@@danal81 "curious how you thanked a woman" Really, Danny, you need to stop fantasizing about the extent of your clinical psychoanalytical skills, and your own willingness to waste time indulging in protracted troll shoots. Get a life indeed, said the kettle to the pot.
I think all of you with opinions on these pieces being made for children should acknowledge that children also have deep emotions and can feel music and appreciate and understand music with depth.
1) Andantino 0:04 2) No walk today 1:53 3) Ljado is sick 3:10 4) Birthday 5:24 5) Study 6:44 6) Musical portrait 8:08 7) Invention 9:55 8) Fuga 12:48 9) March of the cavaliers 14:15 10) Tunes in folk style 15:17
When I first heard these pieces by accident I did not know that they were childrens pieces, and I really enjoyed the amazing harmonies and melodies, still think its much more than childrens etudes
So beautifully played here! I make a proposal: these pieces are for those adults who take lessons because they have a piano no longer played by anyone. This music may have more to say to them than to their children. The music is sophisticated and begs for someone who has experienced childhood--not for a 12 year old still experiencing childhood.
I like your analysis and I partially agree, but I think it also speaks to the emotions that children cannot express just due to lack of experience or education. Or, perhaps the emotions of a child in conflict (whether internal or external). Regardless, these pieces are beautiful and sophisticated and reflect childhood in a different light than what I've seen in other pieces.
I think you two folks would be surprised what child musicians are capable of! I’ve been teaching these sophisticated and gorgeous pieces to not particularly gifted students throughout my decades long career. The music brings out the best in them and some play it very beautifully indeed. Don’t underestimate the depths if young musicians.
@@sarahsteinhardt1697 yes!! You're so right! I neglected to say that I disagreed with Steve's proposal LOL. I meant in my (admittedly wordy) response that these pieces would speak to a child just as well as they may speak to an adult. I played Ivan Sings when I was younger and it's still a favorite for me 💗
Joaquin Delgado Khachaturian es definitivamente un compositor bastante tocado y escuchado en el ámbito académico por quienes estamos dentro de la música impresionista. Más que redescubrir, habría que compartirlo al mundo fomentando concertar sus piezas
La primera melodía (Ivan sings) fue un ejercicio para pedal que mi maestro de piano me puso de niño. Hoy en día casi solo toco Bach, Scarlatti, Haydn, etc... pero vine para escuchar las demás melodías del libro de Ivan a ver si hay alguna que también me guste para practicarla, para mi si será redescubrirlo... 🤓
This may be intended for a child’s abilities (I can sight read it), but the music can only be understood by those who have lived long enough to endure some tough shit.
@@Angelo-z2i I agree. The music is wonderful, but the wistful nature of the pieces just go over their heads sometimes. I teach at a nonprofit that serves a lot of underprivileged kids though, and I have found that pieces like the andantino of this collection and the Bach 999 C minor prelude, although gloomy for some, are very therapeutic for many kids.
Agree, I feel a bit nostalgia and melancholic when listening to this, especially the first 3 pieces. It's like a wandering into the deep old past memories...
Eek! Yikes! Help! I learned the first song -Ivan Sings-50 years ago. Played it so often my younger brother who didn’t read music learned it by ear. Now I hear at 1:29 DIFFERENT NOTES for a bar. Please someone tell me that there are 2 versions, or explain why there’s a difference!
Khachaturian - one and only,my the dearest composer❤
if we ignore the fact that these are children's pieces, we realise that the pieces are filled with amazing harmonies, melodies and writing
Why would we ignore that?
i really like the first one, its very romantic-melancholic-elegant
Or Maybe it is pieces about children.
@@kristinamusik7414 Oi. On second look, It is both, apparently , as one realizes, reading the song titles. You are correct Kristina! Thanks.
@@danal81 "curious how you thanked a woman" Really, Danny, you need to stop fantasizing about the extent of your
clinical psychoanalytical skills, and your own willingness to waste time indulging in protracted troll shoots. Get a life indeed, said the kettle to the pot.
I think all of you with opinions on these pieces being made for children should acknowledge that children also have deep emotions and can feel music and appreciate and understand music with depth.
Well said!
1) Andantino 0:04
2) No walk today 1:53
3) Ljado is sick 3:10
4) Birthday 5:24
5) Study 6:44
6) Musical portrait 8:08
7) Invention 9:55
8) Fuga 12:48
9) March of the cavaliers 14:15
10) Tunes in folk style 15:17
thank you
Thanks Vincenzo
Thank you very much.
Where was I as a child?
Digging holes in the back yard.
So happy I found music, albeit much later in life.
When I first heard these pieces by accident I did not know that they were childrens pieces, and I really enjoyed the amazing harmonies and melodies, still think its much more than childrens etudes
So beautifully played here! I make a proposal: these pieces are for those adults who take lessons because they have a piano no longer played by anyone. This music may have more to say to them than to their children. The music is sophisticated and begs for someone who has experienced childhood--not for a 12 year old still experiencing childhood.
I like your analysis and I partially agree, but I think it also speaks to the emotions that children cannot express just due to lack of experience or education. Or, perhaps the emotions of a child in conflict (whether internal or external). Regardless, these pieces are beautiful and sophisticated and reflect childhood in a different light than what I've seen in other pieces.
I think you two folks would be surprised what child musicians are capable of! I’ve been teaching these sophisticated and gorgeous pieces to not particularly gifted students throughout my decades long career. The music brings out the best in them and some play it very beautifully indeed. Don’t underestimate the depths if young musicians.
@@sarahsteinhardt1697 yes!! You're so right! I neglected to say that I disagreed with Steve's proposal LOL. I meant in my (admittedly wordy) response that these pieces would speak to a child just as well as they may speak to an adult. I played Ivan Sings when I was younger and it's still a favorite for me 💗
Thank you for posting this. A few years I searched and searched for this full collection, but was unfruitful. Happy to find you!
Thank you for the video!! Such beautiful little pieces, I really love the first one, so much sorrow.
Una pasada. Realmente un compositor por redescubrir...
Joaquin Delgado Khachaturian es definitivamente un compositor bastante tocado y escuchado en el ámbito académico por quienes estamos dentro de la música impresionista. Más que redescubrir, habría que compartirlo al mundo fomentando concertar sus piezas
La primera melodía (Ivan sings) fue un ejercicio para pedal que mi maestro de piano me puso de niño. Hoy en día casi solo toco Bach, Scarlatti, Haydn, etc... pero vine para escuchar las demás melodías del libro de Ivan a ver si hay alguna que también me guste para practicarla, para mi si será redescubrirlo... 🤓
I have played Andantino when I was 7 years old ❤
My favourite Andantino, which I played at music school.
Gonna’ look these up. Thanks! Good short compositions.
Beautiful interpretation of this book, I using as a guide.
Some pieces are played too fast imo
It's so precious and deep
Khachaturian, master of the chromatic.
That little Etude sounds so Kabalevsky like to me, hot dang it's a cute little thing
어린이를 위한 작품이 아닌 슈만의 처럼 어른을 위한 동심의 작품입니다.
5:37 - 18 bar
a motif very similar to 2 pieces by Bortkiewicz (op. 64 no. 2 - Mazurka | op. 40 no. 3 - Prelude)
At 5:24 (Birthday) does anyone else hear Poulenc?
agreed
Poulenc, Prokoviev, Ravel, Prokoviev! Khatchaturian was amongst that special group of composers who have a very special affinity with the piano.
the first one is really beautiful, sounds brazilian . The second is for quarantine
What do you mean by "sounds Brazilian"?
@@dacoconutnut9503 i mean, it caused an association with my impression of some brazilian music in my head 2 hrs ago
@@emanuel_soundtrack oh ok
@@dacoconutnut9503 if i find a song i post hear, check Camargo Guarnieri dont know
they were influenced by the europeans, but the inverse may be also true in 20 century
No. 2 sounds like a wander into the childhood past.
It's hard to describe the feeling.
Oh this brings back memories.
5:24 i'll greet my friend/s on their birthday with this piece and not the traditional birthday song
That's a good idea! I think I'll do that too. Thank you for good suggestion!
Why did they change the name from "Adventures of Ivan" I loved that name. I played this when I was a kid.
A great composer ! Magnifique
Indeed.
One of the Genius Armenian composer❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Très belle musique... Je la connais depuis longtemps, il faut que je retrouve la partition...
6:44
This may be intended for a child’s abilities (I can sight read it), but the music can only be understood by those who have lived long enough to endure some tough shit.
I don't want to downgrade this music, but I feel some of these pieces are a bit gloomy and dark. I'd certainly pick "happier" music to teach.
@@Angelo-z2i I agree. The music is wonderful, but the wistful nature of the pieces just go over their heads sometimes. I teach at a nonprofit that serves a lot of underprivileged kids though, and I have found that pieces like the andantino of this collection and the Bach 999 C minor prelude, although gloomy for some, are very therapeutic for many kids.
Liking your nickname
Agree, I feel a bit nostalgia and melancholic when listening to this, especially the first 3 pieces. It's like a wandering into the deep old past memories...
Awesome! Do volume II !
Fantástic pie e beatiful song
Old but gold.
Andantino became adagio here.
No. 6 is definitely spot-on Khachaturian.
No. 2 is basically SNES-era RPG dungeon music.
Khachaturian: 1:53 No Walk Today
Me, quarantined: that's pretty relatable
Bravo!!!!!!!! 🎼🎹💐👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
amazing music!
Also known as "variations on Chopin's prelude in E minor"
❤❤❤❤❤❤
Technique for children.. But feels for the adults 😢
7 is named "Little horse" insteadd of "invention" and 9 "In folk dance style" instead of "Fuge" in my book
Donde puedo conseguir el libro.,,??
Amazon
I can't find the pdf of the Fugue :( where can i find it?
Why do you write that previously it was known as *The Adventures Of Ivan*?
Maybe 'also known as" is better.
@@GNGianopoulos who's Ivan
Eek! Yikes! Help! I learned the first song -Ivan Sings-50 years ago. Played it so often my younger brother who didn’t read music learned it by ear. Now I hear at 1:29 DIFFERENT NOTES for a bar. Please someone tell me that there are 2 versions, or explain why there’s a difference!
There is no difference? When a piece is written there’s no changes to it
Is it just me or the last piece sounds a bit Spanish ?
8:08
Remember me children's stuck of Alberto Mozzati
6:45 numero 5
6:58 DROP DA BASS!
i think you wrote the wrong order, 7 is invention not like what you put tho
Mais mais mais….. c’est Charlotte Forever
You’ll find that Gainsburg copied a great majority of his tunes from the classics
This is for kids ? :,v
russian kids
children
Não se parece nem um pouco peças para crianças...
5:24
8:08
6:45