yes I believe she is... I love her so much and this is my favorite scene other than in La Vie Boheme when she grabs Joanne's butt and says "Hey Mister, she's my sister."
@ShrimpSticks1 That's not even why they weren't in the movie. The woman that played Mimi (Daphne Ruben-Vega) was pregnant and the woman that played Joanne (Fredi Walker) felt that she was too old to play in the movie. Also it takes a lot of talent to be on Broadway, a lot more than it does in movies.
Both the original and the Glee version are great. I don't understand why, on EVERY video for a song done on Glee, there has to be arguing over which version is better.
This...it just isn't doin it for me...they sound sooo....sick. Maybe that was on purpose, but I don't like it. I love that Glee did a version of this and in my opinion I think it's better and has more feel to it. Gave me chills when I 1st heard it ^_^
I am aware, I'm just saying more people would be familiar with the movie that came out in 2005, not the stage musical in 1996. Which is why my reply was referring to how its debatable if most teenagers learn the song from Glee, when the movie version came out less than 6 years when Glee did theres. See what happens when you make assumption of context?
Aw, this represents me and my friend ;^; MIND. WHY ARE YOU TAKING ME TO SONGS THAT REMIND ME OF HER WHEN WE'RE FIGHTING!? The problems are different and the personalities, but this song says so much about us...
Only reason I'm listening to this song is because Liz Gillies and Ariana Grande sang this song to each other, but i couldn't hear the words clearly, now i know them, all i have to say is OMG!!!! YAY!!!!!
I don't understand why your comment has so many thumbs down. But I wonder why this is as well... :/ I like both versions. If Glee sucked, it wouldn't still be running. If the original sucked, there wouldn't be so many stupid arguments telling Gleeks that the Glee version sucks... etc. You see my point..?
I on't agree with the previous commenter, but Glee doesn't ruin every song they cover. They're actually pretty good. Maybe you're not into them, but you just can't say they're not good because you don't like Glee the show...
RENT was actually a musical long before a movie was even thought of. It first aired on Broadway in 1996.
I sang this to my ex a week before we broke up. I'm now happily out of the closet as a lesbian.
The most beautiful song about love I've ever heard. Seriously, it shuold be an anthem of love. ;)
im doing this for a musical selection in my drama class i don't think i can pull off maureen SHE'S AMAZING
Idina's voice has progressed SO MUCH!!!
SO BABY TAKE ME OR LEAVE MEEEEEEEEEEEE
yes I believe she is... I love her so much and this is my favorite scene other than in La Vie Boheme when she grabs Joanne's butt and says "Hey Mister, she's my sister."
I love both versions :)
I agree! No one can beat Idina!
i meet freddi walker browne. it was awesome. she is amazing.
@ShrimpSticks1 That's not even why they weren't in the movie. The woman that played Mimi (Daphne Ruben-Vega) was pregnant and the woman that played Joanne (Fredi Walker) felt that she was too old to play in the movie. Also it takes a lot of talent to be on Broadway, a lot more than it does in movies.
The quotation should end after "Baby" because so sweet is a description of how they say "baby." People don't call her "baby so sweet."
Omg - That sounds nothing like Idina!!! Wowww!! I love her :D
ANNNND IF YOU GIVE A DAMMMMNN!! (many thanks ☺️)
thanks! :{)
omg I know right, glee ruin everything!
Both the original and the Glee version are great.
I don't understand why, on EVERY video for a song done on Glee, there has to be arguing over which version is better.
@Thefuzz17901 Yes, yes they are. Is that a problem?
This is a great sediment for woman to man relations!! Not to try to change the person you fell in love with!!! Accept folk for who they are.
@broadwayxdude06 No problem.
Glee did a remake of this... FML
@MissLilSummer who?
The Glee version is fucking awful
well yeah but some are
@SuicidalSiren Why? Friday is legend :D
@SuicidalSiren Even Friday?
No actually
you need to just stop now. glee ruins just about every song they "cover"
I actually agree with you -_-. This original version just isn't doin it for me
love glee's version, but this is cool too.
Kay just completely disregard what I said
dead version of you wayyyyy better
This...it just isn't doin it for me...they sound sooo....sick. Maybe that was on purpose, but I don't like it. I love that Glee did a version of this and in my opinion I think it's better and has more feel to it. Gave me chills when I 1st heard it ^_^
I'm a gleek, but Idina is THE BEST :B
@ShrimpSticks1 well when you go on broadway/west end give us all a shout... till then dont diss people who have actually got somewhere
I am aware, I'm just saying more people would be familiar with the movie that came out in 2005, not the stage musical in 1996. Which is why my reply was referring to how its debatable if most teenagers learn the song from Glee, when the movie version came out less than 6 years when Glee did theres. See what happens when you make assumption of context?
The Glee version is just disgusting and has completely ruined the song.
I've been singing this at the top of my lungs for the last thirty minutes. :)
im doing this for a musical selectiion in my drama class i don't think i can pulloff maureen SHE'S AMAZING
this comment needs more likes
sixth formers at my school performed this song last night! ever since i cant get it out my head!! fab songg
Aw, this represents me and my friend ;^;
MIND. WHY ARE YOU TAKING ME TO SONGS THAT REMIND ME OF HER WHEN WE'RE FIGHTING!?
The problems are different and the personalities, but this song says so much about us...
Idina Menzel.. love her(:
I dont know, Rent is a pretty popular movie and it came out only a few years before Glee
the glee version is mediocre at best. This is true Broadway stars singing a true Broadway song, not two actors singing on a tv show.
@suzynjohnny Then you obviously don't know real broadway music. The original will always be better.
this makes me remember that guys r dogs and that us girls r better and no one can tell us deff
@fpark221 Yes it is. This is the OBC recording with Idina Menzel and Fredi Walker.
Saw her in concert last night i met her and she invited people on stage to sing this!!!!!
I reject the Glee version. Sorry, Gleeks, but the song is much better in context.
glee did an amazing job but rent is better(: and am a Gleek just sayin
My sister when she was like 3 knew all the words to this song, and would sing it all day in the car. This just unlocked a memory I forgot I had 😂
Oml, all these comments are like 9 yrs ago-
@rthestar95 That's because it's the original Broadway version.
I always sing this song at my boyfriend when he's mad at me. It seems to fix the problem, haha.
@xXLove2ReadXx Nope, just wondering. Thanks for answering.
@ShrimpSticks1 Yeah that's why they were on Broadway
@Thefuzz17901 In this movie/ musical yes
Sounds weird. Like an old tape.
Congratulations! Not that you broke up with someone, but that you're out. I know what a journey that is!
Oh, Idina, you enlighten me with your beautiful voice and inspirational acting
@ImNotWeirdYourNormal mine too shes amazing i love her in wicked!!!!
Only reason I'm listening to this song is because Liz Gillies and Ariana Grande sang this song to each other, but i couldn't hear the words clearly, now i know them, all i have to say is OMG!!!! YAY!!!!!
yea and they left important parts to the song out
Glee :)
she does amazing in glee as well
@ReddieForeverXOXOXO yea!(:
thankies for posting
Oh, Idina Menzel
i love this song :D
luv this movie!!!
i love this sung
i luv this song!
thank you! :D
good for you!
same here!
No
Everyone is entitled to their own opinion. Doesn't give you a right to disapprove mine -_-. My opinion isn't wrong and neither is yours. Deal with it
That's your opinion. I happen to like their version way better. You like the original better. Plain and simple -_-
@mtndewgirl6661994 I love this version, but yes, NOTHING beats the Glee version. ^-^
I don't understand why your comment has so many thumbs down. But I wonder why this is as well... :/ I like both versions. If Glee sucked, it wouldn't still be running. If the original sucked, there wouldn't be so many stupid arguments telling Gleeks that the Glee version sucks... etc. You see my point..?
Ironic how mother and daughter sing this to a black woman... o.0
~SFG
just so people know.. this is def not idina menzel... just saying.
I on't agree with the previous commenter, but Glee doesn't ruin every song they cover. They're actually pretty good. Maybe you're not into them, but you just can't say they're not good because you don't like Glee the show...
I have a question, Is Joanne and whats her face lesbians?
this gives a girl confidence!