Russian Non Acoustic Submarine Detection System
Вставка
- Опубліковано 17 тра 2024
- Russian Non Acoustic Submarine Detection System
#usnavy
#Submarine
#Nuclearweapons
#Ships
#War
#Missile
#US Navy
#nuclearsubmarine
#aircraftcarrier
#navy
#russia
#submarines
#nuclear
#military
#typhoon-classsubmarine
_______ - Наука та технологія
Not to mention the traitors who sold our secrets
And now we have the Biden administration selling out the world to terrorism and lunatics.
The biggest traitors are the politicians who can't keep their mouths shut. As the old saying goes, "two people can keep a secret only if one is dead"
thankfully
@@sabian8700
Thankfully?
GET IN THE HELICOPTER.
@@DarkMatterX1 he is Russian.
Very sceptical of this claim. I was a reactor operator and then a test engineer on sub reactors as a career during the Cold War. The claims made do not make any sense.
Same was said by rocket engine designers from NASA and other MIC of US. But Soviet rocket engine scientists designed Rocket Engines that were 15% better than American Rocket Engines.
Be it basic sciences or math, Soviet Scientists were better in those domains compared to American ones. It was only in electronics that US was better
Same attitude applied to the Japanese torpedoes ww2.
Yes, it really happened. The Soviets developed a system called SOKS (System Obnarujenia Kilvaternovo Sleda or "wake object detection system") This system included gamma ray spectrometers that could detect these tiny traces of radiation left in the submarine's wake.
Like the "claim" Sputnik was the first satellite in orbit around earth!! Also the "claim" that Tsa Bomba was the biggest nuclear bomb dropped. There are others, but you know what I mean??
@@DrRajReddy Yet, the Soviet rocket engines were never powerful enough to launch their moon mission, so they had to use several times the number of engines on the Saturn V.
Meanwhile on the US Sub, "Is he still there? Yep! Cool."
Talk about clumsy cope
@@OleDiaBole How? Observers thought tbey didn have it but obviously the american sub detected them. Nuclear subs can't be snuck up on like this wothout anyone knowing. It's the same for air interceptions, it's a consensual game of cat and mouse and it happens all the time. Too bad you couldn't get your "gotcha" for today lmao.
@@Xer405Russian copium is the #2 export of Russia after Oil😅
Uhh... the reactors were closed loop, how the hell would this ever leave radiation?
Secondary cooling is not closed loop, it uses sea water to cool the main loop, which is closed. The water from secondary cooling does pick up some radiations though much too low to be harmful to organisms, it is detectable by specialized equipment.
You lost me at "The Soviet Union claimed"
💀💀
And the stupidest of all the supidest happenings?
An American Sub and a Soviet Sub colliding with each other
also soviet sub tried to hide under a US carrier because the soviet reactors where comicaly loud. well the skipper misjudged the distance and hit the screw of the carrier.
@@Irobert1115HD BS. Soviet submarine tracked that CSG for days and ASW section of that CSG were aware that in area is Soviet submarine, but was unable to locate it.
Because this was Victor I class, it did not have towed sonar and was practically deaf in its posterior hemisphere. 21.3.1984 at night was very bad weather, which caused two things - sea was noisy and was poor visibility. Because of this, Soviet skipper lost contact with Kitty Hawk and K-314 outruned Kitty and was unable to regain contact, soviet captain ordered periscope depth to find carrier optically, but because CSG were undergoing military provocation in Soviet backyard, she was not using her signal lights and due poor visibility soviet captain did see shit. This is why they get hit by Kitty. Ov course result was what would anyone expect when 80000 ton carrier smash 5000 ton submarine. Kitty has some minor damage in hull and K-314 lost its rudder and several screw blades.
@@tomascernak6112 Thanks, Boris.
Never underestimate your opponents
In the end N.Tesla more respected than t. edison who won that war
You forgot to mention that the Soviets credited the invention of their Super-Sekrit Sub Sniffer to Dr. Trofim Lysenko.
Read “BlindMan’s Bluff “ and it was the Americans who followed multiple Soviet subs.
Both of us are constantly shadowing each others subs.
Soviets were not good at electronics but were good with basic sciences. Be it rocket engines or sensors like those mentioned in this video, soviet scientists were a lot better than Americans.
@@DrRajReddy Yes, the Soviets were so good with rocket engines, they got to the moon first. And they were so good with sensors, everyone wants to buy Russian fighters instead of American. LOL.
@@DrRajReddy Soviets had to steal almost all technology. Stole blueprints of FatMan bomb. They did have some smart people, but they were never allowed to do much outside of nuclear weapons. Soviet navy was entire pile of junk. The subs were loud and unreliable until long after Soviet Union died
@@DrRajReddy lmao they stole usa rocket tech just like nuclear and what they didnr steal came from german pows. They stole our nuclear tech, air to air missile tech, bomber tech, ect. A paper tiger is what they are.
Legend has it Russians are following boomers to this day.
Gotta wonder if it' was so effective why build only one? Declassified documents? Video brought to you by the Russian Ministry of Trust Me Bro..
If it's true, it's because Russia did what Russia does best and mouthed off about it. The subject would be investigated, rectified, improved then perfected.
Because *that's* what a fucktastic defense budget does.
If a Soviet sub was anywhere near a boomer, there was an American SSN following it. It also never happened in open ocean.
Nope. This is myth. Simple math says, you are wrong. Soviets had much more nuclear submarines in active duty, than Americans, especially in 80s.
Also Soviet submarines were fairly superior to American ones in that era.
Keep watching YT reels to improve yr expertese in military matters.
Now you can go to sleep calmly 🤣🤣🤣
@@tomascernak6112you're claiming that akula subs were better than Los Angeles class subs?
@@basedgamerguy818 Victor III subs were better than 688i class, Akula was Seawolf level, just came 15 years before Seawolf ;-)
Meanwhile, while the Soviet sub was carefully following the US sub the British was collecting data on the Soviet sub!
Look at the Soviet/russian navy , it makes no sense.
To you, a propagandized cherub!
When one is as prpaganda-branwashed as much as y, it certainly does not.
Nice try, but I call bullshit on all these claims.
Hahahah.. Ok than😂
Meanwhile you dont have space program since yr best rockets do not receive Russian engines any more.
Remember closed circuit, oxygen rich RD190, the best rocket engine in the world?
Tech yr scientists could not even copy.
@@OleDiaBole That's funny because every two to three days, I step outside my house and watch another SpaceX Falcon 9 or Falcon Heavy launch from Cape Canaveral. I'm pretty sure that Elon has put more cargo into space than every national space agency in the world combined! And the Merlin engines get reused many times.
But, to be fair your Russian scientists and engineers are very good and have developed some amazing technologies. The problem with the old USSR was that it couldn't actually build anything in volume and with high quality. Perhaps that is getting better now that communism is gone?
I learned all of this playing Silent Service on the NES back in 1990
YOU KNOW IT HAS BEEN SAID, " FIRST LIAR HASN'T GOT A CHANCE"
Either that or the Soviets just glued some stove pipes on the sub they had laying around.
Both sides have very capable technology because both side know what the other side has, with some exceptions. The exceptions would frighten the crap out of you.
So it was NOT sonar
So then a decoy leaving a somewhat stronger trail to follow would be useful, along with a decrease of chemical trail by the sub...
Little known fact about the United States is that they had an underwater hydrophone system that bordered the entire continent what's North America that was used to listen in on Russia's highly feared and regarded for its stealth capabilities the Typhoon class submarines.
Actually, that fact is very well known.
I was on a Boomer in the late 80s and we never heard a perp.
They are having a Big headache dealing with Ukraine's non-Navy
They're just helping Russia bolster their submarine fleet
Slava 🇺🇦
Meanwhile the US sub had the Soviet sub on sonar and knew exactly where it was and which individual sub it was, 20 miles away before the Soviet sub got close enough to follow.
They were doing tricks on each other all the time. There were several close calls and actual collisions when the Soviets got suspicious, and did a crazy Ivan......when they did that, they knew that the Yanks were near by
Sounds to me like Soviet propaganda, they couldn't make a Carrier that actually worked. Also managed to blow up their own subs with iffy tech.
Mhmmm... That is why your best rockets used to fly on Russian RD190 engines. Your astronauts use complete knock-off of Russian space suits. Titanium Alpha class was twice as fast as yor fastest subs and could dive 3 times deeper. You stll havent developed supercavitating torped wich Russians had in 70s. You managed to copy IRST with 40yrs delay compared to russians, same goes for helmet mounted aiming sight. You still would not have those havent you bought MiG29 and copy those from it.
Carriers are weapons of invasions against infinately weaker oponents, they did not need those.
@@OleDiaBole Soviet Propaganda rubbish, Russian space rockets were antiques with technology from 1960s when Soviet space exploration ended. No more space race when Americans landed on the moon. In America today private enterprise is leading space technology with ultra modern tech.
@@OleDiaBole What does that have to do with the video or the comment?
Pretty sure that was a flag for the city of Chicago at the beginning, not the USSR
😮 very interesting 🤔 🤔
Wow !!! So many tech and military experts here
Yeah, it's content on cold war subs. Lots of info/media out there on topic.
Broad demographic. From history nerds to war gamers.
Who else would comment?
psst. They probably know a lot of stuff about other warfare & military history too. Poke the bear. Let's see what they do. You first.
I would bet on there being a lot of other technical details that won't see the light of day for a long time to come.
And in 2024 the world is amazed that two russian navy ships made it to cuba without breaking down and or sinking
But our tech is SOOO SUPERIOR.... NEVER UNDERESTIMATE YOUR ENEMIES.
Chemical sensors. Almost sounds like science fiction.
Acoustic for sure 😉
Do you know how many American and British submarines ( especially the US) rivers sat for weeks with out the Russians knowing? Well if ykyk
So the Russians found a way to detect our submarines chemically at close range. We should also credit them with developing a submarine that we could detect audibly at any range.
I’m very skeptical about this information
Basically they used a geiger counter as a instrument to follow another sub
😮 NEVER underestimate your ENEMY 😮😮
Never underestimate how gullible UA-camrs are. This is called propaganda,.comrade percy
more disinformation
sub brief or covert shoes is a great source not youtune shorts
That doesn’t give you time or location as those chemicals and ions move with the flow of the ocean
Is that only for tracking, or it can also be used for aiming, targeting and shooting on the Submarine?
Zinc is already in salt water. In order for there to be a detectable increase in zink, that sub would have to be made entirely of zinc and melting fast. Not going to happen.
The only trail left is the Russian trail of lies.
All these things can be put into the water to leave a decoy
Yeah, except the Yanks didn't have a clue that the Soviets were testing for those particles/ elements. They thought that the Soviets were only using some outdated sonar equipment. Good for the Soviets
( if the story is true)
Was this before or after they tried to sell a large part of their navy for a bunch of Pepsi?
Gravitational field
The Enterprise wish that they had sensors, like the Russians had, at the time.
Left out is, we had an SSN behind the K ...
You forgot to mention the typhoon class with the magnetohydrodynamic drive.
If they're venting their hydrogen from the electrolysis that also means that they're dumping a little bit more of a radiation trail than you'd think they would be. The tritium levels would also be higher.
That being said it's amazing that they thought about that all the way during the Cold war. It makes you wonder how far we really are with technology, the ones we don't get to see until 60 years later
This is a wake detection sensor, which don't really work well... I have no damage idea what this guy is saying
Calling bullshit on this. S reactors have three loops. Primary loop is pressurized water, second is from the steam generator. Third is circulating water .. this third loop is the only one that has water drawn from the sea, desalinated & purified, and returned. This circulation loop is so far from the reactor that it has zero radiation contamination. ..and they're closed barriers. There's zero direct interaction between the loops.
As for the other detectors .. theoretically possible, but we're talking about such small amounts that you'd need to literally have the nose of your sub hanging a few meters behind the screw of the lead sub to detect such trace amounts.
Sounds dangerous
So... you can "smell" the sub.
When o read that all I could
Think of is them running silent and some guy ripping a government egg fart
Well, we gotta work on that
Some of this sounds familiar. Probably worked for a few weeks until it broke thanks to the poor training of sailors.
And they could look out the port holes and see....
L so not only were they smart they're still smarter than us
Remenber reading syi fi books about this kind of tech back in the sixties.
If this is true then it is absolutely remarkable technology and thought processes to develop such devices to measure the changes in the sea water! It reminds me of the shark being capable of detecting blood in the water. Let's hope the United States can develop something similar
It is 🐂💩
In other news, a Swedish Gotland class ...........
The Soviets claimed .....
WE COULD SOLVE THIS PROBLEM IF WE DESIGNED A SUBMARINE THAT HAD A REDUNDANT POWER SYSTEM.. half nuclear half diesel / battery 🔋 🔋 🔋
if you run the sub on nuke.. switch the diesel or fully electric.. sequester all coolants within the ship letting the trail run cold.. then diving deep before turning on the nukes and opening the coolant system any sub following would see a dashed line vs a solid line and it would be easier to hide if the battery system could be on for a full day allowing the gaps between on and off to be over 100 miles
We called em sea dogs.
the Americans and other Western countries have used other similar methods for long. It is not a secret
The Lunar Lander's greatest secret and the sole reason America has not landed humans on the Moon since...
3M Scotch Tape.
Without 3M's Scotch Tape haphazardly affixing the faux gold foil, inconsistently all over the Lunar Lander, such space travel would bot have been possible.
But alas, 3M cut back on the production and barely enough to wrap presents remained.
Hope USN was able to over come this issue.
American arrogannce says this never happened.
Show me proof and I will believe you.
Nothing a Russian says is true
So basically, why bother cleaning the oceans when they’re constantly polluting it anyhow !
Hey captain ah like we have a week to go before going home and I well we were thinking could we have a little fun messing with the Russian sub
Captain, what do you mean ?
Could we lead them around and make them think they're actually following us without us knowing that they are there
Captain, sounds like fun to melets do it😅😅😅😅😅😅😅
But communism never worked😂
I'm calling bullshit on this They did have good sonar and the us knew it what they had were nosier subs ours are much quieter.And no you can't detect the reactor like that if that were true the crew would be dead.
Us boomer ?
Boomer ? What's that ?
this is claimed, not proved
And America did the same many times also
How about the John Walker spy gang? A traitor.
The Soviet Union still fell.
Why would the Americans underestimate the people who entered into orbit first?
Because the Americans were right. The Russians lost the submarine war as they lost many wars, including the Cold War. And they will lose the current war in Ukraine too.
@@substecu simpin’ real hard!
@@MeenPo786 "It" is putin fakkdoll
Arrogance
@@MeenPo786stating the facts, tho. Where is the Soviet Union?
Brilliant. 😊 Ingenious
Kopeck wumao fantasy
Ho hum 🤣
F Russian propaganda and everyone posting it
I do believe the United States has fallen behind in the defense industry mainly because in the United States especially in the defense industry prices of defense technology are so inflated due to the profit-driven economy and the fact that these companies are only trying to please their shareholders by maximising profits not through cutting cost by inflating cost in getting the American people to pay for it while our politicians benefit monetarily for approving these contracts and these budget line items we in the United States simply cannot match the production probably of even Iran or North Korea let alone Russia and China yes their defense budgets are way smaller than ours but they don't need to be as big as our budget in the United States because most of their manufacturers are government-controlled so they are only paying workers and material cost there is no need for huge profits because they don't have shareholders I think the United States might be in trouble and we no longer lead the world in technology we have lost the edge because of corporate greed and political greed
Sounds like complete BS To me
When considering the enviromental impact those nuclear reactors would have on sea mammals, it puts into perspective how dangerous those subs are nlt only to humans but the health of sea mammals
Russian propaganda.
they teach us not to worry about Russian technology 😅
Bull crap never happened
Hahaha hahaha hahaha!!
Seawater cooling the reactor would defeat the purpose of the power plant
No,it doesn't
How does running seawater through the reactor produce steam for the turbines?
@@ericrand6276 Are you asking how does water turn into steam or am I missing something?
@@divebombexpert2619 I know how water turns to steam. You do not run seawater through the reactor to make steam.
Pure water runs through the reactor removing the heat. This water then runs in its loop through the steam generators to boil the water in the secondary loop to make steam. This steam in the secondary loop is used to turn the propulsion turbines and turbine generators to make electricity. This steam is then condensed and sent back to the steam generators.
Seawater is used to cool the steam back to water in the condensers.
Seawater does not touch the reactor.
Never underestimate the other side.
BS
The amount of negative comments about the Soviet advanced technology is staggering. Are jealousy and envy the cause, perhaps?
The USA and UK have always thought they had better technology but we are learning g more and more it’s not all the propaganda build up and news reports make it out to be.
Russia and China are both very capable countries in developing counter measures which we are seeing in Ukraine where new western equipment has the upper hand for only about 3 months.
My grandpa was chief of nuclear design for the Americans for building submarines.
So proud.
Carbon tax for us, what about these pollutants?
I knao that propaganda and movies create stereotypical picture of Russia army, but in reality they are on the same level or even more advanced. When usa abndond agreements agaist development od interceptors of ballistic mislles, the Rusian develooed then hypersonic mislles that outperform anything west has at the moment. Look what happens to the best aa systems like patriot or iris t in Ukraine, when detected they are one shot by kiznal or anything else
Always gives me a good laugh when I hear yanks claiming to be unbeatable. I would bet on the Russians to have more than a few surprises up their sleeves.
Trouble is, somebody over there will have sold it, or vital bits of it.
Yeah how would you know……and how many boats are in the RN?
Lol. And the S400 was claimed to be the best too. But Ukraine just took out a couple using ATACMS missiles while the S400 fired 6 missiles at them and missed.
Hahahahahaha! Always a good laugh when people like you are proven wrong with actual real world examples.
The U.S. has OCEAN going NAVIES ,were as the Russian navy can’t get out of the Black Sea their only warm water port . You are supposed to control the waters around your port.
Rooting for Russia 🇷🇺