Family Guy characters have become mean spirited ever since Seth stopped writing for the show. American Dad characters are pretty chaotic, but there is still a sense of empathy with them.
I can’t describe why I find the type of comedy in American dad so funny but I just do. Like family guy had Peter turn up the tv volume while his pregnant wife was throwing up in the bathroom and that’s funny, but American dad just takes it to another level by making stan so arrogant that he tells his wife her water didn’t break because he’s always right and then just going to bed lmao
i think its bc family guys humor w peter usually just stems from being dumb and hating his family (at least modern family guy) but the humor w stan usually comes from his pride, selfishness and actually wanting to do whats best for his family, even if it's not actually the best but he believes it is. Like I really love all the dynamics the characters have w each other most of the time.
“Good morning USA!,I got a feeling that it’s going to be a wonderful day,the sun in the sky has a smile on its face and it’s shining a salute to the American race ”🗣️🔥🔥🔥🔥
Another thing that American Dad has over Family Guy is that over the years its actually improved. Like at first they had clear ideas of what they were doing, then they realized they could just make Roger into literally anyone and just ran with it. Jeff as an added member of the family is actually interesting. Haley and Stan becoming less politically preachy has been great for the characters, Haley becoming more comically lazy and Stan more comically ignorant. Steve having a character outside of being the nerd. The consistency between Francine and Lois' backgrounds is such an interesting comparison. Seeing how Lois' family outside her parents are treated in FG made me think that there was a chance that Francine being adopted would be a weird one of joke but it wasn't! They stuck with it! And kept it natural!
some other things that make american dad better imo is that all the characters are more fleshed out and interesting. like Chris just exists for teenage pervert and masturbation jokes, Meg is just a punching bag and Lois is just a straight man( the comedy archetype), episodes that focus on those characters often suck because there's not much you can really do with them whereas all the smiths have enough quirks interests and talents that you can make an episode that focuses on one of them and it's still funny. even claus gets better in latter seasons whereas in family guy the characters just become parodies of themselves. peter went from a caring but dumb dad to a an unhinged lunatic who doesn't really care about anyone, brian went from a cynical but smart alcoholic to an idiotic hypocritical stoner liberal ,etc the other thing is that by not relying on cutaways and random jokes, but having the humour come naturally from the story of the episode it makes each episode more memorable. in family guy, especially the later seasons i can remember certain jokes that are funny but half the time i can't remember what episode it's from at all, with american dad when i see a funny clip or joke online i then remember other funny jokes and moments from the same episode
When the writers got tired of Klaus trying to sleep with Francine, n@z! jokes and being depressed/ignored, he kinda found his own groove. They just embraced the stupidity of having a talking german fish and they imply he has a whole rich life going on in the background.
@@joshuamartiancartoons Klaus is one of the characters who needed some time just like early roger but even in the earlier seasons Klaus was highly underrated
i feel like american dad is super underrated because you need to watch full episodes to understand the context of the jokes whereas family guy has so many cutaways and random jokes that can be easily put into compilations that people react to.
After several months of being an active hate watcher I finally come full circle, now I wait daily for your uploads and it's a delight when it's a childhood show I'm fond of, american dad rick and morty family guy all those weird cartoons. I found your guys channel through south park and hated every single second of the reactions, I hated it so much I had to keep watching to find any redeemable quality and it took me several months of daily active hate watching to the point I subscribed to your patreon for uncut recordings. It was never enough, until this day. I realized I'm no longer hate watching I'm actively invested, what have I become.. Like a dog waiting for the mailman so he can bark and ravage anything he slides through I wait patiently and get sad when the day doesn't arrive. I am a disgrace to my former self and now an active spilling the milk fan, may God have forgiveness on my burdened soul. also I hope Jack's doing good he's my favorite between you three
The first couple seasons of American Dad really established the characters personalities but they BUILD on those traits SOOOO much. Family Guy is a hard second to American Dad.
@Theabyssdobeburning he was married to a wife for 31 years and they had 4 kids. i can't find anything on the internet about him being gay. maybe hes bi like me but i can't find anything about jt
@ Damn, my bad. After some fact checking, realized I was thinking about Richard Hunt (the muppets’ puppeteer). You’re right and now the joke in the show makes no sense to me now either.
That’s wild I started a rewatch a couple weeks ago. Seth McFarlane seems like he cooked way harder with this show compared to the other ones. Also Stan being in the CIA and Roger being an Alien is such a smart way to create wacky hijinks without relying on cutaway gags fr
American Dad is better than Family Guy in my opinion. Like earlier seasons had the same level of random humour, but it matured over time and had ongoing story arcs that made permanent changes to the characters and lore. Plus no cutaways, just a lot of Steve singing.
American Dad is the second funniest animated show of all time behind South Park, just extraordinarily underrated! Funny and even brilliant, at times. Also, yes some episodes are essentially proto-Rick and Morty plotlines. Those are usually some of the best episodes. 😂 (also, Klaus the German fish is a one-note joke in the early seasons but hilarious in the later seasons once the writers pinned down his full character; the bit where he pulls a muscle in his back alone in a hotel room is an all-timer) (also too, the Mr. Pibb lore in American Dad is 100x more deep than you would expect)
honestly the only character i'm not a fan of from american dad is jeff because he's pretty one note: a dumb stoner, but even with him i can remember funny moments whereas with someone like chris from family guy i would struggle to think of a single funny moment
They ditched the whole Klaus is a nazi thing after the first couple seasons and leaned into the fact that everyone thinks Klaus sucks lol. They even had Klaus address the American Dad reddit.
You ever heard the saying that goes something like “If you’re young and have a heart you’re liberal, if you’re old and have a brain you’re conservative.” This is how I liken family guy to American dad. Family guy is funnier when you’re a kid and simple gag stuff and randomness is very funny, American dad is funnier when you have a better understanding of the world/western society
The idea of a "most dangerous game" theme park where one team survives and the other hunts them with paint guns sounds like the most fun thing ever I wish it was real And so people can get the full experience, the teams would go twice, and the teams switch between who hunts and who's hunted
I loved when spilling the milk had the AmericanDadExplainer and the Family Guy Statistician on as guests today. If you guys ever get the Family Guy Philosopher i might have to subscribe
American Dad: Angelic court, Angelic weapons, women fighting in court with heaven = Charlie, Jesus is well suited = Alastor pimped out This is literally hazbin hotel
You can't just use a screenshot from Season 5, Episode 7; "My Morning Straitjacket" without watching it! You should watch musical episodes: Season 7, Episode 1: Hot Water Season 8, Episode 3: Can I Be Frank with You? Season 9, Episode 17: Rubberneckers
So even though that first episode was in the goo I think we all learned a lesson that if we're going to die around Stan Smith we better not be an organ donor
Like and freakin subscribe!!!
Yes
Yar
maybe
The episodes Eden chose are good episodes
Watch Raptures Delight next!
Unironically I believe The Smiths love each other FAR more than the Griffins, which is wild cuz they're arguably more toxic and chaotic.
Because the Smiths actually respect each other to an extent. The Griffins….
Family Guy characters have become mean spirited ever since Seth stopped writing for the show. American Dad characters are pretty chaotic, but there is still a sense of empathy with them.
The Smiths feel like an actual family while the Griffins just feel like husks to feed jokes through.
at first i thought you meant the band the smiths 😭
I think it’s because they have some level of deep love and respect for each other.
I can’t describe why I find the type of comedy in American dad so funny but I just do.
Like family guy had Peter turn up the tv volume while his pregnant wife was throwing up in the bathroom and that’s funny, but American dad just takes it to another level by making stan so arrogant that he tells his wife her water didn’t break because he’s always right and then just going to bed lmao
For me why American Dad is so funny is because the humor most of the time is just so blunt lol
I enjoyed it more simply because of Stan being a more competent person than Peter and the Smiths being much more functional
i think its bc family guys humor w peter usually just stems from being dumb and hating his family (at least modern family guy)
but the humor w stan usually comes from his pride, selfishness and actually wanting to do whats best for his family, even if it's not actually the best but he believes it is. Like I really love all the dynamics the characters have w each other most of the time.
true or when peter was screaming cause of being kicked in the balls and louis ignored him
I like how 80% of this video is just Eden talking
Spilling the milk is like pirating but 80 percent of the episode is gone
😂
Jack is not here to scream for no reason
He's the American Dad Dad-istician after all.
Bro’s a professional yapper
Glad to see them do American Dad again since the last time was a year ago
They probably dont even know the family intro speedrun
“Good morning USA!,I got a feeling that it’s going to be a wonderful day,the sun in the sky has a smile on its face and it’s shining a salute to the American race ”🗣️🔥🔥🔥🔥
OH BOY ITS SWELL TO SAY!!!
@@Choffee617 “good morning USA”
🗿
@@Brayden_filmz🗿
@@Brayden_filmz 🎺🎺🎺 GOOD MORNING USA!
I miss jack so badly
So true besty
I hope he gets better soon! 🙏
nah he colonized all the screen time away from these guys, its good hes gone.
@@nullakjg767bro… not cool
hot take but I enjoy American dad WAY more than family guy. It also is just better than family guy
A TRUE take.
I personally don’t think this is a hot take, it’s a way better show
Good morning USA
Artic Take🥶🥶
@@PolandballAnimations.1🗿
6:58 I like the detail of Stan and Francine shielding the kids when it comes down to it.
Another thing that American Dad has over Family Guy is that over the years its actually improved. Like at first they had clear ideas of what they were doing, then they realized they could just make Roger into literally anyone and just ran with it. Jeff as an added member of the family is actually interesting. Haley and Stan becoming less politically preachy has been great for the characters, Haley becoming more comically lazy and Stan more comically ignorant. Steve having a character outside of being the nerd. The consistency between Francine and Lois' backgrounds is such an interesting comparison. Seeing how Lois' family outside her parents are treated in FG made me think that there was a chance that Francine being adopted would be a weird one of joke but it wasn't! They stuck with it! And kept it natural!
some other things that make american dad better imo is that all the characters are more fleshed out and interesting. like Chris just exists for teenage pervert and masturbation jokes, Meg is just a punching bag and Lois is just a straight man( the comedy archetype), episodes that focus on those characters often suck because there's not much you can really do with them whereas all the smiths have enough quirks interests and talents that you can make an episode that focuses on one of them and it's still funny. even claus gets better in latter seasons whereas in family guy the characters just become parodies of themselves. peter went from a caring but dumb dad to a an unhinged lunatic who doesn't really care about anyone, brian went from a cynical but smart alcoholic to an idiotic hypocritical stoner liberal ,etc
the other thing is that by not relying on cutaways and random jokes, but having the humour come naturally from the story of the episode it makes each episode more memorable. in family guy, especially the later seasons i can remember certain jokes that are funny but half the time i can't remember what episode it's from at all, with american dad when i see a funny clip or joke online i then remember other funny jokes and moments from the same episode
American Dad is peak adult cartoon in my opinion
Praying for jack 🙏 hope he gets better
what happened to him
@@leikvz7780 concussion
@@leikvz7780Watch their video titled "We need to talk." Jack had a concussion and is recovering currently.
@@leikvz7780concussion
@@leikvz7780He got a concussion
Oh my god you guys HAVE to do It's always sunny in Philadelphia! I'll join your Patreon for it!
I'm broke but sentiment wise, I agree.
@@SupHapCak me too, but I'll sacrifice this months rent for this show🤣
Stop no they’ll put it behind a paywall! They’re already keeping avatar from me
There are so many innumerable moments that I want to see them lose their shit over
@@balgrithfennir3581they watched it once on the channel
The disrespect for klaus is crazy, he is just one of the boyz
When the writers got tired of Klaus trying to sleep with Francine, n@z! jokes and being depressed/ignored, he kinda found his own groove. They just embraced the stupidity of having a talking german fish and they imply he has a whole rich life going on in the background.
Klaus'z Boyz
@@joshuamartiancartoons Klaus is one of the characters who needed some time just like early roger but even in the earlier seasons Klaus was highly underrated
That episode where he invented the hi five😂 "und now I vill Steel your accent"😭😭😭 @@joshuamartiancartoons
i feel like american dad is super underrated because you need to watch full episodes to understand the context of the jokes whereas family guy has so many cutaways and random jokes that can be easily put into compilations that people react to.
After several months of being an active hate watcher I finally come full circle, now I wait daily for your uploads and it's a delight when it's a childhood show I'm fond of, american dad rick and morty family guy all those weird cartoons. I found your guys channel through south park and hated every single second of the reactions, I hated it so much I had to keep watching to find any redeemable quality and it took me several months of daily active hate watching to the point I subscribed to your patreon for uncut recordings. It was never enough, until this day. I realized I'm no longer hate watching I'm actively invested, what have I become..
Like a dog waiting for the mailman so he can bark and ravage anything he slides through I wait patiently and get sad when the day doesn't arrive. I am a disgrace to my former self and now an active spilling the milk fan, may God have forgiveness on my burdened soul.
also I hope Jack's doing good he's my favorite between you three
I respect continuing to watch out of pure hate
Bro stockholm syndrome’d himself 😭
4:09 The way me and Eden laughed the exact same... I'm becoming one with the hivemind
The first couple seasons of American Dad really established the characters personalities but they BUILD on those traits SOOOO much. Family Guy is a hard second to American Dad.
American Dad > Family Guy
Agreed!
Ngl, they both are so bad.
Family Guy More like American Bad
Good Morning U.S.A! I Got a feeling that's gonna be a wonderful day!
The sun in the sky has a smile on his face
For context for the Jim Henson joke, he was gay. That’s it, that’s the entire joke.
Edit: I got some people mixed up, the joke makes no sense
he's not?
@@squiddyanimations6617 he is? He was while he was alive anyways
@Theabyssdobeburning he was married to a wife for 31 years and they had 4 kids. i can't find anything on the internet about him being gay. maybe hes bi like me but i can't find anything about jt
@ Damn, my bad. After some fact checking, realized I was thinking about Richard Hunt (the muppets’ puppeteer). You’re right and now the joke in the show makes no sense to me now either.
@Theabyssdobeburning alright glad we could resolve this
Sometimes, American Dad pulls out the random jokes that cause proper belly laughs that neighbours hear.
Finally! We’re back to the TV show that’s made by the same man who made Family Guy, yet it’s nothing like Family Guy at all.
Thats because Seth stopped writing for family guy like 15 years ago
@@n0body550Okay, everyone seriously need to stop saying that. We get it already!
@@BatmanFan76 You asked a ducking question and i gave you the answer so why tf you telling me to shut up? Stupid little cunt
American Dad Christmas episodes are P E A K
I just realized one of the hunters in the vacation episode is Kraven the Hunter
Jacks been gone so long that I’ve just started hallucinate him in the videos that have to restart the video to see if he was actually there
Francine in the thumbnail had me folding... 🥵💀
12:45 THIS JUST IN:
Eden has NO IDEA what Eminem looks like 💀
That’s wild I started a rewatch a couple weeks ago. Seth McFarlane seems like he cooked way harder with this show compared to the other ones. Also Stan being in the CIA and Roger being an Alien is such a smart way to create wacky hijinks without relying on cutaway gags fr
Roger's gonna be in someone's blunt rotation somehow
3:32 Don't say what, Eden? Don't think what?
Man, I miss Jack screaming at 2D women for no reason
3:52 so you're saying Steve is Scott the Woz
The Claus / Krampus specials are worth watching together, cause they're some of the best episodes in the series.
0:54 Pulling up to your house like a drive-thru 😂
19:00 Russian Dad would be a hilarious show.
"That's just a rick and morty episode, I'm sorry."
Bold claim considering this aired in 2007
love whoever synched Roger's keyboard playing in that clip to the keyboard in this video outro's song
Not gonna lie steve is a lot like morty. In the sons that they're both perverted simps.
Oh, THIS is the "in the goo" episode. I for some reason remember an episode with the phrase "I'm in the goo".
American Dad is better than Family Guy in my opinion.
Like earlier seasons had the same level of random humour, but it matured over time and had ongoing story arcs that made permanent changes to the characters and lore.
Plus no cutaways, just a lot of Steve singing.
I hope jack is doing ok. I hope he recovering well
American Dad is the second funniest animated show of all time behind South Park, just extraordinarily underrated! Funny and even brilliant, at times. Also, yes some episodes are essentially proto-Rick and Morty plotlines. Those are usually some of the best episodes. 😂
(also, Klaus the German fish is a one-note joke in the early seasons but hilarious in the later seasons once the writers pinned down his full character; the bit where he pulls a muscle in his back alone in a hotel room is an all-timer)
(also too, the Mr. Pibb lore in American Dad is 100x more deep than you would expect)
honestly the only character i'm not a fan of from american dad is jeff because he's pretty one note: a dumb stoner, but even with him i can remember funny moments whereas with someone like chris from family guy i would struggle to think of a single funny moment
@@666FallenShadow Jeff has his moments. He pairs surprisingly well comedically with Stan and with Klaus.
They ditched the whole Klaus is a nazi thing after the first couple seasons and leaned into the fact that everyone thinks Klaus sucks lol. They even had Klaus address the American Dad reddit.
When you said “how can you be an Angel and a lawyer at the same time” I immediately thought Saul Goodman
American dad is better then family guy and I stand on that
GOOD MORNING USAAAAA 🗣
I got a feeling that it's gonna be a wonderful day
The Sun in the sky has a smile it's face.@@Ilanaharon888
I like how into the show Eden is
Family Guy & American Dad are both really funny shows... Does anybody else agree with me? ☺
Oh dear god I remember how horrible that episode at 8:28 was, that shit was low key traumatizing when I saw it on tv at like 10 yo
Can't wait for them seeing The hundred or the true Christmas Story of American dad.
The American Dad theme song would be incredible
It's funny cause the Dad Bod/Bear Body has gained mass popularity in recent months
Jack is recovering so slowly, hope he can hold in there.
Love the "Bye Bye Man" reference from Eden
Its hilarious people inside and outside of the show dunk on Klaus. If you know why he's in the fish body, its even more funny
What a fun realistic survival game, and the length Roger goes to to do stuff or learn something is hilarious
You know what else is funnier than you remember?
*Dan Vs.*
.....Please, I've been suggesting it for years.
I didn’t know Eden’s such a fan of American Dad and they already have reactions to the show before
You guys need to watch the episodes; "Tapped Out," & "Shallow Vows".
It put your favourite Francine in a new light 😂
"Don't say it, don't think it."
Dammit.
They actually got good episodes this time. Peak television
4:03 Jack has a Sonichu medallion?!
10,000 more American Dad!
2:17 If jack was here he’d go crazy in the scene.
Lol at Eden’s laughs today 😂❤
Roger is a certified baddie
PS i love how Eden laughs
12:27 Jpegmafia and Danny Brown jumpscare
5:00 Most Dangerous game reference?
KNEW IT!
I never thought I'd say this but I'm beginning to miss Jack.
So true bestie
Man Kor loves American dad 😂
I'm still recommending you guys to watch The Great North.
Fun fact the "The Common Garden Snake of Rumallah" is voiced by Amir Talai (Alastor in Hazbin Hotel)
You ever heard the saying that goes something like “If you’re young and have a heart you’re liberal, if you’re old and have a brain you’re conservative.” This is how I liken family guy to American dad. Family guy is funnier when you’re a kid and simple gag stuff and randomness is very funny, American dad is funnier when you have a better understanding of the world/western society
The idea of a "most dangerous game" theme park where one team survives and the other hunts them with paint guns sounds like the most fun thing ever I wish it was real
And so people can get the full experience, the teams would go twice, and the teams switch between who hunts and who's hunted
Pibb Xtra is unironically my favorite drink. I miss it
Eden is the only reason I can laugh at this 😭
Good to see keyan and carlile return to american dad comentary
That first supper edit 😂😂😂😂
149 of asking for the underated dinosaur king
I forgot Patrick Stuart was a canon character in this show.
I loved when spilling the milk had the AmericanDadExplainer and the Family Guy Statistician on as guests today. If you guys ever get the Family Guy Philosopher i might have to subscribe
AIN'T NO WAY YALL USED VULTURES 2 AS KANYES ONLY EXAMPLE AND WHAT ABOUT MY POOKIE WOOKIE J.COLE
3:33
C’mon Eden, don’t say what? Talk to us 😊
They watched my favorite American dad episode 😱 best day ever. Need a redo when Jack feels better por favor
what if stan smith is THEE STAN eminems song was about and thats why he killed em
There was a what’s eating Gilbert grape reference in American dad once
Someone Needs to show them "Roger Passing the Bar"
You guys should do a video on Terrifier!
"I haven't seen anyone drink Mr Pibb in 20 years" DAMN I DRINK MR PIBB ALL THE TIME
American dad has some amazing episodes u guys gotta do it more
i did NOT think id hear janes addiction in an american dad episode bro
Fun Fact: The terrorist in the CIA telethon episode has the same voice actor as Alastor from Hazbin Hotel.
American Dad: Angelic court, Angelic weapons, women fighting in court with heaven = Charlie, Jesus is well suited = Alastor pimped out
This is literally hazbin hotel
that is NOT a take i was expecting
I actually think american dad is better than family guy
Facts!
Been watching a lot of AmDad lately. What a nice surprise
You can't just use a screenshot from Season 5, Episode 7; "My Morning Straitjacket" without watching it!
You should watch musical episodes:
Season 7, Episode 1: Hot Water
Season 8, Episode 3: Can I Be Frank with You?
Season 9, Episode 17: Rubberneckers
Love this show
American Dad Christmas Episodes >
Love the Rene reference. Go Bruins!
So even though that first episode was in the goo I think we all learned a lesson that if we're going to die around Stan Smith we better not be an organ donor