Wingspan Asia: Tales From Production

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 24 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 80

  • @studleygamer
    @studleygamer 2 роки тому +14

    Echoing one of the things that Jamey mentioned... putting together the Automa rulebook for Wingspan Asia, so it worked as both a standalone for Asia and a comprehensive rule set for the original Wingspan was one of the more challenging things we've done in our work with Stonemaier.

    • @jameystegmaier
      @jameystegmaier  2 роки тому +3

      Thank you for all the time and effort you put into the Automa rulebook and system, David!

  • @bryanway7680
    @bryanway7680 2 роки тому +6

    A fun house rule we have been doing in our playgroup, is add in a token that lets each player refresh the bird offer once (discard all the birds you could draw, and refill). Since we liked that mechanic from the dune expansion so much. Seems to lesson the feel bad moments of not finding birds that match your goals. Anyone else doing something similar?

    • @sambo6266
      @sambo6266 2 роки тому +1

      Do you apply this to the first hand of 5 birds or the bird tray?

    • @bryanway7680
      @bryanway7680 2 роки тому

      @@sambo6266 we did each player got 1 refresh of the bird tray whenever they wanted mid game. Allowing the token to be used for the initial hand of birds instead is an interesting idea, we might have to try that.

  • @sanchi2315
    @sanchi2315 Рік тому

    Just completed my collection of wingspan with this expansion. The expansion itself is extremely well thought out, good job to the team and Elizabeth!

  • @astevezimm
    @astevezimm 2 роки тому +2

    This is my first time seeing the boards for Asia exp. They are gorgeous!

  • @Duxa_
    @Duxa_ Рік тому

    We definitely run into the ying-yang issue, everyone I introduce this for the first time assumes you can both place on the same spot on the board because ying/yang typically are part of one whole, and tokens wrap together nicely (as you pointed out in the video).

  • @garrisonbrown1170
    @garrisonbrown1170 2 роки тому +4

    I appreciate the texture of the rulebooks. My question is, why not include new standard goal tiles? I personally think the amount of goal tiles we currently have is fine, but someone pointed this out of Facebook.

    • @jameystegmaier
      @jameystegmaier  2 роки тому +3

      We're running thin on new goal tile ideas, and so since we were already including goal tiles for Duet mode in this expansion, we decided to save the remaining ideas for the next 3 expansions. There are some good ideas on BGG that Elizabeth is aware (some that work, others that don't).

    • @birnamdesignco
      @birnamdesignco 2 роки тому

      Next 3 expansions?! Does that mean we’re getting an Antarctica expansion someday? Penguins for the win.

    • @jameystegmaier
      @jameystegmaier  2 роки тому +4

      @@birnamdesignco In no particular order, we're hoping to have expansions for Africa, Antarctica, and Latin America.

    • @birnamdesignco
      @birnamdesignco 2 роки тому +2

      @@jameystegmaier and obviously the top secret prehistoric Pangea expansion.

    • @larrychatfield
      @larrychatfield 2 роки тому

      @@jameystegmaier this makes sense but i think there are jus tons of goals that are unexplored. in fact the design of the bonus cards allows for a great thread to which explore. food at end of the turn, cards in hand at the end of the turn, etc

  • @relo999
    @relo999 2 роки тому

    Ohh man, the colormatching of the backs of cards brings me back. Used to play a boardgame/TCG mix, x610z, that from what I know was only really played somewhat seriously in the Netherlands in 2 or 3 cities. So I met the designer a few times. But long story short, the early versions had a nearly all black back which apparently is really hard to color match consistently. And being the crafty player I was build a deck around shuffling with a bunch of first edition cards, except for some from high priority cards that I used later editions for so it was relatively easy to spot which cards where which. Won quite a few rounds with that and noted the issue to designer when playing a friendly tournament, and technically wasn't cheating just abusing poor color matching.
    Later they changed the backs to a grey gradient with more of a design and required opaque sleeves for using cards from earlier editions.

  • @johannesheine9738
    @johannesheine9738 2 роки тому +2

    Really astonishing to see how much thought went into every component and also your push for more eco-friendliness! Could you elaborate a bit on the card design for this expansion? Especially since it's so flexible on how you can play it (standalone, with base game + expansions, different modes etc.). How do you keep balance for all these different scenarios?

    • @jameystegmaier
      @jameystegmaier  2 роки тому +1

      Elizabeth, the designer, is much better equipped to answer that great question. :) From what I can tell from her process, she uses a big spreadsheet that helps to ensure that the cards are balanced compared to existing birds and that the ratios for the bonus cards remain mostly the same.

  • @ertai222
    @ertai222 2 роки тому +1

    Hype. I'm going to get all the expansions for each continent. I already have everything so far.

  • @bluefire700
    @bluefire700 2 роки тому +4

    Does moving to wooden tokens and more eco-friendly components increase the price of the game in the end? I don't mind, I'm just curious

    • @jameystegmaier
      @jameystegmaier  2 роки тому +9

      The impact on the cost is quite minimal, and it did not impact the price to the consumer.

    • @bluefire700
      @bluefire700 2 роки тому +6

      @@jameystegmaier oh so its win win for everyone! Including our precious planet :)

  • @28green
    @28green 2 роки тому +2

    Did you consider adding cardboard “walls” to the feeder board (like Dead Reckoning does with their battle board)? This would allow dice to be rolled into the “tray” without falling out.

    • @jameystegmaier
      @jameystegmaier  2 роки тому +4

      The original birdfeeder has walls like that, but a 3D structure would not fit into the Wingspan Asia box, so we didn't consider it. We did, however, test it, and in playtesting we found that it was easy to roll the dice near/on the birdfeeder and then place them all on the birdfeeder.

    • @larrychatfield
      @larrychatfield 2 роки тому

      @@jameystegmaier exactly. since the beginning we have simply used the base of the birdfeeder as the food tray and that has worked great

  • @JessicaAnderson-yd8xv
    @JessicaAnderson-yd8xv 2 роки тому

    This looks so awesome. Thanks so much for sharing. Are there any other expansions that will be coming out in the future?

    • @jameystegmaier
      @jameystegmaier  2 роки тому +1

      Indeed there are! The plan is to have an expansion for every continent. The remaining continents (in no particular order) are Africa, Latin America, and Antarctica.

    • @JessicaAnderson-yd8xv
      @JessicaAnderson-yd8xv 2 роки тому

      @@jameystegmaier thanks so much! So excited for these!!

  • @cryozeal
    @cryozeal 2 роки тому

    Hi Jamie,, thanks for the very thorough video detailing all the rational behinds the production. One thing came to mind when I was watching is that wood isn't always more eco-friendly than plastic. I'm not an expert but from what I learned, with some paints on it, wood may not even be recyclable. Plastic can be recycled with the right process (which many countries may not have it in place). In addition, plastic is generally lighter and may have a lower transport and delivery footprint. I'm not saying B is better than A, but the whole material life cycle is an additional thing worth considering. 🌍

    • @jameystegmaier
      @jameystegmaier  2 роки тому +1

      Those are some great points! The big thing about wood isn't where it's going, but rather where it's coming from. Wood is a renewable resource if it's sustainably forested (which our sources are); the components that create plastic are not. Also, while some plastic is recycled and recyclable, nearly 95% of all plastic just ends up in landfills, where (unlike wood) it will not biodegrade.

  • @Panda-qj5xj
    @Panda-qj5xj 2 роки тому +3

    Hi Jamey, the new expansion looks great! I can’t wait to receive it! I’m really excited for the duet mode and flock mode. I also really like the new player boards. If future expansions don’t need new player boards, would you consider selling some with new landscapes that match future expansions on your store? Maybe double sided with Africa and South America? I would definitely purchase it.

    • @jameystegmaier
      @jameystegmaier  2 роки тому

      Thanks for sharing that! Those expansions don't exist yet, but we'll see when we get to them. :)

  • @djoj20
    @djoj20 2 роки тому

    Can't wait for Nov 2nd 😁

  • @barbaramazzocca4605
    @barbaramazzocca4605 Рік тому

    I'm struggling to understand how to find where to place the ying/yang piece on the duet map in the solo mode. I understand the example in the rulebook, how to find where to start on the map, but I do not understand which icons I should be looking at when I am trying to determine the Type Section and Habitat Section. Should I be looking at the exact same icon that was used to determine where to start on the map? Or, do I look at the icons that are to the left of these sections (Type section and Habitat Section) even though those are for rounds 3 and 4 on the card?

    • @jameystegmaier
      @jameystegmaier  Рік тому

      To decide where to place the yin/yang pieces on the duet map in solo mode, you look at the icons that are to the left of each of the three sections (Type, Habitat, and Map sections). So, to the left of the Map section for the map; left of the Type section for the type, and left of the Habitat for the habitat.

    • @barbaramazzocca4605
      @barbaramazzocca4605 Рік тому

      @@jameystegmaier Ok, thank you so much for clearing that up! I received two Stonemaier games for Christmas and am having a blast playing them! Thanks for all your hard work!

  • @larrychatfield
    @larrychatfield 2 роки тому

    only "complaint" i really had was there should have been a lot more end of round goals in the duet mode (at least 10) to provide more variation to that aspect. and while it was a standalone game it would have been great to include some more bonus round goals for the non-duet mode again like 5 2-sided more goals - i know i have heard people say it's supposed to be standalone but games do this all the time provide product offering that may or not may not be used specifically for that like the Automata etc

    • @jameystegmaier
      @jameystegmaier  2 роки тому +1

      Fortunately we've received an outpouring of suggestions, and we'll include them in at least some of the remaining expansions (while trying to balance that request with all the other people who have said, "Just give us more bird cards! :) ).

    • @larrychatfield
      @larrychatfield 2 роки тому

      @@jameystegmaier having all the expansions, lack of bird cards is the furthest thing from a "problem". love the game and have played with nesting box for last month gleefully, and anything mentioned is only a request or wish list

  • @M0oATH
    @M0oATH 2 роки тому +1

    Thanks for sharing, and I hope it’s fun experience for you solving such problems related to production and how it relates to the experience of the players and the mechanics of the game. I like that you prioritized solving for the stand-alone rather than standardizing for someone who already own original Wingspan and its expansions.
    Now, any thoughts of reimplementing the whole line into an essential / complete edition? Or is it too soon for that? Or is it not desirable?

    • @jameystegmaier
      @jameystegmaier  2 роки тому +4

      We'll just continue to sell each expansion for Wingspan separately so people can pick and choose what they do or don't want. It's more consumer friendly that way.

  • @dixaba
    @dixaba 2 роки тому +1

    Did I understand correctly that duet mode has the same gameplay loop (playing cards and gaining resources) as base game, but a completely different scoring system?

    • @studleygamer
      @studleygamer 2 роки тому +1

      It has the same scoring. The only difference is with Duet, the end of round goals are based upon the Duet map, replacing the end of round goals you may be familiar with. In Duet you also gain points for you largest contiguous group of tokens on the map at the end of the game.

  • @marcelineleiman4330
    @marcelineleiman4330 2 роки тому

    For the yin and yang tokens-have you ever considered having a version where players can occupy the same space to effectively “block” the other player in that space from gaining points for end of round?

    • @jameystegmaier
      @jameystegmaier  2 роки тому +2

      We did consider that! But it doesn't work, because part of the design is such that you can see the icon on the space below it for end-of-round goals--you would completely block that icon if both tokens went there.

    • @marcelineleiman4330
      @marcelineleiman4330 2 роки тому

      @@jameystegmaier true-tho in a 2 player game the icon may as well not be scored anyway since it’s zero-sum (though I don’t know the end of round goals)

  • @ricardp60
    @ricardp60 2 роки тому +2

    Hi Jaimey, this look like a fantastic game. I already have the base game as well as Oceania. Love both of those. Can't wait to play with Asia as well. when will it become available in retail (in Canada)? thanks

    • @jameystegmaier
      @jameystegmaier  2 роки тому +4

      Thanks Pierre! The direct preorder from Stonemaier Games starts on November 2, with shipping happening throughout November from our regional fulfillment centers (including one in Calgary). The retail release date is in mid-December.

    • @ricardp60
      @ricardp60 2 роки тому

      @@jameystegmaier Thanks. Looking forward to get my game. Great job!

  • @Crixler
    @Crixler 2 роки тому +1

    Will you ever offer a set of Oceania dice on the Stonemaier shop, so that both groups in flock mode can have a full set?

    • @jameystegmaier
      @jameystegmaier  2 роки тому +1

      No, that's not the correct way to include the dice in Flock mode. Per the rules, you use 2 Oceania dice and 3 standard dice per group.

    • @Chalos909
      @Chalos909 2 роки тому +2

      Is there something specific to flock mode that makes 2 Oceania dice better? Or is this split just the best way to solve the dice problem?
      My friend has Oceania too, thought we might just grab his dice for our first flock mode game…

    • @jasonmetcalfe4695
      @jasonmetcalfe4695 2 роки тому +1

      @@Chalos909 its to balance the nectar fairly among the teams, since we're not issued any extra here

    • @jameystegmaier
      @jameystegmaier  2 роки тому +1

      @@Chalos909 Part of it is to ensure the dice are available. You're welcome to try with just Oceania dice if you'd like.

  • @briggan
    @briggan 2 роки тому

    Seeing all the ways you guys have pushed for a more eco-friendly production in this expansion (which is great to see btw) led me to wonder if you were planning on switching out the components in your past expansions and the base game with more eco-friendly materials in future production runs as well? And will other colors of the eggs made of wood be available for purchase separately?
    I was also wondering about how well the new wooden eggs would hold up against potential scratches/paint chipping, and if this is something you've tested?
    Just a couple of curious questions. I just preordered my copy of the Asia Expansion and I can't wait to give it a try!

    • @jameystegmaier
      @jameystegmaier  2 роки тому +2

      Indeed, all printings of Wingspan products that started this summer (and in the future) use non-plastic components. We aren't selling wooden eggs separately, but a future reprint of the speckled eggs will be wood. They're the same shape, size, and color as the original eggs and will blend in well. My wooden eggs seem quite durable and scratch-resistant so far.

  • @Duxa_
    @Duxa_ Рік тому

    what is the chemical reaction with the bag? Should we not be keeping our eggs in those bags?

    • @jameystegmaier
      @jameystegmaier  Рік тому

      The bags we included in the game are fine--there is no issue with them. The discussion in the video is about something that happened *before* we finalized production.

    • @Duxa_
      @Duxa_ Рік тому

      @@jameystegmaier The biodegradable bags are fine? Because when I pack up, I actually put the eggs into the biodegradable white opaque bag that was included because I prefer clear bags for other components.

    • @jameystegmaier
      @jameystegmaier  Рік тому +1

      @@Duxa_ Yes, all of the bags included in the game should be fine. The worst that can happen is that a little paint can come off the eggs, but I don't think it's possible with the components included in the game.

    • @Duxa_
      @Duxa_ Рік тому

      @@jameystegmaier Perfect, thanks so much for confirming, and thanks so much for being so engaged into questions that pop up on BGG, here and elsewhere. It means a lot! Your engagement is a big reason why I am always interested in what SM is doing/releasing. And is a big part of why I have so may SM games in my collection. It feels good to support people like you and companies like yours. Please dont ever change (or sell to Asmodee).

    • @jameystegmaier
      @jameystegmaier  Рік тому

      @@Duxa_ To be honest, it always concerns me when someone says something like "Please dont ever change (or sell to Asmodee)," for multiple reasons. One, I think change is good. It's important to learn, grow, and improve. Two, if we ever did consider a merger/acquisition, I hope the trust is there with our followers that we would only consider such a thing if we could continue to serve you just as well as we do now (and even better). Three, Asmodee is already a major partner of ours--they handle distribution in Europe and fulfillment in Canada. You seem to have a poor impression of them, but they've actually been a huge asset to Stonemaier Games.

  • @sherlockhomeless7138
    @sherlockhomeless7138 2 роки тому

    So.. just to see if I understood this correctly: If I want to play Wingspan solo, I can choose to play Wingspan Asia only or I choose Wingspan asia + oceania expansion and use the back of the board and I can choose to play the original Wingspan game and add wingspan asia as an expansion? That would be so great.

    • @jameystegmaier
      @jameystegmaier  2 роки тому

      You can play Wingspan solo with any combinations of expansions, Asia, and the core game.

  • @NP-dw4fc
    @NP-dw4fc Рік тому

    I own Wingspan in my own native language, and I am curious how it works with the other bonus cards.
    For example English a bird might have a region in its name, while in a different language it has a colour in its name, and if there are multiple birds like that then the bonus cards % are not really correct anymore.
    I can only imagine how much of a pain it must be to get sorted out.

  • @antonwig
    @antonwig 2 роки тому

    May have been asked elsewhere, do any IRL birds lay red eggs? I always assumed the original egg colors were based on eggs found in nature. (And now realize that may have been a false assumption!)

    • @jameystegmaier
      @jameystegmaier  2 роки тому +4

      Birds lay eggs in a hugely vast variety of colors--do a Google image search for "bird eggs" and you'll see them. While this exact shade of red may not match a specific bird, there are some birds that lay red eggs.

  • @cryozeal
    @cryozeal 2 роки тому

    Another thing I'd like to see in the future is the board similar to Oceania but without the nectar. Love the flexibility and the nerf to the eggs on grassland that the Oceania board brought to the game. But personally, I don't like playing with the nectar that much because it makes the decisions on the bird feeder and bird food in general a lot less meaningful; it doesn't matter as much anymore what types of food the birds eat. And I believe many share similar feelings on the BGG forum. Moreover, I think the nectar scoring add unnecessary complexity to Wingspan that it wasn't originally designed toward that direction.

    • @jameystegmaier
      @jameystegmaier  2 роки тому

      I totally get that, and you don't need to play with nectar. The original board is perfectly fine--it's what I use.

    • @cryozeal
      @cryozeal 2 роки тому

      ​@@jameystegmaier When I play with my group with the original board, I see less diverse strategies being played. I know there are many strategies that also have high win rate when successfully pull off, but the egg spam is so reliable and easy as a high point generation in round 3 and 4. Hence, a lot of people are inclined to go toward that easy route instead of others.
      It's still fun though. I'm looking forward to see the next expansion that can tie all the good parts of previous expansions together rather than seeing many new things introduced.

  • @ian_forbes
    @ian_forbes 2 роки тому +1

    I think it’s great you are trying to be more eco-friendly but will there be an opportunity to purchase the red eggs (and potentially future new eggs in upcoming expansions) in the same material as the previous eggs? I’m excited about new eggs but a bit OCD about matching components and would prefer symmetry in the components.

    • @jameystegmaier
      @jameystegmaier  2 роки тому +14

      The eggs are exactly the same size, shape, and color. It would be a huge disservice to the environment to add that level of redundancy, particularly in plastic, when the wooden eggs seamlessly mix with the original eggs. All eggs we make from now on (including any that started production in the last 5 months) will be wood--we're not going back to plastic.

    • @ian_forbes
      @ian_forbes 2 роки тому

      Fair enough, thanks for confirming! 🙂

  • @jeremyhewitt2637
    @jeremyhewitt2637 2 роки тому

    To bad about the plastic. Not like anyone is going to throw them away. It would be ideal if there were wooden inserts or boxes or glass that could be bought.