@Ofra Cohen wow we are same i am confused that i like jiu or sua more but i think sua is more versetile and siyeon is my bias cz her vocals .....................
Siyeon when performing on stage just hits different, like she looks so intimidating and her gazed is just scary not to change the fact that her vocal is just Chef's kiss... JiU's visual is just something else and I can't explain, it's PERFECTION... I love her perfect features and the way she smiles? No words, she's a sunshine of the group... But everyone is beautiful in their own way.. Dami's voice just suits in rap because she has a unique tone in her voice, kinda deep but what I love the most of her is that she can sing and belt highnotes! It's rare.... I also agreed in terms of Vocal, Siyeon is just on another level, she is so underrated... I fell inlove with her when I saw her 'Speechless' cover, I became InSomnia since then... In terms of Dance, SuA has this fluidity and her control of her body is just on another level... I love all of the songs she choreographed... Okay... All of them are good, they are all-rounders... When I started to check their MVs, I'm pretty sure that time that the girl named Siyeon is the Main Vocalist but then when I heard the other members singing, I was like.. "Who the fuck is the main vocalist?!" "Who the hell is the Main Dancer?!" "Who's the Visual?!"... I had a hard time so I decided to get to know them more... And yes, 7 main vocalist, 7 main dancers, 7 main visuals, 7 main rappers, 7 chaotic dorks, 7 top energy, 7 GAYS.... OJAY STAN DREAMCATCHER
Think it's tough to rank all these categories in Dreamcatcher cept for maybe Vocals and Rap. Rap because of the format, haven't seen JiU and Handong rap yet. Vocals because there is a clear heierarchy and Dami while talented focuses on rap heavily and Gahyeon is splitting her time between Vocal/Rap. Popularity for kpop group members honestly changes by country so not much use arguing it, but, Siyeon gets sent to variety shows by herself at times. Competed in shows an such along with the slaying a few OSTs and her Solo song. Think DCC sees Siyeon as their ace.
Stage presence is hard to be objective on but I agree this was very biased. JiU and Gahyeon were way too low. Yoohyeon is also easily a better dancer than Dami. SP should be Gahyeon>SuA/JiU>Siyeon>Yoohyeon imo
@@DarkMage501 I agree, stage presence is highly subjective. Think Gahyeon has the advantage in versatility of facial expressions...but... A lot of that is concept based cuz it's not like the other members can't laugh and/or smile. When DC isn't being strict with their expressions on stage and just having fun singing I don't think Gahyeon has the same impact with her facial expressions. All the members are at a high level for pretty much everything so it comes down to personal preference or what category you weight and when. Think Siyeon has a clear advantage for solo stage presence since shes dominated several stages by herself and if given freedom to sing how she wants even in a group setting her voice, the freedom and confidence she has with it really stands out.
@@DarkMage501 Yoohyeon dancing as DC stands out more for her height and length, looks great posing in the center or front of the other girls. Think DaMi is probably the better technical dancer inside the choreo, especially with her gestures and such. Outside choreo tho, Dami doesn't dance much at all. Yoohyeon moves with high energy, dances with Siyeon and Sua at random and also twerks at random. Inside the organized performances i think you can make an argument for anyone at the top of Stage presence. In a free-for-all. Think the Only real choices are SuA and Siyeon with Yoohyeon challenging that two top from time to time.
La más popular es Jiu, además que su popularidad en Corea es buena que es la única que ha entrado a los rankings de marca de idols femeninos en algunas ocaciones. Y tiene muy buena presencia en el escenario.
FR. In their cover of Rhythm Ta as well, during minx too. Like she's so good in dancing. But i understand that other members are just very good too. They're just all great tbh. And her split in Boss just.. 🥰🥰
Dance and Vocal are accurate. Visual and Stage Presence can be subjective but we probably all agree on #1 Popularity is the only one I'd say is off. I'll just add a few stats I've noticed below. Based on their IG follows: 1. Jiu 2. Sua (used to be #1 when Wendy followed her + was the only one with a solo schedule) 3. Dami 4. Yoohyeon 5. Gahyeon 6. Siyeon 7. Handong Based on teaser RTs and likes: 1. Jiu 2. Gahyeon 3. Yoohyeon / Dami 4. Siyeon / Sua / Handong Based on years collecting (and getting scammed by overpricers lol) - most collected: 1. Jiu 2. Yoohyeon 3. Siyeon / Gahyeon 5. Handong 6. Dami / Sua
@@crystalorbit5767 yooh has the best technique but isn't the best vocalist for Dreamcatcher in particular. Siyeon has the dynamics, power and a certain uniqueness that make her the ideal main vocal for their style. kinda the same reason why Sua and Dami get so many lines despite their weak techniques. also, as a former dancer, I'd say that no yooh isn't a better dancer than Dami. she just works very hard in hiding her weaknesses and that actually makes her one of my fave dancers in DC :)
I respect your ranking, and i personally think all 7 are so so talented but I disagree with you on the stage presence, I think Minji and Yoohyeon are the top 2 when it comes to that. But honestly, each member has their moment, they know exactly how to work well together when to step back and let someone else shine and when to go take the spotlight so in the end it comes down to preference and who ur bias is. Thank you for the video!!
Personally imo jiu, yoohyeon, siyeon, sua have top stage presence every era. All of deukae have incredible strengths and stage presence. Dreamcatcher is so good at making sure everyone shines and since they're all incredible, they all catch your eye at some point which is rarw for a group to have all members have strong stage presence ❤️🔥
And literally you should be fair to Handong's vocal as she got more exposure for the latest songs released (ODD EYE, BECAUSE), not convinced by using deja vu only
I have 2 disagreements: Jiu should be in the top 5 of stage presence (To me she is 3rd). Jiu is the most popular of the members. Btw Siyeon is my bias, so its not biased hahha But I agree with u in the most parts
Siyeons vocals are beyond pretty much any idol I've heard. Not only can she reach absurdly high notes and hold them, but she can easily SING those high notes as well. Truly we don't deserve her talent.
I believe the 'Visual' ranking in this video is actually based off of who meets the Korean beauty standards the most, which is as follows for the Top 5: 1. JiU - 70% 2. SuA - 60% 3/4/5. Siyeon, Yoohyeon, Gahyeon - 50%
I like these videos on only one group so there isn’t all these toxic fan wars. I swear they are making me not enjoy Kpop as much anymore 😞. We need to make our communities less toxic, is it that hard?
I don't want to say much, but there's a position that an individual has, and the company or the members would have decided. The main vocalist is the best singer in the team. The main dancer is the best dancer in the team. And JiU's popularity ranking is weird. As far as I know, JiU in the top3 overseas and top in Korea.
I think this video used the Korean Beauty Standards ranking, which obviously places Handong out of the Top 5 straight away. The Top 5 based on the KBS is: 1. JiU - 70% 2. SuA - 60% 3/4/5. Siyeon, Yoohyeon, Gahyeon - 50%
Based on numbers of like on every teaser's photo and Instagram followers.. i think the most popular member in Dreamcatcher is Jiu. But i love all of them equally 🤩.. it is very hard to choose bias in this group😂
for stage presence, even though Handong has improved a lot, but still there's a bit of confidence issue from the past. Yoohyeon seems better for stage presence but not for holding mic performance (she seems a bit strained). like a 50-50 between Handong Yoohyeon for visual, honestly I can't rank them because each has distinct type of visual. but yeah I kinda agree for the rank if it forced to be ranked for rap, even though Yoohyeon is one of my bias trinity, I think Handong still better. we already heard her a bit of rap tone in Eclipse, that Really Really cover Yoohyeon not really rap too. JiU tried to rap in cover too but still the tone from Handong will suit the rap more. also Gahyeon over SuA just because of recent experience and decision from SuA to get more vocals than rap for vocals a lil bit tricky. for hard choreo, SuA surely over JiU. in some vibe, Yoohyeon will be over Siyeon. but overall I kinda agree for the rank in this video for popularity it keep changing a lot tho. but nowadays Dami seems over JiU. during Nightmare series Yoohyeon JiU probably top 2. in BOCA Gahyeon Dami Siyeon are top 3. also in Odd Eye Handong at least in top 3 (not biased, she's not in my bias trinity but in Odd Eye she really stood out. I've watched some reactors who don't have Handong as bias but talking a lot about Handong in Odd Eye) for dance also a lil bit tricky. for shape/angle, Yoohyeon can be #3 or #2. Handong can be #4. if only based on movement, I kinda agree with the video if you read fully until this point, thanks to read my essay a.k.a a bit review about rankings :D
Based on both the video and the comments, i got very interested in knowing how they came to Dreamcatcher? Like on earth does someone who should have been a shoe-in for any mainstream group (like Siyeon) end up in what was basically an experimental underdog group? I've dabbled in a few other kpop groups but none of them ever had that personality that Dreamcatcher has.
Honestly it's really difficult to rank the girls in terms of vocal ability, obviously Siyeon is at the top in first place, Yoohyeon/SuA in a close second tie, but then the remaining 4 are pretty close in vocal ability. I feel like we haven't seen JiU or Handong's chance to shine vocally yet, while we've only briefly seen what Dami and Gahyeon can do.
my top 5 vocals siyeon yoohyeon jiu sua gahyeon handong dami (strong vocal line) and I also think that gahyeon and handong are on the same level rap dami gahyeon I couldn't see the other members shining as rappers sorry dance sua all I couldn't see the other members shining solo as dancers visual jiu gahyeon sua yoohyeon handong dami siyeon (they all are pretty) I just noticed that siyeon looks the oldest, but I still think that she's pretty.
personally, I think that Jiu has the best stage presence, + she reads rap well, her abilities are perfectly revealed in the new clip and it’s immediately clear who the leader is and + her vocals are the most unique sounding in the group and her voice is very beautiful with her voice association with dreamcatchers ( my opinion )
I don’t agree with Jiu be 2nd for dance. Dami is the second best while Yoohyeon is 3rd. Handong is 4th. Jiu’s dance lines aren’t that smooth compared to Handong who moves like a silk feather. Siyeon is the worst dancer in the group tho. My list 1. Soowa 2. Dummy 3. Youhyun 4. Hendongue 5. Geeyou 6. Ghahyun 7. Seeyoncè
gotta be honest m,y bias is siyeon but sua with her vocals and high notes and what we have seen is able to replace siyeon gotta say sua is a real all rounder that is number 1 is everything but the ranking how you did were good hihihi sua her sub vocal title is to low for her she should be also lead vocal in my opinion
I think it's also just experience-wise. SuA had the most training and she was in Minx. Compared to Handong, SuA is objectively higher ranked. SuA's voice also suits DC's sound better, which goes to show how shocked we are of Handong's vocals when she is given the opportunity to show her jazzy voice.
@@someoldytaccount yes, and i don’t think people seem to realise that the kprofiles polls actually let you vote more than once. so for all we know, 100 of those votes could be the same person. then you’ve got the fact that their popularity differs across different platforms or communities too. they’re never too far apart from each other but it’s still noticeable.
Yall really don't want to give Handong the credit she deserved lol. She's easily top 3 vocalists and top 2 dancers in Dreamcatcher. As someone who's covered several songs of dreamcatcher and had to analyze their dance practices, she's one of the cleanest dancers in the group. Dami is far from being as clean as Handong and JiU is not as energetic as her either 🤷
handong is very good vocalist but sua, jiu, yoohyeon and siyeon are better then her ig. but we all know if she's under another group she could easily be lead vocalist
@@k.l.6282 i don't think sua and jiu are better vocalists than her but tbh the three of them are a really close match and they are great vocalists. Tho i won't change my monde when it comes to dancing she defo is 2nd in that category 👍
Why sua unnie is not in the list of popularity??! She is popular?! I cant,this is unfair she is so popular.she is unapreciated queen.she became a dj.she alot.of.kpop idols friends.
I personally hate these videos bc the amout of toxic people here say no she in 1 no she in 3 and putting paragraphs about her ability of singing ,dancing,rapping,and. More drives me sick all we need to know is that there all amazing at anything it might kinda not be th best but it's good I just saw so many people fighting over who top and all it annoying and you know the girl don't like comparing each other remember it's ot7 just stop fighting
What ones do you disagree with? It's completely fine to do so, but most of it was based on actual evidence. And everyone has different appeals, so let's be mindful of that, no?
@@anapalaio6427 Please answer my question. Besides 'Stage Presence' and 'Popularity,' everything else is non-conditional and supported by legitimate evidence; based on their positions and experience. If you tell me what you disagree with, then I can explain it for you.
@@Moonlighter22 No one got into scandals, it's just impressive how she is the most searched member but it's all positive. Normally with search results, members that have scandals may be least biased but they are the most popular searched.
My first Dreamcatcher videos🥳
Wait for my other dreamcatcher videos😄
Cool 😎, keep it up you're making other's day good 😁
Dreamcatcher queen 👑 👑 👑
More DREAMCATCHER please
Siyeon is such an underrated ace, Sua too is an all rounder
When a main vocalist rank 1 in stage presence says alot about how good they are
She earns it
my bias is sua and siyeon
sua is an ace and siyeon is a insane vocalist
stand dreamcatcher stan talent
Mine also
@Ofra Cohen wow we are same i am confused that i like jiu or sua more but i think sua is more versetile and siyeon is my bias cz her vocals .....................
Dreamcatcher for me are the queens of the horror concept and bridges.
Hi can you please tell me who is the girl who sing too many angels die now i am goona change your mind in boca
@@itzykep1ianonceteume28 sua
@@jawadhasan8287 thank you for telling me❤️
@@itzykep1ianonceteume28 np
@@itzykep1ianonceteume28 her name is sua.
siyeon is the all rounder
periodt. 💅🌠
suA too
Siyeon when performing on stage just hits different, like she looks so intimidating and her gazed is just scary not to change the fact that her vocal is just Chef's kiss...
JiU's visual is just something else and I can't explain, it's PERFECTION... I love her perfect features and the way she smiles? No words, she's a sunshine of the group... But everyone is beautiful in their own way..
Dami's voice just suits in rap because she has a unique tone in her voice, kinda deep but what I love the most of her is that she can sing and belt highnotes! It's rare....
I also agreed in terms of Vocal, Siyeon is just on another level, she is so underrated... I fell inlove with her when I saw her 'Speechless' cover, I became InSomnia since then...
In terms of Dance, SuA has this fluidity and her control of her body is just on another level... I love all of the songs she choreographed...
Okay... All of them are good, they are all-rounders... When I started to check their MVs, I'm pretty sure that time that the girl named Siyeon is the Main Vocalist but then when I heard the other members singing, I was like.. "Who the fuck is the main vocalist?!" "Who the hell is the Main Dancer?!" "Who's the Visual?!"... I had a hard time so I decided to get to know them more... And yes, 7 main vocalist, 7 main dancers, 7 main visuals, 7 main rappers, 7 chaotic dorks, 7 top energy, 7 GAYS.... OJAY STAN DREAMCATCHER
I can tell you really like Deja Vu era Handong! :)
Although my bias is Dami, i think Sua is a damn full package.(but they all are already somewhere beyond highest standard of kpop in my opinion)
Imo, JiU have the best stage pressence especially on their live concert
yes :(
Handong voice so pretty
yes i agree she is my bias wrecker 😍(it's so hard to have bias)
Objectively speaking,how is JiU not in top 5 of stage presence?? Top 2 or 3 even
And from what I've seen, JiU is the most popular
Think it's tough to rank all these categories in Dreamcatcher cept for maybe Vocals and Rap. Rap because of the format, haven't seen JiU and Handong rap yet. Vocals because there is a clear heierarchy and Dami while talented focuses on rap heavily and Gahyeon is splitting her time between Vocal/Rap.
Popularity for kpop group members honestly changes by country so not much use arguing it, but, Siyeon gets sent to variety shows by herself at times. Competed in shows an such along with the slaying a few OSTs and her Solo song. Think DCC sees Siyeon as their ace.
Stage presence is hard to be objective on but I agree this was very biased. JiU and Gahyeon were way too low. Yoohyeon is also easily a better dancer than Dami. SP should be Gahyeon>SuA/JiU>Siyeon>Yoohyeon imo
@@DarkMage501 I agree, stage presence is highly subjective. Think Gahyeon has the advantage in versatility of facial expressions...but... A lot of that is concept based cuz it's not like the other members can't laugh and/or smile. When DC isn't being strict with their expressions on stage and just having fun singing I don't think Gahyeon has the same impact with her facial expressions.
All the members are at a high level for pretty much everything so it comes down to personal preference or what category you weight and when.
Think Siyeon has a clear advantage for solo stage presence since shes dominated several stages by herself and if given freedom to sing how she wants even in a group setting her voice, the freedom and confidence she has with it really stands out.
@@DarkMage501 Yoohyeon dancing as DC stands out more for her height and length, looks great posing in the center or front of the other girls.
Think DaMi is probably the better technical dancer inside the choreo, especially with her gestures and such.
Outside choreo tho, Dami doesn't dance much at all. Yoohyeon moves with high energy, dances with Siyeon and Sua at random and also twerks at random.
Inside the organized performances i think you can make an argument for anyone at the top of Stage presence.
In a free-for-all. Think the Only real choices are SuA and Siyeon with Yoohyeon challenging that two top from time to time.
@@DoroboInu Handong rapped a bit in Come a Come cover
All their vocals are so good
I’m so excited for Apocalypse:Save Us. Only 11 days till the release!!
yes i need to have this album at home please !!! (i will have B day soon 🤫)
First win!!
I love Handong’s deja vu outfit
about dance i would say:
1. SuA
2. Dami
3. Yoohyeon
4. JiU
When bottom 2 members in stage presence are actually amazing performers, it says a lot about power they hold
La más popular es Jiu, además que su popularidad en Corea es buena que es la única que ha entrado a los rankings de marca de idols femeninos en algunas ocaciones.
Y tiene muy buena presencia en el escenario.
Siyeon and Handong visual on top
I love JiU and Yoohyeon both idk who’d better
Gahyeon and Dami stage presence 😍
im my opinion the most popular members are 1jiu 2gahyeon and 3dami or siyeon
NAH 🤗
Dreamcatcher best kpop group ✨❤️
I'd give more credit to Siyeon's dancing. Yall should watch their cover of Boss during Minx👀
FR. In their cover of Rhythm Ta as well, during minx too. Like she's so good in dancing. But i understand that other members are just very good too. They're just all great tbh. And her split in Boss just.. 🥰🥰
Dance and Vocal are accurate.
Visual and Stage Presence can be subjective but we probably all agree on #1
Popularity is the only one I'd say is off. I'll just add a few stats I've noticed below.
Based on their IG follows:
1. Jiu
2. Sua (used to be #1 when Wendy followed her + was the only one with a solo schedule)
3. Dami
4. Yoohyeon
5. Gahyeon
6. Siyeon
7. Handong
Based on teaser RTs and likes:
1. Jiu
2. Gahyeon
3. Yoohyeon / Dami
4. Siyeon / Sua / Handong
Based on years collecting (and getting scammed by overpricers lol) - most collected:
1. Jiu
2. Yoohyeon
3. Siyeon / Gahyeon
5. Handong
6. Dami / Sua
Yoohyeon has the best technique in dreamcatcher lmao
@@allykelly periodt
Yoohyeon is easily the best vocalist in dreamcatcher.
And I'd argue she's a stronger dancer than dami, but I'm not particularly an expert on that.
@@allykelly I won't argue with that, she does.
@@crystalorbit5767 yooh has the best technique but isn't the best vocalist for Dreamcatcher in particular. Siyeon has the dynamics, power and a certain uniqueness that make her the ideal main vocal for their style. kinda the same reason why Sua and Dami get so many lines despite their weak techniques.
also, as a former dancer, I'd say that no yooh isn't a better dancer than Dami. she just works very hard in hiding her weaknesses and that actually makes her one of my fave dancers in DC :)
I respect your ranking, and i personally think all 7 are so so talented but I disagree with you on the stage presence, I think Minji and Yoohyeon are the top 2 when it comes to that. But honestly, each member has their moment, they know exactly how to work well together when to step back and let someone else shine and when to go take the spotlight so in the end it comes down to preference and who ur bias is. Thank you for the video!!
Personally imo jiu, yoohyeon, siyeon, sua have top stage presence every era. All of deukae have incredible strengths and stage presence. Dreamcatcher is so good at making sure everyone shines and since they're all incredible, they all catch your eye at some point which is rarw for a group to have all members have strong stage presence ❤️🔥
And literally you should be fair to Handong's vocal as she got more exposure for the latest songs released (ODD EYE, BECAUSE), not convinced by using deja vu only
I have 2 disagreements: Jiu should be in the top 5 of stage presence (To me she is 3rd). Jiu is the most popular of the members. Btw Siyeon is my bias, so its not biased hahha But I agree with u in the most parts
Siyeons vocals are beyond pretty much any idol I've heard. Not only can she reach absurdly high notes and hold them, but she can easily SING those high notes as well. Truly we don't deserve her talent.
I like the video but in my opinion:
Stage presence:
1.- Siyeon
2.- SuA
3.- Dami
4.- Yoohyeon
5.- Gahyeon
Visual:
1.- JiU
2.- Yoohyeon
3.- Gahyeon
4.- Handong
5.- Siyeon
Rap:
1.- Dami
2.- Gahyeon
3.- SuA
4.- Siyeon
5.- Yoohyeon
Vocal:
1.- Siyeon
2.- Yoohyeon
3.- SuA
4.- JiU
5.- Handong
Dance:
1.- SuA
2.- JiU
3.- Yoohyeon
4.- Dami
5.- Siyeon
I believe the 'Visual' ranking in this video is actually based off of who meets the Korean beauty standards the most, which is as follows for the Top 5:
1. JiU - 70%
2. SuA - 60%
3/4/5. Siyeon, Yoohyeon, Gahyeon - 50%
They are all good at everything 💕
JUST EVERYONE IS TALENTED
Handong Ace!!
Stage presence: 1.Gahyeon ♕
2.SuA
3.Siyeon
4.Dami
5.Handong
Visual: 1.Jiu ♕
2.SuA
3.Yoohyeon
4.Handong
5.Gahyeon
Rap: as u
Vocal: 1.Yoohyeon ♕
2.Siyeon
3.Jiu
4.SuA
5.Handong
Dance (by a dancer): 1.SuA 9.5/10 ♕
2.Jiu 8.9/10
3.Dami 8.6/10
4.Yoohyeon 8.2/10
5.Handong 7.2/10
I like these videos on only one group so there isn’t all these toxic fan wars. I swear they are making me not enjoy Kpop as much anymore 😞. We need to make our communities less toxic, is it that hard?
yes i think the same :-(
The most popular member is jiu yoohyeon siyeon
STAN DREAMCATHER STAN TALENT
2:37 dami rap and rock part 😍
I think for visual first place is for Siyeon
I don't want to say much, but there's a position that an individual has, and the company or the members would have decided. The main vocalist is the best singer in the team. The main dancer is the best dancer in the team. And JiU's popularity ranking is weird. As far as I know, JiU in the top3 overseas and top in Korea.
My opinion is I could agree with all this ..your rankings is .. especially the rap ranking.
My bias is Siyeon & SUA & JIU 😘😘😘😘
fully same
I think Sua is the Most popular member
10:16 can someone tell me what the song name is?
I'm an Insomnia newbie :D
You and I
Welcome to dreamworld~
You and i btw welcome to fandom
visual:
5. gahyeon
4. sua
3. yoohyeon
2. siyeon
1. jiu
How Handong isn't in the visual line? She's pretty as Taeyeon wtf
i know she is my bias wrecker but everyone has different opinion please don't be toxic
She's one of my bias wrecker too, and I'm not being toxic, is just that her visual is underrated when she's one of the best in dc
@@anthonyfernandez6125 Ok i understand 😁
I think this video used the Korean Beauty Standards ranking, which obviously places Handong out of the Top 5 straight away.
The Top 5 based on the KBS is:
1. JiU - 70%
2. SuA - 60%
3/4/5. Siyeon, Yoohyeon, Gahyeon - 50%
You used my favorite SuA fancam for dance.
The way they’re all aces
Yoohyeon has the best technique in DC so she should be no 1
vocal isn't all about technique hun.
@@Cherry__806 that's subjective
I personally don't agree with the popularity. I would've said:
1st - JiU
2nd - Dami
3rd - Siyeon
4th - Gahyeon
5th - Yoohyeon
Based on numbers of like on every teaser's photo and Instagram followers.. i think the most popular member in Dreamcatcher is Jiu. But i love all of them equally 🤩.. it is very hard to choose bias in this group😂
i really lkie siyeon
for stage presence, even though Handong has improved a lot, but still there's a bit of confidence issue from the past. Yoohyeon seems better for stage presence but not for holding mic performance (she seems a bit strained). like a 50-50 between Handong Yoohyeon
for visual, honestly I can't rank them because each has distinct type of visual. but yeah I kinda agree for the rank if it forced to be ranked
for rap, even though Yoohyeon is one of my bias trinity, I think Handong still better. we already heard her a bit of rap tone in Eclipse, that Really Really cover Yoohyeon not really rap too. JiU tried to rap in cover too but still the tone from Handong will suit the rap more. also Gahyeon over SuA just because of recent experience and decision from SuA to get more vocals than rap
for vocals a lil bit tricky. for hard choreo, SuA surely over JiU. in some vibe, Yoohyeon will be over Siyeon. but overall I kinda agree for the rank in this video
for popularity it keep changing a lot tho. but nowadays Dami seems over JiU. during Nightmare series Yoohyeon JiU probably top 2. in BOCA Gahyeon Dami Siyeon are top 3. also in Odd Eye Handong at least in top 3 (not biased, she's not in my bias trinity but in Odd Eye she really stood out. I've watched some reactors who don't have Handong as bias but talking a lot about Handong in Odd Eye)
for dance also a lil bit tricky. for shape/angle, Yoohyeon can be #3 or #2. Handong can be #4. if only based on movement, I kinda agree with the video
if you read fully until this point, thanks to read my essay a.k.a a bit review about rankings :D
I love each of them so much.
imo handong should be the second one after siyeon in the vocal category she truly served in deja vu
Siyeon is my bias. But I don't think she's the top popular one
Yoohyeon better Siyeon in vocal. because Siyeon F+, Yoohyeon D
Based on both the video and the comments, i got very interested in knowing how they came to Dreamcatcher? Like on earth does someone who should have been a shoe-in for any mainstream group (like Siyeon) end up in what was basically an experimental underdog group? I've dabbled in a few other kpop groups but none of them ever had that personality that Dreamcatcher has.
ok but why dont u use other handong fancam (and others songs fancams like fly high, good night, what....) lmao
Can you tell me name of the song with Yooheon's, Siueon's and Sua's rap parts? What's the song?
It's a cover of "Really"
So pretty
I'm late but back when this video was made Yoohyeon was by far the best vocalist
For me piri rap is on top
I would say dami is a better dancer than jiu but everything else is spot in
In my opinion about rank dance is
1. Sua
2. Jiu
3. Yoohyeon
4. Dami
5. Handong
Gahyeon is 1 in stage precense
Oh im early
idk i would say jiu and yoohyeon have better stage presence than handong/gahyeon
Honestly it's really difficult to rank the girls in terms of vocal ability, obviously Siyeon is at the top in first place, Yoohyeon/SuA in a close second tie, but then the remaining 4 are pretty close in vocal ability. I feel like we haven't seen JiU or Handong's chance to shine vocally yet, while we've only briefly seen what Dami and Gahyeon can do.
How are ranking Yoohyeon and SuA in the same tier??
@@zarav731Yooh is only the best in dc when it comes to techniques, but other than that, she is same as Sua, may even be lower than her in some case
my top 5
vocals
siyeon
yoohyeon
jiu
sua
gahyeon
handong
dami
(strong vocal line) and I also think that gahyeon and handong are on the same level
rap
dami
gahyeon
I couldn't see the other members shining as rappers sorry
dance
sua
all I couldn't see the other members shining solo as dancers
visual
jiu
gahyeon
sua
yoohyeon
handong
dami
siyeon
(they all are pretty)
I just noticed that siyeon looks the oldest, but I still think that she's pretty.
I know this is perhaps your own opinion but ranking Yoo at number 4 on dance? She should be atleast 2 haha
she’s a great dancer but when you put her up against jiu and dami (who both have lead dancer positions) obviously she’s going to be 4th
*Ok ⛓️Somnias⛓️ let's go and see if we can get ✨Maison✨some views!*
4:40 What Song is this? :-D
Really Really - Winner
In this second is dami the most popular
personally, I think that Jiu has the best stage presence, + she reads rap well, her abilities are perfectly revealed in the new clip and it’s immediately clear who the leader is and + her vocals are the most unique sounding in the group and her voice is very beautiful with her voice association with dreamcatchers
( my opinion )
jiu has MUCH better sp than handong
JiU and Yoohyeon is in the top 3 for me, have u seen yoohyeon's boca fancam?? These two are the best for me
it supposed to be
1) Siyeon
2) JiU
3) SuA
4) Dami
5)Gahyeon
I don’t agree with Jiu be 2nd for dance. Dami is the second best while Yoohyeon is 3rd. Handong is 4th. Jiu’s dance lines aren’t that smooth compared to Handong who moves like a silk feather. Siyeon is the worst dancer in the group tho.
My list
1. Soowa
2. Dummy
3. Youhyun
4. Hendongue
5. Geeyou
6. Ghahyun
7. Seeyoncè
Who are you? 😂😂
gotta be honest m,y bias is siyeon but sua with her vocals and high notes and what we have seen is able to replace siyeon gotta say sua is a real all rounder that is number 1 is everything but the ranking how you did were good hihihi sua her sub vocal title is to low for her she should be also lead vocal in my opinion
4:27
what's name the song?
It's their cover of really really really
@@damisslave2406 THANK！！！！！！
I would say that handong is a better vocalist than sua but its just my oppinion
While they do have different techniques, imo SuA is better. Her voice is versatile and can hit high notes. She can even hit whistle notes.
Sua can hit highest note,she can whistle too.she cant fully show her vocals.because she is the main dancer of the group.thats why she not always show.
I think it's also just experience-wise. SuA had the most training and she was in Minx. Compared to Handong, SuA is objectively higher ranked. SuA's voice also suits DC's sound better, which goes to show how shocked we are of Handong's vocals when she is given the opportunity to show her jazzy voice.
And jiu?? V odd ranking
@@wearepublic waht about Jiu?
SuA is so popular ☆
Yall really did a stage presence ranking not ranking Jiu???
I agree for all but siyeon not the most popular gahyeon dami is popular than her for the most popular member on them is jiu
Actually, the popularity ranking is very redundant when it comes to Dreamcatcher cuz the ranking just kept changing.
@@24yeffinakawarjri24 yes i know i talk about their ranking now even their no big difference betwen them in the popularity they so close
it depends where you’re looking tbh
@@aeongies Right. If you go off of 'Kpop Profiles,' then they're all #1 (as they should be, but that's not a 'ranking' then).
@@someoldytaccount yes, and i don’t think people seem to realise that the kprofiles polls actually let you vote more than once. so for all we know, 100 of those votes could be the same person. then you’ve got the fact that their popularity differs across different platforms or communities too. they’re never too far apart from each other but it’s still noticeable.
SuA all rounder
Yall really don't want to give Handong the credit she deserved lol. She's easily top 3 vocalists and top 2 dancers in Dreamcatcher. As someone who's covered several songs of dreamcatcher and had to analyze their dance practices, she's one of the cleanest dancers in the group. Dami is far from being as clean as Handong and JiU is not as energetic as her either 🤷
handong is very good vocalist but sua, jiu, yoohyeon and siyeon are better then her ig.
but we all know if she's under another group she could easily be lead vocalist
@@k.l.6282 i don't think sua and jiu are better vocalists than her but tbh the three of them are a really close match and they are great vocalists. Tho i won't change my monde when it comes to dancing she defo is 2nd in that category 👍
All dreamcatcher members deserve praise but let's not lie
I agree they always discredit her abilities
Why sua unnie is not in the list of popularity??! She is popular?! I cant,this is unfair she is so popular.she is unapreciated queen.she became a dj.she alot.of.kpop idols friends.
yes i think she should be here
@@jijelir5605 she should be,it make me upset😕 that she love by.others alot.all of them are popular but in different categories.
Don't take this too seriously
@@zarav731 i know but if about talking dreamcatcher it make me upset 😂
I personally hate these videos bc the amout of toxic people here say no she in 1 no she in 3 and putting paragraphs about her ability of singing ,dancing,rapping,and. More drives me sick all we need to know is that there all amazing at anything it might kinda not be th best but it's good I just saw so many people fighting over who top and all it annoying and you know the girl don't like comparing each other remember it's ot7 just stop fighting
when you make a video, at least try to get closer to reality, not your personal tastes.
What ones do you disagree with? It's completely fine to do so, but most of it was based on actual evidence. And everyone has different appeals, so let's be mindful of that, no?
@@someoldytaccount and where did you go to get that evidence?
@@anapalaio6427 Please answer my question. Besides 'Stage Presence' and 'Popularity,' everything else is non-conditional and supported by legitimate evidence; based on their positions and experience. If you tell me what you disagree with, then I can explain it for you.
f
siyeon isnt the most popular tho
She is the most search results. She also has no scandals either, so it's only positive.
@@damisslave2406 as far as i know none of the girls have gotten into any kind of scandal so far, or am i out of date?
@@Moonlighter22 nope, u are right. DC might be the least problematic and purest group in this industry.
@@Moonlighter22 No one got into scandals, it's just impressive how she is the most searched member but it's all positive. Normally with search results, members that have scandals may be least biased but they are the most popular searched.
@@damisslave2406 i would say Siyeon is the 2nd most popular along with Dami but the most popular is JiU
siyeon 2nd for vocals
She has the best technique tho
@@ever8815 she strains way too much even yoohyeon is better
@@linapetrova7284 woah relax 😳. She does not have the worst
@@ever8815 nope. Vocal wise yes siyeon is the best but technique wise it's yoohyeon
Siyeon has best vocals the proof is Shadow song in both versions but my bias is Yoohyeon
in dance i thik what Dami on 2nd position and Jiu on 3rd
video is so cool😍