The less you understand this country, the better it is for your health. An eye opener to the tribal, herd behavior n elite capture in the society. Well explained
One of the best topic and interview ever....this tells that only Army and Politicians are not responsible for Pakistan's debacle. Its the people of Pakistan who are equally liable for it.
Wonderful wonderful wonderful input by zaidi which a true loyal, honest, intelligent, experienced and educated Pakistani do. He diagnosed all the diseases of sick economy in front of everyone even at the cost of political affiliations, friendship, safety and his future. No one can give reward to him him for his sincere effort to revive the economy of Pakistan. He is my hero. Solute to him. May God take care of him. Thx
Because I truely believe that Islam is the best and I will not regret or mind admitting Muslims are the worst as far as acting practically upon Islam is concerned. WasSalam.
This is a must-watch best interview show by Shahzaib on Pakistani Economy in recent times to recommend anyone of an unconventional Ex Tax Master, exposing the darkest reality of the poor economy unlike unnecessary contemporary talkshows or so-called podcasts. Kudos, keep up the courageous work of true national watch-dog!
This is my first time watching khanzada as in PTI supporter and geo is full of anti imran but I must commend this show . Zaidi sahab exposed the loopholes, he clearly said every mafia is involved, so much that even imran had no answer. Zaidi sahab didn’t say anything about khan’s corruption which goes to show even his critics know . I don’t think any other fbr head of any government can come and talk this because those leaders would get exposed. More support for khan .
By far the single most dangerous statement in entire show: politicians threatened FBR chairman to finance anti state actors if their constituents are forced to pay taxes.
Not the whole truth FBR personnel, even down to the level of clerks face such challenges on daily basis but those who have spine always stand up to these challenges. Succumb to such pressures are either those carrying a baggage or wanting to stick to their position.Why did he give in.
@@madmax-bu6wh PM don't get to even know such trivial matters . The policy matters are handled at best at ministry level. He is a coward and didn't have the nerve to withstand any pressure and now making such frivolous tall claims
شاہزیب خانزادہ صاحب ۔ بوہت ہی زبردست انٹرویو بوہت اچھا پروگرام زبردست سوالات اور شبر زیدی صاحب کو بھی بوہت زیادہ خراج تحسین کے انہوں نے عوام کو سچ بتایا جس کی جتنی بھی تعریف کی جاۓ کم ہے شبر زیدی صاحب بلکل سچ بول رہے ہیں اس کا ثبوت یہ ہے کہ خیبر پختون خوا کے سنٹر حلال ارحمان نے 33 ارب کی کرپشن پکڑی اور انہوں نے شہباز شریف صاحب کو بھی خط لکھا لیکن شہباز شریف صاحب نے بھی کوئی ایکشن نہیں لیا ۔
Zaidi sb. is right that we need to discuss all these matters but unfortunately no one is interested and political and military backed people are ripping the economics. May Allah protect Pakistan from all these people and may we have more intellectual and subject matter experts in action to stabilize and lead the country, Ameen!
Unfortunately, everyone who is supposed to be "savior" of this nation chooses europe and america as their permanent home after retirement. Be it judges, army personnel, or chairmen of bureaucratic bodies.
Extremely candid interview. Never have I seen in 54 minutes someone lay bare the power blocks in the country who resist paying taxes. Congratulation Mr Zaidi and also Mr Shahzeb Mr Shabbar Zaidi very candidly has shared the details of some of the pressure groups which do not allow this country to get it's due share of taxes. This has to stop!. The country has to develop and progress and for this taxes are needed. The retailers have to be brought into tax net and they have to pay their due taxes May be next interview with Mr Shabbar Zaiadi should discuss the challenges in FBR administration and why FBR has let down the nation in not collecting due taxes
@Shahzeb Khanzada sb! I appreciate your effort to highlight genuine challenges faced by Pakistan and I have great respect for Shabbar Zaidi sb for sharing his first hand experiences. I have never seen any ex-chairman FBR or ex-Finance minister to bring up these matters in limelight. Shabbar sb has rightly pointed out that the political parties of Pakistan do not pay attention to address long term economic issues of Pakistan. They do not have the right persons and the will to fix our issues. The observations highlighted in this interview should be propagated to all Pakistanis. I request Shahzeb sb to conduct more sessions on discussing the solutions to the problems highlighted by Shabbar sb. Please invite correspondents from all Political parties and ask them to present tangible solutions. The party who wins elections should be held accountable to implement the solutions earlier presented.
@@shahzadghumman6563 The whole media is run as a business, and does all to gain power & money. No such thing as ethics & honesty. If you watch the last five minutes, it becomes evident, how questions & answers are scripted.
SHAHZAIB SB. ALLAH SBWT AAP K ILM SOUCH MALOOMAT JAZBE MULK SE MOHABBAT MAY MAZEED AZAFA KARE .AAMEEN. ALLAH SBWT AAP KO SUB BALAWOON SE BHI MEHFOOZ RAKHIE AAMEEN
Amazing facts, Tax chori ke khilaf baat krne waaley PTI rehnuma tax choron ke numaindey or sifarshi bun kr aatey rahe. Shabbar Zaidi sb. ke iqdamaat or unki jurrat ko Salam.
Try to get taxes on agriculture and retail by creative means.Give this study to LUMS and ask them for PHD thesis.I am sure they will give creative ideas which will ensure correct direction of charging tax.
Exactly I was saying same . Zaidi sahb exposed our system and not once blamed imran khanzada ghom ke imran per . Koi aur government ka fbr sari umer bhi aesa show nakare.
ALLAH KA KHOF KRO............................ imran khan kitna nalaiq tha ye exposed hogya.............................. pura interview suno............
@@vantagehistory1813 pura interview suno aur bughz ke beghar samjho. You can’t control every individual. You can’t police every individual. Aur nailiki, chori se behtar . Koi dhamki deta ata nahi dounga, koi kehta cheeni , koi kehta steel mil band kerdoun ga while you have 10x more mess to deal with. Difference is isne bola, aur government ka banda to aker bhi na bole kuch because wo khud corruption mein involved .
@@abdulghaffar9468یہ گر ایماندار ہے تو ساڑھے پانچ ہزار لڑکیوں کی عزت کا سوال اٹھاتا یہ دو نمبر ہے یہ پی۔ڈی ایم سے پوچھتا کہ آپ تو مہنگائی کا نعرہ لگا کر آئے تھے اب ہر چیز تین گنا کر دی ہے ایمان ہوتا تو بولتا
میں اوورسیز پاکستاني ہوں، عمران خان نے مجھے اپنے ملک سے پیار اور محبت کرنا سکھایا ہے اور ہمارے اندر فخر ، ہمت ، وقار پیدا کیا ہے IK Zindabad💪🇵🇰🦅....
Sir Zinda bad raho Tho mujay itna bahadur aur piyara lagtey ho jaisa aik chothey bachey apni piyarey gorhya kay sath khithey hoy khosh hothey hay Arsala khan ka peshawar say lahore tak SALAM
The less you understand this country, the better it is for your health. An eye opener to the tribal, herd behavior n elite capture in the society. Well explained
You can expand this to everything and everyone in Pakistan
absolutely man ...... I cant even make sense of how terrible everything is here..... the only best thing for us is to get out of here probably
@@MuhammadAli-tw9htJinnah: Kin Bakrichodon ko azad karwa dia 😂😂
Exactly Yar.... Me to wakai me pagal hojaonga soch soch k... Ab esa hi karna padega
@@Abdul_Rasheed005 Jinnah manji dhok gaya hamari
One of the best topic and interview ever....this tells that only Army and Politicians are not responsible for Pakistan's debacle. Its the people of Pakistan who are equally liable for it.
Yes ...this is the issue people are blaming only 2 political parties & army generals
True...Pl believe me ...Hamaray liyae Angrez he best Hukamraan haen kaash WO hum pur hukamraani kur laen
It means only politicians n army officers are responsible
Lmfao how the fk did you conclude this? Everything he said is on politicians and generals.
Hmm at this time ignorance is bliss
I wish every Pakistani watch this interview and understand it.
exactly 💯
Great analysis of Pakistan's economy. This country is run by landlords, politicians, developers, and the army in their vested interest.
Awam is fed opium of religion to keep the pliant
آج آپ کی عزت دل میں بڑھ گئی ہے،
بہت خوب پروگرام کیا آج کا،
اب عوام کی بات کی سچ میں
Shahzeb Sir , Best Explainer & Analyst 👏 Not only for he explains smoothly but sach ugalwaane main bhi No one can beat Him 😂
Bilkul Sai kha apny
😊😊o😊o of lo😊op😊😊 on l😊o pl
@@wajidgujjar9965l
😊l😊😊ll
Llll
One of the best interview I've seen on Pakistani news channel, else are just for TRP purpose, totally worthy to see.
Wonderful wonderful wonderful input by zaidi which a true loyal, honest, intelligent, experienced and educated Pakistani do. He diagnosed all the diseases of sick economy in front of everyone even at the cost of political affiliations, friendship, safety and his future. No one can give reward to him him for his sincere effort to revive the economy of Pakistan. He is my hero. Solute to him. May God take care of him. Thx
شاہزیب خانزادہ تمہاری جرات اور تمہاری صحافت کو سلام پورے میڈیا میں پورے میڈیا میں آپ جیسا مرد جرنیلسٹ نہیں ہے اور نہ ہی کوئ آئے گا ❤❤❤❤
22Cr. Bheekhari duniya ke liye bojh ban gaye hain. IMF, CHINA 57 OIC kab Tak pet bharnge es Nikkammi Kaom ka.
❤❤❤❤❤❤
@@abbdulqayyum6406Cy
Yeh buhat munafiq hy pehlay PDM k ganay garaha tha
@@dazzlingdecorations1963jinnah: in Bakrichodon ko kyun Azad karwa dia 😂😂
Excellent.
There cannot be a better analysis of Pakistan economy.
WasSalam.
😂😂😂Excellent discussion of ISLAMI RIYASAT.
@@shivbisht7598
I most sincerely hope it's not a sarcasm
Because I truely believe that Islam is the best and I will not regret or mind admitting Muslims are the worst as far as acting practically upon Islam is concerned.
WasSalam.
Great interview...never watched such shocking and informative interview...Well done Shahzaib and shaber zaidi
Shahzeb Khanzada ❤
Is the best journalist ever
May Allah Pak bless you always and your Family ❤
shabber zaidi sb was telling realities of Pakistan Salute to Zaidi Sb
Great achour shahzeb 💞💞💞
😂
This is a must-watch best interview show by Shahzaib on Pakistani Economy in recent times to recommend anyone of an unconventional Ex Tax Master, exposing the darkest reality of the poor economy unlike unnecessary contemporary talkshows or so-called podcasts.
Kudos, keep up the courageous work of true national watch-dog!
Best interview. Very informative. I don’t think Pakistan will ever prosper.
Appreciate shahbair Zaidi telling the truth. Now the coming government must address out of tax net groups and businesses.
Direct Tax is the main solution of Pakistan economy problems
Shabar Zaidi Absolutely right ❤️❤️
This is my first time watching khanzada as in PTI supporter and geo is full of anti imran but I must commend this show . Zaidi sahab exposed the loopholes, he clearly said every mafia is involved, so much that even imran had no answer. Zaidi sahab didn’t say anything about khan’s corruption which goes to show even his critics know .
I don’t think any other fbr head of any government can come and talk this because those leaders would get exposed.
More support for khan .
From 45minutes onwards it is all planted questions & answers.
Maybe Shabbar is opening his options for a long caretaker govt.
By far the single most dangerous statement in entire show: politicians threatened FBR chairman to finance anti state actors if their constituents are forced to pay taxes.
PTM leaders are elected members and part of current govt.
Not the whole truth
FBR personnel, even down to the level of clerks face such challenges on daily basis but those who have spine always stand up to these challenges. Succumb to such pressures are either those carrying a baggage or wanting to stick to their position.Why did he give in.
@@seemajabeen1408
If PM has succumbed what can he do.
@@madmax-bu6wh PM don't get to even know such trivial matters . The policy matters are handled at best at ministry level. He is a coward and didn't have the nerve to withstand any pressure and now making such frivolous tall claims
Zaidi sahib you hit the nail on the head half of Pakistan economy
Depends on no2 jugarh methods
Ye program dekh k mera maatam krne ka dil kr rha h
شاہزیب خانزادہ صاحب ۔ بوہت ہی زبردست انٹرویو بوہت اچھا پروگرام زبردست سوالات اور شبر زیدی صاحب کو بھی بوہت زیادہ خراج تحسین کے انہوں نے عوام کو سچ بتایا جس کی جتنی بھی تعریف کی جاۓ کم ہے شبر زیدی صاحب بلکل سچ بول رہے ہیں اس کا ثبوت یہ ہے کہ خیبر پختون خوا کے سنٹر حلال ارحمان نے 33 ارب کی کرپشن پکڑی اور انہوں نے شہباز شریف صاحب کو بھی خط لکھا لیکن شہباز شریف صاحب نے بھی کوئی ایکشن نہیں لیا ۔
Zaidi sb. is right that we need to discuss all these matters but unfortunately no one is interested and political and military backed people are ripping the economics. May Allah protect Pakistan from all these people and may we have more intellectual and subject matter experts in action to stabilize and lead the country, Ameen!
Unfortunately, everyone who is supposed to be "savior" of this nation chooses europe and america as their permanent home after retirement. Be it judges, army personnel, or chairmen of bureaucratic bodies.
It requires major overhauling of the systems..Reforms Reforms and Reforms.. unfortunately..nobody is serious about pakistan😢😢
انتہائی معلوماتی انٹرویو ۔ شاہ زیب خانزادہ میرا پسندیدہ نمبر ون اینکر
Shahzaib is one of the finest journalist in Pakistan. Stay blessed.
Extremely candid interview. Never have I seen in 54 minutes someone lay bare the power blocks in the country who resist paying taxes. Congratulation Mr Zaidi and also Mr Shahzeb
Mr Shabbar Zaidi very candidly has shared the details of some of the pressure groups which do not allow this country to get it's due share of taxes.
This has to stop!. The country has to develop and progress and for this taxes are needed. The retailers have to be brought into tax net and they have to pay their due taxes
May be next interview with Mr Shabbar Zaiadi should discuss the challenges in FBR administration and why FBR has let down the nation in not collecting due taxes
One of the star programmes of this year so far
Thanks, Shabbar sb for exposing the corrupt face of this country.
The best interview ❤
Well done shahzab, great discussion on economic challenges of Pakistan.
Now over to PML-N, PPP and establishment to respond logically and responsibly.
@Shahzeb Khanzada sb! I appreciate your effort to highlight genuine challenges faced by Pakistan and I have great respect for Shabbar Zaidi sb for sharing his first hand experiences. I have never seen any ex-chairman FBR or ex-Finance minister to bring up these matters in limelight. Shabbar sb has rightly pointed out that the political parties of Pakistan do not pay attention to address long term economic issues of Pakistan. They do not have the right persons and the will to fix our issues. The observations highlighted in this interview should be propagated to all Pakistanis. I request Shahzeb sb to conduct more sessions on discussing the solutions to the problems highlighted by Shabbar sb. Please invite correspondents from all Political parties and ask them to present tangible solutions. The party who wins elections should be held accountable to implement the solutions earlier presented.
Ya Allah Pakistan ki halat per apna fazal kar ameen
Sir g buhat muddat k baad maza aaya God bless you
Brave and non controversial journalist shahzeb khanzada
No Sir, very controversial.
@@afaqh2356 maybe for pti
@@shahzadghumman6563 The whole media is run as a business, and does all to gain power & money. No such thing as ethics & honesty.
If you watch the last five minutes, it becomes evident, how questions & answers are scripted.
@@shahzadghumman6563 Shabbar Zaidi fails to mention, how his successor was able to get record tax collection, while he failed to do so.
@@afaqh2356 only mafia holds this country
A must listern for everyone
Can we have another session too ?
Most jewellers don’t give you receipt when you try to purchase gold bar In pakistan 😂😂😂
Good interview ❤❤
Shabar zaidi best of In pakistan🎉🎉
As a responsible citzen of Pakistan, I will only vote on the manifesto of the political parties and plans to handle economic challenges.
Great sir
Zabardast interview...ye bt any wali govt ko samjhna ho gi .or sb idaron ko bi taxe ma lana ho ga chahy miltry ha ya' adliya'.
Good discussion
SHAHZAIB SB. ALLAH SBWT AAP K ILM SOUCH MALOOMAT JAZBE MULK SE MOHABBAT MAY MAZEED AZAFA KARE .AAMEEN. ALLAH SBWT AAP KO SUB BALAWOON SE BHI MEHFOOZ RAKHIE AAMEEN
Best program ever!
😢 یا رب العالمین مملکت خداداد کو ان مگرمچھوں کے منہہ سے نکال، آمین یا رب
Aameen
Allah kabhi beamal ki madad nahi karta
@@OwaiseAli یہ شامت اعمال ہی تو ہے
Ek e dil h khanzada sb kitni bar jeeto gy??
important,,,very important discussion
❤
Outstanding ❤
Very nice/informative discuss
Love u both
Authentic answers of authentic questions❤
ٹیکس ہر مہذب معاشرے میں لیا جاتا ہے لیکن ایمانداری سے خرچ بھی کیا جاتا ہے
Kherch kerny k leay pehly tax dyna perta hai.. tax deay bagir ap kherch ki tvaka ker rahy hain...bhai.
Good shazaib sb
Good interwiew.
Wonderful analysis....
Best program on economics
Finally saw some sense in pakistani media... get it going shazeeb sir.
حل صرف اسلامی نظام معیشت و حکومت اور دیانتدار و اہل قیادت ہے
Janab Shazeb Kahanzada Shab very very good Interview
Salam Salam
Zundabad always also ever zundabad
Excellent program
Great shahzab khanzada
controversy in shabbar zaidi today's statements and when he was holding position in Imran government in finance ministery??
Planted stuff from 45th minute onwards
This was not his stance back then
@@seemajabeen1408Right.
Great work ..awam ko pta to Chala ke Tax ke mamley sary politicians AK side pe ho jaty ..
@19:42 why can't we remove or reduce import duties in order to avoid snuggling?
Amazing facts, Tax chori ke khilaf baat krne waaley PTI rehnuma tax choron ke numaindey or sifarshi bun kr aatey rahe. Shabbar Zaidi sb. ke iqdamaat or unki jurrat ko Salam.
Awesome. Interview
Try to get taxes on agriculture and retail by creative means.Give this study to LUMS and ask them for PHD thesis.I am sure they will give creative ideas which will ensure correct direction of charging tax.
Proven that Arny runs the country instead of elected government. It's a trio of the army , politicians, and landlords
سیاست نے معیشت کا بیڑہ غرق کردیا اور جب معیشت تباہ ہوتی ہے تو ملکوں کی تباہ صاف نظر آتی ہے
آج سمجھ آیا کہ عمران خان کتنا مجبور تھا. میری تو خان سے محبت اور بڑھ گئی. شہازیب نے پوری چالاکی سے اپنا بغض عمران نکالنا چاہا مگر زیدی صاحب چھا گئے.
Exactly I was saying same . Zaidi sahb exposed our system and not once blamed imran khanzada ghom ke imran per .
Koi aur government ka fbr sari umer bhi aesa show nakare.
ALLAH KA KHOF KRO............................ imran khan kitna nalaiq tha ye exposed hogya.............................. pura interview suno............
@@vantagehistory1813 pura interview suno aur bughz ke beghar samjho. You can’t control every individual. You can’t police every individual. Aur nailiki, chori se behtar .
Koi dhamki deta ata nahi dounga, koi kehta cheeni , koi kehta steel mil band kerdoun ga while you have 10x more mess to deal with.
Difference is isne bola, aur government ka banda to aker bhi na bole kuch because wo khud corruption mein involved .
@@Awais_Sohrab89 shabar sahab to imran khan ko blame kr rhe he
@@Awais_Sohrab89 agr imran khan in chalenges ko control nhi kr skta to hat jata pm post se..................ajeeb log ho pm ka kia kam hota he???
Acha bnda ha zaidi sahb
It seems Shabbar Zaidi is offloading huge burdens on his chest. .. see him getting relieved every minute.
Yes truth comes out this way
i am not the economist but my advice is reducing the rate of tax from bribe everything be ok.
Ya Allah shahzaib khanzada sb ko FBR chairman ya ministry of finance kr de Ameen 💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌
Jb hamari county me aise honest people's he to help Leni chahye government ko
Aur shabbar zaidi in k advisor hon
عہدہ ملتے ہیں تین سو ساٹھ ڈگری پہ جائے گا ایلیٹ کا چپڑاسی بنے گا
@@abdulghaffar9468یہ گر ایماندار ہے تو ساڑھے پانچ ہزار لڑکیوں کی عزت کا سوال اٹھاتا یہ دو نمبر ہے یہ پی۔ڈی ایم سے پوچھتا کہ آپ تو مہنگائی کا نعرہ لگا کر آئے تھے اب ہر چیز تین گنا کر دی ہے ایمان ہوتا تو بولتا
@@whyisntitکھوتا کھایا کیا
Alslamualeikun shaba zaidi
Surprisingly, a similar situation exists in India too.
♥️♥️
Shahzaib bhai haste huay bht ache lagte ho❤
This should be added in every pakstudies book.
Planted interview.
Very good interview
Excellent
بہت اچھا انٹرویو ہے ۔ لیکن پریشان کن ۔ اللہ پاک اس وطن کو مخلص حکمران عطا فرمائے ۔ آمین
جو کاغذ جلسے میں لہرایا تھا وہ سائیفر نہیں بلکہ پنکی کے جادو ٹونے کے لیے سامان کی لسٹ تھی ۔۔
Pinky pirni 😂😂 kute hands full of bilak majic 💕💕
اب انصاف والے جو اس کی عزت کرے گۓ وہ دیکھنا کیونکہ ان کے خلاف بولنا ممنوعہ ہے
This interview will create an outrage in Pakistan 🇵🇰........ when Pakistan will wake up.
میں اوورسیز پاکستاني ہوں، عمران خان نے مجھے اپنے ملک سے پیار اور محبت کرنا سکھایا ہے اور ہمارے اندر فخر ، ہمت ، وقار پیدا کیا ہے
IK Zindabad💪🇵🇰🦅....
Lol😂😂
❤❤❤❤❤ Excellent 👌
Sir Gawdar ma Pali check post FC Ki hai jas ke daily income petrol ma one cor hai Gawdar tak 3 check post hain
Sir Zinda bad raho Tho mujay itna bahadur aur piyara lagtey ho jaisa aik chothey bachey apni piyarey gorhya kay sath khithey hoy khosh hothey hay Arsala khan ka peshawar say lahore tak SALAM
EMAM❤
👍👍👍
A good discussion after a long time
Dear geo news please sponsor this interview😢
ماشااللہ😍❤️ پاکستان مدینہ کی ریاست بن چکا ہے پاکستان میں زندگی کی بنیادی سہولیات بجلی پانی گیس موجود نہیں
Dr qadri was very much right about curupt system and Mafias
Good