Mayawati's ‘insecurities’,Akash Anand removal & BSP future:DK Singh,Dilip Mandal with Shekhar Gupta
Вставка
- Опубліковано 7 тра 2024
- #CutTheClutter #Mayawati #loksabhaelection2024
The dismissal of her nephew, Akash Anand as her successor and calling him 'immature', has raised questions about Mayawati's intentions for her party in UP politics. In episode 1446 of Cut The Clutter, Editor-in-Chief Shekhar Gupta, along with Dilip Mandal and ThePrint Political Editor DK Singh look at Mayawati's rampant political decisions and their implications for BSP in UP politics.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
0:32 - The Rise of BSP
2:37 - Mayawati as a Dalit Leader
3:43 - Is BSP trying to help BJP?
5:48 - Akash Anand's removal as Mayawati's successor
13:33 - Mayawati's insecurities and politics
26:32 - BSP and Mayawati in UP's Dalit politics
32:42 - Mayawati's BJP-friendly moves
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Special benefits: theprint.in/subscribe/
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/subscribe/
» Subscribe to our UA-cam Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintIndia
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
Exclusive content, privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for special benefits: theprint.in/subscribe/
DK: I completely agree with Dilip...
*goes on to logically rip apart Mandal's point every time*
I found this guy talking in circles and making speculative points. No reporting or useful analysis
😂 true
Mandal is too biased in his view of BSP
BSPs biggest enemy is SP & Congress. Since whole opposition wants the same base vote, they’ll have to eliminate each other before competing with BJP.
BSP & SP vote can never gel...BSP vote can only go to Congress or BJP.
Yeah bahenji is transferring the BSP vote to INDIA
@@SPrabhakar lmao you’re a fool with ZERO political knowledge. BJP will have a 85-90% strike rate against Congress. Wait for 4th June.
@@ddzl6209 didn’t you read my message. Bahenji’s biggest threat is SP & Congress. She would never transfer her vote to them. Even in 2019, BSP vote didn’t transfer to SP.
@@va8085 bahujan samaj cannot trust bahenji anymore and decided to vote for INDIA to save constitution and democracy
Caste based parties and caste politics are on the death bed.
Most common people have moved on from it (irrespective if which caste they are from) and are aspiring for better things in life.
BSP will be gone in a few years, so will the other caste parties like SP, JDS etc
In your dreams lol. You are watching in this timeline so u r judging it from here. Read little about history (especially political history of this country). BSP RJD like parties will always be there. The graph of the performance may fluctuate. It may dive deep too but as long as leadership and cadre based organisation is there, most importantly will is there, these parties will always be there. Only teens think just by looking at today's performance that some party won't rise up again....
Forgot to mention congress
Except upper cast, biggest votebank of BJP
@@cinefile0075 Lol whatever you say makes no sense.
If cadres are there, obviously parties will exist. The real point is, if parties remain out of power for a long time and have no money, how will they pay the cadres.
On top of that, when caste based politics itself is on its last legs, how will caste based parties exist😂
You are probably mentally challenged, if you think what I said seems like something a teenager would say.
@@noneoftheabove666 you are liking your own comment and telling me mentally challenged. Chomu 🤡..
Knowing Mayawati and her vindictive nature , Anand is a gone story . Very soon we will have a new successor announcement maybe around the time of UP assembly elections
Mandal uncle is speaking like he is a representative of BSP.
Mandal was really angry with Ravish Kumar for his UA-cam video on BSPs doom 😂
Kashiram was a leader of ground who worked on ground. He just picked mayawati from a rally. According to me mayawati wasn't that politically knowledgeable. She isn't even working on the ground
Never come out from her house. After kanshiram she only won 1 election that too because of anti incumbency of SP. Now BSP is justva jatav party in UP. With 10% votebank they can't win. In 2019 BSP votes wasn't transferred to SP
She seems like a spent force.
RIGHT ✅
@@SANJAYSHARMA-gi1kk Sharma ji how can you comment about sc politics?
@@shivmohan2982just like 0.
01% neobuddhist doing SC politics. Any one can give opinion on anyone.
@@shivmohan2982
I BELIEVE IN PUJYA MAHA MANAV DR BABASAHEB AMBEDKAR JI
Never miss a chance to promote walk the talk!
Shekhar sir pls try to be crisp in your screen addressals. Jalebiyaan mt bnane lag Jaya Karo.. Attention drop ho jaati hai
Shekhar ji in 2022 UP election BJP increased its vote share from 39% to 42%. But BSP vote fell from 22% to 12% while SP vote increased to 32%(basically 22% + 4% vote went taken from congress +6% additional vote)
if you are adding 4% of INC in 2017, then must also add the 4-5% of SBSP & RLD which then got added to the SP alliance in 2022. So it's still a 10+% points increase, roughly the same as decline of BSP.
Dilip sahabs optimism about BSP is contagious 😊.....30 saal laga sahab 2 se 272 pohochne mein with a base like RSS
Dileep mandal ka analysis out of earth hai ....he is jem...🤣🤣🤣🤣
in the rarest of chances that NDA gets less than 272 seats, Mayawati will be the first one to offer external support to the BJP
What support? How many seats is she winning?
Zero. @@slomob
Intelligent and informative discussion🎉. To summarise, if BSP were a stock, Mandal is recommending "hold" for the BSP ticker, while DK went with "sell". Mandal delivered a nice history session but it appears his optimism for BSP's revival was more about hope rather than sound reasoning. Personally, I don't see Muslims abandoning SP but then I'm not from UP. DK was more focussed on current events and perhaps a bit too harsh on the party. Personally, I don't think "pappufication" can happen overnight. Akash Anand is not Rahul Gandhi. Akash seems far more articulate and better at sensing the pulse of the crowd. I think Mandal's explanation is more sound but I concur with DK regarding the party's bleak future. Nevertheless, Yogi will be a 2 term CM in 2027. He'll have to go beyond "law and order" to win a 3rd term. It might sound odd, but before Modi it was actually Mayawati that had united Hindus. Her famous "social engineering" was the talk of the town then but the main problem with these parties is that even for 2% Muslim votes they readily abandon Hindu causes.
Good to see prof dilip mandal in panel . He is true or in classical terminology organic intellectual for majority of indian working caste
Do we remember Shashank Shekhar singh ?
I think BJP wants SP as opposition compared to BSP as there is soft corner to neutral voters cam shift
If SP main opposition BJP easily make Gunda Raj main issue & no neutral voters will shift
Excellent Insights...
I respect DK Singh.
More you declutter - More gets cluttered 😅 !
Election circus of the biggest democracy in the world .
Jai Hind
2017 seat tally was due to demonetisation . Completely derailed both SP and BSP .
So 2022 with SP and Congress together was actually a better performance in spite of the decrease in seats
With all due respect
Jayalalitha, Mayawati are of the same clan they don't like anyone growing in fame ahead of them, if such is the case they get axed.
THIS BASICALLY A USELESS DISCUSSION
Loving the format of having multiple guests in Cut the Clutter Shekharji, Thanks!!
Thank you, Balraj. Well, it is election season and there's so much to unpack and discuss. Always good to have more voices. Do keep watching and writing in, and thank you for appreciating our journalism...best wishes, Shekhar
Mondal saab did not do justice with his profession in this interview.....i felt he tried confuse the viewer and was trying get away from bsp+ bjp collaboration, because he does not want to speak facts
Deelipji ‘s analysis of bsp or Mayawati is based on facts but most of the people specially journalists see the action of Mayawati as BJP sponsoring action
Why can’t this guy be more precise and focused ! On and on snd on …
Even Mayawati seems to be not interested and you all three wasted your precious time on that party.
Lol. Dilip Mandal is behaving like a party member instead of a journalist. I don't why he was a panelist in this episode. He's hell bent on defending the indefensible. He usually has very sharp arguments on all issues but here his biases have obscured his intelligence.
On the other hand DK had pretty logical and strong arguments. He has beautifully destroyed every argument presented by Mandal.
To put it in North Indian accented pronounciation as spoken by TP " journalists" - Mayavati's nephew went to Lundhan, used aunt's ill-gotten money to buy an " Yum Bee Hai" *(MBA) degree and came back to India as the Dalit Pappu !!!
Jay shah
Your papa's team (BJP's Corporator to MP) is looting people day and night. It's just CBI ED etc are in the hands of Modi. They aren't being attacked. Don't you ever think they have stopped looting us...
Your Daddy's team (BJP's Corporator to MP) is looting people day and night. It's just CBI ED etc are in the hands of Modi. They aren't being attacked. Don't you ever think they have stopped looting ....
Is Dilip a journalist or BSP sympathiser…so tiring to listen to his rant…
He had jealousy towards others obc n OBC part like as he belongs non prominent OBC n they don't get proper political importance ....it is like to insult ur neighbour u r giving more importance to other n less to neighbour
19.3 % in 2019 in UP with alliance with congress and samajwadi
When alone in UP assembly 12.88 in 2022
It is masterstroke . Saving his image
To distract what congress and sp is saying they are picking on bsp.
After getting utterly disappointed with Congress and SP in UP, now looking towards BSP !!!
BSP is doing a tactical retreat, but not for the reason Prof. Mandal is saying. Mayawati is scared. It is clear.
Two superb good political analyst and very good moderator but still I fnd this show somewhat lacking on all aspects. I dont know what eent wrong or dont know what more i am looking for. Still some great political acumen i was searching which i could not find. All in all good episode but could have been better. One important thing that DK's subject matter expertise and his unbiased view is unparalleled and very very rare. DK please accept my salutations on it
An american graduate will get reservation and not the poor upper caste
Disappointed with the analysts of sg and DK. Main reason could be she does not want SP to benefit
If Caste is Favourable: Autocractic, dictatorial becomes invisible.
Good discussion. Dilip does not appear to be objective about BSP. It’s like his own life’s work is coming under question if BSP’s shenanigans are exposed. And he didn’t say much about their core voters also moving away from “hurt” politics to aspirational politics. Looks like his politics is also becoming an anachronism!!
Dear Shekarji, why is Print afraid of speaking on what Sam Pitrida has to say about Indian culture....or is that u do not want to.call the Congressis bluff
Namaste sir
This is English channel or Hindi channel, why your guests speaking in Hindi in English channel
Making him her successor was wierd but removing him made sure that BSP is working for BJP only.
I thought she can come back by making right decisions but Mayawati is just working on BJP behest to remain out of jail.
Aakaash Aanand is most mature youth leader
Dilip is like a bsp propaganda paid person
they all are :)
Not sure if this de-cluttered anything for me.
It’s very hard to achieve any meaningful progress in India if caste fault lines exists and people keep voting on caste basis. Contrary to popular liberal belief, developed countries like Japan, S Korea, Germany and to some extent US maintain a very high standard of nationalism and feel very proud of it. Unless Indians rise above caste and accept being Indian as their identity, we will be too busy fighting among ourselves and pulling each other down.
All the developed countries in the world are very homogeneous.
First decide national language and forcefully impose it.
Mr Gupta, you need to know that Dilip Mandal isn't an objective commentator. He is more of a political activist like Kancha Ilaiah who frequently gives skewed commentary attacking or trolling the BJP.
Like in 2018 or so he wrote a piece claiming that for Dalits the BJP was no more than an oppressor so why should they vote for it? Then in 2019 the BJP's share of the Dalit vote increased!
Then in 2020 or so he wrote a piece trolling Modi by asking him to rig the selection process for the Ram temple committee to put a Dalit in charge.
YOU to Dilip Mandal ?????????????????? Shame......
Was Akshay Anand removed due to his recent interview with Pranoy Roy...Who knows Behenji might have succumbed to pressure from BJP'S central leadership
If you think that, then you seem too young to know what Mayawati is.
Dilip Mandal ji has unqualified bias.
Raise of BSP is dependent on muslim's fatigue and disappointment with SP which has been happening and may culminate after the result of current election. If Muslims take side with BSP it would become a massive force and SP will become just small marginal player.
दरी बिछाऊ लोग नही समझेंगे ये बात
Some corrections bjp ka votes share 2017 se 2022 me vidhan sabha me 1.47 + huwa thha 55 seats bipolar election ke karan Hara gaya thha jo 2017 me nahi thha
the print should use tag of " BJP Spokesperson" for this mandal guy.
28:07
BJP's vote share actually increased b\t 2017 and 2022
by 1.62% from 39.67% to 41.29%
सवाल पूछने वाले को इतना अंग्रेजी में नहीं बोलना चाहिए था।
Jai bhim
Jai bsp
Dilip mandal speak like bsp spokesperson 😂😂
Gupta ji, Dr.Roy did that interview and he will scale up soon.
Desh main kya chal raha hain aur aap kis chiz par content bana rahe ho sir...
Mandal ji, are you listening what are you saying..
So basically BJP is NO WHERE without the help of other political parties and breakaway bands. 😂
Where have you been dude, started getting worried. Tumhara Rona dekhne ki aadat hai comment section me.
@@SunilKumar-nf7ft
Truth hurts? happy to know😂
@@mg.f.9023 the only person hurting in TP comments section is you.
You are so hurt you have to cry under each and every video.
I'm not sure what's the actual deal with you. Like how can someone be so religiously against a party that they have to talk negative under every single video. Are you related to some Congress neta who lost and in turn you lost some kickback you were getting.
Tell me man what's the actual deal with you.
@@SunilKumar-nf7ft
I will tell you what the deal is.. The Nation's Main stream Media has been hijacked by your Fascist BJP/RSS and want the people of this Nation to live in a bubble created by your ITcell and Godi media... Now your kind are even irritated of any comments exposing the TRUTH. You wish no one speaks about the deterioration of this Nation by your fascist agenda. ... Don't deny it.
D K Singh Jee 🫡👏👏
Dilip's argument that Akash is been preserved is so stupid. You dont preserve your assets but make it battle ready. Whats the point in taking perspective of people who tries to create a smokescreen and diverge from reality. Are we so stupid that whatever you say we will accept? DK's throught process is clear and is based on logical derivatives.
बीएसपी शून्य नहीं हुई थी, बलिया ज़िले की रसड़ा विधानसभा सीट से पार्टी के उमाशंकर सिंह जीते थे.
BSP means Mayawati. Mayawati is not a common woman. She is something else, what's inside her ,is only known to her. She will never go for family politics. She is looking for a Diamond. And the Diamond of the Best' standard and quality isn't easy to find. So it will take Time.
जातिवादी हमेशा बसपा की आलोचना करते हैं।
Confusion worst confounded. Only one thing is clear, Mayawati is definitely helping BJP 😂
Few days the Quality of CTC Fallen ..( Please keep noted).... Very hard to keep listening ( focused )even for few minutes....
... Anyway love for Shekhar Sir...
Mish .
Niagara Falls City .
food for thought; why the print has lower subscribers compared to Ravish Kumar who is way ahead; both coming out same time; need to relook on the content and stand.
playing neutral shows that you are playing safe; and being weak to speak ur stand; hard to get crowd to trust you, being owning your own channel, be free with your thought; unlike working under someone pressure, unless you say I dont have any stand; hard to believe that, thats my 2 cents to you Sir
Aakash - berojgari, mahgai agniveer has increased and BJP is responsible...
Maya- immature beta say Modi is vishvaguru, ramrajya has come....
Prit- mayavati is preserving energy ....🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Akash Anand jindabad 💐💐
2 guests nothing to share no value add.
Prof. Dilip Mandal seems to be an irrational supporter of the BSP and a silent supporter of the BJP. It might not be surprising if he gets a ticket in future
You are very naive 😅
Why is there so much discussion on this topic, Mayawati has clearly tweeted the reason for his demotion? Why are you guys thinking too much about this whole topic?
Dried up
Dilip mandal ji ne सवं के हित के लिये बीजेपी जोइन कर ली जब dr अम्बेडकर बहुजन के हित के लिये संघर्ष कर रहे थे कुछ ओबीसी दलित नेता आरएसएस, हिन्दू परिषद की गोद में बैठे थे
Dalit mondal lies to us or himself Series of events prove Maya is on Modi remote-ED etc. Dalits in denial are fooling themselves
Hey Christian . Antonio manio didn't teach you talk dilip mandal is Bania ( jaiswal ) , Dilip mandal is not a Dalit . Btw 90% indian Christians are converted from Shudra and dalit castes , this is said by Dr Ambedkar himself . So your ancestors are themselves Dalits/Shudras. Educate yourself.
Flimsy
Turmoil in bsp leads its votes transfer difficult to BJP. Mayavati trying to leverage with bjp for coming 2027 assembly elections. She might think its becoming bjp difficult to come to power and wants to her vote bank to go for sp and congress alliance as bjp slogan of is bar 400 par and its against reservation narrative is cooking up.
Dileep Mandal says Mayawati is good politician???? In wat way??? Building statues, parks, corruption. Voter's r getting smart, they want development, better life, not her style of running govt
Statues are built even now.
@@sauron2000000show me yogi adityanath statue built by taxpayer money
@@Abiram69 Vallavbh Bhai Patel Statue
@@sauron2000000 are you comparing Patel to mayawati?lol
@@Abiram69 I am comparing statue to statue
The print is a godimedia and Shekhar Gupta is a b & d
Chamcha 😂 identified
Print is godi media? 😂😂 This is perhaps the first time Shekhar has been accused of that. We all know he is a die hard Leftist and a loyal Congressi.
@@rajbaniwal3236 exactly a congi
@@swaditi1 me or Shekhar or the main comment maker?
@@rajbaniwal3236 he was. Not any more. Look at his recent comments about the freedom of speech and take a look at Print posts these days.
nonsense talk by Dilip mandal. waste of time
As a core voter of bsp, let me assure u of one thing ... We r with bsp till we find a alternative... We are at war with all parties viz As INC, BJP, SP, etc. The ambedkarite ideologies will remain till eternity.... We will never vote for any party.... ASP may be our new 🏠
Good decision.🙏
Mandal should be thrown out of print and / or dk singh should start his own media outlet
Mandal's trying too hard to save BSP
SG is a fool and claimed Narendra will win 2024 and 2029... now Licking
Modi may offer Presidentship if he gets a third term. A first time female Dalit President 😂
In 2022 BJP's vote increased. BJP lost seats because BSP collaspsed and went to SP. BJP is still far no 1 in BJP. It hqs almost 44% votes
Shekhar Gupta has become a gas bag. Shekharji please give a short intro and let the experts speak
Sam PETRODA 😂, Shaikh Gupta’s uncle is live and kicking 😅😊
Congratulations Our Modiji has exposed Adani and Ambani that they gave crores of blackmoney thru tempos to Congress. Hope ED will believe PM statement and raid Adani Ambani.
His expression looks like that of a scared dog tugging his tail between his legs and urinate
Correct Jo dar gaya samjo mar gaya @@BI-iv7vu
@@BI-iv7vutwo Chinese discussing 😂
Wishful thinking 🧐
45 min on a party that has minimal relevance within the state and zero relevance outside it? Is this a joke? I would spend max 12 mins on this topic. Too long, didn't watch. Cheers and best wishes!
Actually what is obvious here is the insecurity of fake news peddlers like coiptaji