The fact that Qui Gon was so attuned to the Force, I think he'd have trained Anakin to be a pure Jedi 👍 not a slave to the arrogant ways they followed. Qui Gon followed the will of the force and nothing else.
“If the training of young Anakin would not be sanctioned by the Jedi it shall be sanctioned by the force.” That is the most qui gon statement I’ve ever heard
Obiwan would’ve left, too. This is shortly after him and Satine’s original fling and Quigon leaving would’ve given him the courage to do the same thing.
And give the new splinter cell order Mandalore to set up shop on. A new pacifist regime, a rogue jedi master, knight and padawon Mandalore would be a happening place for balance. (yeah Dathomir is badass but I'm pretty sure Qui-Gon would not be willing to bring a kid there, the angsty teenager, oh yeah)
@@timlewis9004 Like they never were before...? They never got with the times or tried to change their ways as the galaxy changed around them. That's how the Sith nearly did the Jedi in every time.
@@99thJediWarrior Can't argue with that. I don't understand why Yoda or Mace never realized the danger of being ignorant to the dark side. Especially after Mauls defeat to obi wan. They knew there was another sith out there and later they knew the dark side was clouding their vision. Seems like it would be glaringly obvious that they needed to break out of their comfort zone.
@@timlewis9004 most of the Jedi council were generals on the frontlines of the clone wars, palpatine did a good job keeping them distracted as he took over the government
Qui gonn probably would have been smart enough to realize that going back and saving Anakin's mother from slavery and her eventual demise would greatly aid his training of Anakin as his doubts and fear of losing her would be reduced and when her time does come he would be old and wise enough to accept the nature of the force and not try to bend it to his will by way of the dark side
Honestly, hard agree. It's really sad that the council could have easily saved her from slavery, but chose not to. Anakin becoming Vader, was a very slow burn that could've easily been prevented if the council weren't so emotionless and dogmatic.
I doubt Qui-Gon would have waited ten years before saving Shmi. Knowing that Shmi was a slave, Qui-Gon probably would have saved her sometime during Anakin's first year on Coruscant. Even if the Jedi Council forbid it, Qui-Gon and Anakin would have simply taken the long way back after one of their missions in deep space, via Tatooine, and rescued Shmi.
@@LoganDX1990 Actually there is. It's called Star Wars Infinities. It's a comic book series that basically rewrites the Original Trilogy movies 4 - 6. It goes over what would have happened if Luke didn't destroy the Death Star as well as many other hypothetical parts of the series. You can find it on UA-cam as well. Take a look, you'll love it 😁👍🏿
Yoda: train the boy, you will not Qui-gon-gin: *leaves Jedi order* Dooku: *leaves Jedi order* Yoda: no no, this isn't how you're suppossed to play the game
If Qui Gon replaced Obi Wan in the Mustafar duel. Anakin: From my point of view the jedi are evil! Qui Gon: *Smacks Anakin* Shut up. Anakin: Yes master...
We need a part two. Star Wars Theory made a theory about exactly the same concept and it was absolute nonsense from the very start.This is so much more realistic and logical in the SW universe. I really want a part two
I feel like JJ Abrams can make an alternate timeline version of star wars using this video's synopsis to make a new prequel trilogy that's more satisfying than the one we have now. Anyone Agree? 🤔🤷♂️
I feel as if Anakin went down this route a purple light-saber would have fit his aesthetic perfectly, being trained in exactly how to combat and counter the dark side by understanding its power but while simultaneously being fully pledged towards the light outside of the Jedi's doctrines. A fascinating Theory thx for the upload.
@@jonathanflanagan1504 White wouldn't happen unless he specifically stole or somehow obtained a Sith's saber, because white is only possible when you take a red saber - red representing the dark side corruption of the kyber crystal within - and purify it with uncorrupted force powers. A purple saber can happen naturally, as in the case with Mace Windu, and I agree with Daniel: it would have represented Anakin very well.
I think yellow would represent him better as I think qui gon would have trained anakin to seek out the dark side within him compared to the jedi orders way of repression
I remember the first “what if Qui-Gon trained Anakin” you did years ago, which led him to be easier swayed by Sidious. With all of the new things we know in the lore, it’s great that you’re doing an updated version. Keep it up.
Yeah, I too remember that one. I'm looking forward to see if Anakin would be able to foresee the invasion of the Yuzong Vongg like Palpatine did, and how he would effectively deployed ships like the Death Star, Star Killer Base, the Sun Eater.
Agustín Baletti It was this channel. I’ve been following this channel for 4 years and I’d normally play the original videos in my store whenever it was slow. In the original version, anakin still turns to the dark side and manages to kill Qui-Gon at the Temple as well as Obi-Wan on Mustafar. In a separate video he talked about what if he killed Obi-Wan and trained Luke and Leia as Sith. I pointed out that they are pretty much the same storyline, just different points in time.
I didn't agree with his theory that he'd be easier to sway to the dark side in my opinion I feel like he'd be more like grandmaster Luke Skywalker from legends or Jacen solo before he went on his sojuron throughout the galaxy for five years
PWN HUB in theory he was by proxy. From Dooku’s training passed to Jinn passing both what he learned from Dooku, and his own raw experience to Anakin. No Luke or Leia likely though. 🤣🤣🤣🤣
I disagree. I think Anakin still would have returned to Tatooine to save his mother, but I think he would have arrived in time to save her and Qui-Gon Jinn would have helped him.
Qui Gon: we have a sith we need jedi assistance Jedi: we are busy Qui Gon: all are busy Jedi: yes sit on comfy chairs we do. Qui Gon: send help there is a sith lord Jedi: no Qui Gon dies Jedi: our plan worked we got him killed.
@Ms Taylor exactly I know that main reason why Mace Windu really wanted Darth Sidious dead was because he was a sith lord which being a sith isnt a crime also they threatened him they drew their weapons first technically that's asking for trouble. CIS or the Separtist get a world Jedis say we cant let them have it even tho the planet means nothing to us.
@Ms Taylor I do believe no side was really good except for the way QuiGon and Luke's way of the force the Jedis used Anakin for their deeds like a slave Anakin bring balance to the force only a jedi world ok that's good dont let him in the Siths hands the sith he can destroy the sith and bring peace then I will kill him to find a new apprentice. Jedis say he can destroy the sith and bring balance to the force both were wrong except he did bring balance to the force killed the jedis and with the help of his son destroyed the sith so no side was really good.
@Ms Taylor ok yea I go by legends tho like for the clone troopers up to a degree like them being brain washed the chips you cant go digging around ripping shit out and surviving its like saying if you take out a lung you can still live even if you smoke cigarettes well, Disney ruined it by making the tv show. That's my opinion. I understand people being stupid too if I say it's my opinion they say no you are wrong. Like learn to read I dont think people now know what an opinion is.
@@lieutenantnitewolf3337 Well... You are wrong on one account. You CAN live if you remove a lung and smoke. It won't be for very long, but you can live on one lung, even as a smoker. Other than that, I disagree with your opinion, I personally think you are wrong. But I will agree that you have every right to your opinion, and I won't try and force my opinion on you.
Kori Harpoon True. Maul would reach into the force and connect with his home planet and find his whereabouts rather quickly. Unless of course, QuiGon expertly hid himself and made a pact with one of the more peaceful night sister clans in their mountains
@@thalmoragent9344 The Force is also fate. He would find his way there just like the drive to find Obi Wan got him within the grasp of Luke in Rebels. Image Maul training Luke.
The Raven King Ehhh... not quite. Vader had many reasons to never return to Tatooine. Maul had no such reason never to return to Dathomir. In fact, he had every reason to return every once in a while.
Qui gon Jinn has always been one of my favorite characters. He was drastically different from most jedi. He was so attuned to the force and insightful. Not to mention he followed the living force unlike most.
Moreover, supposing Anakin had not only spared the Jedi younglings, but went a step further and saw to it that they would be trained as dark side acolytes, something akin to the Inquisitors.
Honestly, I feel like Qui Gon-Jinn could have been a much better and developed character if he was at least explained a bit more before he was killed off early.
The fact that Qui Gon was so attuned to the Force, I think he'd have trained Anakin to be a pure Jedi 👍 not a slave to the arrogant ways they followed. Qui Gon followed the will of the force and nothing else.
@@bobjohnson-ub1sx one thing for sure, qui gon wouldnt let mace windu treat the way obi wan let all the things windu have done harshly treating anakin, qui gon is vicious in the jedi council on what he believes, like you said hes so attuned to the force, his faith to the force rivals yoda. at the same time the council acknowledges him and respected him, i believe anakin wouldnt turn to the dark side because qui gon would treat him better but most importantly would make the council follows.
I wish he survived episode one and would work with anakin and obiwan as a trio of friends, quigon always trying to keep anakin from turning to the dark side and helping him deal with his issues with the Jedi order and especially the council. Ultimately he wouldn’t be able to and at the fight with sidious he could join mace kit fisto Eeth koth and the other one. I think they could have an incredibly emotional and powerful moment of anakin being so concerned about Padme that he would betray quigon though he would not be corrupt enough to kill him and would ask sidious to dew it for him.
If he'd lived he probably would've filled the role that Palpatine did. Anakin would've trained under Kenobi, but when he needed a mentor and friend he would turn to Qui-gon.
Mace would have dropped him, in an epic fight, with both combatants foregoing light and dark, and fighting to the death as men.... The more I think about it, the more I need it in my life.
@@mkadoza not so sure , dooku definitely has an age issue , but he's got all the skills man ! Plus he's fighting style is built to fight people like mace , THE form 7 master , form 7 opens one up to force attacks watch dooku would definitely exploit. That being said yea , mace could just out last him , but it's not a good look ...
@@heyimjoshnicetomeetya purple use hatred and control together at once still on light side they are so it could have been purple plus blue plus red equals purple
@@heyimjoshnicetomeetya Purple lightsabers are used by force users who are able to strike a balance between light and dark which is what Anakin would have become with Qui-Gon's tutelage serving neither Jedi nor Sith but the force itself similar to the Bendu.
I think it would be purple because qui gon followed the force and knew that if anakin was to be trained in both sides and learned how to control it he could destroy every living creature or he might have green because he may train him in the force more than lightsaber dueling
Luke: loses hand Vader: loses hand Leia: loses Han I didn’t make this joke so don’t let me take the credit I saw this n a comment section before I wrote this
@@Cap_1726 Nah, even the idiots at Disney said that Qui-Gon would've taught Anakin well. He might not fall, but I imagine he would flirt with the Dark Side, learn a few techniques.
@@kingtorrhenstarkstark5311 Yah! I mean studying the dark side isn't bad lol. It's your choice. Darth Vectivus studied it but he chose the business side.
Hey, I'm liking this! I always wished that Qui-Gon hadn't been killed off in The Phantom Menace. With all due respect to Obi-Wan, I think Qui-Gon would've been a much better Master for Anakin, especially since he didn't seem as rigid and inflexible in the ways of the Jedi as the others.
asterisk197 actually that is incorrect,Jedi temple guards have gold lightsaber,not exactly the same as yellow,anyways,a yellow lightsaber represents balance between light and dark,while only using the light side,they want no one side to be superior,and they want balance,making it different than purple,it also means that the are a mix of guardian and consular,which means and they are a mix of relying on their lightsaber and using the force on a physical level,and a mix of relying on negotiations and using the force on a higher level,so while you are correct that his lightsaber shouldn’t be yellow,it is not the same shade as the guards lightsabers
Palpatine greatly feared all who wielded a yellow lightsaber; they where often intuned greatest with the will of the Force, as mostly Sentinel Jedi where "city or planet" residents.
No he would not have a yellow lightsaber because he is not a part of the Jedi Order PERHAPS he would have a white light saber or a purple lightsaber White because it is balanced not in the light or the dark side light the one Ahsoka Tano has in Rebels Or a purple lightsaber because he knows both the dark side AND the light side
I think your right, i heard Luke Skywalker was supposed to have had A Yellow lightsaber. Instead of Blue / Green, i have a original Luke Skywalker action figure , it has a yellow lightsaber, before they changed it to Green
I believe that qui gon would've made things easier and more understanding for Anakin as well as help him understand why things happen and the reasons behind them. He would open his eyes to the true nature of things.
That's because we hardly know anything about Qui-gon by just watching the movie, that makes fans romanticize him and attribute qualities to him, that he doesn't have.
Let me make a correction I’ve have rewatched it and have seen alot of the legends content and read up on him here and there it also gave me a better idea. But its also unfair to say that we dont know much about qui-gon just by watching the movie theres plenty of materials to work off of.
@@BoredmanTutorials From the movies we know that he has disagreements with the council, we know that he is Obi-Wan's master and that he wants to train Anakin because he believes him to be the chose one, we can also infer that he tries to help others where he can and that he is very wise. That's about it. From legends we know that he trained a padawan before Obi Wan who fell to the Dark Side when Qui-gon killed his father in front of him and ended up committing suicide rather than be captured. We also know that he abandoned Obi-Wan on a war torn planet at the age of 13. If anything Legends paints a rather grimmer picture, and outlines him as entirely inadequate in training Anakin.
@Holy Emperor Souther O get a feeling that Obi wan was getting closer to Anakin as a brother than a teacher and thats why he wasnt the right fit for Anakin especially since Anakin is seen to be more powerful Qui-gon would have probably helped him not turn to the dark side so easy and Mace windu would just made Anakin more powerful than what he already was
I personally believe Jinn was one of the few Jedi who had the insight to see past the Order’s narrow interpretation of the Force, while not becoming so disillusioned as to be vulnerable to the dark side. Jinn, imo, was the only Jedi who could really understand Anakin’s position and could have turned him from his dark fate.
Qui gon’s view on the force gave him unrivaled wisdom in my opinion. I feel like he would’ve been able to become some what of a teacher to dooku like he did to yoda. I think he’d be able to at least stabilize dooku in his views on the force
@@Gandalfmandalf Darth Vader: "me and Sidious are dark lords..." (cut off before saying 'of the Sith') Voldemort: "No! I'm the dark lord!" Sauron: *fuming* "All three of you are just copycats! I'm the dark lord!"
My Prediction: Anakin cuts down Palpatine instead of siding with him. Order 66 Never happens. Obi-Wan would be weaker since Qui Gon's death prepels him to master Soresu. With him still alive he'd probably stick to Form 4. A Grey Anakin would be the strongest Jedi in history.
I love the amount of thought and detail you put into this video and alternate storyline. I wish we could have a spin of series where these events happen bc I want to see more of Qui-gon
Being that Qui-Gonn is my favorite jedi I enjoy any story to where he survives and I do enjoy your take on this subject up to a certain point, something that I don't think he would ever do. I'm a firm believer that Qui-Gonn is the true Jedi, that he listens to the Force first before anything/anyone else. And that the council are the diluted jedi, listening to the politics of the galaxy before the Force. I don't think Qui-Gonn would every train Anakin in the ways of the dark side or take him to Dathomir. Knowing he is to train Anakin to bring balance to the force, I don't understand why teaching him in the dark side or taking him to such a evil and corrupted place would help in Qui-Gonn's goal. We have seen tons of times in the books and comics to where Jedi can become corrupt to long exposer to the dark side and Qui-Gonn would not risk that for Anakin or himself falling to the dark. I think he would take Anakin to Unknown space and hide away there, telling him all aspect of the force but never teaching him the dark side, mainly because he would not really know how to train him in the dark side. Knowing that Anakin can turn fully to the dark so easily. I'm pretty sure people will disagree with me on this and perfectly fine, just throwing my take on it out there. Again always enjoy these episodes and all you do. May the Force be with you.
In the clone wars saga the center of the force with the father the son and the daughter. Balance is not when the dark side is absent. But when they both work together to destroy and regenerate. As discussed the Jedi were using the light side of the force in an incorrect manner. So then the sith may be as well.
There's a difference between teaching someone the Dark Side, and exposing them to it. Yoda takes Luke to the Dark Side locus on Dagobah for a similar reason; he knows Luke will have to face off against at least one, probably 2 very powerful Sith at some point, as that is the whole plan for him. In that case, it's probably best that his very first exposure to the Dark Side is *not* when the future of the Galaxy and the Force are at stake...
Qui-Gon would have seen through Palpatine eventually. Would the outcome of been the same, or would he have been able to save Anakin. I can't say. But the loss of Qui-Gon was a loss the Jedi could not afford.
Some friends and I had an idea for a Star Wars tv series set in an alternate reality. In it, Qui-Gon was unable to free Anakin from his slavery on Tatooine, and instead, Darth Maul found him and decided to train him as his secret apprentice. Being trained by one of the greatest light-saber duelists of the time. Later in the series, Palpatine finds out, kills Maul, then takes Anakin as his apprentice. Now being trained by one of the greatest dark side force users, and not getting chopped up and burned on Mustifar, we get to see Anakin at his full potential. I have this vision of a season finale with full-strength Anakin standing against a huge number of Jedi. As he cuts them down, he controls their lightsabers with the force, and uses them to fight more and more Jedi at once. It would be an amazing story and would allow for some absolutely sick fight scenes.
I like that Anakin learns the ways of the Dark Side. I feel like that was where his potential lays the most, but he also knows the Light too. Like Revan.
This feels like what If Qui Gun Jinn Started The Grey Jedi order My opinion this is an incredible What if lot better then your last what if Master Jinn trained Anakin BUT one thing you miss is that Qui Gun Jinn would never ever leave Obi Wan Kenobi in the order that’s already fallen & Corrupted he’d take Both Anakin Skywalker & Obi Wan Kenobi with him And trained them both in the new method Qui Gun Jinn will create not the ways of the Jedi or Sith but just the ways of THE FORCE Both Anakin & Obi Wan basically are his kids / Sons / boys etc etc that he cares very deeply about & are basically his responsibility (in a parenting way) I can’t be the only one who thinks this
@@Fulcron13 thanks bro & ikr !?! Plus he wouldn’t let not even palpatine get anywhere near Anakin Skywalker or even Obi Wan for that matter Under qui gun Skywalker would have brought balance to the force
I have would like The Middle Order No pun intended Qui Gon : middle fingers the order by training anakin Ahsoka : middle fingers the order by still being a forcewielder but sides nobody
What if, instead of ditching the clones in favor of recruits, the empire had stuck with clones and simply turned up all their chips like they did with Crosshair?
Kind of odd IMO that you made Dooku evil still. I think it can be argued even as a "sith" that he was more of a dark Jedi. Qui-gons death is the straw that broke the camels back for him. I think without that, he still would have been on the good side at the least, though yes willing to experiment with some of the dark side abilities with Qui-gon to train Anakin and give himself greater strength.
@Mr. C You mean Dooku? Because count Dooku was the greatest duelist the Jedi ever trained. Dooku even scared Palpatine after going toe to toe with Yoda. You're making mace Windu sound like a Mary sue.
Skywalker’s fate was sealed the moment he met Padme and then left his mother to become a Jedi Padawan... no matter if Qui-Gon Jinn lived or not... He always 2 things on his mind other than training to be Jedi Knight his Mother and Padme....
I like where your going with this, basically an established grey order maintaining balance in the force instead of trying to shift the balance either way
i have my theories that if qui gon had trained anakin, palpatine wouldn't have been able to use the methods he did to sway him to his side. i also have to agree that taking him to dathomir would be wise, despite it being a dark side planet, the residents don't quite follow it the same way the sith do. maul (as far as i know) was only brought there to recover (which in this video he will not need to) and dooku only to gain savage as an apprentice. the planet surprisingly doesn't seem to have much interaction with the sith. also as a side note, i was wondering if your would do a 'what if' kylo ren didn't need his lightsaber to have a crossguard or if he found and used darth vader's sith lightsaber. after seeing him wield the skywalker lightsaber against the knights of ren so fluently, myself and a few others have thought the crossguard he used made his style exactly like luke said about the knights of ren using the force as a hammer while he used it like a blade.
I would love to see this story and this different spin on these amazing characters. Maybe if the MCU what if stories are loved by a wide audience, Disney might think about doing a similar what if for their popular stories/characters
Born from darkness Forged by the light There is no peace There is no wrath There is only strength There is only knowledge There is only life There is only the FORCE !!!
This is the best. I would love to see an entirely rewritten saga where Anakin didn’t turn to the dark side of the force. And The Jedi have to fight against the clones because Order 66 still happens.
As much as I hate to point it out, in the most recent canon novel; Master and Apprentice which is set prior to the events of TPM Dooku is already no longer a member of the Jedi order. And has no contact with Qui-Gon
I want a movie of this story but I’m afraid even if it was made they would find some way to screw up its awesomeness. You’ve more than earned a like on this one, my friend.
Nice take - only thing missing which I found central to Annakins development is his love for his mother and love for Padme and if these attachments would still have had a conflictive bearing on his character as he grows older. Plus would Qui-Gon would have gone the Jedi route and restricted him, or supported him in at least reestablishing contact with his loved ones
In canon the novel "Master and Apprentice" it's said Dooku left the order sometime before Jinn and Kenobi's mission on Pijal, which was a few years before ep 1
Fantastic mate ... THIS IS the Star Wars Novel I’m dying to read more into . My favourite thing is actually Qui-Gon and Dooku .. my two favourite force sensitive characters ever tbh
I love how Anakin is supposedly so strong with the force that no one has ever seen anything like it, and yet the most interesting thing we ever see him do with the force is choke someone. Like, really? Even Yoda managed to pull an entire X-wing out of a swamp, but the "chosen one" can squeeze people's throats enough to cut off their breathing. That really doesn't take much force, no pun intended.
He also deflected blasts from weapons with his open palm. Don't forget that most of his force abilities where lost when he lost his limbs. Such as force lightning
@@Archedgar I think you give him a little too much credit, but I get where you're coming from. He was able to see brief flashes of things that would soon happen...but all jedi have some level of extrasensory perception. They can know something bad is happening, or will happen, by sensing it through the force.
A splinter cell Jedi order with Dooku, Qui-gon, Obiwan and Anakin would’ve been absolutely unstoppable. Sidious would be stuck with Maul and couldn’t turn Anakin. They could’ve reformed the Jedi order to be balanced and connected with the force, not stupidly afraid of attachment or even studying the dark side within them. Given the clone wars shows yoda being taught by Qui-gon I think Yoda was open minded and wise enough to have joined on too and at that point the entire order could’ve been reformed and saved with Qui Gon and Anakin ushering in a new era and defeating Sidious. Damn. What could’ve been…
The fact that Qui Gon was so attuned to the Force, I think he'd have trained Anakin to be a pure Jedi 👍 not a slave to the arrogant ways they followed. Qui Gon followed the will of the force and nothing else.
yeah Qui Gon was super under utilized in Star Wars. It's a shame we didn't see more. I would love a Qui Gon prequel show.
@@JohnDerek57 same here! He's an amazing character. So wise and I loved how he put the force above anything else, now that's committment...
Him and Mace are my favorites.
Both are very attuned with the force and lean into its will in different ways.
Total cool guys.
@@JohnDerek57 And god knows Liam Neeson would be on-board in a heartbeat.
@@SigTheSauceMan Anikin, I going to teach a particular set of skills, skills that would make you a nightmare for.....
“If the training of young Anakin would not be sanctioned by the Jedi it shall be sanctioned by the force.”
That is the most qui gon statement I’ve ever heard
Obiwan would’ve left, too. This is shortly after him and Satine’s original fling and Quigon leaving would’ve given him the courage to do the same thing.
And give the new splinter cell order Mandalore to set up shop on. A new pacifist regime, a rogue jedi master, knight and padawon Mandalore would be a happening place for balance. (yeah Dathomir is badass but I'm pretty sure Qui-Gon would not be willing to bring a kid there, the angsty teenager, oh yeah)
The Jedi order would end up looking pretty lame
@@timlewis9004 Like they never were before...? They never got with the times or tried to change their ways as the galaxy changed around them. That's how the Sith nearly did the Jedi in every time.
@@99thJediWarrior Can't argue with that. I don't understand why Yoda or Mace never realized the danger of being ignorant to the dark side. Especially after Mauls defeat to obi wan. They knew there was another sith out there and later they knew the dark side was clouding their vision. Seems like it would be glaringly obvious that they needed to break out of their comfort zone.
@@timlewis9004 most of the Jedi council were generals on the frontlines of the clone wars, palpatine did a good job keeping them distracted as he took over the government
Qui gonn probably would have been smart enough to realize that going back and saving Anakin's mother from slavery and her eventual demise would greatly aid his training of Anakin as his doubts and fear of losing her would be reduced and when her time does come he would be old and wise enough to accept the nature of the force and not try to bend it to his will by way of the dark side
Honestly, hard agree. It's really sad that the council could have easily saved her from slavery, but chose not to. Anakin becoming Vader, was a very slow burn that could've easily been prevented if the council weren't so emotionless and dogmatic.
Yeah you're right about all that. I also beleive in Ep2 Qui-Gon would've helped Anakin to save his mother had he lived.
I doubt Qui-Gon would have waited ten years before saving Shmi. Knowing that Shmi was a slave, Qui-Gon probably would have saved her sometime during Anakin's first year on Coruscant. Even if the Jedi Council forbid it, Qui-Gon and Anakin would have simply taken the long way back after one of their missions in deep space, via Tatooine, and rescued Shmi.
@@jimdigitalvideo exactly.
Especially considering that Qui Gon tried to free them both originally. He knew the trouble that would bring by leaving her.
Ah, the "What If" saga returns. Balance has been restored.
wish there was a "what if" comic series for star wars
Gabriel Gilmore
Ever heard of Star Wars Infinities?
Owen Thangwen I’d love to see these ideas officially put to screen
I'm actually working on my own "What if" story too with Star Wars. It largely goes over what would've happened if Anakin chose to stay on Mortis.
@@LoganDX1990 Actually there is. It's called Star Wars Infinities. It's a comic book series that basically rewrites the Original Trilogy movies 4 - 6. It goes over what would have happened if Luke didn't destroy the Death Star as well as many other hypothetical parts of the series. You can find it on UA-cam as well. Take a look, you'll love it 😁👍🏿
They should do “What If...” for Star Wars as well as Marvel, it would be amazing to see the alternate scenarios in Star Wars
What if the sequel trilogy was just Luke's vision after ep7
There comes a series on marvel with every episode as a different what if scenario. On disney plus
Yeah
It's called the sequel trilogy, and it's what if we had no semblance of a plan
this is a brilliant idea
Yoda: train the boy, you will not
Qui-gon-gin: *leaves Jedi order*
Dooku: *leaves Jedi order*
Yoda: no no, this isn't how you're suppossed to play the game
Well guess we gotta have Obi Wan train Anakin again
*No, no, how you're supposed to play the game, this is not.
Game Over
Maul left the chat
This lame bantha dialogue meme trope is tiresome. Just say what you want mean without these theatrics and pleasantries, please.
If Qui Gon replaced Obi Wan in the Mustafar duel.
Anakin: From my point of view the jedi are evil!
Qui Gon: *Smacks Anakin* Shut up.
Anakin: Yes master...
Lil
Lol
There is no good or evil, there is only power and those too weak to have it
Lol
Alternatively: "Playing dumb, Master Sith?"
This needs a part two. Just like the What If Maul Killed Obi Wan one as well
Dont worry we're way past 5000 likes we'll get one (it's not even been a full day yet the people want this as bad as you do)
luke oates god damn right they do
luke oates WOAHOOO!!!
We need a part two. Star Wars Theory made a theory about exactly the same concept and it was absolute nonsense from the very start.This is so much more realistic and logical in the SW universe. I really want a part two
I feel like JJ Abrams can make an alternate timeline version of star wars using this video's synopsis to make a new prequel trilogy that's more satisfying than the one we have now. Anyone Agree? 🤔🤷♂️
“If the training of the young Anakin will not be sanctioned by the Jedi, it will be sanctioned by the Force.”
That line hits deep!
8:45 I think Quigon would have been smart enough to go back and make sure Anakin's mom was ok and check on her with Anakin from time to time.
Prometheus 18562 that would have made all the difference
Yeah
In porn parady he would...
@@Brownismyname I mean he wouldn't be a jedi of the order anymore, and who wouldn't want him for a dad/ master
I think qui gon jin would off freed anakins mother and would of let her live with them
I feel as if Anakin went down this route a purple light-saber would have fit his aesthetic perfectly, being trained in exactly how to combat and counter the dark side by understanding its power but while simultaneously being fully pledged towards the light outside of the Jedi's doctrines. A fascinating Theory thx for the upload.
Maybe he could've gone white like Ahsoka, but I do think yellow works as well.
@@jonathanflanagan1504 White wouldn't happen unless he specifically stole or somehow obtained a Sith's saber, because white is only possible when you take a red saber - red representing the dark side corruption of the kyber crystal within - and purify it with uncorrupted force powers.
A purple saber can happen naturally, as in the case with Mace Windu, and I agree with Daniel: it would have represented Anakin very well.
I think yellow would represent him better as I think qui gon would have trained anakin to seek out the dark side within him compared to the jedi orders way of repression
@@lonelyone69 wouldnt that involve with a purple light saber?.
@@jmgonzales7701 no purple is for jedi with dark side tendencies and yellow is for those that seek out the dark side
I remember the first “what if Qui-Gon trained Anakin” you did years ago, which led him to be easier swayed by Sidious. With all of the new things we know in the lore, it’s great that you’re doing an updated version. Keep it up.
Yeah, I too remember that one. I'm looking forward to see if Anakin would be able to foresee the invasion of the Yuzong Vongg like Palpatine did, and how he would effectively deployed ships like the Death Star, Star Killer Base, the Sun Eater.
Wasn't that from Star Wars Theory???
Agustín Baletti It was this channel. I’ve been following this channel for 4 years and I’d normally play the original videos in my store whenever it was slow. In the original version, anakin still turns to the dark side and manages to kill Qui-Gon at the Temple as well as Obi-Wan on Mustafar. In a separate video he talked about what if he killed Obi-Wan and trained Luke and Leia as Sith. I pointed out that they are pretty much the same storyline, just different points in time.
The first video of his I ever watched was “Are All Sith Evil?”
I didn't agree with his theory that he'd be easier to sway to the dark side in my opinion I feel like he'd be more like grandmaster Luke Skywalker from legends or Jacen solo before he went on his sojuron throughout the galaxy for five years
Jedi Council: " The balance doesn't see you fit to wield the force "
Anakin Skywalker: " *I am the balance* "
God level comment
Jedi Council: " Not Yet "
I feel like Anakin was meant to be the Equalizer. He has no true allegiance to the Jedi or the Sith. Sides mean nothing to him.
@kobeftw2400 I said sides, not titles.
@kobeftw2400 No Anakin didn't choose to be a Jedi. He never chose that.
Just imagine if Anakin was trained by Jinn and Dooku ... he'd have been a literal god.
PWN HUB in theory he was by proxy. From Dooku’s training passed to Jinn passing both what he learned from Dooku, and his own raw experience to Anakin. No Luke or Leia likely though. 🤣🤣🤣🤣
PWN HUB yoooooo didn’t know Mr Apex himself checks out these videos 😁
@@pepeclifton4462 theres still a chance he hooks up with padme at a later time and they could still have kids .
He'd truly be the Chosen One.
Emperor palpatine: Why do I hear boss music?
Qui-Gon was a gray jedi. Shit would be so different if he survived. I wish we could explore this in an alternate universe plot of Star Wars.
I'm pretty sure a bunch of sand people wouldn't have died.
Along with the millions of others.
Lets all be honest.... even in KOTOR when the sand people are humanized, they are still a rather unpleasant species
@@herrikudo They're a pack of ignorant and vicious savages.
@@nicholasmaude6906 racially motivated ignorant and vicious savages lmfao
I disagree. I think Anakin still would have returned to Tatooine to save his mother, but I think he would have arrived in time to save her and Qui-Gon Jinn would have helped him.
edge lord he would still hate sand tho
Qui Gon: we have a sith we need jedi assistance
Jedi: we are busy
Qui Gon: all are busy
Jedi: yes sit on comfy chairs we do.
Qui Gon: send help there is a sith lord
Jedi: no
Qui Gon dies
Jedi: our plan worked we got him killed.
@Ms Taylor exactly I know that main reason why Mace Windu really wanted Darth Sidious dead was because he was a sith lord which being a sith isnt a crime also they threatened him they drew their weapons first technically that's asking for trouble. CIS or the Separtist get a world Jedis say we cant let them have it even tho the planet means nothing to us.
@Ms Taylor I do believe no side was really good except for the way QuiGon and Luke's way of the force the Jedis used Anakin for their deeds like a slave Anakin bring balance to the force only a jedi world ok that's good dont let him in the Siths hands the sith he can destroy the sith and bring peace then I will kill him to find a new apprentice. Jedis say he can destroy the sith and bring balance to the force both were wrong except he did bring balance to the force killed the jedis and with the help of his son destroyed the sith so no side was really good.
@Ms Taylor ok yea I go by legends tho like for the clone troopers up to a degree like them being brain washed the chips you cant go digging around ripping shit out and surviving its like saying if you take out a lung you can still live even if you smoke cigarettes well, Disney ruined it by making the tv show. That's my opinion. I understand people being stupid too if I say it's my opinion they say no you are wrong. Like learn to read I dont think people now know what an opinion is.
@@lieutenantnitewolf3337 Well... You are wrong on one account. You CAN live if you remove a lung and smoke. It won't be for very long, but you can live on one lung, even as a smoker. Other than that, I disagree with your opinion, I personally think you are wrong. But I will agree that you have every right to your opinion, and I won't try and force my opinion on you.
@@Snipergod1024 duh but, with one lung you arent getting as much oxygen. One lung you need all the oxygen you can get so it wouldnt be wise to smoke.
Qui Gon: “Where can I hide from Maul?”
*Reaches into the Force itself*
Qui Gon: “I know I’ll hide on his home planet!”
@Sheldon Cooper Maul will know. Sith always know.
Kori Harpoon
True. Maul would reach into the force and connect with his home planet and find his whereabouts rather quickly. Unless of course, QuiGon expertly hid himself and made a pact with one of the more peaceful night sister clans in their mountains
@@thalmoragent9344 The Force is also fate. He would find his way there just like the drive to find Obi Wan got him within the grasp of Luke in Rebels. Image Maul training Luke.
I mean that’s the same thing Obi-Wan did for Luke so
The Raven King Ehhh... not quite. Vader had many reasons to never return to Tatooine. Maul had no such reason never to return to Dathomir. In fact, he had every reason to return every once in a while.
Qui gon Jinn has always been one of my favorite characters. He was drastically different from most jedi. He was so attuned to the force and insightful. Not to mention he followed the living force unlike most.
Yeah Qui-Gon certainly was different from the other Jedi and he was really the only one capable of training Anakin too had he lived.
I have a good idea, what if Anakin spared the younglings...
Moreover, supposing Anakin had not only spared the Jedi younglings, but went a step further and saw to it that they would be trained as dark side acolytes, something akin to the Inquisitors.
@@aarondevaldez9134 Penis lol
@@gotnothingbettertodo472 ?
@@Rory695 Penis ahahaahahha
@@gotnothingbettertodo472 you, sir, are an idiot.
Honestly, I feel like Qui Gon-Jinn could have been a much better and developed character if he was at least explained a bit more before he was killed off early.
I agree
The fact that Qui Gon was so attuned to the Force, I think he'd have trained Anakin to be a pure Jedi 👍 not a slave to the arrogant ways they followed. Qui Gon followed the will of the force and nothing else.
@@bobjohnson-ub1sx one thing for sure, qui gon wouldnt let mace windu treat the way obi wan let all the things windu have done harshly treating anakin, qui gon is vicious in the jedi council on what he believes, like you said hes so attuned to the force, his faith to the force rivals yoda. at the same time the council acknowledges him and respected him, i believe anakin wouldnt turn to the dark side because qui gon would treat him better but most importantly would make the council follows.
I wish he survived episode one and would work with anakin and obiwan as a trio of friends, quigon always trying to keep anakin from turning to the dark side and helping him deal with his issues with the Jedi order and especially the council. Ultimately he wouldn’t be able to and at the fight with sidious he could join mace kit fisto Eeth koth and the other one. I think they could have an incredibly emotional and powerful moment of anakin being so concerned about Padme that he would betray quigon though he would not be corrupt enough to kill him and would ask sidious to dew it for him.
If he'd lived he probably would've filled the role that Palpatine did. Anakin would've trained under Kenobi, but when he needed a mentor and friend he would turn to Qui-gon.
I have a good one:
What if Mace Windu fought Count Dooku in Attack of The Clones
This needs to happen.
Mace would have dropped him, in an epic fight, with both combatants foregoing light and dark, and fighting to the death as men.... The more I think about it, the more I need it in my life.
Anakin would have TWO HANDS!
@@mkadoza not so sure , dooku definitely has an age issue , but he's got all the skills man ! Plus he's fighting style is built to fight people like mace , THE form 7 master , form 7 opens one up to force attacks watch dooku would definitely exploit.
That being said yea , mace could just out last him , but it's not a good look ...
Mace would most likely win consider his fight with Sidious.
Quigon was such an underrated character. So much potential was shut down with his death :(
But so many doors had opened for the story as well
Anakins fate was to become Vader. Qui-gon would never let that happen while he lives.
His death was very sad but very necessary.
I always thought Anakin would have had a purple lightsaber if he were trained by Qui-Gon Jinn.
I think it would still be blue
@@heyimjoshnicetomeetya purple use hatred and control together at once still on light side they are so it could have been purple plus blue plus red equals purple
@@heyimjoshnicetomeetya Purple lightsabers are used by force users who are able to strike a balance between light and dark which is what Anakin would have become with Qui-Gon's tutelage serving neither Jedi nor Sith but the force itself similar to the Bendu.
I think it would be purple because qui gon followed the force and knew that if anakin was to be trained in both sides and learned how to control it he could destroy every living creature or he might have green because he may train him in the force more than lightsaber dueling
I think he would use the color that he wanted to use
Anakin was so powerful he never reached he's full potential
Qui-Gon would've taught him to *oppose the sand*
Yes give into to your hatred destroy all the sand
ZombiFeline Tuba *Glasses tatooine*
@@armanii_rose kill younglings
I still can't oppose sand to this day. This is me to the sand of that weird homeworld of mine I Hate You !!!!!
I agree to that idea good ani good 👍
This sounds way more interesting than the actual story.
Please do “what if Palpatine lost his election as Chancellor”!
What if trump never became the president... dun dun DUNNNN
living soul of time Studio I wish
He would have manipulated the other chancellor
@@ZainAhmed-ns2di probably
@@livingsouloftimestudio2887 if trump didn't become president the world would be a better place
Luke: loses hand
Vader: loses hand
Leia: loses Han
I didn’t make this joke so don’t let me take the credit I saw this n a comment section before I wrote this
Darth vader lose HANDS and legs (because of revenge of the sith)
han already gave leia the D so that’s spot on
diego Hernandez that was not my intent to be spot on
diego Hernandez 😂😂😂😂😂
Gary funny
I want this idea turned into a book, I would read the heck out of it
I like how this story is turning out and I feel like your ideas here are definitely very plausible. I look forward to part two!
If Qui Gon Jinn was still alive, he would've put Anakin on a straight path and Anakin wouldn't have fallen to the dark side.
Derek Lopez this is a good theory, but Anakin was still fated to fall to the dark side, as jinn was fated to die
@@Cap_1726 Nah, even the idiots at Disney said that Qui-Gon would've taught Anakin well. He might not fall, but I imagine he would flirt with the Dark Side, learn a few techniques.
99thJediWarrior and then be the true chosen one by actually finding balance between the light and dark side of the force and using both at once
@@kingtorrhenstarkstark5311
Yah! I mean studying the dark side isn't bad lol. It's your choice. Darth Vectivus studied it but he chose the business side.
Hey, I'm liking this! I always wished that Qui-Gon hadn't been killed off in The Phantom Menace. With all due respect to Obi-Wan, I think Qui-Gon would've been a much better Master for Anakin, especially since he didn't seem as rigid and inflexible in the ways of the Jedi as the others.
Like being trained by a high performing player instead of the head coach.
Why do you believe Anakin would possess a Yellow lightsaber? Yellow lightsabers were mainly for protectors, such as the Jedi Sentinels/Temple guards.
asterisk197 actually that is incorrect,Jedi temple guards have gold lightsaber,not exactly the same as yellow,anyways,a yellow lightsaber represents balance between light and dark,while only using the light side,they want no one side to be superior,and they want balance,making it different than purple,it also means that the are a mix of guardian and consular,which means and they are a mix of relying on their lightsaber and using the force on a physical level,and a mix of relying on negotiations and using the force on a higher level,so while you are correct that his lightsaber shouldn’t be yellow,it is not the same shade as the guards lightsabers
But,if channeled,anakin might as well have had a yellow lightsaber
Palpatine greatly feared all who wielded a yellow lightsaber; they where often intuned greatest with the will of the Force, as mostly Sentinel Jedi where "city or planet" residents.
No he would not have a yellow lightsaber because he is not a part of the Jedi Order PERHAPS he would have a white light saber or a purple lightsaber
White because it is balanced not in the light or the dark side light the one Ahsoka Tano has in Rebels
Or a purple lightsaber because he knows both the dark side AND the light side
I think your right, i heard Luke Skywalker was supposed to have had A Yellow lightsaber. Instead of Blue / Green, i have a original Luke Skywalker action figure , it has a yellow lightsaber, before they changed it to Green
I believe that qui gon would've made things easier and more understanding for Anakin as well as help him understand why things happen and the reasons behind them. He would open his eyes to the true nature of things.
I rewatched phantom menace again and i came to the conclusion that yes qui-gon jinn would have been a better master for anakin.
That's because we hardly know anything about Qui-gon by just watching the movie, that makes fans romanticize him and attribute qualities to him, that he doesn't have.
Let me make a correction I’ve have rewatched it and have seen alot of the legends content and read up on him here and there it also gave me a better idea. But its also unfair to say that we dont know much about qui-gon just by watching the movie theres plenty of materials to work off of.
@@BoredmanTutorials From the movies we know that he has disagreements with the council, we know that he is Obi-Wan's master and that he wants to train Anakin because he believes him to be the chose one, we can also infer that he tries to help others where he can and that he is very wise. That's about it.
From legends we know that he trained a padawan before Obi Wan who fell to the Dark Side when Qui-gon killed his father in front of him and ended up committing suicide rather than be captured. We also know that he abandoned Obi-Wan on a war torn planet at the age of 13.
If anything Legends paints a rather grimmer picture, and outlines him as entirely inadequate in training Anakin.
Holy Emperor Souther no chance. Windu never believed or trusted in ani
@Holy Emperor Souther O get a feeling that Obi wan was getting closer to Anakin as a brother than a teacher and thats why he wasnt the right fit for Anakin especially since Anakin is seen to be more powerful Qui-gon would have probably helped him not turn to the dark side so easy and Mace windu would just made Anakin more powerful than what he already was
I personally believe Jinn was one of the few Jedi who had the insight to see past the Order’s narrow interpretation of the Force, while not becoming so disillusioned as to be vulnerable to the dark side. Jinn, imo, was the only Jedi who could really understand Anakin’s position and could have turned him from his dark fate.
I love the “What if” series!
What if Count Dooku turned Obi-Wan to the dark side in Attack of the Clones?
Alex
I agree
Qui gon’s view on the force gave him unrivaled wisdom in my opinion. I feel like he would’ve been able to become some what of a teacher to dooku like he did to yoda. I think he’d be able to at least stabilize dooku in his views on the force
“We must join with him, Qui-Gon. We must join with Sauron.” “Who?” “Sidious. We must join with Sidious, I said.”
LOL
I see what you did there (since Christopher Lee played both Count Dooku AND Saruman)!
@@jcrews8582 lol jokes are better when they get explained
@@Gandalfmandalf Darth Vader: "me and Sidious are dark lords..." (cut off before saying 'of the Sith')
Voldemort: "No! I'm the dark lord!"
Sauron: *fuming* "All three of you are just copycats! I'm the dark lord!"
It would be wise, my friend!
I like how, when voicing Dooku, you even imitated Christopher Lee's way of speaking.
I love What Ifs. Thanks for making this!
I am hoping to start doing some "WHAT IFS" and "IF I WROTE" videos on my channel once I grow a little bit more
@@ApprenticeEwok your comment is a breath of fresh air as far as self promotion in the comments goes.
What if Bail Organa had said "we always wanted a son" and had picked Luke, leaving Leia to grow up on Tattooine under the eye of Obi Wan?
Leia isn't a force wielder tho broski, no reason for Obi-Wan to train a non force-sensitive if he's in the Jedi Order
@@Bamblesssss yes she is
@@Bamblesssss Luke literally says "aye yo u just like me sister" at the end of episode 6 u dingus
My Prediction:
Anakin cuts down Palpatine instead of siding with him.
Order 66 Never happens. Obi-Wan would be weaker since Qui Gon's death prepels him to master Soresu. With him still alive he'd probably stick to Form 4. A Grey Anakin would be the strongest Jedi in history.
I love the amount of thought and detail you put into this video and alternate storyline. I wish we could have a spin of series where these events happen bc I want to see more of Qui-gon
i actually like this more then star wars theory's take on this
Please prioritize this story, it's honestly so good and the way you've written it is phenomenal
Please keep up with the “What Ifs?” That’s what I started watching back in the day and loved.
Literal chills. This is wonderful. Someone give this man a raise.
Being that Qui-Gonn is my favorite jedi I enjoy any story to where he survives and I do enjoy your take on this subject up to a certain point, something that I don't think he would ever do. I'm a firm believer that Qui-Gonn is the true Jedi, that he listens to the Force first before anything/anyone else. And that the council are the diluted jedi, listening to the politics of the galaxy before the Force. I don't think Qui-Gonn would every train Anakin in the ways of the dark side or take him to Dathomir. Knowing he is to train Anakin to bring balance to the force, I don't understand why teaching him in the dark side or taking him to such a evil and corrupted place would help in Qui-Gonn's goal. We have seen tons of times in the books and comics to where Jedi can become corrupt to long exposer to the dark side and Qui-Gonn would not risk that for Anakin or himself falling to the dark. I think he would take Anakin to Unknown space and hide away there, telling him all aspect of the force but never teaching him the dark side, mainly because he would not really know how to train him in the dark side. Knowing that Anakin can turn fully to the dark so easily. I'm pretty sure people will disagree with me on this and perfectly fine, just throwing my take on it out there. Again always enjoy these episodes and all you do. May the Force be with you.
In the clone wars saga the center of the force with the father the son and the daughter. Balance is not when the dark side is absent. But when they both work together to destroy and regenerate. As discussed the Jedi were using the light side of the force in an incorrect manner. So then the sith may be as well.
There's a difference between teaching someone the Dark Side, and exposing them to it. Yoda takes Luke to the Dark Side locus on Dagobah for a similar reason; he knows Luke will have to face off against at least one, probably 2 very powerful Sith at some point, as that is the whole plan for him. In that case, it's probably best that his very first exposure to the Dark Side is *not* when the future of the Galaxy and the Force are at stake...
Qui-Gon would have seen through Palpatine eventually. Would the outcome of been the same, or would he have been able to save Anakin. I can't say. But the loss of Qui-Gon was a loss the Jedi could not afford.
I would’ve like to see the maverick train
the Chosen One in the Jedi arts
Perfectly balanced, as all things should be. Well done The Stupendous Wave.
Looking forward to part 2 , Qui-Gon is easily my all-time fave Jedi, all about the path of the grey.
Some friends and I had an idea for a Star Wars tv series set in an alternate reality. In it, Qui-Gon was unable to free Anakin from his slavery on Tatooine, and instead, Darth Maul found him and decided to train him as his secret apprentice. Being trained by one of the greatest light-saber duelists of the time. Later in the series, Palpatine finds out, kills Maul, then takes Anakin as his apprentice. Now being trained by one of the greatest dark side force users, and not getting chopped up and burned on Mustifar, we get to see Anakin at his full potential.
I have this vision of a season finale with full-strength Anakin standing against a huge number of Jedi. As he cuts them down, he controls their lightsabers with the force, and uses them to fight more and more Jedi at once. It would be an amazing story and would allow for some absolutely sick fight scenes.
Didt u touch up a kid
how old are you my friend xD
"Not Jedi, not sith...." BEHOLD! THE FAR SIDE OF THE FORCE!
I love how you tell it like a story and add pictures and cutscenes. With your great story telling I can actually imagine the story
I'd love to see what George Lucas's thoughts are on how this alternate scenario would work out.
I like that Anakin learns the ways of the Dark Side. I feel like that was where his potential lays the most, but he also knows the Light too. Like Revan.
This feels like what If Qui Gun Jinn Started The Grey Jedi order
My opinion this is an incredible What if lot better then your last what if Master Jinn trained Anakin
BUT one thing you miss is that Qui Gun Jinn would never ever leave Obi Wan Kenobi in the order that’s already fallen &
Corrupted he’d take Both Anakin Skywalker & Obi Wan Kenobi with him
And trained them both in the new method Qui Gun Jinn will create not the ways of the Jedi or Sith but just the ways of THE FORCE
Both Anakin & Obi Wan basically are his kids / Sons / boys etc etc that he cares very deeply about & are basically his responsibility (in a parenting way) I can’t be the only one who thinks this
@@Fulcron13 thanks bro & ikr !?! Plus he wouldn’t let not even palpatine get anywhere near Anakin Skywalker or even Obi Wan for that matter
Under qui gun Skywalker would have brought balance to the force
“The Grey Order”
Anyone else like this name for an Order for Grey Jedi?
yEP
Just sounds like some edgy cult
I have would like The Middle Order
No pun intended
Qui Gon : middle fingers the order by training anakin
Ahsoka : middle fingers the order by still being a forcewielder but sides nobody
That’s shit
I prefer The Order Grey
What if, instead of ditching the clones in favor of recruits, the empire had stuck with clones and simply turned up all their chips like they did with Crosshair?
Qui-Gon was my favorite, glad to hear more of him
Kind of odd IMO that you made Dooku evil still. I think it can be argued even as a "sith" that he was more of a dark Jedi. Qui-gons death is the straw that broke the camels back for him.
I think without that, he still would have been on the good side at the least, though yes willing to experiment with some of the dark side abilities with Qui-gon to train Anakin and give himself greater strength.
What if Mace Windu trained Anakin? Mace would have taught Anakin how to properly use his emotions and both sides of the force.
Mace Window straight up hated Anakin, no freaking way is he training him lol
Mace Windu was a jealous jerk.
@Mr. C You mean Dooku? Because count Dooku was the greatest duelist the Jedi ever trained. Dooku even scared Palpatine after going toe to toe with Yoda. You're making mace Windu sound like a Mary sue.
Skywalker’s fate was sealed the moment he met Padme and then left his mother to become a Jedi Padawan... no matter if Qui-Gon Jinn lived or not... He always 2 things on his mind other than training to be Jedi Knight his Mother and Padme....
Not really
This really deserves a movie.
It would have been interesting if Qui Gon had taken Dooku along, seeing Dooku help train Anakin would've been epic.
I like where your going with this, basically an established grey order maintaining balance in the force instead of trying to shift the balance either way
i have my theories that if qui gon had trained anakin, palpatine wouldn't have been able to use the methods he did to sway him to his side. i also have to agree that taking him to dathomir would be wise, despite it being a dark side planet, the residents don't quite follow it the same way the sith do. maul (as far as i know) was only brought there to recover (which in this video he will not need to) and dooku only to gain savage as an apprentice. the planet surprisingly doesn't seem to have much interaction with the sith.
also as a side note, i was wondering if your would do a 'what if' kylo ren didn't need his lightsaber to have a crossguard or if he found and used darth vader's sith lightsaber. after seeing him wield the skywalker lightsaber against the knights of ren so fluently, myself and a few others have thought the crossguard he used made his style exactly like luke said about the knights of ren using the force as a hammer while he used it like a blade.
This story was Amazing would really like if there was a part 3.
I would love to see this story and this different spin on these amazing characters. Maybe if the MCU what if stories are loved by a wide audience, Disney might think about doing a similar what if for their popular stories/characters
I would love them to make movies going with this flow vs the way they did it
I think my master (Qui-Gon) would teach him how to force heal
Obi-Wan Kenobi so true he woulda learnt him good 😁
Yeah something you definitely couldn’t learn him
Jack Roman that’s because when my master died, my training wasn’t finished yet
@@ObiWanKenobi85 Ahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh
*teach him
qui gon is what anakin needed since he just dont listen to the council if he knows they are wrong
The thing that we will not see if Jin is alive or more accurate heard is the tragedy of Darth Plagues the wise
I really want a part 3
Born from darkness
Forged by the light
There is no peace
There is no wrath
There is only strength
There is only knowledge
There is only life
There is only the FORCE !!!
Great work! I don't think I would've chosen Dathomir, but I'm excited to see where the story goes.
Would Master Qui-Gon attempt to rescue Shmi from slavery now that he can, It might keep Anakin more grounded as a person
Thanks Stupendous Wave, you’re videos make me able to get through self quarantine
This is the best. I would love to see an entirely rewritten saga where Anakin didn’t turn to the dark side of the force. And The Jedi have to fight against the clones because Order 66 still happens.
Some of these stills look like Niel Patrick Harris' face was melded with theirs. I love it!
At 5:00 Qui Gonn looks a bit like Winston Churchill
This was one of the best "What if...?" videos I've seen regarding Star Wars. I'm really curious about what you will bring us on part 2.
“I want to bring the series back in full force.”
Ahhhh, clever!
As much as I hate to point it out, in the most recent canon novel; Master and Apprentice which is set prior to the events of TPM Dooku is already no longer a member of the Jedi order. And has no contact with Qui-Gon
What if Anakin fell in love with a Nightsister instead of Padme in this scenario?
So glad you have decided to bring this series back!!!
I want a movie of this story but I’m afraid even if it was made they would find some way to screw up its awesomeness. You’ve more than earned a like on this one, my friend.
I think this 'what if story' was executed perfectly, keep up the good work.
his DARKNESS... grows BRIGHTER?
Nice take - only thing missing which I found central to Annakins development is his love for his mother and love for Padme and if these attachments would still have had a conflictive bearing on his character as he grows older. Plus would Qui-Gon would have gone the Jedi route and restricted him, or supported him in at least reestablishing contact with his loved ones
Okay heres a neat idea:
What if Anakin was randomly selected to become a Temple Guard (while secretly married to Padme)?
In canon the novel "Master and Apprentice" it's said Dooku left the order sometime before Jinn and Kenobi's mission on Pijal, which was a few years before ep 1
I'm actually happy Anikan skywalker turned to the dark side because then there would be no Darth Vader
Me too
Fantastic mate ... THIS IS the Star Wars Novel I’m dying to read more into . My favourite thing is actually Qui-Gon and Dooku .. my two favourite force sensitive characters ever tbh
I love how Anakin is supposedly so strong with the force that no one has ever seen anything like it, and yet the most interesting thing we ever see him do with the force is choke someone.
Like, really? Even Yoda managed to pull an entire X-wing out of a swamp, but the "chosen one" can squeeze people's throats enough to cut off their breathing. That really doesn't take much force, no pun intended.
He also deflected blasts from weapons with his open palm. Don't forget that most of his force abilities where lost when he lost his limbs.
Such as force lightning
@@doesyomamaknowtho1468 Oh yeah...that's a good point.
Anakin was able to predict the future with complete accuracy though. That's something we never saw anyone do in the films.
@@Archedgar I think you give him a little too much credit, but I get where you're coming from. He was able to see brief flashes of things that would soon happen...but all jedi have some level of extrasensory perception. They can know something bad is happening, or will happen, by sensing it through the force.
In the game star wars jedi fallen order he ripped apart the ENTIRE FRICKING BASE BECAUSE HE COULD just walking past it.
A splinter cell Jedi order with Dooku, Qui-gon, Obiwan and Anakin would’ve been absolutely unstoppable. Sidious would be stuck with Maul and couldn’t turn Anakin. They could’ve reformed the Jedi order to be balanced and connected with the force, not stupidly afraid of attachment or even studying the dark side within them.
Given the clone wars shows yoda being taught by Qui-gon I think Yoda was open minded and wise enough to have joined on too and at that point the entire order could’ve been reformed and saved with Qui Gon and Anakin ushering in a new era and defeating Sidious.
Damn. What could’ve been…