Muhammad Prophecy Debunked: Skyscrapers
Вставка
- Опубліковано 27 вер 2024
- One of the most popular purported miracles or accurate prophecies of Muhammad is the narrative that certain people will build tall buildings toward the end of time. Here is a thorough refutation of this undeniable miracle.
@HassanRadwan133's article about the Prophecy: / tall-buildings-prophecy
Support AP: apostateprophe...
Patreon: / apostateprophet
Paypal: www.paypal.me/...
AP Merchandise: merch.apostate...
Equipment Wishlist: www.amazon.com...
Twitter: / apostateprophet
Facebook: / theapostateprophet
BC: tinyurl.com/y8... (auto-upload)
Some people will do something in the future. Prove me wrong.
Only if they are barefoot.
But what if they start to, but change their mind halfway through and stop? Checkmate, atheists.
u will rise up to the moon on a flying donkey 🦄 🦄🤲
What if i "delete" them first?
OUCH !!!! yes.
I have many times encountered this stupid claim while debating with Muslims.
Well how about u debate me you clown 🤡
Stupid for ppl who forcefully try to disprove something that's established and clearly true, saying the barefoot, Bedouin shepherd's does not imply that they should be so while making these bldngs, it implies that their nation or their group will one day compete in making tall buildings and it's happening, the arabs (who were once barefoot, bedouins, shepherds) are now in competition with the the world in making tall buildings and many of the tallest are in arab lands, any man with common sense would accept this except the ones which forcefully try to resist it, they r the ones who are truly stupid and heavily engrossed in deceiving themselves.
Sad
It's actually unbelievable that anyone in 2022 still uses this argument. Really shows the intellectual peasantry of these apologists who actually think this is an impressive presiction
@@helix7203 Who?
Reminds me of other “prophecies” where people talk about “war and famine” as if that hasn’t been a problem since the start of civilization!
The Bible speaks that those will increase in the end times, and indeed they do seem to be increasing.
@@carpediem7654 seize the day so what more ppl less land.
This is in the Bible -and I’m a Christian but many Christians interpret this and quote it wrong. Matthew 24:3-8 And as he sat on the mount of Olives, the disciples came unto him privately, saying, Tell us, when shall these things be? and what shall be the sign of thy [a]coming, and of [b]the end of the world? 4 And Jesus answered and said unto them, Take heed that no man lead you astray. 5 For many shall come in my name, saying, I am the Christ; and shall lead many astray. 6 And ye shall hear of wars and rumors of wars; see that ye be not troubled: for these things must needs come to pass; but the end is not yet. Jesus is saying here that evil and tragedy must occur on the earth-BUT that doesn’t mean it’s the end yet. People typically say “rumors of war and famine” are a sign that it’s the end but Jesus is actually saying the opposite. He’s saying they have to happen (and they’ve happened since the beginning of time) but that doesn’t mean it’s the end. It just means you have to remain hopeful and stick till the end and remain faithful until He comes. (Hope that helped😊)
@@jenellemelendez2521 these things have always happened thats nothing
A more interesting prophecy would be saying of a time in the future where war, famine and poverty are non-existent.
Best part, self fulfilling prophecy mechanics will ensure that events of the prophecy will come true, and all for the better.
"There'll be more people going to space in the future"
This is my prophecy and I'm the true prophet
🤣🤣🤣
😂
Peace be upon you!
In christianity God was a baby for 9 months then he declared that he is God yea people believe in silly things
Everyone knows that since the 1960s, you too late for that.
The tower of Babel was a tall building built long before Mohammed.
Tower of babel never existed hou know
So were the Mayan temples, pagodas in SE, pyramids, ancient hindu temples. Poor Mo just a frog in a well.
@a no you clown, tower of babel was just the ziggurat of babel
@@ΘάνατοςΧορτοφάγος Actually it was, archeologist found it, l saw it in a doco. However it wasnt was that tall, not reaching the sky.
lietreally no one in islam or outside it has ever used the tower of babel story, most muslim books dont even know about it
i keep getting ads on helping mosque and shit quite annoying
They are fake ads. These abduls are so desperate
it means google/youtube are greedy, corrupt, or both
@@SoldierOfChristAlmighty where is Tommy Robinson nowadays?
@@bluerock9238 probably still outing muslim paedophiles at the court 🤷♂️
My prophecy: " There will be Sunday after this Saturday "
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
OMG are you a phophet of Allah
- Avarage Arabian guy
@Click_2See_my-plaaylisst the last hour will be when the world ends ,...there you go
@Click_2See_my-plaaylisstPeople in the future will eat
the prophecy is about how the bedouin (nomads) will compete in building tall buildings...Nowadays Saudi Arabia and UAE is doing this and you can't deny that both countries are building insanely mega cities and projects...who would imagine 100 years ago that these people will achieve such a great development in urban planning and architecture. the reason for this was the oil boom...SORRY YOUR DEBUNKIG IS FRAGILE AND WEAK AND HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH THE PROPHECY IT SELF.
Can u pls show where in the hadiths it explicitly says bedouin or nomads🤔 u don't need to add words to ur prophet's ridiculous statement to make it prophetic
Whiles christians are claiming their Bible prophesied the wrld powers, the destruction of the temple, wars and other stuff u muslims are claiming ur prophet prophesied tall buildings 😂😂 really he couldn't even be clear on who competes in building them😂😂😂
@@Tom-f6x It's my pleasure:
Hadith of Gabriel (Jibril) is one of the most important hadiths. included in most of Sunnah Books. you can check it yourself. The text of the argument:
Arabic: "وَأَنْ تَرَى الْحُفَاةَ الْعُرَاةَ الْعَالَةَ رِعَاءَ الشَّاءِ يَتَطَاوَلُونَ فِي الْبُنْيَانِ."
English: "that you will see the barefooted, naked, destitute, the herdsmen of the sheep (competing with each other) in raising lofty buildings."
So who are (barefooted, Naked, Destitute, Herdsmen of the sheep)?.
Major Early Muslim Scholars (centuries ago) said they are "Arab nomads".
@@Tom-f6x It's my pleasure:
Hadith of Gabriel (Jibril) is one of the most important hadiths. included in most of Sunnah Books. you can check it yourself. The text of the argument:
Arabic: "وَأَنْ تَرَى الْحُفَاةَ الْعُرَاةَ الْعَالَةَ رِعَاءَ الشَّاءِ يَتَطَاوَلُونَ فِي الْبُنْيَانِ."
English: "that you will see the barefooted, naked, destitute, the herdsmen of the sheep (competing with each other) in raising lofty buildings."
So who are (barefooted, Naked, Destitute, Herdsmen of the sheep)?.
Major Early Muslim Scholars (centuries ago) said they are "Arab nomads".
@@Tom-f6xHadith of Gabriel (Jibril) is one of the most important hadiths. included in most of Sunnah Books. you can check it yourself. The text of the argument:
Arabic: "وَأَنْ تَرَى الْحُفَاةَ الْعُرَاةَ الْعَالَةَ رِعَاءَ الشَّاءِ يَتَطَاوَلُونَ فِي الْبُنْيَانِ."
English: "that you will see the barefooted, naked, destitute, the herdsmen of the sheep (competing with each other) in raising lofty buildings."
So who are (barefooted, Naked, Destitute, Herdsmen of the sheep)?.
Major Early Muslim Scholars (centuries ago) said they are "Arab nomads".
🙄 Shared on other Social Media… Thanks for sharing real journalism. SAFI.
no that was just the introduction. the real sign was when he said "they will compete to build tall buildings with each other."
"compete"
If I read the "complete" story of the hadith, it seems to me it all was quite different.
A muslim man approached Mo to convert him to Islam (lol), but then he did ask the question about the "last hour".
Mo said, I dont know. The man insisted then, and Mo said something like "It will happen when hell freezes over" to get rid off this man.
Mo is Mohammed,right？
Ap need to explain the pagan trinity to people it will help Christian's leave christianity
@@generaljg4373 Is the pagan god Allah's word and his spirit different from Allah?
There is one key but missing ingredient the retractors of Islam are leaving out...Bedouin Arabs. in Sahih al-Bukhari we read that among the signs of the Day of Judgment is “when the destitute (al-buhm) camelherds compete in building tall structures.” In Sahih Muslim it is written: “you shall see the barefoot, naked, indigent (al-`âla) shepherds compete in building tall structures.”
Closely associated with this phenomenon is the fact that such destitute people will become the leaders and kings of the Earth, as mentioned in some of the versions of such narrations. For example, one version in al-Bukhari has: “when the barefoot and the naked are the top leaders (lit. “heads”) of the people.” A wording from in Saheeh Muslim has: “when you see that the barefoot and naked, the deaf and dumb are the kings of the earth
Continued: Imam an-Nawawi (d.1278 CE) (in his interpretation of Sahih Muslim) mentions:
The people of badia (the desert Bedouins) and their like are people of need and poverty. (A time will come) when the world will be laid open for them until they compete with one another in (the construction of buildings..."(Muslim, Vol. 9, p.28 ).
When we see the history of skyscrapers within the Arabian Peninsula we realize that until the past few decades, there were absolutely no tall structures of any type in the skylines of the Gulf countries. The reason for this is, of course, that for most of their history, the majority of the inhabitants of the Arabian Peninsula were nomadic Bedouins, and this situation continued for many centuries until the middle of the twentieth century (1950’s and 1960’s) when a combination of geographic, demographic, and political factors forced large numbers of Bedouins to settle in the large cities of the Middle East. At this point, it is important to note that the major ruling families in the Gulf states are from bedoiun ancestry, much like the rest of the native population in the Gulf countries
300 years before Muhammad, India was building tall building in terms Temple Gopurams
I like how he picks out certain English translations of the Hadith instead of just looking at the original Arabic one and getting its direct translation. Also convenient how he left out the part where the Prophet (pbuh) specifically mentioned the Arabs .
Bro is a walking illogical fallacy😂😂, bro really tryna say just because the people putting the blocks are not arab then the prophecy is false?!😂😂😂, man i just love laughing at him,
Please show me the hadith that Prophet specifically mentioned the Arabs ?? Give me the hadith name and chapter
Sunan Ibn Majah 63 Hadith 63 it says .وَأَنْ تَرَى الْحُفَاةَ الْعُرَاةَ الْعَالَةَ رِعَاءَ الشَّاءِ يَتَطَاوَلُونَ فِي الْبِنَاءِ ...
Which means, barefooted, naked and shepherds competing in building tall building. There is was no mention of Arabs building anything in hadith. If you know other hadith that says "Arab" then please mention it
Imagine someone saying "i predict that people will building tall building" with no time limit and not defining what tall building is. Thats very predictable thing. It is not prophecy in the first place (even if they say Arab anyway)
@@killermoon635 STRAWMAN, who the frick is the barefooted unclothed people who need stuff and are poor?,at the time of the prophet There were no ONE except the arabs who love in the dessert that perfectly fit this description they were even called , again you STRIVE to try to undermine every miracle of the prophet (pbuh) How could he have predicted that the people he described are going to COMPETE in building tall building he even predicted that the dessert of Arabia will become green AGAIN KEY WORD AGAIN?!!!, this is super true since now its becoming green and it was green wayyyyyyy back in time, so how the heck could he have known that,? Its not a theory its a fact he does not tell you it might no he is as certain as one can be,
@@killermoon635 you aint finna respond?, typical💀, everytime falsehoods is faced with the truth falsehoods losses inshallah,
@yourcarsextendedwarranty5376 Stop flooding my lands you ignorant dog. The inherent superiority of the West is all you need to know about Muh Humas.
I miss this style of videos yay back to classic AP :)
Its a no brainer that humans want to create and be faster, stronger, bigger, better from the beginning. and its vague and making something obvious to be exclusive as mention. By their logic, Moore should be considered a prophet since he created the Moore’s law.
This one sounds even more like a fill in the blank story you'd do for 5th grade homework or someone needed to come up with it to put on record as a prophecy when they were writing them. Either way doesn't make it true. People have competed in building tall structures forever.
Muhammad is the god of islam
Muhammad is a DemiGod of islam can't be a muslim without accepting him
@@alphadragon1948 Can you be a Christian without accepting Paul as Apostle of Jesus ?
He was a human and a prophet of Allah just like Abaraham, Moses, Jesus, and others.... We love all of them and we respect all .... I can't understand why people do not argue in logical and respectful manner here ... ua-cam.com/video/wCTeCuw-keI/v-deo.html
@@saula.k.apaulthefalseapost4041 Jesus is the savior in Christianity I’m not Christian
@@saula.k.apaulthefalseapost4041 Paul is a chosen vessel Jesus used to spread his messages of the Gospel after he returned to the heavenly position, it written in scripture!
The More prophecies they Make… The more DESPERATE THEY ARE!!!
😅😅😅😂😂😂😂
I love your profile pic🤣
@@steen275 it’s a real Quran with real Bacon I used to read it now I use it as Toilet paper page by page 😃
@@themurtad821 random fact:
Pigs are one of the cleanest animal in the world
@@ihaventshoweredin6weeksbut527 that’s where you are wrong… The Prophet Muhammad was the biggest pig Alive he was ANYTHING but Clean 😵💫
If there were a prophecy that addressed “Men wearing black, dominating the market, building towers, and trading spiritual money”. Or if it talked about the internet in detail, that might be something to consider. The prophecies available from the QURAN and BIBLE are terrible. Just terrible.
Awomen to that!
The standard Christian narrative is sketchy theres many different bibles and people bowdown to the Pope
@@generaljg4373 No. popes are not Christian. And the 66 book canon is considered the Bible.
@@elijahj9902 in christianity God is Jewish man and he has a mother
@@generaljg4373 No and no. In the Bible, Jesus is the manifest word of God, and Mary is never called mother or mother of God. In the gospels, Jesus referred to Mary as “woman”.
You would think that God's final messages spoken through his final, and greatest prophet would be of more importance to humanity than things like tall buildings, or the outcome of some war 1200 years or so ago.Which is about equal to correctly calling heads or tails. Thanks for the heads up Muhammad, don't know what we would have done without it.
Or who can marry his wives after his death or how to come to his home for a meal and not linger for conversation.
We all agree that christianity is BS god became a baby for 9 months then he declared that he is God smh
Agreed, but I'm glad the quran teaches goat herders how many times to shake their peepee when they do weewee, because without this divine knowledge, who knows how long they'll be sitting there 😂😂
@@generaljg4373 and surah 52:24, lots of handsome boy servants for muslim males in jannah. It is not homosexuality, do not worry. Or pdfilia
@@generaljg4373ok nine years rapist
Some ex muslim in india raised the below point about 50 namaaz
"The prophet then continued on to what's called the Lote-Tree of the Farthest Limit, and it was then when Gabriel told him he'd have to go it alone. There, the prophet spoke directly to God. He commanded him to instruct Muslims to pray 50 times a day".
50 × 15 minutes. plus time to travel to and from mosque. People will not get time to go to toilet also
Right, praying for 12h a day is no big deal right? 🤣Oh boy, this religion is at its worst.
Why is there no holiday on the donkey of Mohammad who took his life because he missed the prophet? The donkey should be honored…🫏
Quran 22:46Have they not travelled throughout the land so their hearts may reason, and their ears may listen? Indeed, it is not the eyes that are blind, but it is the hearts in the chests that grow blind.
Here example of false prophecy
I heard Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) as saying: The Last Hour would come (when) the Romans would form a majority amongst people
@@killermoon635
Ohh!! Common I will give you a verse from Quran which was prophecised that Romans have been defeated but will win again and it was time bound and Alhamdulillah the prophecy came true. Don't be fooled by these islamophobes study Islam and may Allah guide you to the truth Ameen
“The Romans have been defeated, In the land nearby, and they, after their defeat, will be victorious. In a few years - Allah’s is the command before and after [that] - and on that day the believers will rejoice, With the help of Allah. He helps whom He pleases; and He is the Mighty, the Merciful. Allah has made this promise. Allah breaks not His promise, but most men know not.” (Surah ar-Rum, Ch.30: V.3-7)
You think that quote is meaningful but is just ignorance of the 7th people at the time. People believed the heart was the centre or reason and logic, so they said it is their heart is blind beacuse they believed we thought with our hearts it’s only retrospectively that this quote takes a new meaning. Or is more meaningful than it actually was it’s the equivalent of saying it’s not their heart which is blind but their mind. Which is hypocritical since Islam discourages independent thinling
@@tunnelvision7906 then why your heart get constricted whenever the Prophecies of our beloved Prophet Muhammad peace and blessings of Allah be upon him comes true or when Muslims intellectually grill every religious people and atheists and when your hear that the Islam is the fastest growing religion. It is meaningful quote but not to the dumb Islamophobic content listeners like you. Nothing personal but please be a rational thinker and accept the truth, because on the day of judgement these clowns will not help you and eternal hellfire is not a Joke. May Allah Subhanahuta'la guide you to the truth.
Don't mind they aren't barefoot, naked, destitute or Shepard's. They are building a tall building so he prophesied this EXACTLY! 🤦
I think the issues was about building Tower of Babel again. Trying to get to God and God attacking people like he did before but this time in term of the end of the world.
prophet mohammed talking about Arabic nomads people, not other people, so they trying to raise more for the building and compete.
Competing in bigger and taller buildings has been done since ancient Egypt, pyramids and obelix, sphynx. Probably even before that.
I think if you make like 100 predictions that are possible to happen and don't tell when they are going to happen, then for the next 1500 years some of them will happen
Hey AP- love your work , is it corrrect that Sahih Bukhari died 238 years after Mohammed ?
Forget about that I am still baffled that Muhammad’s biological father died in 606 AD and Muhammad was born in 610 AD. So Muhammad’s father died 4 years before he was born. Clearly his father is unknown makes him a real bastard.
They are *slaves (not workers)
Last time I checked, people who built buildings had shoes on..
To give Mohammed some credit, I think his point was in the last times people will lose all sense of priority. People who can hardly afford necessities will spend all their money on luxuries to one-up their neighbors. Prophecies about people losing their minds before the end of the world is nothing new, but adding the financial aspect was an interesting twist.
Literalyy no one in islam oroutside of it ever said that, where did you get this
@(see my playlists) truth is bitter Woe unto me for what?
@@islamapologetics1019You are cringe Mohammad is a child molester cope.
So in muslim country they build tall buildings fullfilling the scriptures.
So they go against gods will
The biggest problem is that if muhammad really did have some kind of divine insight into the future, wouldn't allah have given muhammad better insight? Like, couldn't he have given muhammad specific very solid insight that he could have spoke about to really convince people that he was a prophet? Couldn't allah have told him, in 2 thousand years, people will speak to each other from opposite sides of the globe? Why not say the earth is round and speak of the solar system? Muhammad clearly didn't have divine insight into the reality of the world.
None of the religions do
@@allenanderson2129 woke.
In christianity God is Jewish man and he only speak to the Israelites
@@generaljg4373 so what their are no gods
@@generaljg4373 Jesus spoke Hebrew, you lie!
Tall buildings are already present before the birthday of Islam . But in few numbers .
For example :
I predict the ai technology going to impose a threat on humanity if not controlled well .
This is common sense .
Prophet Muhammad's prophecy was about a specific group of poor people would compete in the construction of tall buildings which is an unlikely scenario:
*“Now, tell me of the Last Hour,” asked the man.
The Prophet replied, “The one asked knows no more of it than the one asking.”
“Then tell me about its signs,” said the man. The Prophet replied, “That you see barefoot, unclothed herdsmen competing in the construction of tall buildings." [Sunan Ibn Majah, Hadith #63]*
Notice the detailed characteristics: the barefoot, unclothed herdsmen were mentioned. When Prophet Muhammad was asked about the identity of these people, he responded by identifying the Arabs:
*“It was said: ‘Who are the barefoot herdsmen?’ He
answered: ‘The Arabs’” [Musnad Ahmad, Hadith **#2924**]*
We can see that Prophet Muhammad prophesied that a very specific group from among the Arabs, the barefoot, unclothed herdsmen, would one day compete in constructing tall buildings. In fact, this detailed description refers to a very particular type of Arab, the Bedouins.
Prophet Muhammad could have easily played it safe by using more general language such as “you see competition in the construction of tall buildings…” which of course would be flexible enough to be applied to anyone in the world.
From millennium past there are two types of Arabs, city dwellers and Bedouins. The former make up the majority and live in ancient cities like Damascus, Cairo, and Baghdad. In contrast, the Bedouins are nomads, they travel through the vast deserts and are constantly on the move. Even during the Golden Age of Islam when the Arabs were the richest and most learned people on earth, Bedouins remained in virtually the same state they had been for thousands of years, poor, uneducated and cut off from rest of the world.
As recently as the 1940s the English explorer Sir Wilfred Thesiger was travelling through the deserts inhabited by the Bedouin and documented their condition:
*As I listened I thought once again how precarious was the existence of the Bedu. Their way of life naturally made them fatalists; so much was beyond their control. It was impossible for them to provide for a morrow when everything depended on a chance fall of rain or when raiders, sickness, or any one of a hundred chance happenings might at any time leave them destitute, or end their lives. They did what they could, and no people were more self-reliant, but if things went wrong they accepted their fate without bitterness, and with dignity as the will of God.*
*- Sir Wilfred Thesiger, Arabian Sands*
Many early Muslim scholars and classical commentators understood Prophet Muhammad’s prophecy to be a reference to the Arab Bedouins who were known as the “people of the desert”.
The famous jurist Imam an-Nawawi
(1233 - 1277) said the following in his interpretation of Prophet Muhammad’s prophecy:
*The people of the desert and their like are people of need and poverty. (A time will come) when the world will be laid open for them until they compete with one another in (the construction of) buildings, and God knows best.*
*- Muhammad Hisham Kabbani, The Approach of Armageddon? An Islamic Perspective, p. 90*
The renowned scholar Al-Qurtubi (1214 - 1273) said:
*What is meant here is the prediction of a reversal in society whereby the people of the desert will take over the conduct of affairs and rule every region by force. They will become extremely rich and their primary concern will be to erect tall buildings and take pride in them.*
*- Muhammad Hisham Kabbani, The Approach of Armageddon? An Islamic Perspective, p. 90*
We can see that these early Muslim scholars and classical commentators, who were writing centuries ago, were consistent in their identification of the Arab Bedouins.
This shows just how clear Prophet Muhammad’s description of these
people was.
Today we find in the Arabian Peninsula that a particular group of Arabs, the Bedouins who used to be impoverished herders of camels and sheep until the mid-20th century, are now competing to build the tallest tower blocks, just as Prophet Muhammad foretold.
How did this change happen seemingly overnight? How did one of the poorest people on earth, who literally wore rags, become one of the wealthiest nations on earth? One thing made this rapid change possible, something upon which the modern world would revolve around perhaps more than any other, the discovery of “black gold”, oil.
The seemingly empty deserts of the Bedouins had it in abundance. The Bedouins went from camels to Cadillacs in a generation!
Today one of the highest concentrations of tall buildings in the world is in the Arabian peninsula, specifically the areas in which Bedouin Arabs lived.
In 2012 the tallest building in the world was the Mecca Clock Tower, standing at 601 metres, this gigantic structure was built in the desert city where Prophet Muhammad was born. Only two years after its completion, the Burj Khalifa was built in Dubai with a height of 828 metres. A short time after the Burj Khalifa was completed, a rival family in Saudi Arabia announced that they would build a taller one (1,000 metres); the Kingdom Tower.
The Bedouin Arabs of today are literally competing with each other over who can build the world’s tallest building.
The Companions of Prophet Muhammad also understood his prophecy to be a reference to buildings of vast heights.
*“They said: So when you see in Mecca that channels have been dug and its buildings reach the tops of the mountains, then know that the hour has cast its shadow over you” [Al-Musannaf, Hadith **#124**]*
The famous Mecca Clock Tower is currently the fourth tallest building in the world. In order for such construction to be possible, many of Mecca’s ancient mountains have been demolished in order to make room for the tall buildings that have sprung up.
Amazingly, this is also something that Prophet Muhammad foretold; he said that mountains will one day be moved from their places:
*“The Hour will not be established until mountains are moved from their places." [Al-Tabarani, Mu‘jam al-Kabir, **#6857**]*
This tremendous feat of demolishing entire mountains has only been possible in the 20th century with the advent of technology such as explosives. Thanks to these modern technical advances, mountains can now be blasted into rubble in order to make room for massive city infrastructure such as buildings and highways.
What would motivate Prophet Muhammad to even make such a prophecy? If he was going to make up such a prophecy it would make more sense to relate this prophecy to the superpowers of his time: Rome, Persia or even China who (unlike the Arabs) already had a tendency to construct extravagant buildings and palaces. For example, the Hagia Sophia cathedral was built by a Roman emperor in 537 CE, the century before Prophet Muhammad, and it remained the world’s largest building for nearly a thousand years.
Furthermore, the immense detail that Prophet Muhammad provided in this prophecy is very revealing. Frauds, those who falsely claim to be able to predict the future, typically make their predictions general and ambiguous in nature so that they can be applied to multiple situations. The more general and ambiguous the prophecy, the greater the chance that something, somewhere, will eventually occur that bears enough of a resemblance that it will seem like the prophecy was an accurate prediction. Prophet Muhammad could have made a prediction such as “you will see the construction of tall buildings”. Such a prediction uses very general descriptions that are flexible enough to be applied to anyone in the world.
By comparison, the prophecy that Prophet Muhammad did make is filled with lots of very specific details. He gave a clear context for the building construction, that of competition. He also identified who the builders would be, the Arab Bedouins, by describing some unique distinguishing features such as their physical appearance (“barefoot and unclothed”) and their way of life (“Bedouins”). We can see that such a prophecy contains multiple variables, each of which is very detailed and must be fulfilled in a very specific manner, which strictly limits how the event could happen.
It’s important to point out that Prophet Muhammad himself did not like Muslims to be involved in trying to unnecessarily increase in wealth. Indeed he often warned of its dangers and how it would corrupt his nation. He did not like or promote the construction of extravagant buildings. He was a simple man who lived in a simple house and wanted other Muslims to maintain that simplicity. That is what he taught and how he lived.
If he wanted to “will” this prophecy to become true, he would have encouraged the Arabs to build tall buildings and perhaps start off trying to do that himself! In fact the Qur’an itself discourages such behaviour:
*“Do you build on every height a monument? Vain is it that you do. And you make strong fortresses as if you were to live forever?” [Qur'an 26:128-129]*
Hamza Yusuf likes to quote a prophecy about how a sign of the end times will be a shoe that can talk to you. Nike of course designed such a shoe. So, Hamza thinks that the prophecy has been fulfilled.
The prophecy mentions shoe lace btw. So it doesn't even fit what Nike made.
@@mightbyson I am not a Muslim and I do not think that Muhammad’s prophecies are true, just to be clear. I wanted to give an example of how Muslims use these prophecies
@@bayreuth79 I know you just shared how Muslims use this prophecy. I was just adding my comment to show that even the way it's used is invalid.
*_"Anyone who can make you believe that women have dicks, can make you commit attrocities"_*
Sounded like the closing music was Ave Maria..Was it?...Also A.P. just to inform you it's not "Learned" it is "Learn-ED" when speaking of a scholar.
Why don't u debate Joram van Klaveren, the former anti muslim far right leader from Netherlands and also another anti muslim Dutch leader Arnoud Vann doorn Who became muslim...in anti muslim country like Netherlands every year so many convert to islam..same is the scene in other European countries and Latin America
His (Jerome's)book titled "Apostate from Christianity to Islam in times of sécularisation and terror" was published in both Dutch and English.
Joram van Klaveren;) Buahaha, that guy political carrier was in deep sh_t because his driving under alcohol influence, so when he lost another elections he just came to a great idea, he became believer, and suddenly his carrier skyrocketed;) Wow, if no one sees how he converted for fame and profits, then one is seriously blind;)
Once during eid up adha, one of the cows that we owned was sacrificed and then cut into pieces and a piece of it said allahuakbar in arabic,it was written. Explain that?? This is proof that Islam is the one and only religion.
Funny that the architects and main engineers were Europeans not Muslims 😭😂😂😂😂✝️
Because Muslims got the cash 💷 Europeans need.
But who owns and competes in building them?!
@@shapsugh1864 Oil rich playboy Sultans supposedly "Sunni conservatives" 🤦♂️🤣
@@BT-qs7id okay, to what race and family do they belong
@@shapsugh1864 Wow YOU CAN'T figure it out comrade? ..............well looking at your thumb pic NO SUPRISE
🥴 🇷🇺 good luck in kindergarten
Can you debunk the theory of the word month mentioned 12 times and the word years apparently mentioned 365 times In the Coran ...
"The sun shall rise."
😮
its talking about the Bedouin
The industrial requirements of them and the era they lived in wasnt for this kind of things, note that the Hadith just say "building" it says COMPETING, because they would have alot of wealth and power to the point they keep up with these mega projects they keep making them
But, it heavily depends on the socio economics of the region and the bedouins were in no shape or form a kind of group of people to do these
hence why nobody so far could have refuted this Prophecy properly nor logically
I wonder if Muhammad did a prophecy in his Quran about the Oil abundance of Dubai and Qatar. 🤔
No there is no but they mix up other word and somehow make it.
@@thomaskennedy5728 So Muhammad is a big joke?
He forgot
Thank you, AP. Great stuff. And I love how you close with the Ave Maria. :)
The Hagia Sophia already existed in Muhammad's day. That's a pretty f#cking tall building.
There is one key but missing ingredient the retractors of Islam are leaving out...Bedouin Arabs. in Sahih al-Bukhari we read that among the signs of the Day of Judgment is “when the destitute (al-buhm) camelherds compete in building tall structures.” In Sahih Muslim it is written: “you shall see the barefoot, naked, indigent (al-`âla) shepherds compete in building tall structures.”
Closely associated with this phenomenon is the fact that such destitute people will become the leaders and kings of the Earth, as mentioned in some of the versions of such narrations. For example, one version in al-Bukhari has: “when the barefoot and the naked are the top leaders (lit. “heads”) of the people.” A wording from in Saheeh Muslim has: “when you see that the barefoot and naked, the deaf and dumb are the kings of the earth
Imam an-Nawawi (d.1278 CE) (in his interpretation of Sahih Muslim) mentions:
The people of badia (the desert Bedouins) and their like are people of need and poverty. (A time will come) when the world will be laid open for them until they compete with one another in (the construction of buildings..."(Muslim, Vol. 9, p.28 ).
When we see the history of skyscrapers within the Arabian Peninsula we realize that until the past few decades, there were absolutely no tall structures of any type in the skylines of the Gulf countries. The reason for this is, of course, that for most of their history, the majority of the inhabitants of the Arabian Peninsula were nomadic Bedouins, and this situation continued for many centuries until the middle of the twentieth century (1950’s and 1960’s) when a combination of geographic, demographic, and political factors forced large numbers of Bedouins to settle in the large cities of the Middle East. At this point, it is important to note that the major ruling families in the Gulf states are from bedoiun ancestry, much like the rest of the native population in the Gulf countries
It’s like when the Bible prophesies war, illness and famine to end of the days😂
Shepherd of black camels refered to the "Beduine" tribe of Arab as they were shepherds. They were known for their strange lifestyle at that time such as constantly moving one place to another, barefooted and so on. And if you know the history, the UAE was formed mostly by Beduine people.
You dug so deep bro!
Imagine someone saying 'i predict that people will build tall building' with no time limit and not defining what tall building is. It is very predictable thing. It is not prophecy in the first place because you are talking about something that will happen for sure (as civilization advanced people will building something taller than we have before)
But the fact that it says barefooted, naked & shepherds or Shepherd of black camels building tall buildings refute. We don't see such thing. All we see is rich non-shepherd Arabs siting on chair and asking foreigners to build tall buildings.
@@killermoon635the prophecy is in our faces….
Mohammad crawled into bed with me last night and gave me one hell of a blow job. He said I was a bad boy for sleeping on my stomach.
@killermoon635 bro what he meant is the non rich arabs
Also there is hadith the says that Romans will become majority of people before hour come.
False prophecy
Jubreel just squeezed me and revealed to me that some people are sleeping right now, can anyone prove me wrong???
Ha ha, you reminded me of David Wood's Boom Boom Room, Satan episode, have you seen it?! Now I have to go watch it, again...
🌟♦️You missed a point .. 👈
The narration goes against Quran. In Quran, opponent of M*hammad demand that angel should come in humanly form and talk to you. Quran denies explicitly. The narration of "Tall Buildings" part of story when Angel appears in humanly body and talks to M*hammad.
Contradiction 🚫
your argument is really weak 🧠🧠🧠 it's still a great clear miracle
More like a self-fullfiling prophecy. They were aware of it and likely influenced them to make tall buildings.
Reminds me of the tower of Babylon.
Seems like there is an endless pit of BS in that book, no matter how much you scrape the bottom a new smell will emerge.
Thanks for information
The irony is that the true scholars of islam, are apostates.
Apostates and non Muslims are the only ones that tell the whole truth of this cult.
Indeed. And actual serious scholarly research is done by Western scholars.
Yo Apostate Prophet looks like Drowzee the pokemon 🤣
I died when I saw 4 tier Kaabah😂😂😂
Well they do believe the kabaa was originally built by a 14 m tall Adam.
Some people in the future won't bother to read and think, and will believe in tales of the ancients.
what did you mean?
Saying something vague and then having people who believe in you do the thing you said might happen is not being prophetic. Not even close. LOL
The Jews say, "Ezra is the son of Allāh"; and the Christians say, "The Messiah is the son of Allāh." That is their statement from their mouths; they imitate the saying of those who disbelieved before [them]. May Allāh destroy them; how are they deluded?
Omg when they credit round earth to islam when Hypatia of alexandria was literally tortured to death for presenting a heliocentric model close to a thousand years before the prophet was even born!
I am certain that Sheikh Yaboodi will refute your claims and prove that this prophecy is correct.
The hadith wasn't saying nothing about who has the first buildings but it talks about one of the sign before the end of time. The desert man or the Bedouin would be competing about having the tallest buildings ,( Dubai is an exemple)
Did you not listen to a single word?
I think I've discovered a new drinking game where I take a drink every time you say "tall buildings"
Surely for any prophecy to be taken seriously, it should, at least, hint of a timescale.
4:18 Were yellow helmets prophesied?
An educated Muslim is an Ex Muslim
Haha
Yeh, 100%. AP does not even know the shortest chapter in Quran which proves that he was not a practicing Muslim at all. Just take some time to view the world from a different angle : ua-cam.com/video/wCTeCuw-keI/v-deo.html
You Should Say! Named Muslim... Believe it or not Allah is Real, Islam is Real...
@@lillahinstitute prove its existence
@@lillahinstitute you are sick, today in my country, ur stupid religion claimed the blood of a christain in the name of blasphemy against an idoit who fucked a 9 yrs old and married his sons wife, a false prophet called Muhammad my foot, God almighty will judge u people, swear u guys will burn in hell, Antichrist religion of Doom and blood suckers, both ur children and unborn children will have blood stains in their hands for the blood of the innocent sheld by Islam.
Here is my prophecy:
more people will be commuting by AI-powered vehicles in the future
People built tall buildings long before Mo came along. The tallest ones were pyramids and ziggurats, because the sloping pile was the most stable structure possible without structural steel.
Babylon
Mo ham mad
was
too
busy
with
his
Child wife to notice all that
Interesting
Well even romans lived in big apartments long before.
Momo was just an illiterate 7th century desert man. He didn't know shit
You can say everything about islam but when the hour comes you will regret just like the people of noah regret they doesnt go to the ship and continue mocking noah
I could make a prophecy and have it come true.... It's easy to make past prophecy come true
Many people before said that 2012 will be end of the world and come 2013 nothing happens
@@kerjadakwah7782 2012 maybe they meant backwoods so 2102
@@bryanbradley6871 Why no one before that said it was either 2012 or 2102. Clearly you have no knowledge and made that up.
The mind boggles at the attempts by apologist to justify their faith just as drowning men grasping at straws.🙄🙄🙄
Are you illiterate? The hadith says "competing" to make tall buildings." not" they will make the first ever tall buildings. Lol
Even if that’s the case, it’s still stupid.
If anyone is interested, the outro music is Ave Maria by Franz Schubert...
That’s the problem when you don’t understand the Hadith. The prophet said ( People from my peoples ) in that time the Arabs wasn’t even close to build those kind of tall towers. The prophet was talking about the Arabs will be competing against each others to see who will build the tallest buildings. ( What I know the pharaohs wasn’t Arabs, the Romans wasn’t Arabs, the Babylonians wasn’t Arabs, the Parisians wasn’t Arabs ) soooo he prophecy was talking about the Arabs that in his time the only thing they knew to do well was trading goods. So please before you keep lying and confusing your followers understand the Hadith. ( The Hadith talk about the Arabs and today the ones who are competing on who will build the tallest skyscrapers are the Arabs from the golf ).
He didn't say Arabs, he said barefoot destitute shepherds. Where are these shepherds then?
So why he don't say Arabs, Instead using something vague? I mean barefooted, naked, poor, shepherds, doesn't really refers to arabs for me. I would use "people of the desert", or at least if there is a "trader" in his prophecy (it's vague but) only then your argument is a bit more make sense. This is just because you want to believe you fool yourself.
@@darkira2129 He said ( People from my people barefoot ) Prophet Muhammad is Arab so if you’re wise enough you will realize he was talking about the Arabs. It’s clear the Hadith says ( People from my People ) . He wasn’t talking about Egyptians, Persians or other civilizations but about the Arabs. And if you see the tallest building nowadays is in the Arab peninsula. So I’m Hispanic and if I tell you ( in the future my people will be the number one builder around the world ) you have to realize that I’m talking about the Hispanic community and not about the Asian or the africans. Because the key is ( My People ) . But anyways everyone is free to believe in what they want. And what this channel is doing is confusing the non Muslims.
AP I miss the intro
People participate in build-fighting in Fortnite.. therefore, islam must be true!
Bro it isn't about fortnite
Where does the Hadith say they will be pious Muslims or their building large buildings will be commendable Islamically ?!?
I do not think that it is possible for barefoot, naked, destitute shepherds being capable of competing in constructing tall buildings.'
Here is the rest of Sunan Ibn Majah 63
It was narrated that 'Umar said:
"We were sitting with the Prophet (ﷺ) when a man came to him whose clothes were intensely white and whose hair was intensely black; no signs of travel could be seen upon him, and none of us recognized him. He sat down facing the Prophet (ﷺ), with his knees touching his, and he put his hands on his thighs, and said: 'O Muhammad, what is Islam?' He said: 'To testify that none has the right to be worshipped but Allah, and that I am the Messenger of Allah, to establish regular prayer, to pay Zakat, to fast in Ramadan, and to perform Hajj to the House (the Ka'bah).' He said: 'You have spoken the truth.' We were amazed by him: He asked a question, then told him that he had spoken the truth. Then he said: 'O Muhammad, what is Iman faith? He said: 'To believe in Allah, His angels, His Messengers, His books, the Last day, and the Divine Decree (Qadar), both the good of it and the bad of it.' He said' You have spoken the truth.' We were amazed by him. He asked a question, then told him that he had spoken the truth. Then he said: 'O Muhammad, what is Ihsan (right action, goodness, sincerity)? He said: 'To worship Allah as if you see Him, for even though you do not see Him, He sees you.' He asked: "When will the Hour be?' He said: 'The one who is being asked about it does not know more than the one who is asking.' He asked: 'Then what are its signs?' he said: 'When the slave woman gives birth to her mistress' (Waki' said: This means when non-Arabs will give birth to Arabs") 'AND WHEN YOU SEE BAREOOT, NAKED, DESTITUTE SHEPHERDS COMPETING IN CONSTRUCTING TALL BUILDINGS .' The Prophet (ﷺ) met me three days later and asked me: 'Do you know who that man was? I said" 'Allah and his Messenger know best.' He said: 'That was Jibril, who came to you to teach you your religion.'"
Dam I'm converting to Islam 🤣
@@techknow9237 🤣🤣🤣
how could the construction of miracles be a prophecy when it was thanks to westerners that the Arabs were able to develop with oil it was the westerners who discovered And the Bedouins were taught how the refined .
I think the prophecy is right. It is the beginning of the end of time for Islaaaam!
petra also got so many tall buildings. they're even mentioned in quran
You called me out? 🤔
Pls AP whenever you talk about some hadith or verse, put the reference in the description so that we wee lil followers of you may have references on the go while debating! Anyways, love you from Pakistan!!!
You left Islam while performing Umrah?
@@confirmjannati Yea I'm that lucky guy who didn't get to kiss the black stone! 😄
@@toxicdota9290 🤣🤣
@@toxicdota9290 Don't use your picture as a DP of you are in Pakistan.
@@confirmjannati Yes I am in Pakistan but saving grace is no longer an option for me but thanks a lot buddy, rarely do I ever find someone who happens to say somethin' good to me!
Probably stolen and changed idea of the tower of babel
I think it's more likely that the early Muslims, being caravan traders, simply travelled to large cities and saw tall buildings and aspired for having the same one day.
Damn. I just made a meme about it as well. I also compared it to the USA in the early 1900 - where Shepards (a Cowboys) and naked and barefooted refers to Native Americans (the America). This is the lie we were told in the 1980' as sign is END OF TIME!
This so called prophecies is just a lie that keeps giving.
can you make a video regarding the alleged Roman "miracle?"
Sounds like a story about Babel tower that made God angry etc... and they think it might repeat ... they tried to reach Heaven , aka Jannah ... and be like God, btwbhi think they were barefoot and almist naked back than...
Hindus have stories about flying objects....people and other religions used to mock it....but now , we have it...LOL 😂....
AP, good one. Too bad you use logic! Believers don't!👍💙🥰✌
Wth
Do you even watch believers videos 🤔
To say such a thing 🤨
All what they talk about is logical
@@samir_ZX I don't agree. I have studied science for many years and have watched many vidoes made by Muslims about "scientific miracles" in the Quran. These people do not understand the science that they are describing, they never quote historical sources that talk about the same things that the Quran does and they re-interpret the meaning of the Quran, sometimes changing the words - their interpretations never agree with what the best Islamic scholars in the tafsirs say (which base their ideas on sahih hadiths often). So, where is their logic? They pull things out of a hat to convince people who don't know much science or history.
@@theastronomer5800 can you give me an example
@@samir_ZX OH! That was good! I'm generalizing believers, as in 'of all religions ' ! It is pretty much all emotion, projection and ignorance. Science doesn't know everything, but religion doesn't know anything! 🥰✌
@@samir_ZX Hey Samir. Sure. Look for example into video about pulsars and the Quran. Muslims claim in these that this is a "scientific miracle", that the Quran is describing "knocking stars" and these have been discovered.
First, they don't understand what the Quran is talking about. If they would read the tafsirs on this verse (which they always say people who criticize verses should do!), the best Islamic scholars explain why the name At-Tariq is used. For example, Ibn Kathir explains "The star has been named Tariq because it is only seen at night and it is hidden during the day'. [This] view is supported by what has been mentioned in the authentic Hadith that prohibits a man to come to his family Taruq. This means that he comes to them unexpectedly at nighttime." Ibn Abbas says " this refers to the planet Saturn which shines at night and disappears during the day".
Second, they don't understand what pulsars are - how they generate the beams of electromagnetic radiation, what we observe, how the intensity of the beam is "converted" into sound, they don't understand that the star or its radiation does NOT make a sound however we can convert intensity into sound just like we can convert colour intensity into sound. They don't understand that the Quran is talking about something that comes at night, while pulsars are visible day and night, they don't understand that the Quran talks of a star of piercing brightness but pulsars are some of the dimmest objects in the universe (we can't see them with the eye and most are radio pulsars and radio waves as you may know are the least energetic of electromagnetic waves). The Quran also seems to talk of one star, but there are millions of pulsars.
I often use the example of seeing a lighthouse far away and each you see the beam you hit a drum. The lighthouse light of course does not make any sound! We can use the exact same equipment as we do to observe pulsars and get the same result. However, I have people who do not understand physics (or who have read the tafsirs) argue with me that I'm wrong. What can you do :) I have only studied pulsars in my astrophysics courses, so what do I know.
Before 50 years ago saudi Arabia have no buildings but after black gold oil saudi Arabia rich
8 floor buildings did exist in saudi arabia in 1960
Also the hadith all it say barefooted shepered will compete in building taller constructions. It does not say tall building or define what tall building is
Also we do not see any barefooted or shepered or Arab building anything. Just rich Arabs hiring foreigners to build it
@killermoon635 dude it meant the descendants of the naked,destitute and barefooted arabs akhi.
May ALLAH have mercy on you on the day of judgement
Good point bro
AP, at about 4am I had an apostrophe. I asked myself, why is all the filth in Islam nearly identical? Answer, they are all SINonyms.
The thing about prophecies like these.... it tends to be the kind of prohpecy people will try their best to fullfill. Especially if said regime has any religious people in control of it.
Yet it got fulfilled
Today, only Rich people who by default have nice clothes and shoes can compete in building Tall buildings.
Well done 👏👏
Fuck, it's only been 12 minutes and I'm not the first comment 🥺 it must be Allah's will
No masjeed in south Buffalo New York! What ever will we do? Please take all my money until it is built!!!
What they don't tell you is that it's built on the ruins of a former church. It's an act of dominance and wanton desecration of another religion's temple.
@@Xbalanque84 its a fake ad they have heaps of them
You need to use some pimple cream and clear those spots
We love you so much keep doing this great work
Do you know this video has been criticized?
@@Mohamed-wp9kw what
@@abraham_1997 Search my comment in this section
@@abraham_1997 I've criticized it, and eventually received, unfortunately, an overall irrelevant & bad feedback
@@Mohamed-wp9kw what's your point