this clip is absolutely amazing. when the doctor and rose say goodbye i cant help but cry. the chemistry between them is strong and beautiful. its chemistry that most people hope to find someday.
I can't get over how well this is made. When the doctor's screaming at the dalek to kill him and the music builds and then it flashes to when he loses Rose.... it gets me every time. FANTASTIC job.
Wow!! It's been a while since I've watched a music video of the Doctor and Rose that has made me sob as hard as I just did, but this one did it! I absolutely love it! It was perfection!
To name just a few (of my numerous) fave parts... 00:33 "you're presence still lingers here", 2:30 blending the two scenes together with the fireworks and the build up (the lovely "though you're still with me") to the powerful climax of the song/vid with the doctor pounding his chest to the drums kicking in which was just... wow, I mean, WOW. So perfect, so powerful.
That was absolutely lovely. I've seen these scenes so often I've gotten a bit hardened to them, but this video made me want to cry all over again. Brilliant.
OMG, I just cried like a baby watching this. This video was incredible and was put together beautifully. Thank you for making this. It has left me in awe.
It was fairly tedious to make this one. It took 3 weeks to produce from scratch. Putting quite a few hours in each day after work. Exhausting, but i am so glad i didn't rush this one. xx :) Glad you enjoyed it.
Oh my God. I was totally sobbing by the time he said "I lost her", but when he told the Dalek to 'just take care of him' I lost it. Favorited and 5 stars. Wow.
totally agree! and seduff fit it so well with the music (it sort of built up after that bit) and then it shows him loosing rose... ooohh it gave me shivers.
that song may be used alot but that is BY FAR the best usage of it I have EVER seen! It was brilliant! The part where the band kicks in and the doctor is shouting....goosbumps! Excellent video!
Just amazing, so well done, I love how you used the ninth doctor early in the song and tenth later on. It just showed so well the whole relationship between the doctor and rose. Just loved it. BRILLIANT!!!
Liyrah: Thanks so much for your comment. I am really pleased to hear that you enjoyed it and warmed (at least a little) more towards Rose's character. I think all the companions are brilliant, but as she was there from the start of the new series and through the doctors regeneration she will probably always hold a special place fro me. :) Thanks again x
itsmeyall : Thankyou so much. You comment has a very valid point... My videos would be nothing without the wonderful portrayal of the Doctor by David Tennant. His emotions are so raw. Just amazing. He and Billie had such a wonderful chemistry together. x
What words can describe what I felt and saw, watching this video. It's absolutely amazing. The doctor's pain just seeped right on through my computer screen. 5 STARS!
I'm not even sure what to say about this video. It's breathtaking and absolutely made me tear up. That moment you put in where he's yelling at the Dalek to just kill him, UGh, with the music and DT's acting and just....the doctor just seems so broken. Thank you for making and sharing such beautiful videos.
I absolutely loved it. After I saw the end to season two, I cried. It was so not fair. This video is a perfect dedication to these two. Well done. ^_^ And to all the tools out there who decide to be cruel, one thing is to be said: A life without love is terrible.
I Especially love the "hold your hand" parts with 9 and 10, the "gonna die in battle" part coupled with that lonely shot from LoftheTL at 1:23, the "captivate me" part cut together from POTW and U to the "left behind" image from series 4, "still with me" at 2:50 with the "then kill me" part, the Doomsday cut together with "all of your tears", and the end bit at Bad Wolf Bay cutting to the doctor alone remembering the "stuff of legends". This video is fab and is my new favorite.
This is one of those great youtube videos that had made me unable to listen to the song without thinking of the fandom, and indeed some of the specific clips you used. In a word: brilliant.
i thought maybe i was moving on then this just broke me down and made me bawl my eyes out. Thanks for making me realise that you just can't move on from these two- your vids are the best!
that was so fantastic that I had to look up synonyms to express the awesomeness of this video. my top three are astounding, extraordinary, and overwhelming
This is seriously the best fan video i've ever seen. I love it so much. I cry so hard when I watch it lol ty, you're brilliant and i'm grateful for talented people such as yourself.
sommersprechen: Oh what a wonderful comment. :) I am so glad you enjoyed it. I just felt so many of the lines (including the one at 2;00) were so poignant to their relationship. Thanks again. :) x
awe this video is so amazing i keep on watching it..rose and the doctor will always be the best two for me! and i am not a very emotional person but i was crying inside!! xxx
"Thankyoooaw"... as Rose would say. :) just love the desperation in her face wanting to get through the wall for him to touch her. Just heartbreaking. :( xx
Wow, the most brilliant fan video I have ever seen! At the beginning I had tears in my eyes, my the middle, tears were streaming down my face. I just love this so much! I've always been a huge Doctor+Rose fan, and this was amazing. When the Doctor thinks he sees Rose coming into the TARDIS but she's isn't just killed me! It's fantstic! GREAT job!!
I love how you used dialogue in this vid, especially the moment of the Doctor screaming at the Daleks (2:55), ah it gave me chills. That moment is so heartbreaking, and the way you used it was perfect.
Excellent work. You did a brilliant job of capturing what they did an equally brilliant job of portraying. I suspect a thousand years from now story tellers will still have quite a bit to say about the Doctor and Rose.
Wouldn't you know that I'm out of tissues? **wipes tears on sleeve** Really, truly fabulous! I've seen more than a few Doctor/Rose vids and this is absolutely one of the best! I need to go watch your Rose's return now so I know the poor Doctor will be ok.
Wow... I mean overwhelming sadness, but so well done! It's like whenever I feel I need a good cry, this video'll do the trick for me (grant it, my tears provide the ocean for my shipping of these two). So much love for something that just wraps it all up beautifully. Well done.
This video is one of the most amazing I've seen. I haven't cried watching a video in a long time but this made my tears fall all over the keys. You did an amazing job. Keep up the amazing work. Lela
Thank you so much! This was amazing. I am practically in tears, and no fanvid has ever done that to me before. Beautiful. The best video I have seen with this song.
Thanks sooo much! It is always a real challenge to have the music and the speech together, getting the levels right, but when it works its a real buzz. ;D I feel it can really add to the overall emotional impact. xx
You know, I think both My Immortal and Doomsday have been beaten to death in fanvids, but this totally gave me chills. I love how you masterfully mixed the dialogue in. This is completely epic.
Thanks so much! Even with the most overplayed song from the 00's i am so glad i managed to convey the doctor's story in such an emotional way. :) xx Put a lot of work into this one, so happy it has had such a great response.
I am seriously obsessed with watching Doctor/Rose videos so i've seen a lot, probably hundreds by now. This one is by far the best. The scenes used, the way you've ordered and edited and everything about this video is simply fantastic and i'll probably be watching it again and again. I almost never comment but i couldn't help myself, i've never found a video so well done before. Thank you :)
I absolutely love this vid, the song is perfect. i well up every time at 2:55 to 3:00, every time!!! this is perfect for the doctors love of rose. the editing is so amazing! thank you for putting this out in the world for all of us to love!!
O.O................E.P.I.C.!!!!!!! Ugh, SOO beautiful, and the clips are timed perfectly. Usually when dialogue is put into a video, it sounds sort of awkward but this one REALLY brought an amazing feel to it. So incredible.
i was watching this for like the millionth time and i started to notice how the tenth doctor and rose hold hands alot n its so sweet. i dont think rose will stay with the doctor when she returns this series but it would be so nice if she did. thank you seduff = )
oh my god! amazing video! this made me cry! :'( its not fair they were seperated!! the doctor and rose ARE the stuff of legends! they're forever, no matter what!!
Absolutely BEAUTIFUL!! One of the BEST DW vids I've ever seen! You managed to breath new life into a, as you admitted, "done to death" song with your brilliant editing and interpretation of lyrics.
This was one of the first videos I ever saw after I opened my account, yet it remains to be my favourite youtube video ever. Beautiful, I cry every time. Thankyou seduff :)
Wow that was an amazing video. You matched everything perfectly. This is probably the best version of this song that I have seen to explain the situation between the Doctor and Rose.
FriendsFanForever: That's fantastic to hear that you are thinking of doing a media degree, I did 4 years of Film and TV. :D Good Luck and thankyou so much for the wonderful comment. x :) Sarah
This is brilliant! I think this is the best match up of video and music on the whole of youtube! This is PERFECT. It made me cry and it made me laugh. It's simply brilliant
Oh no...this is just too good... This song is already enough to put me in tears all on its own (throwback to highschool angst and a heart-rending Kirk/Spock fanvid set to it), but this... The use of color and b/w, the cuts, the *amazing* editing & manips and the specific clips you chose, the bits of dialogue that float through...oh my... Really, really lovely. One of the best vids I've ever seen
bloody hell! that was amazing!! I loved it! your sooo so good at these videos! i think you put the rest of us to shame! tears came to my eyes!! LMAO excellent! Well done!
Oh, i'm glad you made it this vid from 'I'm with you'. That was one of my first vids.... and i would love to redo it. :P Thanks for the lovely comments. :) x
Thanks so much. It definately needed Nine to be included as he was such a big part of their blossoming relationship. :) Especially remembering how devastated she was when he first changed. I can't beleive i can still watch it, the peak in the music still gets to me now.... how sad. :P xx
I'm gonna cry... again. There was a little Dr. Who marathon on the scifi channel today and they showed I think almost all the clips from the eps you have in this video, "Doomsday" being the last one for the day. That ep still makes me sad. And this video. Just beautiful!
Some truly brilliant stuff here. I loved the build up, and this song suits the Doctor and Rose so perfectly. Especially liked 3:26 to 3:35, the effects there were totally awsome! The whole thing was. Well done!
this clip is absolutely amazing. when the doctor and rose say goodbye i cant help but cry. the chemistry between them is strong and beautiful. its chemistry that most people hope to find someday.
I can't get over how well this is made. When the doctor's screaming at the dalek to kill him and the music builds and then it flashes to when he loses Rose.... it gets me every time. FANTASTIC job.
I burst into tears after seeing this video. It's so sad and beautiful at the same time. The best Doctor/Rose video I've ever seen.
that is so amazing! i teared up at the part where he's yelling at the dalek, and then screams "hold on!" beautiful!
I've heard this song a million times...but watching this vid? I never tire of it.
this is really good
it made me cry and movies like this usually don't make me cry
this song has so much power
it's beautiful
DT was the most Human of all the Doctors & this vid shows th Doctors' humanity in his love for Rose.
Just wonderful.
Wow!! It's been a while since I've watched a music video of the Doctor and Rose that has made me sob as hard as I just did, but this one did it! I absolutely love it! It was perfection!
To name just a few (of my numerous) fave parts... 00:33 "you're presence still lingers here", 2:30 blending the two scenes together with the fireworks and the build up (the lovely "though you're still with me") to the powerful climax of the song/vid with the doctor pounding his chest to the drums kicking in which was just... wow, I mean, WOW. So perfect, so powerful.
That was absolutely lovely. I've seen these scenes so often I've gotten a bit hardened to them, but this video made me want to cry all over again. Brilliant.
Oh, man. This is amazing. I love it. And I miss them.
I feel like going back and watching it all now.
that was amazing! I loved it especially when the Doctor was screaming to be taken and then the guitar starts. Just fantastic!
Favs*
It made me cry! That was SUPER! It's nice to know i'm not the only doctor who fan in this world!
OMG, I just cried like a baby watching this. This video was incredible and was put together beautifully. Thank you for making this. It has left me in awe.
It was fairly tedious to make this one. It took 3 weeks to produce from scratch. Putting quite a few hours in each day after work. Exhausting, but i am so glad i didn't rush this one. xx :) Glad you enjoyed it.
That was outstanding! Bought a real tear to my eye! I still miss Rose! Well done!
This is one of the most wonderful songs ever, displaying such deep emotion and need for someone else... Beautiful vid.
This is still my fav Doctor/ Rose vid and I've pretty much seen them all...ok that's impossible but I've seen alot. Brings tears everytime!
the was amazing!
that part when it's like "i've been alone all along"
and he's like "DO IT!"
i was like freaking out, i almost cried, great job!
Hairs standing on the back of the neck and tears down my face. Great work.
Oh my God. I was totally sobbing by the time he said "I lost her", but when he told the Dalek to 'just take care of him' I lost it. Favorited and 5 stars. Wow.
totally agree! and seduff fit it so well with the music (it sort of built up after that bit) and then it shows him loosing rose... ooohh it gave me shivers.
Perfect use of an almost-always-cliche'd song, complementing a beautiful, tragic, underappreciated couple. Ugh, I'm weeping.
Thank you.
that song may be used alot but that is BY FAR the best usage of it I have EVER seen! It was brilliant! The part where the band kicks in and the doctor is shouting....goosbumps! Excellent video!
Just amazing, so well done, I love how you used the ninth doctor early in the song and tenth later on. It just showed so well the whole relationship between the doctor and rose. Just loved it. BRILLIANT!!!
Liyrah: Thanks so much for your comment. I am really pleased to hear that you enjoyed it and warmed (at least a little) more towards Rose's character. I think all the companions are brilliant, but as she was there from the start of the new series and through the doctors regeneration she will probably always hold a special place fro me. :)
Thanks again x
itsmeyall : Thankyou so much. You comment has a very valid point... My videos would be nothing without the wonderful portrayal of the Doctor by David Tennant. His emotions are so raw. Just amazing. He and Billie had such a wonderful chemistry together. x
i havnt watched this in ages cos my computer was down. it still makes me cry its just so beautiful xx
What words can describe what I felt and saw, watching this video. It's absolutely amazing. The doctor's pain just seeped right on through my computer screen. 5 STARS!
I'm not even sure what to say about this video. It's breathtaking and absolutely made me tear up. That moment you put in where he's yelling at the Dalek to just kill him, UGh, with the music and DT's acting and just....the doctor just seems so broken.
Thank you for making and sharing such beautiful videos.
One of the most powerful edits I've seen in a long-long time!!! Congratulations, I couldn't stop crying while watching!
I absolutely loved it. After I saw the end to season two, I cried. It was so not fair. This video is a perfect dedication to these two. Well done. ^_^ And to all the tools out there who decide to be cruel, one thing is to be said: A life without love is terrible.
I Especially love the "hold your hand" parts with 9 and 10, the "gonna die in battle" part coupled with that lonely shot from LoftheTL at 1:23, the "captivate me" part cut together from POTW and U to the "left behind" image from series 4, "still with me" at 2:50 with the "then kill me" part, the Doomsday cut together with "all of your tears", and the end bit at Bad Wolf Bay cutting to the doctor alone remembering the "stuff of legends".
This video is fab and is my new favorite.
This is one of those great youtube videos that had made me unable to listen to the song without thinking of the fandom, and indeed some of the specific clips you used. In a word: brilliant.
i thought maybe i was moving on then this just broke me down and made me bawl my eyes out. Thanks for making me realise that you just can't move on from these two- your vids are the best!
that was so fantastic that I had to look up synonyms to express the awesomeness of this video. my top three are astounding, extraordinary, and overwhelming
ive watched this about ten times in a row now its brilliant it made me cry its so beautiful!
This is seriously the best fan video i've ever seen. I love it so much. I cry so hard when I watch it lol ty, you're brilliant and i'm grateful for talented people such as yourself.
My goodness, that moment when it goes into the rock instrumental was overwhelming, especially how you placed the sound, another brilliant video!
I have never cried while watching a fan vid. Thanks. You're amazing.
sommersprechen: Oh what a wonderful comment. :) I am so glad you enjoyed it. I just felt so many of the lines (including the one at 2;00) were so poignant to their relationship. Thanks again. :) x
I haven't cried watching a UA-cam vid for a looong time but this was just beyond beautiful. Excellent stuff.
I cried like a baby but I'm not ashamed! This is beautiful and you are amazing.
awe this video is so amazing i keep on watching it..rose and the doctor will always be the best two for me!
and i am not a very emotional person but i was crying inside!! xxx
"Thankyoooaw"... as Rose would say. :) just love the desperation in her face wanting to get through the wall for him to touch her. Just heartbreaking. :( xx
Wow, the most brilliant fan video I have ever seen! At the beginning I had tears in my eyes, my the middle, tears were streaming down my face. I just love this so much! I've always been a huge Doctor+Rose fan, and this was amazing. When the Doctor thinks he sees Rose coming into the TARDIS but she's isn't just killed me! It's fantstic! GREAT job!!
Absolute PERFECTION! Melding one of my favorite songs with your uncanny style to edit... speechless!
seduff, you really are marvelous. I've watched this more times than I can say, and it's completely wonderful.
Absolutely FIVE star video!! It is my favorite Rose/10 video that I have ever seen so far. It's so sad and so brilliant. You are very talented.
I love how you used dialogue in this vid, especially the moment of the Doctor screaming at the Daleks (2:55), ah it gave me chills. That moment is so heartbreaking, and the way you used it was perfect.
Excellent work. You did a brilliant job of capturing what they did an equally brilliant job of portraying.
I suspect a thousand years from now story tellers will still have quite a bit to say about the Doctor and Rose.
Wouldn't you know that I'm out of tissues? **wipes tears on sleeve** Really, truly fabulous! I've seen more than a few Doctor/Rose vids and this is absolutely one of the best! I need to go watch your Rose's return now so I know the poor Doctor will be ok.
Wow... I mean overwhelming sadness, but so well done! It's like whenever I feel I need a good cry, this video'll do the trick for me (grant it, my tears provide the ocean for my shipping of these two). So much love for something that just wraps it all up beautifully. Well done.
I actually shed a tear.. this video was beautiful. 5 stars.
man that video is absolutely amazing! it seriously made me cry. rose was my favorite and that last episode made me cry so much! wonderful job!
This video is one of the most amazing I've seen. I haven't cried watching a video in a long time but this made my tears fall all over the keys. You did an amazing job. Keep up the amazing work.
Lela
this is the saddest video ever!
Cant help it, I'm, just crying and crying. So much emotions in this video!
Thank you so much! This was amazing. I am practically in tears, and no fanvid has ever done that to me before. Beautiful. The best video I have seen with this song.
Thanks sooo much! It is always a real challenge to have the music and the speech together, getting the levels right, but when it works its a real buzz. ;D I feel it can really add to the overall emotional impact. xx
My GOD!!! I love it!!! So beautiful. The best My immortal MV out there!
You know, I think both My Immortal and Doomsday have been beaten to death in fanvids, but this totally gave me chills. I love how you masterfully mixed the dialogue in. This is completely epic.
*sigh* This is wonderful! you are so right about their connection. In my point of view, she isn't just "a replaceable companion", too.
Thanks so much! Even with the most overplayed song from the 00's i am so glad i managed to convey the doctor's story in such an emotional way. :) xx Put a lot of work into this one, so happy it has had such a great response.
I am seriously obsessed with watching Doctor/Rose videos so i've seen a lot, probably hundreds by now. This one is by far the best. The scenes used, the way you've ordered and edited and everything about this video is simply fantastic and i'll probably be watching it again and again. I almost never comment but i couldn't help myself, i've never found a video so well done before. Thank you :)
VintageRose93: Wow! I am so honoured that you think so! What a wonderful comment to recieve. Thankyou so very much :) xx
WOW!!. That was brilliant, beautiful, wonderful. I loved it. Well Done!
I absolutely love this vid, the song is perfect. i well up every time at 2:55 to 3:00, every time!!! this is perfect for the doctors love of rose. the editing is so amazing! thank you for putting this out in the world for all of us to love!!
Wow. This is brilliant. Beautiful...just...perfect. Definitely the best My Immortal vid I've ever seen.
O.O................E.P.I.C.!!!!!!! Ugh, SOO beautiful, and the clips are timed perfectly. Usually when dialogue is put into a video, it sounds sort of awkward but this one REALLY brought an amazing feel to it. So incredible.
i was watching this for like the millionth time and i started to notice how the tenth doctor and rose hold hands alot n its so sweet. i dont think rose will stay with the doctor when she returns this series but it would be so nice if she did. thank you seduff = )
oh my god! amazing video! this made me cry! :'( its not fair they were seperated!!
the doctor and rose ARE the stuff of legends! they're forever, no matter what!!
This is brilliant,i mean it so emotional and brilliant clips put together and Aerojuanas you totally right I'd rate this a million and one times
This was... Beautiful, words cannot describe it :)
You made cry, DAMN YOU!
5 stars x
Absolutely BEAUTIFUL!! One of the BEST DW vids I've ever seen! You managed to breath new life into a, as you admitted, "done to death" song with your brilliant editing and interpretation of lyrics.
This was one of the first videos I ever saw after I opened my account, yet it remains to be my favourite youtube video ever. Beautiful, I cry every time. Thankyou seduff :)
LisaSmithDoctorWho: That's so lovely to hear. Thanks for letting me know, it's always so nice to know about how my videos are enjoyed by others. :D xx
You make incredible Doctor Who videos, Respect bro!
That is briliant! The end is so great, its just flat out amazing, well done!
Thanks so much, that's lovely. ;) I absolutely LOVE making them for you all to enjoy! xx
Wow that was an amazing video. You matched everything perfectly. This is probably the best version of this song that I have seen to explain the situation between the Doctor and Rose.
CRYING. Uggh, I'm freaking torturing myself watching these videos. This one was amazing. Great editing.
FriendsFanForever: That's fantastic to hear that you are thinking of doing a media degree, I did 4 years of Film and TV. :D Good Luck and thankyou so much for the wonderful comment. x :) Sarah
Ah hell...this video breaks my heart every time I watch it. You are amazing.
wow! this is one of the best videos about Rose and Doctor! luv it!!!
As the Doctor would say ... "Fantastic, oh yes!" lol.
So heartbraking and warming at the same time. I love this video, thanks for making it!!
This is brilliant! I think this is the best match up of video and music on the whole of youtube! This is PERFECT. It made me cry and it made me laugh. It's simply brilliant
amazingly put together!!!!! Its great for people just getting over season 2s sadness!
Oh no...this is just too good...
This song is already enough to put me in tears all on its own (throwback to highschool angst and a heart-rending Kirk/Spock fanvid set to it), but this...
The use of color and b/w, the cuts, the *amazing* editing & manips and the specific clips you chose, the bits of dialogue that float through...oh my...
Really, really lovely. One of the best vids I've ever seen
bloody hell! that was amazing!! I loved it! your sooo so good at these videos! i think you put the rest of us to shame! tears came to my eyes!! LMAO
excellent!
Well done!
Oh, i'm glad you made it this vid from 'I'm with you'. That was one of my first vids.... and i would love to redo it. :P Thanks for the lovely comments. :) x
Wow...that was...I can't even describe it. 'Beautiful' and 'amazing' just don't quie cover it....really, really, really good job with this.
I got all teary-eyed and I'm not even a Ten/Rose fan!
This is amazing. Very clever editing! :)
By the wayy this video is AMAZING, i cry every time i watch it:( its proper heartbreaking:,(
Really well edited and the clips fit so well to the song!
Your videos are truly amazing!! Rose and the Doctor will always be soulmates 5 stars!
Thanks so much. It definately needed Nine to be included as he was such a big part of their blossoming relationship. :) Especially remembering how devastated she was when he first changed. I can't beleive i can still watch it, the peak in the music still gets to me now.... how sad. :P xx
I'm gonna cry... again. There was a little Dr. Who marathon on the scifi channel today and they showed I think almost all the clips from the eps you have in this video, "Doomsday" being the last one for the day. That ep still makes me sad. And this video. Just beautiful!
:'o) this is beautiful! it made me cry and.. and i never cry. awesome job thank you so much for posting. you deserved every one of those awards!
This was AMAZING. So emotional and real.
irisxeyes vidio almost made me cry, this vidio I litraly in tears. Oh my God my hands are shaking! awsome vid!
Beautiful, beautiful work. That was absoutly brilliant! I just love your work, it's fantastic. Never ever stop. ***** 5 stars.
Some truly brilliant stuff here.
I loved the build up, and this song suits the Doctor and Rose so perfectly.
Especially liked 3:26 to 3:35, the effects there were totally awsome! The whole thing was.
Well done!