Short hours, long breaks: Are French workers lazy?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 17 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 154

  • @Desi_Des
    @Desi_Des 5 років тому +26

    Lived in Paris for many years, speak French (although a little rusty now since I haven’t been back for 2 years) , know the culture and love the food. I have learned so much from your videos that I wasn’t aware of which is surprising. I do want to thank you very much for opening all these new doors for me and others who are interested in the French culture. Will follow you on FB and Twitter. Merci bien Mademoiselle.

  • @duke613
    @duke613 4 роки тому +53

    Lazy? No it's the way life is supposed to be lived.

  • @thecitizenjoan
    @thecitizenjoan 5 років тому +72

    My Goal in Life is too become a French Cliche

    • @patrickmcshane7658
      @patrickmcshane7658 5 років тому +2

      Hands up!

    • @e0o9kii
      @e0o9kii 5 років тому +2

      Better get that Red Wine and Croissants ready.

    • @erepsekahs
      @erepsekahs 4 роки тому

      Try learning to spell in English first.

  • @Rayschall1
    @Rayschall1 6 років тому +27

    I've bacome a fan of Florence Villeminot. I'm so glad I've found this channel just today since I live in France for quite some time. I subscribed now. Thank you very much for interesting videos concerning France!!!

  • @Eusantdac
    @Eusantdac 6 років тому +30

    So, let me get this straight: the French are not legally allowed to fish for scallops until October in their own French waters but the British are legally allowed to come into the French waters and fish for those scallops? That makes absolutely no sense.

    • @julies8813
      @julies8813 5 років тому +3

      EU makes the decisions who and what.. Eu does not care who get and not get it. But it gets more complex.. Britain has more power and larger economy than France.. So France agreed to it because want the Britain's money and sell out on its own citizens lesser incomes on French people. So in the end you shall protest against EU for that.

    • @EvilSmonker
      @EvilSmonker 5 років тому +7

      @@julies8813 Britain and France actually have practically the same gdp, along with practically the same population. More likely quid pro quo.

    • @ihatefrogs4390
      @ihatefrogs4390 3 роки тому

      the french are scared of the english..they tremble in the presence of the english..germany, ran right over france twice in two world wars, without firing a shot.

    • @saucyrossy3698
      @saucyrossy3698 Рік тому

      Yeah. Welcome to the EU. None if it makes sense. Its a terrible idea and reality itself is proving that out.

    • @ericmamadou4735
      @ericmamadou4735 Рік тому

      Many things in france are based on the logic you just pointed out.

  • @helenepege6043
    @helenepege6043 5 років тому +15

    Unfortunately, those winderful labor laws aren't applied un France...let's talk about the 35 hours, for example. I'm an accountant. I've been working all my carreer well over 35 hours each week.Those hours weren't paid or converted into Rtt because they weren't legal. The major issue in France is that companies don't respect the labor laws. I ate at my desk with my collegues, worked past legal hours, had my share of illegal CDD...statistics show only what has been declared by the companies...

    • @leesteal4458
      @leesteal4458 5 років тому +4

      You guys enabled your employers.

    • @jeanfonssedeporte3158
      @jeanfonssedeporte3158 4 роки тому +1

      You should have sue your employers. And maybe it is because you have a "cadre supérieur" contract, in this case you dont have maximum hours

  • @jonathanmcgovern2464
    @jonathanmcgovern2464 4 роки тому +21

    Counterintuitive but shorter hours longer breaks leads to more focus productivity at work. Too much focus is on number of hours.... should be in terms of productivity, not number of hours at work aka burnout, presenteeism.

    • @barnabydinosaurroadsafetyp3457
      @barnabydinosaurroadsafetyp3457 3 роки тому

      I am a Brit - more productivity joke - no problem with 2 hour lunches but too many here are just a bit too relaxed about everything - seen a few who work for themselves work very hard but productivity compared to uk, germany, dutch is laughable. UK went back to work months ago here we are still on a long covid holiday. Complacent not lazy complacent.

  • @injektileur
    @injektileur 5 років тому +8

    it is actually 25 days off / year. Except in restaurants. And lots of holidays are nulled if they happen during a week-end. Like a july 14th on a sunday.
    So there are never 30 + X days off. Except when it comes to RTT. That part is right.

  • @kramerberbon1804
    @kramerberbon1804 4 роки тому +8

    I'm surprised 1/2 hour seems long for a lunch break. Seems normal to me.

    • @jamesfletcher474
      @jamesfletcher474 4 роки тому

      Depends if you want to go home at 5:00 and see your kids or if you prefer to work till 7pm so you can have a long lunch paid for with ticketresto

  • @richardparrington8636
    @richardparrington8636 6 років тому +31

    Great content. Do more stuff like this please.

  • @hori166
    @hori166 3 роки тому +4

    30 paid days off? In Amerika, most workers get NONE because of the mantra "Arbeit Macht Frei". The French aren't lazy, they just have different priorities. Get busy living, or get busy working...

  • @AlbandAquino
    @AlbandAquino 4 роки тому +13

    A healthy worker is more productive than a semi present worker, trying to meet ends ...
    In France we value our time off because it's making us more committed to our work environment.
    For sure, when at work we work our arses off, but when on a lunch break, or on week end ... Don't mess with us.
    Live and let live, if you want a productive worker let him/her have some time off. You will get a good value for your money.

    • @___beyondhorizon4664
      @___beyondhorizon4664 Рік тому +2

      Long lunch hours and many cigarettes breaks was what I saw in Paris...

    • @AlbandAquino
      @AlbandAquino Рік тому

      @@___beyondhorizon4664 In almost every jobs, you have a mandatory 20 mins break every 2 hours. If you decide to split it in half, you can totally have your smoke every hour :)
      I'm usually doing a combo. Coffee + smoke :P And quite often, colleagues are joining to enjoy a coffe as well even if they don't smoke.

  • @markjmaxwell9819
    @markjmaxwell9819 5 років тому +5

    Well in Australia we work a 38 hour week with a minimum hour break distributed over the day.
    With four weeks paid holidays and public holidays.
    And a maximum of twelve hours per shift.
    mmmmm
    Food for thought.
    😆😆😆😆😆

    • @leesteal4458
      @leesteal4458 5 років тому +2

      Twelve hours is way too long.

  • @stevencarrier2466
    @stevencarrier2466 6 років тому +6

    I Love Flo and Genie!

  • @leesteal4458
    @leesteal4458 5 років тому +15

    I want to work in France.

  • @leesteal4458
    @leesteal4458 5 років тому +3

    Not true. In the USA, I don't know who takes less than a half an hour for lunch. Some offices actually close for an hour for lunch break.

  • @piedadepais
    @piedadepais 4 роки тому +2

    I’m from Portugal, I work 35 hours a week, have a 1,5 hour lunch break and 15 minutes pause int morning and the afternoon. It’s the legal work hours. 22 vacation days, and the usual holidays, Easter, Christmas, saints, and so many during the year.

  • @iFreeThink
    @iFreeThink 3 роки тому

    Monthly pay might be more appropriate for evaluating
    - buildings and
    - educational employees/texts.

  • @iFreeThink
    @iFreeThink 3 роки тому

    It's fine to give tracks.
    But don't require being stuck with blocked people.

  • @saraclark5099
    @saraclark5099 5 років тому +5

    Bonjour, where did you film this? Would be nice to Know the Name of that Restaurant, thank you

    • @d.f.991
      @d.f.991 5 років тому

      11:59

    • @IzabelParis
      @IzabelParis 5 років тому +3

      Le Café du Commerce, rue du Commerce, Paris 15ème

  • @ivermektin6874
    @ivermektin6874 Рік тому

    Well this puts current events into perspective.

  • @violetgruner707
    @violetgruner707 5 років тому +8

    In America you do not dare ask for more vacation time. You would be labelled a Communist and told to leave the country. You would be called "lazy" and thus your morals would be questioned.

  • @CyborgZeta
    @CyborgZeta 6 місяців тому

    Man, I wish I had 30 days off here in the US.

  • @bwb4416
    @bwb4416 3 роки тому +2

    sure they are on strike 24/7

  • @sayakhalder4138
    @sayakhalder4138 Місяць тому

    My owner makes me do 12 hrs a day and gives 6 day work like 72 hrs what should I do

  • @Ethioutforlunch
    @Ethioutforlunch 2 роки тому

    I really love and Enjoy French connections please continue like this

  • @iFreeThink
    @iFreeThink 3 роки тому +1

    They should be with tax exams.
    Random people who don't even serve food to hungry Hippos.

  • @georgegrigoriu5114
    @georgegrigoriu5114 5 років тому +1

    All that matters is how much one produces, not how much time he stays in an office. Just look at the Germans. They don't work the most time but they have the best outputs because they are the most efficient.

  • @davepasopton8840
    @davepasopton8840 4 роки тому +1

    Why does everyone interview only office type workers with programmes like these? There are many more real workers who apply practical and technical skills in various environments that must also take adequate break durations. These are just as important and possibly of more value to a country’s society and wealth creation. Bakers, Engineering craftsman, Joinery, Building, Public services etc?

    • @mihiec
      @mihiec 4 роки тому +2

      Yes! Every journalist focuses only on fancy jobs in office.... Its mosty well paid easy job to do.

    • @danielbtwd
      @danielbtwd 3 роки тому

      Yes I agree, I work as a welder/fabricator, I make 1 kilometres of welding per year and 50 tons of equipment with a value of 1500 000 euros. One needs the stamina of an occupational athlete. Many of my colleagues at 55/60 yrs need replacement hips, knees and shoulders. By retirement most are finished. Yes I work in France and they are hard working conscientious people. Conditions are much better than other countries that I have worked. Medical, pension, education, nice holidays, better pay and lower cost of living generally.

  • @I_like_YT_lots
    @I_like_YT_lots 5 місяців тому

    There's a reason why most of the western countries are running on deficit with YoY growth on borrowing.

  • @iFreeThink
    @iFreeThink 3 роки тому

    People are claiming the randomest stories and royalty whatever.

  • @lex2151
    @lex2151 2 роки тому

    Please kindly add closed captioning for disabled viewers.

  • @chris14091975
    @chris14091975 4 роки тому +7

    I love how they prove the stereotypes

  • @goodbarbenie5477
    @goodbarbenie5477 2 роки тому +1

    Ahem...I had the worst job in my life in S.Africa...where I wasn't even allowed one day off because illness. They still took a whole day's pay off. I was also forced to use up all my accumulated leave. I wasn't even allowed to visit the toilet...I was not even paid overtime...Even working on weekends doing stock staking etc. I was never remunerated for that at all...When I needed help or assistance in my work I was punished as being incapable or inept for doing my work... When I approached the labour department in N.W. province they laughted and sniggered at me in their language...No salvation... For a White Englishman...hah... Life can be bummer when U least expect it of people...Hahaa... Knowing what I just learnt from this program, I would preferred to have been lost in France...even though I cannot speak a word...Hahaa... LuvU. Guys...

  • @m.j.golden4522
    @m.j.golden4522 3 роки тому

    So not true about the money making in France. People make money and they just consider it as important as taking a bite of bread. It's nonchalant. And that's the way it should be. They don't worship money and they should keep it that way.

  • @SilvanaDil
    @SilvanaDil 6 років тому +17

    A bit more work and France's per capita GDP could be higher.

    • @ke8814
      @ke8814 6 років тому +14

      And a lot more work and France's gdp per capita could be even higher.
      Work is necessary for us to live, but life is much more than work. Remember you only have one life, 110k income instead of 100k income won't bring back lost years.

    • @remicaillot
      @remicaillot 6 років тому +10

      Having financial success in france doesn't mean having a successful life for everyone

    • @CameronCourts
      @CameronCourts 5 років тому +9

      But most of those gains would go to the rich. People wouldn't necessarily be better off.

    • @danielbtwd
      @danielbtwd 3 роки тому

      You would just be taxed more.

    • @ltgdr6298
      @ltgdr6298 3 роки тому

      in france if you lose you job you get 80% of you salary for up to 3years, You also have free healtcare, eduction and tons of other right providing you money on top of your monthly earnings.
      Your monthly earnings dosent mean how well you live.
      If your kid need a brain surgery that cost 500k living in UE is buy far the way to go.

  • @wahidullahzadran2149
    @wahidullahzadran2149 5 років тому +4

    🤘✌I love you English French❤❤❤❤🤩🤩🤩🤩

  • @thierryf67
    @thierryf67 5 років тому

    "fonctionnaires" don't have higher wages. this is full of private worker cliché.

    • @danielbtwd
      @danielbtwd 3 роки тому +1

      They are paid more for the kind of work that they do. Plus all the advantages.

    • @popkhorne5372
      @popkhorne5372 3 роки тому

      @@danielbtwd wrong, at least for teachers. They are actually underpaid.

  • @jamesfletcher474
    @jamesfletcher474 4 роки тому

    Short hours??? Not true at all, 9-7

  • @williambilltran3528
    @williambilltran3528 5 років тому +2

    Awesome!!!

  • @nanaprt61
    @nanaprt61 5 років тому +5

    I love this country.

  • @myyoutube5567
    @myyoutube5567 3 роки тому

    Mais, C'est loin.

  • @PrinsTan
    @PrinsTan 5 років тому +2

    25 days not 30.

  • @mage5890
    @mage5890 4 роки тому +1

    Really I'm a bit disappointed...
    Some comments are really friendly (maybe too much 😆, but that's welcome 😊), whereas others are soooooo disrespectful!! 😭😭
    I guess it's the same everywhere in the world, some people are indeed arrogant or else in France (and all over the world), but not all people, please! That's mean to say that and false for sure!!
    I hope you will meet nice people 😊👊
    Have a good day 😘🇨🇵

  • @GJ-ho2hy
    @GJ-ho2hy 3 роки тому

    I disagree fundamentally, french are very similar to the americans actually. Having worked with French and for a french firm, they are the only ones working crazy overtimes, judging those who leave home on time and think they are productive because of the long hours. Awful corporate culture really..definitely not european

  • @Vietnam-mintDotCom
    @Vietnam-mintDotCom 3 роки тому +1

    French services are lousy!

  • @tobeytransport2802
    @tobeytransport2802 3 роки тому

    1:20 that’s not quite true. I’m from the UK and I believe that in the US because of their federal system it appears that they get 0 days holiday but that is just the federal limit, the states can (and probably do) set limits however they probably aren’t as good as the UK or the EU (and definitely not as good as France)

  • @Vietnam-mintDotCom
    @Vietnam-mintDotCom 3 роки тому +1

    France has the lowest paid earnings and poverty is increasing.

    • @ltgdr6298
      @ltgdr6298 3 роки тому +1

      in france if you lose you job you get 80% of you salary for up to 3years, You also have free healtcare, eduction and tons of other right providing you money on top of your monthly earnings.

    • @stud6414
      @stud6414 3 роки тому +1

      @@ltgdr6298 why work if you'll get a salary for not working? Also, France lives in a greater global complex so they don't have to innovate or work hard because countries like USA will pull up the slack.

  • @lamijojo7003
    @lamijojo7003 3 роки тому

    A question to the English native speakers: does the interwiever Florence has a French accent when she speaks English?

    • @jamesfeww
      @jamesfeww 3 роки тому

      No, her accent isn't noticeable at all.

    • @life_lab_chronicles
      @life_lab_chronicles Рік тому

      No. No accent. She sounds like a native speaker of North American English.

  • @iFreeThink
    @iFreeThink 3 роки тому

    There goes leading the UK.

  • @jamesb312
    @jamesb312 5 років тому +9

    France is not a free market economy, it's rife with protectionism...it could account why the French economy is such a mess...For crying out loud they even dictate when shops can have sales and frown on commercial competition,

    • @fredericlallinec7450
      @fredericlallinec7450 5 років тому

      Like Brexit it is the mess
      Like Trump government is he Staline or Adolf Hitler?
      And many Americans or British are in poverty and lower educated, almost illetrate
      I

    • @danielbtwd
      @danielbtwd 3 роки тому

      Actually the French economy is on a par with that of the UK. They also enjoy one of the highest standards of living in the world. There are also many wealthy people, just look along the French Riviera. Of course there are problems like everywhere.

  • @jamesb312
    @jamesb312 5 років тому +12

    How can they be lazy, they are constantly active in being on strike...it also takes a lot of effort to be so rude and arrogant!!

    • @frederic4844
      @frederic4844 5 років тому +3

      jamesb312
      Well, you have just proven that the french are not the only one being rude and arrogant, well done !!!

    • @jamesb312
      @jamesb312 5 років тому +1

      This is from a French funded channel...I stand by my assertion that the French are rude, lazy, arrogant and cowardly when, in fact, the French have nothing to be arrogant about. France is a disaster area!!
      France is known to be the strike capital of the World..SNCF are always on strike.

    • @frederic4844
      @frederic4844 5 років тому +4

      jamesb312
      A statement, not a proper reference.
      And, congrats, you have just made my point again ...

    • @jamesb312
      @jamesb312 5 років тому +1

      Oh but yes, it's a proper reference..I unfortunately got stuck in France
      and had to deal with the bloody French on a day to day basis..I have
      lived all over the World and I have never met a people as bad as the
      bloody French!!

    • @frederic4844
      @frederic4844 5 років тому +1

      jamesb312
      Oh, so it’s an opinion, not a fact ... I knew that some people tend to confuse anecdots with data ...

  • @bwb4416
    @bwb4416 3 роки тому

    ohhhh so sorry! 39, I am so sorry , the French are so stressed out uh? 39 uh

  • @kukamusa1947
    @kukamusa1947 4 роки тому +5

    Too many holidays because free money and minerals from Africa..3.5 billion a year

    • @xxxxxx-kk7mh
      @xxxxxx-kk7mh 4 роки тому

      @C. Michael false

    • @ltgdr6298
      @ltgdr6298 3 роки тому +2

      3.5billion a years are joking ? sociale help that is mostly use for migrant is 700billions... you are so funny with your 3 billions

    • @popkhorne5372
      @popkhorne5372 3 роки тому +1

      Which is a ridiculously small sum. For a country like france.

  • @CalebMcCarthy
    @CalebMcCarthy 5 років тому +3

    I want to become a French Fonctionnaire

    • @ornella6243
      @ornella6243 5 років тому +3

      I'm French and what they about functionaires isn't totally correct. Because if you have fewer hours you have a small fee, you got an earlier retirement it's with a lower pension, and you can have bigger pensions only if you succeed prestigious public Concours or prestigious public school

    • @ornella6243
      @ornella6243 5 років тому +3

      Oh and I forgot that you not pay and you don't receive more "congé payée" if you work more than 35h per week in practice

  • @Beestist
    @Beestist 5 років тому

    Competition seeking top talents should dictate vacation days, not the law.

  • @redadermane8177
    @redadermane8177 2 роки тому +2

    It's not a myth folks. it's a fact ! it's a mixture of laziness and a system that is "too socialized" , discouraging ambition and hard work. you add to it the overly hierarchical working environment: if you have a lower education degree , you can almost never hope to do better. you're blocked by an idiotic system. while in the US, you can say : " if i work hard, smart and persist, i can succeed", it's the opposite in France. they're happy with an income and hope to get a raise by stabbing their coworkers in the back, licking asses to get upper. i know it happens in the US also. but in France it's a culture.
    i've been living in France for the last 2 years. i travel all the time around for work. so i talk from experience. and i speak French fluently.
    Government workers (fonctionnaires) are "Gods": they do whatever they want, whenever the hell they want. just check how long it takes to get a simple "passport" , ID card or drivers license-copy. or anything issued by a government office for that matter. i have French friends that still hold to their very old drivers license (paper made) because it can take weeks, or even months, just to get it renewed. same for passports...etc. now , tell me that's not laziness and inefficiency !
    indeed, the health care system is socialized, and sounds great when you say it. but good luck getting an appointment with a doctor. i had to call 7 dentists for a tooth abscess, no one would take me in. finally i had to go to the emergency room and wait for hours before i could be seen by a doctor. same thing with many specialists. customer service here is a joke. very unprofessional, rude and inefficient.
    I can go on and on, and i dare anyone to contradict these facts. i can't wait for my contract to end to go back home without losing my job.
    I advice any fellow American to think hundreds of times before deciding to live or stay in France for a long time. even tourism, i always recommend my friends who want to visit Europe, to choose Spain, Netherlands, Italy or northern countries. at least you can have some fun without headaches.

  • @xz1891
    @xz1891 4 роки тому +1

    Hopeless

  • @rodionkulichenko4211
    @rodionkulichenko4211 4 роки тому +2

    So basically the stereotypes are true! okay

  • @MrACPAHMADALI
    @MrACPAHMADALI 5 років тому

    Le français est très difficile.

  • @nicksincredibleopinion
    @nicksincredibleopinion 5 років тому +6

    Lol, American here. We have time off, we just negotiate that for ourselves. If you have no skills, probably not worth anything to your boss. Hey, France, how is your innovation of new industries going with all those days off? LMFAO

    • @ashleatenny2719
      @ashleatenny2719 5 років тому +7

      Is that an east coast thing? Everywhere I've ever worked they just told you which holidays you get off, and paid vacations are accrued based on hours worked, non- negotiable. And even then you get ridiculed and gossiped about if you dare take more than 2 or 3 days in a row off, even if you have weeks, or even months, of accrued time.

    • @JM-nt5ex
      @JM-nt5ex 3 роки тому +1

      There is no such thing as "negotiating for yourself". You're either in a union or you get what you get.