its kinda hard to believe this is asriel, but this poor "soul" went trough so much time thinking, seeing, *playing* and so much more to the point it won't matter, he's just like us... when we get curious.
I think my most anticipated part of the mashup was the “over and over” chant transitioning to “everybody dies in pain, all will fall to flowey’s reign”. Makes flowey sound like he’s reciting a mantra while breaking it down to clover.
Man, both of these versions have such good things about them. It kind of makes me want to splice just the best parts of each of them together into one cohesive song.
Woah I think that the best part was Best Friends Forever, Afterlife is kind of a mess, and the specimens really vary. I like it, it's a good ol representation of how messed up Flowey's mind is
Josh did a good job, but I don’t understand how anybody can hear the sheer showmanship and intensity in xander’s performance and still think it’s a contest
This seems like one of the versions wasnt the first this happend and flowey is remembering it while fighting since clover is getting absorbed he can see it
This is an ok mix but could be improved, but not a bad shot with more practices, this will be an incredible mix of the songs. Keep going, this is not easy to do especially with these songs and the chaotic nature.
I agree with this. Not to say MOTI's version is bad its pretty good, but I feel like Josh's lyrics are overall better, especially how he ties them into each of the themes of the specimens.
I prefer MOTI version cause it's better with the voice, only the lyrics that arent that good, not saying the other version is bad but i cant hear other song with flowey without the MOTI's flowey voice.
I like motis afterlife better but best friends forever goes to Josh along with specimen clay organic And patchwork… I do feel moti did get polygonal mechanical and paper better tho
I’d give this a 7/10 of a mashup. Perhaps at some parts of the Afterlife part of the mashup you should have alternated between Josh and MOTI. The Experiment parts were pretty well done though at the gray Flowey Parts I probably would have done Josh, Then 2 Specimen parts, Josh solo, 2 Specimen Parts, Josh and MOTI, Last 2 Specimen parts, and then ended with MOTI cause Man on the Internet only did 2 Gray Flowey Parts.
I like the Drama Josh version more, like... actually I don't really like most of MOTI's lyrics video, I like when lyrics match up with the melody and moti kind of break that a lot... which I guess could just be how musical works? But it feels... weird, and things, like I like game music because it doesn't have lyrics, so it's just the melody, and the melody is nice, so when those are just kind of covered with more different notes lyrics it's kinda... (shrug emoticon)
I personally disagree. Don’t get me wrong, I usually like the lyrics being matched to the melody, but one, I can’t get behind Drama Josh’s voice for flowey, it sounds too normal while Alex Rybitski does a good job of friendly yet crazy, and two, I think not matching the melody perfectly makes sense for flowey. After all, he’s insane, why should he do the normal thing, especially since, I’m pretty sure Meta Flowey is all in Flowey’s mind
![Enemy Retreating...WITH LYRICS! [Undertale Yellow]](/img/n.gif)
Josh's version is a narratively accurate depiction of a psycopath, while MOTI'S is just going insane.
That's flowey for you
Accurate representation of Flowey's mind
Ha
its kinda hard to believe this is asriel, but this poor "soul" went trough so much time thinking, seeing, *playing* and so much more to the point it won't matter, he's just like us... when we get curious.
Accurate representation of clover in his mind
He’s just us
Well his mind looks kinda similar to the inside of my brain when I think about Airy
Y’all: “I can fix him.”
His mind on a regular Monday: “ 9:45 “
him is me. no cap
Both of y'all aren't wrong, can I join the group of people that are "him" ?
@@xcreepercrafterx8016 I meant I am flowey in this situation.
We literally fix the guy in the pacifist thought
I think my most anticipated part of the mashup was the “over and over” chant transitioning to “everybody dies in pain, all will fall to flowey’s reign”. Makes flowey sound like he’s reciting a mantra while breaking it down to clover.
10:42 - 10:54 is honestly my favorite part the way the voices come together just feels right
They dont over lap as much its actually so cool!
Man, both of these versions have such good things about them. It kind of makes me want to splice just the best parts of each of them together into one cohesive song.
Woah
I think that the best part was Best Friends Forever, Afterlife is kind of a mess, and the specimens really vary. I like it, it's a good ol representation of how messed up Flowey's mind is
1:41 why is this actually fire?!
lowkey just flowey from both games trying to see whos the better singer.
specimen: paper only played Drama Josh's version
@@Alexios1114 oh yeah when I exported the file I only realized afterwards that I had accidentally muted that part so uh...whoops
Is there a way you could fix it?
@@macncheesyfun4328 no not really
@@Smug-Catruh roh
The few parts where it fits together perfectly are the best
Till you diiiiii-
Iiiiiive thought uppppp
*Perfection*
Josh did a good job, but I don’t understand how anybody can hear the sheer showmanship and intensity in xander’s performance and still think it’s a contest
This seems like one of the versions wasnt the first this happend and flowey is remembering it while fighting since clover is getting absorbed he can see it
In some ways, the lyrics together sound pretty good and makes sense since Floweys insane
Its basically 2 sides of flowey with Josh's side is more serious and moti is more chaotic
This is an ok mix but could be improved, but not a bad shot with more practices, this will be an incredible mix of the songs. Keep going, this is not easy to do especially with these songs and the chaotic nature.
POV: clover got cloned and they both died
I was curious how whould be the two together... Now I now that is terrible lol. But thanks to the remix, great work!
I prefer Joshs version but MOTI always makes good songs
I agree with this. Not to say MOTI's version is bad its pretty good, but I feel like Josh's lyrics are overall better, especially how he ties them into each of the themes of the specimens.
I prefer MOTI version cause it's better with the voice, only the lyrics that arent that good, not saying the other version is bad but i cant hear other song with flowey without the MOTI's flowey voice.
I like motis afterlife better but best friends forever goes to Josh along with specimen clay organic And patchwork… I do feel moti did get polygonal mechanical and paper better tho
opposite for me - i prefer MOTI's version but i still really like josh's version too
I’m convinced that you’re only saying that because all the wordplay and references are flying right over your head
I’d give this a 7/10 of a mashup. Perhaps at some parts of the Afterlife part of the mashup you should have alternated between Josh and MOTI. The Experiment parts were pretty well done though at the gray Flowey Parts I probably would have done Josh, Then 2 Specimen parts, Josh solo, 2 Specimen Parts, Josh and MOTI, Last 2 Specimen parts, and then ended with MOTI cause Man on the Internet only did 2 Gray Flowey Parts.
GENIUS
When guns blazing with lyrics MOTI and TCA's mashup?
two peaks combined
Clay and Organic and Best Friends Forever were pretty good. The rest was kinda rough
Is it weird that i can hear each one separately?
My Favorite PURE CHAOS!
CHAOS, CHAOS!
I CAN DO ANYTHING
1:33 to 1:53 sounds very good
Because one part is just repetition and the other is just lyricss
@@emanuel_616I mean both have repetition on their respective parts. Idk what’s the problem
This seems like something Flowey would do
At 8:53 the "No"s kind of overlap
I like that
Same with 10:22 i think
I really like this version!
For very neutral run you do flowey comes up with new lyrics
And i thought i made an accomplishment by stitching together your best nightmare the right way 😅
I was waiting for this
7:48 and why did you decide not to mix the sounds?
when I exported the file I only realized afterwards that I had accidentally muted that part
Can we instead of overlapping them, make like an extended version
I personally like Josh's more but MOTI is still very good
Me when I wake up and realize it’s Wednesday
why tf was moti's flowey's paper part cut out
@@sourdough_sy8008 because when I exported the video I forgot to unmute that part
@@Smug-Cat ah alr
IT'S KILL OR A BE KILLED!!!!
Undertale yellow two player
Esto es lo que necesitaba para vivir
Best Parts:
1 - 1:33 -1:53
2 - 9:25 - 9:41
I like the Drama Josh version more, like... actually I don't really like most of MOTI's lyrics video, I like when lyrics match up with the melody and moti kind of break that a lot... which I guess could just be how musical works? But it feels... weird, and things, like I like game music because it doesn't have lyrics, so it's just the melody, and the melody is nice, so when those are just kind of covered with more different notes lyrics it's kinda... (shrug emoticon)
Moti tries to make the lyrics add onto the song rather than just singing on rhythm with the main melody
I personally disagree. Don’t get me wrong, I usually like the lyrics being matched to the melody, but one, I can’t get behind Drama Josh’s voice for flowey, it sounds too normal while Alex Rybitski does a good job of friendly yet crazy, and two, I think not matching the melody perfectly makes sense for flowey. After all, he’s insane, why should he do the normal thing, especially since, I’m pretty sure Meta Flowey is all in Flowey’s mind
aint no way i made this exact vid for myself lol
Shall I see?
@@macncheesyfun4328 why? its the exact same lol
@@juno4823 well yeah. But the paper part got messed up in this one
@@macncheesyfun4328 gotta be honest im not done with it but if you want to see it i could go work on it
:D
@@juno4823 PLEASE DO
You should do this for Showdown!
Why in the comments there are so many people with bg yellow
WHERE IS MARLET MELTING
@@joeygosboo2647 it's wasn't in the original videos so 🤷
AAAAAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAA
+1+2=
You forgot MOTI's paper
when I exported the file I only realized afterwards that I had accidentally muted that part
@@Smug-Cat you can try reuploading unless you deleted the original file
@@Flowery0 I don't think I have it anymore so sadly no :(
@@Smug-Catwhoops