There is no doubt he was great thinker but his political thinking is wrong... partition leads Hindus and muslims towards hate...it widens the gap ...and that gap push the rise of RSS in India so Iqbal was wrong but his poetry and spiritual intelligency always mesmerized everyone wether you are Hindu or Muslim...but he was wrong in his political thinking.
@@dipakdebnath2285it was written after pressure from the jiahdis and mullahs. It was only hindustan hamara. But hindustan only meant Pakistan at that time so boycott is reasonable. It is nuclear what did he mean by hindustan
@@prabalmohanta138😂 Arey Mere Bhai Konse Jihadis Molana Azad Bhi To Unhi Jihadis Me Se The Iqbal Was A Pure Pakistani Khutba Allahabad Ka Pata Hai Ya Nahi Pata
Last few lines are very nicely said. It is important to prosper secular India . But it is not the responsibility of only one religious people to keep India a secular state. All religion's people have to take this responsibility.
@nick p that's why i have mentioned only india , as during independence there was no Pakistan , which emerged out of it only on the religious basis ignoring the socio-cultural ties that people shared , i am very sure if plebiscite had happened at that time , people would have voted to remain where they were and no partition would have taken place , but future remained on some politicians and you see what they are still doing for their profits , easy way to distract from real issues . If India (whether be a Hindu majority or Muslim majority acc. to your assumption ) will follow similar thought process like Pakistan then it is open also for risking of misery that Pakistan has today . If religion in reality is a foremost issue than Bangladeshi should have been living as a east Pakistanis .
बहुत अच्छा एपिसोड एपीसोड के अन्त की बातें दिल में समा गई किसी पिता के दो बच्चे थे एक बच्चा सज्जन पितृ भक्त था और सब से प्रेम करता था परन्तु दूसरा रागद्वेष तथा स्वार्थ भरा था उसने बडे़ भाई से लड़ कर हिस्सा ले लिया लेकिन कभी न उन्नति कर पाया न ही गाँव के निवासियों की इज्जत पा पाया जबकि बडे़ भाई ने उन्नति की और इज्जत पायीं उसके आने वाली पीढ़ी भी उन्नति की ओर बढ़ रही है और छोटा भाई रो रहा है.इस बात को हमें समझनी चाहिए सरकार की वोट नीति पर नहीं जाना चाहिए तथा उसके कोरे भाषण नहीं सुनने चाहिए.
Aaj ki indian politics ko dekh kar allama Iqwal sahi saabit hue kyunki humne khoob khoob in 7 se 8 saalon me dekh liya ki kis tarah alag alag religious communities ke sath kaisa bartaav kiya ja raha hai. Khair mujhe ummid hai aane wale dino me isme badlaav dekhne ko milega.
@@fuzailrehman5396 please move to islamic mulli country..india is only for seculars and tolerant people..islam is dangerous to whole world..sooner or later it will be destroyed
Kis had tak wwfadaar ho ??? Pakistan ke against ti main bhi khada hun ,par kya jab maajid e Al aqsa par hamla hoga or india Israel ka support karega to kya tum kab bhi karoge support
True your analysis is beautiful although Iqbal and Jinnah looked for a state where muslims can live in peace but the irony is indian muslims are more happy
@@jaihind9194 see, I agree with what you are saying.. There are some reasons due to which an ideology or thought process evolves or changes. Otherwise, when sir syed who once said, India is a beautiful bride and Hindus and Muslims are two eys of it, changed his views and after sometime he was the one who said, Hindus and Muslims are two different nations and cannot live together. Backtracking would lead to no where and how far one can go. Like, reasons behind sir syed views changes was, Arya samaj and its shuddhi movement, and swami dayanand saraswati saying, "Hindustan sirf Hinduon k liye" as early as 1860. Then local government elections propounded by Lord Lytton, made people like sir syed apprehensive about Muslims being reduced to second class citizens as they are lesser in numbers. Now this lead to, formation of Muslim league in 1906-07 and ultimately getting separate electorate. This one apparently sided favour by government towards Muslim lead to apprehensions among hindus and so, Hindu mahasabha came into being in 1915 and ultimately RSS in 1925. This is one of the examples that I quoted which lead to the growing tensions. But the point is how far one can backtrack.. Now even Hindus can say, since there was growth in conversion due to missionary activities by Christians and revivalist Muslim movements like Deoband movement, lead to radical approach by hindu organisations like Arya samaj. So, why I said, it was well researched, because people who are being mentioned here that is Jinnah and Allama iqbal, only contributed to this thing (given prevailing political situation in the country) than to allay such idea like Maulana Azad and Dr zakir Hussain sahab did. Similarly, there were hindu leaders like Savarkar, golwalker who were on the other side of the spectrum, and were speaking for Hindus only rather india as a whole., but at the same time there were hindu leaders like, Gandhiji, Rajendra Prasad who were fighting for a joint India.
@@jaihind9194 if you start back tracking you can say that two nation theory came when Bin Qasim landed in Sindh and that's what they teach in Pakistan. The two nation theory that we are talking about here is the one thought by Iqbal and implemented by Jinnah and resulted in blood bath during partition. This theory also permanently damaged the relations between Hindus and Muslims.
@@jaihind9194 so we stick to the 2 nation theory which was actually implemented and its author didn't care about the bloodshed it has caused. Also which resulted in creating a separate country on the basis of convoluted idea that Muslims cannot live with non -Muslims.
bahut hi behtreen koshish NIKHIL sir aapne bahut sahi tarike se bina kisi pakshpaath ke is mudde ko hamare saamne rakha he ummid he ki hamare watan parast log is mudde ko samjhenge, ye mudda sirf hindu muslim par jakar nahi rukega, hindu muslim ke baad kshetriya vibhajan, uske baad panth, uske baad jaat biradari aur uske baad khanadan par jakar ye rukega........ hum dobara desh ka batwara bardasht nahi kar sakenge....... thank you sir
Zabardast eye opening, It shows extremitioms can damage country really hard, please be aware of politicians who manipulate on name of religion to unite, rather to unite on 🇮🇳for country 🙏🙏🙏
Me jab bhi Arab country me gaya, Budhde aged arbo ne muje sirf hindi kaha. Na kabhi hindu ya mushlim sikh kaha. Kyuki hindi hai hum hindustan watan hamara
@@AjaykumarYadav-ux1et sayad india me hindu k population ka idea nahi h Tumko.. Hamlog k population aranjeb nhi katam kr saka.. Ab to ye karna namumkin h
@@collegedays1324 During partition their population is not more than 30 percent and India is not only one example Serbia- koosvo,Sudan- South Sudan, Nigeria aur v bahut saare example hain.
@@collegedays1324 बेवकूफ इंसान अपनी आंखों का पर्दा हटाओ मुसलमानों ने तुम से पाकिस्तान लिया बांग्लादेश लिया अफगानिस्तान तुमसे ले लिय किसी समय इंडोनेशिया भी हिंदू राष्ट्र था अब भारत की बात बताता हूं मेघालय मणिपुर त्रिपुरा अरुणाचल प्रदेश केरल कश्मीर लक्षदीप और आधा पश्चिम बंगाल मैं हिंदू संप्रदाय अल्पसंख्यक हो चुका है धन्यवाद
@@AjaykumarYadav-ux1et WhatsApp university k digree panewala gyan deraha hain ! Meghalaya, mizuram, Nagaland, manipur sare state me majority isai dharam manne wala hain ! Kerala me 26% musolmane Bengal me 29% musolmane
इस्लामिक राष्ट्र बन कर कया खास हासिल किया पाकिस्तान ने जो कुछ लोग भारत को हिन्दू राष्ट्र बनाना चाहते हैं, और क्या आजादी के वक्त अगर हिन्दू राष्ट्र की बात होती तो नक्शा यही रहता
Humare liye to alama iqbal ki poetry ki ek pankhdi hi kafi hia. Sare jahha se acha Hindusta🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳 humara hum bulbule hai is ke ye gulista humara❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️.
@@suhailsingh7138maine aapka comment Aaj hi dekha moulana Abdul Kalam aajad, dr.syyed Ahmad khan, Khan Abdul gaffar our bhi hai kaho to research karke bata deta hun
kya insan ho be abdul kalam sahab bahut chhote the azadi ke waqt. aur o kameena dazzal firaun goron ki jutiya chatne wala hindustan ka pahla hindu muslim fasad karane wala ladkiyon ke taleem ke khilaf khada hone wala castist yahood ka agent syyed ahmad khan vo azadi se 40 50 sal pahle guzar gaya tha.khan abdul gaffar khan was a great leader and true freedom fighter lekin aakhiri waqt vo bhi majboori me pakistan chale gaye the. @@imranHussain-ww5jy
Iqbal was radicalized why living in Europe. The geopolitics at that time was such that Germany had an alliance with Ottoman empire. They have pushed these religious feelings to create pushback for other European powers (England and France) Something on the line of what has happened in Afghanistan where USA used the religion card to push out USSR.
Iqbal was radical and In india cow-dung eater and cow-meat eaters live side by side ? It's been 75+ years of partition and despite Pakistan being in crisis his points are still valid.
I am currently living in his name's hostel Allama Iqbal boarding house,AMU but the respect is not given by video logo .. He was a great scholar and you have not right to disrespect him
Aur kuch log kehte hai hum mushlim hai, hum hindu hai .. Areee bewakufo sare hindustani ho, chahe hindu kaho ya hindi kaho . Me jab bhi Arabic county me gaya budhhe aged arbo ne muje bina dharm dekhe kaha hindi ho tum ? Sambhal jao hindustanio Ikbal bewakuf ban gaya aur Quran k khilaf jakar apne watan k tukde kiye Aaj dekho Pakistan me kya hai ? Daily fight, redical, terrible life, Shia Sunni ahmediya Baloch sindhi panjabi Pashtun taliban labbaik Army aam log garibi border issue jung Aur sabkuch China 🇨🇳 ke pass Girwi pada hai, karachi port, jinnah garden, gawadar sab kuch.
Iqbal and Jinnah changed and so all the muslims after Rajpal maloon and GHAZI ILM UD DIN SHAHEED..... they realised how hindoo will treat Muslims once Brits left And they're absolutely right
Muslims are being treated in the same way as they have been treating yahudi, Christians, and Hindus for a long period of time, it is karma, but I accept it is wrong.
@@tangocharlie2453 muslims are the only nation who gave refuge to YAHUDIS go read some history as they were persecuted around the world Muslims protected them and Muslims only nation in the world who never persecuted any other nation or race...... Read some independent and unbiased true history......
@@MsIdiot000 Surah 5 (Al-Ma’idah) Verse 51: O you who have believed, do not take the Jews and the Christians as allies. They are [in fact] allies of one another. And whoever is an ally to them among you - then indeed, he is [one] of them. Indeed, Allah guides not the wrongdoing people. The prophet waged war against the Christians and Jews because they didn't believed (respected)Mohammad as any prophet. A Jew lady who was taken as a slave named zainab poisoned the prophet as she claimed that her family members were killed by the prophet. From sahih bukhari
Aur kuch log kehte hai hum mushlim hai, hum hindu hai .. Areee bewakufo sare hindustani ho, chahe hindu kaho ya hindi kaho . Me jab bhi Arabic county me gaya budhhe aged arbo ne muje bina dharm dekhe kaha hindi ho tum ? Sambhal jao hindustanio Ikbal bewakuf ban gaya aur Quran k khilaf jakar apne watan k tukde kiye Aaj dekho Pakistan me kya hai ? Daily fight, redical, terrible life, Shia Sunni ahmediya Baloch sindhi panjabi Pashtun taliban labbaik Army aam log garibi border issue jung Aur sabkuch China 🇨🇳 ke pass Girwi pada hai, karachi port, jinnah garden, gawadar sab kuch.
Jaise Iqbal k poorvaj 300 saal pehle hindu secular, vaise hi tumhare vansaj 300 saal baad allah hu akbar bolte milenge. Kyonki unka daada Rahul patil proud secular tha, jabki tumko proud hindu hona tha. Jinnah or Iqbal tumse jyada padh likhe, phir b secular nai hue,
@@Randomindian7 bhai aise hi secular k vansaj 100 saal baad Alaah u akbar krte nazar aayenge, jaise iqbal k poorvaj secular hindu hoke convert hue. Jinnah ka dada secular hindu tha. 🙏
He didn't demand He didn't Proposed He predicted the That at least a Nation In the North west India is the destiny of the Indian Muslim. He is most Educated & Most Influential poet of the 20th Century India. He is the man that born once in 100 years. He was a, Poet Philosopher Thinker Visionary Reformer Professor Islamic Scolor Lawyer Politicians Sufi One the Greatest Muslims of All time. He is my Ideal, He was a Fundamentalists Anti Nationalist Anti Materialist He was Right I support him in 95% What he has done. He was the poet of east He is Hakeem of the Ummat-e-Muslima His poetry is majory for the muslims Pakistan was never what the Iqbal wanted a nation to be.
@@AkashKumar-jp4qb UNIFROM CIVIL COURT MAI SABSE HADA NUKSAAN BHI TUM LOG KA HOGA. AAJ HAR JAGHA MANDIR BANA DIYE HO CHAHE POLICE STATION HO YA ROAD KA DIVIDER.
@@hasanmohd4273 Accha kitni nazayaz mazar tooti hai. Up me. Beech rod pe railway station pe highway pe tum log kabza kre hue the. Koi bhi sarkari jameen pe bna ho mandir he kyu na ho htt jye koi problem nhi mujhe. Pr tum log ko ho jati hai dekho muslim pe atyachaar ho rha bolke.
Allama Iqbal ki baat aaj sahi saabit ho rahi hai,BJP hampe julm karne pe tuli hui hai,,, Aakhir wo philospher the bhai, Itni dur ka socha unhone, aalah unhe jannat mein aala makam ata kare.
Iqbal thought was wrong there is no doubt he was great thinker but his political thinking was wrong...his idea of partition leads hate between Hindus and muslims ...and finally give to the rise of RSS that's why muslims condition is bad in our country .
Allama Iqbal never showed consistency in his thoughts. On one hand, he praises the Himalaya and the Shivala, Ram and Ganga, and then a few years later, talks of Muslim conquests that had nothing to do with Indian sub continent. He had his own mind and way of thinking.
You forget that Hindutva movements were on the rise ( Brahamu samaaj, Sudhi, Sanghatan). Congress were not the Congress of 1900s or 1910s. Moti Lal Nehru is one of the reason plus 1937-39 Congress governments in different Indian states freaked muslim elite like it would do now under Modi sarkar. Political history is Science, it never forgives or forgets.
आप के तारीख की जितनी तारीफ़ हो कम है. भारतीय राम तीर्थ को अमूमन नहीं पढ़ते. रामतीर्थ फारसी भाषा में भी लिखते थे. ब्यक्ति के सभी गुणों का आकलन करना चाहिए.मूल विचार मननीय होना चाहिए.
Hindustan is liye Dharam nirpekch hai ki molana Muhammad Ali Johar molana Abdul Kalam Azad molana mehmood Hasan Yeh bhi sotantarta senani the aur bhi bahut name hai Jo Bharat ki baat karte the
@@dineshkumar-dx8fq Asthana sir why hindu never tell these fact to their children Hindu should also tell their children that Koran is copied from bible & torakh of Jews so that the conversion to that religion Wil Stop
@@MS-ch5vg first by Syed Ahmed Khan then by Iqbal both received knighthood from British, Iqbal knew Jinnah can be a tool to fetch the partition from Congress leaders as he was very intelligent. Vaise British k talwe chaat kr unde Pakistan le liye.
No it was propounded by sir Syed Ahmed Khan...before that the decision based on religion was propagated by Karl Marx..communists n extremists destroyed the world
I am muslim, lekin ye dekhkar rona ata hai or pachtava hota hai unn musalmaano ki soch par jo dekhte the ke hindustan mai koi participation nhi hai musalmaano ka, mai 5 wakt ki namaaz padhta hu, zakaat deta hu wo bhi puri azaadi se sare faraiz ada krta hu or apna watan se bhut pyaar krta hu or afsoos or ghussa ata hai un logo ke faisla par jinhona partition karaya pta nhi inhona kya padha London jakar. 😞😭. SARE JAHA SE ACHA HINDUSTAN HAMARA. Jai Hind🇮🇳🇮🇳
@@beastbhaiya04 Iraq aur Iran me kya hua abhi,...aur 40-50 country aur h, 2-3 hi mile. ...hum dusro ke bjay apne desh pr dhyan de to jyada achchha hoga ,hmare liye ,auro se sabak le kr
@@indianbhaukaaltv4702 him 7-8 country ka maine naam diya hai vo aatankwadi ghatna se parast hai aur baki Saudi, UAE aur ek do ko haata lo unme to greh yudh hi hota rahta hai, kabhi sena hi sarkar par kabza kar leti hai
Mujhe to ikbaal ke kaumi tarana jo hindustan k liye likha tha bhut pasand hai mai hamesha chahta hu ki sare jahan se achcha hindustan hamara ye national song hona tha Ek jangad mangal Ek sare jaha se achcha Ye dono tarana(rastriya geet) bahut pasand hai
Aur kuch log kehte hai hum mushlim hai, hum hindu hai .. Areee bewakufo sare hindustani ho, chahe hindu kaho ya hindi kaho . Me jab bhi Arabic county me gaya budhhe aged arbo ne muje bina dharm dekhe kaha hindi ho tum ? Sambhal jao hindustanio Ikbal bewakuf ban gaya aur Quran k khilaf jakar apne watan k tukde kiye Aaj dekho Pakistan me kya hai ? Daily fight, redical, terrible life, Shia Sunni ahmediya Baloch sindhi panjabi Pashtun taliban labbaik Army aam log garibi border issue jung Aur sabkuch China 🇨🇳 ke pass Girwi pada hai, karachi port, jinnah garden, gawadar sab kuch.
Aur kuch log kehte hai hum mushlim hai, hum hindu hai .. Areee bewakufo sare hindustani ho, chahe hindu kaho ya hindi kaho . Me jab bhi Arabic county me gaya budhhe aged arbo ne muje bina dharm dekhe kaha hindi ho tum ? Sambhal jao hindustanio Ikbal bewakuf ban gaya aur Quran k khilaf jakar apne watan k tukde kiye Aaj dekho Pakistan me kya hai ? Daily fight, redical, terrible life, Shia Sunni ahmediya Baloch sindhi panjabi Pashtun taliban labbaik Army aam log garibi border issue jung Aur sabkuch China 🇨🇳 ke pass Girwi pada hai, karachi port, jinnah garden, gawadar sab kuch.
@Jack Kilo shukr kr us bhagwan ka jo pakistan bn gya or bngladesh alag ho gya wrna jo aj tm dharam ke name pe kr rahe ho bakchodi wo kr ni pte sb number ka khel h ek PM tk ni chun pate agr pakistan alag na hota smjhe
Bravo, aptly put. A lot of people are choosing Pakistan's path, you're bearing the torch of the path India's founding fathers had chosen. India is a great country because we are a democracy, secular country, everyone is equal by the law. I hope more and more people subscribe to this ideology, we cannot afford to choose the extremist path like Pakistan did otherwise we'd have to face the same fate as Pakistan (a failed state)
इकबाल के दूसरे वाले हम की वजह अंग्रजों का बनाया हुआ विस्वा हिंदू परिषद था भारत अगर नहीं टूटता तो ये ईस्ट इंडिया कंपनी के लिए बहुत बड़ा खतरा होता और आज भारत कबुल से लेकर अराकान तक होता
Bhai, pravachan achcha hai.. now as Pakistan ban gaya, 2 nation theory wahi sahi prove ho gayee. Now in the name of secularism, same , same policy was followed by Congress then and they followed after independence. They supported khilafat, kept eyes closed on mopla massacre. You have to understand as muslims , political and religious islam is same. You cannot change it. If you are keeping your eyes closed, you will be eliminated like other civilizations.
Sardar Patel on RSS in 1949. "Change your plans, give up secrecy, eschew communal conflict, respect the Constitution of India, show your loyalty to the Flag and make us believe that we can trust your words. To say one thing and to do another is a game which will not do."
@@hindihindu77 राष्ट्रीय स्वयंसेवक संघ और हमारी कार्य प्रणाली में हमेशा ही विरोध रहा है. जब कांग्रेसी जेल में जाते थे, उस वक्त उनकी नीति फौज और पुलिस में दाखिल होने की थी. जहा हिंदू मुसलमानों का झगडा खड़ा होने की संभावना होती, वहा वह लोग पहुंच जाते,हिंदुओ को उकसाने के लिए. उस वक्त की ब्रिटिश सरकार इन सब बातों को अपने फायदे का समझते थी. इसलिए ब्रिटिश सरकार ने भी उनको उत्तेजन दिया. नतीजा हमको भुगतना पड़ रहा है. - आचार्य विनोबा भावे, 15 मार्च 1948, सेवाग्राम
@@RahulPatil-fs7bc BHai aap pata nahi kisko represent karate ho. Congress did well for initial few years. THen lost the way. They have done most harm to this country. Also because of Congress tustikaran, Hindu Nationalism came to forefront. I don't understand why Congress support Khilafat and didn't say a word against Mopla massacre. Gandhi was not able to stop Hindu killings in Noakhali. He left Hindus to die. So it became one side fight as Muslims will not listen to Gandhi and Hindus will stop due to Gandhi. Then Shahbano case was milestone when Congress changed constitution. Bottom line is India is secular not because of constitution. it is secular becos majority is Hindu. The day it changes, India will not remain Secular. Take all the examples of neighboring countries
@@hindihindu77अगर ये तुष्टिकरण है तो हम सही रास्ते पर है सरदार पटेल जी ने दिखाए हुए रास्ते पर है कांग्रेस कांग्रेस जिंदाबाद❤️🇮🇳 हिन्दू राष्ट्र की सोच एक पागलपन है,धर्म निरपेक्षता भारत की आत्मा है. - सरदार पटेल, फरवरी 1949, मद्रास मेरे विचार में हिंदू ना देश का ना सरकार का धर्म बन सकता है। हमें याद रखना चाहिये कि हमारे देश में अल्पसंख्यक भी रहते है और ये हमारा कर्तव्य है कि उनकी सुरक्षा का प्रबन्ध करें। ये देश सबका देश है। चाहे किसी का कोई धर्म हो जाति हो। हम उस रास्ते पर नहीं चल सकते जिस पर पाकिस्तान चल रहा है। हमें यह ध्यान रखना होगा कि हमारे धर्म निरपेक्षा उद्देश्य सुरक्षित रहें। यहाँ हर मुसलमान हर ईसाई और अन्य अल्पसंख्यक वर्ग को यह विश्वास होना चाहिये कि वे सुरक्षित हैं और उसे भारतीय नागरिक की हैसियत से बराबर के अधिकार प्राप्त हैं। अगर हम उसे यह अहसास दिलाने में नाकाम रहे तो ये हमारी विरासत और देश का घोर अपमान होगा.
Aaj 70+ yr baad india k musalmano ki halat Dr Iqbal sahab k jo personal experience the use sahi sabit karte hai. Indian muslims r most suppressed community in the world. APJ Abdul Kalam sahab ko as a rastrapati isliye highlight kiya gya tha taki muslimon pe ho rahe julm ko dhaka ja sake ye kah k ki hamne muslimon ko rastrapati banaya.
Savarkar offered muslims n Christians to consider this land as fatherland. They never did it. Iqbal offered Hindus to change their faith. Savarkar hindu rashtra was inclusive but Iqbal's islamic nation was not.
बिना चीखे चिल्लाये भी अपनी बात को सौम्यता के साथ बोला जा सकता और और उसको सुना भी जा सकता है, ये रिपोर्ट इसी का उदाहरण प्रस्तुत करती है।।।
Juthi khbr btate h
@@vickyamarjeetsingh1313 ha bhai sabdo ka jhota jaal h ... sirf hindu ko bawkuf banana h bass
@@babblusingh1726 Bhai Sarkar Hindu ko bewakoof bana rhi hai na ki yeh channel
@@avengers9784 aby Karvy tu apana gayan mat dy jhadi
@@babblusingh1726 😂😂pagal
Lallutop, Iqbal jaisa aaj tk koi paida nahi, great visionary leader.
Aaj to iqbal sahi sabit ho rhe hain .. 😌
Bhai mere request hai pakistan chale jao hum tumko free ka ticket denge
@@roxxamann tumare jeeja 😂😂😂
@@yashtiwari4885 kon kiska jija hai duniyA. Janti h doglon
@@roxxamann hahahaha jali tere 😂😂😂😂
@@roxxamannmost of muslim population ne partition ko vote kiya tha
Par vote karne ke baad bhi india mai reh gaye
Iqbal the real thinker of Indian Muslims, what he said has been proven right.
There is no doubt he was great thinker but his political thinking is wrong... partition leads Hindus and muslims towards hate...it widens the gap ...and that gap push the rise of RSS in India so Iqbal was wrong but his poetry and spiritual intelligency always mesmerized everyone wether you are Hindu or Muslim...but he was wrong in his political thinking.
One who write the story owe my respect. 👌
ua-cam.com/video/nHkEKkOBMOs/v-deo.html
15 August mai Muhammad IQBAL ki gana kon kon boycott korega?
Chin - Arab hamara, Hindustan to hai hi hamara.
Muslim hai hum, sara jahan hamara.
@@dipakdebnath2285it was written after pressure from the jiahdis and mullahs. It was only hindustan hamara. But hindustan only meant Pakistan at that time so boycott is reasonable. It is nuclear what did he mean by hindustan
@@prabalmohanta138😂 Arey Mere Bhai Konse Jihadis Molana Azad Bhi To Unhi Jihadis Me Se The Iqbal Was A Pure Pakistani Khutba Allahabad Ka Pata Hai Ya Nahi Pata
@@dipakdebnath2285iqbla write this ghazal after knowing the thoughts of hindumahasabha and savarkar
Last few lines are very nicely said. It is important to prosper secular India .
But it is not the responsibility of only one religious people to keep India a secular state. All religion's people have to take this responsibility.
I think to keep any state a secular one does not depend on people but on few bunch of leaders as we have already seen during independence of India .
@nick p that's why i have mentioned only india , as during independence there was no Pakistan , which emerged out of it only on the religious basis ignoring the socio-cultural ties that people shared , i am very sure if plebiscite had happened at that time , people would have voted to remain where they were and no partition would have taken place , but future remained on some politicians and you see what they are still doing for their profits , easy way to distract from real issues . If India (whether be a Hindu majority or Muslim majority acc. to your assumption ) will follow similar thought process like Pakistan then it is open also for risking of misery that Pakistan has today .
If religion in reality is a foremost issue than Bangladeshi should have been living as a east Pakistanis .
Yes , keeping india secular is not the responsibility of hindus alone
For making secular india support uniform civil code
15 August mai Muhammad IQBAL ki gana kon kon boycott korega?
Chin - Arab hamara, Hindustan to hai hi hamara.
Muslim hai hum, sara jahan hamara.
I am Indian Muslim and I love my india and I agree Episode ka end sab se sahi hai
बहुत अच्छा एपिसोड एपीसोड के अन्त की बातें दिल में समा गई किसी पिता के दो बच्चे थे एक बच्चा सज्जन पितृ भक्त था और सब से प्रेम करता था परन्तु दूसरा रागद्वेष तथा स्वार्थ भरा था उसने बडे़ भाई से लड़ कर हिस्सा ले लिया लेकिन कभी न उन्नति कर पाया न ही गाँव के निवासियों की इज्जत पा पाया जबकि बडे़ भाई ने उन्नति की और इज्जत पायीं उसके आने वाली पीढ़ी भी उन्नति की ओर बढ़ रही है और छोटा भाई रो रहा है.इस बात को हमें समझनी चाहिए सरकार की वोट नीति पर नहीं जाना चाहिए तथा उसके कोरे भाषण नहीं सुनने चाहिए.
और हिस्से का बंटवारा कैसे हुआ एक हिस्सा छोटे भाई का दूसरे हिस्से मे बड़े छोटे दोनो का हक दूनिया मे ऐसा अनोखा बँटवारा शायद ही कही हुआ हो
Allama Iqbal (R.A) zindabad ❤️
RH not RA
Brahman samaj ka shukriya jisne hame allama Iqbal jaisa heera dia
Aaj ki indian politics ko dekh kar allama Iqwal sahi saabit hue kyunki humne khoob khoob in 7 se 8 saalon me dekh liya ki kis tarah alag alag religious communities ke sath kaisa bartaav kiya ja raha hai.
Khair mujhe ummid hai aane wale dino me isme badlaav dekhne ko milega.
Then why Jinnah thought of a united India at first? Later changed immediately.
Need to think and analysis of everything before going for a decesion..
Pehle tumlogo me desh toda
Alama Iqbal khud hi jihadi tha aur use pata tha ki uske soch ke logo ko koi jagah nhi milega ek democratic India me
Allama ikbal ka kitna bada yogdan hai india ke independence me hm kabhi nahi bhul sakte hai 👍
Kya yog Dan hai...... when he get arrested...... which jail.......
he is an average poet (Mamuli shayar)..........
India ke independence me ya paxtan ki creation me?
Tumhari community se hai iska ye Matlab nhi ki uske galat kaamo ko bhi glorify karo
@@user-lm8zd9kd1w galat kamo ko kon glorify kr rha hai saare jahan se achha hindustan hamara ye galat hai
Ye pakistani hai
आज जो कुछ भारत मे मुस्लिमो के साथ हो रहा है उसे इकबाल बहोत पहले जान चुके थे इसलिए उन्होंने अलग राष्ट्र की मांग की थी।
आपके पूर्वजों को किसने मना मना किया था क्या पाकिस्तान जाने के लिए आप भी अफगानिस्तान
Aaj gundagardi nhi chal rhi saf saf bolo😂😂
तो अभी भी निकल ले पाकिस्तान,, क्योंकि तेरे लिए तेरा मजहब ही सबसे पहले है और तू कभी भी अपने मजहब के आगे सोच ही नहीं सकता।
To der kis baat ki hai chale ja
@@Saurav_Raj46 Muslims ko vitcm banao aur agar apni takleef zahir kare tu deshdrohi boldo 😢
Hindi hain hum hindi hain hum, hindostan humara, jain hind
Muslim hun jahan hai hamara
@@fuzailrehman5396 please move to islamic mulli country..india is only for seculars and tolerant people..islam is dangerous to whole world..sooner or later it will be destroyed
@@eatlovepray2023 lol 😂 pehle hindu extremists se nipat lo
@@fuzailrehman5396 pehle jihadio se to nipat le...
Kis had tak wwfadaar ho ??? Pakistan ke against ti main bhi khada hun ,par kya jab maajid e Al aqsa par hamla hoga or india Israel ka support karega to kya tum kab bhi karoge support
*Allama Muhammad Iqbal!* ❤️
May be west British🇬🇧 be mind change ker dya hoga
I love every story natrated by Nikhil. He is best in delivering TARIKH. I don't miss a episode when I see Nikhil in it.
True your analysis is beautiful although Iqbal and Jinnah looked for a state where muslims can live in peace but the irony is indian muslims are more happy
Next Muslim partion Few years 😭😭
Wrong....Pakistan and Bangladesh creates for get power in politics and demolished Hindu religion....
Hahahha
Bjp it cell wla h kya bhai 🤣🤣🤣
@@amnibba tera owesi bjp ka dalal he....isiliye Muslim Muslim karta he....baki history padhle samajh jayega...Pakistani supporter
Are you dreaming
Day lite dream
Well researched.. Beautifully articulated, and those last lines.. Simply wow..
Keep up the good work.
Long live India 🇮🇳🇮🇳💪💪
@@jaihind9194 see, I agree with what you are saying.. There are some reasons due to which an ideology or thought process evolves or changes. Otherwise, when sir syed who once said, India is a beautiful bride and Hindus and Muslims are two eys of it, changed his views and after sometime he was the one who said, Hindus and Muslims are two different nations and cannot live together.
Backtracking would lead to no where and how far one can go. Like, reasons behind sir syed views changes was, Arya samaj and its shuddhi movement, and swami dayanand saraswati saying, "Hindustan sirf Hinduon k liye" as early as 1860. Then local government elections propounded by Lord Lytton, made people like sir syed apprehensive about Muslims being reduced to second class citizens as they are lesser in numbers.
Now this lead to, formation of Muslim league in 1906-07 and ultimately getting separate electorate. This one apparently sided favour by government towards Muslim lead to apprehensions among hindus and so, Hindu mahasabha came into being in 1915 and ultimately RSS in 1925.
This is one of the examples that I quoted which lead to the growing tensions.
But the point is how far one can backtrack.. Now even Hindus can say, since there was growth in conversion due to missionary activities by Christians and revivalist Muslim movements like Deoband movement, lead to radical approach by hindu organisations like Arya samaj.
So, why I said, it was well researched, because people who are being mentioned here that is Jinnah and Allama iqbal, only contributed to this thing (given prevailing political situation in the country) than to allay such idea like Maulana Azad and Dr zakir Hussain sahab did. Similarly, there were hindu leaders like Savarkar, golwalker who were on the other side of the spectrum, and were speaking for Hindus only rather india as a whole., but at the same time there were hindu leaders like, Gandhiji, Rajendra Prasad who were fighting for a joint India.
Long live Hindu Rashtra Bharat 🕉 🛕 🚩
@@jaihind9194 let me fix an appointment with a psychiatrist for you...
JAI HIND..🇳🇪
@@jaihind9194 if you start back tracking you can say that two nation theory came when Bin Qasim landed in Sindh and that's what they teach in Pakistan. The two nation theory that we are talking about here is the one thought by Iqbal and implemented by Jinnah and resulted in blood bath during partition. This theory also permanently damaged the relations between Hindus and Muslims.
@@jaihind9194 so we stick to the 2 nation theory which was actually implemented and its author didn't care about the bloodshed it has caused. Also which resulted in creating a separate country on the basis of convoluted idea that Muslims cannot live with non -Muslims.
bahut hi behtreen koshish NIKHIL sir aapne bahut sahi tarike se bina kisi pakshpaath ke is mudde ko hamare saamne rakha he ummid he ki hamare watan parast log is mudde ko samjhenge, ye mudda sirf hindu muslim par jakar nahi rukega, hindu muslim ke baad kshetriya vibhajan, uske baad panth, uske baad jaat biradari aur uske baad khanadan par jakar ye rukega........ hum dobara desh ka batwara bardasht nahi kar sakenge....... thank you sir
ua-cam.com/video/nHkEKkOBMOs/v-deo.html
Tum bantwara kyu chahoge .tumhe pura bharat Darul Islam banana hai
@@surenderkumarmahto1055 Bhai esme buraie galat kya Hai
@@aaftabali5500 tumhare liye bura thodi hoga.hamare liye bura hai
Sahi kaha ham dubara vibhajan nhi chahte isliye next pm yogi ko hi banayege. 😊 happy
Allama Iqbal is a legendary personality
He is Islamist nothing else
Tukde tukde wala tha ye
Legend se lund tak safar
@@Peaceful_World130 bro everyone have a different view on every topic. You can Express your feelings with your positivity😇
❤️ we love India 🇮🇳 forever ❤️
what about two way sickularism?
Zabardast eye opening, It shows extremitioms can damage country really hard, please be aware of politicians who manipulate on name of religion to unite, rather to unite on 🇮🇳for country 🙏🙏🙏
Sabse zyada extremist to tumhi ho.
Please Bhagwan ke liye ab ye mat kehna ki isis, lashkar e taiyaba, al qaeda aur taliban, RSS ki wing hai.
@@user-lm8zd9kd1w extremist spotted 🤣
Quran and Hadiths should be purged of extremist verses and references. Educated Muslims like you should take the lead. That is the only way forward.
@@user-lm8zd9kd1w pata hai mob lyching tripura up and all country main one sided game chalra hai people knows who's extremists now...
हिन्दी/हिन्दू है हम बतन 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳हिन्दुस्तान हमारा।
पहले इकबाल ने दिल से कहा जो बो सच
Hindi = Hindustani
Me jab bhi Arab country me gaya, Budhde aged arbo ne muje sirf hindi kaha. Na kabhi hindu ya mushlim sikh kaha.
Kyuki hindi hai hum hindustan watan hamara
Not " Hindu"
It's Republic of India..
A shame of democracy , a nation like India !!
Cry more ....hindu h hum watan h@@Arunava_Sar
In last minute the "Post script" Well define,why our nation is best
Why should we save our democracy .
One of the best episode.
जिस दिन संख्या बल में तुम कम हो जाओगे उस दिन डेमोक्रेसी तुम्हें बचाने नहीं आएगी पाकिस्तान और बांग्लादेश का उदाहरण तुम्हारे सामने है
@@AjaykumarYadav-ux1et sayad india me hindu k population ka idea nahi h Tumko..
Hamlog k population aranjeb nhi katam kr saka.. Ab to ye karna namumkin h
@@collegedays1324 During partition their population is not more than 30 percent and India is not only one example
Serbia- koosvo,Sudan- South Sudan, Nigeria aur v bahut saare example hain.
@@collegedays1324 बेवकूफ इंसान अपनी आंखों का पर्दा हटाओ
मुसलमानों ने तुम से पाकिस्तान लिया
बांग्लादेश लिया
अफगानिस्तान तुमसे ले लिय
किसी समय इंडोनेशिया भी हिंदू राष्ट्र था
अब भारत की बात बताता हूं
मेघालय मणिपुर त्रिपुरा अरुणाचल प्रदेश केरल कश्मीर लक्षदीप और आधा पश्चिम बंगाल मैं हिंदू संप्रदाय अल्पसंख्यक हो चुका है
धन्यवाद
@@AjaykumarYadav-ux1et WhatsApp university k digree panewala gyan deraha hain !
Meghalaya, mizuram, Nagaland, manipur sare state me majority isai dharam manne wala hain ! Kerala me 26% musolmane Bengal me 29% musolmane
Naa samjo he to mit jaao he aee Hindustan walo
Tumari daasta.n Tak na hongi dastaano me
Feel the lines -allamaiqbalsays ❣️
सरफ़रोशी की तमन्ना, अब हमारे दिल में है। देखना है ज़ोर कितना, बाज़ु-ए-कातिल में है
Feel this bhagat singh line ❤
इस्लामिक राष्ट्र बन कर कया खास हासिल किया पाकिस्तान ने जो कुछ लोग भारत को हिन्दू राष्ट्र बनाना चाहते हैं, और क्या आजादी के वक्त अगर हिन्दू राष्ट्र की बात होती तो नक्शा यही रहता
Secular se better atheist country honi chahiye thi. Religion is the problem of all the issues.
@@rk-ind-oz धर्म को समस्या पैदा नहीं करता , बल्कि नेताओ ने अपनी समस्या हल करने का तरीक़ा खोज लिए हैं m
@@rk-ind-oz true , all religions are fake , there is no god
@@rk-ind-oz atheism is future
@@profarmer9087 right bro
Muslim hai hm Watan hai sara Jahan hmaara
Pakistan nikal
Alama iqbal our proud ❤
Is Desh Ke Zarre Zarre ko Hum Apne Khoon Se Senchengey
Allah Ki Kasam Is Dharti Ko Gulzar Bana Kar Dam Lengey☝️💚
Ye sang e gira jo hayal hai raste se hata kr dum lenge izzat se jiye to ji lenge ya jaaam e shahadat pee lenge
Jitni malomat allama iqbal us waqt men thi bina inter net bina tv ki aj puri lallantop team ko nahi hogi aj
Humare liye to alama iqbal ki poetry ki ek pankhdi hi kafi hia.
Sare jahha se acha Hindusta🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳 humara hum bulbule hai is ke ye gulista humara❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️.
Vo Muslim leaders jinho ne two nation theory ka oppose kiya tha...un par bhi ek vedio banaaen....aap gagar me Sagar bhar dete hain... great
Bhai naam ginwa do please
@@suhailsingh7138maine aapka comment Aaj hi dekha moulana Abdul Kalam aajad, dr.syyed Ahmad khan, Khan Abdul gaffar our bhi hai kaho to research karke bata deta hun
kya insan ho be abdul kalam sahab bahut chhote the azadi ke waqt. aur o kameena dazzal firaun goron ki jutiya chatne wala hindustan ka pahla hindu muslim fasad karane wala ladkiyon ke taleem ke khilaf khada hone wala castist yahood ka agent syyed ahmad khan vo azadi se 40 50 sal pahle guzar gaya tha.khan abdul gaffar khan was a great leader and true freedom fighter lekin aakhiri waqt vo bhi majboori me pakistan chale gaye the. @@imranHussain-ww5jy
Iqbal was radicalized why living in Europe. The geopolitics at that time was such that Germany had an alliance with Ottoman empire. They have pushed these religious feelings to create pushback for other European powers (England and France) Something on the line of what has happened in Afghanistan where USA used the religion card to push out USSR.
ur comment makes sense
@@dipakdebnath2285arai dono alag alag najam hai
Iqbal was radical and In india cow-dung eater and cow-meat eaters live side by side ?
It's been 75+ years of partition and despite Pakistan being in crisis his points are still valid.
@@haseebahmed3258stop eating cow then
You have plenty of meat like goat,fish and chicken
Simple is that
Dr apj Abdul Kalam become president of india
I love Iqbal ..
When allama iqbal returned to europe he said : muslaman ko musalman kr diya toofan e maghrib ne ❤
I am currently living in his name's hostel Allama Iqbal boarding house,AMU but the respect is not given by video logo .. He was a great scholar and you have not right to disrespect him
Hindu thinks all muslim leader were bad villian
@@taslim1344 i agree with you they do this for their views 🙌
@@Youth910no they really believe in it i suggest to read iblees k majlees e shura by iqbal for explanation u can watch Dr Zakir Naik
Sorry Dr israr Ahmed
Kya disrespect ki hai, impartial video hai ye.
Great poet iqbal
Esse soch se mujhe problem hai fhir mulle kahte hain desh mai comnual badh rha hai thankgod jo soye hue hindu jag rhe hain
Aur kuch log kehte hai hum mushlim hai, hum hindu hai ..
Areee bewakufo sare hindustani ho, chahe hindu kaho ya hindi kaho .
Me jab bhi Arabic county me gaya budhhe aged arbo ne muje bina dharm dekhe kaha hindi ho tum ?
Sambhal jao hindustanio
Ikbal bewakuf ban gaya aur Quran k khilaf jakar apne watan k tukde kiye
Aaj dekho Pakistan me kya hai ?
Daily fight, redical, terrible life, Shia Sunni ahmediya Baloch sindhi panjabi Pashtun taliban labbaik Army aam log garibi border issue jung
Aur sabkuch China 🇨🇳 ke pass Girwi pada hai, karachi port, jinnah garden, gawadar sab kuch.
Great poet iqbal
@@or220 pakistan largest army surrender 😂
muslim hy hum watan hy sara jahan hamara 💞
Pakistan to sambhal ly apna pehly.
Allama iqbaal aap pe lakho salam
Wow !!
बहुत ही अच्छा लेखन और बोला भी बहुत अच्छा है
धन्यवाद
उत्कृष्ठ पत्रकारिता 🙏निखिल भईया
Iqbal and Jinnah changed and so all the muslims after Rajpal maloon and GHAZI ILM UD DIN SHAHEED.....
they realised how hindoo will treat Muslims once Brits left
And they're absolutely right
You're right
Muslims are being treated in the same way as they have been treating yahudi, Christians, and Hindus for a long period of time, it is karma, but I accept it is wrong.
@@tangocharlie2453 muslims are the only nation who gave refuge to YAHUDIS go read some history as they were persecuted around the world Muslims protected them and Muslims only nation in the world who never persecuted any other nation or race......
Read some independent and unbiased true history......
It's not karma it's punishment for turning away from our deen so was done to every Muslim ummahs before ummah of Muhammad SAW
@@MsIdiot000 Surah 5 (Al-Ma’idah)
Verse 51:
O you who have believed, do not take the Jews and the Christians as allies. They are [in fact] allies of one another. And whoever is an ally to them among you - then indeed, he is [one] of them. Indeed, Allah guides not the wrongdoing people.
The prophet waged war against the Christians and Jews because they didn't believed (respected)Mohammad as any prophet.
A Jew lady who was taken as a slave named zainab poisoned the prophet as she claimed that her family members were killed by the prophet.
From sahih bukhari
Allama iqbal and Jinnah always right bro❤️🇵🇰
How they ??? explain.....
Isliye masjid me blast. Aur shiya ahmadiya ki pelai hoti hai us pak me
Aur kuch log kehte hai hum mushlim hai, hum hindu hai ..
Areee bewakufo sare hindustani ho, chahe hindu kaho ya hindi kaho .
Me jab bhi Arabic county me gaya budhhe aged arbo ne muje bina dharm dekhe kaha hindi ho tum ?
Sambhal jao hindustanio
Ikbal bewakuf ban gaya aur Quran k khilaf jakar apne watan k tukde kiye
Aaj dekho Pakistan me kya hai ?
Daily fight, redical, terrible life, Shia Sunni ahmediya Baloch sindhi panjabi Pashtun taliban labbaik Army aam log garibi border issue jung
Aur sabkuch China 🇨🇳 ke pass Girwi pada hai, karachi port, jinnah garden, gawadar sab kuch.
Explain
आज मुझे गर्व है में धर्मनिरपेक्ष भारतीय हूं❤️🇮🇳
भारत धर्म निरपेक्ष नही पंथ निरपेक्ष है
संविधान की प्रस्तावना पढो जाकर
👍
Jaise Iqbal k poorvaj 300 saal pehle hindu secular, vaise hi tumhare vansaj 300 saal baad allah hu akbar bolte milenge. Kyonki unka daada Rahul patil proud secular tha, jabki tumko proud hindu hona tha. Jinnah or Iqbal tumse jyada padh likhe, phir b secular nai hue,
@@Randomindian7 bhai aise hi secular k vansaj 100 saal baad Alaah u akbar krte nazar aayenge, jaise iqbal k poorvaj secular hindu hoke convert hue. Jinnah ka dada secular hindu tha. 🙏
@@Randomindian7 i am law student😂
Hats off to the writer and the narrator 🙏🙏🙏
15 August mai Muhammad IQBAL ki gana kon kon boycott korega?
Chin - Arab hamara, Hindustan to hai hi hamara.
Muslim hai hum, sara jahan hamara.
He didn't demand He didn't Proposed He predicted the That at least a Nation In the North west India is the destiny of the Indian Muslim.
He is most Educated & Most Influential poet of the 20th Century India.
He is the man that born once in 100 years.
He was a,
Poet
Philosopher
Thinker
Visionary
Reformer
Professor
Islamic Scolor
Lawyer
Politicians
Sufi
One the Greatest Muslims of All time.
He is my Ideal,
He was a Fundamentalists Anti Nationalist Anti Materialist
He was Right I support him in 95% What he has done.
He was the poet of east
He is Hakeem of the Ummat-e-Muslima
His poetry is majory for the muslims
Pakistan was never what the Iqbal wanted a nation to be.
I agree with all points except that he was not a sufi in his second innings. He was one earlier!
@@ranjittyagi9354 please explain me sir!
Your reply is interesting!
I just have one word to say "Wow".
@@jaihind9194 if you think this is true , they all were sidelined by congress
Wahhh ,,,जबरदस्त टॉपिक आपने लिया 👌💐💐💐💐
अल्लामा इकबाल ने जो कहा वो अब सही होता दिख रहा है।
Jihadi soch.
Uniform civil court aane wala hai. Sharia jane wala hai😂
@@AkashKumar-jp4qb UNIFROM CIVIL COURT MAI SABSE HADA NUKSAAN BHI TUM LOG KA HOGA.
AAJ HAR JAGHA MANDIR BANA DIYE HO CHAHE POLICE STATION HO YA ROAD KA DIVIDER.
@X Factor hahaha Abe Kuch BHI Yaha tere is gobar gyaan ki jarurat thi Nahi waise ,topic BHI ye Nahi hai.
@@hasanmohd4273 Accha kitni nazayaz mazar tooti hai. Up me. Beech rod pe railway station pe highway pe tum log kabza kre hue the. Koi bhi sarkari jameen pe bna ho mandir he kyu na ho htt jye koi problem nhi mujhe. Pr tum log ko ho jati hai dekho muslim pe atyachaar ho rha bolke.
Sirf ummat
Allama Iqbal ki baat aaj sahi saabit ho rahi hai,BJP hampe julm karne pe tuli hui hai,,, Aakhir wo philospher the bhai, Itni dur ka socha unhone, aalah unhe jannat mein aala makam ata kare.
allama iqwal aatankwadi tha jisne islam k name pr alg desh le liya aur yaha k makkar conngress ne sare musalmano ko hissa dekar bhi rakh liya
Urdu se meethi koi juban nahi hai,
❤️❤️🤗🤗❤️❤️
Terrorists ki zubaan hai
@@Annu.26 sahi baat hai bhai
@Nadim Khan
It's also the language of traitors and
back stabbers !🤣😂
How many languages do you know?
No Brother visit Maharashtra you will definitely love *Marathi* language.
Excellent💯 shi h...ek bar bhedbhav shuru ho gya to wo kaha jake rukega kisi ko pta nhi ❤
Iqbal though was brilliant. We can see Muslim condition in india.. 👌👌👌
we can see muslim condition in pakistan...then realize that how happy you are in India...
Iqbal thought was wrong there is no doubt he was great thinker but his political thinking was wrong...his idea of partition leads hate between Hindus and muslims ...and finally give to the rise of RSS that's why muslims condition is bad in our country .
Agr batwara na hota to aaj musalman ki abadi 70cr+ hoti or hmare interest ko dabaya nhi jata smjhe
@@middleclassmc9202 batwary k time pe 7 cr Muslim tha or 21 cr hindu..
Hindu phr bi 3 times zada thy start sy
@@imranhaider1029 us 10 cr tha or abhi 75cr hota
Allama Iqbal ji dimaag ne "U turn" liya from love to hate .
Allama Iqbal never showed consistency in his thoughts. On one hand, he praises the Himalaya and the Shivala, Ram and Ganga, and then a few years later, talks of Muslim conquests that had nothing to do with Indian sub continent. He had his own mind and way of thinking.
@@ranjittyagi9354 he was pure a jihadi minded. he did al taqiya by praising shri ram
@@utkarshagrawal2002 initially wasn't. Later, he changed 180⁰.
You forget that Hindutva movements were on the rise ( Brahamu samaaj, Sudhi, Sanghatan). Congress were not the Congress of 1900s or 1910s. Moti Lal Nehru is one of the reason plus 1937-39 Congress governments in different Indian states freaked muslim elite like it would do now under Modi sarkar.
Political history is Science, it never forgives or forgets.
mere peer ka yaum-e-paidaish hai aaj💞
Peer Iqbal Qalandar Lahori (ra)
बेहतरीन वीडियो।।।लेकिन बेहतर होता lallantop उत्तराखंड स्थापना दिवस पर भी ध्यान देता।
More power to u boy ! God bless u ! So clearly explained ! Amazing !
Hindu hai mai hindustan harmar sara jaha harma jai hind 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
आप के तारीख की जितनी तारीफ़ हो कम है. भारतीय राम तीर्थ को अमूमन नहीं पढ़ते. रामतीर्थ फारसी भाषा में भी लिखते थे. ब्यक्ति के सभी गुणों का आकलन करना चाहिए.मूल विचार मननीय होना चाहिए.
Iqbal aur jinna wadi soch aaj hindustan mein bhi phail rahi hai jo desh ka nuksan ke alawa kich nahi karegi...
Wonderful script 👍🏼
तुम इस्लामी पाकिस्तान बनाओ और हिंदुओंको उपदेश करे हिंदुस्तान को भी सेक्युलिरिज्म का धर्मनिरपेक्षता का !वा भाई वा
Hindustan is liye Dharam nirpekch hai ki molana Muhammad Ali Johar molana Abdul Kalam Azad molana mehmood Hasan Yeh bhi sotantarta senani the aur bhi bahut name hai Jo Bharat ki baat karte the
@@ajmalkhanfurqankhan9849 ye sab mil ke Pakistan manga tha
Jo le bhi lia
Ye sirf bharat ko barbaad karne ka baat kia
Nikhil is doing 👍work.Saurabh sir has lot of impact on lallantop
Two nations theory was first proposed by Allama iqbal
Emanated from Syed Ahmad.
Savarkar
@@dineshkumar-dx8fq Asthana sir why hindu never tell these fact to their children
Hindu should also tell their children that Koran is copied from bible & torakh of Jews so that the conversion to that religion Wil Stop
@@MS-ch5vg first by Syed Ahmed Khan then by Iqbal both received knighthood from British, Iqbal knew Jinnah can be a tool to fetch the partition from Congress leaders as he was very intelligent. Vaise British k talwe chaat kr unde Pakistan le liye.
No it was propounded by sir Syed Ahmed Khan...before that the decision based on religion was propagated by Karl Marx..communists n extremists destroyed the world
Iqbal ne Sabit Kiya Ki Muslim ke liye Islam Pahle hai Desh baad me. Kuch Apwad hote hain Jaise Hamare Hero Veer Andul Hameed.
I am muslim, lekin ye dekhkar rona ata hai or pachtava hota hai unn musalmaano ki soch par jo dekhte the ke hindustan mai koi participation nhi hai musalmaano ka, mai 5 wakt ki namaaz padhta hu, zakaat deta hu wo bhi puri azaadi se sare faraiz ada krta hu or apna watan se bhut pyaar krta hu or afsoos or ghussa ata hai un logo ke faisla par jinhona partition karaya pta nhi inhona kya padha London jakar. 😞😭.
SARE JAHA SE ACHA HINDUSTAN HAMARA. Jai Hind🇮🇳🇮🇳
Aap ki bato se hm bhi egree hai, kusurwar jinna hai mulq n bata hota toh aaj hamari halat shadi aisi n hoti, muslim bhi tadad me hote mazbut hote,
allama Iqbal was right history has proved him right he saw the future
Allama Iqbal ne sayad aj ka bharat dekh liya tha 100 sal pehle isliye yeh kaha tha 🙂🙂
Ha Pakistan Bangladesh Afghanistan bhi dekha honga
Allama Iqbal ko Pakistan, Afghanistan, Iraq, Syria, Iran, Libiya, Lebanon, Yemen bhi dekh lena chahiye tha
@@beastbhaiya04 Iraq aur Iran me kya hua abhi,...aur 40-50 country aur h, 2-3 hi mile. ...hum dusro ke bjay apne desh pr dhyan de to jyada achchha hoga ,hmare liye ,auro se sabak le kr
@@indianbhaukaaltv4702 him 7-8 country ka maine naam diya hai vo aatankwadi ghatna se parast hai aur baki Saudi, UAE aur ek do ko haata lo unme to greh yudh hi hota rahta hai, kabhi sena hi sarkar par kabza kar leti hai
Ha bahot door ka dekha hoga........
Ajka pakistan, Bangladesh, Afghanistan,
shayad Seria, Yemen, boko haram, ISIS, bhi dekha hoga
allama Iqbal was a changed man since he came back from London he saw what was happening in Europe which changed his views
Mujhe to ikbaal ke kaumi tarana jo hindustan k liye likha tha bhut pasand hai mai hamesha chahta hu ki sare jahan se achcha hindustan hamara ye national song hona tha
Ek jangad mangal
Ek sare jaha se achcha
Ye dono tarana(rastriya geet) bahut pasand hai
Aur kuch log kehte hai hum mushlim hai, hum hindu hai ..
Areee bewakufo sare hindustani ho, chahe hindu kaho ya hindi kaho .
Me jab bhi Arabic county me gaya budhhe aged arbo ne muje bina dharm dekhe kaha hindi ho tum ?
Sambhal jao hindustanio
Ikbal bewakuf ban gaya aur Quran k khilaf jakar apne watan k tukde kiye
Aaj dekho Pakistan me kya hai ?
Daily fight, redical, terrible life, Shia Sunni ahmediya Baloch sindhi panjabi Pashtun taliban labbaik Army aam log garibi border issue jung
Aur sabkuch China 🇨🇳 ke pass Girwi pada hai, karachi port, jinnah garden, gawadar sab kuch.
Allama Iqbal thinker and dreamer of Pakistan
This is universal truth, wherever Whenever Muslim will become majority survival of others people always become tough.
Thank you lallantop team 🙏
Team lallantop,specially Kamal sir the writer of this series,itni acchi stories likhne ke liye behad shukriya aapka.
Feedback : Episode ko 15min ka bnaya kre and current ki situations ko bhi include kiya kre.
Dr. Manmohan joshi sir विधिक शिक्षा India's no 1 platform for judiciary exam and a great mentor ❤️
jai hind ... "INDIA" one beautiful country , One Beautiful Story.
15 August mai Muhammad IQBAL ki gana kon kon boycott korega?
Chin - Arab hamara, Hindustan to hai hi hamara.
Muslim hai hum, sara jahan hamara.
The concluding remarks are precious! Kudos!
What made Iqbal changed his thoughts and adopted 2 nation theory
Jihadi mindset
Aur kuch log kehte hai hum mushlim hai, hum hindu hai ..
Areee bewakufo sare hindustani ho, chahe hindu kaho ya hindi kaho .
Me jab bhi Arabic county me gaya budhhe aged arbo ne muje bina dharm dekhe kaha hindi ho tum ?
Sambhal jao hindustanio
Ikbal bewakuf ban gaya aur Quran k khilaf jakar apne watan k tukde kiye
Aaj dekho Pakistan me kya hai ?
Daily fight, redical, terrible life, Shia Sunni ahmediya Baloch sindhi panjabi Pashtun taliban labbaik Army aam log garibi border issue jung
Aur sabkuch China 🇨🇳 ke pass Girwi pada hai, karachi port, jinnah garden, gawadar sab kuch.
Nikhil our country need people like you who study things and then comment
*अलामा इक़बाल को लंदन जाकर ऐसी कौनसी ज्ञानप्राप्ति हो गई की वो "मज़हब नहीं सिखाता" से "मुस्लिम है हम" हो गए??*
London wahi he na jisne devide and rule ke jariye hum par raaj kiya shayad wahi gyaan mila hoga.....
@Jack Kilo shukr kr us bhagwan ka jo pakistan bn gya or bngladesh alag ho gya wrna jo aj tm dharam ke name pe kr rahe ho bakchodi wo kr ni pte sb number ka khel h ek PM tk ni chun pate agr pakistan alag na hota smjhe
@@delhikhan6494 absolutely bro
@@delhikhan6494 victim card khelna shuru😝
Angrejo ne paisa de diya hoga😆
Alhamdulillah mujhe khooshi hai k hamare dada pr dada ne hindustan me rhne ka faisla liya....
Taki fhir se esko islamic country banao
Bravo, aptly put.
A lot of people are choosing Pakistan's path, you're bearing the torch of the path India's founding fathers had chosen.
India is a great country because we are a democracy, secular country, everyone is equal by the law.
I hope more and more people subscribe to this ideology, we cannot afford to choose the extremist path like Pakistan did otherwise we'd have to face the same fate as Pakistan (a failed state)
Wow , what a clarity in thought !!!
इकबाल के दूसरे वाले हम की वजह अंग्रजों का बनाया हुआ विस्वा हिंदू परिषद था भारत अगर नहीं टूटता तो ये ईस्ट इंडिया कंपनी के लिए बहुत बड़ा खतरा होता और आज भारत कबुल से लेकर अराकान तक होता
Iqbal ka usme apna swarth tha.
अच्छा है!सारे जहाँ से अच्छा हिन्दोस्ता हमारा......
......तुम हो तो क्या तुम हो' ये शायरी बौर्डर फिल्म मे सनी देवल जैकी सरोफ से कही थी।।
Bhai, pravachan achcha hai.. now as Pakistan ban gaya, 2 nation theory wahi sahi prove ho gayee. Now in the name of secularism, same , same policy was followed by Congress then and they followed after independence. They supported khilafat, kept eyes closed on mopla massacre. You have to understand as muslims , political and religious islam is same. You cannot change it. If you are keeping your eyes closed, you will be eliminated like other civilizations.
I'm Truly Proud To Be A I'm Indian Muslim Because I Know Islam Is The 😘🇮🇳
You support secularism?
Sardar Patel on RSS in 1949.
"Change your plans, give up secrecy, eschew communal conflict, respect the Constitution of India, show your loyalty to the Flag and make us believe that we can trust your words. To say one thing and to do another is a game which will not do."
Same congressi negotiated India partition with Jinnah
@@hindihindu77 राष्ट्रीय स्वयंसेवक संघ और हमारी कार्य प्रणाली में हमेशा ही विरोध रहा है. जब कांग्रेसी जेल में जाते थे, उस वक्त उनकी नीति फौज और पुलिस में दाखिल होने की थी. जहा हिंदू मुसलमानों का झगडा खड़ा होने की संभावना होती, वहा वह लोग पहुंच जाते,हिंदुओ को उकसाने के लिए. उस वक्त की ब्रिटिश सरकार इन सब बातों को अपने फायदे का समझते थी. इसलिए ब्रिटिश सरकार ने भी उनको उत्तेजन दिया. नतीजा हमको भुगतना पड़ रहा है.
- आचार्य विनोबा भावे, 15 मार्च 1948,
सेवाग्राम
@@RahulPatil-fs7bc BHai aap pata nahi kisko represent karate ho. Congress did well for initial few years. THen lost the way. They have done most harm to this country. Also because of Congress tustikaran, Hindu Nationalism came to forefront. I don't understand why Congress support Khilafat and didn't say a word against Mopla massacre. Gandhi was not able to stop Hindu killings in Noakhali. He left Hindus to die. So it became one side fight as Muslims will not listen to Gandhi and Hindus will stop due to Gandhi. Then Shahbano case was milestone when Congress changed constitution. Bottom line is India is secular not because of constitution. it is secular becos majority is Hindu. The day it changes, India will not remain Secular. Take all the examples of neighboring countries
@@hindihindu77अगर ये तुष्टिकरण है तो हम सही रास्ते पर है सरदार पटेल जी ने दिखाए हुए रास्ते पर है कांग्रेस
कांग्रेस जिंदाबाद❤️🇮🇳
हिन्दू राष्ट्र की सोच एक पागलपन है,धर्म निरपेक्षता भारत की आत्मा है. - सरदार पटेल, फरवरी 1949, मद्रास
मेरे विचार में हिंदू ना देश का ना सरकार का धर्म बन सकता है। हमें याद रखना चाहिये कि हमारे देश में अल्पसंख्यक भी रहते है और ये हमारा कर्तव्य है कि उनकी सुरक्षा का प्रबन्ध करें। ये देश सबका देश है। चाहे किसी का कोई धर्म हो जाति हो। हम उस रास्ते पर नहीं चल सकते जिस पर पाकिस्तान चल रहा है। हमें यह ध्यान रखना होगा कि हमारे धर्म निरपेक्षा उद्देश्य सुरक्षित रहें। यहाँ हर मुसलमान हर ईसाई और अन्य अल्पसंख्यक वर्ग को यह विश्वास होना चाहिये कि वे सुरक्षित हैं और उसे भारतीय नागरिक की हैसियत से बराबर के अधिकार प्राप्त हैं। अगर हम उसे यह अहसास दिलाने में नाकाम रहे तो ये हमारी विरासत और देश का घोर अपमान होगा.
@@RahulPatil-fs7bc ये देश हिन्दू राष्ट्र ही है । पाकिस्तान बनने के साथ ही ये तय हो गया ।
The Great Iqbal, We lost our heart ❤
iqbal zindabad ❤️✌️
Thank you allama Iqbal. You did such a great favour to Muslims. God bless your soul
Not for muslims and not for pakistani look how much chaos pakistan is in
Tum us haram ke pille allama iqbal ki bat to nahi kar rahe ho ??????
@@pigeonlover935 is Liye ka tum kafir sazish kerty rahty hoo
sach yeh he ke,
zinnah aur iqbal sahi nikle.
aaj jo minorities ki haal india me he.
Ab bhi time h chala ja.
Puchha tere se kisi ne?
@@TheHafeisticShow Mohammad was ram rahim n asaram of 7th century. He was lucky he was not exposed. He has lot of andhbhakt today.
Gavanr...
WhatsApp university.
That's why jinnah is very famous in up politics... They know still 20 crore jinnah lover left in India
बहुत अच्छी जानकारी दी है,, धन्यवाद
This tool of secularism is assisting islamists to convert this remaining land too into darul Islam...great..
Allama Iqbal ❤️❤️❤️ Rekhta e Iqbal❤️❤️
पाकिस्तान एक मुस्लिम राष्ट्र होने के बावजूद पाकिस्तान में सिर्फ 120000 मस्जिद हैं लेकिन भारत में 300000 मस्जिद है।
ये सोचने की विषय है।
Ye sochne ka nahi ,Sharam karne
ki baat hai ..Secularism ke nam
pe desh barbad kardiya .😇
Karan India main muslims jada hai isliye
@@thehp3001 muslim Kam hone chahiyen kya Pakistan me hindu jyada hai
@@72hooren67 ek baat bata har video mai tera comments hota hai it cell se 2 rs mil gya....yeh agli baar apni ghar ki aurto ko na bej dena 😂😂😂😂
@@mypride4973
Ek baat bata ,Bap hai tera ya
Haalala se paida hua ?😂🤣
Wah... Laga tha... Kya baat hai... Kitni achi bhasha ka istemal karte hai
Aaj 70+ yr baad india k musalmano ki halat Dr Iqbal sahab k jo personal experience the use sahi sabit karte hai. Indian muslims r most suppressed community in the world.
APJ Abdul Kalam sahab ko as a rastrapati isliye highlight kiya gya tha taki muslimon pe ho rahe julm ko dhaka ja sake ye kah k ki hamne muslimon ko rastrapati banaya.
Allama Iqbal ki bat sach horhi hai ajbhi musalman ke sath bhed bhao or dusre darje ka shahri banadiya hai
इकबाल ने कहा, एक स्वायत्त राज्य। सावरकर ने "पुण्यभूमि और पितृभूमि" के सिद्धांत को दो राष्ट्र सिद्धांत के अग्रदूत के रूप में रखा।
Masha lulla
Mohammad was ram rahim n asaram of 7th century. He was lucky he was not exposed. He has lot of andhbhakt today.
Savarkar offered muslims n Christians to consider this land as fatherland. They never did it.
Iqbal offered Hindus to change their faith. Savarkar hindu rashtra was inclusive but Iqbal's islamic nation was not.
Distorted view on savarkar will get reply by distorted view on Islam