Hey can you also mention the aayats about how firstly man was created but not in his original form but as a beast like being (Javed Ahmedy refrence it at 6:20 )
پونے چار یا پورے چار ارب سال لگے انسان کو موجودہ صورت میں آنے میں ۔۔۔ سارا کھیل ہی اس پھونک کا ھے۔۔۔ آدم میں جب تک دم نہ تھا وہ خاک سے آدم نہ تھا آدم میں آ کے دم ھوا یہ خاک سے آدم ھوا یہ کھیل سارا دم کا ھے یہ دم اسی ہمدم کا ھے۔۔۔ و فی انفسکم افلا تبصرون ۔۔۔
This explanation is acceptable for a Muslim who is much having religious mind but we have many Muslims with no religious mind debunking such explanations in a matter of seconds
Sir, u are saying mostly elements, even a single missing element can stop any process, every religion wants to proof that their religion is more scientific. There is no need of proofing anything, we u think u r on right path then go ahead.
@@bilalsyed8088 Brother, The Qur'an says that Allah SWT created Adam(As) from the mud, maybe of the paradise, but I don't know, and then Allah SWT said that he created his progeny from a fluid, which is a Scientific fact, that fluid is "Nutfa", which means a "Mixture of Fluids( Semen )". Only Adam(As) created from mud, not us.
what people need to understand is that a scientist cannot randomly put out a theory , a scientific theory is supported by mountains off evidence for e.g. evolution is supported by more than sever different fields of studies for e.g. embryology , comparative anatomy , fossil records , genetics , observation etc .
آواز کا مسٸلہ ہوا درمیان میں۔ حیرت ہے امریکہ جیسے ترقی یافتہ ملک میں اس طرح ہورہا ہے۔ منتظمین کو اس پر توجہ دینا چاہیے۔ میرے خیال میں کالر ماٸیک تو لازمی طور پر لگایا جاۓ۔
Science believes in the cause and effect. According to science, every thing has a reason and that there is no coincidence, and so does the God says. In every Ayah of Quran ,where Allah is persuading the human about His Presence as a Creator , is accompanied with Rational scientific evidence or with the marvelous blessings(Surah Rehman). So Islam is not against the Science. It is a bad luck of Muslim ummah that we have disconnected the Religion from Science, Politics and Economics. and considered them two distinct poles that cannot merge into each other. The western culture doesn't want to merge them because of their pathetic catholic-protestant experience and the clash of civilization. Whereas our traditional Orthodox ulma are opposing it because of the lack of knowledge(Science-study-gap) to counter modern Science theories, contradicting with Islamic principles.
غامدی صاحب سے بہت اختلاف ہیں مگر وہ دین کو سمجھنے اور سوچنے کے لئے ایک نئی فکر دیتے ہیں جو مدرسوں کے علماء جو کنویں کے مینڈک کی طرح ہیں اور جن کو صرف رٹو طوطے بنایا گیا ہے سوچنے سمھنے سے عاری سے بہت مختلف ہیں اور ایک نئی راہ دکھاتے ہیں
Meray khyal mae ye bahtreen explnation ki hy ghamdi sb ny. Lakin shetaan ka sajda krna or jannat sy nikaly jana is cheez ko thora confuse ker deti hy. Baharhaal achi explanation di ap ny. Shukria
Technically the theory of evolution doesn't really say that we directly evolved from chimps, it only explains that we had the same ancestors as them. So, technically what Ghamidi sahab stated is true except that one small misconception.
For a second accept humans and chimps have same ancestors. But aisa kya hua jo ek hi same ancestors se ek human bn gya jo itna intelligence rkhta hai aur perfect hai. Aur dusri taraf chimpanzee abhi bhi us level ka intelligence nahi la paya. Aur ha agar hm survival of fittest ko dekhe bhi to hm dono me se ek ko eliminate ho jana chhaye tha. But dono abhi tk survive kr rahe hai. Agar hm DNA ke bhi bat kare to aisa kya hua ki itna same DNA hone ke baad bhi hm physically and mentally itne differ kr rahe. Aur one more question kya ye possible hai future me human beings evolve kare aur kare bhi to kitna wo kya cheez hai jo control kar rahi hai hamare evolution ko .
@@gunjan2323natural selection Kya ha ya scientifically proven nhi Sirf dimag hi select krta ha cheez ko hamra as pas Sirf matter ha Jo select nhi krta isliya Sirf dimag select krta ha Jo matter nhi ha
everything that Ghamdi sahib explain regarding creation of mankind through Quran actually inlined with the theory of evolution...just because Quran doesn't use the word Ape doesn't means that it cant be a stage during all that....Ghamdi saab clearly mentioned first stage was about physical form of humans second stage was about mental development.....physical form of apes and humans is very close...... genetic studies has revealed that we (human) share 99% similarlity with Apes on genetic level...clearly that's an evidence for close relativeness of two species ....one cant deny that if studies biology....
No there is a fundamental difference. Theory of evolution says all species evolved from a single cell, i.e. species transformed from one to another, this part is in contradiction to what Quran says and also is not proven by any scientific method.
Quran 32:7 Who perfected everything which He created and began the creation of man from clay. Quran 32:8 Then He made his posterity out of the extract of a liquid disdained. Quran 32:9 Then He proportioned him and breathed into him from His [created] soul and made for you hearing and vision and hearts; little are you grateful.
We read these Surahs and Ayahs everyday and they are from commonly read passages in Qur'an Al Kareem; even learnt from heart! But has Mankind ever thought that if it is not just recited, but pondered upon and understood, The Qur'an Al Kareem will open up the mind and intellect for the true Believer and guide him/her on tbe Straight path. It holds the answer to every problem be it Scientific, Mathematical or otherwise (every other field) and the result is Mind blowing! I leave this comment with one oft repeated Verse of Surah Qamar Ayaat 17, 22, 32 and 40. "And We (Royal Plural denoting Allah Himself) have made the Qur'an incredibly easy to remember and learn from, but is their anyone who will ponder and reflect upon it."
Evolution aik single species per nhi hoti only, aap ye btayein phir jub hazrat Adam bungaye two hazrat hawwa kaise banein aap ki baat sirf hazrat Adam ki creation define ker rhi hai!
Quran 32:7 Who perfected everything which He created and began the creation of man from clay. Quran 32:8 Then He made his posterity out of the extract of a liquid disdained. Quran 32:9 Then He proportioned him and breathed into him from His [created] soul and made for you hearing and vision and hearts; little are you grateful.
Insan ko allah ne Adam as ki shakl me duniya me utara or ek bar me hi perfect Adam ko banaya allha ko kisi chiz ko banane k liye experiment ki zarurt nhi vo ek bar me hi apne hukum se perfect chiz bana sakta he
Evolution has been reinforced by many other fields of scientific knowledge since it was first propounded by Charles Darwin in 1886. Embryology, Genetics, Anthropology, Microbial mutation, cosmology etc.
Respected, Watching in June 2024. Very Thoughtful. However add something from my perspective, Which you called an egg, may be a cell, then call was broken into 2, Male and Female. Quran stated that we have created everything in Couple ( Joray) . That was Adam and Hawa. First Couple. Hawa was not born from the ribs of Adam. ( As propagating in subcontinent) .
You know what there is an ayah in Quran, in which Allah says that He converted human beings into monkeys, Alsmot like downgrading them to lower level.. So Quran itself has proof for conversion between one specis to another??
It proves that monekys or apes are a low species than humans and humans are above species and better thats why Allah swt converted them to apes as a punishment..so how can then we superior humans evolve from a low species? Then monkeys or apes must have done something great so as a reward Allah must have converted them to humans?.. which is not true..ur arguemnt reject the thoery of evolution if u think on it!
Islam and evolution video of sahil adeem please watch that One question : if all living organism development from one cell then where is the intermediatary Skelton between fish and Maan Monkey and man like this
mera ghamidi saheb se yeh sawal hai kay islam mein sab se afzal tareen khatoon khon hain? Aur jo bhi hain woh kis base per hain.plz detail mein jawab di jiye ga.
Sir Sab log sune sunaye aur padhi padhiye baat karte chahe koi bhi dharam ho. Aap bhi apne book ko sahi bata rhe hai dosre apne book ko. Ye ander mahsosh karne wale baat hai, sakshat dekhne wali baat hai.
This is one of the only points where I think Javed Ghamidi sb unfortunately fails to fully grasp the subject he is talking about, which is biological evolution. The term "Theory" in science isn't just an unproven idea but a well established scientific explanation of the observed data, which is based on evidence and testable predictions. Evolution is extremely well grounded in evidence. Dr. Israr Ahmed, probably because of scientific education was able to understand the scientific part better and therefore accepts evolution and has better explanation of quranic verses in that light.
do you have a link to Dr. Israr's lectures on evolution? I strongly believe in the theory of evolution and which must be triggered by Allah. I need to see further details.
I think the point made by Javed sahab is that evolution is a fact. Darwin's theory was AN explanation of that fact. There can be other explanations too for how and when evolution happened. For example, a person's death is a fact. How he dies is AN explanation of that fact which can differ. He concludes by saying that the Qur'an provides its own explanation of evolution. So why not investigate whether there is evidence for Qur'ans explanation and if so, is it more substantial than for Darwin's explanation?
Koi alag alag satge me Adam as ko nhi bayana sir allah ne jo fossiles hume duniya me milte he sirf unko justify Karne ke liye hum Qur'an ki esi explanation Baya. Kare ye sahi nhi
I am confused, is he saying that humans evolved form beastly humans (hayvani insaan), if no, then explain what and how did it happen because only beastly humans came out of the egg, or if they did evolved from the beastly humans then , whats the way to prove it because science says that every human and even those beastly hums (chimpanzee and all) is evolved from some other animal, and our last ancestor is not any beastly human but something else, dna are the proofs of that, please tell me the exact reasons, how does it contradicts science?
This is a primitive explanation without evidence but evolution has fossil evidence(scientific by definition). A priest friend said to me,those are bunch of bones and l replied,we have a bunch of for evidence,what have you got,he just laughed. ...Prof.Dr.Nasir Fazal gold medalist Cambridge USA Gamidy sahib l was at govt.college Lahore with you in the 60ies.
Adam as ko to allah ne jannat me banaya he na to fir vo fossile perfection vale hume earth par kese mil rhe he vo fossile bhi jannt me hi hona cahiye jiske perfection ske badAdam as bane
Can I have the reference of all the ayah that Ghamidi sahab quoted? Only three ayah have been mentioned in the comments I want to know all the ayah that Ghamidi sahab quoted.
![[UA] Eternal Fire проти NAVI | EPL Season 20 Malta](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/chvlsDygrZM/mqdefault.jpg)
References of ayats
32:7, 32:8, 32:9, 55:14, 15:26, 37:11
Hey can you also mention the aayats about how firstly man was created but not in his original form but as a beast like being (Javed Ahmedy refrence it at 6:20 )
Amazing explanation, Ghamd Sahib is a blessing for students like me.
no other molana even come close to his clear understanding. MashAllah
ua-cam.com/video/yUMczu60RH0/v-deo.html
U don't need to say that about other maulana.....I know may who explain it but they are not on youtube
Ghamdi sb is the true Mujaddid of the era, now,
Every thing has been elaborated by him in easy and understandable way.
Love u ,
More like mujtahid. If he develops consensus and Ijma like Iqbal and Afghani he may be looked back as Mujaddid.
No he is mutajaddid
Woh kaise Apne theoryu ke waja se
❤️❤️❤️❤️...Never seen such an explanation on evolution..u r truly a genius and the Mujaddid ..
پونے چار یا پورے چار ارب سال لگے انسان کو موجودہ صورت میں آنے میں ۔۔۔ سارا کھیل ہی اس پھونک کا ھے۔۔۔
آدم میں جب تک دم نہ تھا
وہ خاک سے آدم نہ تھا
آدم میں آ کے دم ھوا
یہ خاک سے آدم ھوا
یہ کھیل سارا دم کا ھے
یہ دم اسی ہمدم کا ھے۔۔۔
و فی انفسکم افلا تبصرون ۔۔۔
Kia bat👍💥
According to the Quran and science,
Great, JazakAllah Gandhi sb
First time i gt clear reply….i was so confused n now alhumdullilah i gt clear answer
This explanation is acceptable for a Muslim who is much having religious mind but we have many Muslims with no religious mind debunking such explanations in a matter of seconds
One of the Greatest Scholars of this century
JazakAllah sir
The idea of creation from mud is scientific because earth is composed of the same periodic table as our body.
Yes, you are right. Mostly elements in earth and in a Human body are same but their proportion is different
Sir, u are saying mostly elements, even a single missing element can stop any process, every religion wants to proof that their religion is more scientific. There is no need of proofing anything, we u think u r on right path then go ahead.
@@mutatedamir3031 yes except silicon
That isn’t a really good correlation
@@bilalsyed8088 Brother, The Qur'an says that Allah SWT created Adam(As) from the mud, maybe of the paradise, but I don't know, and then Allah SWT said that he created his progeny from a fluid, which is a Scientific fact, that fluid is "Nutfa", which means a "Mixture of Fluids( Semen )". Only Adam(As) created from mud, not us.
what people need to understand is that a scientist cannot randomly put out a theory , a scientific theory is supported by mountains off evidence for e.g. evolution is supported by more than sever different fields of studies for e.g. embryology , comparative anatomy , fossil records , genetics , observation etc .
Again, it’s just an interpretation of all that data. No empirical evidence to support it
evolution theory is now also a fact. discusion ended
Shukria Ghamidi Sahb....💞♥
Allah pak ghamidi sahb ko jazaye khair dy. Main 2, 3 din sy buht iztrab main tha ab har cheez clear ho gai hai
جزاک اللہ
آواز کا مسٸلہ ہوا درمیان میں۔ حیرت ہے امریکہ جیسے ترقی یافتہ ملک میں اس طرح ہورہا ہے۔ منتظمین کو اس پر توجہ دینا چاہیے۔ میرے خیال میں کالر ماٸیک تو لازمی طور پر لگایا جاۓ۔
Came here after Zakir Naik's response to evolution. Ghamdi is the new successor of greatest Islamic scholars.
Science believes in the cause and effect. According to science, every thing has a reason and that there is no coincidence, and so does the God says.
In every Ayah of Quran ,where Allah is persuading the human about His Presence as a Creator , is accompanied with Rational scientific evidence or with the marvelous blessings(Surah Rehman).
So Islam is not against the Science.
It is a bad luck of Muslim ummah that we have disconnected the Religion from Science, Politics and Economics. and considered them two distinct poles that cannot merge into each other. The western culture doesn't want to merge them because of their pathetic catholic-protestant experience and the clash of civilization. Whereas our traditional Orthodox ulma are opposing it because of the lack of knowledge(Science-study-gap) to counter modern Science theories, contradicting with Islamic principles.
100% true
And yet things could unfold more and more in future.
Mashallah ❤️
SubhanAllah 💞love you ghamidi💕sab
غامدی صاحب سے بہت اختلاف ہیں مگر وہ دین کو سمجھنے اور سوچنے کے لئے ایک نئی فکر دیتے ہیں جو مدرسوں کے علماء جو کنویں کے مینڈک کی طرح ہیں اور جن کو صرف رٹو طوطے بنایا گیا ہے سوچنے سمھنے سے عاری سے بہت مختلف ہیں اور ایک نئی راہ دکھاتے ہیں
MashaAllah Ghamidi Sahib, such a brilliant scholar
Ghamdi Sb "The Great" ❤️
جزاک اللہ خیرا
very logical answer
Ghamidi speaks true updated islamic views
Very well explained sir , I search n u cleared the confusion 💓
Every excellent explanation
Jazakallah u khairan sir ameen
Ma sha Allah ❤️
Meray khyal mae ye bahtreen explnation ki hy ghamdi sb ny. Lakin shetaan ka sajda krna or jannat sy nikaly jana is cheez ko thora confuse ker deti hy. Baharhaal achi explanation di ap ny. Shukria
Great, and scholarly explanation
Technically the theory of evolution doesn't really say that we directly evolved from chimps, it only explains that we had the same ancestors as them. So, technically what Ghamidi sahab stated is true except that one small misconception.
Yes humans and chimps had same ancestor
For a second accept humans and chimps have same ancestors. But aisa kya hua jo ek hi same ancestors se ek human bn gya jo itna intelligence rkhta hai aur perfect hai. Aur dusri taraf chimpanzee abhi bhi us level ka intelligence nahi la paya. Aur ha agar hm survival of fittest ko dekhe bhi to hm dono me se ek ko eliminate ho jana chhaye tha. But dono abhi tk survive kr rahe hai. Agar hm DNA ke bhi bat kare to aisa kya hua ki itna same DNA hone ke baad bhi hm physically and mentally itne differ kr rahe. Aur one more question kya ye possible hai future me human beings evolve kare aur kare bhi to kitna wo kya cheez hai jo control kar rahi hai hamare evolution ko .
@@canchange it's called natural selection. That's the mechanism of evolution
@@gunjan2323natural selection Kya ha ya scientifically proven nhi Sirf dimag hi select krta ha cheez ko hamra as pas Sirf matter ha Jo select nhi krta isliya Sirf dimag select krta ha Jo matter nhi ha
Sir I love you so much. You explained QURAN very very well.
Ghamdi sahab say ilmi ikhtalaf apni gagah lekin Ghamdi sahab islam ki bohat khidmat kar rahay hai
Masha Allah Algamdulillah that's the truth
Ghamidi sahib is a great scholar .
Just amazing
everything that Ghamdi sahib explain regarding creation of mankind through Quran actually inlined with the theory of evolution...just because Quran doesn't use the word Ape doesn't means that it cant be a stage during all that....Ghamdi saab clearly mentioned first stage was about physical form of humans second stage was about mental development.....physical form of apes and humans is very close...... genetic studies has revealed that we (human) share 99% similarlity with Apes on genetic level...clearly that's an evidence for close relativeness of two species ....one cant deny that if studies biology....
No there is a fundamental difference. Theory of evolution says all species evolved from a single cell, i.e. species transformed from one to another, this part is in contradiction to what Quran says and also is not proven by any scientific method.
@@K_Shahzad If this not scientific proof then we don't believe but for me cell even contain 70 percentage of water. So it is not a big deal.
Now we need these type of islamic mulana in our society for betterment
Qareen az feham bayaan hay aap ka!
Great video, thank you very much , note to self(nts) watched all of it 8:14
Loved this explaination
This ia the most beautiful interpretation of quranic evolution ever... impressive
there is no evolution, everything is creation
Evolution is fact and no one can refute it
first time understand islam and evolution
Anyone to please give
1) PARA
2) SURAH
3) AYAT NUMBER
of what Ghamdi Sahib is quoting.
JAZAK ALLAH KHAIR
سورہ دھر
Quran 32:7 Who perfected everything which He created and began the creation of man from clay.
Quran 32:8 Then He made his posterity out of the extract of a liquid disdained.
Quran 32:9 Then He proportioned him and breathed into him from His [created] soul and made for you hearing and vision and hearts; little are you grateful.
SURAH SAJDAH AYAH 7
(3:53)
SURAH RAHMĀN AYAH 14
(5:40)
SURAH SAJDAH AYAH 8
(6:10)
SURAH SAJDAH AYAH 9
(6:27, 6:46)
We read these Surahs and Ayahs everyday and they are from commonly read passages in Qur'an Al Kareem; even learnt from heart!
But has Mankind ever thought that if it is not just recited, but pondered upon and understood, The Qur'an Al Kareem will open up the mind and intellect for the true Believer and guide him/her on tbe Straight path.
It holds the answer to every problem be it Scientific, Mathematical or otherwise (every other field) and the result is Mind blowing!
I leave this comment with one oft repeated Verse of Surah Qamar Ayaat 17, 22, 32 and 40.
"And We (Royal Plural denoting Allah Himself) have made the Qur'an incredibly easy to remember and learn from, but is their anyone who will ponder and reflect upon it."
Best explanation.
Thanks
Watched all of it
The quran version and what this bloke just said is ridiculous, given the 2 choices i would take sciences explanation everytime
Then explain how did all living things exist on its own? Even luis poisture prove by experiment that no living thing exist without another living
He seems some more logical Islamic scholar
اللّٰہ پاک آپ کو حفظ وامان میں رکھے مجتہد زماں اللّٰہ پاک آپ کو سلامتی عطا فرمائے آمین یارب العالمین
ALLAH hi ney insaan ko zameen sey mitti sey paida kiya .
Agreed
پھر جنت میں وہ آدم علیہ السلام رہ رہا تھا وہ کون تھا جس کو زمین پر اتارا گیا قرآن پاک میں بتایا گیا
Jab Allah ne rooh phoonki jise ghamidi sahib insaniat bata rahe hay pir unhay jannat may tikkana dia
yeh ghamidi jhhhhl hai..
Ghamidi
صاحب کا کوئی جواب نہیں
Can anyone plz provide all Quranic references he quoted or interprets after 5:30 ?
Sir aap Jo Quran ki ayat bayan kar rahe usme samandar Bahar ka to kois word hi nahi hai !
Evolution aik single species per nhi hoti only, aap ye btayein phir jub hazrat Adam bungaye two hazrat hawwa kaise banein aap ki baat sirf hazrat Adam ki creation define ker rhi hai!
Can anyone give me reference to the ayaat which sir ghamidi have read ?
Quran 32:7 Who perfected everything which He created and began the creation of man from clay.
Quran 32:8 Then He made his posterity out of the extract of a liquid disdained.
Quran 32:9 Then He proportioned him and breathed into him from His [created] soul and made for you hearing and vision and hearts; little are you grateful.
Insan ko allah ne Adam as ki shakl me duniya me utara or ek bar me hi perfect Adam ko banaya allha ko kisi chiz ko banane k liye experiment ki zarurt nhi vo ek bar me hi apne hukum se perfect chiz bana sakta he
He gave the perfect answer among all the others
ارتقاء کب تک چلا،،فرشتوں کے سجدہ کرنے تک،،،یا اس کے بعد 🙂
Evolution has been reinforced by many other fields of scientific knowledge since it was first propounded by Charles Darwin in 1886. Embryology, Genetics, Anthropology, Microbial mutation, cosmology etc.
❤❤❤❤❤
Cause is from Allah SOT and Effect is from scientific brain which is also from Allah SOT!
Respected, Watching in June 2024. Very Thoughtful. However add something from my perspective, Which you called an egg, may be a cell, then call was broken into 2, Male and Female. Quran stated that we have created everything in Couple ( Joray) . That was Adam and Hawa. First Couple. Hawa was not born from the ribs of Adam. ( As propagating in subcontinent) .
Ghamidi sahib, kamaal kar dia...
Does muslim scholars believe the story of Eden garden ?
If it's true then why human beings are not still creating by this method.
اگر انسان پر حیوان کے دو ادوار گزرے ھیں تو وہ کسی درجہ میں حیوان تو تھا۔۔ارتقا یہی تو ہے۔۔بے شک وہ چمپانزی نہ سہی
pir wo jannat say Adam and Hawa (A S) ko nikall na , wo shitaan ka Adam ko sajda na karna on ka kiya explaination hai
You know what there is an ayah in Quran, in which Allah says that He converted human beings into monkeys, Alsmot like downgrading them to lower level.. So Quran itself has proof for conversion between one specis to another??
That was azaab
Bhai wo azab tha aik irtaqa hai
@@cluelesspotato1416 that might be a punishment but could also be the continuation of a species
It proves that monekys or apes are a low species than humans and humans are above species and better thats why Allah swt converted them to apes as a punishment..so how can then we superior humans evolve from a low species? Then monkeys or apes must have done something great so as a reward Allah must have converted them to humans?.. which is not true..ur arguemnt reject the thoery of evolution if u think on it!
Islam and evolution video of sahil adeem please watch that
One question : if all living organism development from one cell then where is the intermediatary Skelton between fish and Maan
Monkey and man like this
دور حاضر میں اللہ کا انعام
mera ghamidi saheb se yeh sawal hai kay islam mein sab se afzal tareen khatoon khon hain?
Aur jo bhi hain woh kis base per hain.plz detail mein jawab di jiye ga.
agher tummay yaah pata chall b jaay tu kiya ker loo gay? kiya qaber iska sawaal hogaah tum say?
Islam Mai sab say afzal khatoon wo Hain jo say parsa Hain aur koi insan nahi janta k kon zayada mutaqi hai
koi please iska khulasa byan kr sktaa hy mjhe is baat ki samjh nhii i
Sir Sab log sune sunaye aur padhi padhiye baat karte chahe koi bhi dharam ho. Aap bhi apne book ko sahi bata rhe hai dosre apne book ko. Ye ander mahsosh karne wale baat hai, sakshat dekhne wali baat hai.
he taling truth if u dont believe him then read 32:7-9,then4:1
Give
1) Para
2) Surah
3) Ayat
NUMBERS
PLEASE
How he ended the answer made me numb. Amazing.
Allahumma Salli WA barik ala Muhammad wa Ali Muhammad.
Well Done, well researched
Can some one give the reference to the ayats he quoted please
32:7 to 32:09
Agar allah ko bhi evolution chahiye to fir kun-ya-fukun ka kya matlab ha!
Sachai koi nahi janta, bahut confusion ha bhai!
It means human is made from thousands and many ancestors. Evolution happened... so darwin was true...
Please let not your mic go through evolution
Very miss leading .. Hewani insan ka zikr kahan hy Quran Pak may?
This a total misleading interpretation of Quran. Quran no where says ‘lamba arsa’ and different set stages till it reaches the perfect stage.
This is one of the only points where I think Javed Ghamidi sb unfortunately fails to fully grasp the subject he is talking about, which is biological evolution. The term "Theory" in science isn't just an unproven idea but a well established scientific explanation of the observed data, which is based on evidence and testable predictions. Evolution is extremely well grounded in evidence. Dr. Israr Ahmed, probably because of scientific education was able to understand the scientific part better and therefore accepts evolution and has better explanation of quranic verses in that light.
do you have a link to Dr. Israr's lectures on evolution? I strongly believe in the theory of evolution and which must be triggered by Allah. I need to see further details.
Theory in biology is not a fact dummy
Darwin's theory of evolution needs a cell to start with but can't explain the primary source of this cell.
جینوم سائنس ڈارون تھیوری کو رد کرتی ہے۔
I think the point made by Javed sahab is that evolution is a fact. Darwin's theory was AN explanation of that fact. There can be other explanations too for how and when evolution happened. For example, a person's death is a fact. How he dies is AN explanation of that fact which can differ. He concludes by saying that the Qur'an provides its own explanation of evolution. So why not investigate whether there is evidence for Qur'ans explanation and if so, is it more substantial than for Darwin's explanation?
Koi alag alag satge me Adam as ko nhi bayana sir allah ne jo fossiles hume duniya me milte he sirf unko justify Karne ke liye hum Qur'an ki esi explanation Baya. Kare ye sahi nhi
I am confused, is he saying that humans evolved form beastly humans (hayvani insaan), if no, then explain what and how did it happen because only beastly humans came out of the egg, or if they did evolved from the beastly humans then , whats the way to prove it because science says that every human and even those beastly hums (chimpanzee and all) is evolved from some other animal, and our last ancestor is not any beastly human but something else, dna are the proofs of that, please tell me the exact reasons, how does it contradicts science?
Human have tailbone and apendix which are useless and usefull in animals
This is a primitive explanation without evidence but evolution has fossil evidence(scientific by definition).
A priest friend said to me,those are bunch of bones and l replied,we have a bunch of for evidence,what have you got,he just laughed.
...Prof.Dr.Nasir Fazal gold medalist Cambridge USA
Gamidy sahib l was at govt.college Lahore with you in the 60ies.
Germ theory , cell theory, big bang theory etc. are also theories why do yoi believe in them.
Adam as ko to allah ne jannat me banaya he na to fir vo fossile perfection vale hume earth par kese mil rhe he vo fossile bhi jannt me hi hona cahiye jiske perfection ske badAdam as bane
All claims without any evidence
Can I have the reference of all the ayah that Ghamidi sahab quoted? Only three ayah have been mentioned in the comments I want to know all the ayah that Ghamidi sahab quoted.
55:14, 15:26 , 37:11
32:7-9
Jazakallah
He doesn't even understand the difference between a normal theory and a scientific theory! 🤦🤦🤦
TOTALLY WRONG EXPLAINATION.. IRRELEVANT AYATS..
Evolution is just a theory