोड़ा बहुत आशा के वशीभूत पूजा इबादत करता है लेकिन साधू अघोरी तांत्रिक मौलवी धार्मिक प्रवचनकर्ता लंडचंड आदि 24*7 इसमें इंवाल्व होते हैं और ऐसे लोग अदृश्य आत्माओं का मिडीयम होते हैं इसलिए धर्म को संविधान की किताब में जगह ना दिया गया इसलिए प्राचीन राजा धर्म प्रवचन के लिए जंगल में चले जाते थे ताकि आम प्रजा को निगेटिव प्रभाव ना भुगतना परे संविधान लिखने वाले पहले इंसान को ना पता था इसलिए भारतीय संविधान लेखक कॉपी ना कर पाएं ,,,,,सोचा बता दूं।...that's it.
☠VJ...☠
In that pic that is not ems it is vs achuthanadan . Correct it
Thank god that doctor outfit is replaced by saree
🤣🤣🤣🤣... Anyhow, looks good on her...
She wears the doctors uniform because she has to treat those Andhbhakts.
👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼
Anything for votes. Trying
ఐనవాల్లకు ఆకుల్లో కానివారికి కంచాల్లో బీజేపీ అవార్డ్స్ పొలసీ 😘
Why should not Gulam Azad take the honor bestowed on him, and still be s congress man? If there is feelers in the congress party, that he has put himself for auction, then the people who voted for him till now, will judge him, when he stands for the next election.
🇮🇳
Another historicalblunder 🤣
Licking govt boots is not communist style
@@amritsaluja5267 now the very word communist is but of laughter 😅
Seriously, English speaking classes are gravely needed. It's criminal to hear the language being decimated and keep quite!
Ummm...keep quite 🤭?
You talk about EMS and show the picture of VS Achuthanandan, check out for the actual pic of EMS. By the by Communists are all not saints
Buddha pagal ho giya he. Josh Josh me reject krke ab sar k bache khuche bal v ukhad Raha hoga
WASTE FELLOWs battacharya
Wteva Gannu...
You look more graceful in a saree.