Who is forcing those soldiers to kill people on the other side of the world? Everyone is free to chose his/her job. Making a living of killing people is morally corrupt.
@XcXcz Sorry, my fault. Of course they protect their country. I just didn´t know the U.S. shares borders with Afghanistan and Iraq. Making the world your enemy is very patriotic. Whatever.
@XcXcz but it's part of the job, this dude has a valid take. Whatever their motives are they know they have the ability to kill people (this is not true for all parts of the army) but if you're partaking in more than training drills for offense then it's iffy. Also what exactly are most of the army protecting by entering other countries? I'm sure they're protecting by literally digging a hole in a graveyard on the other side of the world; The literal ex-soldier in the video even brings up this gray area. "They have to do as they're told" this is not nazi Germany, if you don't agree with job ethics - then leave, such a poor excuse - hence the morally corrupt part. The humanitarian part of the army doesn't make up for the political side. Let people challenge political ideas, it's the whole point of a democracy.
U.S Soldier Bowe Bergdahl was charged in military court with desertion and misbehavior before the enemy he was sent to prison after his release from the Taliban. Some U.S soldiers called Bowe Bergdahl a traitor some of his fellow soldiers were killed by the Taliban looking for him when he walked off base and went AWOL.
@@davidcheeseman658Bowe Bergdahl made himself look bad ! The facts are he went AWOL and got caught by the enemy and then went to a U.S military prison for it. Obama released 5 top Taliban fighters for exchange of a U.S traitor.
@@twinbee13monsterhunter he's not posing information like it is a truth to others though, apart from anything else you can lie the dead searchers at the feet of their commanding officers not Bergdahl.
@@davidcheeseman658 If sergeant Bergdahl never deserted his post their commanding officers would have never given the order to look him. U.S soldiers never leave anyone behind enemy lines.
@@twinbee13monsterhunter if Bush hadn't invaded he wouldn't have been there, hell if he hadn't illegally rigged the election he wouldn't have been in power. Doesn't change the fact that there are no deaths without direct chain of command faults during the search for him.
I thought the thumbnail was a line of penguins for a quick sec. Was really confused why they were in the desert and thought it was a vice documentary on worsening global warming
Aside from the title. Stupid comment, of course that's not how it works and penguins wouldn't last anywhere near a desert. . Also not a joke. If you understood the ferocity and implications of climate change, which is by far the biggest threat to us all,including China's impact on the earth and pollution, which is the earth's biggest problem, along with over population of humans (mostly in Asia and India etc.. that's by far the biggest impact on our earth and is what NO ONE will address 🧐😩😡.. time is ticking and politically correct bs won't save you from overwhelming death looming, which it is.
Why would you add Ilford HP5 Film “film strip” masks to his images.. I’m assuming by doing so he shot digitally? Btw, Ilford HP5 is a black & white film.
I wonder if he was shooting digitally. 2005... quite possible, but a lot of photojournalists were still shooting film then too. Certainly wasn’t HP5 though, you’re right!
madmitch105 the borders around the color photographs say “Illford HP5 Plus,” but HP5 is a BW filmstock which means that was added digitally and not the real border.
@@twinbee13monsterhunter And that very same government and their 'allies' achieved what exactly else after spending countless billions of dollars and sending this dude to jail... ? 🦗
@@checkcheck1579 And they didn't arm him previously to fight the Soviets in Afghanistan?😬 or that's all you had to say, so you typed it in here and @ me
This guy was super nice to listen to. I like that he was critical of the soldiers and really seems to have a well considered opinion which I agree with. Great video and great photos
They don’t do the best job of that and usually treat you as a sex slave as well. But the main reason to take an American POW is for that sweet sweet political currency. We traded a half a dozen or so Gitmo prisoners just for him.
@@m.albypods a lot of their reporters seem very young. So I wouldn't be surprised if they don't require a lot of previous experience. If you really want something, i believe in you. I hope to see you on some videos in a couple years!
@@Oakleaf700 yep... Left or Right whenever an "Independent" media company/journalist develops a base... Corporate Media sweeps in and buys it out....but doesnt tell the viewers. The Grayzone is the last good Independent News Networks... then its just vloggers.
@@sandguy134burns7 we know who you are if someone believes out of your thoughts there bad and a Nazi wee why he believes that and you can change what he thinks by giving proof
yeah vice, if you're going for the contact sheet look, especially in photo-journalism, please refrain from that unless it is an ACTUAL contact sheet from the photographer, if I were this dude I'd be highly disgraced by this amateurism.
He's a local boy from around here. Idk what to think myself. But I haven't heard of anyone or group harassing him. That would make the news here. I'm pretty sure he didn't get locked up.
wow you are absolutely right. I even did 1.5 speed and it was much more ear pleasing to watch/hear and get the info of the videos content. Could you imagine having an argument with this guy as his partner? Try hearing his argument for not putting the dishes in the dishwasher or the cap on the toothpaste.
Lol you act like you’re some philosopher or something... we’re not blind bud, we know what goes on but some of us don’t have any other option. I despise people like you who think us who join the military are just mindless robots. You’re the blind one from my perspective.
Too often we blame soldiers when its the politicians using us all.
Who is forcing those soldiers to kill people on the other side of the world? Everyone is free to chose his/her job. Making a living of killing people is morally corrupt.
@@relaxdreamsleepofficial5117 baby brain take
@XcXcz Sorry, my fault. Of course they protect their country. I just didn´t know the U.S. shares borders with Afghanistan and Iraq.
Making the world your enemy is very patriotic. Whatever.
@XcXcz but it's part of the job, this dude has a valid take. Whatever their motives are they know they have the ability to kill people (this is not true for all parts of the army) but if you're partaking in more than training drills for offense then it's iffy. Also what exactly are most of the army protecting by entering other countries? I'm sure they're protecting by literally digging a hole in a graveyard on the other side of the world; The literal ex-soldier in the video even brings up this gray area. "They have to do as they're told" this is not nazi Germany, if you don't agree with job ethics - then leave, such a poor excuse - hence the morally corrupt part. The humanitarian part of the army doesn't make up for the political side. Let people challenge political ideas, it's the whole point of a democracy.
They do injustice & they enjoy it.
Any man smoking a pipe on the battlefield is automatically +5 persuasion -5 Health
He deserted and American died to get him back
+3 charisma
And +5 for stupidity
@@tracyfollowell6747 it's not like their observation post was a hideout tho
-150 to LEGACY for this traitor no matter how you view these foreign wars.
1.25 playback speed fixes him
Thanks! Works good
Wow, he seems like a normal person now!
Are we just living too fast?
thanks!!
Most helpful comment😂😂😂😂
U.S Soldier Bowe Bergdahl was charged in military court with desertion and misbehavior before the enemy he was sent to prison after his release from the Taliban. Some U.S soldiers called Bowe Bergdahl a traitor some of his fellow soldiers were killed by the Taliban looking for him when he walked off base and went AWOL.
Reductive presentation of the facts exclusively to make him look bad.
@@davidcheeseman658Bowe Bergdahl made himself look bad ! The facts are he went AWOL and got caught by the enemy and then went to a U.S military prison for it. Obama released 5 top Taliban fighters for exchange of a U.S traitor.
@@twinbee13monsterhunter he's not posing information like it is a truth to others though, apart from anything else you can lie the dead searchers at the feet of their commanding officers not Bergdahl.
@@davidcheeseman658 If sergeant Bergdahl never deserted his post their commanding officers would have never given the order to look him. U.S soldiers never leave anyone behind enemy lines.
@@twinbee13monsterhunter if Bush hadn't invaded he wouldn't have been there, hell if he hadn't illegally rigged the election he wouldn't have been in power. Doesn't change the fact that there are no deaths without direct chain of command faults during the search for him.
After all these years Afghanistan still hasn’t seen peace
@bittercottoncandy so true and so sad 😢
@@user-ic1mx4hj5d why would you need it when you have 1000 year old religion to live by
There won’t be any until all the lithium is gone
@bittercottoncandy Americans invade a country then say there's no peace because of other countries lol.
@@drifter1171 in musk we trust
Stop invading countries that are not yours 🤷🏾♂️
That's the issue of white man
They’re trying to help the afghan govt, the taliban aren’t associated with them. its not invading its providing aid
Is that what you say when Mexicans and foreigners legally crossed the border into the USA!?
@@ghostcasper3185of course not that would make too much sense
I thought the thumbnail was a line of penguins for a quick sec. Was really confused why they were in the desert and thought it was a vice documentary on worsening global warming
😂😂😂 ... Stay tuned and coming up next ... Your eye trick will be realty
ua-cam.com/video/dY5sLobuarc/v-deo.html...
@@ibrotv8070 well that didn't go well
Aside from the title. Stupid comment, of course that's not how it works and penguins wouldn't last anywhere near a desert. . Also not a joke. If you understood the ferocity and implications of climate change, which is by far the biggest threat to us all,including China's impact on the earth and pollution, which is the earth's biggest problem, along with over population of humans (mostly in Asia and India etc.. that's by far the biggest impact on our earth and is what NO ONE will address 🧐😩😡.. time is ticking and politically correct bs won't save you from overwhelming death looming, which it is.
@@doxasophosmoros Kaboom, more like kare(o)n
Ok, so i've edited this comment in order to increase the confusion.
Thanks
?? Ok 🤷♂️
??
@@dannyp4312 yea what are they talking bout dude secret video? lol what are they smoking
Yea now that I’ve had a week to watch it with mactwiggles I’m glad it’s public
so this got posted 6 minutes ago but there are comments from 6 days ago....huh
Strange times we live in
Ikr
It was unlisted hiding from us idk why
It was posted a week ago, probably public by accident. A lot of people upload in advance
Premium subscriptions
Why would you add Ilford HP5 Film “film strip” masks to his images.. I’m assuming by doing so he shot digitally?
Btw, Ilford HP5 is a black & white film.
I wonder if he was shooting digitally. 2005... quite possible, but a lot of photojournalists were still shooting film then too. Certainly wasn’t HP5 though, you’re right!
@Liverpool 11 still made and used today! I have a half dozen rolls I need to develop right now haha
ua-cam.com/video/dY5sLobuarc/v-deo.html...
Doesn’t make any sense. I think the earlier photos were film, but the latter were definitely digital
I believe its just an after effects templates they slap on the images for viewing purposes
Why the comments from a week ago when this video was uploaded 14 minutes ago wtf???
UA-cam premium
Maybe Someone replied or liked it
@@Ops535 YTP members don’t get early access
@First name Last name Vice doesn’t have a membership. UA-cam Premium has.
Dude are you an idiot!?!
WE ARE THE ELITE CHOSEN FEW WHO HAVE BEEN DEEMED WORTHY TO VIEW THIS SECRET VIDEO
Great storytelling. Please keep making these and allowing for the people behind the lens to open up a conversation around their subjects and captures.
At 1.25x speed his voice is actually normal.
Wow. Thanks.
Yup I did that just bc he talks so slow
1.5x is more realistic I feel
Excellent video, Vice! Keep this up 🙏🏼
Incredible segment of words and information. Thank you VICE once again for providing what no other news outlet would.
the music never disappoints on the channel=) Makes the atmosphere.
This algorithm is broken, this video uploaded 13 minutes ago and theres people from the past. Am i in the future inside the past?
oh wtf, were are in a simulation
It might have been a private video made public again
@Nicky Nutnut I think people just stumbled upon it, most people in the comments found it on autoplay because it was unlisted
Its something called unlist
I got this on autoplay whilst unlisted
Got it through an annotation in another video. Idk why its hidden
Weird. It’s in my sub box, yt feed and I got a notif.
you are a timetraveller
@@sav- I guess they published it
@@sav- those comments were posted a week ago
So you made a video about pictures? Great job vice !!
I appreciate you want to show that those pictures have been taken on film, but I would be careful as "Ilford HP5 Plus" never was a color film ;-)
Indeed! Our dad was a professional photographer... Ilford B&W.
yes really dumb, I also hate it when this bullshit influencers using portra fake film filters for b/w pictures!
I saw no mention of film.
madmitch105 the borders around the color photographs say “Illford HP5 Plus,” but HP5 is a BW filmstock which means that was added digitally and not the real border.
madmitch105 it is visible at 0:14
This man has such a unique cadence and style of speech. It’s most certainly a unique viewing experience.
Yes it’s unique to people of asbergers
@@taynocappin2374 It is. I assumed he might be an aspie.
loving the picture series
His dissent is noted though. Literally just walked away...
He was charged in U.S military court with desertion and misbehavior before the enemy. He was sent to prison after his release from the Taliban.
@@twinbee13monsterhunter And that very same government and their 'allies' achieved what exactly else after spending countless billions of dollars and sending this dude to jail... ?
🦗
@@twinbee13monsterhunter he didn’t go to prison. He was fined $10,000, reduced to Private rank, and discharged from the military
@@Treysorable they killed osama
@@checkcheck1579 And they didn't arm him previously to fight the Soviets in Afghanistan?😬 or that's all you had to say, so you typed it in here and @ me
That guy was litteraly the definition of Captain Price.
Are those pictures taken on film or digital? What camera do you reckon?
That was my first time hearing word *"centigrade"* instead of *Celsius*
It's used quite commonly in the UK
@@davidcheeseman658 im british and its barely used you must be high
@@lifelikeaglitch7343 I'd reflexivity use it instead of Celsius and have heard it plenty, each to their own.
No need to be a dick.
@@davidcheeseman658 nah it was just a light joke, sorry.
Are you for real?
This guy was super nice to listen to. I like that he was critical of the soldiers and really seems to have a well considered opinion which I agree with. Great video and great photos
Why would they keep a prisoner for 5 years. They gotta feed him. Clean him and whatnot. Never understood why he left post in the first place
They don’t do the best job of that and usually treat you as a sex slave as well.
But the main reason to take an American POW is for that sweet sweet political currency. We traded a half a dozen or so Gitmo prisoners just for him.
@@LBdreamin nothing like handing over terrorists for traitors.
doctor: "you have 6 minutes and 26 seconds left to live"
me:
I like ya ass g
Put some clothes on and learn how to post something original.
gang, unlisted ayeeeeee
How did you comment 1 week ago when this video came out 1 day ago?
Nisar yt premium
Deeep 😩
"What one says kills another a thousand miles away.."
why is this video hidden ????? it makes you think
Yeah.. Wtf??
Vice usually has some weird terms. You get a lot of videos blocked in some countries to.
How do you know it's hidden?
@@kev9486 look at the views mate, its also unlisted
Traitor pos who got good men killed.
I wonder what software is the photographer using? Surely not Lightroom.
I’m Sean smith and I talk very slow
2003:
2020: Weapons of mass destruction.... Still looking ? Covid hold my beer....
How do I volunteer to get sent by Vice to do these deadly documentaries 👀
go get a journalism degree and then go apply. Make sure you practice your camera voice and face in the mirror.
@@TheSword2212 I’m actually about to graduate with a journalism degree 🙏🏻🙌🏻 I’ll work towards that 🙌🏻
@@m.albypods a lot of their reporters seem very young. So I wouldn't be surprised if they don't require a lot of previous experience. If you really want something, i believe in you. I hope to see you on some videos in a couple years!
Who remembers when 'Vice' was a magazine given away free in 'edgy' music shops? {probably 1990's?..It was always interesting.
Now its owned and run by Ex Obama Security State Officials and its EXCLUSIVE Purpose is make Regime Change/Endless Wars HIP to Millenials.
@@sisyphusvasilias3943 Sadly I think you are right.
@@Oakleaf700 yep... Left or Right whenever an "Independent" media company/journalist develops a base... Corporate Media sweeps in and buys it out....but doesnt tell the viewers.
The Grayzone is the last good Independent News Networks... then its just vloggers.
I love this series!
I hope the photographer is safe
😂😂😂 that explains
More photo content from vice, this is gold!
Brilliant description of the blind leading the blind. The soldier is blindly following orders and the prisoners are blindly following the soldier.
I see that after the US lost in Afghanistan, the pentagon are showing how tough they are after the world recognized their weakness.
You clearly dont know what your talking about. Or your just trolling. Or both
K Nazi
stfu
Lol u jus the only one still thinking about that...
@@sandguy134burns7 we know who you are if someone believes out of your thoughts there bad and a Nazi wee why he believes that and you can change what he thinks by giving proof
Incredible photos
Misleading title and thumbnail, Vice. And 1:46 that's not a Marine, that's a US Army soldier.
Bergdahl was captured?
Didn’t know US Marines were issued ACU’s 🙄😆
I was thinking the same thing but imma shut up 😂
Great podcast about the solider that went walk about. Nuts story. He just wandered into enemy territory. Mad
What podcast?
@@BobbyTMF Serial
@@prettylittleravenna awesome thanks. I need to check them out
@@BobbyTMF You’re welcome. It’s a great podcast, every season is a different case, highly recommended
Dang, unlisted?
wtf ur comment is week ago but video is published hours ago
@@unapologetic7291 Yeah I somehow watched it back when it was unlisted hence my original comment :D
yeah vice, if you're going for the contact sheet look, especially in photo-journalism, please refrain from that unless it is an ACTUAL contact sheet from the photographer, if I were this dude I'd be highly disgraced by this amateurism.
Makes me scared for my little brother who just joined the military last year.
@Mukhtar Vp He doesn't get to choose where he goes.
Uploads a whole video of a guy describing a photograph.
It’s the slow ass voice for me
Eh
Slow motion ass voice
Put it on 1.25X it’s perfect
Seeing those „negatives“ and spotting „Ilford HP5+“ as medium format on color digital frames just kills it for me. Sorry
Put your playback speed at 1.25x or 1.5x for it to sound normal
Bergdahl got exactly what he asked for. Discussion over.
One doesn’t experience self-transcendence, the illusion of self only dissipates🔻Non-Duality
Dude... shut up
Bruh what are you smoking
Color Positive HP5? Where do you get that?
This man sounded depressed
Damn where can I get some of that color ilford film??
Ok I just need to say that the soldier leading the blindfolded men was not a Marine.
Anyone else notice the Ilford hp5 filmstrip? Why would you put b&w film strip for an obvious color photo?
He wasn't captured. He joined them. Of his own free will.
Looks like that guy had a sense of humanity by walking away
wow us "marines" rescued him. that was the us army ACU camo was only used by the us army
Depends. Every service has people in Army kit from time to time.
If you want to hear more about this story there’s a podcast called Serial which covers the story I think in its second season
Thank you so much. Listening now. Season 2 - all episodes.
So many unanswered questions like wtf man
He's a local boy from around here. Idk what to think myself. But I haven't heard of anyone or group harassing him. That would make the news here. I'm pretty sure he didn't get locked up.
Why are some of the comments are from 1 week ago???
God Bless 🇦🇫Afghanistan🇦🇫and it's people.
Imagine seeing your country leader shaking hands with the leader of the country you are fighting in...
I'm pretty sure this guy left his post thinking he was gonna kill every terrorist he sees and just got caught instead
photos were colored so beautifullly
You gotta watch it at 1.25x speed
Thank you
I love you Vice, gj
2:07 ye right, u didnt know. EXACTLY!
what...? is that some "ah hah" moment for you?
Perfect timing, I just finished...
Spoilers ?
@@valerielopez8302 she's pregnant.
@@llRandomxStuffxManll what were u referring to ? is there a movie or series about this?
By Christ this guy would put a sloth to sleep with his voice
You may know "disorientate" by it's street name "disorient."
Amen. Drives me NUTS
All I got from this is that this guy has a hard on for the taliban
Someone else should have narrated this video. He drags this out and the content is lost on me.
Play at 1.25 speed.
wow you are absolutely right. I even did 1.5 speed and it was much more ear pleasing to watch/hear and get the info of the videos content. Could you imagine having an argument with this guy as his partner? Try hearing his argument for not putting the dishes in the dishwasher or the cap on the toothpaste.
Some "combat journalist" you are. 1:44 is a soldier, not a marine.
what the difference tho, can you explain it to me good sir.
Nobody cares Phillip you dork
@@paperexplain9342 A marine is in the US Marine Corps. A soldier is in the US Army.
Lost opportunity to take an epic selfie
He wasn’t captured he’s a traitor!!!
how tf are there comments from almost a week ago if the video just got posted? i am confusion
How are his pupils that small with all the lights pointing at him?
because that's what happens when your eyes are exposed to light?
The blind leading the blind very true
Lol you act like you’re some philosopher or something... we’re not blind bud, we know what goes on but some of us don’t have any other option. I despise people like you who think us who join the military are just mindless robots. You’re the blind one from my perspective.
@@ElijahJenkins2196 if joining the military is the only option then you have a long way to go to leave the middle ages
@@Sadik15B you’re ignorant and closed minded... sad
Vice videos 36 hours = 1 day
This is the truth and war is never justified despite what many Americans believe
The guy couldn’t sound more monotone if he tried
“2000 and free”
The soldier leading the prisoners is not a marine, its a army soldier.
@Joe Sudz The soldier is wearing US Army UCP camo, the Marine Corp uses MARAPT
How tf are there comments from 6 days ago
So what was the moral of the video cause I’m so confused
War is old men talking and young people dying
Deep
I like people that WEREN'T captured
All sides were right yet all sides were wrong.
In this rate i won't go in afghanistan.
I thought the thumbnail was penguin 😬