This video was published August 1 2021 5:00pm (17:00) Central European Time I encourage you to turn on the english subtitles / Zachęcam do włączenia angielskich napisów This video is monetised. If you want to support my channel you can send me a donate (link in the discribtion)
Define "successfully", becouse the whole thing was a fucking disaster from day one. Such a shame that so many smart, young guys died there for nothing ;(
"I judged the Poles by their enemies. And I found it was an almost unfailing- truth that their enemies were the enemies of magna- nimity and manhood. If a man loved slavery, if he loved usury, if he loved terrorism and all the trampled mire of materialistic politics, I have always found that he added to these affections the passion of a hatred of Poland. She could be judged in the light of that hatred ; and the judgment has proved to be right.” G.K. Chesterton
Actual Wehrmacht casualties - 1570 killed and 9043 INJURED. Majority of civilians after few days were, to put it mildly, not happy about the uprising still going on (that is not so popular to say publicly). ~200.000 CIVILIANS WERE KILLED during the battles as well as MURDERED because of Himmler revenge decision + almost 90% of the city flatten. It was one of the biggest tragedy in Polish history. I hope we won't be in the same situation even again but please, wake up! People speaking about honor and bravery - think of these 200.000 people in basements, scared, alone and executed as well and not only about Polish soldiers with guns, flags and romantic picture of freedom.
5:48 I'm going to assume that only 100,000 people were left, but if it was indeed 100, dear god, the Warsaw population was wiped out, to be fair either way. The Nazis really were cruel and evil, slaughtering innocent people all for nothing.
After the uprising the Germans ordered all remaining residents to leave the city, and then systematically demolished more than 80% of the city's buildings down to their foundations. Some areas were apparently still being rebuilt into the 1980s. The value of the damages are estimated to be as high as 200 billion USD, and that isn't considering the irreplaceable cultural value of many of the 16 million books and other documents destroyed.
For reference, Hiroshima lost 140,000 as a direct result of the nuclear bomb over the course of two weeks, mostly civilians, while Warsaw lost 200,000. 1 million people died in Aushwitz, while 1 million people were killed or displaced from Warsaw throughout the war. Hard to see the Poles as anyone but pure victims from 1939 to 1989, even if the revolution wasn't planned. They payed the ultimate price for not surrendering.
Based on the what I know, the uprising was planned by people sitting in London who had no knowledge of the material conditions in the actual battlefield and weren't going to pay the price of failure either. The AK fighters thought that by launching it at the moment they would have been able to liberate Warsaw with help from the red army, but really the reason it was launched at that time was to bring back the government in exile and make sure the Soviets wouldn't have any rights to Western Ukraine and Belarus. So basically, the uprising's true goal was political, detached from reality and the fighters were betrayed by those who told them to do it.
@@gnas1897the war was planned by Poles. The plan was to shock german soldiers with an unexpected attack. The soviets were supposed to enter few Days after the start of the uprising. Stalin decided to blow the bridges up and wait for Poles to bleed.
Nikt nie żebrał o pomoc Czerwonej Zarazy, wręcz przeciwnie to Czerwona Zaraza fałszywie podjudzała Polaków do zbrojnego czynu: propaganda komuchów o AK stojącej z bronią u nogi, radiostacja Kościuszko wzywająca Warszawę do powstania, a do tego "sojusznicze" walki o Wilno, Lwów, boje 27 Wołyńskiej Dywizji AK, czy współdziałanie z sowiecką partyzantką samoobron otoczonych przez banderowskich morderców na Wołyniu - a po wspólnej walce sowiecka kula w łeb naiwnemu Polakowi, a w najlepszym razie zsyłka na tzw "Sybir"
🪖Ivan: Commander, we urgently need to help the rebel Poles! 👮🏻♂️Sergei: We will only have time to get to the river, but we will not have time to help the rebels, large Wehrmacht troops are already suppressing the uprising in the city, even if a small part of the rebels remains there, it will be pointless to cross the river to help... 🪖Ivan: *silently looked towards Warsaw, smoking from the fire* 👮🏻♂️Sergei: Don't be sad, sooner or later the enemy will lose and go to a fair court, you'll see... perhaps Poland will be given almost all of Germany's eastern lands, if of course Churchill allows it, I don't know for sure, everything will be clear after the war 🥸
@@Ulle2419 Bullshit. Stalin would've deported all those nationalists after the war anyways, so he figured he'd let the nazis do the dirty work for him. Nazi-soviet teamwork struck again, that's what happened.
There was no "deliberate delay" of the Soviet offensive. One day before the uprising, the Herman Goering division traveled through Warsaw to show that a Polish uprising was without any chance and in fact, the Germans carried a successful counter-offensive that pushed back red army far from Warsaw so when the Polish-Soviet army arrived on the right bank of Warsaw (where the AK the home army did not organise deliberately any uprising !!!), the Germans were already in full control of the left bank. From the very beginning this uprising was badly organised by military with only one obsession, not letting Soviets and Polish communists to take control of a functioning Polish capital city.
Huh after the war warsaw population dint exceed 100 the same thing happened in my city of Klaipėda after ww2. In 1939 there were 47,000 people but in january 1945 after the liberation there were only about 50 left
Could you do something like this, but about Slovak National Uprising, because its not very talked about but was pretty big resistance against German occupation.
@@Open_56 Probably all of mapping videos about WW2 shows Yogoslav partisans which were largest, but they don't show Slovak National Uprising, probably there were other big ones, but not shown
Bohaterom? 15 latkowie zrywający się na 16000 profesjonalnych żołnierzy z granatami zrobionymi z puszek po konserwach, przez których Niemcy obrócili całą stolicę w popiół i wymordowali tysiące to bohaterowie?
@@alfatejpblind6498 Dude stop talking nonsense because it makes me want to vomit! The Russians had no purpose in helping the Poles, they were waiting for him to bleed out.
@@nibiru27Russia has always had hindered logistics. They advanced at insanely fast rate. I hate that country but Germans were much more prepared during the time of uprising than soviets. I know Poles want to blame everyone but themselves. If you play stupid games, you win stupid prizes.
You can see that the Soviets were actually helping the poles somewhat as they were still taking casualties. Like not many casualties but its still some
casualties are taken from soviet offensive on eastern Warsaw in September and Polish army on Soviet command that tried to cross vistula river to help the uprising
w necie było. kilka książek podawało podobne dane np. Warszawa tragiczne powstanie Alexandry Richie. Wiem, że dane raczej są błędne. przynajmniej te niemieckie straty są przesadzone. Zamieściłem informacje w napisach i opisie filmu
@@MazovianProductions Dzięki za odpowiedź. Istnieje cała dyskusja dotycząca strat niemieckich i sporo dotyczących tego tematu kontrowersji, bo niejasności zaistniały już u źródła w raportach niemieckich.
"Stare Miasto" tłumaczy się na angielski jako "Old Town", nie City (wiem, że to taka pierdółka, ale jako fan architektury musiałem zwrócić na to uwagę)
używałem sprzecznych danych dotyczących strat niemieckich, bo sumowały się one z ofensywy armii czerwonej na Warszawę oraz z tych z Powstania które są błędne więc jakoś tak wyszło. film jest raczej nieaktualny już
You need to put more effort in this: Soviet casualties should be specified if they are of Polish Peoples Army or of Soviet Red Army, because here they are put together. German casualties should be specified if they are of Wehrmacht or of Vlassov's Russian Army or of Ukrainian SS Galizien, because here they are put together.
Vlassov's Russian Army (or more clearly Russian Liberation Army - ROA) was not involved in pacifying Warsaw. 29-th SS Division RONA did. Two completely different military organisations with simmilar name, which often get confused. Otherwise I agree that more detailed analysis could be interesting.
@@MazovianProductions A tak jeszcze zapytam - pomysł żeby dać Niemcy na czarno, powstańców na żółto a sowietów na czerwono to był Twój pomysł czy wzięty z mojego filmiku sprzed 3 lat?
@@Meow-ml5hv Na wielu mapach przebiegu powstania warszawskiego był taki układ kolorów stron walczących. Na yt są też filmy gdzie strona polska ma żółty kolor. Teoretycznie przyjęte jest dawanie polsce koloru ciemnego różu np. w graj jak Hoi4 czy EU4, ale ma zbyt mały kontrast względem czerwonych sowietów, dlatego pozostałem przy żółtym
And thus two hundred thousands of people died completely for nothing, only 10% of whom were actually under command of morons responsible for this mistake. Who, just to add salt to the wound, knew very well that their goal is completely impossible to reach.
I must point out the amount of losses, especially when it comes to the German side. No more than 2,000 German soldiers died at the hands of the insurgents. Even logically, if considering that in September 1939 on the territory of the whole country about 16,000 Germans died at the hands of an organised and fully armed army, then to assume that only in Warsaw 9,000 soldiers died at the hands of such badly armed insurgents is, unfortunately, absurd.
Tak kiedyś myślałem, że nie wybuchło tam ale podczas tworzenia tego filmu dowiedziałem się że trwało dwa dni na Pradze, potem powstańcy przedostali się do śródmieścia i walczyli dalej
używałem jako źródło artchiwów Muzeum Powstania Warszawskiego i nie widziałem nic konkretnego po prawej stronie po za pragą. Może masz rację nwm ale wtedy nie widziałem@@freexo1229
Niemców, a raczej żołnierzy różnych narodowości w służbie wehrmachtu oraz innych formacji zginęło nie 9000 a łącznie około 1500. Cywilów również nie zginęło aż 200.000 ale około 80.000
From a historians perspective, the uprising was a huge mistake... One of the biggest. But from the perspective of a participant... Every patriot would have likely joined. Trapped between terrible countries, tyrants with no heart. The war rages on. No one knows how it will end. Is it worth the risk to NOT take up the fight? Then youre risking that your country disappears from the map again, leaving the world in the hands of nazis and corrupted, merciless communists... A desperate fight for freedom and change is, in my opinion, definitely something good... Poles simply act. They are brave and want change. I admire AK rebels, despite the controversies. We are humans, we make mistakes, and they fought for us. We should be at least greatful. Not exactly mention it as our big achivment, but it is definitely a good example of Polish unstoppable, valiant, great spirit.
@@АланТейлор-и7у How is this related to my comment? The best part is that your comment is even incorrect. We didnt attack them directly, we just sent an ultimatum, which they accepted. Was it a good thing? Thats debatable. But what does it have to do with my comment? xd
@@АланТейлор-и7уdo you russians always have to speak in your own language? Not everyone knows it, if it wasn't for the google translate, i wouldn't know what you said. And also, the fuck does this have to do with the warsaw urprising?
This is actually a story where Ive been told my whole life that the Soviets did nothing for the Poles but where its kinda the opposite. And yet its still being spun as something that is being "uncovered". Stalin was a political demagogue and probably didnt want to help the uprising but the generals and especially the first soviet polish army did. Also if the Poles in Warsaw had held the bank of the river 6 more days, things could have been very different.
@@mareksicinski3726 I honestly doubt anything could have been done but I dont doubt that Stalin didnt want anything done. Doesn´t mean the Red Army didn´t try with the resources it had. But both Stalin and the realities on the ground, having just exhausted a general offensive and the poles not holding the bank long enough meant it would fail.
@@Tomszpl Ale wiesz że dużo polaków w Armii Czerwonej również byli żołnierzami AK? ZSSR dało im wybór, sybir albo odejście z AK i dołączenie do Armii Czerwonej
planuję zrobić remake. Niestety to tak wygląda bo moim głównym źródłem informacji były dzienne informacje z Muzeum Powstania a nie bardzo orientuję się w geografii przedwojennej warszawy więc jakoś tak wyszło
Piękna praca, ale, niestety, straty niemieckie (w tym Kozaków/Rosjan/Ukraińców, Azerów, Skandynawów itd) były niższe. Ocenia się je obecnie na ok. 3.000 zabitych i 8.000 rannych.
Red army what? They litterly just committed the biggest offensive in entire WW2 and destroyed around 30 divisions. Do you expect them to just continue fighting? Poles never tried to contact red army before uprising. Why the hell should Soviet soldiers risk their lives in an unprepared offensive to save people who absolutely hate them?
Lack of equipment, organisation and trust with the AK as it was an anti-communist organisation. If you look closely, you'll see that they tried to help but were unable to achieve anything and after that they just waited to reorganize their army.
@@MazovianProductionsFalse. The Red Army was completely and utterly exhausted from conducting operation Bagration which destroyed 30 German divisions. The Poles initiated the uprising under directions from Churchill and British high command who had no insight into matters on the ground and ignorant of the fact that the Red Army was in no position to help. The Uprising should have been delayed by 2 months and should have been conducted in co-ordination with the Red Army.
There's a lecturer I listen to on tiktok that explains how the soviets waited to let the Germans defeat the uprising so that Poland wouldn't have any representation post war
@@MazovianProductions if you have studied strategic studies, or let alone historiography on the contemporary order of battle you would know this assertion to be completely false. The Red Army had just conducted Operation Bagration, the largest scale soviet offensive to date with massive men, equipment, vehicles, and infrastructure involved. Expecting them to take a massive urban center, situated across the vistula no less, after their forces had been exhausted destroying THIRTY axis divisions is a ridiculous expectation. Understandable from the poles perspective though, they had been occupied for 5 brutal years at that point
Not really. They wanted to liberate the city before them, but after the soviets came, some polish troops in the red army, came to the other side of vistula river for help
For some reason, no one says, "The Americans could have done D-Day earlier" or "The Poles could have let the Soviet troops through." Hypocritical insults. If the leaders of the uprising had really wanted to liberate the city, they would contact the Red Army and act in an organized manner.
Don't blame Stalin for what was a pointless, foolish move by the Polish government in exile. The Warsaw uprising only led to the massacres of helpless civilians.
Well maybe exiled government was folish, becouse they were powerless, amybe tired citizens after 4 years of occupation shouldnt make an uprising, but Stalind was technically Ally off Poland and Uk, that couldn't use Soviet airfields for their supply planes to do some help, or maybe Stalin just stopped and watched this massacre from the other side of vistula becouse he was tired and offensive was not possible
@@MazovianProductions The red army was exhausted from Operation Bagration and wasn't capable to move into Warsaw. In theory, the Soviets wanted to take Warsaw by the end of summer but the German resistance near the city was too big and the fighting caused enough damage to halt them east of the Vistula, thus making them unable to actually push into Warsaw. Also Stalin was only involved in political affairs, not military. He wasn't like Hitler who put his nose everywhere.
Kiedy Niemcy zaczynały przegrywać na froncie wschodnim powinniśmy zaprzestać z nimi walki i skupić się na spowolnieniu sowietów, żeby państwa zachodnie nas wyzwoliły
@@50pka ну дак типичные либерахи, для них важнее сохранить мифическую "независимость" чем свой собственный народ. Просто толпа людоедов которая дошла до власти
czk ile masz lat? chyba z rowerka spadłeś. Jeśli chcesz bawić się krytyka to niech będzie konstruktywna a nie rzucasz frazesami typu: Na chuj to robisz jak nie znasz angielskiego! Zostaw to lepszym! Jeśli chcesz przedstawić swoją opinię to przedstaw ją teraz. Niczego nie będę usuwał
This video was published August 1 2021 5:00pm (17:00) Central European Time
I encourage you to turn on the english subtitles
/
Zachęcam do włączenia angielskich napisów
This video is monetised. If you want to support my channel you can send me a donate (link in the discribtion)
Z szacunku do poległych z pułku "Garłuch" wypada nanieść na mapę działania bojowe przy lotnisku Okęcie (1-2.08.44)
@@bukaciarnia w produkcji jest remake gdzie walki na Okęciu będą ukazane
With so little outside support they managed to successfully fight the Germans for many days. Those men where true heroes
And died for nothing i think. Uprising was ill considered. Polish home army command knew that allies or soviets will not help
Define "successfully", becouse the whole thing was a fucking disaster from day one.
Such a shame that so many smart, young guys died there for nothing ;(
They died for their freedom, I wasnt there but I think I wouldnt enjoy my fellow citizens getting slaughtered by nazis
@@MazovianProductions they had 2 options:
1. Uprising
2. Germans and Soviets will make there second Stalingrad
@@MazovianProductions Better to die fighting then to die under nazi germany or the Soviet Union
"I judged the Poles by their enemies.
And I found it was an almost unfailing- truth
that their enemies were the enemies of magna-
nimity and manhood. If a man loved slavery,
if he loved usury, if he loved terrorism and all
the trampled mire of materialistic politics, I
have always found that he added to these
affections the passion of a hatred of Poland.
She could be judged in the light of that hatred ;
and the judgment has proved to be right.”
G.K. Chesterton
Actual Wehrmacht casualties - 1570 killed and 9043 INJURED. Majority of civilians after few days were, to put it mildly, not happy about the uprising still going on (that is not so popular to say publicly). ~200.000 CIVILIANS WERE KILLED during the battles as well as MURDERED because of Himmler revenge decision + almost 90% of the city flatten. It was one of the biggest tragedy in Polish history. I hope we won't be in the same situation even again but please, wake up! People speaking about honor and bravery - think of these 200.000 people in basements, scared, alone and executed as well and not only about Polish soldiers with guns, flags and romantic picture of freedom.
Long live Poland, pozdrowienia z Francji !
Great work. it's a little pity that this amazing video has only 9k views. Chwała bohaterom.
Everything is absolutely perfect in this video! Animation, music, details. Really great work!
Komentarz dla zasięgu...
Super film !
Kuteox XDDDDD
5:48 I'm going to assume that only 100,000 people were left, but if it was indeed 100, dear god, the Warsaw population was wiped out, to be fair either way. The Nazis really were cruel and evil, slaughtering innocent people all for nothing.
After the uprising the Germans ordered all remaining residents to leave the city, and then systematically demolished more than 80% of the city's buildings down to their foundations. Some areas were apparently still being rebuilt into the 1980s. The value of the damages are estimated to be as high as 200 billion USD, and that isn't considering the irreplaceable cultural value of many of the 16 million books and other documents destroyed.
*Germans
@@Lucas_07-PL*Nazis
150-250k civilians killed, 16-18k soldiers killed, 25k wounded, 700k civilians moved out of the city to diffrent camps.
P@@Lucas_07-PL
O mój Boże Mazovian to jest piękne że to zrobiłeś
Żeby każdy na świecie wiedział o tym
Dziękuje wzruszyłem się
No no Mazovien.
Jest czego podziwiać.
W Godzinę "W" trzeba zobaczyć.
Now this is what i call masterpiece
Good to hear (or see) that
For reference, Hiroshima lost 140,000 as a direct result of the nuclear bomb over the course of two weeks, mostly civilians, while Warsaw lost 200,000. 1 million people died in Aushwitz, while 1 million people were killed or displaced from Warsaw throughout the war.
Hard to see the Poles as anyone but pure victims from 1939 to 1989, even if the revolution wasn't planned. They payed the ultimate price for not surrendering.
Nice iq
Based on the what I know, the uprising was planned by people sitting in London who had no knowledge of the material conditions in the actual battlefield and weren't going to pay the price of failure either. The AK fighters thought that by launching it at the moment they would have been able to liberate Warsaw with help from the red army, but really the reason it was launched at that time was to bring back the government in exile and make sure the Soviets wouldn't have any rights to Western Ukraine and Belarus.
So basically, the uprising's true goal was political, detached from reality and the fighters were betrayed by those who told them to do it.
@@gnas1897 The Uprising was planned by the Main Command of AK.
1772-1989 were the worst years for Poland.
@@gnas1897the war was planned by Poles. The plan was to shock german soldiers with an unexpected attack. The soviets were supposed to enter few Days after the start of the uprising. Stalin decided to blow the bridges up and wait for Poles to bleed.
Good video, you deserve more followers
thx
Polska: ZSRR POMOZ MI
ZSRR: 🙃🍿
Nikt nie żebrał o pomoc Czerwonej Zarazy, wręcz przeciwnie to Czerwona Zaraza fałszywie podjudzała Polaków do zbrojnego czynu: propaganda komuchów o AK stojącej z bronią u nogi, radiostacja Kościuszko wzywająca Warszawę do powstania, a do tego "sojusznicze" walki o Wilno, Lwów, boje 27 Wołyńskiej Dywizji AK, czy współdziałanie z sowiecką partyzantką samoobron otoczonych przez banderowskich morderców na Wołyniu - a po wspólnej walce sowiecka kula w łeb naiwnemu Polakowi, a w najlepszym razie zsyłka na tzw "Sybir"
🪖Ivan: Commander, we urgently need to help the rebel Poles!
👮🏻♂️Sergei: We will only have time to get to the river, but we will not have time to help the rebels, large Wehrmacht troops are already suppressing the uprising in the city, even if a small part of the rebels remains there, it will be pointless to cross the river to help...
🪖Ivan: *silently looked towards Warsaw, smoking from the fire*
👮🏻♂️Sergei: Don't be sad, sooner or later the enemy will lose and go to a fair court, you'll see... perhaps Poland will be given almost all of Germany's eastern lands, if of course Churchill allows it, I don't know for sure, everything will be clear after the war 🥸
Вообще попытки форсировать Вислу были:/
@@Ulle2419 Bullshit. Stalin would've deported all those nationalists after the war anyways, so he figured he'd let the nazis do the dirty work for him. Nazi-soviet teamwork struck again, that's what happened.
@@АндрейКорнишов-б9э Tak, były.Polskiej Armi Ludowej.
Great job man
There was no "deliberate delay" of the Soviet offensive. One day before the uprising, the Herman Goering division traveled through Warsaw to show that a Polish uprising was without any chance and in fact, the Germans carried a successful counter-offensive that pushed back red army far from Warsaw so when the Polish-Soviet army arrived on the right bank of Warsaw (where the AK the home army did not organise deliberately any uprising !!!), the Germans were already in full control of the left bank. From the very beginning this uprising was badly organised by military with only one obsession, not letting Soviets and Polish communists to take control of a functioning Polish capital city.
exactly
Ok komunisto
@@Byzantine_Vengance cry 😭
@@Byzantine_Vengance you're not a reasonable person you just want your way
@@TheProjectVoid clarify
Huh after the war warsaw population dint exceed 100 the same thing happened in my city of Klaipėda after ww2. In 1939 there were 47,000 people but in january 1945 after the liberation there were only about 50 left
3:50 why did the Germans cross the river
Bridges were destroyed, to not let the soviets help uprising
Very good work!
Could you do something like this, but about Slovak National Uprising, because its not very talked about but was pretty big resistance against German occupation.
A lot of History events are neglected :(
@@Open_56 Probably all of mapping videos about WW2 shows Yogoslav partisans which were largest, but they don't show Slovak National Uprising, probably there were other big ones, but not shown
What if they waited till the soviets reached the Vistula then launched the uprising
Uprising started when Soviets were approaching Warsaw but few days later they were pushed back by german counteroffensive
Jeszcze Polska nie zginęła, Niech żyje Polska!
Chwała Bohaterom...
Bohaterom? 15 latkowie zrywający się na 16000 profesjonalnych żołnierzy z granatami zrobionymi z puszek po konserwach, przez których Niemcy obrócili całą stolicę w popiół i wymordowali tysiące to bohaterowie?
@@Diedwhilemakingwaffles Tak
ポーランド万歳！！祖国の自由のために蜂起した人々に、敬意を表します。日本からのご挨拶。
Nazi symbol
@@usuarioanonimo5899 It is a thing of the past that the Azov Regiment was neo-Nazi.
The polish videogame enemy front bring me here
Rest in peace, people from all bands
Trup: Ożywiony
USSR on the other side: *Interesting*
And how were they supposed to cross? Logistics were overstretched
@@alfatejpblind6498 Dude stop talking nonsense because it makes me want to vomit! The Russians had no purpose in helping the Poles, they were waiting for him to bleed out.
@@alfatejpblind6498 you seriously believe that?
@@nibiru27Russia has always had hindered logistics. They advanced at insanely fast rate. I hate that country but Germans were much more prepared during the time of uprising than soviets.
I know Poles want to blame everyone but themselves. If you play stupid games, you win stupid prizes.
@@DesideriusTheSerious The Soviets could have dropped suplies for the Polish (Or at the very least have allowed the UK and USA to do it).
You can see that the Soviets were actually helping the poles somewhat as they were still taking casualties.
Like not many casualties but its still some
casualties are taken from soviet offensive on eastern Warsaw in September and Polish army on Soviet command that tried to cross vistula river to help the uprising
Most of them were Poles who joined soviet offensive
@@ogoemtojestesmuem7708 генерал который там командовал был поляком😃
@@wektortynwho? And even if there is difference between Poles who fought for free Poland and those who were soviet puppets
Jestem ciekaw, na jakiej podstawie dokonałeś tego wyliczenia strat po obu stronach.
w necie było. kilka książek podawało podobne dane np. Warszawa tragiczne powstanie Alexandry Richie. Wiem, że dane raczej są błędne. przynajmniej te niemieckie straty są przesadzone. Zamieściłem informacje w napisach i opisie filmu
@@MazovianProductions Dzięki za odpowiedź. Istnieje cała dyskusja dotycząca strat niemieckich i sporo dotyczących tego tematu kontrowersji, bo niejasności zaistniały już u źródła w raportach niemieckich.
"Stare Miasto" tłumaczy się na angielski jako "Old Town", nie City (wiem, że to taka pierdółka, ale jako fan architektury musiałem zwrócić na to uwagę)
Sory, wiem trochę zwaliłem z tym tłumaczeniem dzielnic
Cześć i wieczna chwała bohaterom!
Великолепная работа, только жаль, что не показано дальнейшее продвижение РККА
We didnt help since Warsaw Uprising.
Ej a może każda godzina powstania paryskiego? To tylko 6 dni więc dużo roboty mieć nie będziesz
to ma sens
a pomyśleć że powstanie miało trwać 2-3 dni i mieliśmy odbić Warszawe
świetny film, fajny nowy styl mapy i wojen..
P
W
Oddajmy hołd żołnierzom Powstała Warszawskiego
2:28 niemcy zmartwychstali czy jak?
używałem sprzecznych danych dotyczących strat niemieckich, bo sumowały się one z ofensywy armii czerwonej na Warszawę oraz z tych z Powstania które są błędne więc jakoś tak wyszło. film jest raczej nieaktualny już
@@MazovianProductions a okej
I'm confused for a few seconds. There's a Prague in Warsaw?
yea this is very old district of Warsaw. Its name was created from word Prażyć (eng. Roast) not from Prague (Czech Capital). It can be confusing
Poland has more Prague than Czech Republic capital Prague
Great job, guys, but you seem to have omitted Saska Kepa contribution in the first hours of the fights:/
Świetne wykonanie!!
Ale szczerze poczułem bul gdy widziałem już gdy żółty kolor znika z Warszawy...
Ból*
Gratuluje dzielności powstańcóm warszawskim!
Dzielni z nich bohaterowie
Pamietam jak jeszcze rok temu kazdy mapper wstawial w rocznice powstania co gdyby polska wygrala powstanie
Nostalgia
I to jeszcze z współczesnymi granicami Warszawy
@@szost7135 tak xd
Tu mistrzowie historii nie wiedzą, że Obecna granica Warszawy jest ustalona przez sowietów
Przecież to wróżenie z fusów. Nawet sami dowódcy nie wiedzieli co robić. Chaotyczny desperacki zryw to był, krzyk rozpaczy, a nie geniusz oręża
You need to put more effort in this:
Soviet casualties should be specified if they are of Polish Peoples Army or of Soviet Red Army, because here they are put together.
German casualties should be specified if they are of Wehrmacht or of Vlassov's Russian Army or of Ukrainian SS Galizien, because here they are put together.
Vlassov's Russian Army (or more clearly Russian Liberation Army - ROA) was not involved in pacifying Warsaw. 29-th SS Division RONA did. Two completely different military organisations with simmilar name, which often get confused. Otherwise I agree that more detailed analysis could be interesting.
Praga isn’t Prague, names aren’t related / one Downey ordinate form the other
Yeah i explained that to the intrested but thx for that
Wychodzi na to , że powstanie powinno wybuchnąć ale z minimum miesięcznym opóźnieniem
Nie mogę się doczekać
To jest świetne ale obejrzę jescze kilka razy by wszystko dobrze zobaczyć
Wow, świetna robot.
Skąd zdobyłeś tyle szczegółowych informacji jeśli mogę spytać?
W opisie masz linki do stron
@@MazovianProductions A tak jeszcze zapytam - pomysł żeby dać Niemcy na czarno, powstańców na żółto a sowietów na czerwono to był Twój pomysł czy wzięty z mojego filmiku sprzed 3 lat?
@@Meow-ml5hv Na wielu mapach przebiegu powstania warszawskiego był taki układ kolorów stron walczących. Na yt są też filmy gdzie strona polska ma żółty kolor. Teoretycznie przyjęte jest dawanie polsce koloru ciemnego różu np. w graj jak Hoi4 czy EU4, ale ma zbyt mały kontrast względem czerwonych sowietów, dlatego pozostałem przy żółtym
Glory to the heroes, they could havent started an uprising and just fled the city.
TO DZISIAJ, TERAZ !!
Brdzo fajny film
troche odkleiło z tymi stratami
And thus two hundred thousands of people died completely for nothing, only 10% of whom were actually under command of morons responsible for this mistake. Who, just to add salt to the wound, knew very well that their goal is completely impossible to reach.
Sorry ale niemcow zginelo okolo 3 tys tylko a powstancow szacuje sie ma 15 tys
@@tuviks1 dałem informację taką w opisie 2 lata temu. Czytajcie opis
Czekam z niecierpliwoscią
I must point out the amount of losses, especially when it comes to the German side. No more than 2,000 German soldiers died at the hands of the insurgents. Even logically, if considering that in September 1939 on the territory of the whole country about 16,000 Germans died at the hands of an organised and fully armed army, then to assume that only in Warsaw 9,000 soldiers died at the hands of such badly armed insurgents is, unfortunately, absurd.
@@przemysawciechonski4113 the remake is in preparation
Гении. «Поляки не просят свободы, они борется за неё». Ну что, поборолись? Выиграли свободу?
да, очень плохо живут они. Не то что в Независимой России, прекрасной и безопасной)
Sorry, że ci tak przerwe, ale no... wygraliśmy
rest in peace to all of the people that died due to the german war machine
Nareszcie ktoś pokazał powstanie po prawej stronie wisły
Tak kiedyś myślałem, że nie wybuchło tam ale podczas tworzenia tego filmu dowiedziałem się że trwało dwa dni na Pradze, potem powstańcy przedostali się do śródmieścia i walczyli dalej
@@MazovianProductionsbyło też przez 6 dni na Targówku swoją drogą
używałem jako źródło artchiwów Muzeum Powstania Warszawskiego i nie widziałem nic konkretnego po prawej stronie po za pragą. Może masz rację nwm ale wtedy nie widziałem@@freexo1229
Przez twoje tęczowe profilowe ci walczący się w grobie przewracają
@@BacaZaklinaczOwiec😘😘😘
Niemców, a raczej żołnierzy różnych narodowości w służbie wehrmachtu oraz innych formacji zginęło nie 9000 a łącznie około 1500. Cywilów również nie zginęło aż 200.000 ale około 80.000
80.000 zdecydowanie za mało.
From a historians perspective, the uprising was a huge mistake... One of the biggest. But from the perspective of a participant... Every patriot would have likely joined. Trapped between terrible countries, tyrants with no heart. The war rages on. No one knows how it will end. Is it worth the risk to NOT take up the fight? Then youre risking that your country disappears from the map again, leaving the world in the hands of nazis and corrupted, merciless communists... A desperate fight for freedom and change is, in my opinion, definitely something good... Poles simply act. They are brave and want change. I admire AK rebels, despite the controversies. We are humans, we make mistakes, and they fought for us. We should be at least greatful. Not exactly mention it as our big achivment, but it is definitely a good example of Polish unstoppable, valiant, great spirit.
Польша с Германией напали на Чехословакию в 1938 году.
@@АланТейлор-и7у How is this related to my comment? The best part is that your comment is even incorrect. We didnt attack them directly, we just sent an ultimatum, which they accepted. Was it a good thing? Thats debatable. But what does it have to do with my comment? xd
@@АланТейлор-и7уdo you russians always have to speak in your own language? Not everyone knows it, if it wasn't for the google translate, i wouldn't know what you said. And also, the fuck does this have to do with the warsaw urprising?
А почему коммунисты злые и коррумпированные ?@@_Hellscaqe
@@_HellscaqeВсе героические, когда против русских.
Chwała powstańcom !
Niby za co...
Za poświęcenie i odwagę żeby stanąć w obronie wolności. A ty co w życiu zrobiłeś?
super
Oddajmy hołd żołnierzom Powstała Warszawskiego
nigdy nie wybaczę niemcom za naszą zniszczoną Warszawe
Co tam jacyś ludzie, kupa ceramiki poukładana w budynki ważniejsza.
This is actually a story where Ive been told my whole life that the Soviets did nothing for the Poles but where its kinda the opposite. And yet its still being spun as something that is being "uncovered". Stalin was a political demagogue and probably didnt want to help the uprising but the generals and especially the first soviet polish army did. Also if the Poles in Warsaw had held the bank of the river 6 more days, things could have been very different.
The generals didn’t care and were following orders
This is sophistry, Stalin actively blocked help, the units chosen for the landing were absurdly little
This is sophistry, Stalin actively blocked help, the units chosen for the landing were absurdly little
This is sophistry, Stalin actively blocked help, the units chosen for the landing were absurdly little
@@mareksicinski3726 I honestly doubt anything could have been done but I dont doubt that Stalin didnt want anything done. Doesn´t mean the Red Army didn´t try with the resources it had.
But both Stalin and the realities on the ground, having just exhausted a general offensive and the poles not holding the bank long enough meant it would fail.
Chociaż troche czerwonych zdechło
To nie do końca czerwoni tylko straty wp w armi czerwonej.
@@husc7775 to dobrze że oni też pozdychali
@@Tomszpl wiesz że to byli polacy?
@@husc7775 ci którzy gdy tam zostali uganiali się za powstańcami i skazali pileckiego na śmierć
@@Tomszpl Ale wiesz że dużo polaków w Armii Czerwonej również byli żołnierzami AK? ZSSR dało im wybór, sybir albo odejście z AK i dołączenie do Armii Czerwonej
Mapa zawiera bardzo dużo błędów. Niestety. Choć animacja interesująca.
planuję zrobić remake. Niestety to tak wygląda bo moim głównym źródłem informacji były dzienne informacje z Muzeum Powstania a nie bardzo orientuję się w geografii przedwojennej warszawy więc jakoś tak wyszło
Piękna praca, ale, niestety, straty niemieckie (w tym Kozaków/Rosjan/Ukraińców, Azerów, Skandynawów itd) były niższe. Ocenia się je obecnie na ok. 3.000 zabitych i 8.000 rannych.
W opisie to napisałem z rok temu. Zorientowałem się ale nie mogłem inaczej poprawić. 9000 zabitych i rannych napewno
red army why?
Red army what? They litterly just committed the biggest offensive in entire WW2 and destroyed around 30 divisions. Do you expect them to just continue fighting? Poles never tried to contact red army before uprising. Why the hell should Soviet soldiers risk their lives in an unprepared offensive to save people who absolutely hate them?
Месть за 1938 год, когда Польша и Германия напали на Чехословакию.
Why didn’t the soviets help
Stalin wanted uprising to fall, becouse polish resistance would be to weak to stop him from making communist poland
Lack of equipment, organisation and trust with the AK as it was an anti-communist organisation. If you look closely, you'll see that they tried to help but were unable to achieve anything and after that they just waited to reorganize their army.
Was the USSR supposed to help?
@@MazovianProductionsFalse. The Red Army was completely and utterly exhausted from conducting operation Bagration which destroyed 30 German divisions. The Poles initiated the uprising under directions from Churchill and British high command who had no insight into matters on the ground and ignorant of the fact that the Red Army was in no position to help. The Uprising should have been delayed by 2 months and should have been conducted in co-ordination with the Red Army.
Soviets were helping by providing air superiority and preventing German planes to attack the resistance
German retaliation was crazy read up
Wow! film 11/10
Czekam
hah..cant download it for watch later
zapowiada się maśniutki specjał.
zrób kiedyś może Historia Polski 0-2021 every minute
Nie to nie miało by sensu
@@MazovianProductions wiem
@@historical3258 to czemu piszesz
I can't imagine how strong Germany was like this is 2v1 even overall it was like Germany vs the world
2v1? This was partisans vs a proper german army
@@AinKrab but in the end there was red army
@@legend9181no red army did nothing or not much more to help the uprrasing. They were alsi exhouster after the bagration.
There's a lecturer I listen to on tiktok that explains how the soviets waited to let the Germans defeat the uprising so that Poland wouldn't have any representation post war
I read Alexandra Richie "Warsaw 1944" and it was well explained.
@@MazovianProductions if you have studied strategic studies, or let alone historiography on the contemporary order of battle you would know this assertion to be completely false. The Red Army had just conducted Operation Bagration, the largest scale soviet offensive to date with massive men, equipment, vehicles, and infrastructure involved. Expecting them to take a massive urban center, situated across the vistula no less, after their forces had been exhausted destroying THIRTY axis divisions is a ridiculous expectation. Understandable from the poles perspective though, they had been occupied for 5 brutal years at that point
Chwała bohaterom
Lengyelek hősök
smutne :(
🇵🇱🙏🏻❤
just heroes
Zaczęło się
That was dumb. Did the Poles really think the Soviets were coming to their rescue?
Not really. They wanted to liberate the city before them, but after the soviets came, some polish troops in the red army, came to the other side of vistula river for help
@@MazovianProductions Yeah and the Soviets let them cross just to watch them get massacred. Pure evil.
@@Ausf.D.A.K. Is that a bad thing? The USSR wasn't stupid to help anti-communists.
@@Ausf.D.A.K.The Soviets didn’t intervene as it was exhausted from past offensives.
👍
Typical Soviets when normal peaople need help
For some reason, no one says, "The Americans could have done D-Day earlier" or "The Poles could have let the Soviet troops through." Hypocritical insults. If the leaders of the uprising had really wanted to liberate the city, they would contact the Red Army and act in an organized manner.
@@50pka U don't know anything about the Warsaw Uprising, aren't u?
@@GremlinPL no u
was zum Teufel ist hier verdammt?
verdammter Premierminister, wenn ich nach Bulgarien gehe
Polnische antideutsche Propaganda
@@MazovianProductions Że co?!
Own fault
?
@@GremlinPL the Polish, own fault.
Is like 1939 but worse
Yeah
Жаль, поляки не успели поставить памятник Гитлеру в 1939 году.
Бессмысленный комментарий
No szkoda, może polska nie była by taka zniszczona po wojnie
Don't blame Stalin for what was a pointless, foolish move by the Polish government in exile. The Warsaw uprising only led to the massacres of helpless civilians.
Well maybe exiled government was folish, becouse they were powerless, amybe tired citizens after 4 years of occupation shouldnt make an uprising, but Stalind was technically Ally off Poland and Uk, that couldn't use Soviet airfields for their supply planes to do some help, or maybe Stalin just stopped and watched this massacre from the other side of vistula becouse he was tired and offensive was not possible
@@MazovianProductions The red army was exhausted from Operation Bagration and wasn't capable to move into Warsaw. In theory, the Soviets wanted to take Warsaw by the end of summer but the German resistance near the city was too big and the fighting caused enough damage to halt them east of the Vistula, thus making them unable to actually push into Warsaw.
Also Stalin was only involved in political affairs, not military. He wasn't like Hitler who put his nose everywhere.
@@gnas1897 the Soviets intialy refused to lend the airfields to the Western Allies making them unable to help the uprising.
Im pretty sure the soviets also arrested/executed all AK solidiers in Praga (east warsaw).
also in Wilno
Kiedy Niemcy zaczynały przegrywać na froncie wschodnim powinniśmy zaprzestać z nimi walki i skupić się na spowolnieniu sowietów, żeby państwa zachodnie nas wyzwoliły
Sowieci i tak by wygrali. Nie mieliśmy takich sił by ich spowolnić na większy okres
Цель Германии была - уничтожение поляков. Как ты собрался не воевать против её?
"Лучше мы будем до конца независимыми, чем убережём сотни тысяч людей"
@@50pka Польша никогда не была независимой и никогда не будет. Сейчас Польша оккупирована США.
@@50pka ну дак типичные либерахи, для них важнее сохранить мифическую "независимость" чем свой собственный народ. Просто толпа людоедов которая дошла до власти
Kompletna porażka i wstyd narodowy
Twoje zdanie
@@GremlinPL *obiektywne
Na chuj robisz filmik po angielsku jak podstaw angielskiego nie znasz? Do szkoły wróć albo zostaw lepszym
czk ile masz lat? chyba z rowerka spadłeś. Jeśli chcesz bawić się krytyka to niech będzie konstruktywna a nie rzucasz frazesami typu: Na chuj to robisz jak nie znasz angielskiego! Zostaw to lepszym!
Jeśli chcesz przedstawić swoją opinię to przedstaw ją teraz. Niczego nie będę usuwał
Głupota Polaków nie ma granic
dowódców ak napewno
1944
🇷🇺
🇩🇪
🇵🇱
L poles