Why does the BJP want partition of Bengal? | MAMATA BANERJEE | BENGAL POLITICS | TMC

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 17 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 53

  • @mdyesup5890
    @mdyesup5890 2 місяці тому +4

    আমার মাটি আমার মা বাংলা ভাগ হবে না বাংলা ভাগ চাইবে যারা বাংলা ছাড়া হবে তারা জয় বাংলা 🐯🐯

  • @shahalam5386
    @shahalam5386 2 місяці тому +9

    It not a new strategies BJP and RSS have been doing.... Muslim -hundu, maitai-kukies, higher and lower castes and same in Bengal

  • @jankinandanjha3548
    @jankinandanjha3548 2 місяці тому +6

    ताकि पूरे बंगाल को जेहादीकरण से बचा सके। याद रहे बंगाल बंटवारे से ही देश का विभाजन शुरू हुआ था।

    • @AniketBanerjee-xf2ch
      @AniketBanerjee-xf2ch 2 місяці тому

      Beta jha , apne Bihar aur apne aukaat dono me simit rhe ... Tere baudhik sakshamta iss starr me nhi h ki tu samajh paye ki regime chahe jis party ka bhi ho , Bengal k log bengalees bn kr jeete h , bengali Gobarbhakt ya bengalee jihadi bnke nhi 😂😂

    • @crockeryunboxing9760
      @crockeryunboxing9760 2 місяці тому

      Niyog ki paidais

    • @crockeryunboxing9760
      @crockeryunboxing9760 2 місяці тому

      Gobor kha kha ke dimag me gobor bhar gaya

    • @sayandipmajumder1621
      @sayandipmajumder1621 2 місяці тому

      Lord Curzon Broker

  • @cenexcise
    @cenexcise 2 місяці тому +5

    Nirenji, North Bengal ka matlan sirf Darjeeling nahi hai. Siliguri ke sath sath baki 5 districts mein Bengali majority mein hai. Congress aur TMC mein vote bantwara ke karan BJP ko 4 seat uttar bangal mein mila.

  • @debiboot2456
    @debiboot2456 2 місяці тому +6

    In North Bengal, there are demand of Gorkhaland consists of hill areas of Bengal, demand for Kamta pur, demand for Kotch and demand for North Bengal as a whole. In every case BJP performing hide and seek game.All of these statement on the division of Bengal is well planned.

  • @aminkhankhan5408
    @aminkhankhan5408 2 місяці тому +1

    Good news sir salut sir all

  • @rekhakumar1441
    @rekhakumar1441 2 місяці тому +6

    Baat nikli hai toh abh door tak jayengi. Reminds me of Sawarkar.

    • @tekuvaswani4859
      @tekuvaswani4859 2 місяці тому

      आपके संवाद से ऐसा प्रतीत होता है कि प्रत्येक ज़िले को अलग राज्य बना दिया जाए ।

  • @zainpasha943
    @zainpasha943 2 місяці тому +3

    Modiji ki deal hogai hai xi jinping se
    Modi ne pehle hi kaha hai
    Na koi gussa tha na koi ghusse ga

  • @lovelyeyes7753
    @lovelyeyes7753 2 місяці тому

    जिस भुभाग बारे में आपलोग चर्चा कर रहे हैं उसभुभाक के भुमि पुत्रऔँ को भी panel मे बुलान चाहिए।

  • @ravindrakumarchaudhary5036
    @ravindrakumarchaudhary5036 2 місяці тому

    शतीश सर् घुसपैठियों की संख्या बढ़ा है तो केंद्र सरकार असफल रहे हैं क्योंकि अंतर्राष्ट्रीय सीमा केंद्र के अधीन है और 10 वर्षों से भाजपा का शासन चल रहा है।

  • @manaranjanbiswas212
    @manaranjanbiswas212 2 місяці тому +1

    If you had included a bengali panelist it would have been better.

  • @Ashoksingh-l1k
    @Ashoksingh-l1k 2 місяці тому +1

    mukeshji, Gorkhaland is Tribal Land in North Bengal
    Similarly why not Bhojpuri Pradesh, Maithali Pradesh, Magadh Pradesh, Bhillkhand, Awadh Pradesh, Braj Pradesh, Bundelkhand, Gondwanaland, Brahad Jharkhand states on identity ? 12:53

  • @gyanendrakumarmohanty3642
    @gyanendrakumarmohanty3642 2 місяці тому +3

    SATIS KO KUCH MALUM NEHI , PAHELE WO SAB KUCH NAKAR DEGA , BADME PALTEGA, USKA PAS RAMDEV KA ANAS HAI. US KA AKALAN INDIA GATHBANDHAN KA PURANA DEBEAT KA OPINION DEKHLO.

  • @krishnapradhan8067
    @krishnapradhan8067 2 місяці тому

    U t ❤

  • @ABO-Destiny
    @ABO-Destiny 2 місяці тому

    First thing:
    It is true some people of North Bengal are not ethnically Bengali and forcing them to speak Bengali will be causing problems for them. But I do not think that is true. Nepali is already part of the recognised state languages so I dont think it is true that somebody is having to give exams in Bengali against their wishes.
    2. On the economic development front I dont think utbistrue either. Historically North Bengal had been behind south bengal and the reason for that is Calcutta and the historical importance of sea ports which are located in south bengal. However, the idea that North Bengal was being deliberately neglected is utterly false. North Bengal had always been part of Bengal and very integral part of it. Remember the Naxal movement had started from North Bengal and had spread in the whole region.
    3. However there are ethnic dissimilarities between South west bengal and north west bengal like there was ethnic dissimilarities between East Bengal (present day Bangladesh) and West Bengal. Infact it is very much true that North Bengal ethnically and culturally is very similar to Assam and East Bengal than South Bengal or Southern Bangladesh. There are definite genetic differences too with Coastal South Bangladesh and Coastal South Bengal are more like Eastern Odissa and have majorly dravidian population while Central Bengal and Bangladesh i.e. riverine Bengal having mostly Indo-European a.k.a Aryanic people and culture while North Bengal (north of Murshidabad) and North Bangladesh having strong Mongolian genetic people and culture. This division and resulting friction is visible in Bangladesh too.
    And all these hiatoric differences had played strong part in shapibg culture as well as religion of the people.
    ***
    However, the mistake BJP is making is it does nit have the mandate , neither the support of the people in this move except ethnic minority regions like Darjeeling and Coochbehar.
    Moreover BJP had always been politically motivated in diviiding people. It had already divided Kashmir, it has divided Manipur ,it has divided Tripura, it has created problems in North East India, in Punjab, in UP, in Bihar.
    Bengalis I am sure will never accept any division which is initiated by Non Bengalis. We do not trust BJP and probably will nit trust in future too. If Bengali people votes for the division then it is ok but by initiating this division through non bengali entity will not just backfire but will put whole region undeer serious turmoil.
    BJP is a baniya party abd they do not understand anything about history, neither cares for history, bunch of illeterate idiots who just crrates division in same way as village mukhias fight wuth each other or kings used to fight with each other earlier.
    These are bunxh of irresponsible idiots. And i had always been saying they are the sane as older indians who had lost power to Mughals due to their infighting , then got it back after British had left India.
    I think this is a natural culmination of politics, i think indians will start fighting with each other soon, that had already started in many places but not in Bengal though, not yet. And in future india will again have rule of someone from outside. Which will be logical movement of history.

  • @nareshkumargupta7261
    @nareshkumargupta7261 2 місяці тому

    क्या बटवांरा करने से ही किसी प्रान्त की प्रगति होती है। यदि सरकार चाहे तो प्रगति कुछ प्रयासों से हो सकती है।ये अंग्रेज़ो की नीति है जो भाजपा अपना रही है यदि जनता का दिल जितना है तो उनकी उन्नति का रास्ता प्रशस्त करना होगा।

  • @sarojgarg3082
    @sarojgarg3082 2 місяці тому

    Muslim majority areas of Bengal; bihar and Karnataka should be declared union territories like ladakh

  • @Messi06
    @Messi06 2 місяці тому

    One speaker is saying in govt exam bengali is mandatory but it is factually wrong. We can write the same test in Nepali too.

  • @tamalbhattacharjee8384
    @tamalbhattacharjee8384 2 місяці тому +1

    This Nagore guy should know that the majority population of North Bengal is Bengalis, not the other linguistic groups; nonetheless, people in the hills of Darjeeling are mostly Nepalese, Lepcha and all. Also, Nagore doesn't like to be called himself Bengali for which he ended up tagging himself half-Bengali. Given wll, he's on the side of the secessionists. 😂

  • @ravindrakumarchaudhary5036
    @ravindrakumarchaudhary5036 2 місяці тому

    BJP कुछ कर ले पर BJP का अवनति काल चल रहा है सब जगह से खिसकते जायेगा।

  • @amritaparui3114
    @amritaparui3114 2 місяці тому

    We read in our college life a lot of work of different writer that says *"Janasangh and the Brahmins were behind the division of Bengal"* . Today BJP has confirmed it to all except the blinds.

  • @ravindrakumarchaudhary5036
    @ravindrakumarchaudhary5036 2 місяці тому

    क्या स्टेट गवर्मेंट के सहमति बिना अलग स्टेट बना सकता है।

  • @vinayvashisht9270
    @vinayvashisht9270 2 місяці тому

    BJP is in reality a Tukde Tukde Party n cherish a thinking to divide the country in parts.

  • @udaynathsinha4883
    @udaynathsinha4883 2 місяці тому +1

    35% muslim TMC ke saath Jaye to thik hai hindu nahi jaye BJP me ye narrative hai aise patrakaro ka bjp ka itna virodh kyon karte ho tum log kimansha Bharat me gajwa a hind ka hai tab tum khush hoge

  • @BONDKING124
    @BONDKING124 2 місяці тому

    Anyone from N.Being will love new home ..its simple human logic😂😂😂...

  • @sirrobertdowneysenior8080
    @sirrobertdowneysenior8080 2 місяці тому

    Mukesh ji ye Satish Singh ko burka pehnakar debates me laiye so unpleasant to see his frustration and desperation when he disagrees with someone, yehi janak hain godi media channels ke.

  • @bikramsen9952
    @bikramsen9952 2 місяці тому

    Seperate the poorest districts of Orissa too. Why not ?
    If there is a development aim, then many many districts in many states will get involved.
    No. Its all about votes.
    DIVIDE AND RULE. Like what the British did

  • @KuldeepSingh-g7w
    @KuldeepSingh-g7w 2 місяці тому

    Niyat kisi n kisi. Niyati. Ko. Bhi. Jnm. Deti. Rehi. H. Aur. Deti. Rehegi any. Episode that have. Happened. Or. To. Be. Happened. Again this is popular. Accepted. Saying. Here we. Born. Or not. Born in. Any family. Or. Society no. Body here. Always. Has. Been. Infallible but some person. Who enjoy. Any. Legacy of. High. Profile and. Then. By. Getting a. Few remarkable. Performance. Happened. The. Victim. Of their. Arrogancy up. To. The. Mark. Of. Think. Their own. Self as they are served. With. Too. Much exaggeration. That. Such after. Calling or. Posing as. Dignitory. First. They. Do. Not like. Any. Comment of.critcism but. Even. After. They like. And. Let. Other. To. Critisiz much or less very rarely they. Take. A. Serious. Note of. It as. First. After. Victory. Of. 1971. At. Last. About. One. Lakh. Pow our. Force succeeded but. The. Same. Dictum. Lade. Foj. Nam. Sardar so atal. Ji exaggerated or. Praise. As. That. May. Knowingly. Or. Unknowingly. A. Diplomatic. Move as. To. Get. Any. Body. Climb. On the. Little. Plant. But. Called. Chane. Ke. Pad. Tree. Pr. Chadana. Instantly atal. Ji. Called. It. Durga. Avtar him. Self he. Use. To. Call. As. In. Parliament. Ye. Ox. Bail. Bikau. Nahi. As. Why the. Whole of. Life any. Person. Earn like. Ox either. For. His. Family. Or organisation. But. Get. Very. Little. For. Only. As. Food. Or. Chara. Husk only. Of. Survival. Latar she. Start. To. Rule. Totally. Authoritarian. Way as. After. Two. Third. Majority. Leader. Have. And. Have been. Behaving. So but In. West. Particular. Britain. From. Where. We. Have. Owned. Such. All. System their. Voters. Or. It. May be. Right. To. Say. Citizen here. We. All. Are if. Really. Impartialy our. Most of. Leader. Except. Few one. We. Still. Are. About. Voters a. Citizen. Behave more. Reapolonsably. Then. Thei. Any. Leadership as. In. Western v democratic. Countries demonstration. Start. Over israil and. Filistin. Bombardment by. Israil where as. We almost like to silent what. Happen. In. Any. Other. District. Of our. State. And. Even what. Going. In. Neighbour limg. State after. Ii. World. War Churchill was. Replaced. By. Labour party. Pm. Ately under whom. Under. We. Get. Freedom. While. As. Churchill. Severely. Oppose. That. Bill. Of. Freedom. To. India of here. Such gain. As. Chuchil. Got he. May. Easily be. Declare even. By. Public. As. King. His.majesty. for. Whole. Life Kennedy usa. After. Remark. His. Fellow. All. American people. As. Always. Why. Do. Yu. Think what. America. Can. Do. For. Yu. Any. Time. Or. Ever. Yu. Think. What. Can. Yu. Do. For. America but even. A little. Postive. Point. Which. Is. Favourable. Not. One. Self. But. To. As. Nation. Too. The. Family. Planning that. Was. Launched. In. Emergency a. Good one. Policy. So. Wise. Our. Constitution. Is. As. Good. But. It's. All. Implementation only. 5. Percent. May be. Positive. But. Rest. One 95 percent. Totally contra once. A. Known. Fellow elder. Than. Me. Having. Good. Profile. As. Dy. Director. Legal. Advisor happen. To. Revealed. His hidden. Wish. To. Get. A. Ticket of. Any. Party. And. Win. Election suppose. Congress. Party. Bhaeyo dekho. Family. Planing. Policy. Was. Quite ok. But it's. Implementation. Was. Or may. Be. Wrong due. To. Some. Beaurocarate ei. Police. Or. DC then. Suppose yu get. Ticket of. So called. Bjp. Then same point. Bhaeeyo. Aap. Ko. Yad. Rakhna. Chahiye. Hume. Budah. Old. Dekhna. Jawan. Married. Even. Unmarried. Pakad ke. Bakre. Ki. Tra. Kat diye ek. Sike. Ke. Do. Pahlu. Jese din. Aur. Rat kabhi apne. Bhi. Kr. Jate. H. Dushman. Se. Bhi jayada. Gahat v. Kabhi. Dushman. Bhi. Kr. Jate. H. Apno. Jesi. Bat. As. Britisher. Exploited. Kuch but. Give. Some. Better. Too of. They. Were. Not. Here. So. Many. States. Like. Countries. Would. Have. Been. Here. Itne. Bade. Mulk. Ko. Ek. Mala. M Piro. Gaye and. Even. By offer. Of. Cabinet. Mission plan undevided India. As. They. Were. Having. Now with. Us but. By. Decline of. Cabinet. Mission plan. What. Happen the riots. Dange. Of. 1947. And. There. After. Same. Phenomena. We. Find. In. Delhi. Sheikh. Genocide kushal. Updesh. Bahutre. Achrahi na. Nr ghanere ek. Sadhe. Sab. Sadhe sab. Sadhe. Sab. Jaye. V Bora. M. Jo dekhan. Chala. Jhanka. Jab. Mn. Apna. Mujh se. Bura. Mila. N. Koi. Jai hind. Ram 7. 27. July. 24. Mnn. Which. Discovery we. Or. Yu. Finding. Here. Better. Discovery of. India. Or. God. As. Modi. Ji. Thali bzao. Chimta. Bjao. Corona. Ko. Bhi. Bhagao sath. M. Occupied area. Se. 1962. Vale. Chima. Ko. Bhagao. Ram. Ram. Sat. H. Da. Sat Nam. Gat. Fir. Bhi. Hume. Kutte ki. Doom. Bne. Rehne. Ki. Lat h

  • @tapabratadam8573
    @tapabratadam8573 2 місяці тому

    These panelists know nothing. It shows how important to have right panelists to discuss a matter. What they says is not only superficial but not true. In north bengal bengali is primarily language, Bangali are primary ethnicity.
    We the people of north bengal want more inclusiveness in development thats it.

  • @KamrulHabib-l5u
    @KamrulHabib-l5u 2 місяці тому

    North bengal is dependent sumthing south bengal, (BJP North bengal ko torna chata hai) wrong ideas for BJP

  • @udaynathsinha4883
    @udaynathsinha4883 2 місяці тому

    Aag lagi hai inlogo ko haar Hui ya Jeet sarkar me hai fir bhi agenda chalate ho ghatiya manshikta se debate mat karo

  • @mustafizurrahman8521
    @mustafizurrahman8521 2 місяці тому +1

    Dube ji jhuth bol rahe hain,

  • @shahnawazalam733
    @shahnawazalam733 2 місяці тому

    Satishji ke baat p dhyan dene ki hai
    Assam model anti bangladeshi

  • @tamal-7
    @tamal-7 2 місяці тому

    West bengal is new pakistan😊.. Me from wb😮

  • @lalusharma7133
    @lalusharma7133 2 місяці тому

    Hindutva have all elements init ti divide country.

  • @kiritnaik3099
    @kiritnaik3099 2 місяці тому

    Modi jii USA 🇺🇸 copy 📓 Karne pe ho US Ka 50 states he India 🇮🇳 ka Banana chahte 50 states
    US me 100$ Dollars Ke upper Koy currency 💴 nahi he toh India me bhi 500 note bandh karna chate 400 site nahi aya vohi karan bache 500 band hone me

  • @ConfusedCroquet-ih9yu
    @ConfusedCroquet-ih9yu 2 місяці тому

    𝑨𝒅𝒊𝒃𝒂𝒔𝒊 𝒔𝒊𝒘𝒌𝒂𝒓 𝒏𝒂𝒉𝒊 𝒌𝒂𝒓𝒂𝒈𝒂