[OLD] My Personal Ranking of Elsa (63 Versions)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 29 бер 2022
  • Heyoo! This is the last vid I had saved on my drive... But I still hope you enjoy!
    #Elsa #Disney #Frozen #PersonalRanking

КОМЕНТАРІ • 150

  • @mademousiele20
    @mademousiele20 Рік тому +12

    I love when non-lovers Taryn spizlman says that she sounds too old for elsa but when you look into their top 10 voices, they put voices like Arabic in first, which I'm not complain because I love her voice too and she's is also one of my favorites, but guys c'mon 🤣🤣🤣.

    • @mademousiele20
      @mademousiele20 Рік тому +1

      Just say already that she's not enjoyable to you, nobody is gonna kill you or something for it LMAO ☠️😂.

    • @maniagirl1801
      @maniagirl1801  Рік тому +3

      Nesma doesn't sound old at all, neither does Taryn (maybe a little), what I might say for Elsas that sound old would be Serena and Monika, but both of them sing magnificently the songs :)

    • @elijahmartinobracia4741
      @elijahmartinobracia4741 Рік тому +4

      I think it's because Taryn is more on the brass side, while Nesma is more on the rich side. And a brass voice doesn't really work with these kinds of songs which were more on the bold yet melodic type. Nesma, on the other hand, sounds mature and rich, but this richness is probably what makes her blend incredibly well with these songs, making them work in the most otherworldly beautifully way. This is all just my opinion.

    • @mariarinta-rahko958
      @mariarinta-rahko958 2 місяці тому

      Ikr

  • @n.uvideos1947
    @n.uvideos1947 2 роки тому +11

    12:26 Thank you very much for 25
    A lot of people put Taryn last and say she's not a good Elsa

  • @luc5773
    @luc5773 Рік тому +2

    loved how different your ranking is from the others 🙂

  • @Isabela_Buckley
    @Isabela_Buckley Рік тому +9

    Ty for the 3th place! My fav Elsa is Castilian (I know that is the same in Catalan but I prefer her in Castilian) Bulgarian and Danish are fantastic too

  • @GowayriaSaif
    @GowayriaSaif Рік тому +1

    Your personal ranking is so beautiful ❤❤

  • @alexanderbolton
    @alexanderbolton Рік тому +4

    My favourites are
    Finnish (i love the power she has and i actually like that's she's different)
    Sami (she fits perfectly)
    Kazakh (F2) a major improvent and extremely memorable with great power.
    Estonian (i think she does go a bit overboard sometimes but the voice is amazing)
    German + Dutch (definitely a true Elsa, dutch is better of the two)
    Greek (another favourite who really fits the role)
    Abkhaz (i know many think she's bad but in frozen 2 she does amazingly well, especially in Uabaķoy nac (show yourself).
    Danish (number 1 for me, she rocked it).

  • @banka3475
    @banka3475 2 роки тому +8

    Thanks for taryn 💚

  • @elijahmartinobracia4741
    @elijahmartinobracia4741 Рік тому +6

    Owen is also the voice of Pepa in Encanto, but I would still prefer her as Elsa. Not the best rendition, but I love the happiness that radiates in her LIG, and the heartwarming delivery from both her FTFTIF and the reprise. Her voice is not really disgusting, it's not really the best word to describe her, but doesn't really fit, but still a decent performance.

    • @maniagirl1801
      @maniagirl1801  Рік тому

      I prefer her nowhere

    • @elijahmartinobracia4741
      @elijahmartinobracia4741 Рік тому +2

      @@maniagirl1801 I'm actually surprised you still respond to comments that commented days ago in your videos that were uploaded many months ago

    • @maniagirl1801
      @maniagirl1801  Рік тому

      @@elijahmartinobracia4741 I always reply

    • @momoxhienie1204
      @momoxhienie1204 Рік тому +2

      I think, if anything, she just doesn't fit Elsa in terms of her voice imo, but yeah I agree, "disgusting" isn't the best term to describe her voice (how is it disgusting?). I do love her performance as Pepa in Encanto though.

    • @maniagirl1801
      @maniagirl1801  Рік тому +1

      @@momoxhienie1204 the ranking is old, I don't wanna explain myself, I'm working on the updated one

  • @hellskitchenlover
    @hellskitchenlover 6 місяців тому +2

    My forever Elsa are Dalma and Shanis ❤😊 but everyone has their opinions anyway ;)

  • @mimishor7783
    @mimishor7783 2 роки тому +5

    thx for 4th place🇹🇩🇹🇩🇹🇩 at first I really couldn t believe that we re so high :))

    • @maniagirl1801
      @maniagirl1801  2 роки тому +3

      I adore Dalma, she deserves to be high in every ranking

  • @elijahmartinobracia4741
    @elijahmartinobracia4741 Рік тому +2

    I also find the songs very....high-quality, don't know how to describe it though

  • @igottasneeze091
    @igottasneeze091 2 роки тому +2

    Тази класация е всичко! Не се разбрахме само по едно нещо, което намирам за много смешно. Както и да е, благодаря за 6/31 и 60. Харесвам тази класация и редакцията. Снежинката отстрани със знамената на всяка страна е толкова невероятна.

  • @BMZ_Multilanguages
    @BMZ_Multilanguages 2 роки тому +6

    This is your old rankings or new rankings? Btw thanks for Malay

  • @Hikari_Saito
    @Hikari_Saito 2 роки тому +3

    I heard that your original channel got hacked and terminated. Is there any chance you’ll get it up and running again? (Perhaps via contacting UA-cam)

    • @maniagirl1801
      @maniagirl1801  2 роки тому +2

      I contacted UA-cam and they said they can't return me my channel... I really feel terrible that I lost everything... Thanks for thinking of me tho

    • @Hikari_Saito
      @Hikari_Saito 2 роки тому

      @@maniagirl1801 Aww man, that’s awful. Well, I hope you’ll be able to regain your following. Keep making great content!

    • @maniagirl1801
      @maniagirl1801  2 роки тому

      @@Hikari_Saito thank you so so so much

    • @n.uvideos1947
      @n.uvideos1947 2 роки тому

      Знайте, че вече сте ме абонирали

    • @evelynmedrano522lover
      @evelynmedrano522lover Рік тому

      @@maniagirl1801Your old channel got terminated? That sucks hun. Trust me, mine too tbh.

  • @LiaLuna96
    @LiaLuna96 8 місяців тому +2

    Elsa in italian is perfect,she is warm and mature❤ perfect Serena Autieri

  • @m.e.g.a.n07
    @m.e.g.a.n07 Рік тому +4

    Danish number 1!! My favourite version😍💕🥰 I love Maria Lucia

  • @PopRock-gl5ey
    @PopRock-gl5ey 5 місяців тому +1

    I absolutely agree on everything you said about Willejmin,I"ve never found why she is so beloved her vibrato is very irritating sometimes especially in Dutch,Thanks for 23rd place btw!My biggest disagreement would be Malay she is my #1 no doubt but we have many disagreements so I will not comment others...

    • @maniagirl1801
      @maniagirl1801  5 місяців тому

      Finally someone agrees with me about Willemijn! Also anytime soon I'll remake the ranking
      Sad we have disagreements but that's what opinions are for

    • @PopRock-gl5ey
      @PopRock-gl5ey 5 місяців тому +1

      By my username You should know I adore Pop By the way What would be your Ranking of Let It Go Pop this Is Mine: 1.Korean🇰🇷 2.Chinese Mandarin🇨🇳 3.Italian🇮🇹 4.Spanish🇬🇹 5.Indonesian🇮🇩 6.Malay🇲🇾 7.French🇫🇷 8.Russian🇷🇺 9.Portuguese🇵🇹 10.Japanese🇯🇵 11.English🇺🇲 12.Kazakh🇰🇿

    • @maniagirl1801
      @maniagirl1801  5 місяців тому

      @@PopRock-gl5ey yeah, we disagree a lot but maybe someday I'll make a ranking of it too

    • @PopRock-gl5ey
      @PopRock-gl5ey 5 місяців тому +1

      @@maniagirl1801 How many Disney Songs have Pop Version Btw I only know for Let It Go and How Far"Ill go Your Ranking of How Far II" go Pop not sure about mine

    • @maniagirl1801
      @maniagirl1801  5 місяців тому

      @@PopRock-gl5ey I can't tell you now, but they're a lot :)

  • @MysticalLemonade
    @MysticalLemonade 2 роки тому +2

    Thank you for Vietnamese being 8th. I’m kinda sad that you ranked Vietnamese Encanto dubs low but I agree with your options at the same time lol

    • @maniagirl1801
      @maniagirl1801  2 роки тому +2

      Well yeah, vnese Mirabel and Luisa ain't really my faves, but in other rankings vnese is higher 👀

    • @MysticalLemonade
      @MysticalLemonade 2 роки тому +2

      @@maniagirl1801 Ok, btw, how in the universe did you find these versions of Elsas especially in the languages that almost no one knows like Abkhaz, Northern Sámi and Karachay-Balkar??

    • @maniagirl1801
      @maniagirl1801  2 роки тому +2

      @@MysticalLemonade I'm a true disnerd

    • @alexanderbolton
      @alexanderbolton Рік тому +1

      I think the main issue with the encanto dub is that they are quite nasally, and i think many don't see the characters in the singer's voices.

  • @inimaluminoasa3363
    @inimaluminoasa3363 Рік тому +5

    Fun fact: this is would exactly my personal ranking for Elsa. As for the romanian Elsa(my native version) Dalma is the perfect choice,i can not think about another girl to cast her...maybe Alexandra Crăescu,she would be great,too. I was wondering,what if Meshi Kleinstein casted Elsa? It would have been to much,even if i like her. Sometimes in my mind i make switches between a disney movie cast(all around the globe) and another. It would have been fun if Jasmine's all around the world cast would have been casting Elsa(do i make sense?) I would totally want to hear Nevena Goneva singing Let it Go or Maria Haukaas's high notes etc

    • @maniagirl1801
      @maniagirl1801  Рік тому

      I'm glad
      Also, I'm a huge fan of Alexandra Crăescu, so I want her as all roles

    • @elijahmartinobracia4741
      @elijahmartinobracia4741 Рік тому +1

      @@maniagirl1801 I wonder if Maria Haukaas dubbed Elsa though

    • @elijahmartinobracia4741
      @elijahmartinobracia4741 Рік тому +2

      Meshi is obviously an overused voice and her best asset is definitely the gentility that she took in...all her characters she dubbed, and it doesn't always work in all, and sometimes you need a different take to stand out.

    • @maniagirl1801
      @maniagirl1801  Рік тому

      @@elijahmartinobracia4741 YES PLEASE

  • @ilj9662
    @ilj9662 Рік тому +1

    Mania girl what do you think about maori elsa(awhimai fraser)?

  • @mariarinta-rahko958
    @mariarinta-rahko958 2 місяці тому +1

    Willemijin isn't my favourite as Elsa the energy is amazing and the speaking parts are perfect. Her acting is perfect and she is very talented she just doesen't fit Elsa. Love her as other characters and she killed it as Elphaba from the Wicked musical. Not a fan of Willemijn but i really like her💛💛💛

  • @ashton_white
    @ashton_white 6 місяців тому +1

    3:52

    • @ashton_white
      @ashton_white 6 місяців тому

      I don’t mind Elsa in E.U Portuguese it just probably wasn’t the best fit for Elsa

  • @PopRock-gl5ey
    @PopRock-gl5ey 4 місяці тому +1

    When we can expect a remake?

  • @enggoleando
    @enggoleando 2 роки тому +3

    what does (F1, FF, 0FA, F2...) means?

    • @maniagirl1801
      @maniagirl1801  2 роки тому +4

      Frozen 1, Frozen Fever, Olaf's Frozen Adventures, Frozen 2

    • @enggoleando
      @enggoleando 2 роки тому +2

      @@maniagirl1801 ow ty for the explanation

    • @maniagirl1801
      @maniagirl1801  2 роки тому

      @@enggoleando alwaysss

  • @xXRosaliefanxX
    @xXRosaliefanxX 2 роки тому +4

    my personal Favorites are Norwegian, German, English, Italian and Spanish and my Personal true Elsa is her mother tongue, the Norwegian one, I love the Norwegian version of show yourself so much 😍❤️ I have it on my mobilephone

  • @elijahmartinobracia4741
    @elijahmartinobracia4741 Рік тому +2

    I have a question: if I'm going to Bulgaria, can I live there only speaking English?

    • @maniagirl1801
      @maniagirl1801  Рік тому

      No, because not so many people speak english here, sadly

    • @elijahmartinobracia4741
      @elijahmartinobracia4741 Рік тому +1

      @@maniagirl1801 Can you teach me some Bulgarian? The only Bulgarian word I can say is Zdraveite, which means hello (I can't do Cyrillic)

    • @maniagirl1801
      @maniagirl1801  Рік тому

      @@elijahmartinobracia4741 Sure, tell me what do you wanna know?

    • @elijahmartinobracia4741
      @elijahmartinobracia4741 Рік тому +2

      @@maniagirl1801 Some daily basic Bulgarian phrases. Good thing for me that I know a bit of the Cyrillic alphabet

    • @maniagirl1801
      @maniagirl1801  Рік тому

      @@elijahmartinobracia4741 You must learn the whole cyrillic alphabet
      Also please tell me the exact things you wanna know, I'll translate everything for you

  • @HeroManNick132
    @HeroManNick132 2 роки тому +2

    Честно казано малко ме е яд, че Антоанета Георгиева или позната повече като Тони у нас, е участвала в този филм също, озвучавайки като Булда, ала не е получила по-главна роля, спрямо Надя, която почти винаги получава все главните роли и вече ми омръзва от нея честно казано, срещайки я в почти във всеки анимационен филм, който ѝ падне.
    Между другото Тони е била по-дълго време в дублажи, спрямо Надя, ама те я наемат за много специфични роли и нито един път като главна героиня. Тя беше в Златният боец, Барби, Уинкс, Финиъс и Фърб и последно в Сейди Спаркс в песните, ама като роля само като Булда я пишат, че са е озвучавала и в този филм в хор на по-подценените песни от Замръзналото кралство, ама в първата част.
    Въпреки, че тя едва ли щеше да е по-добър избор за Елза, спрямо Надя, защото тя е и по-възрастна на всичкото отгоре, ала все пак ми се искаше да участваше по-често в по-главни роли. Изненадва ме, че за нейната си възраст има сравнително млад глас, защото съм виждал хора, които са по-млади от нея и в други дублажи, ала звучат сякаш, че са по-възрастни.
    Обикновено аз много рядко съм я срещал да пее в дублажи, ала в Уинкс тя най-възхително се беше представила и ми е чудно как ли би се представила тук, ако беше назначена в по-главна роля да пее? Според мен тя е доста подценена певица и повече ми харесва от Надя Панайотова. Не, че я мразя Надя, ама просто за мен е ту така, ту иначе. В един дублаж е гола вода, а в друг - проблясва като например в ,,Мега-чудесата на Калинката и Черния котарак" в някои песни се старае, ама в други не се старае чак толкова много. В първия филм на ,,Замръзналото кралство" изобщо не ми харесваше как пееше, ала във втория поне жената се постара повече и вложи повече усилия.
    Даже ,,Слагам край" в ,,Гласът на България" беше по-добро представянето ѝ някак си, спрямо тази в сериите. Ала все пак тя тогава не знам, откога е започнала да дублира, ама в самото начало на нейната си кариера в дублажите, е нямала никакъв опит, ала постепенно се подобрява, въпреки както казах - тя за мен е ту така, ту иначе! В едни е буквално кралица, а в други - гола вода.
    Забавен факт, че аз наскоро научих за тази Тони (миналата година) и преди това не съм знаел абсолютно нищо за нея. 😂Благодарение на нашия другар, който от време на време се появява във видеата ти - Митко Дралчев и той ми я беше показал. И както казах бях шокиран от нейното ѝ представяне в Уинкс, че даже тя спечели 2 Уинксовизии на Сиреникс и Хармоникс. Колко е иронично, че ние нито една Евровизия сме спечелили, ама сме спечили 2 и то на Уинкс, където уж на италиански всички предпочитаха песните, ала като гледам някак си Тони ги разби в сезон 5 песните.🤣

    • @maniagirl1801
      @maniagirl1801  2 роки тому +1

      Аз да ти кажа честно съм много зле с имената, и дори не знам повечето български дубльори, ако ми хареса, хареса ми и дотам

    • @HeroManNick132
      @HeroManNick132 2 роки тому +2

      @@maniagirl1801 То и аз съм така хаха. И аз не знам всичките наши дубльори разбира се и почти да се каже с всяка измината година все научавам нови и нови, които съм изпуснал досега хаха.
      Да се каже долу-горе съм научил повечето наши актьори тук, ама има и все още такива, които не съм ги запомнил като цяло хаха.
      Между другото Тони беше се появявала 1-2 пъти по телевизията изненадващо, както да кажем както и Вилма Карталска и още други, за които не се сещам в момента.
      Ама тази Златина Тасева, която ми стана една от любимите дубльорки, заради Финиъс и Фърб не съм я виждал пред екрана нито веднъж, ала па дано да я извикат все пак, че ми е приятно да си видя моите любими български актьори от детството ми, хаха.

    • @maniagirl1801
      @maniagirl1801  2 роки тому +1

      @@HeroManNick132 Налиии, друго си е да чуеш актьорите от детството

  • @mariarinta-rahko958
    @mariarinta-rahko958 2 місяці тому +2

    Love
    Shennio-Lin
    Katja
    Gisela
    Anai's
    Gam
    Hu Wei-Na
    Hanna-Liina
    Lisa
    Natasha
    Taryn
    Nadezhda
    Augusta
    Begum
    Dalma
    Marsha
    Annika
    Charlotte
    Gulsim
    Sia
    Idina
    Marianne
    Jelena
    Katarzyna
    Sophy
    Ramaya
    Jolanta
    Sarina
    Nuska

  • @aaronhoraciocerdanmorel4147
    @aaronhoraciocerdanmorel4147 4 місяці тому +1

    Are you still neutral about Carmen? Personally she is my version but i don't really like her, she sounds too robotic and i feel like her voice on Iduna will be perfect. I wish they casted Mayra Calderon for that Argentinian cover that was Actually Mexican, she would have been perfect for Elsa.
    My favorite Elsa is Hu-Weina, i love her wise voice and how serene and responsible she sounds, listening to her in the sequel always makes me think she really is Elsa.

    • @maniagirl1801
      @maniagirl1801  4 місяці тому

      Yes, I still am, but you'll know better when I remake the ranking
      Also nice suggestion you gave!
      And damn, your fave is a true queen and I totally agree with you

    • @aaronhoraciocerdanmorel4147
      @aaronhoraciocerdanmorel4147 3 місяці тому +1

      ​@@maniagirl1801Hi again! I have a question. How many versions are going to be in the remake of this rank?

    • @maniagirl1801
      @maniagirl1801  3 місяці тому

      @@aaronhoraciocerdanmorel4147 all of them plus the new ones but I'll exclude persian

  • @elijahmartinobracia4741
    @elijahmartinobracia4741 Рік тому +3

    I find the designs of your new rankings look a little lazy than your Elsa ranking or maybe it's because it doesn't have much design, only the character

    • @maniagirl1801
      @maniagirl1801  Рік тому

      Good thing I design my rankings the way I want them to be

    • @evelynmedrano522lover
      @evelynmedrano522lover Рік тому

      @@maniagirl1801your editing is soft and beautiful like seriously I’m not even kidding

  • @s.a8714
    @s.a8714 6 місяців тому +1

    This is My Ranking My Queens:Annika,Elke, Marsha,Wei-Na,Maria Lucia Love So Much:Jobelle,Jelena, Brandy Tien Love:Gisela,Sia,Nikolett, Kataryzna,Takako,Hye-Na, Hanna Liina,Anais,Charlotte, Anna Buturlina Very Good:,Gam,Mikha,Mafarikha, Sophy,Duong,Tieu,Shennio Gulsim,Ramya,Shruti,Sunidhi Like A Lot:Jolanta,Ana,Olha, Nadezhda,Carmen,Nataša, Andrea,Monika,Begum,Xalimat,Antonela(2015/2016),Sarina Ok:Willejmin,Roshansk,Serena, Lisa,Nuška,Mona,Yong-Chun, Tarranum,Saida,Owen,Parisa Dislike:Nesma,Ainur,Taryn, Afsehanih,Mina,

  • @HermionePotterRowling
    @HermionePotterRowling 2 роки тому +2

    Anaïs my favorite Elsa Forever

  • @alexjeremias521
    @alexjeremias521 Рік тому +1

    Taryn❤

  • @s.a8714
    @s.a8714 10 місяців тому +1

    Thanks for 23 this is the WORST version of Elsa Ranking

    • @maniagirl1801
      @maniagirl1801  10 місяців тому

      Glad you like it 🥰

    • @s.a8714
      @s.a8714 10 місяців тому +1

      I literally Said this is the worst mit best,so many disagreements that I don't know where to start🤣

    • @maniagirl1801
      @maniagirl1801  10 місяців тому

      @@s.a8714 i know i just don't care 😚

    • @s.a8714
      @s.a8714 6 місяців тому

      So sorry for seeing worst I mean the most Weird

  • @someonerandomidk
    @someonerandomidk 2 роки тому +4

    Persian is so hated lol

    • @HeroManNick132
      @HeroManNick132 2 роки тому +3

      If they don't do these dubs illegally and they were ACTUALLY owned by Disney, we could see some decent ones but sadly not.

    • @maniagirl1801
      @maniagirl1801  2 роки тому +1

      And better mixing

    • @HeroManNick132
      @HeroManNick132 2 роки тому +2

      @@maniagirl1801 Exactly. But only if Disney provided that.
      Not not mention that in 1 show they blantantly ripped off Bruno Mars's song like this one: 😂 ua-cam.com/video/6dKS6IZ2V00/v-deo.html
      And poor Iranians their dubs don't stop to make my day of how bad they are. Haha

    • @maniagirl1801
      @maniagirl1801  2 роки тому +2

      @@HeroManNick132 Yeah but because of politics and hate they can't make decent dubs, because usually persian singers are amazing in persian songs

    • @HeroManNick132
      @HeroManNick132 2 роки тому +2

      @@maniagirl1801 Съгласен!

  • @emiliaperez.m
    @emiliaperez.m Рік тому +3

    You are the first person that I see don't like Willemjin

    • @maniagirl1801
      @maniagirl1801  Рік тому

      Yep

    • @mariarinta-rahko958
      @mariarinta-rahko958 2 місяці тому

      I don't like her as Elsa but she's an incredible actress and i love her as other characters. She's also an amazing singer and killed it as Elphaba from the Wicked musical. Not a fan but i really like her alot she is super talented

  • @HeroManNick132
    @HeroManNick132 Рік тому +1

    Мисля, че и на това трябва да правиш едно ъпдейтче. 😂

    • @maniagirl1801
      @maniagirl1801  Рік тому +2

      Почнала съм, не бой се ;)

  • @jora8467
    @jora8467 2 роки тому +6

    I agree with your placing on Willemijn, she is kind of too old for the role. She is way better on broadway, and she makes a good Elphaba.

    • @maniagirl1801
      @maniagirl1801  2 роки тому +2

      Her voice is not pleasant for me, but she indeed is a great vocalist

    • @evelynmedrano522lover
      @evelynmedrano522lover Рік тому +3

      @@maniagirl1801her voice isn’t pleasant to you? Aww.. it’s so sad and it hurts. It’s okay. I respect your opinion.

    • @Gamesky-op7kq
      @Gamesky-op7kq 9 місяців тому

      @@evelynmedrano522loverYeah. I love Willemijn and she is defiantly not to old for the role. I‘ll see her in the frozen Musical in Hamburg on October 18 on her premiere as Elsa!

  • @MagdalenaBarszczewska
    @MagdalenaBarszczewska 2 роки тому +1

    elsa shmelsa

  • @mvpflorrt
    @mvpflorrt Рік тому +2

    Ciao Sono Italiano 🇮🇹🇮🇹🇮🇹🇮🇹🇮🇹