I could just cry again! I was going to record the song but was frozen in shock that it was really being performed live for the first time! Thank you for this amazing video!!!!
I was aware of this song, and I like it, but I didn't realize it was so beloved. Sorry. I went to all 3 nights at the ballroom. All i could hear him say was "deep cuts" originally so thank for this recording. He did a wonderful David Bowie Tribute night 3, Reznor broke out the sax for "I Can't Give Everything Away" and then played Subterrraneans for the first time since 1995.
that's a deep cut alright. wish I could've been there for that one. was at 2/3 vegas shows. left 20 minutes early the 3rd night cause I started really missing my little boy at home. turns out Gary numan took stage aswell and played metal. still haven't forgiven my son. came home to a shitty diaper and a pissed girlfriend.
My favorite NIN song. Cant believe they played it live. Wow.
I was almost in tears then
And I'm almost in tears now
just from seeing this live.. It completely sealed the awesomeness of the show
Holy shit. I never thought he’d play it live. I missed it by two damn shows. Amazing. Tears. Lucky bastards that were there!!
Just wow. What an encore. Chills is right.
I could just cry again! I was going to record the song but was frozen in shock that it was really being performed live for the first time! Thank you for this amazing video!!!!
Chills. Tears.
I was aware of this song, and I like it, but I didn't realize it was so beloved. Sorry. I went to all 3 nights at the ballroom. All i could hear him say was "deep cuts" originally so thank for this recording. He did a wonderful David Bowie Tribute night 3, Reznor broke out the sax for "I Can't Give Everything Away" and then played Subterrraneans for the first time since 1995.
But this was very VERY unexpected and, amazing. I don't mean to try to change the subject about a different night.
I was in tears the entire time ❤😍
it took 16 years and a near performance in 2009 but they did it.
i can't believe it. and it's so good!
@GazB85 Yeah. Justin Medal-Johnson said that in 2009 they had rehearsed AATCHB for the Wave Goodbye tour but alas it never happened.
@@lisgod3 that's fucking interesting
I’m glad that he waited this long to play this and I hope he never plays it again. This song is special and beyond perfect.
Forever my favorite NIN song
Holy shit this sounds incredible
Thank you too my sweetest friend and I'm sorry too
i saw this. i curled up in a ball wearing my combat boots. and i cried and cried and cried.
Beautiful. Yup I cried
Fuck I can’t get through one listen of this song without getting teary eyed.
insane. wow. bravo.
that's a deep cut alright. wish I could've been there for that one. was at 2/3 vegas shows. left 20 minutes early the 3rd night cause I started really missing my little boy at home. turns out Gary numan took stage aswell and played metal. still haven't forgiven my son. came home to a shitty diaper and a pissed girlfriend.
Great Awesome OMG
I still don't believe it was real, though I was right there.
Pyra Barnes good to meet you!
@@iamthemaxx Good to meet you, as well. Hope that last show was a blast, too.
Can’t believe I missed this. Biggest regret of my life by far.
I can't believe I missed this!!!!!!!!! No!!!!!!!!!!
Could I dow load this for my insta page? It's a whole NIN tribute kind of thing.
Tard Moments yes please. Just please give me credit. I appreciate you asking!!!
What the fuck..... Not fair. This ruined my two nights in Boston 😣
Great song indeed but IMO should have been left unplayed live and left to be heard only on Still🤷♂️