There's music on one hand and a study on the other. If you want to push the technique it's centered around, rush it. If you want to make it sound, play it as it is played here. For example, the way Segovia used to rush through Bach's Prelude in d minor, didn't get me at all but still he's one of the greatest of all time.
It IS a study, it has a purpose. They key is to play it with the right technique in demanding tempo. If you are truly studying classical guitar there is no "rushed tempo", but it is the needed tempo to develop your fingers technique.
Incredible! I find it amazing how the music sounds as the camerawork looks. It’s like they share some sort of a same clear and bright tone. Beautiful performance!
I like the speed that Ines Thome played it at. Too often the virtuosos feel like they have to play this piece super fast. The way Ines played it sounds more heartfelt. Just my opinion though. :)
Totally agree! This is not meant to be a tremolo exercise like so often played, as if they feel the need to show off. Perfect speed and tempo for this piece. We can actually hear the notes and enjoy the movements and passages. Thanks for your observation.
@@tomh3110 actually this has written "allegro" tempo so it must be played faster than this. somewhere between 129 and 137 BPM ,she is playing it slower as Carcassi wrote it to be played, but it´s ok, to me it sound cool too
I agree with your opinion. As an Etude, the tempo requirement is written as higher. I believe that is simply for the practice of developing virtuosity. When using the piece for performance, a slower tempo with rubato allows the piece to breathe properly.
Beautiful lady beautifuly plays beautiful music. That's all I can say😀 And btwy - intresting and unusual interpretation! Thanks a lot, it was sheer pleasure to listen, no kidding.
I've worked on this etude, and my teacher emphasized that it's not only a tremolo study but also an exercise in using rest stroke with the thumb--the melody after all is in the bass. It doesn't appear to me that you're using rest stroke but rather free stroke with the thumb. Am I correct? If I am, can you explain why?
Hi David. Thanks for the question. Highlighting the melody does not necessarily require the usage of rest strokes. The melody can be played/emphasized quite well with free strokes granted that the accompaniment is played as such (at lower volume than the melody). It ultimately comes down to an artistic preference for tone when one chooses rest vs. free strokes. Whatever allows you to express the music the best, use that technique. It may look quite different for another performer.
@@Gregory.LEFEVRE the answer is correct, it is Barrios valse n3, but maybe you mean the phrase starting in the middle of the song, not at the beginning, right?
+Shawn E.: Totally agree with your "mind-fingers-instrument array" assessment. And, the music is antique. But I was happy to hear it today. The last time I heard this played was at least forty years ago and it sure wasn't this well played. Peace to you!
Yes this is the perfect tempo for this piece! Finally someone who doesn't rush through the whole thing.
There's music on one hand and a study on the other. If you want to push the technique it's centered around, rush it. If you want to make it sound, play it as it is played here.
For example, the way Segovia used to rush through Bach's Prelude in d minor, didn't get me at all but still he's one of the greatest of all time.
It IS a study, it has a purpose. They key is to play it with the right technique in demanding tempo. If you are truly studying classical guitar there is no "rushed tempo", but it is the needed tempo to develop your fingers technique.
Incredible! I find it amazing how the music sounds as the camerawork looks. It’s like they share some sort of a same clear and bright tone. Beautiful performance!
Thank you for sharing this so that us novices and beginners can aspire to your performance....please share more of your guitar brilliance
I like the speed that Ines Thome played it at. Too often the virtuosos feel like they have to play this piece super fast. The way Ines played it sounds more heartfelt. Just my opinion though. :)
Totally agree! This is not meant to be a tremolo exercise like so often played, as if they feel the need to show off. Perfect speed and tempo for this piece. We can actually hear the notes and enjoy the movements and passages. Thanks for your observation.
@@tomh3110 actually this has written "allegro" tempo so it must be played faster than this. somewhere between 129 and 137 BPM ,she is playing it slower as Carcassi wrote it to be played, but it´s ok, to me it sound cool too
I agree with your opinion. As an Etude, the tempo requirement is written as higher. I believe that is simply for the practice of developing virtuosity. When using the piece for performance, a slower tempo with rubato allows the piece to breathe properly.
I would agree....but I do love to play this at break neck speed woohoo
Actually, it should be played a bit faster than this, 112 would be a nice tempo. Expression is not that remarkable here.
Your playing is so beautiful. The melody ready sings. Thank you.
C'est très beau. Le tempo est parfait. Merci.
Beautiful tone and great chops!
playing great!
Thank you for good playing!
Nicely played.
🌹👍✌️
AMAZING MIRACLE
Bravissima, grazie
fantastic very virtuous
Love this study
Fantastic!
Very nice played!
Beautiful lady beautifuly plays beautiful music. That's all I can say😀
And btwy - intresting and unusual interpretation! Thanks a lot, it was sheer pleasure to listen, no kidding.
Bravissima!!!
Carcassi at his best.
I love her facial expresions haha
I will be there(in this level) 🙏
I thought my eyes lose the ability to recognize the colors first second🤣🤣
Excelente.
👍
What model is the guitar that she is playing? Or is it a custom work from a luthier?
Loved it! How long have you been playing?
Nice good job
What's the song in the pening?
I've worked on this etude, and my teacher emphasized that it's not only a tremolo study but also an exercise in using rest stroke with the thumb--the melody after all is in the bass. It doesn't appear to me that you're using rest stroke but rather free stroke with the thumb. Am I correct? If I am, can you explain why?
Hi David. Thanks for the question. Highlighting the melody does not necessarily require the usage of rest strokes. The melody can be played/emphasized quite well with free strokes granted that the accompaniment is played as such (at lower volume than the melody). It ultimately comes down to an artistic preference for tone when one chooses rest vs. free strokes. Whatever allows you to express the music the best, use that technique. It may look quite different for another performer.
It sounds very nice the way you do it. Thank you for the explanation.
Rest stroke with the thumb is difficult. Unless your right hand is anatomically suited almost impossible.
Flamenco guitar different to classical.
What's the music played into introduction please?
Barrios valse n.3 😉
Thx !! :-)
Sorry, I didn t find this version, is there somewhere in your data please? I really like her sound.
@@Gregory.LEFEVRE the answer is correct, it is Barrios valse n3, but maybe you mean the phrase starting in the middle of the song, not at the beginning, right?
赞一个
Muy hermoso
Bellisimo.
ว่าวเราอะไปเรียนครูเล็กและเล่นเพลงนี้
beautiful aroma
It should've been a constant expression of forte and Mf, but good work
В самом начале проехалась по ушам,бас и верха потянула в сторону левую кисть,остальное 👍👏
This is not allegro, but very neat 👍
i prefer to shred away on this piece.
I thought this supposed to be allegro?
Laisse en note
This guitar is made up of Cider wood, I can tell by its sound.....it’s not a spruce for sure 😎
I'm assuming you mean cedar wood and not cider wood? :-)
Cheddar
Гитара это не женское дело. Сразу чую брак
Excellent phrasing for such a mediocre study. Well played.
+Shawn E.: Totally agree with your "mind-fingers-instrument array" assessment. And, the music is antique. But I was happy to hear it today. The last time I heard this played was at least forty years ago and it sure wasn't this well played. Peace to you!