Scorsese made his passion project “silence” 2016 and could have ended it there…. But no he gave us a three and half hour gangster epic “the Irishman” with the three best mafia actors ever and his collabs….. and that would’ve been fine to end it there but no NOW he gives us this other 3 and half hour epic but this time set in a time place that he NEVER did before and that he NEVER delved into before like damn Scorsese… every film he feels the need to top himself and funny thing is he DOSENT HAVE TO. The man could rest on his achievements but no he STILL has stories to tell. Directors like him make me look at others and go “what’s ur excuse “?
@@otavioclassics and major studios are probably regretting that cause also I think they mentioned a three and half hour deniro Scorsese Pesci Pacino movie wouldn’t bring in audiences or whatever and although flower moon didn’t break any box office records or anything it did pretty well still in top 5, if people were interested in Scorsese 3 half hour Osage Native American film.. a lot of them prob would’ve saw Irishman too in theatres
@@Johnconno Nah... Spielberg has his fair share of bad movies, but that's the same man who also made Jaws, Schindler's List and Saving Private Ryan...that's enough to catapult him into the 🐐 list 🤷
@@rishabhprasad5417 that's without including ET, Jurassic Park, the Indy trilogy and Close Encounters. Even the ones a tier below like Munich, minority report and bridge of spies were extremely well made.
That’s my one main criticism about Steven. He needs to collaborate with past actors more frequently. Martin Scorsese, Robert De Niro, and Leonardo DiCaprio know the benefits of collaboration.
True, but I see that as part of Spielberg's prolificness and curiosity. He bounces around between so many wildly different tones and genres from picture to picture, sometimes even in the same year. I see his varied casting as a part of that.
I was initially a little bit worried about the length of this film, but i need not have worried, it is fantastic and the nearly 3 and a 1/2 hours flew by!
There are SPOILERS just so you know- I had to bail because I haven’t seen it yet so be careful if you haven’t seen it either. Excited to come back once I have.
@@AlexThe1Menace it’s based on his love of cinema and it relates to him as a child. Fabelmans isn’t an exact representation of Spielbergs childhood either. It’s just aspects placed into a fictional scape. Also that’s why I said he “kinda” did it with Hugo
@@Ooth9999 ik I'm just pulling your leg lol. Although Fablemans, despite some changes, is very explicitly meant to reflect his life and upbringing. Hugo meanwhile is based on a book and is more about Marty's love of film rather than being about his own life.
Art it’s not sports. No such thing as better or worse at that level of craftsmanship anyway. They are both incredible in their own right. And above all great friends.
Stan the man hasn't existed in a couple of dozen years. Unless he faked his death to live even more reclusively. Which is kind a Kubrickian sorta thing to do actually.
@@gpapa31 UA-cam took my comment off…But basically I was saying that yeah, Kubrick is on a whole different level than them, I just have been fanboys of S & S since I was a young child.
This needs to happen: Angelina Jordan in Paris Steven Spielberg Angelina Jordan is a young singer who has amazed the world with her voice and style. She has performed in many countries and events, but one of her dreams was to sing in Paris, the city of love and art. That dream came true when she was invited by Steven Spielberg, the famous director, to be part of his new movie project. Spielberg was impressed by Angelina's talent and wanted her to sing the main theme song of his film, a romantic comedy set in Paris. Angelina was thrilled and accepted the offer, and soon she found herself in the beautiful French capital, recording the song and exploring the city with Spielberg. They had a great time together, and Angelina felt inspired by the culture and history of Paris. She also learned a lot from Spielberg, who shared his wisdom and experience with her. Angelina said that this was one of the best experiences of her life, and that she was grateful to Spielberg for giving her this opportunity.
It's devastating how Steven Spielberg cut Shia LaBeouf out of his life. I always believed that Shia could have helped Steven win six more Oscars if they kept their collaboration strong like Martin Scorsese and Robert De Niro. Offering constructive criticism about Indiana Jones is an unacceptable reason to fire someone. The only obstacle that stands in the way of success for Steven is his inability to listen to the advice from the people around him. Steven recently lost 7 Oscars to Everything Everywhere All At Once. I'm glad that I'll never use my Bachelor's Degree in Film to become a movie director.
Marty should’ve made this a miniseries, as is there’s not enough time spent with the main players on their own in order to really get an idea of what’s going on in their head. If we had another hour or so in this runtime and the whole thing was split up into 4 episodes I think it would’ve had a bigger impact at the end. It’s still a fine movie but I do think there was too much to try and squeeze into a feature length film. So much of the screen time is dedicated to the actual plot and also showcasing the Osage culture and that’s all handled well, but I wish I actually saw more of DiCaprio’s thought process during all of this and the rationalizations he must be giving to himself about everything.
@@atlas3565 Because he made the quintessential movie about the horrors of genocide and has incredible influence in the US to shift the toxic policy it currently has towards Israel.
Christopher Nolan has easily overtaken these guys. In fact Spielberg was always a sentimental hack that appealed to the average dumb American movie goer. Even his serious movies are filled with cringe 😂
I really enjoy Nolan’s movies but there’s no way he’s better then Scorsese or more successful then Spielberg. Today he is a top 3 director but Scorsese and Spielberg are all time greats.
@@karansoni909 Quantity does correlate to quality. Spielberg has made many many trash movies whereas Nolan hasn't made one. Schindler's List was cringe, Spielberg was a typical stupid American taking something like the Holocaust and telling a feel good one man saving a few Jews story out of it lmao. That's his worst movie. Spielberg was the biggest director in the world at that point and he could've had the power to make a proper Holocaust movie but he didn't. Scorsese is good but not on Nolan's level, that's a fact.
@@karansoni909 Yeah, it's his biggest cringe movie. It's a bigger atrocity than his mediocre blockbuster movies. Go watch the short clip of Terry Gilliam's views on Spielberg and Schindlers List which explains my feelings on that movie and what's wrong with it.
@@elonif4125 Nolan just turned a 3 hour talky biopic into a near billion dollar movie. That's something Spielberg and Scorsese in their prime never came close to doing. Those two guys like most directors are just journeymen directors who just pick up a book or screenplay with no input. Nolan is an actual storyteller and it shows considering he went to a world class university studying English. He's numerous classes above Scorsese and Spielberg it's not even close lol.
felt bad for ernest , i don't think he was 100 % well, either from the war (though the was a cook) or just some mental health , i wanna know more about his background before saying he was this spineless guy even if the may be true its quite easy to say ... he felt like an good guy , pure but with something bodering him from within. along with external situations , did anyone even him knew he wasn't 100 % well and stable ? he lost as much as anyone in the movie , my guess and opinion :)
Two legends of the New Hollywood who managed to survive today when cinema is going through crises.
These men have been making films since the Johnson administration. Nothing new about that
Legends?! yuck, I will throw up.
@@arasgeylanigo ahead, your mother will come afterward and lick it up
@@arasgeylanilegends of legends
How come the DGA doesn't record these interviews anymore.
They do it just takes them forever to release the footage
unfortunately the producers guild isn’t there
They only released the full interview exclusively on THR website. You can check there
They’ve done other videos on it
Scorsese made his passion project “silence” 2016 and could have ended it there…. But no he gave us a three and half hour gangster epic “the Irishman” with the three best mafia actors ever and his collabs….. and that would’ve been fine to end it there but no NOW he gives us this other 3 and half hour epic but this time set in a time place that he NEVER did before and that he NEVER delved into before like damn Scorsese… every film he feels the need to top himself and funny thing is he DOSENT HAVE TO. The man could rest on his achievements but no he STILL has stories to tell. Directors like him make me look at others and go “what’s ur excuse “?
A lot of his films were long-gestating passion projects. He wanted to make Gangs of New York in the late seventies with DeNiro in the lead role.
He also meant to do The Irishman for quite some time until finally secure financing
@@otavioclassics and major studios are probably regretting that cause also I think they mentioned a three and half hour deniro Scorsese Pesci Pacino movie wouldn’t bring in audiences or whatever and although flower moon didn’t break any box office records or anything it did pretty well still in top 5, if people were interested in Scorsese 3 half hour Osage Native American film.. a lot of them prob would’ve saw Irishman too in theatres
@@ThomasKirby-ub4vy Oh absolutely! I personally believe all comes down to marketing, but big studios just like to play safe nowdays
silence of the lambs?
Two legends
Errr...One. He's talking to a permanent teenager.
@@Johnconno Nah... Spielberg has his fair share of bad movies, but that's the same man who also made Jaws, Schindler's List and Saving Private Ryan...that's enough to catapult him into the 🐐 list 🤷
One is a pedophile I think?
@@rishabhprasad5417I-
@@rishabhprasad5417 that's without including ET, Jurassic Park, the Indy trilogy and Close Encounters. Even the ones a tier below like Munich, minority report and bridge of spies were extremely well made.
I could listen to Martin Scorsese talk about movies for hours.
Martin Scorsese & Steven Spielberg - the GOATs.
I watched Scorcese's The Age Of Innocence for the first time last week... Probably the most underrated movie of all time, it is fantastic.
I suggest you watch The King Of Comedy (1982), which stars Robert De Nero and Jerry Lewis in a serious role.
The Age of Innocence is one of his best films, but people don´t associate it with him. I love that film.
Eh, its low key a snooze
Thank you for recording this event and releasing it here.
And I’m hoping Robert D will work with Spielberg soon.
who is robert d
@@FoodforThought12345678dsds DeNiro
@@FoodforThought12345678dsds in this context I would say he is referring to Bobby De Niro
Two of my all time favorite filmmakers talking about filmmaking, what more can I ask. 🤷
Lovely interview, even with the severe weather alarm going off
That’s my one main criticism about Steven. He needs to collaborate with past actors more frequently. Martin Scorsese, Robert De Niro, and Leonardo DiCaprio know the benefits of collaboration.
He did a lot of movies with Tom Hanks, and you can really feel the trust between them with each passing film.
True, but I see that as part of Spielberg's prolificness and curiosity. He bounces around between so many wildly different tones and genres from picture to picture, sometimes even in the same year. I see his varied casting as a part of that.
I was initially a little bit worried about the length of this film, but i need not have worried, it is fantastic and the nearly 3 and a 1/2 hours flew by!
2 living legends right here..
Thanks for the upload
Your very welcome. Please like, share, and subscribe! Appreciate it!
Scorcese Forever ♥️
There are SPOILERS just so you know- I had to bail because I haven’t seen it yet so be careful if you haven’t seen it either. Excited to come back once I have.
Great video, the sound is just low...
Thank you for recording and posting
Very welcome! Please consider liking, sharing, and subbing for more panels and Q&As
Thank you for recording this 🫡
Very welcome! Please consider liking, sharing, and subbing for more panels and Q&As
Imagine combining Steven’s brilliant science friction mind with Marty’s narrative style. We could have something extraordinary
He directed an episode of Amazing Stories, and of course made Cape Fear at Amblin.
Something truly shit.
Thanks for the knowledge men
You're very welcome. Thank you for watching!
PUT THE PHONES DOWN
Spielberg made the Fablemans about his family growing up. I think, wish, Scorsese would do his backstory. No doubt it would be fascinating.
he kinda did with Hugo
@@Ooth9999 didn't know Scorsese was French and born in the late 1800s lol
@@AlexThe1Menace it’s based on his love of cinema and it relates to him as a child. Fabelmans isn’t an exact representation of Spielbergs childhood either. It’s just aspects placed into a fictional scape. Also that’s why I said he “kinda” did it with Hugo
@@Ooth9999 ik I'm just pulling your leg lol. Although Fablemans, despite some changes, is very explicitly meant to reflect his life and upbringing. Hugo meanwhile is based on a book and is more about Marty's love of film rather than being about his own life.
He made a documentary about his parents in 1974.
My favorite filmmaker of all time is Marty Scorsese. But even I admit, in a lot of ways, Spielberg is a better one.
Scorsese> Everyone,Yaa when it comes to collections nobody surprasses Spielberg
In which ways but monetarily?
Art it’s not sports. No such thing as better or worse at that level of craftsmanship anyway. They are both incredible in their own right. And above all great friends.
This argument is funny when Kubrick exists
Stan the man hasn't existed in a couple of dozen years. Unless he faked his death to live even more reclusively. Which is kind a Kubrickian sorta thing to do actually.
Thank you so much for this! Living vicariously through you right now
🤣 🇺🇸
If Lilly doesnt get an oscar itll be a crime..
THE GREATEST PICTURE CREATORS OF ALL TIME!!!!!
I disagree.
I didn’t see Kubrick on the stage.
@@michaelyeiser1565 Fair Opinion, I believe the greatest is definitely DW Griffith & Orson Welles. Kubrick is definitely God tho.
@@gpapa31 UA-cam took my comment off…But basically I was saying that yeah, Kubrick is on a whole different level than them, I just have been fanboys of S & S since I was a young child.
thank you so much for sharing this!
Very welcome! Please like, share, and sun for more!
Two goat of cinema talking together
I feel privileged watching this on UA-cam so I hope the audience knows they witnessed something special
We did! Thank you for watching!
The sounds coming from the cameraman are annoying. The Mmmmm’s are weird.
Sorry! Live reaction!lol
This needs to happen: Angelina Jordan in Paris Steven Spielberg
Angelina Jordan is a young singer who has amazed the world with her voice and style. She has performed in many countries and events, but one of her dreams was to sing in Paris, the city of love and art. That dream came true when she was invited by Steven Spielberg, the famous director, to be part of his new movie project. Spielberg was impressed by Angelina's talent and wanted her to sing the main theme song of his film, a romantic comedy set in Paris. Angelina was thrilled and accepted the offer, and soon she found herself in the beautiful French capital, recording the song and exploring the city with Spielberg. They had a great time together, and Angelina felt inspired by the culture and history of Paris. She also learned a lot from Spielberg, who shared his wisdom and experience with her. Angelina said that this was one of the best experiences of her life, and that she was grateful to Spielberg for giving her this opportunity.
Thanks for uploading this, buddy
Very welcome! Please consider liking, sharing, and subbing for more panels and Q&As
that's brilliant and thank you for sharing this. what sort of satisfaction does someone get by punctuating every sentence with "mh!", I just wonder.
I think their original script idea was a better one.
Me 🤝 hmmming guy throughout the interview
Wow, thanks for the teaching
Enjoy! Please like, share, and sub for more q&as during awards season in LA!
Why do these guys agree to be interviewed in a large room where sound bounces off the walls and the audience coughs, etc?
They were gracious enough to speak with a live audience.
goat
Thanks
Very welcome! Please like, share, and subscribe!
This is a dream right?
Felt like it!lol
God. Everytime someone coughs I get nervous like “Don’t you realize these men are old?!?”
Perfect thank you ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Wonderful conversation!
It's devastating how Steven Spielberg cut Shia LaBeouf out of his life. I always believed that Shia could have helped Steven win six more Oscars if they kept their collaboration strong like Martin Scorsese and Robert De Niro. Offering constructive criticism about Indiana Jones is an unacceptable reason to fire someone. The only obstacle that stands in the way of success for Steven is his inability to listen to the advice from the people around him. Steven recently lost 7 Oscars to Everything Everywhere All At Once. I'm glad that I'll never use my Bachelor's Degree in Film to become a movie director.
Any more fan fiction?
Any good quality videos of this?
how much better does it need to be? greedy
Hollywood Reporter has it but an ad pops up literally every five seconds. It's unwatchable.
I tried my best with just my phone…🤷🏻♂️
Marty should’ve made this a miniseries, as is there’s not enough time spent with the main players on their own in order to really get an idea of what’s going on in their head. If we had another hour or so in this runtime and the whole thing was split up into 4 episodes I think it would’ve had a bigger impact at the end. It’s still a fine movie but I do think there was too much to try and squeeze into a feature length film. So much of the screen time is dedicated to the actual plot and also showcasing the Osage culture and that’s all handled well, but I wish I actually saw more of DiCaprio’s thought process during all of this and the rationalizations he must be giving to himself about everything.
Scorsese’s riding his old glory
You talking crap.
Go watch a Disney movie. Snow white would be perfect for you.
I wish Spielberg would make a public statement about the genocide in Gaza.
Why? Not everyone famous needs to express their opinions on serious issues
@@atlas3565 Because he made the quintessential movie about the horrors of genocide and has incredible influence in the US to shift the toxic policy it currently has towards Israel.
@@SuperKripke So what do you want him to make a movie about it? He's a filmmaker not a politician.
No matter how many creative marketing happens... if a movie SUCKS liek this one, it will stay SUCK.
You know what sucks? Your grammar. Liek?!
What sucks about it please?
Seeing Spielberg interview Scorsese ruined this film for me.
Why?
Chill your juvenile mind.
It looks your pills stopped having effect. Sorry for that.
Why? If anything I want to see this movie again
what 😭
Christopher Nolan has easily overtaken these guys. In fact Spielberg was always a sentimental hack that appealed to the average dumb American movie goer. Even his serious movies are filled with cringe 😂
I really enjoy Nolan’s movies but there’s no way he’s better then Scorsese or more successful then Spielberg. Today he is a top 3 director but Scorsese and Spielberg are all time greats.
@@karansoni909 Quantity does correlate to quality. Spielberg has made many many trash movies whereas Nolan hasn't made one. Schindler's List was cringe, Spielberg was a typical stupid American taking something like the Holocaust and telling a feel good one man saving a few Jews story out of it lmao. That's his worst movie. Spielberg was the biggest director in the world at that point and he could've had the power to make a proper Holocaust movie but he didn't.
Scorsese is good but not on Nolan's level, that's a fact.
@@karansoni909 Yeah, it's his biggest cringe movie. It's a bigger atrocity than his mediocre blockbuster movies. Go watch the short clip of Terry Gilliam's views on Spielberg and Schindlers List which explains my feelings on that movie and what's wrong with it.
@@elonif4125 Nolan just turned a 3 hour talky biopic into a near billion dollar movie. That's something Spielberg and Scorsese in their prime never came close to doing. Those two guys like most directors are just journeymen directors who just pick up a book or screenplay with no input. Nolan is an actual storyteller and it shows considering he went to a world class university studying English. He's numerous classes above Scorsese and Spielberg it's not even close lol.
Spielberg's best movie is Jaws, which was a long time ago.
He didn't thank me when I told him that back in 2016.
felt bad for ernest , i don't think he was 100 % well, either from the war (though the was a cook) or just some mental health , i wanna know more about his background before saying he was this spineless guy even if the may be true its quite easy to say ... he felt like an good guy , pure but with something bodering him from within. along with external situations , did anyone even him knew he wasn't 100 % well and stable ? he lost as much as anyone in the movie , my guess and opinion :)
Spielberg offers Marty his sweeties, Marty declines.
Where was this?
Directors Guild in LA
on earth