The first QQ always fascinated me. The thought of making that kind of choice is so intriguing. When the prequel books were announce, so many people clambered for books based around Haymitch's games and I felt like the outlier wanting the first quell represented.
@@EdTheCreator I agree and in one of the books we even had a quick summary of it I would however love to watch a movie on his games just not necessarily spend the time reading when I know the outcome
I think a book/film based on the 1st Quarter Quell would be extraordinary, just thinking of the raw emotional overtones of the story. Forcing parents to choose which of their children will die is just wild.
District 2* as they won the first quarter quell and would have most likely won the 3rd Quarter quell, due to their only competition being Fenic, who would most likely have been killed by Katnas, due to Snow wanting everyone to hate Katnas before they killed her.
@@jamesvas6986 District 2 would have most likely won the third Quarter quell if it didn't end early for the reasons I stated above, district 2 deserves the credit for the third quarter quell instead of District 12.
@@freddiemedley5580 Peeta killed Brutus (D2 M) and Enobaria (D2 F) has no allies left she was the easiest target at that point, D12 was the only district to still have both tributes alive which means better chances of winning. The games ended before only one tribute remained so victory goes to D12 for surviving without losing a tribute. D2 comes second place after Brutus died.
I personally think that the tributes in this Quarter Quell would likely be made of: A: Victors Children B: Children of Criminals from a said District C: Juveniles Or D: The Children of the Mayor
*child sees parents put their name in* child: hUH *day of reaping* "this child and this child will be in the games" child:hUUUUh *child hides and kills last person* *child in victors village* *someone knocks on door* mom: why didn't you take us to live with you? child: um because-
Maybe they just voted normally or something, or try something different with voting, like you can’t vote your own child. The Capitol turns a blind eye but they are fully aware of them.
As horrible as this whole thing is... I'd probably vote for the two strongest kids in the district (despite losing at least one of them). At least because I'd think "well, they've got a better chance to win than some of the other kids..."
@@eduardoduc-bonilla5540 Her case was different. She got a beef with mayor's daughter and then her father rigged the reaping for that. People in district(generally) didn't hate Lucy Gray They were not her biggest fans too but they were mostly neutral to her I guess.
If i was thinking logically and didnt care about the children or a anything at all probably 1 strong older child and 1 weaker younger child. The older child would use the younger as a sheild of sorts or a tool to win the game, and If they win the district will be richer and it would be good (ofc the younger child would probably die) but that just seems like a logical choice, so they're not wasting an extra person that would die anyways but using a waste of time for the other tributes.
I love that the idea of the quarter quell is to calm any rebellions, but the 3rd quarter quell not only did the exact opposite, it pissed off a fair share of Capitol people too
I suspect that the 3rd Quarter Quell's gimmick was changed in a desperate attempt to target and get rid of Katniss specifically because by all means, the gimmick they went with fundamentally contradicts "the point" or "fairness" of the games. Winning the games is supposed to give you access to becoming a member of the Capitol's class. "To become one of them" is a "reward" that helps even the Capitol's own people in accepting and rationalizing the sheer violence and dehumanization that happens during the game's process. The notion helps paint the games as a tradition even, a rite of passege that grants a tribute the opportunity of being a darling or honorary memeber of the Capitol. It gives the Capitol this false sense of mercy towards the one's they put in this sacrificial spectacle. Long story short, the 3rd Quarter Quell's gimmick spat even at the believes of the people that thought the games were fair or needed. So, I think it was an extreme miscalculation on Snow's part. He neglected even the favor of the Capitol's people, further fanning the flames of his own downfall.
Never thought about that!! Imagine winning and coming back to the very same district that put you in the arena. If it were me I would be like "I hope your all happy when your children/siblings/you are reaped!!"
could you imagine if a victor in that situation was from District 12? They could "rub salt in the wounds" when they seen some one in need. Meaning say they see some one hungry, "Oh you need food? Wait you voted for me to die, starve!!!"
I saw a fan-made video of the first Quarter Quell. One character said he was voted to go in because his dad had an affair with the mayor's wife and was therefore disliked within the district.
I imagine that they had all the children there and each person had to stand behind the tribute they wanted to send. Just so everyone could see who everyone voted for. And the child would also know. This would create even more distrust. Becuse the votes would be public.
That sounds like an idea the Capitol would have. But do you mean only the other possible tributes voted or the entire population of the district? I ask since I was also wondering about that.
And then face their parents. They'd have a suspicion that it was you, because their kid was always mean with you, and they'd always be thinking "that kid sent my child to die. Why do I have to suffer while his parents have nothing to fear? How could they birth such a monster!"
@@manuekhuntyk2563 what do you mean "it was you"? it's a voting system. So if they do get sent in, it's because other people voted for them too. Which means you can't, by definition, be singled out as "the one" who sent their kid to die.
Or, the capitol could just have some pre-detemined people such as one who did crime, or something else so that the districts don't have to vote for their children
i think they would still make the district vote in order to get through the message capitol was trying to send out that quarter quell, then rig the whole thing and throw whoever they want into the game
@@stickmanguy5583 I just find it so hard to believe that of all people to die she was one of them, and it could have been avoided if coin hadn’t have given the order to send her into combat, knowing she was going to die after the second bombs went off. I can’t even watch the final movie because of it😭
I’d assume that the Panem government would use a shortlist of people that would be considered undesirables: juvenile delinquents, subversives, etc, with the former getting a reduction in sentence to time served, or parole.
@Richard Roxburg Effie I hate to admit that she is not real though I wish she was I meant she was the first how do I put it she was the first real person I have seen that can rock it
What if everyone in the district agreed to opt for tesserae every day and then everyone has again equal chances for the games again whilst having tons of food
I would think that the tributes from Districts 1, 2, and 4 would be pre-determined. Remember, they go through training until they are 18, at which point they volunteer. I assume the volunteers are the strongest male and female student, so I figure they'd already announce within those three districts who the strongest are, so it's not really a vote. Either that, or the kids campaign to be chosen! If it were me, I'd probably choose to send in the kids that had the best chance of winning. I feel like that's the only way a lot of these people could live with themselves. At least they could tell themselves they didn't use the vote to act maliciously to give into the worst of themselves. I think you'd have to be careful that way too, though. If the 74th Hunger Games was the first Quarter Quell, then going by physicality and best chance to win, I probably would've voted for Gale. He would've had a really good chance. However, he also disses the Capitol and openly scorns them all the time, and I doubt Snow would want someone like that to win, so sending in a kid just by physicality may not be the best move if the president is going to rig things. Just my thoughts.
In the career districts some people would certainly do a election campaign to secure votes. Because they want all the glory. Well depending on, if volunteering was disabled for the year.
Hopefully knowing that I'm an invisible no-one, I would put my name in praying that no one else voted for me, so I don't have to live with the guilt with voting for someone else.
I always thought that this year the adults voted lol. Since the reason for this reaping twist was to remind the districts that their children died because of the adults. They would probably vote the stronger/ older children tbh. I always assumed the majority of the tributes were bigger especially the districts whose tributes tend to be traditionally smaller like district 12.
People would maybe vote for the richest families child. Like the Mayors daughter for instance. Maybe they could ask if anyone wanted to volunteer and they could vote for one of the volunteers. Or some rich families could offer money or food for those who voted for a certain child.
There should be a book about Haymitch's Quarter Quell written from Haymitch's perspective and then continue on after the games for his victory tour and his first couple mentorships
If I was in the hunger games I would learn all the survival skills I could in the training center, turn the careers on each other, then hide till there was only one other person left. To win I would take a parachute, put night lock in it and the tribute would eat it. P.S. I love your channel, it’s super underrated
If you were a career you can get out lots of tesserae so that you have lots of votes and then give the tesserae to people who need it, although I am not sure whether the people in the career districts will need it
The Captiol can probably rig the Reaping whenever they want, I remember Katniss saying that the children of Victor's get reaped too often to be a coincidence. Just replace all of the slips in the bowl so they have the same name/names of whoever they're targeting. I guess you could also instruct the escort to announce a certain name no matter what the slip says, since we don't see them check the slip in the books or movies, but the less people involved the better.
If you've watched all the movies you should know what happens but basically they go on something called the Victor's tour where they go to every district and give a speech out and then there are interviews and after your a mentor for the rest of your life
I'd like to think I wouldn't be chosen, seeing as I try my very hardest to be nice to everyone. I would probably vote for a random kid who probably wouldn't get picked, so I wouldn't be a deciding factor. This year would hopefully be a breeze, as I hope no one would pick me. Great video as always, stay safe!💗
I bet the winner of the first quarter quell was dead before the events of Catching Fire. Just imagine coming home to your district that voted for you, likely because they didn't like you. Then they cheer when you come home but you don't see it as sincere. You settle in the victors village but you don't have any friends in the district, you never had. Your distaste for the district grows, so does your depression. You start drinking and taking drugs, all alone. One day you take too much. For weeks no one knows you are gone since you never get any visitors. A short memorial is held in the capitol
There’s one other thing that bugs me-who all gets to vote? I mean, definitely the adults, but what about the 12-18 y/o kids? Do they get to vote as well? And what about kids younger than them?
5:05 a thing they might do, out of resentment, is send the kids with better económical situation, like Madge, for being less probable to be selected, since they don't need the extra food. But their families would know, and since they are in power, they could create even harsher conditions for the district
I think the capital would make a HUGE show out of the voting for the entire year. Sure the first vote would be a bunch of names in the bucket. But then It would kind of be like the TV competition shows we have now. You get your final 50, re-vote and get top 25. Then you get into the top 10 and do shows on each person. Then on the day of the reaping, you vote on the top 3. I think the capital would make it as hard as possible of the district residence, with the most entertainment for the capital citizens.
Wow, I never thought about that but it sounds very convincing. Maybe this was also the time when the Capitol's focus shifted from punishment of the districts to entertainment for the Capitol's citizens.
@@theresaalbert3915 Yeah I agree with the entertainment part. We learned in ballad of S&S that nobody in the capital really cared. This was the 10th games and it was when the 1st interest started to be shown from capital citizens. The first 10 games were simply punishment to the districts. So I'm sure 15 years later, at the 25th games, they had the capital citizens 100% on board and ready for some bloodlust voting competition shows.....and I bet almost anything, the capital allowed the capital citizens to vote who they wanted in from one for the districts. (Unbeknownst to that district of course). Could you imagine, its the 22 districts picks vs the 2 capital picks. It would draw huge ratings and lots of bets. We need more in the young snow series. There was alot of insight and so much more to explore.
Unfortunately I haven't read the Ballad yet, but how you describe it makes a lot of sense (I didn't feel spoilered by what you wrote, don't worry). There could even been some sort of protest in the Capitol in the beginning, demanding to end the games after a decade maybe. But that's only my theory, I really have to read the book 😄 The theory with the Capitol votes also sounds very interesting. That could well be a thing. I could also imagine a pre-selection from which the Capitol citizens could choose, as their votes should not be spread out over the whole population of a district.
I watch this channel which is doing every hunger games arena/ reaping and events. There about an hour long, but it’s really good. It might answer some questions of past games
Given that the hunger games goes to 18, being disliked is probably more than just "annoying" at that point. I'm sure there are young adults that have a reputation for being cruel and violent so I'd vote for them, not the 12-year-old who won't sit still in class and says rude things.
A question I have is who would be able to vote. I’d assume it’d be everyone older than 18 who is ineligible, but if the people who could get sent could vote that would be a whole extra level of strategy. I also wonder about what it’d be like in the career districts where it’s seen as an honor to go to the games. You’d think that they’d pick the strongest ones that usually volunteer, but I’d think there’d be some proud parents who’d try to mess things up
I have also been wondering about who is allowed to vote. Maybe all the kids could vote, too, once they turned twelve since they also could sign up for Tessera then. It could give them the feeling of being less powerless as usual but on the other hand they have to live with the burden they might have sentenced someone to death, even though it is not their fault. I could totally see this cruelty installed by the Capital. For the Career Districts I agree with you. The trainers of the training centers might recommend certain teenagers and depending on the district size there might even be previous tests for the tributes to select the two most suitable ones. Of course there will be some super proud people who think they know better but considering that sending the victorious tribute will benefit all of them, they would probably be a minority.
I never thought of the point about tesserae. Maybe if you chose to take it, the amount of votes for you (if any) would be doubled? If you take it twice, it's tripled etc. so you're putting yourself more at risk, just like a standard year? Oh and regarding who I'd vote for, I wouldn't go based on physical or mental attributes, but simply the person I disliked the most at the time, which I'd base on how arrogant and/or two-faced they were around the district!
Honestly, I wouldn't send in the strongest because we would need them in the district. I would probably send in someone closer to like 14 or 15 because they still have a chance to win at that age. I wouldn't do the most annoying kid because they can annoy the capital later on, and I would vote for someone who has a chance, slim or big, to win
Nightlock. I would use nightlock because I have the worst guilt ever, and I could never make that decision. Nightlock would honestly be the most painless way to go in such a terrible society.
I would think that there would be two votings per district, one for girls and one for boys. I would decide to send a strong male, best chance, and a girl that is known for her smarts, so that I have someone who can win thanks to strenght and brutality and someone who can win because she's very intelligent.
I'd try to figure out whom other people would decide to for - chances are that someone will put my name in, so the only chance I'd have to not get sent into the Hunger Games would be if someone else had more votes than me. Therefore I'd vote for the probably most voted for kid as well, hoping they'd have more votes than me in the end, no matter who that kid is.
Amazing video as always! 🌹 Two questions just popped in my mind though..and I'd be curious to see what you guys think : -What if boys were reaped before girls for the 74th Hunger Games and Peeta and Prim names came out? Would Katniss still volunteer for her sister when we know she recognized Peeta instantly in the canon story? - Why did Peeta volunteer to take Haymitch's place for the quarter quell? Was it because he felt obligated to keep up with the starcrossed lovers act? Was it to be with Katniss? Was it because he didn't trust Haymitch enough to let Katniss win if it came to that? A mix of all this or completely something else?
It was because Haymitch would be no help in the arena because hes an alcoholic and not physically that strong. Also it works better because Haymitch can help them on the outside while peeta helps her on the inside
+3rdEye Lenny My thoughts exactly. Maybe everyone that year- parents and children alike- were entitled to Tesserae free of charge to help pacify the district's during the high pressure and high stress voting system, and incentivise them to vote more than once. Here, the Tesserae pays for itself in the tough choice of votes against someone else. Like, instead of a strike against your name, it's a strike against someone else's of your choice. Each month of Tesserae counts as a vote, so every month every citizen can opt to vote more than once to gain more grain and oil, for once allowing the District's to *"Capitalise"* on food rations. Safe to say those that entered 12 votes (1 for each month of the year in the lead up to the Q.Q) would be relatively well fed. _"You voted? Here, take Tesserae in exchange."_ It would encourage people. To make it even more sadistic, what if every time you voted against someone and gained more Tesserae, an entry of your name was subtracted from the pool? That would be a further incentive. You could hypothetically have your own name removed up to 12 times that year! *Horribly, it might even help the district's to understand and empathize with the Capitol's tyranny.*
If I were in the games I’d bring a beaded bracelet and throw the beads in front of the other tributes during the countdown and jump off myself,if my family gets punished oh well 🙄
I think in the corriere (if that's how you spell it) districts, they would see being voted into the games as a huge privilege and honour and it may turn into a bit of a popularity contest. They would also probably choose to send in the strongest and most skilled children, as they have been training in the academies (unless they didn't have academies 25 years into the hunger games?)
I believe that there would first be nominees of who they would vote for. And then the citizens get a choice to vote out of the couple nominees. In certain districts like 11, the nominees would probably be rebellious children since their district is very strict. In district 2, they would probably nominate the strongest children.
It’s a very interesting subject. I was thinking about other ways they might do this. Not canon, of course. They could do it the way you described where the winner is the one with the most votes OR they could have everyone vote and put the papers in the bowl and do it like a “normal” reaping. I wonder which would be more psychologically harmful to the citizens.
Question do you still believe that Victor of hunger games will still obtain monetary value from capital despite being in district control. Especially since Peter and Katniss will give one month of there Victor money to tribute every year.
I’m not sure if you have done a video in this already, but I was wondering for the hunger games, what was meant to happen in catching fire/ what would have happened if katniss didn’t destroy the arena? Would more people have died and there only been one winner, or all the survivors still survived? - I’m also sorry if this is explained in the book, I haven’t got time to read it yet!
That's interesting, because especially in the bigger districts, you don't know all the children and families... can you vote for someone who's name you probably never heard of, and hope you will never have to face the family? Also, I can imagine that they made the family very prominent and ever-present in the district, as a reminder for everyone who voted for their kid to die. Also, imagine winning the games and coming back to you home and to the people who decided you should participate in the games...
Video idea: what would have happened if katniss killed finnick when he tried to revive peeta, what would have happpened if wires didn’t figure out the arena was a clock and what would have happened if wiress, beetee and Johanna had died in the blood rain. Also I love your channel x 🥰
If you want to know what I would write on my vote sheet “I don’t hate anyone that much” and the capitol would probably kill me or put me in the games anyway for that, but I wouldn’t be able to live with the guilt if I’d voted for a person.
I'm pretty sure the capitol put up list somewhere of where or who you voted for. Just for tension between the citizens to sow distrust and to keep the citizens divided.
I can imagine career district kids campaigning to be tributes.....
HAHA - Cato for the Hunger Games!
@@hogondoz_7522 vote CATO and he will bring your district glory!
Lmaoooo
I would pay good money to see that
Welcome to the first Tributional debate!
The first QQ always fascinated me. The thought of making that kind of choice is so intriguing. When the prequel books were announce, so many people clambered for books based around Haymitch's games and I felt like the outlier wanting the first quell represented.
@@ThatFreakingGinger being as we know the winner and the full ending, it doesn’t feel all that necessary lol
@@EdTheCreator I agree and in one of the books we even had a quick summary of it
I would however love to watch a movie on his games just not necessarily spend the time reading when I know the outcome
YES
I think a book/film based on the 1st Quarter Quell would be extraordinary, just thinking of the raw emotional overtones of the story.
Forcing parents to choose which of their children will die is just wild.
District 12 has won more Quarter quells than any other district.
District 2* as they won the first quarter quell and would have most likely won the 3rd Quarter quell, due to their only competition being Fenic, who would most likely have been killed by Katnas, due to Snow wanting everyone to hate Katnas before they killed her.
@@freddiemedley5580 no it’s district 12 lol, they’re had 3 tributes survive a quarter quell lol
@@jamesvas6986 District 2 would have most likely won the third Quarter quell if it didn't end early for the reasons I stated above, district 2 deserves the credit for the third quarter quell instead of District 12.
@@freddiemedley5580a district 11 male won the first quarter quell
@@freddiemedley5580 Peeta killed Brutus (D2 M) and Enobaria (D2 F) has no allies left she was the easiest target at that point, D12 was the only district to still have both tributes alive which means better chances of winning. The games ended before only one tribute remained so victory goes to D12 for surviving without losing a tribute. D2 comes second place after Brutus died.
I personally think that the tributes in this Quarter Quell would likely be made of:
A: Victors Children
B: Children of Criminals from a said District
C: Juveniles
Or D: The Children of the Mayor
what do you mean by juveniles?
@@gracer1996 prob the younger half of 12-18 so like 12-14
@@Axe-tj7ktyea i don’t agree but i think that’s what this person meant. idk what else they could have meant
@@reeferbonesit probably means criminals like kids in juvie
@@gracer1996criminals that are children basically
Imagine getting voted by your own family.
And you win... No victors village for you!
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣so tru
Ikr lmao
I would NEVER give my family a place in my Victor’s Village house. NEVER.
Whoa, 400 likes? Thanks!
*child sees parents put their name in*
child: hUH
*day of reaping*
"this child and this child will be in the games"
child:hUUUUh
*child hides and kills last person*
*child in victors village*
*someone knocks on door*
mom: why didn't you take us to live with you?
child: um because-
I'm very curious to know how the career districts would do this. Would they vote for themselves and get their families to vote for them as well?
Maybe they just voted normally or something, or try something different with voting, like you can’t vote your own child. The Capitol turns a blind eye but they are fully aware of them.
I dont think there were as much careers in the 25th.
@@goodnight-moon564 I dont think there were as much careers in the 25th.
@Awesome Ibaadut they probably put in a provision that said volunteering would not be allowed for those games.
Campaign for that like you’re campaigning for class president or sumn
As horrible as this whole thing is... I'd probably vote for the two strongest kids in the district (despite losing at least one of them). At least because I'd think "well, they've got a better chance to win than some of the other kids..."
Agreed
Same I think that why haymitch was chosen
@@user-jp6zl5yd1h Haymitch was not voted... He was reaped on the 2nd quarter quell. (X2 tributes).
@@stickmanguy5583 oh yeah I mixed up the quarter quells thanks so much
@@user-jp6zl5yd1h No worries.
I wonder what the Victor felt like knowing his district wanted him dead and he had to go back knowing some voted for him
Lucy Gray
@@eduardoduc-bonilla5540 Her case was different.
She got a beef with mayor's daughter and then her father rigged the reaping for that.
People in district(generally) didn't hate Lucy Gray
They were not her biggest fans too but they were mostly neutral to her I guess.
I think that the children of the more wealthy families would be targeted as they never had to put their names in more times
The comment about vote counting taking a while made me laugh😂.
me too lol
Lol
I would vote for myself
If i was thinking logically and didnt care about the children or a anything at all probably 1 strong older child and 1 weaker younger child.
The older child would use the younger as a sheild of sorts or a tool to win the game, and If they win the district will be richer and it would be good (ofc the younger child would probably die) but that just seems like a logical choice, so they're not wasting an extra person that would die anyways but using a waste of time for the other tributes.
Smart decision.
But it’s still horrible
Plot twist: weaker kids uses the stronger one as a shield
Wow.
When I hear that signature "hi friends" my mood changes so quickly.
imagine if they announced who voted for who at the end and you coukd see who voted for you/ the person you voted for could see that you voted for them
You would either be really pleased because they thought you could win, or really angry because they thought you weren’t a big loss
I don’t think they would do that cuz this is panem not among is
WOAAAAH
I love that the idea of the quarter quell is to calm any rebellions, but the 3rd quarter quell not only did the exact opposite, it pissed off a fair share of Capitol people too
I suspect that the 3rd Quarter Quell's gimmick was changed in a desperate attempt to target and get rid of Katniss specifically because by all means, the gimmick they went with fundamentally contradicts "the point" or "fairness" of the games. Winning the games is supposed to give you access to becoming a member of the Capitol's class. "To become one of them" is a "reward" that helps even the Capitol's own people in accepting and rationalizing the sheer violence and dehumanization that happens during the game's process. The notion helps paint the games as a tradition even, a rite of passege that grants a tribute the opportunity of being a darling or honorary memeber of the Capitol. It gives the Capitol this false sense of mercy towards the one's they put in this sacrificial spectacle.
Long story short, the 3rd Quarter Quell's gimmick spat even at the believes of the people that thought the games were fair or needed. So, I think it was an extreme miscalculation on Snow's part. He neglected even the favor of the Capitol's people, further fanning the flames of his own downfall.
IN THE CAREER DISTRICTS IT WOULD BE LIKE AN ELECTION HAHAHHA WITH EVERYONE CAMPAIGNING FOR THEMSELVES
Story Diver: *Talks about the voting of children who will most probably die in a gruesome and bloody way*
Also Story Diver: H A P P Y B U B B L E S
Kids in district 2-12: wait, you’ve been doing this the entire time
Kids in district 1: you haven’t
Oh my god if I was here I'd be voted into the games cuz I'm the most outspoken person ever, and I would talk trash about this government.
Same
But you would be killed by a game maker if you say garbage about the government
@@grahamfaulkner3969 no you become an avox (the Capitol cut out your tongue so you can’t talk)
@@aAdjnks no, thats if you’re not reaped however if you are reaped to become a tribute best believe you’ll have one of the worst deaths in the games.
@@tsuyuasui7297 oh yeah I was tallking from the POV your not in the games
Never thought about that!! Imagine winning and coming back to the very same district that put you in the arena. If it were me I would be like "I hope your all happy when your children/siblings/you are reaped!!"
could you imagine if a victor in that situation was from District 12? They could "rub salt in the wounds" when they seen some one in need. Meaning say they see some one hungry, "Oh you need food? Wait you voted for me to die, starve!!!"
The idea of sending in an annoying brat only to see them win epicly and come back like a hero being a reason not to send them was funny haha
I saw a fan-made video of the first Quarter Quell. One character said he was voted to go in because his dad had an affair with the mayor's wife and was therefore disliked within the district.
I imagine that they had all the children there and each person had to stand behind the tribute they wanted to send. Just so everyone could see who everyone voted for. And the child would also know. This would create even more distrust. Becuse the votes would be public.
That sounds like an idea the Capitol would have. But do you mean only the other possible tributes voted or the entire population of the district? I ask since I was also wondering about that.
If I could vote who got be part of the Quarter Quell, I would’ve picked my bullies 😂🤣
And then face their parents. They'd have a suspicion that it was you, because their kid was always mean with you, and they'd always be thinking "that kid sent my child to die. Why do I have to suffer while his parents have nothing to fear? How could they birth such a monster!"
@@manuekhuntyk2563 what do you mean "it was you"? it's a voting system. So if they do get sent in, it's because other people voted for them too. Which means you can't, by definition, be singled out as "the one" who sent their kid to die.
But imagine if they won and become richer and more famous than you😭
Or, the capitol could just have some pre-detemined people such as one who did crime, or something else so that the districts don't have to vote for their children
i think they would still make the district vote in order to get through the message capitol was trying to send out that quarter quell, then rig the whole thing and throw whoever they want into the game
I will never get over prim’s death. She was the whole reason behind everything and now she’s gone😢❤️
Think about this: if katniss would have never volunteered, it would have made no difference because Prim does anyway.
@@stickmanguy5583 I just find it so hard to believe that of all people to die she was one of them, and it could have been avoided if coin hadn’t have given the order to send her into combat, knowing she was going to die after the second bombs went off. I can’t even watch the final movie because of it😭
@@aaronward13 It's sad ain't it.
@@aaronward13 yeah but it had to happen for the story
so was Rue.
I’d assume that the Panem government would use a shortlist of people that would be considered undesirables: juvenile delinquents, subversives, etc, with the former getting a reduction in sentence to time served, or parole.
I really like the idea of sending an orphan. They don’t have anybody that would grieve for them and they don’t have to struggle through life
your the first person i have ever seen that can rock any colour lipstick
Thank you!
@Richard Roxburg Effie I hate to admit that she is not real though I wish she was I meant she was the first how do I put it she was the first real person I have seen that can rock it
What if everyone in the district agreed to opt for tesserae every day and then everyone has again equal chances for the games again whilst having tons of food
I would think that the tributes from Districts 1, 2, and 4 would be pre-determined. Remember, they go through training until they are 18, at which point they volunteer. I assume the volunteers are the strongest male and female student, so I figure they'd already announce within those three districts who the strongest are, so it's not really a vote. Either that, or the kids campaign to be chosen!
If it were me, I'd probably choose to send in the kids that had the best chance of winning. I feel like that's the only way a lot of these people could live with themselves. At least they could tell themselves they didn't use the vote to act maliciously to give into the worst of themselves.
I think you'd have to be careful that way too, though. If the 74th Hunger Games was the first Quarter Quell, then going by physicality and best chance to win, I probably would've voted for Gale. He would've had a really good chance. However, he also disses the Capitol and openly scorns them all the time, and I doubt Snow would want someone like that to win, so sending in a kid just by physicality may not be the best move if the president is going to rig things. Just my thoughts.
In the career districts some people would certainly do a election campaign to secure votes. Because they want all the glory. Well depending on, if volunteering was disabled for the year.
I was looking for the same topic and it just appeared
WHAT A COINCIDENT
Hi
lol
I think I would just decide who screwed the district over the most.
In the career this be pretty normal event popularity contest
While the poor ones it be unpopularity contest
And the middle a mix of both
Hopefully knowing that I'm an invisible no-one, I would put my name in praying that no one else voted for me, so I don't have to live with the guilt with voting for someone else.
I always thought that this year the adults voted lol. Since the reason for this reaping twist was to remind the districts that their children died because of the adults. They would probably vote the stronger/ older children tbh. I always assumed the majority of the tributes were bigger especially the districts whose tributes tend to be traditionally smaller like district 12.
People would maybe vote for the richest families child. Like the Mayors daughter for instance.
Maybe they could ask if anyone wanted to volunteer and they could vote for one of the volunteers.
Or some rich families could offer money or food for those who voted for a certain child.
There should be a book about Haymitch's Quarter Quell written from Haymitch's perspective and then continue on after the games for his victory tour and his first couple mentorships
If I was in the hunger games I would learn all the survival skills I could in the training center, turn the careers on each other, then hide till there was only one other person left. To win I would take a parachute, put night lock in it and the tribute would eat it.
P.S. I love your channel, it’s super underrated
If you were a career you can get out lots of tesserae so that you have lots of votes and then give the tesserae to people who need it, although I am not sure whether the people in the career districts will need it
The Captiol can probably rig the Reaping whenever they want, I remember Katniss saying that the children of Victor's get reaped too often to be a coincidence. Just replace all of the slips in the bowl so they have the same name/names of whoever they're targeting. I guess you could also instruct the escort to announce a certain name no matter what the slip says, since we don't see them check the slip in the books or movies, but the less people involved the better.
Imagine voting for someone you don’t like and they come back and win. Facing them like
“Ohhh heyyy yeah I voted for you to die.”
Could you do a video talking about the process that happens after a victor wins
If you've watched all the movies you should know what happens but basically they go on something called the Victor's tour where they go to every district and give a speech out and then there are interviews and after your a mentor for the rest of your life
They could also send government officials children like Madge
I love how she said we all know how long it takes for votes to be counted
The districts that train to try to be in the hunger games would be like regular elections
great video as usual!
Thank you!
I'd like to think I wouldn't be chosen, seeing as I try my very hardest to be nice to everyone. I would probably vote for a random kid who probably wouldn't get picked, so I wouldn't be a deciding factor. This year would hopefully be a breeze, as I hope no one would pick me. Great video as always, stay safe!💗
I bet the winner of the first quarter quell was dead before the events of Catching Fire. Just imagine coming home to your district that voted for you, likely because they didn't like you. Then they cheer when you come home but you don't see it as sincere. You settle in the victors village but you don't have any friends in the district, you never had. Your distaste for the district grows, so does your depression. You start drinking and taking drugs, all alone. One day you take too much. For weeks no one knows you are gone since you never get any visitors. A short memorial is held in the capitol
There’s one other thing that bugs me-who all gets to vote? I mean, definitely the adults, but what about the 12-18 y/o kids? Do they get to vote as well? And what about kids younger than them?
could you please do a character spotlight for cashmere, gloss, enobaria, and brutus please when you get the chance! you’re amazing! thanks! ❤️
I have, they're posted on my Patreon page!
5:05 a thing they might do, out of resentment, is send the kids with better económical situation, like Madge, for being less probable to be selected, since they don't need the extra food. But their families would know, and since they are in power, they could create even harsher conditions for the district
I think the capital would make a HUGE show out of the voting for the entire year.
Sure the first vote would be a bunch of names in the bucket. But then It would kind of be like the TV competition shows we have now. You get your final 50, re-vote and get top 25. Then you get into the top 10 and do shows on each person. Then on the day of the reaping, you vote on the top 3.
I think the capital would make it as hard as possible of the district residence, with the most entertainment for the capital citizens.
Wow, I never thought about that but it sounds very convincing. Maybe this was also the time when the Capitol's focus shifted from punishment of the districts to entertainment for the Capitol's citizens.
@@theresaalbert3915 Yeah I agree with the entertainment part. We learned in ballad of S&S that nobody in the capital really cared. This was the 10th games and it was when the 1st interest started to be shown from capital citizens. The first 10 games were simply punishment to the districts. So I'm sure 15 years later, at the 25th games, they had the capital citizens 100% on board and ready for some bloodlust voting competition shows.....and I bet almost anything, the capital allowed the capital citizens to vote who they wanted in from one for the districts. (Unbeknownst to that district of course).
Could you imagine, its the 22 districts picks vs the 2 capital picks. It would draw huge ratings and lots of bets. We need more in the young snow series. There was alot of insight and so much more to explore.
Unfortunately I haven't read the Ballad yet, but how you describe it makes a lot of sense (I didn't feel spoilered by what you wrote, don't worry). There could even been some sort of protest in the Capitol in the beginning, demanding to end the games after a decade maybe. But that's only my theory, I really have to read the book 😄
The theory with the Capitol votes also sounds very interesting. That could well be a thing. I could also imagine a pre-selection from which the Capitol citizens could choose, as their votes should not be spread out over the whole population of a district.
The closed captions’ logic:
Tessarae = Testosterone.
Tesserae = Tesla.
It’s very simple science.
yEaHhH
Does, therefore, Testosterone = Tesla? Wow, the CC are so sexist
@@ihavelemonade5640 Very true. How sexist these captions are.
I watch this channel which is doing every hunger games arena/ reaping and events. There about an hour long, but it’s really good. It might answer some questions of past games
They're fanfiction
Given that the hunger games goes to 18, being disliked is probably more than just "annoying" at that point. I'm sure there are young adults that have a reputation for being cruel and violent so I'd vote for them, not the 12-year-old who won't sit still in class and says rude things.
A question I have is who would be able to vote. I’d assume it’d be everyone older than 18 who is ineligible, but if the people who could get sent could vote that would be a whole extra level of strategy.
I also wonder about what it’d be like in the career districts where it’s seen as an honor to go to the games. You’d think that they’d pick the strongest ones that usually volunteer, but I’d think there’d be some proud parents who’d try to mess things up
I have also been wondering about who is allowed to vote. Maybe all the kids could vote, too, once they turned twelve since they also could sign up for Tessera then. It could give them the feeling of being less powerless as usual but on the other hand they have to live with the burden they might have sentenced someone to death, even though it is not their fault. I could totally see this cruelty installed by the Capital.
For the Career Districts I agree with you. The trainers of the training centers might recommend certain teenagers and depending on the district size there might even be previous tests for the tributes to select the two most suitable ones. Of course there will be some super proud people who think they know better but considering that sending the victorious tribute will benefit all of them, they would probably be a minority.
We all know a kid or two that people would gladly vote in......
I love how you make videos about what I didnt even notice..
I never thought of the point about tesserae. Maybe if you chose to take it, the amount of votes for you (if any) would be doubled? If you take it twice, it's tripled etc. so you're putting yourself more at risk, just like a standard year?
Oh and regarding who I'd vote for, I wouldn't go based on physical or mental attributes, but simply the person I disliked the most at the time, which I'd base on how arrogant and/or two-faced they were around the district!
First! I never realized that either! I think you had a cool theory! :D also your ideas were so cool for the quinquennial quells :)
Honestly, I wouldn't send in the strongest because we would need them in the district. I would probably send in someone closer to like 14 or 15 because they still have a chance to win at that age. I wouldn't do the most annoying kid because they can annoy the capital later on, and I would vote for someone who has a chance, slim or big, to win
You are the only person I’ve ever seen who makes green lipstick look AMAZING
Thank you so much ☺️
@@StoryDiver OMG thank you so much for the ❤️ and the reply
I would tell my hole district too vote themselves so the capital would get tricked and they choose again
Nightlock. I would use nightlock because I have the worst guilt ever, and I could never make that decision. Nightlock would honestly be the most painless way to go in such a terrible society.
Oh Story Diver.
I need your reaction to The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes trailer!!
I would vote for someone who isn’t likely to get nearly enough votes so my vote wouldn’t matter.
Sameee gurl my wittle primrose winkle crinkle Louie buggy 🤪
I love your channel❤❤
Thank you!
I would think that there would be two votings per district, one for girls and one for boys. I would decide to send a strong male, best chance, and a girl that is known for her smarts, so that I have someone who can win thanks to strenght and brutality and someone who can win because she's very intelligent.
Finally a video talking about the 1st quartell quell
Districts would be trying to use it either using it to get rid of their unwanted . Or they would vote for who will be their best chance of winning .
What do you think the original 3 quarter quell idea was ??
ua-cam.com/video/cnFTsFvFIpM/v-deo.html She made a video about it already.
I'd try to figure out whom other people would decide to for - chances are that someone will put my name in, so the only chance I'd have to not get sent into the Hunger Games would be if someone else had more votes than me. Therefore I'd vote for the probably most voted for kid as well, hoping they'd have more votes than me in the end, no matter who that kid is.
Amazing video as always! 🌹
Two questions just popped in my mind though..and I'd be curious to see what you guys think :
-What if boys were reaped before girls for the 74th Hunger Games and Peeta and Prim names came out? Would Katniss still volunteer for her sister when we know she recognized Peeta instantly in the canon story?
- Why did Peeta volunteer to take Haymitch's place for the quarter quell? Was it because he felt obligated to keep up with the starcrossed lovers act? Was it to be with Katniss? Was it because he didn't trust Haymitch enough to let Katniss win if it came to that? A mix of all this or completely something else?
It was because Haymitch would be no help in the arena because hes an alcoholic and not physically that strong. Also it works better because Haymitch can help them on the outside while peeta helps her on the inside
you should do an analysis on the 50th hunger games!
who won the 25th Hunger games?
Canonically, it’s unknown
There’s this guy that puts out like fanfic games, it’s pretty cool
@@temo4901 are you talking about the tales of the hunger games series? I love watching those
@@NicoNeoX YESS
For the first quarter quell tesserae it would probably be each tesserae is an extra vote for you
+3rdEye Lenny My thoughts exactly. Maybe everyone that year- parents and children alike- were entitled to Tesserae free of charge to help pacify the district's during the high pressure and high stress voting system, and incentivise them to vote more than once. Here, the Tesserae pays for itself in the tough choice of votes against someone else. Like, instead of a strike against your name, it's a strike against someone else's of your choice. Each month of Tesserae counts as a vote, so every month every citizen can opt to vote more than once to gain more grain and oil, for once allowing the District's to *"Capitalise"* on food rations.
Safe to say those that entered 12 votes (1 for each month of the year in the lead up to the Q.Q) would be relatively well fed.
_"You voted? Here, take Tesserae in exchange."_ It would encourage people.
To make it even more sadistic, what if every time you voted against someone and gained more Tesserae, an entry of your name was subtracted from the pool? That would be a further incentive. You could hypothetically have your own name removed up to 12 times that year!
*Horribly, it might even help the district's to understand and empathize with the Capitol's tyranny.*
I think there would be no age limit so that way the unpopular would be voted of like criminals.
There had to of been the age limit in place. The capital wouldn’t care who went in. They put children in and arena who aren’t criminals
a really good quarter quell idea in the capitol's eyes would be a games with all 12-year-olds.
If I were in the games I’d bring a beaded bracelet and throw the beads in front of the other tributes during the countdown and jump off myself,if my family gets punished oh well 🙄
You’re a riot!!! 😆
Smart
What would happen to volunteers
I think in the corriere (if that's how you spell it) districts, they would see being voted into the games as a huge privilege and honour and it may turn into a bit of a popularity contest. They would also probably choose to send in the strongest and most skilled children, as they have been training in the academies (unless they didn't have academies 25 years into the hunger games?)
it’s career
Thant would make sense. Apologies.
I believe that there would first be nominees of who they would vote for. And then the citizens get a choice to vote out of the couple nominees. In certain districts like 11, the nominees would probably be rebellious children since their district is very strict. In district 2, they would probably nominate the strongest children.
I love the fact that the quarter quell are meant to quell uprising and the revolution happened/started during a quarter quell
I would do strongest male and most likeable/persuadable female. Strongest male so they might win with persuadble female to get sponsorships
I love your videos keep it up girl 👍🙏🏽💕
Thank you!
5:24 pls 😭😭😭
I love this video and your lipstick looks great!!
Thank you!
It’s a very interesting subject. I was thinking about other ways they might do this. Not canon, of course. They could do it the way you described where the winner is the one with the most votes OR they could have everyone vote and put the papers in the bowl and do it like a “normal” reaping. I wonder which would be more psychologically harmful to the citizens.
Question do you still believe that Victor of hunger games will still obtain monetary value from capital despite being in district control. Especially since Peter and Katniss will give one month of there Victor money to tribute every year.
I’m not sure if you have done a video in this already, but I was wondering for the hunger games, what was meant to happen in catching fire/ what would have happened if katniss didn’t destroy the arena? Would more people have died and there only been one winner, or all the survivors still survived? - I’m also sorry if this is explained in the book, I haven’t got time to read it yet!
great job on this! Big fan! Keep doing what you're doing.
1 dislike was president snow
you look like annie cresta :D
yay
What if there was a tie in the vote?
is it weird I have only ever seen the first movie but i still watch almost every hunger games story dive
i always look forward to your hunger games videos🥰🥰
Thank you!
@@StoryDiver ofc!!💕
I wonder if everyone casted their vote & it was put into the bowls like a regular reaping instead of being counted.
That's interesting, because especially in the bigger districts, you don't know all the children and families... can you vote for someone who's name you probably never heard of, and hope you will never have to face the family? Also, I can imagine that they made the family very prominent and ever-present in the district, as a reminder for everyone who voted for their kid to die.
Also, imagine winning the games and coming back to you home and to the people who decided you should participate in the games...
Video idea: what would have happened if katniss killed finnick when he tried to revive peeta, what would have happpened if wires didn’t figure out the arena was a clock and what would have happened if wiress, beetee and Johanna had died in the blood rain.
Also I love your channel x 🥰
If you want to know what I would write on my vote sheet “I don’t hate anyone that much” and the capitol would probably kill me or put me in the games anyway for that, but I wouldn’t be able to live with the guilt if I’d voted for a person.
I'm pretty sure the capitol put up list somewhere of where or who you voted for. Just for tension between the citizens to sow distrust and to keep the citizens divided.