Have you questioned this in Harry Potter ? (7 Questions)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 4 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 18

  • @kimgrod
    @kimgrod 2 роки тому +7

    Wizards live longer. Newt @ 97 is not that old ... for a wizard.

  • @jakesterrett3755
    @jakesterrett3755 2 роки тому +5

    7:37 I cant believe they didn't notice spider man with their brother..

  • @francisgrizzlysmit4715
    @francisgrizzlysmit4715 2 роки тому +2

    Newt was still alive at that time it's in the book, the one called "fantastic beasts and where to find them" the one she did for charity supposed to be Harry's copy of the text, read the about the author bit, also wizards live longer than muggles

  • @couch.patati-patata
    @couch.patati-patata 2 роки тому +1

    Newt stole a bit of the resurrection stone while visiting Flammel.

  • @meghancraft77
    @meghancraft77 Рік тому +2

    Yeah, Fred and George were probably more concerned with finding the 7 secret passages than they were about where everyone was going, when they had the map.

  • @davidkennedy8929
    @davidkennedy8929 2 роки тому +14

    Why would he have passed away as wizards live longer than humans!

  • @MythStarFire
    @MythStarFire 2 роки тому +2

    I doubt Percy would have felt bad for a garden rat, let’s face he never was a kind as the rest of his family. Charlie on the other hand, who would have been 10, would have gone out of his way to heal and wounded garden rat. As for the twins not noticing Tom Riddle or Peter Pettigrew on the map, they used it to sneak around. If Any of those had been near the kitchens or a secret passageway or between them and their goal, they would have noticed, but otherwise, why would they care? Dumbledore, Snape, Filtch, McGonagall, even Peeves, those they would have cared about, not Quirrell or some unknown kid or ghost Peter. If they ever noticed Peter Pettigrew at all, they would have either assumed he was another older student, since he was there BEFORE they arrived or a ghost that didn’t like to show themselves.

  • @Albus_Dumbledore197
    @Albus_Dumbledore197 Рік тому

    1. Newt probably just visit Dumbledore, or became a Hogwarts Ghost (since Newt was 97 years old at 1993).
    2. I'm assuming that boarding the train at King’s Cross Station might be the way kids reporting themselves. And for the kids who live somewhere near Hogwarts, like Hogsmeade and Aviesmore, they could probably talk to the headmaster.(?)
    3. Because James and Lily trusted their friend too much.
    6. I’m imagining Wormtail told Dark Lord the story about how annoying Percy is, during the plot the restore Voldemort, like a fairy tale. LOL😂
    7. Umbridge could produce Patronus because she has pure heart, purely bad heart.

  • @dracolrd19
    @dracolrd19 2 роки тому +3

    the umbridge thing. i seen elsewhere that in her mind she never seen that she was doing anything wrong or evil. and she was trying to make the world a better place by doing what she did and that made her happy. so with in her head being pure in heart and a happy thought its what helped her produce the potronus.

  • @arnavkhurana590
    @arnavkhurana590 Рік тому

    I think that probably Fred & George were too busy with only finding row passages than Looking who's in hogwarts

  • @bellucian1293
    @bellucian1293 2 роки тому

    They must've said THIS is a job for that Potter kid... They were about pranks and they thought either this is a prank or Harry will find out... They know that's the guy that killed Harry's parents so they must've just been waiting until he was ready.

  • @sever5859
    @sever5859 2 роки тому

    I didn't even think about it

  • @Unlicensedpilot
    @Unlicensedpilot 2 роки тому +3

    Full support brother....
    Btw I love Snape so can you make video on Snape??

  • @jami_holmes
    @jami_holmes 2 роки тому +1

    if Peter petigrew became a rat & its technically Percey Weasly's rat
    why does Ron Weasly have it in his First year at hogwarts ?

    • @mikael5890
      @mikael5890 2 роки тому +5

      When Percy was made a prefect, he received Hermes from his parents as a reward so he gave scabbers to Ron.

  • @robertdeffenbaugh9004
    @robertdeffenbaugh9004 2 роки тому

    It’s possible Newt died young Headmaster Phineas Nigellus died at age 78.
    It’s possible that one of the fantastic beast movies in the future Newt dies.

  • @CodeforFoo
    @CodeforFoo 2 роки тому

    Do you know why you have the questions ? Because the author JK Rowling was a broke ass mother who did not know her book could get popular, she was not planning or carefully thinking how the next books would look like. Hence a bunch of continuity and flaws during 7 books.