Overtime: Trace Adkins, Julia Ioffe, Jon Meacham | Real Time with Bill Maher (HBO)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 15 вер 2022
- Subscribe to the Real Time UA-cam: itsh.bo/10r5A1B
Bill Maher and his guests answer viewer questions after the show.
Connect with Real Time Online:
Find Real Time on Facebook: / maher
Find Real Time on Twitter: / realtimers
Find Real Time with Bill Maher Official Site: itsh.bo/HttKcM.
Find Real Time with Bill Maher on HBO GO® itsh.bo/iioY87.
Find Real Time with Bill Maher on Connect: connect.hbo.com/real-time-bill...
Find Real Time on Instagram: / realtimers
The Real Time blog: www.real-time-with-bill-maher-...
It's HBO.
Connect with HBO Online
Find HBO on Facebook: / hbo
Follow @HBO on Twitter: / hbo
Find HBO on UA-cam: / hbo
Find HBO Official Site: HBO.com
Find HBO Connect: Connect.hbo.com
Find HBO GO: HBOGO.com
Find HBO on Instagram: / hbo
Find HBO on Foursquare: Foursquare.com/hbo
Check out other HBO Channels
HBO: / hbo
Game of Thrones: / gameofthrones
True Blood: / trueblood
HBO Sports: / hbosports
HBO Documentary Films: / hbodocs
Cinemax: / cinemax
HBO Latino: / hbolatino - Фільми й анімація
Being a retired history teacher I agree that the way history is taught or not taught is insane, how can we know where we are going if we don't know where we have been. Jon Meacham you are awesome.
He sure is!
"The further we look back into history, the more we can tell about the future".... Winston Churchill's advice to Queen Liz ...
Funny, im about to get my teaching license for history
@@tristinjudd2595 well you should teach all those young minds that elections have consequences and stolen elections have catastrophic consequences we're experiencing that right now don't re write history.
@@tristinjudd2595 So....
This is what overtime should be. Opposing viewpoints debating with conviction but also respectfully with each other.
Respectful? The white liberal woman insulted all of us by saying we need to beg for forgiveness.
How about she begs for forgiveness for the democrat riots of 2020 that killed dozens of people first?
I will not apologize is what I heard from the country singer. For his Heritage of Slavery and Superiority by the South.
@@ChinoEyes1 indeed, and for supporting, enabling, and collaborating with fascists that attempted a coup to overthrow American democracy. These lunatics and deplorable people have some repenting to do to get back into the good graces of 70% of America. This is what MAGA-fascism represents, and who these people brought to power: ua-cam.com/video/3AfswUADw5w/v-deo.html
@@ChinoEyes1 he doesn't have to apologize for slavery since he's never owned a slave. The woman expects foe conservatives to apologize for being conservative.
Maybe she should hold her breath.
@@ChinoEyes1 That's the problem, similar to Julia's.
She also wants the Donaldo's to apologize, but not all of them actually are the stereotype person that many Liberals/Lefties have in mind.
Sorries don't mean much to me anyway, it'll only be a thing to use against them, to remind them, but, the damage has already been done anyway.
And even then... you're not going to get them on your team if you demand them to say sorry first, especially not when their side is also the side with most of the guns and whatnot.
_IF_ a civil war broke out now, it wouldn't have the same result.
Just saying.
Each side is angry at the other side, the president is irrelevant, because if Donald wins in 2024, they might as well demand you to apologize for whatever they disagree with.
That stuff will only keep that tug of war in place, keeping that pendulum swinging one way to the other.
Why not try to see beyond the differences and try to get things running on a normal capacity again without killing/cancelling each other.
Besides, "his heritage of slavery", he's not one of those 'white settlers', it's the USA, to go and try to deny settlers coming to America and ruling it till today, that'll also harken back to the civil war, is that really what you want?
Slavery still happens in many countries with different races, and there are also atrocious acts by other ethnicities, what's the point of singling out the white goat with 666 between its horns.
It looks like many people confuse their superior higher morals for superior firepower, how do you expect to make the Jan 6th bisonguy to apologize, he's not alone, and the more force put behind a movement to make these people apologize, the more resistance there will be to it, and yeah, to repeat myself, it's not going to be any prettier this time around.
I'm not a fan of any politician at the moment, they've all failed in some way or another, but my choice would've been Bernie '16 & '20, but the DNC wouldn't have it, and i am definitely not a fan of Donald, Biden is just a creep, not any less corrupt than the next DNC representative.
There are a lot of pains felt at this moment that are also caused by the Dems, and people celebrating the recent Ukraine win are putting up a nice show, but i am not interested.
I do side with Julia on that one, let's just first wait and see what happens.
But, speaking of apologies... as a working class minimum wage "essential" worker... i did not particularly agree with measures taken, and considering the damage done by putting everything on halt, i can say, there are a LOT of people that owe some apologies.
So, why not skip this whole charade and focus on how to get back to a normal world.
I could listen to Jon meecham talk history. He’s got a voice that makes ppl calm and stay interested throughout his speech
He's one of my favorites. So knowledgeable, very humble wonderful storyteller. He lives next door to Tim McGraw and Faith Hill in Nashville and coauthored a book with Tim Mcgraw on how music shaped America. I haven't read it but want to.
And funny too
His voice reminds me of matthew mconaughey
Okay, first kudos to cameraman who got that shot of Meacham listening to Adkins. I have another level of respect for that man. It almost brought me to tears😢. That is a portrait of empathy and intelligence that unfortunately is so rare right now in this country. It’s ppl like Jon Meacham that inspire you to be a better person. ❤
If you get inspiration from that man I question your sanity
@@mr.j5919 like most people question yours?
and you've gotta love th shots of Adkins sitting there with corssed arms and the look of contempt as Jon made all these very valid points. Adkins was not amused! Love it!!!!!
Wow! Overtime was damn near better than the show! Great group of guests tonight Bill!
Finally, an overtime that cut deep. Bill, don't apologize for 3 intelligent, heartfelt, people unabashedly sharing their positions. None of them were 100% wrong. None of them were 100% right. It is the EXCHANGE that was perfect. The only way we ever 'walk it back' is by, first, recognizing the legitimacy of the other side.
Let's not forget the driver behind the wheel, the economy/ no-one complains when they have a six pack in the fridge
The Jan 6 terrorists are not a legitimate side.
There is no legitimacy on the right. Im not making excuses anymore for out right insane,sick grabs for power ANYMORE. This is coming from someone who is an old moderate Republican. And of color.
****interesting way of looking @ it 💠💠💠****
@@Captpisscums 😊
Trace adkins is the embodiment of restraint
We're so divided in large part because of the tactics of the news.
This was one of the best Overtimes I've ever seen. So very true that we must learn to come together.
How?
With some it's possible, very small %. We're dealing with a Flat Earthers mentality. Deny, dismiss, there is no coming together with that.
trump needs to go away and they need to slither back under their rocks where they belong. Out of sight and in the darkness
100% I was just thinking the same thing. This one really sinks in.
Not when people are misinformed. People who are misinformed are always beneath someone who is informed.
@@RocStarr913 That's why God instructed us to search a matter out for ourselves. The onus is on us. Period, no excuse.
@@anjijack5392 lose the ‘God’ concept… you lose me when you put religion in it…
Always a pleasure to hear John Meacham.
He knows the history we suddenly,don't want taught.
...he is so informative!
He's good for a laugh.
I would like to see a full hour or more of this type of coherent, intelligent civil discussion on a regular basis. This segment proves that it is possible to do as well as making it entertaining.
It didn't happen. It was 45 mins of " how can we make up bullshit about Trump and pretend that he didnt do a MUCH better job than the current incapacitated, self-shitting criminal."
It's on HBO max
Coherent? Yes… Civil? Yes…
Intelligent? Far from it.
This is the kind of conversational exchange that The View so desperately needs.
Fuck the View.
Best over time ever!!! It was long and had thoughtful discussions. Usually, it's bad jokes and 5 minutes of filler. More of today's overtime please!
+1
It's better because Bill reduced his interrupting by 97%.
... Up to that last minute.
🎯🎯🎯💯💯💯
@@LowLight420 Because he didn't have to, but interrupting is part of his job as host, it's necessary and sometimes very much so.
Perfect storm of guests tonight that spoke intelligently, allowed each other to speak reference their viewpoints, and covered subjects that are of consequence to the masses in every location of the world...Great job, William...👍😎👍😉😉😉
Let's understand 3 out of the 4 we're following the rules of a debate.
What a load of bollocks. The problem is that the more money the Democrats steal, the more obvious their corruption and the more the "masses" are exploited and impoverished as a result, the greater this volume of bollocks must become to compensate.
"Orange Man bad" simply isn't going to work. But keep at this bollocks regardless.
Except the woman in pink, she’s divisive.
@@dakotaflower5926 I like Julie Ioffe when she discusses Russia, her area of expertise. But her belief that the 75 million people who voted for Trump owe an apology to the 80 million who voted for Biden, is EXACTLY the reason we cannot come together a nation. We had 2 bad choices in 2016. Hillary decided to call everyone not voting for her a basket full of deplorables, which sounds like she divided us, not Trump. In 2020, we had a corrupt liar who has been on the wrong side of every issue for 50 years, or Trump who is an ass. But the condescending elitist on the left are owed an apology after this 2 year shitshow courtesy of the Biden administration? Her abject contempt for those who disagree with her reminds us of the 2 sides of the American circa 1960. Good to see Bill Mayer explain people have different priorities and views and thats ok.
@@spain1998 pure BS. MAGA-fascists attempted a coup. You supported, enabled, and collaborated with fascists to end American democracy. I would say that makes us enemies until you repent for those atrocities.
It’s so refreshing to see a civil discussion of opposing viewpoints. Everyone making valid points without having to shout over each other. The question really is, how do we walk back from lines that were crossed? We may never find out if we continue hating each other.
Civil? Except the triggered cat lady in the pink.
While I’m not aligning politically with this man I think he’s one of the greatest commentators of our time and I would 100% agree with everything that he has said.
I love how Trace points out where the point of no return is, and she walks right across it. Then Bill takes up and points that out. Hands down best overtime in a long while.
But she still doesn’t realize what Bill and Trace were saying lol
But the south east is evil. Ultimately the US is far too big for a functioning democracy. Values are so different all over the US for a variety of reasons and to think that one federal government for 350 million people is workable is ludicrous. Let the south eastern, ignorant states go their own way and let them drown. Let the rest of the country move on and prosper without having the Bible Belt keep pulling the country down.
She’s also the one woman on the panel and perhaps a better lens into who was hurt most by the Trump administration.
Trump was bad for everyone, but he was certainly worse for women.
@@BloodyInitiate Nah...It was good.
@@BloodyInitiate Please, explain more. How exactly was Trump "worse for women?"
Bill has developed an empathy for both sides without having to necessarily agree with their opinion.
Blanket pardons for all January 6th violence that disabled Capitol Police?
Give me a break dude. More police were injured and killed during the blm riots.
Empathy? His seething hatred for Pres. Trump ( & the 75 million + who support him) was quite obvious in his analogy to OJ.
@@TruthrConsequences And blanket statements like that from the other side. Fuck! Can’t seem to see the point and you end up doing the same thing the other side does. Keep making statements like that and make the divide worse.
that's true for alot of people - listening skills used to be considered valuable, not partisan.
Outstanding segment... Beautiful balance of mature guests with thoughtful nuanced views...
I have been very critical of the "shallow" Bill Maher recently - but here he rose to the occasion with wit and wisdom...
I was once a big fan... After this - maybe I will start watching again...
.
This was really fantastic. I’ve always loved Meacham but Trace had me on every word. The intellect in that beautiful voice and the way John leaned in to listen intently to Trace’s words was lovely to watch.
Jon Meacham made some very stupid misinformed comments, but Trace Adkins riposted beautifully
Intellect?? 😅🤣😂🤣😅
@@michaelhutson9268 🤣😅😆🤣😅😆
Bill, your closing statement was one of the most insightful things you've said on your show in many years. You hit that out of the park.
So here's how, Republicans go with another Republican.
@Jay Kay If the same thing were said about the Jewish Holocaust, would you feel the same? Hitler wasn’t the first to torture and kill people because of who they are, no one tells them to just get over it. In fact Germany rightfully continues to apologize and PAY reparations to try and redress their past sins.
@@badfinger5754 Dems will say every republican is evil. Biden said Romney was going to put us back in chains (black people). Romney, the most moderate Republican in a generation was an evil oppressor, remember? Which Republican is going to be acceptable? Liz Cheney? The dems hated her until she hated Trump, they will hate her again if the time ever comes. They are already gearing up for the "DeSantis is Hitler" ads.
@@badfinger5754 Bill is not a Republican. He is just not an arrogant prick who thinks he has the moral high ground.
@@badfinger5754 You totally missed the point. The world needs more liberals like maher and less like you. This is why conservatives are starting to like Maher. You're allowed to be liberal, no conservative has a problem with that. However, some of the stuff the party does it outright insanity. Maher recognizes that. That woman at the end, does not.
This kind of conversation needs to keep happening. I also blame the media for making it a us against them scenario. There’s huge money to be made pandering to confirmation bias.
yes, we need to hold the media accountable
11:51 as long as you people talk like that. You are my enemy.
Steve H - that makes you part of the problem.
the media, the candidates & their corporate donors are indeed responsible for their share of the blame, but as voting ADULTS we are all responsible for our actions, who we elect, who we support & who we come to believe are wrong, so if there is to be healing & compromise, the MAGA cult- A.K.A. the evangelical far-right GOP need to fist admit what Trump is, what he has done & hold him responsible for it, then they need to admit what they have done in support of him as more than just a candidate on a ballot because nobody has had such a cult following or merchandising like Trump. Trace Adkins is wrong in that he & those on his side of this political divide do have something to apologize for & sins to repent as a result of that. Denial won't work here. If the media lost their viewers because we were sick of their divisive rhetoric they'd change what they do to regain ratings much the same as the parties would shift their platforms to regain votes as the GOP sold their souls to retain the MAGA support. They made a conscious choice of power over integrity & their base let it happen by playing their part. Those who suffered & died as a result of Trump's reign & rhetoric deserve more than just "oops: our bad" or worse: "I have nothing to apologize for".
Bullshit. Trump divided the media too when he started calling CNN fake news. They played it more down the middle before he deliberately went after their anchors, setting the stage for said anchors to push back.
This is a fundamental misunderstanding of the how and why.
Definitely one of my favorite overtime’s ever!
JULIA WAS THE ONLY ONE WHO DIDNT UNDERSTAND THE ASSIGNMENT.
this is why i respect Bill Maher. i love that he's like "im in a blue state and i basically agree with them, but i dont wanna go along with everything they say". if you 100% agree with everything your party says, you aren't making your own choices, you are a tribalist.
There's a difference between saying that you don't agree with everything the party says or advocates for and then in the same breath saying that the other choice is thinking that what the Republicans endorse is somehow better. No, not even close. The two parties are so vastly different that even if I don't agree with the establishment wing of the Democratic party on some policy, I'm not going to endorse a Republican policy or vote for them. The Republican party should be done and gone. It is an ancient relic that should have died long ago. They want us to live in ancient, medieval times. We are in the 21st century! As Wayne from Wayne's World said, "Live in the now!" Maher is now a Republican apologist and it's absolutely disgusting!
@@bcrusher3 No he's NOT a Republican apologist.
@@SuhaibZafar explain how someone who apologizes on behalf of Republicans for the way they vote is not a Republican apologist.
@@SuhaibZafar I've watched Bill since Politically Incorrect, and he's unfortunately as of late become a GOP Apologist. I don't like that he has, but it's what he has become, regardless of my personal feelings.
@@bcrusher3 _"There's a difference between saying that you don't agree with everything the party says or advocates for and then in the same breath saying that the other choice is thinking that what the Republicans endorse is somehow better."_
At what point in his career has Maher ever made such a claim? You aren't paying attention to what is being said.
Saying _'I understand your position'_ [sometimes] is not apologetics and _sometimes_ even Repuglicans have valid arguments to make.
Absolute BEST Show and Overtime since the beginning of "Politically Incorrect," IMHO. I hate podcasts, but I would listen to Bill, John and Julia talk for weeks. John Meacham is goddamned National Treasure.
I agree. The show has been "meh" for some time. Tonight had everything it used to have.
Love Jon!
Was it great? Nobody talked about the real issue, that both parties are bought and paid for by the super rich and they argue around the edges while bleeding the working class dry. How did we get to the point that our choice was Clinton or Trump? I despise them both. Why was the man I supported cheated, straight up cheated twice? Bill Clinton was a Republican wish list president, his choices led to an almost Great Depression, and the people who orchestrated that got bonuses. Fuck them, fuck them all.
We need civil destroy feminist tyranny I don’t agree everything with trump . Id rule law break constitution then this is all bs . Roit not attack
you forgot one
I could watch a full hour of this panel alone.
Good god, bill keep up this kind of work. You need to show that there’s a middle ground we can meet at. Not extreme left or right.
Political discourse keeps a nation on course. Opposing views and respectfully debating. How it should be done. One of the best episodes and overtime! 👏
Damn... Jon Meacham is so easy to listen to. The man is brilliant. Other guests were really good too. People with different views from different places but all managed to make good points and it was funny too. Insightful and humorous. A good combo.
His head is up his a@@ on many issues.
Indeed. Jon Meacham is to history what Neil deGrasse Tyson is to physics.
How rare on this show does someone speak and the audience is quiet.
Until he speaks of trickle down person... Then the bologna starts... Just saying...
But he does get more handsome w/ time... Lol. 😝😝😝
Jon needs to be sharper with his Lincoln facts...
the moment the guy said law, i knew the next word that came out of his mouth would be about January 6th, this show cant go five minutes without bringing up Trump
I still want to know why the capitol police just let people in if it was damn bad?
We will be regurgitating the indigestible lump of vanity & crassness called Trump for decades! Get used to it!
@@mrbob4u495 Overwhelm.
@@billman5379 Aye. The capitol boss lady (Pelosi) didn't want, nor did she ask for, extra cops on scene, so I have read.
I actually like Bill Maher now for not putting Trace Adkins in a bad spot.
If I could have Trace Adkins' voice for one day, the opportunities would be limitless.
It's not the voice you have, within reason, it's how you carry that voice.
@@randolphpinkle4482 Nah, it's the voice. 🤣
Since you have it for a day…the opportunities will be limited, to that day
seriously ! those are some golden vocal chords !
Oddly I find him to be seriously creepy. I had never heard of him before this show.
This was one of the best "overtimes" I've ever seen. Every person made me deliberate about my views. I love intelligent conversation. I know people think you should not talk about religion and politics but I learn so much when I do with people who are willing to discuss it and listen to each other.
And, Thank You Rebecca W., as of the time of my reply, you were in the top 3 comments. I would add that Bill's conclusion statement here was one of his best. As I listened to Julia, I had the sometime same reaction - fuck MAGA. But like Bill, I *try* to understand the Trump voter and even MAGA. My dad was a life-long (84) Democratic Party voter, before Trump absorbed the Republican Party. He voted for the monster... twice. The first time, I adamantly opposed him. When "grab 'em by the pussy" was news, he called Trump a "douchebag". But he told me in the same conversation tho, that he was still going to vote for the douchebag. After Tucker Carlson and FOX 'News' supported and defended Trump, and to this day, during his term in office, my dad's brain was so MAGA-addled that he ended up voting a second time for the "orange man"... which, was no surprise. My point is, I knew my dad for some 70+ yrs as my hero. He is no longer my hero, but I know deep down he is Théoden and Tucker is Gríma Wormtongue.
@@theranchokid and things are better now? how
@@oldmcdonald3376 Your question is not about my reply because if it was then it makes no sense. I assume that you are doing the trolling... "with Trump out of Office and the Leftist Biden in Office... Things are better Now? And, if so... How are they better?" thing. MAGA is very efficient in their use of language; unfortunately, those shortcuts often come with a price. In this case, expressing what you want me to do, which is to engage with you on your terms. And that my friend, I will not.
@@theranchokid You are a prime example of the "Evil finger pointing" They discussed. You don't like Trump, we get it and that's fine, but you need to stop viewing people as "Trump supporters" or "Non-Trump supporters" and start viewing everyone as humans. You will be much happier in life once you do that and let go of all your anger and hatred towards people you don't even know.
@@toddmintz4269 Says the person with "Trump 2020" as their avatar. You are still holding on to an election that ended almost two years ago. Also, I said I try to understand the Trump voter... Because they aren't just human but fellow Americans.
I felt like there was deep respect amongst everyone for each other except for the lady who seem to really come off with an attitude of disdain for the other half of the country.
This is so tiresome. Please read my multiple comments above.
@@joannloraine3790 your comments remain wrong and part of the problem, no matter how many times you write them. In fact, one could say they’ve become tiresome.
I'm blown away!! Great episode!! The part that got me was when Bill said we all have to live together. This is TRUE. We don't always have to agree, but can we just exist and want the same things without fighting?? We all just want TO BE.
so you respect the 2nd ammendment and my right to own an AR15, you expect the southern border to be secured, and there are two types of aliens (non citizens) in this country; those here legally and those here illegally, you respect the SCOTUS overturning RvW and putting decision back to States, you agree that transgenderism shouldn't be taught let alone be encouraged to kids under the age of 18, you're outraged at the suppression of the hunter Biden Laptop story, so close to election AND you're outraged at the role the FBI has played in that censorship ..... yeah I thought so!!
Loffe is clearly off her rocker though and was there for a fight, driven by emotion and a misconception of Republicans.
Thank you Bill for having this conversation. I wish there were more late night hosts like you.
Oh really
Bill shut up so arrogant
Stop interrupting bill stop talking over people
I really like Jon Meacham. Very intelligent, well-spoken man.
Best panel of the season 👌 👏
Really a deep conversation! ✌️🌏☮️
Good conversation and 2 mostly all emotions. Pink lady stfu
I wish Trace Adkins had a chance to respond to Julie Loffe's long-winded diatribe against Trump.
Loffe would vote for Jack the ripper if he was a democrat
This was a good overtime, I really appreciate the view points from all of them and it wasn't just a shouting match or argument. We need to get back to a point where even if you disagree with one another there can still be a respectful conversation. I feel that this is definitely something our country is missing.
They Launched an attack on Trump and America .. divided the Nation! Ruined friendships, famillies and more... so maybe before Jan 6th they should consider that also. Shithole country's? Instead we turn our country into one under Biden
Pure TDS, glad you got your days injection.
This whole episode was excellent. I wish everyone could hear these ideas.
Shame the White Woman had no "ideas". It was just mindless "this offended me" shit while poor country guy was never offered an opportunity to defend himself . Telling of the times!
It is ALL about integrity. Either you have it, or you don't. NOTHING else matters.
Julia just can’t understand other people have priorities
Crime
Immigration
Education
CRT
Economy
Jobs
Rural Americans
Religious beliefs
Abortions
Guns
Wherever
Right Or wrong we can debate .. but everyone has different order of priority
All this segment did was tell me Julia is part of the problem we have in this country.
Another 'weakest link ' that can't separate policy from feelings. Sticks and Stones.
The Comrade is demanding Truth and Reconciliation after the J6 showtrials. She really is the spawn of her ancestors.
Julia Loffe doesn’t understand that some people are not privileged enough to vote based on feelings, but must vote based on policies.
So no other Republicans were running for president in 2016, only Trump?
What policies???
You mean of course that Ms Ioffe still believes in genuine moral concerns as good reasons to NOT vote for a creep like Trump -and good on her for that even if Trumps world thinks that morality is old hat! She comes from a line of Russians who voted with their feet (as did my wife & step-daughters) and her point goes a lot deeper as its very clear to caring immigrants who left their own despots behind that most of his voters were all too aware that Trump was a scheister/crook/con-man/racist/mysoginist but were suckers for his bull-crap anyway. Now theyre in No Mans Land. Just as in Russia all those who welcomed strong-man Putin thought he was a savior of Russia when infact he's destroying it
Julia Loffe has standards of decency, pity not more Americans did and do.
@Bryan Mack TF????
I love the way Jon Meacham casually mentions the Civil War battlefield he grew up near and then mentions the battlefield Trace practically lives on. It's a compliment that he knows where Trace lives, history wise.
Trace has a deep voice and commanding attitude. It doesn’t make his points more valid-it just sounds macho. I’ve not seen three points of view presented so well with Bill in a long time. Trace brought up yet another interesting pov with “America Aflame”.
Meachum and Atkins have to be the two most soothing actual voices ever on Real Time at the same time lol
you’re so right! i felt so at ease listening to both these gentlemen
Once again, an insightful, honest conversation. Our country needs so much more of this and so much less divisive side taking. Bill spot on as usual.
The last speaker, she was really divisive. She seemed to forget the deplorable language. Both sides are terrible. When we have the ingroup forgiving their own atrocities.. our country will never heal.
@@michaelmravetz6276 I agree she was out of line but because the rest of the conversation was good and decent and insightful, she stuck out like a sore thumb and Bill called her out for it.
Before leaving high school, and then at college, everyone should listen to Tim Minchin giving his graduation speech at UWA. There is so much in it that applies here. And it’s funny.
@@michaelmravetz6276 I had the same thought. She was not well versed on her side's missteps.
Enlightening, thoughtful conversation. Very much enjoyed this.
The way Meecham looks at Tracy Atkins while the latter is describing a book on history really shows how much John cares about people’s understanding of history. It’s the face of a person who has truly dedicate his life to educating the public on their own history. He doesn’t correct, he doesn’t nitpick, he sits there, listens, and takes in what Tracy is saying. He then just fills in the picture that the others are painting. Truly a master educator.
Trace Adkins - you know who started calling the other side EVIL? NEWT GINGRICH.
yes alot of people credit him with the beginning of all the vitriol you see in politics and life today... he made it an okay thing to call the opposite side your enemy and treat them as such... I cannot tell you how much I despise this man...for who he has always been and what he has done to our country.... and it blows me away that even today he is being treated like such a hero on faux news and other outlets he appears on...
My history may be off, but wasn't Dennis Hastert the one that started the whole thing?
That crap goes back to the beginning of time. Try again.
His "contract on America" was likely the beginning. Yes, I know that it was called contract for America, but my discription is closer to the truth of the matter
I’m a conservative and never liked Gingrich: there’s something fundamentally wrong with him - exactly like Hilary Clinton 😄
My goodness tonight's show was good. So informative and entertaining and hilarious, and full of very excellent points.
That lady have no problems with pedo Biden, her arguments are just a talking points
dont you think the audio sucked tho
It looked to me like a panel of liberals STILL refusing to understand. They're still like 2 years behind what I think. As a person who left the left, it pleases me to see them failing because it gives me confidence my choice was correct.
When they finally get around to asking and listening, then they will have learned something.
Had pretty much given up on the show recently, as it often seemed to have gotten stale, and Bill seemed kind of jaded and repetitive. But this one was quite good, and real, intelligent conversation.
@@niemand262 That's because you are special and have superior intelligence. You must have achieved such amazing things in your life. It's surprising such an individual has time to comment on You Tube videos. Please, use your precious time and energy wisely, the world needs it.
I'm a woman and I make fun of women's menstrual cycles.
That's fine. Just don't want you representing me for public office.
@@Raja1938 What I'm commenting on is the fact that him being a man has nothing to do with it. You, however, seem think him being a politician is the issue. I agree. He hits low and dirty, and it shouldn't for public consumption or office. But, many people ignore that about him and would rather suffer his crassness than face a Democratic administration.
Hello👋how are you doing and how is the weather conditions there, I see you're country music lover fan of Trace Adkins that's lovely I hope you are staying safe and okay..I'm sorry to bother you, but if you find this message embarrassing pardon my manners..God bless you may your heart desires come through I hope to hear from you.
This is a discussion that should be shown in high school history classes across our nation. This is what thoughtful debate and discussion about the direction of our country is all about. Everyone in this Overtime has thoughtful and valuable opinions and expresses their point well. And most of the comments from viewers about this Overtime and episode are particularly respectful and insightful and should be considered by our youngest minds coming of age also.
Teachers alert! This is a great Overtime and episode for American schools, and any other country experimenting with democracy.
I'm Australian, I love America, I worry for Her.
The world needs a united States of America ,now more than ever.
God bless America 🇺🇸
Always a pleasure listening to Jon Meacham talk with such a calming tone and also showing his humor.
Yeah, but his points are rambling and have nothing to do with the questions. It's hard to follow along when he's not.
Doesn’t he kinda sound like matthew mcconaughey!?
@@Matthew-ve7uv No, you're wrong. His points are intelligently supported by his comments.
@@Matthew-ve7uv Like Andrew Schultz (comedian) said to an audience member about a joke she didn't get or didn't understand. And I paraphrase; "Your brain doesn't get it and it's ok. All people have perspective and bias that is different. You could be a genius at your job, but that doesn't mean that hard vocabulary, history and/or analogy are your forté." In my opinion, It's the lazy way of the mind that turns logical analysis into emotional analysis. Which is why trump won. People want their conclusion to be reached and feel smarter. Say things in a simple way and it somehow makes sense, even though the argument is flawed. Complicate it and people think that you're an "elite" thus, weakening any logical argument analysis.
Ya, I wish other right of center networks would put him on as well Karen.
You Made Overtime Great Again! 🙂
I'd be down for just an episode long overtime. I find the conversational comedy far more interesting than the scripted stuff.
Easily one of the best overtime segments
Perhaps one of the most useful segments in years. There is a place for decency, humanity and intellect!
Once again trying to persuade the guests to your way of thinking even when it was obvious Trace Adkins had his own opinion. I really love and respect him for that.
And once again the emotional woman almost threw a tantrum when someone didn't agree with her.
Three on the panel nearly completely agree with one another. Their comments were nuanced. Of course it will be civil.
😍 Amazing she out-brained both bill & the cowboy hat 👏 bravo🏆
She was the child in the room and it was obvious to everyone there.
I agree n like her, but did she really ? 1 of 4 opinions.....
Not even nearly right!!! But thanks for showing us who you are!
I really like this discussion
is it just me🤔 or are these overtimes are getting better?🤨 maybe they all should be about 15 minutes long😏
Good idea!
The woman in pink thinks Trump supporters have something to “repent” for?? Well, I think Biden supporters need to repent how about that?! Also, the moron on the very left actually think January 6th was an attempt to “overthrow” democracy. Lol no one is that stupid to believe a bunch of unarmed idiots could do anything but stall time for a few hours. I lost brain cells just listening to him
one of the best shows ever jon meachum is a national treasure
I could listen to him all day
...dude drops knowledge on yo' ass!
Meacham is a treasure of the Democratic party, but certainly not a national nonpartisan treasure. He is a well spoken well groomed partisan hack.
That woman was so cringy. She must have a pretty lucky life if her biggest worries are somebody said something mean and those are the main reasons to vote for and against
Listening to someone's speech is the easiest way to learn about them. It reveals integrity and character
YES SPEECH MATTERS
IT CAN CAUSE INJURY AND DEATH. HATE SPEECH SHOULD NEVER BE COSIDERED THE SAME AS FREE SPEECH
FULL STOP.
This was a fabulous segment!
An excellent OVERTIME!
Great people talking facts and debating as rational humans. Thank you
You think “rational” because they can quote some civil war history. Please. In the bubble, self entitled humans. They can’t just disagree, they demand others atone. They can GF themselves.
You mean until the woman inserted her emotional bullshit in the end of it?
Doesn't mean she's wrong...
@@jamesmiller5331 Exactly. Calling women vulgarities as Trump did disqualifies supporters from citizenship in her mind, but Biden actually assaulting a young staffer in his office, that and the many many other complaints by women against Biden for what he did, that needs no atonement for supporting him.
@@jamesmiller5331 it was hardly "personal bullshit".
Listen again.
She outlined ways Trump purposely inflamed differences and hatred in a manipulative way, as well Trump's deeply flawed character that should have disqualified him from being a candidate.
People from the so-called "party of responsibility" walk away from owning up to responsibility for his being elected in the first place and his attempts at authoritarian rule as well as a coup, because their hatred of the other side blinded them or believe their hatred of liberals and progressives gives them a pass.
I feel good that Jon Meacham has President Biden's ear.
but not his memory
Both of them are awful.
As long as he doesn't have Biden's diaper.
There's nothing wrong with Biden's memory. That's just a bunch of right wing BS. Did you listen to his latest speech? I suspect not.
@@belovedrock.
My impression is that the Democratic Party of America is carrying out a Maoist\Marxist take over of America. The FBI, IRS, CIA and big tech are politicizing their mission to run the country. If the Democrats maintain control of both houses of Congress in the November election. The country will be under complete totalitarian control before 2024. It's almost there now.
Brace yourself for the Communist take over of America.
But as Dennis Miller used to say: That's my opinion, I could be wrong. Time will tell.
Been waiting for such a good, deep, overtime discussion
"You are wrong" can be walked back.
"You are evil" cannot be walked back.
Wanna know why this was such a great show? Neither Jon nor Trace felt a need to shout. They both appreciated the conversation. And I think their demeanor kept Bill in check. And we are the beneficiaries. Well done, gentlemen.
Of course the liberal white woman was the one making it personal and insulting everyone.
We need forgiveness for the unarmed INSURRECTION of Jan 6th?😂😂 No, democrats need forgiveness for the democrat riots of 2020 that killed dozens of people, injured 2000 cops and destroyed entire BLACK neighborhoods. Democrats need forgiveness for mutilating children with hormones and surgeries. Democrats need forgiveness for the open border that's allowing drugs, particularly Fentanyl, to flood in killing a RECORD 107,000 Americans last year. This year is on pace to shatter that.
Trump brought peace to the Middle East, was the first president in decades to not start another war, and that idiot is still talking about him having nuclear codes.
Unite with that lying, deceitful evil? NEVER
@@johnpeter8226 The irony is indeed palpable.
You have to admit she was very single minded. She had one point to make and tried to make it multiple times where In the others, Bill, Jon, spoke in varied responses to multiple issues. Her finger pointing seemed almost child like when measured to the complete conversation. Everyone’s had enough of that behavior I hope.
@@brettwallace1604 You really need to tune your receptors and actually listen to the woman, she spoke about various issues, several of which she is an expert of. Saying she only tried to make one point clearly indicates you either didn't watch the show or have comprehension difficulties.
@@Ketraar She was right to take Big Hat to task. She rightly cites the enabling of Trump & how those who did fit Meacham's category of those who want forgiveness without repentance. Big Hat was too swaggeringly self-righteous to even fault Trump as he was treated well "personally" ~ so he feels he doesn't have anything to be forgiven for. Ioffe was detailing the divisiveness ~ which Trump played up ~ which she knows was designed by Putin, but that would have been making too pointed an indictment.
Best overtime I've seen since they started this. What a great conversation
very 1 sided with the crowd.
@@deathfire096 pne sided? The conversation was about how to get past the one-sided Manichean views of too many Americans these days.
Everyone spoke very eloquently about a very 'sensitive' subject. Hate is a hard thing to give up. Doesn't do no one no good. Shame people already picked sides. Keep at it bill.👍
So nice of Bill to finally let the woman speak, after the segment was more than half way over. Even then, ended up interrupting and talking over Julia Oiff.
She was starstruck
This was a great show because everybody was allowed to make their points,and we all got to hear it.FINALLY LOL.
Great show Bill! Keep it up! We need it!!!!
Thanks to Mr. Maher for making a space for real discussion. Kudos to you for really taking the time to understand the frustrations and honest concerns of us who vote for the lessor of two evils.
AMEN
As it often happens, those that speak the least are the ones with the most powerful thoughts
I always appreciate Meacham's historical perspective.
The voices of Meachum and Adkins are to die for literally and figuratively.
WOW! Is there any substance to your life... or only sexual double entendre?
as in literally dead, not breathing? are you slow or something?
@@Nick-gk6hj well literally to die for literally means not breathing. It also means no brain function as you clearly demonstrated by asking this question!
literally?!?!
@@B_M now that you confirmed your statement, I feel sorry for you that a voice makes you want to die. I suggest professional help, or proper use of the English language at the very least.
Trace came across as likeable
I gotta say, I don't always see eye to eye with Bill, but what his final word was in that OT was very ok point.
Overtime is usually nothing more than ten random minutes of chatter with one person doing most of the talking. But *this* one was intense all around.
If you found this intense, then I suggest you move out of your parents place and get a job.
@@prezidenttrump5171 In two weeks I turn 70 you strange auto-triggered little troll. 😂🤣
@@prezidenttrump5171 shut up 🙄
Oh man that pearl-clutcher saying "they must repent" was creepy in a Salem witch trial kinda way.
This genetic descendant of the OG totalitarians, who can't recognize the resemblance of J6 to a show trial, who supports a party that burns down cities, who topples statues, who denies the election of 2016, who attempts an insurrection (by her standard) by storming the white house gates, who establishes their own CHAZ/CHOP confederacy; is now demanding that we have Truth and Reconciliation? She really is the spawn of her comrades.
😂🤣😂🤣🤣
She was the only sane one.
Trace Adkins! 🙌🏼🥰💖
Amen to this entire conversation!
John Meacham is amazing. Having historical perspective is critical in figuring our way out of our current mess.
Positive suprise to me..real speaker
Meacham has had major influence on Biden's speeches- how can he not be asked about the Independence Hall speech. If he didn't help write it, what did he think of it (since it certainly seemed more divisive than inclusive) .Big oversight.
Bill - I’ve said this before… I appreciate your return. Your language of inclusiveness is touching millions of Americans; and, hopefully resurrecting our mutual belief in and love of our Constitutional Republic. Your messaging tonight was not a one sided gang bang on whom ever you have chosen to disapprove. I approve of your journey to create dialogue leading to a respectful listening and discourse of shared values and visions for the future of our Republic. Bravo Sir for the bold risk taking to bring us together. 🇺🇸
Now go get some right wingers to do the same if you want real progress for our county.
I love Trace.
Lincoln working with Fredrick Douglas= THE BEST for a foundational future for America!!!
All I can say is wow. Great overtime. Very intelligent and thoughtful
Very well done segment. Validates my move away from progressive activism toward communal organizing and direct support for families in my community. Much more humbling and rewarding in lieu of constantly sprinting from one national cultural issue to the next- never seeing results on that scale.
Bookmarking this video to share and rewatch 👏
Well done Emily. Think for YOURSELF! Choose what subjects and policies matter. Identify your passion and follow it. Worry not about the rest.
Here's one thing to keep from alienating people and making their eyes roll to the back of their head: don't reference "the patriarchy." It's ivory tower narrativism that has no place in normal people's lives.
What you said is basically the entire idea behind “12 rules for life”.
"Community organizing" my fucking ass. I was banned from my local mutual aid community when they learned I voted for Trump. We were screamed at on social media while city blocks burned when you idiots were activated by the George Floyd crap. People have been threatened, deplatformed, assaulted, hunted down by antifa. This is not a "both sides" thing. One side has clearly benefited from permissive institutional privilege. You want to walk this back but you don't want to admit any of this actually happened. There's no walking this back. You unleashed something and there's no putting the genie back in the bottle.
The "Patriarchy" seems like a "national construct" to me.
"Not a single drop of water should make it to the ocean without running through a hydroelectric dam". DAM right!
She should apologize to us. She more or less just said that everyone that voted for Trump has to agree with her and apologize to her because we did vote for Trump. did we ask for your apology for voting for Clinton and Biden?
Jon Meacham is one of my heroes. 💖
One of the best Overtime's and shows in a while... I can listen to these 4 for hours. 👍🏻
not in small part because of that VOICE! wow. I am not a country music fan, but I'd listen to Trace read me a shampoo bottle.
I’d like to listen to the
Silence of Julia
Someone must've hit the mute button when the woman was talking then. Lmao. Huge props to Bill, Trace and the other guy for not slamming that senseless idiot down in a less cordial manner. How they composed themselves when she tried non stop to lecture everyone on how people vote for the candidate and only that person. Instead of what Bill was saying, which is, they vote for the party who will meet their needs and concerns, it just so happens the face of it at a given time is said candidate. It doesn't mean they agree, like, or condone his behaviour. But because he is the only option to prevent policies people don't agree with from going through, they are left voting for him. Her stupid and ridiculous logic is that because Trump is grotesque and repugnant, then everyone should've voted for Hilary. Boom. Done. End of election. Who gives a damn about the policies or what is important to you and your family. As long as you can say I like this person more than the other, you did your civic duty. She is stuck in elementary school and highschool elections that are just horny kids voting on popularity because no one can change anything anyways
@@kila4 What the hell is that supposed to mean?
I’m waiting for one with Trace Atkins, Morgan Freeman and Sam Elliott.
Like it or not Maher's point at the end was dead on.
i love having conversations with liberals or socialists. they ask me a question and i answer then i ask them one and they say i dont want to talk about this and cant even sit there and talk about it. its weird. i think it might be because they are bombarded by the MSM to hate Trump but they dont actually know why. its all emotions and no brain