Mukul Bhatnagar We South Indians know the differentiation between Urdu and Hindi. Urdu have less Sanskrit words compare to Hindi. From Urdu ,Hindi formed by replacing some Persian and Arabic words using Sanskrit. But Hindi also having Persian and and Arabic words. Urdu written in Arabic format, Hindi written in Devnagiri script. This is the difference. Urdu came from Persia language and from Urdu , Hindi formed. Both language combinely called as hindustani. First of all North Indians show your patriotic on your mother tongue, then show patriot on Persian language hindi. If English is foreign language from western country,absolutely Hindi also foreign language from Persia. Give equal importance to all native languages in India.
+Ananth S Thank you very much for enlightening me about my mother tongue. Hindi has evolved from Apbransha, an ancient, corrupted form of Prakrit which itself was a corrupted form of Sanskrit. In medieval ages it became 'khari boli' which is and was spoken in Madhya Pradesh and Western UP. During the Islamic invasions and rule, first Turkic then Persian became the official language of the courts and administration and remained so till the mid 17th century, when Urdu came into being. Urdu, which was earlier known as 'Rekhta' (literal meaning- to draw, to derive) came into being when the muslim soldiers interacted with the local populace. It picked up the grammar and syntax of khadi boli and local dialects and adopted words from Persian, Arabic and Sankrit/Khadi Boli, justifying its name. Besides Urdu, Khadi Boli continued to be spoken in 17th, 18th and 19th century in the name of 'Hindavi' or 'Hindustani' despite being over shadowed by Urdu. An example of this could be cited when Bihar adopted 'Hindi' sometime in late 1880s as its official language differentiating with, and removing Urdu. When India became independent in 1947, Hindi was adopted as official language of India, and language of United Provinces (later Uttar Pradesh), Central India and Rajasthan. Hindi is a highly evolved language, very much like the part its spoken in- going through massive political, cultural and socio-political upheavals. Before south indians tell us which language to show patriotism to, they should learn that their own languages- tamil, kannada and telugu have heavily borrowed words from Sanskrit, Sinhala (which are both north Indian Aryan languages), Persian and Arabic. Please do not create a wishful opinion about a language that you do not understand/speak/know.
I am a Malayali that has spent 46 of my 54 yrs. in the US. Thus, I am fluent in English and can speak rudimentary Malayalam. Whenever I see an Indian in the US, they instinctively approach me and speak in Hindi. I explain that I don't speak Hindi and they seem outraged. Some then ask if I am Indian or ask why I don't speak Hindi. Then they say if I am Indian, I should learn Hindi. India is a collaboration of various states, each with its own language, culture, and traditions. It has been my experience that most educated people in India speak English. Why would N. Indians impose their language on people that have their own language and values? Why are N. Indians not learning Tamil if they want to live or do business in Tamil Nadu? One of the primary reasons why Bangladesh (E. Pakistan) broke away from Pakistan was because they demanded that they speak Urdu. If people want to learn Hindi, fine, but don't try and enforce your language on others.
Moron, go and read about bangladesh revolution. In 1948, Governor-General Muhammad Ali Jinnah declared that "Urdu, and only Urdu" would be the federal language of Pakistan.[32][33] However, Urdu was historically prevalent only in the north, central, and western region of the subcontinent; whereas in East Bengal, the native language was Bengali, one of the two most easterly branches of the Indo-European languages.[34] The Bengali-speaking people of Pakistan constituted over 30% of the country's population. The government stand was widely viewed as an attempt to suppress the culture of the eastern wing. The people of East Bengal demanded that their language be given federal status alongside Urdu and English. The Language Movement began in 1948, as civil society protested the removal of the Bengali script from currency and stamps, which were in place since the British Raj.
Sunil Thomas If we want to unite India let it be with Hindi which is accepted among all the communities except South India. Why South Indians are not willing to be integrated to our society ? If a tamilian comes to north India to live there, will it be possible without Hindi ? Stop being so narrow minded, we respect your language, therefore respect Hindi please. And if you don’t let it be, but you won’t be considered as Indian. If you hate so much our language then why don’t you separate from us ?
Saitom Sai That holds true if they come and stay in North India. Then they will surely learn. But the majority of the North Indians do not learn the local language even after 10 years. In the beginning, we speak Hindi for convenience but people don't learn at all.
B K GOGOI yeaah ok when islamist and chinese will take your state then dont com crying to new delhi for help. Anf if you come to Delhi to serk help do speak hindi.
Dai Moostaf.. Only Pakistani language people (Hindians/ HIndi people) don't understand India languages. They are foreign traitors. Get lost Mr Pakistani.
when Abdul Kalam was president he never forced anyone to learn Tamil.... when Deve Gowda was prime minister he never forced anyone to learn Kannada.... when NarasimhA Rao was prime minister he never forced anyone to learn Telugu.... when Atal Bihari Vajpayee was prime minister he never forced anyone to learn Hindi.... it's time for Fekuuuussss government to learn some moral ethics.......from his seniors......
Multi-regional, unlike any other Indian languages as they are restricted to one State more or less. Also, apart from Hindi Belt, most people in states like Punjab, Gujarat, Maharashtra, and to some extent Bengal & Orissa, can all speak fluent Hindi. In fact over 50% of the country can speak good Hindi, and over 40% call it their mother tongue. It only makes sense to use it as the link language over English, or any other Indian language. Language is just a tool, you tool. This coming from a half-Sindhi, half-Punjabi, born & brought up in Gujarat, whose mother tongue is Saraiki.
+Ram Kumar Mughal era created Urdu, the language of the tents of Muslim soldiers who invaded India. Hindi is mainly Sanskrit mixed with Brajabuli, Maithili, Bhojpuri, Bengali, Audh dialect, etc. It was created not by the Mughals who used to speak in Farsi. WIKI was created by the CIA; do not believe it.
Mr Mustaff, Pakistani language people i..e Hindian are the Autistic people as they dont speak Indian language, only yap around in Pakistani language Hindi.
Siva, people also say English is an international language, though the constitution of UN doesn't say so anywhere. But the fact is, since it is an international lingua franca, we call it an 'international language'. Also, it's constitution of the US, UK or Australia doesn't mention English as an official or a national language, but it is a de facto official or national language of those countries. Same thing goes about Japan, where constitution doesn't declare Japanese an official language, but it's a de facto official or national language there. This way, Hindi is our de facto national language, though the constitution doesn't say so.
+Amit Shah but india is not usa or uk or australia or japan(where 90% people understand one language) , there is no country in the world as diverse as india-22 official recognized languages in the constitution
So how do you want to connect the country without establishing a language as a link language? If the country is such diverse, there's a need for something common to make it a nation, we need a common language to communicate with each other, there are other multi lingual countries in this world, where they have established a particular language as a link language. So India will never give a special privilege to it's few states, if the entire world follows this trend, our country is no different to them.
entire world even chinese learning english and french were failed in promoting their language as a internet language go and see how many english channels in france( EX-FRANCE24),germany,russia(RT), english is globalised language okay as for as what hindi you are promoting fully sansritized which is not fit in modern world to progress further and imposition of hindi not at all acceptable why you are declaring hindi as defacto national language is this not arrogance,popularisation of hindi take place its own way you dont need indian taxpayers money spending on promotong only hindi which is younger when compared with tamil,bengali,telugu etc so allow people voluntarily to learn what they want and dont declare yourselves hindi as even defacto national language I am from andhra i learned hindi as a second language from 6-10 th class,how many hindiwallahs learning other indian languages and giving respect to southern languages -give respect and take respect otherwise serious consequences will follow
English is unavoidable in this industrialized world. You Hindi Speakers only require to learn English. But what about others they have to learn both English and hindi. It's a double burden for us. It's a very unfair govt. Already Our language is ruined by English.
மொழிகளை சமமாக மதிக்க கற்றுகொள்ளுங்கள், இதுதான் அனைத்து மக்களையும் சமமாக மதிப்பதற்கு சமம். warning for central gov from tamilnadu: many language one country, one language many nation.
+parai isai these rigid narrow hindu bramhanical hindi bigots dont understand brother the seriousness of linguistic identity that is harm to our country if they continue with this policy
+parai isai Sanskrit should be the language of India for the world. Forced imposition of Hindi on India will divide India. Only Sanskrit can unite India. It is very insulting for us when foreigners laugh at us hearing that two Indians are talking to each other in English. It is high time to change this slave mentality.
+Dipak Basu we are agaisnt Sanskrit as much as Hindi... learn what ever pleases you , you have no right to say what we should learn ..... you tomorrow will say that foreigners are laughing that Indians are wearing wester clothing , so we can't change back to dhothis and mundu , even if we do that you will say they are laughing because we are dressed differently , so national dress must be made ... some kind of uniform would be much better , isn't it?. tomorrow they may say you Indians being from one country follow different religions , what are you going to do then .. ghar wapsi...? we live for ourselves not for others
Hahah who the fuck are you to say that... If you have the balls to make Sanskrit national language make it and see what happens .... In fact there is a book by a person which sound very similar to you name... DD Basu... Ah some bhakt , thinks they know every thing. And again am not Tamil am kannadiga . so fuck you...
cool bro this mindset will cause harm to our motherland,yes Sanskrit is a great language but you cant impose it on other people Tamils are as much indians as you are,you have no right to say they have to leave india Iam from andhra we have three language policy(telugu-hindi-english)
kannan sivakumar this is the reason u didnt got supoort from restvof indis on tamil problem in sri lanka and what happened due to that. Extinction dear.
@@pksindi8948srilankan tamilians living in india in many parts of south maybe u dont know they seek asalyam they should have lived rightfully in elam if india wouldn't have involved
As an foreign born south Indian malayalee, I would agreed that Hindi should take prevalence over the languages. One can still keep their language and used it locally. Knowing more languages is always a plus in commercial business life. Hindi can be seen as unifying language for the whole of India. This can be since in countries like China, Malaysia, etc where there is a national language define to tap our top communication barrier. Sometime change may be hard to accept but one must be adaptable to change for growth.
if you are not in India , being born else where, we don't care what you think... if you want to have a say .. come live on India and we can have debate ... else f off
No country has enemy country language has national language. Why India want to replace India language with Pakistani language Hindi. Pakistani language HIndi cant be accepted as national language. First of all how can the Pakistani language speaking people i.e. Hindians even be accepted as Indians. After all the treasons committed. The scoundrels are internal enemy people.
I endorse Alyque. You cannot impose Hindi. And to confused 'Hindi imposers', nobody is imposing English, people wanted to learn it so that they don't have to miss the bus full of opportunities. Hindi has to be learnt not from imposition but from liking. Tamil Nadu government had introduced English as medium of instruction in government schools just because parents preferred to put their children in English medium schools and NONE prefers to be in Hindi medium schools. If you don't have the courtesy to convince people about Hindi, DON'T IMPOSE IT! After all People's choice matters in democracy!
I think we all should join together and push Modi Ji to learn good English and converse effectively so he can deal well with western countries and make them understand what he is trying to say on behalf of our country.
Hindi is always optional and should not be enforced. Tamil is important to people of Tamil Nadu. Telugu is for Andra. Please don't enforce. Hindi is just a language like any other language of India.
***** I am a Malayalee :) I think Hindi should not be imposed. But Hindi will be spread organically. Hindi should be optional. South Indians don't hate Hindi. We in fact do learn Hindi. But it is the feeling of imposition that is in contention. This idea that in order to be 'Indian' you need to learn Hindi. I say no to that. :)
how does Hindi unite india? India is a land of diversity and that is what indians felt as Indianness. Don't impose or make hindi compulsory and lose Indianness.
Hindi was pushed by a very ugly politician of India Jag Jivan Ram in 1965. That had caused riots all over India. Hindi is a regional language of 3-4 states but not exclusively ( there are Bhojpuri, Audh Dialect, Pahari, Rajasthani, Khariboli in those states along with several tribal languages). Non-Hindi speaking states will never accept Hindi as the National Language.
U. R. Ananthmurty has Ph.D in English from UK. He was English professor. He produced a great literature work in Kannada. It's the mother tongue which makes people more empowered. India is an Union like European Union.
Tamil language is 2000 years old and spoken in US about 4lacs speak Tamil in US and it is one of nation language in Singapore, Malaysia, Srilanka and Mauritius There is a place called Amma Nagar I USA, carriabean is Tamil word Mediterranean, Cyprus is Tamil word
hindi should just be the link language. State Language first and 2nd Hindi. Not this colonial mindset that is still going on which makes English more used. India should become United and have in place there mother tongue/state language first then the link language which would be Hindi.
It's good that atleast in news channel people should stop calling any language other than hindi as regional language. After all hindi is just another regional language of about 9 states.
Personally I am against the imposition of Hindi; I think it is much easier to work with English. However, I would like to point out that Tamilnadu and Karnataka have gone to great lengths to impose Tamil and Kannada on the Telugu and Maratha populations of their states.
List of Regional languages(Recognized) goes like this..........Malayalam, Tamil, Telugu, Kannada, Odiya, Marati, Hindi... etc.... If Top most posts of Indian govt(e.g President, PM etc). prefer to speak in one of the regional language e.g Hindi then there should be provisions for live translations into remaining languages.
Instead of doing all ths first improve north states so that migration to south for jobs and livelihood will stop. Many hindi speaking people in karnataka andhra tamilnadu kerala does not speak kannada , telugu, tamil, malyalam.
one question from Tamil nadu. When hindi speaking states are not developed when compared to non hindi speaking states it shows that if you speak hindi you can not see any development in the country. why don't the hindi speaking states learn any of the south indian languages to develop and grow?
After accepting Hindi through out the country, some people could not guess what the danger would be. Later is it possible for non hindi speaking people to compete in all aspects specifically in competitive exams with people whose mother tongue is HINDI. For hindi speaking people , it is mother tongue and for us it is foreign language. In any competition there should be level playing field for justice / unbiased competition. More importantly non hindi speaking people will become second class citizens . Two languages are more than enough for anybody. Better concentrate on science & mathematics and create scientists to make India a technologically advanced country.
There is no word called national language in Constitution. No one can't declare Hindi as national language. Each individual has freedom to choose his favorite language.
Most of the bengalis do not want hindi to be the national language. We are very sensitive towards our language. Although Hindi is a sweet tongue, we cannot allow imposition of it by some language fanatics. First go and ask people of hindi belt to learn telegu, Manipuri, Hazong or Kamta language. জয় বাংলা।
Hindi is not a national language. How about Punjabi, Kashmiri, Rajastani, Gujrati, Marati, Kannada, Telugu, Konkani, Malayalam, Tamil, Bengali, Assamese, Manipuri, Tripuri ? So, with so many states speaking their local languages, how Hindi can be called Rashtra Bhasha ?? It is NOT !!!
Please dont force us to learn Hindi We the South Indians are having our own languages( TELUGU, TAMIL, KANNADA, MALAYALAM) we are pretty much happy with our languages, We don't want Hindi..! JAI HINDH
No one imposed english on you You learnt english for your professional needs English is the lingua franca of the world.. We dont need Hindi in our non hindi states..
Ananta murthy’s words should be made preamble of the National Language policy Hindi arguers in this debate We respect local languages We are not imposing Hindi but...but.... we need Hindi in UN.... so learn Hindi ... We are more in number so you need to learn.... Hindi wants to be like German or French so learn Hindi ....... Arey baba Kannada Tamil Telugu Malayalam are like German French Italian etc Will Germans stop using german language in favour of English It is Kannada not Kannad How will you feel if I call Hindi as Hindei or Hindam
अब हिंदी विश्व भाषा बन चुकी है और बहुत जल्द अंग्रेजी को भी पछाड़ देगी आज पूरे विश्व में सैकड़ों विश्वविद्यालय में हिंदी का पठन-पाठन हो रहा है यह हमारे लिए बहुत गर्व की बात है जय हिंद जय भारत🙏🙏
Why should the North impose Hindi on the South when there is already English a link language in the south. Moreover English is a useful language and ensures a good career, a better paying job and access to the global economy. If the RSS feels that they can sneakingly impose their agenda systematically in a phased manner across India they are going to be sorry as we the southerners are not going to be fooled so easily. We down the south are thrived because of our own languages and English as the link language and we don't intent to change it. Let's face it English is the language of Power which every aspiring Indian wants to master.
I don't understand how the people in central politics are dumb that they don't even know that India doesn't have a national language at all.. They happily exhibit their stupidity by saying that hindi is our national language.. Feel ashamed of it.
Manoj Shukla Because apart from ones mother tongue, learning English makes a lot of sense in getting jobs and understand what’s happening around world, whereas Hindi doesn’t help us in any way as far it’s learnt by choice. Hindi and English is useful for people from states which speak predominantly Hindi and so does other languages are useful for people from their respective states.
@@bjbharath you are right , English language is necessary for getting a job but my question is if Hindi language can destroy regional languages ( as the argument is being given by lady in this debate) ,then English language can also cause damage to regional languages. And she is not raising same questions against English just because English preferred in jobs sectors. I am just saying that either both English and Hindi threat to regional languages or none of them. How , it could be possible that Hindi language is threat to India's diversity while English is not . This kind of argument is not right.
@@manojshukla9346 hindi has destroyed many traditional native north indian languages which existed long before hindi. examples are avadhi bhojpuri magadhi rajasthani marwari braj bhasha etc etc treating them as hindi dialects .that is how it is shown as 44 percent.
We don't oppose Hindi but against imposition. Hindi can be learnt in 30 days and all infrastructure facilities are in Tamilnadu nobody stops it if you need it for communication. What is there in Hindi to study it for 6 years? Hindi is not a only National language and one of the official with English.
Frankly with the kind of pushing Hindi agenda by this BJP guy, I would like to challenge him to speak other South Indian languages. The kind of push only forces me to stop talking in Hindi, even though I being a South Indian and am able to speak and write first class Hindi - that’s because Hindi was not forced. But now I REFUSE TO SPEAK IN HINDI OR EVEN TEACH MY CHILDREN HINDI because of this attitude of politicians forcing the agenda.
Wow , Before watching this clip i thought the nort(hindi speakers) Realy did support the regional languages(atleast some of them) Here we have many intellects arguing about diffrent methords to impose hindi.this is pure hate. Why is the government trying to destroy the nation.
If Rakesh Sinha is that hurt with English being imposed on Indians, then he should better fucking understand that non-Hindi speaking people will be hurt the same way when you impose Hindi on them. UR Anandmurthy is realistic and logically correct. If Hindi is imposed on them, then they will feel only north states are empowered and South is looked down to. And that is absolutely against the principles of Democracy.
How idiotic can some ppl get. Mr Kohli is an SC judge and he thinks hindi is national language. How delusional r these hindi speaking states. No wonder they r called bimaru states of India. What a shame.
INDIA has no National Language Learn English & State Language. If you go to any other other country you learn the language of that country. You have no problem there. Why? when people from Hindi Speaking regions go to Non-Hindi Speaking states demand the locals to speak Hindi rather than leaning the local language. Will they accept of a Non Hindi speaking person goes to Hindi States and demands them to speak his language will they accept? Remember, India is a country of Regional Languages , Hindi is one such Regional Language. All languages in India are Indian Languages no one is less or more. You learn my language and I learn yours.
Balachandar Pandian for 10 days if tourism to ooty kerala etc you want me to learn a bunch of south indian language are u fool u are acting uneducated LITERATE. Will every street vendor will speak english no but hindi is very handy to all just because of television. So think properly and logucalky.
If one wishes to go to a non Hindi speaking state for a tourism or for any purpose for a short period, then anyway they have english, which is the common and linking language. The question, does every street vendor or the touring person know English. Well !! Then why do we have a school for and mandatory minimum schooling for through out the country. It is the failure of the government if it fails to achieve 100% minimum schooling in the country. The real issue here to understand is not to force anyone to lean a particular language. The business dictates the need to learn. Personally I have no hatred towards any language. Country is just fine with its current set up. Don't need any particular language as a national language. Nothing personal.
To PKS "INDI" who appears to Pakistani language commentor. So Pakistani language people want only Pakistani language Hindi which is not even proper India language, but dont want South India languages, which are the real and original languages of India. Why is that ??? It is one more proof that Pakistani language people (i.e. the Hindians) are foreign origin internal enemies and they should be removed from India citizenship.
PKS INDI those that operate businesses which hire employees to host Hindi speaking visitors can require knowledge of Hindi when they hire. But at the end of the day, students should have a choice and be responsible for that choice..
வாழ்க தமிழ் வாழ்க தமிழ் வாழ்க தமிழ் வாழ்க தமிழ் வாழ்க தமிழ் வாழ்க தமிழ் வாழ்க தமிழ் வாழ்க தமிழ் வாழ்க தமிழ் வாழ்க தமிழ் வாழ்க தமிழ் வாழ்க தமிழ் வாழ்க தமிழ் வாழ்க தமிழ் வாழ்க தமிழ் வாழ்க தமிழ் வாழ்க தமிழ் வாழ்க தமிழ் வாழ்க தமிழ் வாழ்க தமிழ்
Total No of Tamil Nadu Population is 6.9 crores. Maximum of People officialy using British English in the Government and Private Sectors. But All Tamil Peoples are not British People. All Tamil Nadu Peoples are Tamil People. Hindi Language offical Language and Literature age is only 400 years. How it is possible the artifical Hindi Language population is increased up to 58.8 Crores. Tamil, Telugu, Malayalam, Kannada languages are the developing Languages Other 18 Languages are Destroyed and 18 language traditional people are forgot their Traditional Family languge. Finally 18 Language speaking people said that they are Hindi Speking People................. Due to the 1961 Cences 1652 tribal languages are spoken in India. At Preesent How Many Tribal Language is Speking in India. The 2011 linguistic census accounts for 121 mother tongues, including 22 languages listed in the 8th Schedule of the Constitution. In India Most of the people want to protect their Cast and Religion. Most of the people will not concentrate their traditional Language?? Other 18 Language People should think How Many New Books are Published after Indipendence since 1947 ??? There is any International community people help to develop North Indian Languages (18 Languages) development?????????? Other 18 Language People should think How Many new Bollywood Cinema will produced after Indipendence since 1947???? and Many Literature Writers wrote their Literature in your Mother Language???? Tamil Language and Literature is updated by More than 300 Countries Tamil People Associaon....
Pakistani language Hindi is not India language. Pakistani language people i.e. Hindians are OK with foreign origin language English and Pakistani language Hindi but not OK with India languages Kannada, Tamil, Telugu, Malayalam etc. Hippocrats.
Hindi is not an indian language but a REMINDER of our historical slavery to invaders. Hindi is a mixture of so many invaders language including sanskrit which us brought to India from anatolia by invaders.. if India want to be proud of their slavery for centuries then keep Hindi. Otherwise Dravidian tam is the native to India and was the lingua franca of whole of India. Later invaders forced their language and Tamil became minorities. Now Tamil is the official language of Sungapore, Malaysia, Sri Lanka and third language of Canada ...its spoken in more than 40 countries ..
Shame if any one says there is no intention to impose Hindi. English is not an elite language. So you want Hindi to be used in the UN and for that you want to destroy India as we know. English provides a window to knowledge and not as one speaker claims puts our languages down. Without English we cannot develop our languages. That is accepted that is why they want English. Hindi and then local language. So there cannot be one rule for Hindi people so that they will learn Hindi and English and for others the burden is to learn two Indian languages. What is the use of Marathi in Mumbai or Poone when you cannot even buy grocery there with Marathi. Shame on these people who say Hindi will unite India. RSS and BJP will destroy India as we know it. USSI will become a reality before long.
Tamil is not our Language..its our INDENTITY
It is also our heritage, culture and motherland!
we sounth Indian's respect our regional languages like Kannada Telugu Tamil maleyalum,but not Hindi,it is foreign language for us
Mustafa Alam mulla u don't speak here..
Dude MALAYALAM!
@@dengaming3048 he can also speak here. He is also Indian.
Yes, absolutely
If tamil is regional language, hindi is my foriegn language..
Benedict Joseph
.......LOL
Varoon Hindi came from urdu in 13 th century
The problem is that people in south cant differentiate between Hindi and Urdu. They equate Urdu and Hindi.
Mukul Bhatnagar We South Indians know the differentiation between Urdu and Hindi. Urdu have less Sanskrit words compare to Hindi. From Urdu ,Hindi formed by replacing some Persian and Arabic words using Sanskrit. But Hindi also having Persian and and Arabic words. Urdu written in Arabic format, Hindi written in Devnagiri script. This is the difference. Urdu came from Persia language and from Urdu , Hindi formed. Both language combinely called as hindustani. First of all North Indians show your patriotic on your mother tongue, then show patriot on Persian language hindi. If English is foreign language from western country,absolutely Hindi also foreign language from Persia. Give equal importance to all native languages in India.
+Ananth S Thank you very much for enlightening me about my mother tongue. Hindi has evolved from Apbransha, an ancient, corrupted form of Prakrit which itself was a corrupted form of Sanskrit. In medieval ages it became 'khari boli' which is and was spoken in Madhya Pradesh and Western UP. During the Islamic invasions and rule, first Turkic then Persian became the official language of the courts and administration and remained so till the mid 17th century, when Urdu came into being. Urdu, which was earlier known as 'Rekhta' (literal meaning- to draw, to derive) came into being when the muslim soldiers interacted with the local populace. It picked up the grammar and syntax of khadi boli and local dialects and adopted words from Persian, Arabic and Sankrit/Khadi Boli, justifying its name. Besides Urdu, Khadi Boli continued to be spoken in 17th, 18th and 19th century in the name of 'Hindavi' or 'Hindustani' despite being over shadowed by Urdu. An example of this could be cited when Bihar adopted 'Hindi' sometime in late 1880s as its official language differentiating with, and removing Urdu. When India became independent in 1947, Hindi was adopted as official language of India, and language of United Provinces (later Uttar Pradesh), Central India and Rajasthan.
Hindi is a highly evolved language, very much like the part its spoken in- going through massive political, cultural and socio-political upheavals. Before south indians tell us which language to show patriotism to, they should learn that their own languages- tamil, kannada and telugu have heavily borrowed words from Sanskrit, Sinhala (which are both north Indian Aryan languages), Persian and Arabic. Please do not create a wishful opinion about a language that you do not understand/speak/know.
I am a Malayali that has spent 46 of my 54 yrs. in the US. Thus, I am fluent in English and can speak rudimentary Malayalam. Whenever I see an Indian in the US, they instinctively approach me and speak in Hindi. I explain that I don't speak Hindi and they seem outraged. Some then ask if I am Indian or ask why I don't speak Hindi. Then they say if I am Indian, I should learn Hindi. India is a collaboration of various states, each with its own language, culture, and traditions. It has been my experience that most educated people in India speak English. Why would N. Indians impose their language on people that have their own language and values? Why are N. Indians not learning Tamil if they want to live or do business in Tamil Nadu? One of the primary reasons why Bangladesh (E. Pakistan) broke away from Pakistan was because they demanded that they speak Urdu. If people want to learn Hindi, fine, but don't try and enforce your language on others.
Moron, go and read about bangladesh revolution. In 1948, Governor-General Muhammad Ali Jinnah declared that "Urdu, and only Urdu" would be the federal language of Pakistan.[32][33] However, Urdu was historically prevalent only in the north, central, and western region of the subcontinent; whereas in East Bengal, the native language was Bengali, one of the two most easterly branches of the Indo-European languages.[34] The Bengali-speaking people of Pakistan constituted over 30% of the country's population. The government stand was widely viewed as an attempt to suppress the culture of the eastern wing. The people of East Bengal demanded that their language be given federal status alongside Urdu and English. The Language Movement began in 1948, as civil society protested the removal of the Bengali script from currency and stamps, which were in place since the British Raj.
Sunil Thomas
If we want to unite India let it be with Hindi which is accepted among all the communities except South India.
Why South Indians are not willing to be integrated to our society ? If a tamilian comes to north India to live there, will it be possible without Hindi ? Stop being so narrow minded, we respect your language, therefore respect Hindi please. And if you don’t let it be, but you won’t be considered as Indian.
If you hate so much our language then why don’t you separate from us ?
Saitom Sai That holds true if they come and stay in North India. Then they will surely learn.
But the majority of the North Indians do not learn the local language even after 10 years.
In the beginning, we speak Hindi for convenience but people don't learn at all.
South Indians people are unemployed or ❓
@@SumitKumar-fn3gj unemployed hindi speakers are begging for jobs here in south
assamese people don't want hindi as national language.
B K GOGOI yeaah ok when islamist and chinese will take your state then dont com crying to new delhi for help. Anf if you come to Delhi to serk help do speak hindi.
Dai Moostaf.. Only Pakistani language people (Hindians/ HIndi people) don't understand India languages. They are foreign traitors. Get lost Mr Pakistani.
Full support bro.
Lets bring an end to this
@@pksindi8948 delhi ninte thanthede vakayanoda myere!
@@Naveen-Sebastian please reply in hindi or english. Go and save prabhakaran first.
when Abdul Kalam was president he never forced anyone to learn Tamil....
when Deve Gowda was prime minister he never forced anyone to learn Kannada....
when NarasimhA Rao was prime minister he never forced anyone to learn Telugu....
when Atal Bihari Vajpayee was prime minister he never forced anyone to learn Hindi....
it's time for Fekuuuussss government to learn some moral ethics.......from his seniors......
Stop saying other languages as Reginal languages. Hindi aslo Just a regional language
Hindi is the national language. Hope you learn it asap :)
Multi-regional, unlike any other Indian languages as they are restricted to one State more or less. Also, apart from Hindi Belt, most people in states like Punjab, Gujarat, Maharashtra, and to some extent Bengal & Orissa, can all speak fluent Hindi. In fact over 50% of the country can speak good Hindi, and over 40% call it their mother tongue. It only makes sense to use it as the link language over English, or any other Indian language. Language is just a tool, you tool. This coming from a half-Sindhi, half-Punjabi, born & brought up in Gujarat, whose mother tongue is Saraiki.
nnn Tamil is a Sri Lankan language...language of terrorist Tamil Tigers
which nation's language hindi is ? , go learn it asap , it is just official language of india along with english .
Tamil is international language , entire india once spoke tamil , ur ancestors spoke tamil once.
Tamil is the oldest language of India. So, no need of pushing your Hindi language to us.
you've changed your tune a lot. You must just be here trolling....
Human being and does every south state speak tamil. Will kannada learn english.
@nnn MOST WORKERS TO M8DDKE EAST ARE FROM SOUTH ONLY.
We miss Ananthmurthy , a great literary gaint , Kannada is missing you sir... may be this was his last public appearance...
If English is a colonial era language, Hindi is output from Mughal era language. Sources: Wiki
correct
+Ram Kumar
Mughal era created Urdu, the language of the tents of Muslim soldiers who invaded India. Hindi is mainly Sanskrit mixed with Brajabuli, Maithili, Bhojpuri, Bengali, Audh dialect, etc. It was created not by the Mughals who used to speak in Farsi.
WIKI was created by the CIA; do not believe it.
Mr Mustaff, Pakistani language people i..e Hindian are the Autistic people as they dont speak Indian language, only yap around in Pakistani language Hindi.
The South rejects imposition of Hindi..
@1.57 The person need some education. Hindi is not national language of India.
Siva, people also say English is an international language, though the constitution of UN doesn't say so anywhere. But the fact is, since it is an international lingua franca, we call it an 'international language'. Also, it's constitution of the US, UK or Australia doesn't mention English as an official or a national language, but it is a de facto official or national language of those countries. Same thing goes about Japan, where constitution doesn't declare Japanese an official language, but it's a de facto official or national language there. This way, Hindi is our de facto national language, though the constitution doesn't say so.
+Amit Shah but india is not usa or uk or australia or japan(where 90% people understand one language) , there is no country in the world as diverse as india-22 official recognized languages in the constitution
So how do you want to connect the country without establishing a language as a link language? If the country is such diverse, there's a need for something common to make it a nation, we need a common language to communicate with each other, there are other multi lingual countries in this world, where they have established a particular language as a link language. So India will never give a special privilege to it's few states, if the entire world follows this trend, our country is no different to them.
entire world even chinese learning english and french were failed in promoting their language as a internet language go and see how many english channels in france( EX-FRANCE24),germany,russia(RT), english is globalised language okay as for as what hindi you are promoting fully sansritized which is not fit in modern world to progress further and imposition of hindi not at all acceptable why you are declaring hindi as defacto national language is this not arrogance,popularisation of hindi take place its own way you dont need indian taxpayers money spending on promotong only hindi which is younger when compared with tamil,bengali,telugu etc so allow people voluntarily to learn what they want and dont declare yourselves hindi as even defacto national language
I am from andhra i learned hindi as a second language from 6-10 th class,how many hindiwallahs learning other indian languages and giving respect to southern languages -give respect and take respect otherwise serious consequences will follow
+siva Subramaniyam
Sanskrit is the real National language of India.
Kannada is official language of karnataka so why ask us to speak hindi in karnataka
Hindi Just a regional language nothing more
Kannada and Tamil oldest in india no need Hindi . my state my language Kannada no like Hindi
English is unavoidable in this industrialized world. You Hindi Speakers only require to learn English. But what about others they have to learn both English and hindi. It's a double burden for us. It's a very unfair govt. Already Our language is ruined by English.
It is avoidable.
Look at Japan.
Panipooris seller Muslim language Hindi is useless and only reduce people to paanipoori level.
மொழிகளை சமமாக மதிக்க கற்றுகொள்ளுங்கள், இதுதான் அனைத்து மக்களையும் சமமாக மதிப்பதற்கு சமம்.
warning for central gov from tamilnadu: many language one country, one language many nation.
+parai isai these rigid narrow hindu bramhanical hindi bigots dont understand brother the seriousness of linguistic identity that is harm to our country if they continue with this policy
+parai isai
Sanskrit should be the language of India for the world. Forced imposition of Hindi on India will divide India. Only Sanskrit can unite India.
It is very insulting for us when foreigners laugh at us hearing that two Indians are talking to each other in English.
It is high time to change this slave mentality.
+Dipak Basu we are agaisnt Sanskrit as much as Hindi... learn what ever pleases you , you have no right to say what we should learn ..... you tomorrow will say that foreigners are laughing that Indians are wearing wester clothing , so we can't change back to dhothis and mundu , even if we do that you will say they are laughing because we are dressed differently , so national dress must be made ... some kind of uniform would be much better , isn't it?. tomorrow they may say you Indians being from one country follow different religions , what are you going to do then .. ghar wapsi...?
we live for ourselves not for others
Hahah who the fuck are you to say that... If you have the balls to make Sanskrit national language make it and see what happens .... In fact there is a book by a person which sound very similar to you name... DD Basu... Ah some bhakt , thinks they know every thing.
And again am not Tamil am kannadiga . so fuck you...
cool bro this mindset will cause harm to our motherland,yes Sanskrit is a great language but you cant impose it on other people Tamils are as much indians as you are,you have no right to say they have to leave india
Iam from andhra we have three language policy(telugu-hindi-english)
Hindi should be thrown back to Arabia
***** lol Pind means shit in Malayalam. Suits you very well.
Terin Rajan I agree Hindi should be demolished, it is the base for Hindutva
Mohamed Naushad Ali So should Urdu and Arabic in that case. They form the basis for Islamism!
+Mohamed Naushad Ali Urdu also should be demolished then... It is the base of Islam in South Asian countries.
Islam is not dependant on any language. It is beyond languages, nations, cultures, races and geography!
Tamil nadu people don't want Hindi as national language...
kannadigas also bro
Telugus also..... Cheers bro
Malayalis also....
Maharashtrian Marathi people also
If you wish to keep India as one, then keep your hindi in 4 states. You are already using my tax money to promote Hindi. How dare?
Hindi not national language 22 language also national language
wtf...... he doesn't even know that we don't have a national language.....
India haven't a single national language.All indian languages are national languages.
for this only reason BJP never entered TAMIL NADU. and sure it will not enter
kannan sivakumar this is the reason u didnt got supoort from restvof indis on tamil problem in sri lanka and what happened due to that. Extinction dear.
Please do not make this the only reason
@@pksindi8948srilankan tamilians living in india in many parts of south maybe u dont know they seek asalyam they should have lived rightfully in elam if india wouldn't have involved
There are not even 25% of Hindi speakers in India if you take out bojpuri, mythali & other variation languages which are put together as Hindi.
As an foreign born south Indian malayalee, I would agreed that Hindi should take prevalence over the languages. One can still keep their language and used it locally. Knowing more languages is always a plus in commercial business life. Hindi can be seen as unifying language for the whole of India. This can be since in countries like China, Malaysia, etc where there is a national language define to tap our top communication barrier. Sometime change may be hard to accept but one must be adaptable to change for growth.
+Jolly John dai mallu idiot.... India is known for its cultural diversity. It should remain like that. Hindi is good to know but not must.
if you are not in India , being born else where, we don't care what you think... if you want to have a say .. come live on India and we can have debate ... else f off
No country has enemy country language has national language. Why India want to replace India language with Pakistani language Hindi.
Pakistani language HIndi cant be accepted as national language.
First of all how can the Pakistani language speaking people i.e. Hindians even be accepted as Indians. After all the treasons committed. The scoundrels are internal enemy people.
Many disagree with you
I endorse Alyque. You cannot impose Hindi. And to confused 'Hindi imposers', nobody is imposing English, people wanted to learn it so that they don't have to miss the bus full of opportunities. Hindi has to be learnt not from imposition but from liking. Tamil Nadu government had introduced English as medium of instruction in government schools just because parents preferred to put their children in English medium schools and NONE prefers to be in Hindi medium schools. If you don't have the courtesy to convince people about Hindi, DON'T IMPOSE IT! After all People's choice matters in democracy!
Hindi is not official and it is one of the language. Simple as that
I think we all should join together and push Modi Ji to learn good English and converse effectively so he can deal well with western countries and make them understand what he is trying to say on behalf of our country.
Joy Edwards ya first he should learn English.....
correct. south indians know english. he does not even know
completely agreed
Mustafa Alam southern would not mix Hindi accent with Hindi
Hindi is always optional and should not be enforced. Tamil is important to people of Tamil Nadu. Telugu is for Andra. Please don't enforce. Hindi is just a language like any other language of India.
Let Hindi spread organically. If South Indians thinks it is beneficial for them, we will learn.
***** I am a Malayalee :) I think Hindi should not be imposed.
But Hindi will be spread organically. Hindi should be optional.
South Indians don't hate Hindi. We in fact do learn Hindi. But it is the feeling of imposition that is in contention. This idea that in order to be 'Indian' you need to learn Hindi.
I say no to that. :)
We Dont need hindi
We respect English but not hindi. ...
Harish Govin .....Hindi is beautiful and It's literature is rich
Gopal Ambedkar tamil is most ancient language and literature ...
Mustafa Alam, you are from Parsia right>
Harish Govin ya you stil slaves of Britishers
Dai Muttal Mustaaffa : Are you Pakistani??? HIndi is Pakistani language..Get lost.
how does Hindi unite india? India is a land of diversity and that is what indians felt as Indianness. Don't impose or make hindi compulsory and lose Indianness.
We fully vehemently oppose Hindi in Karnataka. we wish to remove from school curriculum also from this year.
Modi govt should not dare to do it.
Hindi was pushed by a very ugly politician of India Jag Jivan Ram in 1965.
That had caused riots all over India. Hindi is a regional language of 3-4 states but not exclusively ( there are Bhojpuri, Audh Dialect, Pahari, Rajasthani, Khariboli in those states along with several tribal languages). Non-Hindi speaking states will never accept Hindi as the National Language.
Hindi is not a national language
Yes hindi is national language
Hindi is as just as like other languages.. Not a national lang..
U. R. Ananthmurty has Ph.D in English from UK. He was English professor. He produced a great literature work in Kannada. It's the mother tongue which makes people more empowered.
India is an Union like European Union.
the guy in green shirt speaks his own language called Hinglish. LOL
Hindi is also regional language.....
For Telugu people
It is Urdu not hindi in telangana... According to my knowledge hindi/Urdu spoken only in hyderabad and in few places of telangana.
Tamil language is 2000 years old and spoken in US about 4lacs speak Tamil in US and it is one of nation
language in Singapore, Malaysia, Srilanka and Mauritius There is a place called Amma Nagar I USA, carriabean is Tamil word Mediterranean, Cyprus is Tamil word
hindi should just be the link language. State Language first and 2nd Hindi. Not this colonial mindset that is still going on which makes English more used. India should become United and have in place there mother tongue/state language first then the link language which would be Hindi.
Never y we shud take the effort when u are not going to take any effort... U learn my language and I will learn urs.. That's it
he says Hindi is the 3rd largest spoken language in the world; wrong again. Mandarin, Spanish, English, and then only Hindi. Don't try to fool people.
Tamils should increse there population that is answer for hindi speakers be proud of tamils
It's good that atleast in news channel people should stop calling any language other than hindi as regional language. After all hindi is just another regional language of about 9 states.
It would be a single largest blunder of the era, if one languages made as national language
slipper shot on RSS devil...ha ha..funny
What does the government done to promote the remaining 21 Official / National languages in India
Personally I am against the imposition of Hindi; I think it is much easier to work with English. However, I would like to point out that Tamilnadu and Karnataka have gone to great lengths to impose Tamil and Kannada on the Telugu and Maratha populations of their states.
List of Regional languages(Recognized) goes like this..........Malayalam, Tamil, Telugu, Kannada, Odiya, Marati, Hindi... etc.... If Top most posts of Indian govt(e.g President, PM etc). prefer to speak in one of the regional language e.g Hindi then there should be provisions for live translations into remaining languages.
Instead of doing all ths first improve north states so that migration to south for jobs and livelihood will stop.
Many hindi speaking people in karnataka andhra tamilnadu kerala does not speak kannada , telugu, tamil, malyalam.
He said English is the colonial language, hindi is the current colonial language, so it's more important to oppose the current colonial language.
one question from Tamil nadu. When hindi speaking states are not developed when compared to non hindi speaking states it shows that if you speak hindi you can not see any development in the country. why don't the hindi speaking states learn any of the south indian languages to develop and grow?
Bengal rejects Hindi Imposition.
Official language in states must be there on regional language plus English central language must be in Hindi and English
If the intend is not negative.. where is the need to bring this issue up ? BJP seems no less than congress
Hindi is not national language... bluddy BJP is the anti -south peoples...Our national languages are tamil,kannada,Malayalam,urdu,telugu etc
Thank God. They didn't "push" rotis, raajma on south. Did they? :)
Hindi is closely related to Urdu having more Persian words than any other Indian language Persian Turkish and arabic
After accepting Hindi through out the country, some people could not guess what the danger would be. Later is it possible for non hindi speaking people to compete in all aspects specifically in competitive exams with people whose mother tongue is HINDI.
For hindi speaking people , it is mother tongue and for us it is foreign language. In any competition there should be level playing field for justice / unbiased competition. More importantly non hindi speaking people will become second class citizens .
Two languages are more than enough for anybody. Better concentrate on science & mathematics and create scientists to make India a technologically advanced country.
hindi hain hum Hindustan hamara......vande mataram.....
I am a hindustani but not hindi
thamizh vazhga
I am Marathi.
Marathi is my identity...
There is no word called national language in Constitution. No one can't declare Hindi as national language. Each individual has freedom to choose his favorite language.
Bjp should know we have edge over other countries because of English
When someone says that they don't need Hindi why is it so hard for the northies to accept?
Most of the bengalis do not want hindi to be the national language. We are very sensitive towards our language. Although Hindi is a sweet tongue, we cannot allow imposition of it by some language fanatics. First go and ask people of hindi belt to learn telegu, Manipuri, Hazong or Kamta language.
জয় বাংলা।
Hindi is not a national language.
How about Punjabi, Kashmiri, Rajastani, Gujrati, Marati, Kannada, Telugu, Konkani, Malayalam, Tamil, Bengali, Assamese, Manipuri, Tripuri ? So, with so many states speaking their local languages, how Hindi can be called Rashtra Bhasha ?? It is NOT !!!
No one allow! Every states must to be deny it.
Mr anandamoorthy sir you are correct , I realised, this point view every one accept
English is a better link language...
Please dont force us to learn Hindi We the South Indians are having our own languages( TELUGU, TAMIL, KANNADA, MALAYALAM) we are pretty much happy with our languages, We don't want Hindi..!
JAI HINDH
I am a Hindi speaker, forced to learn, speak and adopt English lifestyle to move ahead in life. Who imposed English on me?
I am a telugu speaker. I learnt and adopted english just like you. Why should I now learn hindi?
Everyone speaks English...so why should we learn your language??What is the country accomplishing by learning Hindi??
No one imposed english on you
You learnt english for your professional needs
English is the lingua franca of the world..
We dont need Hindi in our non hindi states..
Ananta murthy’s words should be made preamble of the National Language policy
Hindi arguers in this debate We respect local languages We are not imposing Hindi but...but.... we need Hindi in UN.... so learn Hindi ... We are more in number so you need to learn.... Hindi wants to be like German or French so learn Hindi .......
Arey baba Kannada Tamil Telugu Malayalam are like German French Italian etc Will Germans stop using german language in favour of English
It is Kannada not Kannad How will you feel if I call Hindi as Hindei or Hindam
learning a classic language may make some sense than the pakisthani like hindi.
Hindi is better than english
अब हिंदी विश्व भाषा बन चुकी है और बहुत जल्द अंग्रेजी को भी पछाड़ देगी आज पूरे विश्व में सैकड़ों विश्वविद्यालय में हिंदी का पठन-पाठन हो रहा है यह हमारे लिए बहुत गर्व की बात है जय हिंद जय भारत🙏🙏
Why should the North impose Hindi on the South when there is already English a link language in the south. Moreover English is a useful language and ensures a good career, a better paying job and access to the global economy. If the RSS feels that they can sneakingly impose their agenda systematically in a phased manner across India they are going to be sorry as we the southerners are not going to be fooled so easily. We down the south are thrived because of our own languages and English as the link language and we don't intent to change it. Let's face it English is the language of Power which every aspiring Indian wants to master.
I don't understand how the people in central politics are dumb that they don't even know that India doesn't have a national language at all.. They happily exhibit their stupidity by saying that hindi is our national language.. Feel ashamed of it.
That way nobody feels that Hindi is pushing mother tongues out of existence
Hindi language creates threat to regional languages as well as heterogeneous society of India While English languages is not How.
Manoj Shukla Because apart from ones mother tongue, learning English makes a lot of sense in getting jobs and understand what’s happening around world, whereas Hindi doesn’t help us in any way as far it’s learnt by choice. Hindi and English is useful for people from states which speak predominantly Hindi and so does other languages are useful for people from their respective states.
@@bjbharath you are right , English language is necessary for getting a job but my question is if Hindi language can destroy regional languages ( as the argument is being given by lady in this debate) ,then English language can also cause damage to regional languages. And she is not raising same questions against English just because English preferred in jobs sectors. I am just saying that either both English and Hindi threat to regional languages or none of them. How , it could be possible that Hindi language is threat to India's diversity while English is not . This kind of argument is not right.
@@manojshukla9346 hindi has destroyed many traditional native north indian languages which existed long before hindi. examples are avadhi bhojpuri magadhi rajasthani marwari braj bhasha etc etc treating them as hindi dialects .that is how it is shown as 44 percent.
We don't oppose Hindi but against imposition. Hindi can be learnt in 30 days and all infrastructure facilities are in Tamilnadu nobody stops it if you need it for communication. What is there in Hindi to study it for 6 years? Hindi is not a only National language and one of the official with English.
Frankly with the kind of pushing Hindi agenda by this BJP guy, I would like to challenge him to speak other South Indian languages. The kind of push only forces me to stop talking in Hindi, even though I being a South Indian and am able to speak and write first class Hindi - that’s because Hindi was not forced. But now I REFUSE TO SPEAK IN HINDI OR EVEN TEACH MY CHILDREN HINDI because of this attitude of politicians forcing the agenda.
hindi n english r both foreign to south india ... however english n hindi quiet close to each other esp. in their roots
Wow ,
Before watching this clip i thought the nort(hindi speakers)
Realy did support the regional languages(atleast some of them)
Here we have many intellects arguing about diffrent methords to impose hindi.this is pure hate.
Why is the government trying to destroy the nation.
If Rakesh Sinha is that hurt with English being imposed on Indians, then he should better fucking understand that non-Hindi speaking people will be hurt the same way when you impose Hindi on them. UR Anandmurthy is realistic and logically correct. If Hindi is imposed on them, then they will feel only north states are empowered and South is looked down to. And that is absolutely against the principles of Democracy.
অসমত হিন্দীৰ স্থান নাই ,
আমি Indian
নহয় Hindian
জয় ভাৰত ....
জয় আই অসম .....
বন্দে মাতৰম ....
How idiotic can some ppl get. Mr Kohli is an SC judge and he thinks hindi is national language. How delusional r these hindi speaking states. No wonder they r called bimaru states of India. What a shame.
No, it can never be justified.
First translate all technical books in hindi then make it national language...there is no used of learning hindi
INDIA has no National Language
Learn English & State Language.
If you go to any other other country you learn the language of that country. You have no problem there.
Why? when people from Hindi Speaking regions go to Non-Hindi Speaking states demand the locals to speak Hindi rather than leaning the local language.
Will they accept of a Non Hindi speaking person goes to Hindi States and demands them to speak his language will they accept?
Remember, India is a country of Regional Languages , Hindi is one such Regional Language.
All languages in India are Indian Languages no one is less or more.
You learn my language and I learn yours.
Balachandar Pandian for 10 days if tourism to ooty kerala etc you want me to learn a bunch of south indian language are u fool u are acting uneducated LITERATE. Will every street vendor will speak english no but hindi is very handy to all just because of television. So think properly and logucalky.
If one wishes to go to a non Hindi speaking state for a tourism or for any purpose for a short period, then anyway they have english, which is the common and linking language.
The question, does every street vendor or the touring person know English. Well !! Then why do we have a school for and mandatory minimum schooling for through out the country.
It is the failure of the government if it fails to achieve 100% minimum schooling in the country.
The real issue here to understand is not to force anyone to lean a particular language. The business dictates the need to learn.
Personally I have no hatred towards any language. Country is just fine with its current set up. Don't need any particular language as a national language.
Nothing personal.
To PKS "INDI" who appears to Pakistani language commentor. So Pakistani language people want only Pakistani language Hindi which is not even proper India language, but dont want South India languages, which are the real and original languages of India. Why is that ???
It is one more proof that Pakistani language people (i.e. the Hindians) are foreign origin internal enemies and they should be removed from India citizenship.
PKS INDI those that operate businesses which hire employees to host Hindi speaking visitors can require knowledge of Hindi when they hire. But at the end of the day, students should have a choice and be responsible for that choice..
வாழ்க தமிழ் வாழ்க தமிழ் வாழ்க தமிழ் வாழ்க தமிழ்
வாழ்க தமிழ் வாழ்க தமிழ் வாழ்க தமிழ் வாழ்க தமிழ்
வாழ்க தமிழ் வாழ்க தமிழ் வாழ்க தமிழ் வாழ்க தமிழ்
வாழ்க தமிழ் வாழ்க தமிழ் வாழ்க தமிழ் வாழ்க தமிழ்
வாழ்க தமிழ் வாழ்க தமிழ் வாழ்க தமிழ் வாழ்க தமிழ்
Hats off to mr anandamoorthy
Total No of Tamil Nadu Population is 6.9 crores. Maximum of People officialy using British English in the Government and Private Sectors. But All Tamil Peoples are not British People. All Tamil Nadu Peoples are Tamil People.
Hindi Language offical Language and Literature age is only 400 years.
How it is possible the artifical Hindi Language population is increased up to 58.8 Crores.
Tamil, Telugu, Malayalam, Kannada languages are the developing Languages
Other 18 Languages are Destroyed and 18 language traditional people are forgot their Traditional Family languge. Finally 18 Language speaking people said that they are Hindi Speking People.................
Due to the 1961 Cences 1652 tribal languages are spoken in India. At Preesent How Many Tribal Language is Speking in India.
The 2011 linguistic census accounts for 121 mother tongues, including 22 languages listed in the 8th Schedule of the Constitution.
In India Most of the people want to protect their Cast and Religion. Most of the people will not concentrate their traditional Language??
Other 18 Language People should think How Many New Books are Published after Indipendence since 1947 ???
There is any International community people help to develop North Indian Languages (18 Languages) development??????????
Other 18 Language People should think How Many new Bollywood Cinema will produced after Indipendence since 1947???? and Many Literature Writers wrote their Literature in your Mother Language????
Tamil Language and Literature is updated by More than 300 Countries Tamil People Associaon....
In reality 80 percent pol atleast speak in hindi or understand it little little.
So make it national speaking language
One day you politicians will separate India you rascals
सच तोह ये है कि हिंदी खुद ही धीरे धीरे खत्म होरही है
Why do you talk about South Indian and first you teach Hindi to the Hindi people
All 22 languages must be declared as official languages of india along with the regional language hindi .
This is weird. DMK and AIDMK is ok with foreign language but have problem with Indian Language Hindi
Pakistani language Hindi is not India language. Pakistani language people i.e. Hindians are OK with foreign origin language English and Pakistani language Hindi but not OK with India languages Kannada, Tamil, Telugu, Malayalam etc. Hippocrats.
Hindi is also a foreign language...Why should we learn multiple foreign language
Hindi is not an indian language but a REMINDER of our historical slavery to invaders. Hindi is a mixture of so many invaders language including sanskrit which us brought to India from anatolia by invaders.. if India want to be proud of their slavery for centuries then keep Hindi. Otherwise Dravidian tam is the native to India and was the lingua franca of whole of India. Later invaders forced their language and Tamil became minorities. Now Tamil is the official language of Sungapore, Malaysia, Sri Lanka and third language of Canada ...its spoken in more than 40 countries ..
Respect all languages don't push the hindi to learn other states. !
Indian govt degrades Non Hindi speakers in every Union govt jobs and services.
We love India not Hindia.
East Pakistan separated as Urdu was made official language learn from pak
Shame if any one says there is no intention to impose Hindi. English is not an elite language. So you want Hindi to be used in the UN and for that you want to destroy India as we know. English provides a window to knowledge and not as one speaker claims puts our languages down. Without English we cannot develop our languages. That is accepted that is why they want English. Hindi and then local language. So there cannot be one rule for Hindi people so that they will learn Hindi and English and for others the burden is to learn two Indian languages. What is the use of Marathi in Mumbai or Poone when you cannot even buy grocery there with Marathi. Shame on these people who say Hindi will unite India. RSS and BJP will destroy India as we know it. USSI will become a reality before long.
who is said hindus are national language