Who Was A Liar ?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 10 лют 2025
- In this video, we’re diving into one of the most intriguing questions of all time - who was the true prophet? We’ll explore the lives, teachings, and historical impact of two of history's most influential figures: Muhammad and Jesus. Were their messages compatible or contradictory? How did each figure shape their followers and the world as we know it? Get ready to dive deep and uncover the perspectives, evidence, and beliefs that have defined civilizations. Whether you're coming at this with questions or your own views, this is a journey to understand, respect, and reflect.
who was liar Muhammad or Jesus
#JesusVsMuhammad #ProphetsOfGod #ReligiousHistory #TruthAndFaith #WhoIsTheTrueProphet #ComparativeReligion #FaithJourney #Christianity #trinity #islam #toheed
![[DEBUNKED] The Moon Splitting Fairy Tale - Apostate Prophet](/img/n.gif)
Both were true prophet, but the biblical narrative of all prophets is nothing but blasphemy and slander of those honourable souls...
Yes. You are saying Both were true prophet.
Jesus Christ is Son of the God not prophet
The only blasphemy here is your prophet saying he was a mesaenger from God
@@batata1290 but Jesus claimed to be a prophet.
Matthew 21:11 "And the crowds said, 'This is the prophet Jesus, from Nazareth of Galilee'..
@@Opithos813 He was a true prophet, prophesied by Moses, Isaiah, Daniel and Jesus.
If you don't believe that, get lost.
And we can't deny that the Bible blasphemes the prophets ( David committing adultery, Lot committing incest, Moses killing innocent people etc.)..
Your testimony is not valid unless you bring another women to support your claim. Your opinion is half of a man because of your deficiency in religion , your prophet said.
As an Orthodox Christian, I believe that without Jesus Christ, there is no salvation. Jesus is the ultimate path to God, and without His sacrifice, humanity would be lost. According to Christian teaching, Jesus Christ took on our sins and paid the penalty for them by dying on the cross. But He didn’t just die He rose from the dead, defeating death and offering us eternal life. This is our salvation, rooted in His resurrection, which is the foundation of our faith.
If God could simply forgive sins without sacrifice or atonement, then why was humanity cast out of Eden in the first place? Why were Adam and Eve sent away from the Garden of Eden? It suggests that sin has consequences that can’t simply be erased without justice or sacrifice. The Old Testament shows this repeatedly through the sacrificial system, but that system was only temporary and pointed toward the ultimate sacrifice: Jesus Christ.
Islam teaches that we can receive forgiveness by directly praying to God (Allah), but this misses the deeper truth that sin separates us from God in a way that only Jesus can bridge. If direct forgiveness were all that was needed, why would God allow the consequences of sin to fall on humanity at all? Christianity teaches that God’s justice and mercy meet at the cross Jesus took the punishment on our behalf. Only through Jesus, who is both fully God and fully man, can our sins be truly forgiven, allowing us to have a personal relationship with God.
Moreover, while Christianity spread through love, sacrifice, and teachings of peace, Islam historically expanded through conquests and often by force. Christianity teaches us to share the message of Christ with compassion and respect, not compulsion. Jesus instructed His followers to "love your enemies" and to spread His teachings through love, not by the sword.
In my view, Islam offers a path that misses the core truth of humanity’s need for redemption and God’s perfect justice and mercy in Jesus. Jesus Christ is not only a prophet but the Son of God and the Savior of the world. Through Him alone, we find salvation and the true meaning of God’s love.
Chad.✝☦
@Rian_Pajarillaga God bless you❤️☦️
As a practicing Muslim, I think you miss the teachings of Islam. It is not like you can do sins and ask for forgiveness and then do sins again. Firstly, there are two types of sins in Islam; one which is infringement to God's guidance and the religious obligations and other which is harming any soul. During judgement, the first type of sin is forgiven if you ask enough for forgiveness. The second type of sin can only be forgiven if the soul harmed forgives you. According to our belief, our good or bad deeds do not make any difference to God but merely to our souls. We can only enter Heaven through God's mercy. Now, certainly God forgives someone who repents but when you do too many sins, you slowly start to lose shame or conscience, and that is where the problem lies. See, there are people who do few sins previously and truly ask for forgiveness and Islam gives you free will to turn to God and repent no matter how bad you once were to yourself. Even if you harmed someone in past, you can do good deeds and the deciding soul may get convinced by it and forgives you. Asking for forgiveness from your heart is different than just asking for forgiveness shamelessly. When you do it with complete indulgence, you can feel a part of you being better and slowly healing and slowly yet certainly you turn to God. By your sense of speech, every man who did sins must perform sacrifices or suffer the consequences; so how does God be any special than regular justice system? If someone does too many sins and feel pressure about it, he may do more sins and hence he will feel tempted. So, where is peace in prayer?
Lastly, you say Christianity spread through love and harmony while Islam spread through conquests. First of all, Christianity in certain places, have spread because of conquests, just like Islam did. And even though I agree, Islam mostly spread through conquests, most people love being a practicing Muslim. they do not have complaints. Many Muslims today do complain, they have lost faith. Either because the guidance they receive is improper and impulsive unlike the true teachings of Islam. On the other hand, in spite of being in the religion of love and being kind to enemies, I see most of Christians today do sins and cannot even state a few verses from Bible. Where is the Love for God and atonement for sins? Will you say that they shall be burnt in hell or will you be willing to teach them about their religion instead of doing comparisons like radicals...? No matter what religion you belong to, as long as you're a part of the material world, there will be emotional calamities, there will be mistakes. But the true best are those who repent on it.
And, to my eyes, the truth is what you fail to see. To your eyes, the truth is what I fail to see. But my friend, had there been someone to declare his truth as the absolute truth today, he would be a prophet. But this age has no place for a prophet to come. People who believe in God and goodness are less, they stay calm and continue and the disbelievers are those who wage wars, mock others and turn their ears to the devil who bring temptation upon our souls.
@ibnsiddiqui Thank you for sharing your perspective. I respect the emphasis in Islam on repentance and sincerity in asking for forgiveness, as well as the view that sins have different consequences based on whom they affect. In Orthodox Christianity, we also believe in repentance as a way to return to God. We view sin as damaging to the soul, separating us from God, and affecting our relationship with others, so true repentance and reconciliation are essential.
However, as an Orthodox Christian, I believe that only through Jesus Christ can we be fully reconciled with God. According to our faith, Jesus took on our sins and died for us, offering a path to salvation through His sacrifice on the cross. The justice system of God is different from human justice because He took the consequences upon Himself out of love. Christ’s sacrifice doesn’t mean we don’t repent or try to live righteously; rather, it means that we are forgiven not by our deeds alone, but by God’s grace, which transforms us when we genuinely repent and follow His teachings.
You mentioned that in Islam, one enters Heaven through God’s mercy. In Christianity, we similarly believe that we rely on God’s grace, not merely our own actions. In fact, we believe it is Christ’s resurrection that opened the way to eternal life for all who accept Him. This belief is central to our faith because it demonstrates that only through Christ, who overcame sin and death, can humanity enter into eternal communion with God.
As for Christianity’s spread, it is true that individuals and groups have, regrettably, acted in ways contrary to Christ’s teachings. Yet, the early church spread mainly through peaceful means, even amid persecution. Jesus taught us to spread His message through love, humility, and sacrifice, even loving our enemies. He called us to witness with compassion, not force. While not every Christian lives up to these teachings, we are continually called back to love, humility, and faithfulness.
In terms of comparing religious paths, I understand your concern. Christianity teaches us to share our faith, not in judgment or competition, but with respect and love for others. When we believe something is true, it’s natural to share that belief, just as you have shared yours with me. From my perspective, the fullness of truth is found in Jesus Christ, who claimed to be the way, the truth, and the life. Christians believe that God’s ultimate revelation to humanity is in Christ, and through Him, we find peace, forgiveness, and eternal life.
I appreciate your emphasis on mutual respect. I agree that we live in a time when faith is often challenged, and we need to encourage each other toward good, faithfulness, and seeking the truth. While we may see the truth differently, I believe that our discussions can help us deepen our understanding. May God the Father guide us both toward a greater knowledge of Him and the path of true peace in Jesus Name Amen. God bless you❤️☦️
@@128bitman May God bless you as well. We may have our differences; so, I pray to God that all the people worthy of mercy and love shall be granted heaven in the afterlife, irrespective of their differences in beliefs. Good and bad sees no religion. In every religion, there are true believers along with blinded radicals. I completely agree that Jesus Christ(peace be upon him) had come to reveal the truth and did what he was ought to do magnificently. People like you who take the religion by heart is indeed graceful. What concerns me is the increasing number of people who have weak faith in their religion and in the act of showing that they are defending their faith, they become egoistic and aggressive and hurt souls of themselves not only others; not to mention they harm the reputation of their religions as well(most exclusively many Muslims who do debates without respecting others' perspectives)
Peace.
oh naw, not the chatgpt written script and AI voice 😭💀
Mo , who promoted deception as Taqqiya . The prophet of Allah , the best of deceivers . Guess who's the liar ?
السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته
I think the thumbnail should be changed as it is disrespectful to Eisa (AS)
You mean Islamic Jesus.
@@UnbeatenPlayzMinecraftandmore those pictures of Jesus aren't appropriate and should instead be replaced by calligraphy
@@DomainofKnowlegdia
There is no painting of jesus,
You cannot just draw a jewish man with long hair and beard from the 1st century and call it Jesus
@@User_47536 yeah in my opinion the figure of Jesus Christ was meant to by symbolic by that I mean he was an amalgamation of several Jewish martyrs and preachers and messianic rebels and leaders and priests and other monastic sects in second temple period judaism it was these people who inspired the messianic Jews to craft the figure of Jesus as they were expecting the davidic Messiah to come however after the figure was crafted to some extent they differed regarding him and this led to many different Christianities who adopted many different concepts and the term orthodoxy wasn't clear yet or the heresy. Some of these early Christianities would later become Islam and Christianity we know today so in my opinion none of them are correct and they all have their own world view which are symbolic. Also the new testament canon we have today is the work of a later Christianity which had its own theological view point.
@@DomainofKnowlegdia yeah there is evidence, btw if not then you don't exist, and you certainly exist cause you are thinking then Jesus is God
JESUS IS KING
I may be christian but i personally think neither of them were liars.
Then you are a heretic
@@Uberman138-e3c Muhammad certainly was
@@Opithos813 ok
If you don't believe he wasn't a liar, then why are you still Christian?
You're not Christian.
Great video! May Allah bless us all in the dunya and hereafter.
Thank you! You too!
Muhammad told some sick people to drink camel's urine for healing.
Do you drink it when sick?
Alhamdulillah the picture they paint on our prophet is so false. Their indeed was a brother hood of prophets which sounds like common sense. But, common sense ain’t so common. Jazakallah for the video
Great video, keep it up 👍. Also make videos to encourage people to Quran recitation with translation and explanation whether by listening or reading. Make sure to stay connected with the Quran and keep your intensions sincere.
Sure
Masha'a Allah ❤❤❤
Allah is a false god
Your description and titles says both Jesus and Muhammad but you only talk about Muhammad? Likewise, we can argue that why would Jesus lie when he also stood to be persecuted and crucified?
He certainly lied when he said Jesus didn't die on the cross
And [for] their saying, "Indeed, we have killed the Messiah, Jesus, the son of Mary, the messenger of Allah." And they did not kill him, nor did they crucify him; but [another] was made to resemble him to them. And indeed, those who differ over it are in doubt about it. They have no knowledge of it except the following of assumption. And they did not kill him, for certain.
that was not jesus,isa as was take to sky by god that was a different person
@@MDyashin-ru5pu Source: trust me bro
@@isaacgeorge7288 just go and read the quran youll know,we all knnow torah (bible) is not preserved and contain contradiction read the bible just blindly dont belive
@@isaacgeorge7288
source: The Quran
MASHALLAH SIS🥰
PLZ CAN U TALK ABOUT SECTS IN ISLAM (SUNNI, SHIA) . im also mslim but the sects confused me cuz their not the same🙁 .
Sure inshallah
Meanwhile in chapter 5 verses 46-47 your god allows people to judye by their own gospels and in chapter 16 verse 89 says that the Quran is the clearest book of them so called "revelations". It's like a teacher asking you to study with a book you have no historical record of. Sounds quite contradictory not only to me but everyone that decides to see things with other eyes.
What miracle does your Bible contains other than Historical mistakes Scientific mistake magnificent contradictions. Your Bible is nothing Infront of the Quran. The Quran has Miracles and your Bible doesn't. People become a Muslim by studying the Quran and no one becomes Christian by reading the Bible.
imagine using AI to pretend to be a woman 😂
Hiw do you know it’s ai?
@@Uberman138-e3c
This sounds very text to speech
@@Uberman138-e3c It’s obvious listen to the emotions of the voice it doesn’t even match
@shortpam1943islegendary Yes you don’t have to tell me 100 times i already heard the last person explain it to me.
I rlly like ur videos girlie what program do u use to make them?
Primiere pro
Allahuma barik, the size of your channel may be small, but your video editing skills are huge. keep it up.
Thank you, I will
"Why, of course i'm not a liar, this book i wrote says that i'm not a liar!"
mhm right someone known as an illiterate person definitely wrote whats considered as one of the best works in arabic literature (the best imo)
@@Aymanis_professional_account He had scribes.
No because there was no translation of torah In Arabic it was made after his death you can search when was first Arabic translation was made of torah and in hadith there only one new mentioned who became muslim @@prdarlin
@@MDyashin-ru5pu makes sense, Muhammad’s knowledge of the Torah is abysmal in the Quran.
@@prdarlin no that why he couldn't have written the quran but it was God,quran contain embryology which many professor and dr studied after learning Arabic and all were shocked and converted like keith. Moore and marcurice buccaile and many more they learnt Arabic to read Qur'an and how can muhammad would have known this he was literally illiterate and even no one have knew about this stages of embryology which is present in the Quran
simple, its mermaidman of arab, he told he was prophesized by the bible, but later accused bible was corrupted when he realized he contradicted the bible, yet somehow his supposedly almighty god cannot produce any independent sources to support his claim???, instead we have dead sea scrolls etc which confirmed the preservation of the bible, what kind of god to had archeologies evidences stacked against him???
Wonderful
Allahumma Barik
Idk but the video's title is disrespectful for both blessed prophets
Subscribed❤
Sister, what AI did you use to generate the voices?
He was sick, evil and a liar.
You are just dumb after hearing still dumb😂😂
you? its better to speak with a mirror not in YT comments
Great video 👍
Yeah it was a relly great video also i just hawe to say it's relly unusual to find a female Dawah chanel😅
so in short, injil is written or revealed by Isa as. and narrated by his disciple. but bible is dlc which contains commentary and stories
I am myself on a mission to prove that The Qur'an cannot possibly be written by a human, but is divine. Instead of making it a single video, the evidences are so much that I kind of made it a part of my life mission to show these proofs in the shape of these playlists. Maybe you can make a single video showing that The Qur'an has these miracles in some way. Maybe give some examples within a single video. Anyways, these are the linguistic and numerical miracles (and thus evidences) for The Qur'an to be the word of God:
ua-cam.com/video/NNLxGcxuU-c/v-deo.html&pp=iAQB
and
ua-cam.com/video/R_EN4XBD-YQ/v-deo.html&pp=iAQB
My life mission too
Both are speaking truth both are messenger of God Jesus is the messenger of the God and Muhammad is the messenger of God people only change the scriptures so people are only speaking lie
❤❤🎉
So basically Mohamed vannot be a liar, because he wrote down in his book that he is not a liar. Bulletproof logic. 🤣🤣
Assalamu alaykum
In fact, there are well over 20 versions of the Quran and no one knows which one is the original.
A common narrative among you Muslims is that Paul would have distorted the words of Christ (who even in Islam is the only sinless prophet), but Muhammad would have had many more incentives to do so since Paul lost everything he had when he started taking the gospel, but Muhammad achieved prestige, riches, women and an extensive empire through his prophecies, who could be the faker?
Thats why that religion of called Desert Cult religion started by a sex predator who nooked 9 years old girl
20 versions 🙄😮💨, it called "قرائات" people who have the same language may be different the tongue , different ways to spell letters ,in islam all prophet are sinless , David peace upon him was rich he was king and warlord, who had many wifes does that makes him a liar or faker, and let's make something clear the prophet money is the money of the poor , widow, to those who need it ,
@@imaddlk345 Muhammad literally asks for forgiveness in the Quran, which means he had sinned
@imperialanimator1210 asking god for forgiveness is praying to him and teaching to us , and When the Messenger of God - may God bless him and grant him peace - prayed, he would stand until his feet were swollen. Aisha said: O Messenger of God, do you do this when your past and future sins have been forgiven?) He - may God bless him and grant him peace - said: O Aisha, should I not be a grateful servant?, this is one of a lot of things that made me believe he is the messenger of god
@@imperialanimator1210 he had never sinned, you know nothing.
When Abu hurayra asked why did he asked for forgiveness, though being sinless, he said "Will I not be a good servant?"..
MashAllah sister ❤
jazakullah but sister the profile i think thats sunful cuz there are many of our brothers here and when they see your profile i think you get sins im not 100% but still stay safe
The real liars are people who changed pages of the bible to lead the people like handful of slaves
I'm not trying to insult Christians . I'm trying to say the truth
"changed pages of the bible" First rule of taqiyya: "Never discuss, always deflect". Thanks for yet another example.
@@toddbeamer6131 wdym "never discuss, always deflect". Are you trying to say that I must ignore them or smth like that?
Fire ass channel name lmao
@Basedmuslimah According to Saudi cleric Mohammed al-Arife there are 4 kinds of people in
the world:
1) Arab - people from UAE, Kuwait, Qatar, Bahrain, Saudi Arabia (original
Arabs)
2) Abeed (enslaved/ surrendered (colloquial)) - people who became Muslim &
Arab or whose language is now Arabic but who had a different culture &
language earlier ie. Egypt, Iraq, Morocco, Syria, Sudan, Palestine, Yemen
etc
(Abeed al- arab al-islam)
3) Ajam (dumb/ those who speak another language (colloquial) - People who
were conquered by the Arabs in the name of Islam but retained thier
original language & culture ie Iran, Turkey, Pakistan, India muslims
,Malays , Kazakhs etc
4) Kafirun - non Muslims
When asked as to what role the Muslims of the sub-continent and the
'Stans' (as they are numerous) can play, he smiled and said "when we don't
accept the second as equal to us, why would we trust the third?"
Wherever Islam goes blood flows
I'm mad why do Christians want to go to Jahanam
and muslims to
Why do believe the Quran ? Because it is the word of God
Why do you believe it is the word of God ?
Because it says it is the word of God
And why do you believe what it says ? Because it is the word of God
Its like watching a dog chasing its own tail
The Prophets عليهم الصلاة والسلام shouldn't be depicted with images, sister, barakAllahu fik
Did you seriously say that Muhammad was sent by god just because he said he was sent by god? I could claim that I am god (although it might be blasphemous), and with that logic you would say I am god? How do you know he couldn't have been a liar? Just because he was a strong character and was charismatic doesn't mean he wasn't a liar, because the best liars are the ones that tell some truth and some lie, making them harder to distinguish (not indefensible since His writers were the ones that wrote "he was trustable by even his enemies," how do we know that's true).
By the way, there is no record of Abraham building the Kaaba besides the Quran itself, so it would take more evidence for me to believe that.
You might have an argument about the refusing wordly possessions, but so did Jesus, and Buddha, and most other religious figures.
You're straw manning In this video, I’m not trying to prove that Prophet Muhammad came from Allah this isn’t even the main topic, It’s just about the liar claim. Watch the video carefully, then respond
@@Basedmuslimah No, I think you should read my comment again, because one of your main arguments in the beginning was that Muhammad couldn't have lied because he was deemed by his enemies as trustworthy. My point was that he still could have been a liar since the best liars often mix up truths and lies, which makes them very manipulative. This does not mean that Muhammad WAS a liar, just that your claim doesn't support the fact that he wasn't a liar.
@vaedkamat484 he was known by the people before his prophet Hood as " the trustworthy" as he was a trustworthy business man, and Khadija R.A. was impressed by his honesty and reputation of trust among the people and so married him.
Also Abu Sufyan R.A. before his conversion to Islam, he was an enemy of Islam and he was confronted by Herclius, ruler of Rome, and was asked questions and the kind said if he said a lie he would be executed.
Abu sufyan was asked many questions including did the prophet break any promise or tell lies before his prophet Hood he said no. So he was know as trustful among his enemies.
Even Heraclius (devote christian) said all of these signs indicate he is indeed a prophet. (Sahih Bukhari 7)
@@Al-Rizzler21 Fair point.
@@vaedkamat484 👍🏻
Abraham did not build the Kaaba, that is completely ahistorical
MUHAMMAD! ALL DAY EVERY DAY.
@Basedmuslimah Sauda: Goes out to take a dump
Umar: "Sauda! I can see you!"
Sauda: "Mo, Umar won't let me take a crap in peace"
Mo: "God allows you to take a dump, now let me finish my chicken dinner"
Sahih Bukhari Volume 6, Book 60, Hadith Number 402: 'Allah’s Apostle said, “In Paradise there is a pavilion made of a single hollow pearl sixty miles wide, in each corner of which there are wives who will not see those in the other corners; and the believers will visit and enjoy them. (...).' He wasn't a liar? Think again. Mohammed was a pervert, a sinner and an idolater who just like all of us needs redemption for his sins yet he rejected Jesus who died for him. He is not in heaven. The true heaven is the one revealed in the bible where we are all like unto angels with no wives or husbands or partners. Also one of allahs names is the 'greatest deceiver'. How can you trust him? You just can''t.
How is it, then, that Muhammad requested Forgiveness from Allah seventy times a day?
Repentance is not only for redemption, but it is to humbly gain the pleasure of Allah ﷻ, and a higher, more noble standing before Him. And so the chief of all humans and the leader of the Pious, Prophet Muhammad ﷺ, would seek forgiveness in all situations
@snipez9708
Muhammad requested forgiveness -- he showed absolutely no signs of repentance...
@snipez9708
And, er, how many of the Ten Commandments as received by Moses from God did Muhammad obey or uphold? That would be *_NONE,_** NOT ONE, NARY-A-ONE, **_ZERO._*
Quran 77:50: "In which Hadith after this Quran do they believe in?" Destroys the teachings of Bukhari and his fabricated "Sunnah".
If you show me the exact manuscript from the time of Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him of the verse you're quoting from the Quran, I'll become a Quranist Now!
@@BasedmuslimahIs this your way of denying a Qur'an verse?
No i didn't deny any verse, just why I'll take your interpretations instead of sahaba?
@@Basedmuslimah Hello there! Two questions for you.
You mentioned you take from Kutub Al-Sittah (the six main Sunni books), of which the two main ones are Bukhari and Muslim. These two were commissioned by governments of their time and often cite Abu Hurayrah, who was known to be very untrustworthy.
Reference:
When ‘Umar heard about it, he called him in and asked him to repeat that hadīth. Having heard him repeating it, ‘Umar struck him and said to him, “How so when Allāh Himself says it was created in six days, while you yourself now say it was done in seven?!” Abu Hurayra said, “Maybe I heard it from Ka’b al-Ahbar...” ‘Umar said, “Since you cannot distinguish between the Prophet's ahādīth and what Ka’b al-Ahbar says, you must not narrate anything at all.”
Citation Used: (Refer to the book titled Abu Hurayra by the Egyptian author Mahmoud Abu Rayyah.)
2) What is your response to Sahih Muslim 1821a, 1821e, 1821f, 1821d?
It has been narrated on the authority of Jabir b. Samura who said:
I joined the company of the Prophet (ﷺ) with my father and I heard him say: This Caliphate will not end until there have been twelve Caliphs among them. The narrator said: Then he (the Holy Prophet) said something that I could not follow. I said to my father: What did he say? He said: He has said: All of them will be from the Quraish.
Caliphate refers to succession after Muhammad, meaning the individuals must be in successive order. Shias don't define caliphate as simply political or military but also religious
Only 2 of their 12 Imams had political power.
Imam Ali and Imam Hassan.
While you're at it, i would love for you to checkout this google doc!
For the section on purely using Sunni sources rather than Shia ones, skip to Method Three
docs.google.com/document/d/1n65QrEiPgMulqw7_-fic3qymk8eSKReTAlIilFS2XZU/edit#heading=h.gxfy0one0a4z
Have an blessed day!
@@Basedmuslimah Hello there! Two questions for you.
You mentioned you take from Kutub Al-Sittah (the six main Sunni books), of which the two main ones are Bukhari and Muslim. These two were commissioned by governments of their time and often cite Abu Hurayrah, who was known to be very untrustworthy.
Reference:
When ‘Umar heard about it, he called him in and asked him to repeat that hadīth. Having heard him repeating it, ‘Umar struck him and said to him, “How so when Allāh Himself says it was created in six days, while you yourself now say it was done in seven?!” Abu Hurayra said, “Maybe I heard it from Ka’b al-Ahbar...” ‘Umar said, “Since you cannot distinguish between the Prophet's ahādīth and what Ka’b al-Ahbar says, you must not narrate anything at all.”
Citation Used: (Refer to the book titled Abu Hurayra by the Egyptian author Mahmoud Abu Rayyah.)
2) What is your response to Sahih Muslim 1821a, 1821e, 1821f, 1821d?
It has been narrated on the authority of Jabir b. Samura who said:
I joined the company of the Prophet (ﷺ) with my father and I heard him say: This Caliphate will not end until there have been twelve Caliphs among them. The narrator said: Then he (the Holy Prophet) said something that I could not follow. I said to my father: What did he say? He said: He has said: All of them will be from the Quraish.
Caliphate refers to succession after Muhammad, meaning the individuals must be in successive order. Shias don't define caliphate as simply political or military but also religious
Only 2 of their 12 Imams had political power.
Imam Ali and Imam Hassan.
While you're at it, i would love for you to checkout this google doc!
For the section on purely using Sunni sources rather than Shia ones, skip to Method Three
docs.google.com/document/d/1n65QrEiPgMulqw7_-fic3qymk8eSKReTAlIilFS2XZU/edit#heading=h.gxfy0one0a4z
Have an blessed day!
all the "stories: in the Quran are inspired from other jewish, Assyrian christian, or pagan stories that were popular at that time, with some edits here & there.
al kahf from king theodeus story, "the two horned" by Alexander the great mythical, lots of verses from the satanic bible intermixed with normal verses..
you can't argue that someone isn't a liar because people called him the "truthful", especially when hat is exaggerated through islamic writings & not a phenomenal tested method
read about sahabi abdullah, who was with muhammad being dictated some of the quran on leather sheets. maybe you'd understand more
Post hox fallacy
Jesus copied everything from Jewish texts...that's why Jews hated him
"a liar lies for some worldly gain"
like taking a young girl
like retribution from the elders who cast the fool out
like being worshipped as a prophet,
to name a few... nope nothing to see here
Yeah it’s clear from this statement that you do not know anything about our prophet’s life or Islam for that matter.
I do not know if your a liar but your certainly a delusional
No one worships him.
He Forgave those elders
Polygamy and marrying girls at that age were the societal norm at that time.
Sister, I want ask you??
Yes
@Basedmuslimah
What prophet Muhammad thinks about on non-Muslim women and non-Muslim girls?
@@yashfini_20.10the same he thinks about non Muslim men, as in both going to fire
nahhh both are liars
Your testimony is not valid unless you bring another women to support your claim. Your opinion is half of a man because of your deficiency in religion , your prophet said.
Testimony by law. This is not a ruling this is the truth.
@@poopyfish You can't say "this is the truth" when the video is formatted like a trial...