I kind of wish that IZ*ONE did get a small extension. At least an extra six months. They never got to have a final good-bye concert in front of wizones in person due to the pandemic. I’m convinced it would’ve happened, but I’m sure starship was the company that refused. They don’t even allow Wonyoung and Yujin to interact too much with the other ex-IZ*ONE members or mention the group. They also lost a lot of time due to the rigging scandal that put them on a small hiatus.
Yujin mentioned izone in earth arcade a lot. Yujin and wonyoung always interact with the members whenever they see them, especially with chaewon yena Eunbi and yuri
@@arhamislami1910 she is still is graduating. Her graduation concert would be on spring 2023 but her final theater performance still haven't decided on yet.
Wizones are the most loyal fandom in Kpop. Kwizones alone were willing to donate 3 million USD just to keep the group alive. 23k Wizones donated an average of over 100 bucks for the parallel universe project. If they had expanded to J Wizones and C Wizones, they probably could of gotten 6 million USD or even more.
Oh my god, I had no idea about the Parallel Universe project. The fact that the fandom came so close to relaunching the group, only to have CJ stall it in the end...damn. Every time I think I'm done being sad about IZ*ONE some new info comes out and I'm devastated again. I miss them
If anyone is wondering most of the companies actually agreed to the idea of contract extension Yuehua, 8D, Urban Works, AKB48, WM, Woollim, Stone Music were onboard except Wonyoung and Yujin’s company Starship. They knew if they pulled them out and make IVE they would have big bank.
@@zzerorbit im just wondering, what if they actually wanted to further their career otherwise? we dont know what wony and yujin truly wanted in the end. But yeah its clear starship was decided on debuting ive at the expense of Iz*one's success for sure
During the hiatus, all Wiz*ones participate in the hashtag event on twitter..everyday a new hashtag was made, almost every hashtag was trending ..even when it was so emotionally taxing, seeing and participating in the events made me so proud that i am a wiz*one..
Yes, I wished this part of the story was told, since this is about "the power of Iz*ones fandom". Those hastags was the only thing that kept Wiz*ones connected thru Iz*ones hiatus. When SECRET STORY OF THE SWAN debuted I was really moved by the hashtags that was used in part of its debut....
I am THIS close to ugly sobbing. I miss them. I see them everyday, but I still somehow miss them. They were, and will always be my #1 gg. I love all the new projects that have come after their disbandment to pieces, but none will ever hold a candle to the original in my heart. My 12 shining stars
The ending of parallel universe project made me cry. It was so so sad. I saw our fandom completely deflate on that day in April. There was hope but in the back of our minds, we knew. It was sick how they watched us donate, campaign, tweet, promote this project but then just ripped it away. Wiz raised 3 million USD….with each wizone donating around 100 usd. That’s incredible. Wizone were dedicated and loved the girls. We still support the girls in their post Izone groups but if I’m being 100% honest, it will never replicate the love I had for my 12 girls. I miss them. We never got that goodbye concert. We never got that goodbye album. We saw chaewon and others completely break down, I mean the girl was HYPERVENTILATING. It was SICK.
all fandoms are great but we (WIZ*ONE) have amazing stories & memories that other fandoms may not experience. everyday we still imagine these 12 girls always singing & dancing together on stage, we love them so much 💕
@@gwenmloveskpopandmore I think they could have pulled it off if they'd cared, but the least they could have done when promoting one reeler was be like, 'btw this is the last song xoxo'
Man, I knew the rigging was shameless, but it was so damn shameless. I sadly arrived late to the IZ*ONE train, but I really do love the work that they did. I'm a huge fan of Yena's current work and can't wait to see what comes next
Its still so crazy how relevant Izone is till now even though they disbanded years ago. They were still used as the standard as for GGs (not even an exaggeration and not even my opinion). Their concept is so remarkable that if a group tried to that kind of concept theyll be immediately called as a plagiarist, they ate and served so much that.
I had never heard of "fandom funding a group" projects before. Without being mean, it sounds as realistically feasible as tumblr crowdfunding a convention haha
a lot of smaller kpop groups usually crowdfund their comebacks. it's not anything new, it was just the first time an already successful group with such a large fandom size had it done before
Yeah, WIZ*ONEs are not so sad because of the disbandment, but more of the way it happened. It's great the girls are doing great now, but neither them nor us deserved such a farewell. The lost time because of the scandal could have easily been used for another comeback and (hopefully full length) album. Both of the unreleased songs + whatever was in the works would would complete the "ONE" era of the group and become a graceful and somewhat bearable goodbye to the fans. Now we're constantly stuck in a loop missing them and dreaming of something impossible...
Iz one was awesome, and I think they shouldve at least gotten an extension to make up for the lost time, and they should’ve gotten to say goodbye in an in person concert. The saddest thing for me is that we know the girls themselves wanted to stay together, and they’ve all talked about how much they miss each other and I think its so sad they had to be separated. I think the girls should at least be allowed a reunion concert or tour at some point, they should be reunited and allowed to give a proper goodbye to their fans
Yayyy!! Welcome back!! I’m so glad ur doing a vid on IZ*One!! ❤️ About the produce scandal The producers of Produce were so stupid. They ruined things for people who were supposed to debut in S2, S3, and especially S4. Knowing what they did was wrong.I’m glad Japan knows how to not rig things. My fave songs by Izone are La Vi En Rose, Fiesta, You & I, Secret Story Of The Swan, and Panarama.
I don't want to seem rude or anything, but there's this question I've been wanting to ask you a long time ago. Why don't you write your entire thoughts in one comment instead of spamming the comment section with countless ones? If I didn't knew better I would think these channels are being spammed by bots.
Well technically Girls Planet is season 5 And Boys Planet is technically gonna be Season 6 🤫 Although it’s nice to know PD101 is still going strong in Japan after knowing what happened in Korea and China.
woohoo, so excited to finally see this video being brought to life !! thank you for working with me and for delivering an amazing video, loved working with you 💗
I forgot how much the disbandment of Iz*one hurt. I started ugly crying halfway through the video. It was also such a hard time in my life so their disbandment brings back so many horrible memories. Life was so much better when Iz*one was together.
Some random "what if..." questions that came into my mind What would've happened if they had a 7 year contract? What would've happened if they were under YG, JYP or SM? What if La Vie en Rose would've stayed as a song for CLC and not become IZ*ONE's debut song? Which song would they've debuted with?
I honestly thought the contract extension was going to happen, like everyone loved them, I personally wasn't a big fan, but I would always tune in for their releases, is just crazy that it didn't even matter how succesful they were, their agencies just wanted them back to cash out from them, it's so sad, also, I've noticed lately that "disbandment comebacks" are no longer a thing, like groups disband out of nowhere nowadays without a final goodbye, I wish that would stop, it is easier to digest a disbandment when a final goodbye release happens, I wish companies can start doing that again if a group is going to end
No other group comes close to IZ*ONE. Their chemistry together, the many memories and moments shared with WIZ*ONEs... the sheer love and dedication... it's unlike any I've seen before. Proud to be a WIZ*ONE and happily supporting all 12 girls in their own paths ❤ but yes, I'm holding out a thin rope of hope of an OT12 reunion... some time in the future. Thank you for this video!
Something not related to IZone yet weird is that despite the pandemic FNC still tried to have fan meetings for their latest boygroup P1harmony (yeah they’re known to overwork them and ruin Soul’s potential). I mean FNC Ent already Ruined their two girl groups AOA and Cherry Bullet (especially when they should’ve had a comeback right after GP999 but didn’t) so their new Japanese girl group Prikil could be next.
Dang the intro of the rigging scandal seemed like it was from a horror movie except u were watching only to find out about the scandal and X1’s disbandment
My heart goes out to all Wizones for being an amazing fandom. IZ One was a victim as well: getting their reputation dragged in the mud since they too had no idea of the rigged voting. Your video was so awesome I was sick recently and to feel better watched your previous videos on Dia and IOI to get up to speed on events leading to IZ One debut to understand your video Better, Jihoons Carat 😊✌️
I’m still devastated for stanning them late despite of following the girls since pd48 i became their casual listener during their debut yr since my pick (gaeun) didn’t make it, and truly stan them before fiestas postpone 😢
it’s insane that the group’s fandom was powerful enough to almost relaunch an entire group, i was never an iz*one stan but i knew them and how big they were so it sucks that they basically got the run around with their time as a group but looking on the bright side, most of the girls are very successful now in their respective groups snd solo careers and are beginning to reach their potential, the produce series scandal really did mess a lot of things up as well
Great video! I remember the parallel universe project and I had hoped that it would've been successful as izone is one of my ult groups. but I already knew there was no way in hell starship was about to let wonyoung go. I'm still sad about their disbandment but I am glad that the members are still successful in their separate endeavors!
Also, during the hiatus, the fandom organized a hashtag event everyday during the hole hiatus (almost 2.5 months), where almost every hashtag trended on twitter.
also wanted to added that Parallel universe project, its not on the record, but the people in project that being a bridge on between intl wizone and kwizone telling us that PUP actually there is another intention behind it and it would been a started of a revolution on Kpop scene,, we did thinking that for a while since 2020 when we got no anything on the member when they are in hiatus.. so through PUP we also wanted to make a FANDOM AGENCIES for all kpop fandom so FANDOM can also supervise their idol company on treathing the idol member, and it would be also benefit both fandom and the idol because all this time, fandom and idol got nothing on the company and the monopoly is too much, all fans do just tweeting raging mentioning them online or emailing the company even tho we all know it just goona be ignored, so through PUP fandom atleast have some power on the law with the agencies when things happen, let say what happen to LOONA CHUU, she has to fight alone BBC for her salary, if the project are success Orbit or Loona fandom can asking to the Fandom agencies to get help and sue the BBC and get the justice to the members, thats what also the intention of the project.. so we fandom have to get our rights as a fan and as a person who "invested" to the idol and make our favorite idol what their deserve.. if you still dont get it, imagine like this, you are as "a mother" who drop your kids(as idol) into a school and then the school or the teacher "the company" are abusing your kids in the school, what would you do if that happens? there is no way you would just doing nothing right? and in many asia country, in each school they have a system called "Parent Association" and that parent association was the other goal of this PU project, but in the end all of those word up there just gonna stay as idea from wizone and would never gonna be happen in any time.. well, hopefully in the future we could achives that through other fandom that would be doing what we wizone doing on PUP.. fighting everyone!
I miss our girls so much.. They're the first group I really stanned from predebut. Still mad they didn't have an extension just because Starship didn't agree
Izone being the last produce group before disbanding while breaking major records left and right and if they had a contract extension will break even more, and wizones gaining more than enough money to relaunch/extend izone is more than enough reason that both izone and wizones will both go down in kpop history
God damn, why the hell am I sobbing as I'm watching this. I miss the 12 of them being together. Every. Freaking. Day. I deeply regret stanning them late as their last 2 comebacks were the ones I witnessed as a fan. Their music was with me through hard times even until now. I will forever be a Wiz*one. Thank you Iz*One, I will never forget you.
I mean, they managed I.O.I much worse than IZ*ONE. I genuinely don't get what people are complaining about. Thank you for the amazing video though, as per usual! Love your works!
Itzy wasn’t always girl crush. They had teen crush until they went to girl crush with mafia in the morning. If it wasn’t for IZ*One we wouldn’t see more elegant concepts from smaller groups and more smaller and medium groups.
So where did all those millions of dollars go through the project? I don’t understand what the money would have been used for aside from marketing and paying someone to negotiate
Since the project didn’t go through, the money got refunded to all the donors. This money was supposed to kick of the group again and hopefully get them a company (like was happening with CJ E&M) but since things didn’t go according to plan, the money was returned
Saving this to watch on the bus in the morning. I was a strong supporter of the PUP and was very up to date with it (unfortunately donations weren’t international) and I didn’t truly cry about the disbandment until… August? Because it was then that we knew the PUP hadn’t worked. God, I bet this video is going to bring back A LOT of feelings tomorrow.
I don't even know if I am the only one thinking this, but I just want to say I really love your video editing style! I always enjoy watching your videos (obviously for the topics) but you also manage to capture my whole attention visual-wise. Small moments like when you started talking about 4th Gen and used the elevator opening scene from Itzys Dalla Dalla as a transition or when you put the screenshots regarding the voting manipulation articles with that orchestra song (everyone knows the song , but I don't know the title). I really really appreciate the effort you put into making your videos visually appealing and fun to watch. Your doing a great job! ✨
10:50 Yeah, no lmao. CLC's direction from 2017 was more so a 4minute rehash, they weren't >mainly< inspired by BP. They shouldn't be there. Neither should EXID. They both were more sexy than girl crush.
I am not saying they are trying to be BlackPink.. I think you missed the point. My point was that girl crush, sexy and more dark concepts took over. Almost all of the groups I mentioned there had a completely different concept before the release shown. CLC, Gugudan, Weki Meki, Pristin.
@@jihoonscarat I didn't say anything about you implying them wanting to be BP?? Again, CLC's change was unrelated and happened in 2017. They're not a good example, that's all I'm saying.
CLC released Hobgoblin in 2017 yes, however then went back to their cute and soft concept and then picked it back up. Their most popular era is without a doubt Black Dress and No.
@@jihoonscarat yeah cause No was the only song where they had a music show win (2 wins from the show) I feel like Pentagon will also be the same way and disband with only two wins in their career
I hope that company and the ex-izone member (but not really the member mostly to the company) who didn't agreed to extend their contract feel guilt. I was one of the wiz*one the hoped for an extension with the fund raising etc. And I was devastated when I heard that it will not be happening that time
I was not saying they were trying to be like BlackPink, but more showing a point that they were a group that was also doing that concept 😌 before BadBoy and Peek A Boo they had focused mostly and heavily on their “RED” concept
Still obsessed with Fiesta (because of it being performed in the latest Produce 101 Japan). I appreciated it quite late because I never truly enjoyed Izone’s music because of the issue.
I've been a kpop stan since 2nd or 3rd gen (im a casual listener in 2nd gen but became a loyal fan of EXO, TWICE and others). But nothing had me sticking as much as IZONE. I've watched produce because its interesting, the idea of akb48 being in a survival show with Koreans reeled me in. I was right because it was hilarious and mad entertaining ❤ when Izone happened I kinda got busy but after Violeta I came back and Fiesta happened ❤ Izone is such a great group chemistry wise so I end up watching their contents every day. I got attached and I still see them as a group until now. im a Lesserafim fan now but i have to admit it wasn't the same. I like Lesserafim but IZONE was guaranteed smile whenever i watch them.
I'll always be proud to have been a fan from the very first teasers of PD48. I had IZ*ONE while I was in college growing a large group of close friends, and for me the group represents a very special time in my life. At the same time that they disbanded, I had recently started on a new path away from all but one of my friends. I can relate to their struggles, their separation, and their continued efforts to stay in contact with each other. I'll always be proud of IZ*ONE and WIZ*ONEs collective efforts 💛🧡
what is magical about IZONE isnt just how insane of group they are but how well they are all doing individualy post- disbandment. they are all doing great in their area and didnt just vanish afterwards
There are grateful and chaotic times during the disbandment to the PUP timeline like, there are increasingly people who disregards and look down at the groups of j-line (akb,hkt) just for the desperate reboot. Although despite those negative moments, pup shows how iz*one is a powerful group even aki-p himself donated on pup. AKS/Verna would probably still agree on the extension anyway (prolly as kennin member). SS might have planned IVE all the way long before, since how annyeongz is so popular and powerful that an agreement to the contract extension wouldn't be needed.
I one makes me sad bc I came into K-pop first in 2021, and they weren’t on my radar at all more or less. It’s too bad bc they’re really my taste, the group seems to have lovely chemistry and are very talented, but I can’t get into their music or content, bc I’m too aware that they’re not around and it just makes me sad. I find temporary group so cruel in general. The reason I have not listened to Kepler is that I just have the feeling of “they’re gonna disband soon anyway, so why get invested”. It must be so emotional for the girls aswell. Not to mention how it must be so stressful to know you’ll maybe leave this successful group but struggle to find it again bc you didn’t have the time to build up a *personal* fandom yet. Going from 1 artist to 12 when they split is a lot for a general audience to get invested in. Idk, tldr I don’t like the concept of temporary groups and I wish they would’ve gotten more time together
This wasn't going to happen unfortunately. I think the members' companies were still salty over mnet (and some of them) being indicted for rigging the group, wanted to cut ties. and distance themselves from the scandal and each other.
How did ppl have an issue w Yuri being in the line up. I would be like idont care how popular or not she was if she WAS rigged this is a time it makes sense and seh deserves it bc i cant imagine the world not getting to hear her outstanding vocals
YESS THE NEW VIDEO LETS GOOOO great job!💙💙 will edit this comment when I finish it! :) Edit: Forgot to edit!! no! oh my god!! My final thoughts on the matter is that it’s really crazy how if wizone succeeded with the project we wouldn’t have LESSSERAFIM or IVE as we know them, and knowing how things have gone since Iz*one disbanded I think no one thought about how it could actually be the best case scenario, that they would just disband to make a way to the groups they now call home I know when you love a group you want it to last forever but sometimes looking at things critically you gotta know where to stop as well Anyway, just my thoughts uwu thanks again for the video!! Edit2: I got hyperfixated on AKB48 over the past months,,, so, yeah, another reason for me to think that we were actually lucky that they are over, Hitomi looks so happy as the new great AKB center and I'm so happy for her
I had to pause less than a minute in and comment on the clear upgrade in quality. a super nice intro!!! Having followed for awhile it always makes me smile when I notice the small improvements in your videos!
Wonyoung can stop world hunger, and the haters would still call her a pick me girl for no reason" Meanwhile if another K-pop idol does it, they would be praised. Leave poor Wony alone. Why are you calling her pick me and attention seeker. Is it because she's pretty?
as someone who didn't get into iz*one (since I wasn't listening to kpop actively at the time) until 2020 shortly before fiesta came out, I was confused as to why we were talking about the teaser for fiesta in october of 2019 and then i was like "ooooh this is when the voting scandal induced hiatus takes place huh"
I wonder if the contracts some of the 48 girls had with their home groups prevented them from continuing linger than was originally agreed.(I hope not, but sadly 48 management tend to do things like that) since they couldn't be contacted
I kind of wish that IZ*ONE did get a small extension. At least an extra six months. They never got to have a final good-bye concert in front of wizones in person due to the pandemic. I’m convinced it would’ve happened, but I’m sure starship was the company that refused. They don’t even allow Wonyoung and Yujin to interact too much with the other ex-IZ*ONE members or mention the group. They also lost a lot of time due to the rigging scandal that put them on a small hiatus.
F’real
Yujin mentioned izone in earth arcade a lot. Yujin and wonyoung always interact with the members whenever they see them, especially with chaewon yena Eunbi and yuri
If they announce that ONE REELER will be their last album, i can guarantee the sales will be much higher...
Earth Arcade is a diffrent situation because There was Na PD and Starship wont even dare to do or say anything with Na PD @@Useri77u7u7
Wizones are scary that they got that powerful and got that far. 😳
Update on Nako: She’s graduating from HKT48 to become an actress
I made that note in the video 😉
Nako just announced not really graduating until spring 2023
@@arhamislami1910 she is still is graduating. Her graduation concert would be on spring 2023 but her final theater performance still haven't decided on yet.
Wizones are the most loyal fandom in Kpop. Kwizones alone were willing to donate 3 million USD just to keep the group alive. 23k Wizones donated an average of over 100 bucks for the parallel universe project. If they had expanded to J Wizones and C Wizones, they probably could of gotten 6 million USD or even more.
Oh my god, I had no idea about the Parallel Universe project. The fact that the fandom came so close to relaunching the group, only to have CJ stall it in the end...damn. Every time I think I'm done being sad about IZ*ONE some new info comes out and I'm devastated again. I miss them
RIGHT SAME, the parallel universe project just made me more sad😭😭😭
If anyone is wondering most of the companies actually agreed to the idea of contract extension Yuehua, 8D, Urban Works, AKB48, WM, Woollim, Stone Music were onboard except Wonyoung and Yujin’s company Starship. They knew if they pulled them out and make IVE they would have big bank.
This seems very much realistic. especially since IVE debuted really quickly after iz*ones disbanded
Dang, so Ive debuted at the expense of iz*one's disbandment? idk how to feel about it, both were and are truly amazing
@@tan8802 starshit was kinda selfish for that tho.. personally they should have done what wonyoung and yujin wanted.. but they wanted to keep them :(
@@zzerorbit im just wondering, what if they actually wanted to further their career otherwise? we dont know what wony and yujin truly wanted in the end. But yeah its clear starship was decided on debuting ive at the expense of Iz*one's success for sure
@@homohyuck all the members said they wanted to become, during each members birthday they would wish for iz*one to stay one
IZ*ONE is my ultimate group, and one of the first I ever got into. You did an amazing job covering their history, Thank you so much!
Thank you so much for watching 💕💕
During the hiatus, all Wiz*ones participate in the hashtag event on twitter..everyday a new hashtag was made, almost every hashtag was trending ..even when it was so emotionally taxing, seeing and participating in the events made me so proud that i am a wiz*one..
Yes, I wished this part of the story was told, since this is about "the power of Iz*ones fandom". Those hastags was the only thing that kept Wiz*ones connected thru Iz*ones hiatus. When SECRET STORY OF THE SWAN debuted I was really moved by the hashtags that was used in part of its debut....
I am THIS close to ugly sobbing. I miss them. I see them everyday, but I still somehow miss them. They were, and will always be my #1 gg. I love all the new projects that have come after their disbandment to pieces, but none will ever hold a candle to the original in my heart. My 12 shining stars
It’s terrible that starship is getting just what they wanted by disbanding izone- a LOT of $$$
The ending of parallel universe project made me cry. It was so so sad. I saw our fandom completely deflate on that day in April. There was hope but in the back of our minds, we knew. It was sick how they watched us donate, campaign, tweet, promote this project but then just ripped it away. Wiz raised 3 million USD….with each wizone donating around 100 usd. That’s incredible. Wizone were dedicated and loved the girls. We still support the girls in their post Izone groups but if I’m being 100% honest, it will never replicate the love I had for my 12 girls. I miss them. We never got that goodbye concert. We never got that goodbye album. We saw chaewon and others completely break down, I mean the girl was HYPERVENTILATING. It was SICK.
all fandoms are great but we (WIZ*ONE) have amazing stories & memories that other fandoms may not experience. everyday we still imagine these 12 girls always singing & dancing together on stage, we love them so much 💕
I still am and will forever be salty we didn't get a disbandment album that we knew would be their last
Tbh there wasn’t enough time but Panarama is about being sad they have to disband without saying it directly in the song
@@gwenmloveskpopandmore I think they could have pulled it off if they'd cared, but the least they could have done when promoting one reeler was be like, 'btw this is the last song xoxo'
@@Fallphoenix18 yeah but then it probably would’ve made them more upset at the time
@@aLi.CWnpop Tbh I think we all knew, especially with the lyrics, but it would have been nice for WakeOne to do the bare minimum
i'm still salty that we didn't get the official version of parallel universe and lesson
within the first 10 minutes, they raised $700,000?! OH MY LORD that is insane power
Man, I knew the rigging was shameless, but it was so damn shameless.
I sadly arrived late to the IZ*ONE train, but I really do love the work that they did. I'm a huge fan of Yena's current work and can't wait to see what comes next
🚆
Also about PD101 Rip to the two S2 contestants Jeong Joongi and Lee Jihan who are in heaven now hope they fly high. 🌹👼🏻🪦
Lee jihan died in the itaewon tragedy right?
@@johnlabu1154 yep and Jeong Joongi took his own life unfortunately
I don't care about produce scandals, I love izone, their chemistry in the group is unmatched, their reality shows are so good
Its still so crazy how relevant Izone is till now even though they disbanded years ago. They were still used as the standard as for GGs (not even an exaggeration and not even my opinion). Their concept is so remarkable that if a group tried to that kind of concept theyll be immediately called as a plagiarist, they ate and served so much that.
Insteresting fascinating informative video on the history and career of the talented Girl Group I*ZONE
I had never heard of "fandom funding a group" projects before. Without being mean, it sounds as realistically feasible as tumblr crowdfunding a convention haha
a lot of smaller kpop groups usually crowdfund their comebacks. it's not anything new, it was just the first time an already successful group with such a large fandom size had it done before
Usually, it's small companies that do crowdfunding to fund combacks and albums for a group they manage.
@@districtdalsoyeah but most of the time those crowdfunded groups don’t have a good outcome
I’m so happy that Chaeyeon finally made her solo debut!! She deserves all the love for her new solo ❤️
Her solo debut is so good. One of my favourites from the post IZONE solos! I can’t wait to see what she does next
@@jihoonscarat she slayed ✨
Yeah, WIZ*ONEs are not so sad because of the disbandment, but more of the way it happened. It's great the girls are doing great now, but neither them nor us deserved such a farewell. The lost time because of the scandal could have easily been used for another comeback and (hopefully full length) album. Both of the unreleased songs + whatever was in the works would would complete the "ONE" era of the group and become a graceful and somewhat bearable goodbye to the fans. Now we're constantly stuck in a loop missing them and dreaming of something impossible...
Iz one was awesome, and I think they shouldve at least gotten an extension to make up for the lost time, and they should’ve gotten to say goodbye in an in person concert. The saddest thing for me is that we know the girls themselves wanted to stay together, and they’ve all talked about how much they miss each other and I think its so sad they had to be separated. I think the girls should at least be allowed a reunion concert or tour at some point, they should be reunited and allowed to give a proper goodbye to their fans
"they had no intentions of messing with the final lineup" right... 🤡
😂 biggest lie i have heard
@@jihoonscarat yeah each season was rigged especially season 4 and GP999 basically S5
No, you guys, you don't understand, they accidentally rigged the votes for companies that also accidentally may have paid them 👉👈
Ok but there were three *iz albums and only two one- albums. I think there should’ve been atleast 1 more album. Idk.
This was an amazing video! Iz*one really made an impact in such a short time and I'm happy to say I was with them from beginning to the end
Yeah although in Panarama they talk about how sad they are they have to disband without directly mentioning it
Yayyy!! Welcome back!! I’m so glad ur doing a vid on IZ*One!! ❤️ About the produce scandal The producers of Produce were so stupid. They ruined things for people who were supposed to debut in S2, S3, and especially S4. Knowing what they did was wrong.I’m glad Japan knows how to not rig things. My fave songs by Izone are La Vi En Rose, Fiesta, You & I, Secret Story Of The Swan, and Panarama.
I don't want to seem rude or anything, but there's this question I've been wanting to ask you a long time ago. Why don't you write your entire thoughts in one comment instead of spamming the comment section with countless ones? If I didn't knew better I would think these channels are being spammed by bots.
@@precious8129 because I want them to know what I’m thinking that’s related.
@@precious8129 however I have to put different things each time so I have more different thoughts than the last one
Well technically Girls Planet is season 5 And Boys Planet is technically gonna be Season 6 🤫 Although it’s nice to know PD101 is still going strong in Japan after knowing what happened in Korea and China.
woohoo, so excited to finally see this video being brought to life !! thank you for working with me and for delivering an amazing video, loved working with you 💗
Thank you for all your hard work! I really appreciate it and I had so much fun 👏🏻💕💕
Thanks for your hardworks Queens
I forgot how much the disbandment of Iz*one hurt. I started ugly crying halfway through the video. It was also such a hard time in my life so their disbandment brings back so many horrible memories. Life was so much better when Iz*one was together.
Some random "what if..." questions that came into my mind
What would've happened if they had a 7 year contract?
What would've happened if they were under YG, JYP or SM?
What if La Vie en Rose would've stayed as a song for CLC and not become IZ*ONE's debut song? Which song would they've debuted with?
Probably similar to LightSum’s Vivace
@@gwenmloveskpopandmore true
@@purpledreamcatcher they have the same producer so if Izone wasn’t disbanded they (Izone) probably would’ve gotten that song as a comeback
@@gwenmloveskpopandmore i can see them performing this
I honestly thought the contract extension was going to happen, like everyone loved them, I personally wasn't a big fan, but I would always tune in for their releases, is just crazy that it didn't even matter how succesful they were, their agencies just wanted them back to cash out from them, it's so sad, also, I've noticed lately that "disbandment comebacks" are no longer a thing, like groups disband out of nowhere nowadays without a final goodbye, I wish that would stop, it is easier to digest a disbandment when a final goodbye release happens, I wish companies can start doing that again if a group is going to end
No other group comes close to IZ*ONE. Their chemistry together, the many memories and moments shared with WIZ*ONEs... the sheer love and dedication... it's unlike any I've seen before. Proud to be a WIZ*ONE and happily supporting all 12 girls in their own paths ❤ but yes, I'm holding out a thin rope of hope of an OT12 reunion... some time in the future. Thank you for this video!
like Iz*one , all of their songs were such bops , thanks for the video
Something not related to IZone yet weird is that despite the pandemic FNC still tried to have fan meetings for their latest boygroup P1harmony (yeah they’re known to overwork them and ruin Soul’s potential). I mean FNC Ent already Ruined their two girl groups AOA and Cherry Bullet (especially when they should’ve had a comeback right after GP999 but didn’t) so their new Japanese girl group Prikil could be next.
Dang the intro of the rigging scandal seemed like it was from a horror movie except u were watching only to find out about the scandal and X1’s disbandment
you can see the effort put into these videos
the scripts are so high-quality!!
My heart goes out to all Wizones for being an amazing fandom. IZ One was a victim as well: getting their reputation dragged in the mud since they too had no idea of the rigged voting. Your video was so awesome I was sick recently and to feel better watched your previous videos on Dia and IOI to get up to speed on events leading to IZ One debut to understand your video Better, Jihoons Carat 😊✌️
TELL A FRIEND TO TELL A FRIENNNDDD SHES BAAACKKK WELCOME BACK
Now we need Chaennie Lisoo to come back
I’m still devastated for stanning them late despite of following the girls since pd48
i became their casual listener during their debut yr since my pick (gaeun) didn’t make it, and truly stan them before fiestas postpone 😢
I’m glad a member of IZ*ONE is now in Le Sserafim (a group I equally love)
2 members! Chaewon and Sakura! and me too I love Le Sserafim so much and I’m so happy they both got to continue into a great group
I feel like we should've had a 2nd full album to end the Oneiric series
Fiesta was their best comeback and it was tainted. But I’m glad that they came back strong and was shown how much the fans love them
it’s insane that the group’s fandom was powerful enough to almost relaunch an entire group, i was never an iz*one stan but i knew them and how big they were so it sucks that they basically got the run around with their time as a group but looking on the bright side, most of the girls are very successful now in their respective groups snd solo careers and are beginning to reach their potential, the produce series scandal really did mess a lot of things up as well
Great video! I remember the parallel universe project and I had hoped that it would've been successful as izone is one of my ult groups. but I already knew there was no way in hell starship was about to let wonyoung go. I'm still sad about their disbandment but I am glad that the members are still successful in their separate endeavors!
I love how long these videos are. So so so much better than the 8-10 minute videos most other channels pump out every few days
Thank you so much I really appreciate it 😭
Also, during the hiatus, the fandom organized a hashtag event everyday during the hole hiatus (almost 2.5 months), where almost every hashtag trended on twitter.
also wanted to added that Parallel universe project, its not on the record, but the people in project that being a bridge on between intl wizone and kwizone telling us that PUP actually there is another intention behind it and it would been a started of a revolution on Kpop scene,, we did thinking that for a while since 2020 when we got no anything on the member when they are in hiatus.. so through PUP we also wanted to make a FANDOM AGENCIES for all kpop fandom so FANDOM can also supervise their idol company on treathing the idol member, and it would be also benefit both fandom and the idol because all this time, fandom and idol got nothing on the company and the monopoly is too much, all fans do just tweeting raging mentioning them online or emailing the company even tho we all know it just goona be ignored, so through PUP fandom atleast have some power on the law with the agencies when things happen, let say what happen to LOONA CHUU, she has to fight alone BBC for her salary, if the project are success Orbit or Loona fandom can asking to the Fandom agencies to get help and sue the BBC and get the justice to the members, thats what also the intention of the project.. so we fandom have to get our rights as a fan and as a person who "invested" to the idol and make our favorite idol what their deserve.. if you still dont get it, imagine like this, you are as "a mother" who drop your kids(as idol) into a school and then the school or the teacher "the company" are abusing your kids in the school, what would you do if that happens? there is no way you would just doing nothing right? and in many asia country, in each school they have a system called "Parent Association" and that parent association was the other goal of this PU project, but in the end all of those word up there just gonna stay as idea from wizone and would never gonna be happen in any time.. well, hopefully in the future we could achives that through other fandom that would be doing what we wizone doing on PUP.. fighting everyone!
I miss our girls so much.. They're the first group I really stanned from predebut. Still mad they didn't have an extension just because Starship didn't agree
Izone being the last produce group before disbanding while breaking major records left and right and if they had a contract extension will break even more, and wizones gaining more than enough money to relaunch/extend izone is more than enough reason that both izone and wizones will both go down in kpop history
Iz*one has been in my feed again these days and I miss them so much 😭
Wizone power forever~ we can only pray for a reunion stage one day the earth might implode
Let’s hope! Both IOI and Wanna One have had reunions so there is hope 👏🏻
Two of my favourite UA-camrs making a video about one of my favourite groups 🥳
God damn, why the hell am I sobbing as I'm watching this. I miss the 12 of them being together. Every. Freaking. Day. I deeply regret stanning them late as their last 2 comebacks were the ones I witnessed as a fan. Their music was with me through hard times even until now. I will forever be a Wiz*one. Thank you Iz*One, I will never forget you.
Always enjoy your videos. Thanks for the work you put into them.
CLC and Gugudan deserved better 😞😔 We didn’t know at the time Gugudan’s disbandment song would be not that type at the time :(
Do I know most about IZ*one?
*yes*
Am I going to watch an hour documentary about them?
*YES*
Thanks for making this video, they are always so informative and I can get to know more about the gorups I like
I mean, they managed I.O.I much worse than IZ*ONE. I genuinely don't get what people are complaining about.
Thank you for the amazing video though, as per usual! Love your works!
Yeah since IOI was the 1st group and fromis had to go on hiatus because of Izone but then both groups because of the produce scandal
Itzy wasn’t always girl crush. They had teen crush until they went to girl crush with mafia in the morning. If it wasn’t for IZ*One we wouldn’t see more elegant concepts from smaller groups and more smaller and medium groups.
Teen crush and girl crush go hand in hand in the point I was making in the video ☺️
@@jihoonscarat yess!!
So where did all those millions of dollars go through the project? I don’t understand what the money would have been used for aside from marketing and paying someone to negotiate
Since the project didn’t go through, the money got refunded to all the donors. This money was supposed to kick of the group again and hopefully get them a company (like was happening with CJ E&M) but since things didn’t go according to plan, the money was returned
Saving this to watch on the bus in the morning. I was a strong supporter of the PUP and was very up to date with it (unfortunately donations weren’t international) and I didn’t truly cry about the disbandment until… August? Because it was then that we knew the PUP hadn’t worked. God, I bet this video is going to bring back A LOT of feelings tomorrow.
Watching this bc I stan le sserafim lol
Who else cried while watching this?
23:00 “quick guys, let’s act surprised…” the tea of it all…
I don't even know if I am the only one thinking this, but I just want to say I really love your video editing style! I always enjoy watching your videos (obviously for the topics) but you also manage to capture my whole attention visual-wise. Small moments like when you started talking about 4th Gen and used the elevator opening scene from Itzys Dalla Dalla as a transition or when you put the screenshots regarding the voting manipulation articles with that orchestra song (everyone knows the song , but I don't know the title). I really really appreciate the effort you put into making your videos visually appealing and fun to watch. Your doing a great job! ✨
Thank you so much. I am so happy to hear that 😭❤️
^^^^this^^^^
Also PD101S6 is coming AKA BP999 lol 😂
I think this vv well made good job
10:50 Yeah, no lmao. CLC's direction from 2017 was more so a 4minute rehash, they weren't >mainly< inspired by BP. They shouldn't be there. Neither should EXID. They both were more sexy than girl crush.
I am not saying they are trying to be BlackPink.. I think you missed the point. My point was that girl crush, sexy and more dark concepts took over. Almost all of the groups I mentioned there had a completely different concept before the release shown. CLC, Gugudan, Weki Meki, Pristin.
@@jihoonscarat I didn't say anything about you implying them wanting to be BP?? Again, CLC's change was unrelated and happened in 2017. They're not a good example, that's all I'm saying.
CLC released Hobgoblin in 2017 yes, however then went back to their cute and soft concept and then picked it back up. Their most popular era is without a doubt Black Dress and No.
@@jihoonscarat yeah cause No was the only song where they had a music show win (2 wins from the show) I feel like Pentagon will also be the same way and disband with only two wins in their career
@@jihoonscarat Hobogoblin was what made their international fandom base grow and black dress was a hit internationally yet cube did absolutely nothing
I hope that company and the ex-izone member (but not really the member mostly to the company) who didn't agreed to extend their contract feel guilt. I was one of the wiz*one the hoped for an extension with the fund raising etc. And I was devastated when I heard that it will not be happening that time
I don't believe red velvet is a good example of blackpinkification of kpop as their concept was always red and velvet even in there debut
I was not saying they were trying to be like BlackPink, but more showing a point that they were a group that was also doing that concept 😌 before BadBoy and Peek A Boo they had focused mostly and heavily on their “RED” concept
Still obsessed with Fiesta (because of it being performed in the latest Produce 101 Japan). I appreciated it quite late because I never truly enjoyed Izone’s music because of the issue.
I've been a kpop stan since 2nd or 3rd gen (im a casual listener in 2nd gen but became a loyal fan of EXO, TWICE and others). But nothing had me sticking as much as IZONE. I've watched produce because its interesting, the idea of akb48 being in a survival show with Koreans reeled me in. I was right because it was hilarious and mad entertaining ❤ when Izone happened I kinda got busy but after Violeta I came back and Fiesta happened ❤ Izone is such a great group chemistry wise so I end up watching their contents every day. I got attached and I still see them as a group until now. im a Lesserafim fan now but i have to admit it wasn't the same. I like Lesserafim but IZONE was guaranteed smile whenever i watch them.
I'll always be proud to have been a fan from the very first teasers of PD48. I had IZ*ONE while I was in college growing a large group of close friends, and for me the group represents a very special time in my life. At the same time that they disbanded, I had recently started on a new path away from all but one of my friends. I can relate to their struggles, their separation, and their continued efforts to stay in contact with each other. I'll always be proud of IZ*ONE and WIZ*ONEs collective efforts 💛🧡
Hitomi already graduate from AKB. I miss IZONE so much.
What an amazing essay❤
not me crying while watching this cuz i miss them so much
Now all we can ask for is a reunion and maybe a single with it.
what is magical about IZONE isnt just how insane of group they are but how well they are all doing individualy post- disbandment. they are all doing great in their area and didnt just vanish afterwards
There are grateful and chaotic times during the disbandment to the PUP timeline like, there are increasingly people who disregards and look down at the groups of j-line (akb,hkt) just for the desperate reboot. Although despite those negative moments, pup shows how iz*one is a powerful group even aki-p himself donated on pup. AKS/Verna would probably still agree on the extension anyway (prolly as kennin member). SS might have planned IVE all the way long before, since how annyeongz is so popular and powerful that an agreement to the contract extension wouldn't be needed.
I one makes me sad bc I came into K-pop first in 2021, and they weren’t on my radar at all more or less. It’s too bad bc they’re really my taste, the group seems to have lovely chemistry and are very talented, but I can’t get into their music or content, bc I’m too aware that they’re not around and it just makes me sad.
I find temporary group so cruel in general. The reason I have not listened to Kepler is that I just have the feeling of “they’re gonna disband soon anyway, so why get invested”. It must be so emotional for the girls aswell.
Not to mention how it must be so stressful to know you’ll maybe leave this successful group but struggle to find it again bc you didn’t have the time to build up a *personal* fandom yet. Going from 1 artist to 12 when they split is a lot for a general audience to get invested in.
Idk, tldr I don’t like the concept of temporary groups and I wish they would’ve gotten more time together
This wasn't going to happen unfortunately. I think the members' companies were still salty over mnet (and some of them) being indicted for rigging the group, wanted to cut ties. and distance themselves from the scandal and each other.
How did ppl have an issue w Yuri being in the line up. I would be like idont care how popular or not she was if she WAS rigged this is a time it makes sense and seh deserves it bc i cant imagine the world not getting to hear her outstanding vocals
YESS THE NEW VIDEO LETS GOOOO
great job!💙💙 will edit this comment when I finish it! :)
Edit: Forgot to edit!! no! oh my god!!
My final thoughts on the matter is that it’s really crazy how if wizone succeeded with the project we wouldn’t have LESSSERAFIM or IVE as we know them, and knowing how things have gone since Iz*one disbanded I think no one thought about how it could actually be the best case scenario, that they would just disband to make a way to the groups they now call home
I know when you love a group you want it to last forever but sometimes looking at things critically you gotta know where to stop as well
Anyway, just my thoughts uwu
thanks again for the video!!
Edit2: I got hyperfixated on AKB48 over the past months,,, so, yeah, another reason for me to think that we were actually lucky that they are over, Hitomi looks so happy as the new great AKB center and I'm so happy for her
Would you make a video about the story of X1 and how the groups after the disbandment of X1 affected them?
Parallel universe was shut down by Starship saying no to continue :'
The best group from produce serieeeesss!
slayyyyyyyyy izONE FOREVERRR YASSS IZONE FOREVEERR WOOOOO WIZONE WOOOP WOOP
MY GIRLS
jihoons carat is back & made a video about my ult group iz*one !! i’m blessed.
Thanks for all your hard work on this!
IZ*ONE Forever
I had to pause less than a minute in and comment on the clear upgrade in quality. a super nice intro!!! Having followed for awhile it always makes me smile when I notice the small improvements in your videos!
Thank you so much. I really appreciate hearing that ❤️
Wonyoung can stop world hunger, and the haters would still call her a pick me girl for no reason" Meanwhile if another K-pop idol does it, they would be praised. Leave poor Wony alone. Why are you calling her pick me and attention seeker. Is it because she's pretty?
I'm still in denial tbh 😭
Omg
as someone who didn't get into iz*one (since I wasn't listening to kpop actively at the time) until 2020 shortly before fiesta came out, I was confused as to why we were talking about the teaser for fiesta in october of 2019 and then i was like "ooooh this is when the voting scandal induced hiatus takes place huh"
Reminds me of Kep1er. 🧐
I wonder if the contracts some of the 48 girls had with their home groups prevented them from continuing linger than was originally agreed.(I hope not, but sadly 48 management tend to do things like that) since they couldn't be contacted
17:13 I keep seeing this as a news source, what UA-cam channel and/or news station is it from?
I guess they had to say their Goodb*iz 🥲