Voice Teacher Reacts to Red Velvet - Goodbye | 레드벨벳 - 안녕 [Immortal Songs 2]
Вставка
- Опубліковано 26 вер 2024
- Voice teacher Sam Johnson's reaction to Red Velvet singing Goodbye on Immortal Songs 2.
I hope this observation on how they sing helps you figure out how the voice works better, so you can learn how to make smart choices in your own voice.
Go to www.vocalease.net to sign up for lessons with Sam through video chat!
Buy a titanium straw (for vocalizing and the environment): amzn.to/2wwCFNz
Produce electronic music intuitively: amzn.to/2PqnjRx
Buy my watch: amzn.to/2PnAZNi
Social Media:
/ oksamjohnson
This description contains affiliate links.
"a very pleasant sound" is going to be how i describe red velvet to people now
I would go "I prefer this 100% at a time."
💖
This really needs to be said: thank you for pausing the video when you talk. It's annoying when reactors talk over the music because we can't hear what they're saying, but also they miss like half of the song while they're talking abut some 2 sec thing that happened...
exactly
But it's even more annoying when they stop the video to say something totally unimportant. I like this teacher because whenever he stops the video he has something interesting to say
Omg preach!! Like or when they are ranting or dying at some point and they miss such an iconic note or sound bc of it :/
cuz he's a teacher, he know what to do to judge them :]
Ikr?? Then those kind of reactors end up missing the best parts coz they're so chatty. This was an awesome reaction.
Red velvet one of these nights live
Sketchbook Version!!!!!
god i love that song!!! most underrated rv song tbh
Kacovski shows off their vocals in such a nice way :)
ONE OF THE MOST BEAUTIFUL SONGS OF RV YET IT'S SO UNDERRATED :( The song is so good and show their vocals off. Please react to the song (one of these nights) live. Thank you, Sam.
Aireona McNair YES!!! omg i would LOVE to see his reaction to OOTN sketchbook version omg!
Heyyy small fact about Wendy, the girl on the right, is that she has vocal nodules and I was super amazed when you were mentioning how she uses her head voice to make that sound instead of her chest voice. His vocal trainer from way back when she was still a trainee said that she had trained wendy to use her head voice for a variety of notes due to her vocal nodules. Super cool that you were able to pick that up
She used to have vocal nodules. She had it when they debuted. Not anymore
@@Celna525 Yes. But having vocal nodules affects their vocal range even after it healed.
what's vocal nodules?
@@coltv319 It's growth on your vocal cord after overusing them, or using them wrong.
@@Celna525 Thank you for the explanation
The first girl is actually their best vocalist. Her name is Wendy. :) She also participated on Masked Singer. She sang Late Regret.
I think by the end of the video he must get that Wendy is the best singer out of the three and if he were to rewatch would agree Wendy's opening was a stylistic choice and not because she couldnt sing less breathier.
@yummiwatch stability don't define who's a better singer
@yummiwatch but nevertheless, Seulgi and Wendy are both Great Singers.
@yummiwatch factor in live performances but not in singing in proper technique. Seulgi is stable and have great technique tho. and wendy aswell. Both are great singers!
@yummiwatch
It's blatantly obvious that Wendy's the best singer in Red Velvet, followed by Seulgi and then Joy.
Wendy's the main vocal for a reason.
i like how he smiles whenever Wendy hits those notes 😭😭 thank you for this reaction, these three girls did an amazing job :D
wendy is the best vocalist on rv
dimitra sk. Yes she is, but Seulgi and Joy are definitely not far behind.
dimitra sk. Wait I just responded to ur other comment wtf
Red Velvet has one of the best vocal lines in this generation of kpop, actually all members of Red Velvet can sing very well !! Wendy (the first girl that started)is considered one of the best main female vocalist of this generation as well. It's just really sad that people rarely recognise their talent in singing and they are often only seen as the girl group that got famous because of their company. Red Velvet is incredibly talented in singing and dancing AND WE CAN'T FORGET ABOUT THEIR CONCEPTS. They strive to break the stereotype of "female groups only does one concepts" and has succeeded multiple times. I hope you check out more stuff from them !!
Agree
Yep Wendy is indeed one of the best main female vocalist of this generation. Her technique really stands out from other! After Wendy I would say Eunji, Solar, Wheein, Yuju, Solji,...
YES EATS Honestly, I feel like this just applies to all SM groups. They are trained so well vocally.
Agree, SM wins when it comes to vocals
Um, I'm sorry. I like RV, but let's not tell lies here. Yeri and Irene, as far as singing goes... issa no from me.
Tbh, Wendy (the girl with blonde hair) is their main vocalist aka their best vocalist in RV and actually one of the best female vocalists in their new generation among kpop groups. A lot of people in kpop fandom community and also music critics acknowledged her outstanding vocal talent. I couldn't deny that Red Velvet's vocals line (Wendy, Seulgi, Joy) is one of the best among kpop ggs in this new generation along with Mamamoo etc.
MamaVelvet
mamavelvet gay queens
Honestly. The girl in the midle is a MAIN DANCER of the grub but her vocal is really amazing..
Just one of them as MAIN VOCAL.. Her name is Wendy, the girl with blonde hair.
Seulgi was used train for main Vocal until her had problem with vocal folds, she could hardly sing at that time. She had treatment but she thought herself would not be able to sing like before,and She thought she could never get debuted. So she decided to train so hard to be great dancer so at least she could get debut. She trained herself so hard even BoA and other senior idols knew her and her dancer skill. Then she debuted as Main Dancer and luckily after treatment her problem with vocal folds is gone so that made Seulgi is Main Dancer but also can sing like Vocalist.
@@yuiahei8525 can you give me the link or any source that she said or anyone said that she used to train to be a main vocalist? Because I only know the part when she had a problem on her vocal folds.
blackvelvet Seulgi have mentioned it on the show “Idol Drama Operation Team”. A show in which they’ve written a drama according to their real life experiences. Even Moonbyul of mamamoo opened up that she was supposed to be a vocalist.
@@qyojin6842 do you know what ep?
They come from SM Entertainment, same agency with EXO.
I hope you can reacts all of SM Ent. Artist. Their Vocal is no joke.
So many SM Artist multi talented.
Please, react EXO CBX - Diamond Chrystal or EXO CBX - Cry
prapti pratiwi i'm no sm stan, but i do believe sm gives the best vocal training and it reflects in their artists!
Definitely Cry, it’s like my favorite song ever???
Yess i especially recommend Taeyeon and Luna.
@@elizabethlililee9755 yes.. cry and diamond chrystal..
@@ubiquitous_star584 yes.. all of SM vocalist is really amazing..
Their dancer and rapper can sing very well too..
It's because SM trainee system is really hard...
Just proving that Red Velvet are the vocal Queens we know and love.
And this is after Seulgi (the one in the middle) struggled for years over her belief in her singing ability.
Thank you - love watching your analysis.
In my opinion Red Velvet is one of the best groups when it comes to harmonizing . Their voice are unique but they sound so well when they blend together!
Wendy is vocal queen in her generation 👸👌
OMG i was watching all of your reactions today and we can say that i was literally addicted 😅 Now seeing that you reacted to my favorite girl group makes me happy and i feel even happier that you enjoyed it 👀 thank you for making this video!!
Same! He looked really happy watching them! His smile is cute :]
I don't usually ask for reactions but you should check out AKMU, I want to hear someone talk about the girl's voice.
honestly suhyun never really ventures out to try different registers, so that's why she barely improved over the years. she could really improve but... idk it's all up to her
Maybe it has something to do with her voice training? Considering she's under an entertainment company that most likely has her taking vocal lessons (of some sort I guess coz it's YG).
I remember a cover she did where she tried to sing something I had never heard of her before and she couldn't handle it.
Exactly
yeah! chanhyuk's voice is really nice too
Especially Dinosaur, those notes
Aw I wish Joy would watch this and gain her confidence in singing back
I love it when you said the clearest of the three during Joy's part (the one in black) because her voice and the way she pronounce all the words whenever she sings is really referred by all the fans (or not) as clear. And yes, Wendy is ♥
You know who to react SM VOCALIST are some of the best Vocalist in the Kpop Industry cause they focus training their vocals :Exo Red Velvet Girls Generation F(x) TVQX have all of them a good vocal line like Chen, Taeyeon, Wendy, Seulgi Etc
you know what's funny? when most of their sub vocals and sometimes even rappers have really good crazy techniques and skills. i admit some of their vocals don't really appeal to the general public or as 'delicious' but you really gotta admit they have great training (all hail sm vocal trainers). i'm pressed, why are they all so good.
special mentions: heechul, chanyeol, taemin - the hidden vocals
and SHINee :D
you forgot nct too! but i agree with you :)
Yeah all of the groups related to SM they are good Vocalist, and their sub vocalist are even better than any other main vocal of some groups!
@@467loveu Chanyeol is so good Heechul is a Beast, Yeri unique voice is good also but she did not get enough spotlight, Red Velvet in general have unique voices but they blend so well together that it scare me
One thing i noticed everytime vocal coach reacting to red velvet, when wendy started singing there will be a sudden smile on vocal coach's face😂
Yeah she is that amazing😭
omg i actually freaked out when i saw you reacted to this. red velvet is my fav group and im happy to hear all of your good comments on their singing.
this isnt all of red velvet, just their vocal line... which is like one of the best vocal lines for kpop girl groups. wendy, the girl on the right who was also the high harmony, is like one of the best main vocalists in the kpop industry.
Red velvet has the best vocal
Peachy Tae um Mamamoo have the best vocals of third gen groups.
@@harliemontez4488 yeah sure 😉
reveluvl 154 I’m not even a hardcore moo moo but I watched their immortal songs performances and they are literally vocal fire. Mamamoo top RV in vocals just saying. All the members have very good voices 🤷🏻♀️
@@harliemontez4488 nah rv are better and more unique vocally especially the vocal line
nn mw no they’re not. from a technique standpoint or vocal range standpoint. the only one who will maybe be better is Wendy. Call me when anyone in rv can whistle tone and hit those low notes like Hwasa. Or who can go up into their falsetto effortlessly like Wheein. And her high notes? So much power and ease. Solar, she does struggle sometimes but her range is amazing. And even Moonbyul can sing. Let me know when rv’s rap line can sing like that. They can’t. Simple.
Watch their immortal song preformances . There is even one where Wendy and Joy were even in AWE with Mamamoo’s vocal.
You can’t say rv are better for the sake of it. Lol. Give me proof.
So I just binge-watched almost all of your videos and there you go uploading a new one again lol. I hope you're not overwhelmed by all the Kpop requests btw, even though I love those reactions from you the most, because you sound like the most genuine. Oh and I like it when you smile, because the singer hit the right note or is singing really well, like you're happy because they bringing out their potential haha :)
I agree. I was worried about the request once someone reacts to anything kpop
Please react to Red Velvet Wendy singing Halo. She's the main vocalist and she sang the song before she was in Red Velvet.
or Wendy singing Shallow !
The girl in the middle (Seulgi) is multi talented. Not only is she the lead vocalist of Red Velvet but she is also the main dancer of the group, and its rare to find main dancers of girl groups having the same vocal abilities as her.
wendy (the first girl who sung) has one of the widest ranges in kpop!! she has a 4 octave vocal range and the whole of red velvets vocal line is just insanely good and tends to be overlooked, their harmonising abilities and differences in tone makes their voices blend so beautifully
I just loved it.... I actually have never seen this video before, and I just loved all of it.... amazing... Red Velvet is an awesome group... and it was really good to see you reacting to it
Thank you for your explanation, now I know a bit more about vocal. SM entertainment is one of the company that has the best vocals in the industry ( TVXQ's Changmin, SNSD 's Taeyeon, Exo 's Chen, Baekhuyn, D.O, Red Velvet's Wendy, Seulgi, Shinee 's Onew, Jonghuyn, Super junior 's Kyuhuyn, Yesung, Ryeowook, f(x)'Luna ) . That's why I love SM 's artist so much because I think as a singer it's very important that you have some vocal knowledge, it's just show that you are determined to your job as a singer, you care for your voice, you care how it sounds and you protect it.
If you have time please react to Red Velvet 's Wendy " Late Regret", Red Velvet's Wendy & Huh Gak "Happy Me", Exo 's D.O " Best Vocal", Taeyeon " Live Vocal Range".
Thanks again for your reaction.
I mean, I agree, but speaking of SM artists why is everyone acting like Shinee and Super Junior KRY vocal line don't exist 😂😂😂😂
why did u forget shinee and suju
You forgot [former] TVXQ Kim Jaejoong & Kim Junsu (former SM artists but always worth mentioning); CSJH Lina (SM's best female vocalist so far);SNSD Seohyun; SHINee Jonghyun, Onew and Taemin; and f(x) Luna. And yes, SM is KPop's vocal powerhouse. Their roster of artists is amazing.
Ezee Flores Was about to ask if Lina was still in top condition since i havent heard her in a while but found this and got my answer ua-cam.com/video/H_DqG5xhBvg/v-deo.html Man I love SM vocalists
Oops !!! Sorry .....I know SM has many amazing talented vocals cause Iam a SM stans since 2009( I stan all SM groups not just specific groups I mentioned above, it just that I typed that comments so fast that I miscount Shinee and Super Junior. Sorry again..... Let me edit the comment.
WenSeulJoy are the vocal line in RV. He pinpointed their voices perfectly. Their harmonies are always sultry in sound and purposefully placed. 😍😍😍
Thanks for reacting to Red Velvet, they are extremely talented and their vocal line is no joke. Wendy is actually my ultimate bias and she's the best female vocalist of this generation among girlgroups 💙
I agree!
When she first started singing I don't think he knew all Wendy could do, but later he was like now she's proving she can do it. I'm like dude, you don't even know all Wendy can do 😂😂😂
Wendy, Seulgi and joy are amazing vocalists Wendy has the best power Seulgi has the best sound joy has the best clarity their all amazing
To think that a few days ago a large number of people were saying that these girls can't sing...
Its nice to see an individual who actually knows what they are talking about in the field of singing. Great job of you to put out all of these reactions, it brings new perspectives.
Those people are on crack! Red Velvet's vocal line is one of the best in Kpop, especially Wendy!
I’ve been waiting for a red velvet reaction yesssss 😭
So going left to right these are the members
Joy- she’s just a regular vocalist in the group along with being a rapper
Seulgi- she’s the lead vocalist, although her vocals are amazing!!!! She’s mostly known for her dance skills in the group
Wendy- she’s the main vocalist and she’s know for her power vocals and knowing how to play a lot of instruments
I’m glad to see this reaction/lesson because I saw the vocal teacher of this group saying that Wendy (the first girl who début the song placed on the far right) had nodules for pushing her voice too much and too hard when she was a trainee wanting to debut ASAP.
So her vocal coach told her to use more of her headvoice for now on and now watching your explanation I totally understand the process and the results !
Thanks it’s very interesting
Thank you so much for this video. You rarely see dedicated kpop reaction channels do this video, much less professionals so this was a treat. Wendy, the girl on the right, actually has a history of both doing choir stuff during highschool, and has had treatment for vocal cord nodules around the beginning of her pop career around a year prior to the performance you reviewed. I'm really impressed with how you can point out her choices and how easily they map to her past.
I’m so proud of these girlies!!! Red velvet’s vocal line is one of the best in kpop industry. Thank you for reacting to them sam, your reaction is always high quality with all the explanation while you pause the video ❤️
the way he look wendy and reacts is so diamond. I mean he kind look proud you know like a teacher look at his student trought the struggle and give this achievment.
At first I thought he was sleeping on Wendy's vocals, but by the end of the video, he seemed to see how versatile her vocals are and how big her range is.
OMG I am soooo happy that you reacted to this video 😊😊😊😊 I am a huge fan of Red Velvet, my favorite one is Joy(the girl with the clearest voice), and I had been wanting to request for you to watch this video but I was too shy... Anyways I was beyond happy and grateful you reacted to this video and liked the song :) Thank You!!! Please listen to BTOB, they are an amazing group❤❤❤
another interesting reaction. Today I learned about harmonies haha. Wendy is really amazing.
joy is such an underrated vocalist😍
I love that he admired her vocal techniques.
I love Red Velvet's Goodbye, always gives me chills no matter how many times I see it. Vocals that touch your heart
This is why I stan red velvet, they have two sides which shows their vesatility and sings live very well! I think SM should create a sub unit with Wendy Seulgi and Joy! Those three have different voices which is when combined produces a very harmonious melody and just perfect! Thank you for your wonderful observation
You could say wendy is the best vocalist of kpop 3rd gen especially technical wise. Even red velvet is also one of the best group vocally but maybe mamamoo is better as a group. Well just search for more wendy cover if you want to know more. I always love her voice, she never go overboard with the high notes and sings comfortably :)
Thank you so much for making a realistic reaction! Most other voice coaches don’t go into so much technical stuff which is what I actually want to watch...
SM's idol vocals are the best in this generation.
Hope u do SM's
I died (of happiness) a little inside when he praised Joy :')
I've heared Red Velvet a lot but with their dancing songs. I've heared Wendy doing ballads but this is the first time I've heared Joy and Seulgi. And wow!! I missed this great side of them. Need to catch up.
Thanks Sam for letting me hear this.
Red Velvet: Real Vocals, Ruling Visuals and Right Versatility ❤💛💙💚💜 Queens indeed!
Wendy (the blonde one) is actually known for her crystal clear voice but she's also known for her agility and ease in switching between registers and styles. She usually uses her head voice (check out her Halo cover) too but she lessened it once she became a member of RV because their songs are kinda restricting her ability and style. I hope you also do her "Late Regret" from King of Masked Singer too!! (And also her duet with Huh Gak called "Happy Me"). Her voice is so soulful, I swear you'd enjoy every performance of her.
If you're looking for great singers in the k-pop industry check BTOB out as they're known as one of the best vocal groups in South Korea. For example their performance of "To my love" on Immortal songs gives a pretty clear view of their talent
Yes for me they’re one of the best active boy groups for vocals
I agree btob is the best group when it comes to singing ability
i really love hearing your breakdown of their vocal technique. hearing it from a teacher really feels like it gives more credit to the kpop community, proving that they are indeed trained singers (cuz people like to pretend they're not)
Red Velvet killed it in immortal songs!!
I also highly recommend more Mamamoo Immortal Songs as well :)
Wendy❤️ Love you❤️
Red Velvet equal real vocals❤
This 3 is the Best Singers of the Red Velvet ... wendy (right side) , Seulgi (Seulgi), Joy (Left Side). Listening to this Songs Gives me Goosebumps... Weow.. The Best.
You have no idea how long I've waited for a reaction like this for this performance!! Thank you so much for sharing your knowledge on my girls! Wendy (the girl on the right) is my fav and her vocals are just out of this world!
You know what, you are the first voice teacher I've ever watched on UA-cam, and you're very informative and honest. I tried watching other vocal coaches after stumbling upon your channel, but it's not as fun as watching/listening to you. Thank you!
By the way, Red Velvet is my fav K-pop group, and the first girl on the left is my fav member. She sounds like honey to me. And if you notice, these 3 girls (the vocal line of the group) have their own really distinctive voice color which makes the group really interesting to listen to.
can you please react to Kangta, Wendy and seulgi singing DOLL
YES PLEASE
Yes!! Wendy was pretty sick but still did an amazing job!
I really love that these 'reactions' also help us learn how to sing better. You commend my girl Wendy for doing right by her voice, at the same time, I learn something new.
That was the first time in a long time that a singer has given me chills. Wendy is amazing.
React to Jonghyun & Onew(SHINee)-Please don't Go
Ana Caroline beautiful song😭♥️
Ana Caroline tres plss
yeees please
That moment when Seulgi is a main dancer and can sing like this... legends only
Love that you react to my Queens RedVelvet as well! My ultimate bias groups are EXO and RedVelvet!
Thanks Sam! Red Velvet are my favourite group, thanks for another awesome video.
If you want to react to Red Velvet again, they released Psycho on december 23 and it's still charting in korea and some international sites, they have performed it live just a few times because, unfortunely, Wendy got injured on a music show =/ but their entire 2019 trilogy was amazing, it's called The Reve Festival (day 1, day 2 and finale)
Wendy has the widest range among her members, maybe among all kpop idols. 4 octaves.
And I think some people claim she has a tessitura of a soprano.
I'm not sure if the term is right, but that's what I read.
Yeah she's a soprano. A light lyric
Hey Sam, I hope you can react with Wendy's performance (the girl on the right side) in The King of Mask Singer. She performed as the green witch btw.
Owhhh yeaahhh SM always have trio vocalist on the group, after GIrls Generation-TTS (Taeyeon, Tiffany, Seohyun) and now I hope they (Seulgi, Wendy, Joy) will have Subunit too
Thank you!!!❤️😆
Please react to any Jonghyun live performance!! He’s really good at singing!!💓
Agreed! Even a compilation video of his best performances would be great!
Yeah you’re right❤️
Yes, you should check out this 💕
React to Red Velvet's Wendy Last Love
Red velvet so beautiful voice 😍.Your reaction video so best :)
Their main and lead vocal really got me😍😍😍
Just coming back here cause quarantine is killing me
I suggest you react also to Red Velvet "One of these nights" "Candy" "Seulgi's and Wendy's king of masked singer"
Now this is red velvet.
Sam I have an important question, what toothpaste do you use?
For educational purposes??😂
yes for groundbreaking scientific research 😂😂😂
@@anbar 😂😂😂😂
I use my old ass colgate with a strong mint taste. My mouth burns when I use it and I still don't have teeth as perfect as Sam.
I wanted to ask the same thing as you but i hold myself back😹😹✋✋
Sam,
I just discovered you last night when you were reacting to Ignacio Boschetto, one of Il Volo’s singers. I have been going to bed every night for seven years listening to them and Ignacio’s name got my attention.
In 24 hours I have watched several of your videos and subscribed. It’s refreshing to see your smiles, nods, positive comments, and helpful to hear your suggestions. Even I, a non-singer, now believe maybe I could sing.
Sm idols are well trained, I bit I said that million times but truly no one compete them, thanks for reacting to our girls❤ please react to" exo chen stained "❤❤ ❤❤❤
This was 3 years ago, a year after they debuted. Now, they are so much better.
It was my first time watching your kpop reaction last night and I enjoyed it. And now.. you reacted to my fave kpop girl group!! And your reaction was soooo positive. Thank you from all Luvies!!! 💛💚❤💙💜
Real Vocals
Real Visuals
Red Velvet
Red Velvet's vocals is not a joke
I'd really like to thank u for reacting to this wonderful live performance, which not many reactors react to normally!
Please react for seulgi wendy and kangta "Doll" on everysing
Thank you for granting my request to react to my Queens vocals ❤
The first girl, Wendy, had vocal cord nodules and that's why now she uses a head voice a lot more
Yeah Red Velvet is an amazing vocal group for sure! I suggest you to watch Akdong Musician's live performances because they are GREAT too!
i've been binge watching your reactions recently and i gotta say, i think i found my new favourite reactor ❤️
thank you so much for reacting to my favorite group!! it's so interesting to hear an unbiased professional's opinion :)
Omg thanks for reacting to red velvet! I love your reaction and I actually learn a lot and enjoy the way you explains everything especially since this is my favourite so thank you :)
Thank you for talking about my biases! I love Red Velvet and people really do think they get attention because they’re from SM, but they’re really talented vocalists. Nice work!
Please watch them on masked singer 😀
All three of them also appeared in there
Wendy is really one of the best vocalist in KPOP thank you for acknowledging her talent
You should react to Sunyoul singing Tears in Masked singer, he is a guy but erveryone thought he was a woman because of his voice. After he revealed himself everyone was so shook that they at first didnt believe him that he was a guy and so he had to show his pass lol. It was the biggest plot twist of all time on that show
I like how you actually analyze and state how they sing certain parts and what technique they use with their voice. Honestly love your videos. You don't just watch and say I like this and that, you actually say the technical kind of stuff.
Woah. I didn't know seulgi can sing 😱😱😱😱👏👏👏👏
I really love your teachings/reactions anyways 💛
@yummiwatch that opinion is unpopular because technically wendy is the best female vocalist of this generation among girlgroups, seulgi is amazing and she can easily be the main vocalist of other girlgroup, but she's not as good as wendy
@@smallwan7
I agree. Wendy's on another level imo. Seulgi is good, but she still has some room for improvement.
@yummiwatch
Seulgi is really good, but not close to being better than Wendy.
@Zoey Striker
I find Wendy more stable and has better control of her vocals even when she's not stable.
When Seulgi becomes unstable her voice shrill and becomes too nasal.
How dare you
love his honest reactions and reviews, he really know who to react to and not just by the hype.
Wenjoygi best vocalists 😍
I like how you smile on parts THAT REALLY MAKES ME SMILE
Just wanted to tell you that the members of EXO, RedVelvet, and Shinee are all under the same company (SM) which is known for their vocals~
Okay, in this video I saw him smiling a lot..