Col. Vladimir Trukhan: Ukraine’s Army Crumbling? Russia Prepares for a Shocking Turn of Events!

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 29 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 293

  • @ГалинаПопова-з5ш
    @ГалинаПопова-з5ш 8 годин тому +88

    Владимир Трухан- настоящий Полковник,патриот Родной Отчизны,ценю,горжусь им.❤.

  • @stas2711
    @stas2711 4 години тому +21

    Thank you, Nima, for an interview with a real military expert, an officer who actually served in the Operational Department of General Staff of the Russian Armed Forces. He provides the most concise and internally consistent overview of the Ukrainian conflict from the Russian military perspective. He is truly head and shoulders above any other "experts" and "analysts", both Russian and Western, and is in my opinion THE public authority for those who really want to understand why the Russian Army conducts the military operations the way it does.

  • @владимирглущенко-л6м
    @владимирглущенко-л6м 9 годин тому +141

    Gentlemen, I'm from Russia. The guy who gives this interview in Russia is considered a "real colonel"in Russia. You should know this, he is not only a high-class specialist, but also his friends are experienced officers. Then decide for yourself.

    • @somedumbozzie1539
      @somedumbozzie1539 8 годин тому +25

      He is calm measured and thoughtful, I know your military history and knew on the day they went in that Russia would prevail and the west would pay an unimaginable price for its hubris in the post war era.

    • @aneurindavies5943
      @aneurindavies5943 8 годин тому +24

      Its refreshing to be able to receive an Analysis from a Non Western Perspective delivered by a Professional former Russian Senior Military Officer (Retired).

    • @TeriBrown-li4ge
      @TeriBrown-li4ge 8 годин тому +16

      He’s great!

    • @Luke1959
      @Luke1959 6 годин тому +17

      ​@@somedumbozzie1539Agreed..... "chaos all around, he calmly sits, smoking a cigarette, analyzing the situation, planning on the next move!" No emotion, no hysteria, just calm and methodical! 👍💪🇷🇺🇨🇦

    • @iRelevant.47.system.boycott
      @iRelevant.47.system.boycott 6 годин тому +11

      Instant fan from when he lit up the first cigarette. Interesting analysis and thinking. Strategy regarding remaining Ukraine makes sense, was a little surprised that Odessa was not of critical strategic importance.

  • @BulBolcna
    @BulBolcna 5 годин тому +37

    Congratulations. Real Colonel and Real warrior.

  • @lenav544
    @lenav544 6 годин тому +33

    Wow Nima. What a guest! First hand facts and analysis without bs. The guy is a one of a kind personality as well. Thank you, totally enjoyed his dry humor and the whole experience

  • @kamaikg
    @kamaikg 6 годин тому +39

    Nima, thank you for having Colonel Truhan on! I try not to miss your videos every day, but today your video is special! Special thanks to the interpreter as well. I myself speak Russian fluently, and appreciate how much stress the interpreter was under.
    This interview is worth re-watching it.
    Thank you, gentlemen!!! Bravo!

  • @FinehomesofNewHampshire
    @FinehomesofNewHampshire 7 годин тому +34

    Amazing guest Nima. Phew! I so appreciate Colonel Truhkan. Thank you both.
    🇵🇸🇱🇧🇮🇷🇷🇺

  • @paulofz901
    @paulofz901 8 годин тому +55

    НАСТОЯЩИЙ ПОЛКОВНИК!
    Здоровья и сил,уважаемый Владимир Эдуардович

  • @garryhyare1659
    @garryhyare1659 3 години тому +7

    Hey Nima,
    I don’t comment often wanted to say thanks for having Col. Vladimir Trukhan. His insight and knowledge is the best when it comes to Russia vs nato conflict..He needs to be on your show often..
    One of your best guest thank you Nima..

  • @tedcash2834
    @tedcash2834 5 годин тому +26

    Holy smokes! This Colonel scares the heck out of me. Informative stream, thanks Nima for sharing this video. Peace for all 🙏

  • @martinriggs2330
    @martinriggs2330 5 годин тому +24

    Hi, everybody!
    one thing have to confirm, with a pleasure - a person who translated into/from russian/english, with all those special military words and termins, did a great job, a real professional, everything was done perfect))
    so, thanks a lot, to averyone who helped to organize this interesting interview!

  • @Luke1959
    @Luke1959 6 годин тому +50

    Kudos to your translator, Tim, I speak Russian and English, and this guy did a great job of translating the interview!! Good choice of guest, translator and questions from you! Thanks Nima 🎉🎉

    • @whocaresfornames
      @whocaresfornames 3 години тому +3

      Yeah, I'm bilinual, too. it's hard job going between languages in real time. The gentleman has done a great job 👍

  • @jackhamilton8362
    @jackhamilton8362 6 годин тому +42

    Great interview, thank you Dima. I'm an American who chose to make Odesa my home several years ago. It's a beautiful city and its always been considered a Russian city. I applaud the efforts of the Russian Federation to minimize damage to civilian areas and infrastructure. Ukraine needs to GO AWAY!

    • @lothlorien9068
      @lothlorien9068 Годину тому +1

      Stay safe. US citizenship does not protect you. Ukies got rid of Gonzalo Lira.

  • @j.dasilva4567
    @j.dasilva4567 9 годин тому +65

    Absolutely grand. Spasiba, Col.Trukan, obrigado, Nima.

  • @user-rn9nc7cc9e62
    @user-rn9nc7cc9e62 7 годин тому +39

    В. Трухан гениально владеет словом, смыслами. Гениальное изложение! Точное, краткое и в тоже время всеобъемлющее! Интеллект Трухана зашкаливает! Браво!

  • @MikeTzin-o7e
    @MikeTzin-o7e 4 години тому +31

    The difference between chest-beating arrogant American military and level-headed get the job done Russian mentality.

  • @jaromasar8404
    @jaromasar8404 7 годин тому +35

    You are best Nima, finally someone that knows what he talking about

  • @izagabriel6455
    @izagabriel6455 9 годин тому +66

    Oh my ...that was absolutely brilliant

  • @cullancrothers
    @cullancrothers 5 годин тому +20

    Nima, excellent guest speaker and an excellent summary of events! Russia is doing all the right things!

  • @anamariacambiaso5852
    @anamariacambiaso5852 4 години тому +16

    Amazing. The level of professionalism is admirable. To be studied in sections and with unlimited time. Much appreciated Mina. You gave us one of a kind of interview!!!!

  • @raachel271
    @raachel271 6 годин тому +19

    great show Nima..Col.Trukhan was a superb and informative guest...Thanks

  • @Mman.
    @Mman. 6 годин тому +26

    Thank you for having on Colonel Trukhan. It was a pleasure to hear his insights.🙏

  • @judithstapleton74
    @judithstapleton74 6 годин тому +25

    Brilliantly clear explanation of Russian military superiority, completely misunderstood by Lloyd Austin and hence, the entire NATO administrators, whose mission has always been delusional.

  • @jbunting3246
    @jbunting3246 9 годин тому +60

    Nima, thank you. Your show just keeps getting better and better. Kudos!

  • @Alisa-ci9sk
    @Alisa-ci9sk 5 годин тому +28

    Владимиру Трухана огромный ресспект👍👍👍👍👍

  • @LorimaRBG
    @LorimaRBG 8 годин тому +47

    Thanks for bringing to your audience Col. Vladimir Trukhan. I am chasing every interview with him because he is always up to the point and speacking stright forward !

  • @Sandsteine
    @Sandsteine 5 годин тому +25

    Vladimir truhan is exactly how i imagen a russian col.

  • @SergeM123
    @SergeM123 8 годин тому +39

    Special thanks to the interpreter!

    • @Mutineer9
      @Mutineer9 7 годин тому +5

      Yes, Translation is good.

  • @arthurcottrell4028
    @arthurcottrell4028 8 годин тому +52

    Great guest Nima! Strong dosee of reality..

  • @richardmarsden5610
    @richardmarsden5610 4 години тому +14

    Outstanding interview giving a real understanding and thorough insight of where we are... Translation style interview excellent and well suited the conveying of content understanding for non experts.

  • @ThereIsAlwaysaWay2
    @ThereIsAlwaysaWay2 9 годин тому +46

    A real, down to earth, military men. Zero bullshit where wishful thinking goes to die.

  • @JorgePerez-hc8sw
    @JorgePerez-hc8sw 4 години тому +30

    Уважаемый полковник молодец за такие слова, Вы настоящий русский солдат и патриот который реально понимает о чём идёт речь точно поставили точки где надо…спасибо за информацию

  • @bulldrumm
    @bulldrumm 3 години тому +14

    Iz Srbije : Слава России.
    Работаете братья.
    The last bulwark against insanity.
    Pukovnik Truhanov: Živ bio.

  • @paulwellman1030
    @paulwellman1030 9 годин тому +57

    A great look at how the US plays checkers while Russia plays chess.

  • @Dan-vu6en
    @Dan-vu6en 9 годин тому +37

    I've been watching this channel for ages - this may be the best show yet. Thanks Nima

  • @KedraSvet
    @KedraSvet Годину тому +9

    Настоящий полковник! Обожаю его юмор с крепким словом😊! Он умеет сложное объяснить простым языком. Военный ликбез на пять! Такие уроки с переводом на английский и другие языки необходимы! Пусть знают! А эта ссылка полетит в Австралию!

  • @gregorystrakovsky5193
    @gregorystrakovsky5193 8 годин тому +32

    Perfect interview... really enjoy it. As fluent Russian, Ukanan, Hebrew, Accadian and English speakers are pleased by the Colonel"'s military jargon ....

    • @Sandsteine
      @Sandsteine 7 годин тому +4

      The translation is not perfect

    • @kamaikg
      @kamaikg 6 годин тому +10

      @@SandsteineI agree, translation is not perfect. But the pressure to translate for international viewers is huge, so cut him some slack.

    • @iRelevant.47.system.boycott
      @iRelevant.47.system.boycott 5 годин тому +2

      @@Sandsteine Few things are.

  • @me3883
    @me3883 5 годин тому +13

    The interpreter did a great job! 👏 👍

  • @Marius_vanderLubbe
    @Marius_vanderLubbe 4 години тому +7

    This guest is all quality and worth the patience of translation.

  • @JayBoy-b3v
    @JayBoy-b3v 3 години тому +5

    I am suffering from extreme passive smoking just viewing this interview! I literally can smell the cigarette smoke in my living room. Excellent work. Regards, from Bonnie Scotland 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿.

  • @dinocosta9391freePal
    @dinocosta9391freePal 8 годин тому +22

    Excellent choice of guest Nima.

  • @natmazkiev
    @natmazkiev 9 годин тому +62

    Nima, you hit a homerun!!

    • @cfc1232
      @cfc1232 9 годин тому

      I think I know you🤔

  • @crimollo1
    @crimollo1 4 години тому +10

    wow! Vladimir is a star! ❤

  • @fatahsediqui8176
    @fatahsediqui8176 9 годин тому +26

    How nice the Col. is analaysis the situation in its real sense.

  • @jubi3137
    @jubi3137 5 годин тому +13

    Legend !!

  • @redtru
    @redtru 9 годин тому +59

    finally bigger western audience has possibility listen to simple Russian Colonel Truhan. Btw this is friend A.Martyanov is often mentioning

    • @paulwhetstone0473
      @paulwhetstone0473 7 годин тому +6

      It’s not surprising that the colonel is friends with Martyanov. They both enjoy trolling their opponents.

  • @ЕленаЕлена-я2р9и
    @ЕленаЕлена-я2р9и 5 годин тому +16

    Трухан великолепен❤

  • @saikyomogresurrect
    @saikyomogresurrect 5 годин тому +13

    Nima, this interview was CLASS. Obrigada my man🎉

  • @ΚατερίναΚαραγεώργη-δ6λ

    Very interesting interview!! Different and refreshing! 👌🏼Thank you! 🙂

  • @matthewreohorn3585
    @matthewreohorn3585 9 годин тому +26

    Very interesting 👍 And straightforward..Powerful , Good stuff Nima .ATB.

  • @jonarebergheim7958
    @jonarebergheim7958 8 годин тому +16

    Thank you for your good work

  • @tomanderson2023
    @tomanderson2023 8 годин тому +17

    Nima, thank you for allowing your guests to speak and say their say. I always look forward to interviews on your channel.

    • @iRelevant.47.system.boycott
      @iRelevant.47.system.boycott 5 годин тому +3

      Was a highlight when Col at the 1 hour mark as response to Nima's first question, said something to the effect of : Sorry for going on for so long, but it can not be said in few words :)

  • @t.c.s.7724
    @t.c.s.7724 7 годин тому +18

    Great discussion
    .we desperately needed to hear from.more Russian perspectives
    Thank you, gentlemen.

  • @epicmedia179
    @epicmedia179 7 годин тому +18

    awesome talk and guest!

  • @nizar5191
    @nizar5191 2 години тому +5

    Very High quality guest ❤❤❤ спасибо из Туниса

  • @jameskelman9856
    @jameskelman9856 2 години тому +5

    Dialouge Works produces a high calibre of experienced and intellectual guests . RESPECT
    Dialouge , Diplomacy and Trade bring Peace , Prosperity and Stability .
    Viva Russia 🇷🇺
    Viva BRICS
    Viva World Trade
    Support from Canada 🇨🇦

  • @whocaresfornames
    @whocaresfornames 3 години тому +3

    Thanks Nima for the great guest. The colonel gave a good overview of the SMO. Thanks again

  • @julianss3289
    @julianss3289 4 години тому +9

    Amazing guest!

  • @wayneclark59
    @wayneclark59 3 години тому +7

    Hard to dismiss. An incredible amount of detail. Thank you.

  • @maijadergunova7911
    @maijadergunova7911 8 годин тому +11

    Thank you for this guest Nima ❤

  • @crimollo1
    @crimollo1 3 години тому +4

    One short question and 62-minute response. Magic!

  • @judithstapleton74
    @judithstapleton74 5 годин тому +8

    Thanks a million, Colonel!

  • @hilarysimpson3725
    @hilarysimpson3725 7 годин тому +16

    Trump should listen to this. A dose of reality.

  • @apriliaric
    @apriliaric 8 годин тому +19

    Fantastic episode.....thank you x

  • @BorisLeontyev
    @BorisLeontyev 8 годин тому +23

    Боялся, что будет плохо, а получается хорошо. Без слюней, соплёй, по делу. Чётко, прямо, понятно.

  • @Ольга-ц9з3х
    @Ольга-ц9з3х 5 годин тому +8

    Nima, thank you!

  • @vloskutov29
    @vloskutov29 Годину тому +5

    Браво, Владимир Здуардович! Ох и взгляд у Вас😂 - Мудрый Каа и ....

  • @JaneRevne-ds1py
    @JaneRevne-ds1py 2 години тому +6

    Fantastic episode, Nima! Thank you! ❤

  • @ThePeterMann
    @ThePeterMann 3 години тому +4

    Great interview, a "real" russian military expert talking military science. Thanks, very informative.

  • @nosratalamdari4285
    @nosratalamdari4285 9 годин тому +15

    Thank you

  • @p.pingtam7253
    @p.pingtam7253 9 годин тому +47

    These guys are all serious as a jab seizure, clearly. What on earth was the US/NATO thinking in taking on the Russia Army on their OWN frikkin turf.
    The mind boggles.
    (meeeaaoww~)

    • @timgibson3754
      @timgibson3754 9 годин тому +9

      Yep and in their world Ukraine is still winning

    • @sislater6334
      @sislater6334 8 годин тому +8

      Exactly WTF is going on in their heads

    • @aneurindavies5943
      @aneurindavies5943 8 годин тому +8

      They were advised by Washington DC they had the Intelligence, and superior Military resources in the form of NATO and the US-UK Axis Alliance Know-how, and Hubris!

    • @vladdyvansavage8760
      @vladdyvansavage8760 7 годин тому +5

      Theres no jab against delusion & stupidity

    • @Mman.
      @Mman. 6 годин тому +4

      Biggest geopolitical miscalculation in living memory. The SMO has changed the world, permanently.

  • @Николай-с4р3ш
    @Николай-с4р3ш 7 годин тому +17

    Quite surprising.Follow him on russian channels for some years.He is a friend of A.Martyanov,it says a lot.

  • @Saumie
    @Saumie 9 годин тому +22

    I'm an Investigator and I love when I need to use a translator. It forces questions and responses to be well thought out. Also it gives the respondant time to think instead of just speaking off the cuff.

    • @Super121262
      @Super121262 Годину тому

      Респонденту не надо время подумать. Просто переводчик не смог бы досконально все перевести. Трухан человек своего дела, ему не надо время подумать, профессионал с большой буквы

  • @nevillefinlay7538
    @nevillefinlay7538 4 години тому +5

    Wow love the Col.

  • @Theworldaccordingtomickey
    @Theworldaccordingtomickey 8 годин тому +23

    My man sitting there with his cigarette, spitting cold hard words. Love it.

  • @buildingmyfuture6260
    @buildingmyfuture6260 8 годин тому +23

    Спосибо❤🇷🇺♥️🇷🇺

  • @Rob060870
    @Rob060870 7 годин тому +8

    Excellent guest, great channel, thanks👍

  • @ЮлияСеливанова-д6й
    @ЮлияСеливанова-д6й 9 годин тому +15

    Well, you give it! Cool! Truhan!!!1

  • @peteromisore8607
    @peteromisore8607 6 годин тому +5

    Its always a pleasure listening to col. Trukhan

  • @ElizabethJOHNSON-ms3qj
    @ElizabethJOHNSON-ms3qj 8 годин тому +11

    Thank you for informing us

  • @sislater6334
    @sislater6334 8 годин тому +13

    Immensely interesting thank you for making this available, agree with all points made.

  • @dang-ne2yl
    @dang-ne2yl 7 годин тому +7

    Great interview!!

  • @gregorystrakovsky5193
    @gregorystrakovsky5193 8 годин тому +21

    Thank You Nima.... Translations are a bit softening a real attitude. Some words and meaning are much deeper than it sounds in the English.

    • @Theworldaccordingtomickey
      @Theworldaccordingtomickey 7 годин тому +9

      I can see clearly from the colonel's demeanor that the translation has been softened. He strikes me as a straight, no nonsense talker without worrying about political correctness, just facts as he sees them.

    • @fedorevdokimenko3978
      @fedorevdokimenko3978 7 годин тому +5

      I think translator has the problems with understanding or translating military terminology to english. He oversimplified many things, some times with the lose of the meaning.

    • @gregorystrakovsky5193
      @gregorystrakovsky5193 6 годин тому +5

      @@fedorevdokimenko3978 some times it's not even a lack of specifics knowledge or familiarity with terminology. You need long time experience on the field in the different countries... Talking and understanding... meaning, life and overall background, history etc. Logistics a mirror of The History of Humanity.

  • @BAROTIKI
    @BAROTIKI 7 годин тому +7

    Col. Trukhan, Hello!
    🇷🇺 Россия Мощь❗️

  • @martintramil8084
    @martintramil8084 8 годин тому +10

    the Col. burning a heater during the interview🔥🤟💯

  • @barneygoogle4003
    @barneygoogle4003 8 годин тому +8

    Very informative and enlightening presentation.

  • @ElizabethJOHNSON-ms3qj
    @ElizabethJOHNSON-ms3qj 8 годин тому +16

    Awesome

  • @billshockleyiii2288
    @billshockleyiii2288 3 години тому +4

    Nima, I cannot thank you enough. Eye wide open
    Bill

  • @buildingmyfuture6260
    @buildingmyfuture6260 8 годин тому +57

    I am Russian, living in Panama. People always ask me why Russia is so slow. So, now I can send them this video or explain briefly and correctly using this information ♥️♥️♥️♥️🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺😃

    • @aneurindavies5943
      @aneurindavies5943 8 годин тому +25

      An old saying is "The Russians are Slow to Saddle, but Quick to Ride" - "The Most Powerful Warriors are Time and Patience" Leo Tolstoy, Russian Author of War and Peace.

    • @caveman1334
      @caveman1334 3 години тому +2

      ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤😂🍺🍺🍺🍺🍺

    • @heimomoilanen9654
      @heimomoilanen9654 2 години тому

      ​@@aneurindavies5943Brilliant analogy. As seen since February 2022.

    • @genemiller6805
      @genemiller6805 Годину тому

      Если Вы русский, то напомню Вам старый анекдот. Спускаются с пригорка опытный бык и молодой бычок. Внизу видят-пасётся стадо коров. Молодой говорит: "Давай быстро побежим и поимеем вон ту тёлочку". На что старший ему отвечает: "Нет мы сейчас медленно спустимся и поимеем всё стадо".

  • @nhamosamasuwo3551
    @nhamosamasuwo3551 2 години тому +1

    Thank you Colonel

  • @nevillefinlay7538
    @nevillefinlay7538 5 годин тому +6

    Great guest,the Col seen him before with Scott Ritter,very smart and knows the art of modern war,love his coffee mug Z.he likes to smoke,Col slow down on that.

  • @TrueRandomization
    @TrueRandomization 44 хвилини тому +1

    Amazing Guest!!!

  • @annaweiers2947
    @annaweiers2947 5 годин тому +6

    Brilliant Nima!

  • @aelous
    @aelous 3 години тому +2

    Thank you. great insight and perspective

  • @TrueRandomization
    @TrueRandomization 38 хвилин тому +1

    What a GREAT show!!!

  • @maksimluzin1121
    @maksimluzin1121 Годину тому +4

    The Real Russian (ex-USSR) Colonel.
    By the way, if you don't know, he has a Degree (Professor) in the Psychology Science... Military, and not only...😉

  • @buildingmyfuture6260
    @buildingmyfuture6260 8 годин тому +10

    Excellent ‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️♥️♥️♥️♥️

  • @leonidashristou9111
    @leonidashristou9111 2 години тому +3

    From the 60th minute...the logic is ...logical! Smart Russian officer! Realist!

  • @CadreSnob
    @CadreSnob 6 годин тому +5

    Victory will be ours

  • @user-rp2li7ks4e
    @user-rp2li7ks4e 6 годин тому +4

    A true perspective!! 🎯🎯🎯